We value: Our readers.
Our independence. Our region.
The power of real journalism.
We're reader supported.
Get our newsletter free.
Help pay for our reporting.

Site C Dam Approved: A Tyee Reader

Approved today, a sampler from years of reporting on the $8-billion-plus mega-project.

By David P. Ball 16 Dec 2014 | TheTyee.ca

David P. Ball is a staff reporter with The Tyee.

The B.C. government has finally given its blessing to a massive hydroelectric dam proposal six decades in the making.

BC Hydro is now permitted to begin building the Site C project, now pegged at $8.7 billion. The dam aims to provide enough power for 450,000 homes. The province has said the project is needed to help power the liquefied natural gas industry.

At stake in the 1,100-megawatt project -- which has been on the books in various forms since the 1950s until it was shelved 30 years ago by the B.C. Utilities Commission -- is 10,000 hectares of the fertile Peace Valley region, more than 40 per cent of it classified as farmland.

In 2007, The Tyee reported then-premier Gordon Campbell's speech to municipal leaders, in which he vowed to support the BC Hydro proposal.

Nearly three years later, The Tyee published a five-part series about the renewed push for Site C by reporter Max Fawcett. Since then, we've covered the twists and turns as the project flowed through the public debate towards today's decision.

Here is a sampling from The Tyee's coverage of Site C over the last seven years.

2014: The final push for Site C

As Site C dam gets environmental approval, a local journalist's case against

Oct. 14, 2014: In mid-October, B.C. gave the environmental green light to the Site C project, declaring "the benefits provided by the project outweigh the risks of significant adverse environmental, social and heritage effects." Tyee publisher David Beers looked back four years to reporter Max Fawcett's five-part investigative series on the project's impacts.

Ahead of Site C Decision, A Plea from Peace River Valley Residents

Oct. 3, 2014: Ahead of the province's decision on whether to give the environmental green light to Site C, a coalition of Peace River Valley residents, environmental advocates and First Nations leaders released the above video plea to stop the dam from flooding nearly 10,000 hectares of their valley -- 40 per cent of which is classified as farmland.

Site C Review Process Lacked Independence, Says Northern Mayor

Sept. 10, 2014: With succulent cantaloupes and honey pots laid out in front of them like Da Vinci's Last Supper, northeastern B.C. municipal and First Nations leaders renewed their opposition to the proposed dam, wrote reporter David Ball.

582px version of Site C Dam panel
'From the First Nations point of view, Site C is not an option at all,' said Chief Roland Willson at a press conference held by municipal and regional politicians and First Nations officials. Photo by David P. Ball.

No Rush to Build Site C Dam, Review Finds

May 8, 2014: The panel reviewing Site C concluded the project would provide cheap power that will be needed eventually. But as legislative bureau chief Andrew MacLeod reported, that power likely won't be needed as soon as BC Hydro thinks. MacLeod sifted through the panel's 50 recommendations should the project receive approval.

Dams Not Eternal in 'DamNation'

May 3, 2014: Tyee contributing editor Chris Wood interviewed the U.S. director of a documentary film described as "a powerful effort to jolt North Americans out of their complaisant acceptance of big dams as simply part of the landscape."

2013: Dam's future, and finances, under scrutiny

BC Hydro's Darkening Future

Sept. 2, 2013: Tyee columnist Rafe Mair lambasted the government's running of BC Hydro, or as he put it, a "decade of incredibly stupid policy," including ex-premier Gordon Campbell's Clean Energy Act which exempted Site C from full review.

BC Hydro, Peace River District reach Site C deal

June 13, 2013: Tyee reporter Colleen Kimmett looked at a deal to sweeten the Site C deal -- a payment of more than $168 million over 70 years from BC Hydro to the Peace River Regional District to compensate for damage.

Postcard from Fort Nelson, BC's Gasland

June 6, 2013: With the provincial cabinet proclaiming Site C an essential energy source for B.C.'s hoped-for liquefied natural gas boom, reporter Hayley Dunning launched a two-part investigation of fracking in northern B.C. -- including links between LNG dreams and the hydroelectric megaproject that could provide its power.

2011: Yes or No?

Site C, Yes or No? Gov't Never Directly Asked Locals

Sept. 22, 2011: Despite a year-long, $8-million public consultation process on the Site C dam, a team of five advanced investigative journalism students at the University of Victoria examined claims that BC Hydro appeared to have never outright asked Peace River region residents whether the project should go ahead.

BC Hydro's New Way of Reporting First Nations Clashes

Aug. 31, 2011: Amid rising conflict with First Nations in the province, BC Hydro quietly dropped part of its commitment to a global standard of reporting "violations involving rights of indigenous peoples," according to University of Victoria advanced investigative journalism students.

2010: Hydro spending, energy alternatives

Why Is Canada Freezing out Geothermal Power?

Nov. 19, 2010: Tyee writer Mitchell Anderson asked why Canada had become a world leader at generating geothermal power -- just about everywhere except in our own country. Meanwhile, B.C.'s push for Site C dam ploughed ahead despite potentially producing six times less electricity than renewables, at a higher cost.

BC Hydro Spent $62,000 on Party for Politicians

Nov. 15, 2010: The Crown corporation behind the Site C megaproject was confident a series of lavish receptions for lawmakers was good value for money, according to freedom of information request documents obtained by Andrew MacLeod.

Economist Calculates BC Hydro on Path to Ruin

Aug. 23, 2010: Tyee columnist Rafe Mair wrote about former Transport Canada economist Erik Andersen, who raised red flags about Gordon Campbell's energy policies when it came to managing BC Hydro.

'Liberalizing' BC Hydro

July 20, 2010: Amid a renewed push to build the Site C dam, top BC Liberal Party political strategists and supporters took over key positions at BC Hydro. As Tyee columnist Bill Tieleman argued, the results at the province's largest Crown corporation became clear.

Site C dam and private river power proposals exempted from public hearings

582px version of peaceriver.jpg
The Peace River, a stretch of which will be flooded if the Site C dam is built.

May 6, 2010: Reporter Jesse Ferreras put the province's tabled Clean Energy Act under the microscope, along with its ambition to achieve B.C.'s "electricity self-sufficiency." Could that be achieved with its clause allowing bypassed reviews of megaprojects such as the Site C dam?

What Voters Weren't Told about Clean Energy Act

April 29, 2010: Tyee columnist and former NDP MLA David Schreck argued the province's proposed Clean Energy Act should be renamed the "Flood Valleys for Power for Export Act."

BC introduces Clean Energy Act

April 28, 2010: A new bill aiming for B.C.'s "electricity self-sufficiency" contained a clause exempting Site C dam and other megaprojects from approval by the B.C. Utilities Commission, reported Andrew MacLeod.

Pemberton wary of Site C power lines

April 21, 2010: After Gordon Campbell announced the province was taking the next steps towards Site C, reporter Jesse Ferreras went to Pemberton where concerns arose over the impact of power transmission lines from the dam.

Disturbing the Peace: The Case Against the Site C Dam

April 5-9, 2010: Writer Max Fawcett -- former newspaper editor at the Chetwynd Echo in the Peace River area slated to be flooded if the Site C Dam project is approved -- interviewed project opponents, sifts the government's claims, and lays out a dam-free alternative for the region. He shared his findings in a five-part Tyee series.  [Tyee]

Share this article

The Tyee is supported by readers like you

Join us and grow independent media in Canada

Facts matter. Get The Tyee's in-depth journalism delivered to your inbox for free.


The Barometer

Tyee Poll: Do You Think We Should Rename BC?

Take this week's poll