Marking 20 years
of bold journalism,
reader supported.
BC Politics

Two Health Researchers Settle Lawsuits over 2012 Ministry Firings

Rebecca and Bill Warburton say they received a cash settlement, feel 'exonerated.'

Andrew MacLeod 29 Dec

Andrew MacLeod is The Tyee's Legislative Bureau Chief in Victoria and the author of A Better Place on Earth: The Search for Fairness in Super Unequal British Columbia (Harbour Publishing, 2015). Find him on Twitter or reach him here.

The final two wrongful dismissal and defamation lawsuits stemming from the bungled 2012 British Columbia health ministry firings have settled out of court, with two researchers saying they've received a cash settlement.

In a joint statement with the B.C. government, married researchers Rebecca and Bill Warburton acknowledged "that they did breach some rules and procedures" and the province recognized "that such breaches were motivated by their intention to further the research goals of the Ministry of Health, and not for their own personal gain."

In a separate emailed statement, Rebecca Warburton said, "We have been exonerated and our reputations for acting honourably and in the public interest have been restored. It is clear from both the joint statement and the size of the cash settlement that the government shares our view."

Her statement did not specify a dollar value for the settlement, which is not mentioned in the joint statement, and she would not reveal the amount when later reached for comment.

Rebecca Warburton is a University of Victoria associate professor in the school of public administration that was cross-appointed to the health ministry as a co-director of research and evidence development in the pharmaceutical services division.

She and six others were fired from the ministry in September 2012. The government never specified why the seven were fired, but the health minister at the time, Margaret MacDiarmid, said it had to do with contracts, potential conflicts of interest and data management. The situation was serious enough that the government had notified the RCMP, MacDiarmid said.

Bill Warburton held a $1-a-year contract that gave him access to government health data to use in his research. The government cancelled the contract at the time of the firings.

Flawed investigation

Since the firings the government has backtracked, previously settling wrongful dismissal and defamation lawsuits with three of the people who were fired, and even welcoming two of them back to work at the ministry.

The RCMP has said it never received enough information from the government to warrant an investigation.

The government has apologized for the handling of some of the firings, including to the family of Roderick MacIsaac, a co-op student who committed suicide a few months after being fired from his health ministry position.

The joint statement between the Warburtons and the government, released by deputy attorney general Richard Fyfe, said the province recognized there were flaws in the investigation that led to the firings and noted they had been identified in a report by lawyer Marcia McNeil released in December 2014.

The Warburtons are both welcome to apply for access to health data for research purposes or to participate in contracts involving the health ministry and will be treated like any other applicant, the statement said.

The statement also made reference to an ongoing investigation by ombudsperson Jay Chalke's office. "The Province is confident and the Warburtons are hopeful that the process being undertaken by the ombudsperson will provide the public with a thorough review of what occurred in relation to the health-research investigation and firings," it said.

They anticipate resuming their work with the government in the public interest to protect people's health, the statement said.

'Huge cost,' says NDP

Attorney General Suzanne Anton said in a prepared statement, "I recognize and share the public's desire to fully understand what took place in regard to the health-research investigation and firings. My staff are working with the Office of the Ombudsperson to ensure it has the tools it needs and access to all documentation and records in order to conduct a thorough and effective investigation."

NDP leader John Horgan said, "We are very happy for Drs. Bill and Rebecca Warburton, two outstanding researchers who were wrongfully smeared by Christy Clark's government."

The government has "admitted to misconduct and wrongdoing" in the cases, he said. "The government's actions had a huge cost for the individuals involved, and damaged health research in our province," he said.

"Hopefully Bill and Rebecca can now fully return to their extraordinary work which benefits the lives and health outcomes of children, youth and adult British Columbians."

Two former health ministry employees who were members of the BC Government and Service Employees Union went through a grievance procedure following the firings, but did not receive their jobs back or any settlement.

Please note our comment threads will be closed Dec. 21 to Jan. 3 to give our moderators a well-deserved break. Happy holidays, readers.  [Tyee]

Read more: Health, BC Politics

  • Share:

Get The Tyee's Daily Catch, our free daily newsletter.

Most Popular

Most Commented

Most Emailed


The Barometer

Are You Concerned about Your Municipality’s Water Security?

Take this week's poll