The article you just read was brought to you by a few thousand dedicated readers. Will you join them?

Thanks for coming by The Tyee and reading one of many original articles we’ll post today. Our team works hard to publish in-depth stories on topics that matter on a daily basis. Our motto is: No junk. Just good journalism.

Just as we care about the quality of our reporting, we care about making our stories accessible to all who want to read them and provide a pleasant reading experience. No intrusive ads to distract you. No paywall locking you out of an article you want to read. No clickbait to trick you into reading a sensational article.

There’s a reason why our site is unique and why we don’t have to rely on those tactics — our Tyee Builders program. Tyee Builders are readers who chip in a bit of money each month (or one-time) to our editorial budget. This amazing program allows us to pay our writers fairly, keep our focus on quality over quantity of articles, and provide a pleasant reading experience for those who visit our site.

In the past year, we’ve been able to double our staff team and boost our reporting. We invest all of the revenue we receive into producing more and better journalism. We want to keep growing, but we need your support to do it.

Fewer than 1 in 100 of our average monthly readers are signed up to Tyee Builders. If we reach 1% of our readers signing up to be Tyee Builders, we could continue to grow and do even more.

If you appreciate what The Tyee publishes and want to help us do more, please sign up to be a Tyee Builder today. You pick the amount, and you can cancel any time.

Support our growing independent newsroom and join Tyee Builders today.
Before you click away, we have something to ask you…

Do you value independent journalism that focuses on the issues that matter? Do you think Canada needs more in-depth, fact-based reporting? So do we. If you’d like to be part of the solution, we’d love it if you joined us in working on it.

The Tyee is an independent, paywall-free, reader-funded publication. While many other newsrooms are getting smaller or shutting down altogether, we’re bucking the trend and growing, while still keeping our articles free and open for everyone to read.

The reason why we’re able to grow and do more, and focus on quality reporting, is because our readers support us in doing that. Over 5,000 Tyee readers chip in to fund our newsroom on a monthly basis, and that supports our rockstar team of dedicated journalists.

Join a community of people who are helping to build a better journalism ecosystem. You pick the amount you’d like to contribute on a monthly basis, and you can cancel any time.

Help us make Canadian media better by joining Tyee Builders today.
We value: Our readers.
Our independence. Our region.
The power of real journalism.
We're reader supported.
Get our newsletter free.
Help pay for our reporting.

‘Red Zones’ Set the Marginalized Up for More Trouble, Study Finds

One in five court-ordered release conditions restrict where a person can go — with harsh results.

By Stefania Seccia 1 Mar 2017 | Megaphone Magazine / The Tyee

Stefania Seccia is the managing editor of Megaphone Magazine. The Tyee and Megaphone Magazine are partnering as part of a larger Tyee project called The Housing Fix and Megaphone’s series on solutions to homelessness.

A disproportionate number of homeless people, as well as sex workers and drug users, are being unjustly denied access to certain city blocks concentrated in the Downtown Eastside, charges an as-yet-to-be released study.

Courts place a variety of conditions on people released after having been charged with a criminal offence but not yet found guilty. In 20 per cent of cases those conditions include areas where the released person isn’t allowed to go — so-called “red zones.”

Often, these simply lead to additional charges when the released individuals gravitate back to familiar streets, according to the study from a team of researchers at the University of Ottawa, Simon Fraser University, the BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS and the University of Montreal.

The study examined how bail and sentencing conditions are impacting lives in four cities in Canada. It came to light when it was discussed by some researchers involved at a Feb. 15 public forum on policing in the Downtown Eastside.

According to the BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS’ Will Damon, there are more legally innocent people locked up awaiting trial in remand or preventative detention in B.C. today, than there are people serving time because they’ve been found guilty of a crime.

“When you look across Canada, the rates of criminal charges have been declining,” Damon said, “but the category [of charges] including breaches of court orders is an exception to that trend. That’s pretty astounding. A large percentage of the business in courts is concerned with people allegedly violating their bail and probation orders.”

A police officer, justice of the peace, or judge can impose conditions of release after an arrest, or at bail. A judge can also impose them after a trial or a guilty plea as terms of a probation or a conditional sentence order. Red zones, also known as “no-go areas” can be a block, a specific address, or a several block radius, which a person is forbidden to enter.

The conditions fall under an area of the law known as “administrative justice” — more or less the law of fair process. But they still have to be obeyed, and breaking them can lead to charges. In British Columbia, 40 per cent of all criminal cases include at least one administrative justice offence, according to Damon. In 79 per cent it is the most serious offence.

Researchers who reviewed nearly 95,000 cases handled in Vancouver Provincial Court or the Downtown Community Court between 2005 to 2012, found more than 528,000 conditions attached to more than 100,000 orders. One in five — 20 per cent — were no-go or red-zone conditions.

According to a fact sheet on the study distributed at the policing forum event, six unnamed individual “legal actors” the researchers interviewed defended release conditions as a “useful regulatory tool that reduces crime, particularly in ‘hot spots’ tied to the drug supply, promotes rehabilitation and the ‘public interest.’”

The anonymous individuals, described as being involved in imposing or negotiating conditions of release, called red-zone conditions generally reasonable, based on what police request for any specific individual accused. The same “legal actors” conceded however that they could not explain why so many of those conditions end up in breaches.

The conditions have dramatic consequences for the lives of marginalized people, says Marie-Eve Sylvestre, who also participated in the research from the University of Ottawa’s Faculty of Law. Restrictions on a person’s access to public spaces can impede their ability to find health services, shelter or even just familiar faces, if they fall within the no-go area.

“Whenever someone is red-zoned,” Sylvestre said, “their security, and sometimes their life, are threatened.”

The researchers discovered that “red zones were often broader or much wider for marginalized groups,” than for individuals charged with more violent crimes. Moreover, such people often didn’t understand the details of an area condition, partly because it can be vaguely outlined with no timeframe.

Despite a decrease in B.C. incarceration rates — now the lowest in the country — the study found that there has been a simultaneous increase in conditional release to community supervision, particularly in the Downtown Eastside.

The conditions can quickly result in that release being revoked, however, or additional “administrative justice” charges being laid against someone who breaches them.

Doug King, a lawyer with Pivot Legal Society, told the same policing forum that city police officers use observations of bylaw infractions — like jaywalking or street solicitation — to obtain someone’s identification. Then they check to see if that person is breaching an order. If the individual is found to be violating a red-zone order, that’s enough legal justification to search them, even absent of other reasonable and probable grounds to do so.

Unusually for Vancouver, 45 per cent of all calls to police in the Downtown Eastside are from other officers, mostly for information about outstanding warrants, arrests or court orders relating to some individual. In 2013, the researchers say, police in the 10-block neighbourhood also issued 76 per cent of all the tickets written for jaywalking in the whole city, as well as 95 per cent of those for street solicitation.

The following year, failures to comply with release conditions and breaches of probation orders represented 79 per cent of all police-reported administrative offences. The researchers underscored how these smaller breaches occupy a large amount of police, judicial and correctional resources.

While researchers say the restrictions may violate rights to presumption of innocence, mobility, reasonable bail, and even life, security and integrity, they’re seldom challenged in court.

“There are multiple obstacles to formulating rights claims,” in court, the researchers’ fact sheet observed. “Chief among which is the power imbalance that individuals have to negotiate from remand centres, and the ritualized, bureaucratic, and almost banal nature of the criminal justice process.”

The Vancouver Police Department was unable to respond to an interview request by deadline.  [Tyee]

Share this article

The Tyee is supported by readers like you

Join us and grow independent media in Canada

Facts matter. Get The Tyee's in-depth journalism delivered to your inbox for free


The Barometer

Tyee Poll: Are You Preparing for the Next Climate Disaster?

Take this week's poll