After the escape of an estimated 40,000 Atlantic salmon from the Marine Harvest fish farm at Port Elizabeth on October 21, biologist Alexandra Morton has renewed her call for an independent judicial inquiry into the collapse of the Fraser River sockeye run this summer.
Writing on her blog just before the escape was known, Morton published an open letter to Paul Sprout, Regional Director General of Pacific DFO. Among other points, she wrote:
Before he became Premier, Stephen Harper called for a judicial inquiry into what happened to the 2005 Fraser sockeye. The ruling party said “no.” Was the truth inconvenient? Is it still inconvenient? Would we have abundant sockeye this year if a 2005 Inquiry had occurred? If Canada had done a Judicial Inquiry into the declining North Atlantic cod stocks we would still have those fish. We would have learned that crucial findings by government scientists such as Dr. Ransom Myers had been suppressed by DFO.
On October 23, Morton ran a news release from NDP MP Peter Julian, calling for a judicial inquiry. The release also quoted Fin Donnelly, NDP candidate in the November 9 by-election in New Westminster-Coquitlam, as saying "the wild salmon crisis will be a key issue." Morton also included a news release from Marine Harvest about the escape.
In an email to The Tyee, Morton wrote:
Watching how government is handling the Fraser sockeye crash has been disturbing. The public has been misled by statements that draw our attention away from the extremely specific nature of the crash. Some runs failed catastrophically, others did extremely well, within the Fraser River.
If we pay attention and read what the fish are telling us, we can figure this out, but there is only so much a biologist can do. I am greatly heartened to see MP Peter Julian make a public demand for a judicial inquiry into what happened to the Fraser sockeye.
If there had been a judicial inquiry into the cod decline, before those fish crossed the point of no return we would have learned that the research by government scientist Ransom Myers was being suppressed by DFO and we would still have those cod today.
...I don’t fully understand why fish seem to bring out the worst in politics, but I do know we will not keep our salmon unless they gain favour in the polished halls of Ottawa. The biggest thing BC’s salmon need to survive is political will.
Crawford Kilian is a contributing editor of The Tyee.


9
Login or register to post comments
NotFromThePubli...
2 years ago
Teach those sockeye a lesson
Let us just round up all the remaining sockeye, and give the farm fish little Tommy Guns, so they can finish off the competition BC style. Why waste time and money when there are profits to be made.
Norman Farrell
2 years ago
Morton has trouble understanding
that wild salmon don't carry their weight anymore. Besides interfering with fish farming, the presence of wild salmon prevents us from building dams on the Fraser and other rivers to generate power. At least with BC Liberals in office, it's only a matter of time before the salmon are gone and we can resume dumping dioxins and heavy metals and other sh*t in the ocean. The alternatives cost business big money and that's not fair.
http://northerninsights.blogspot.com/2009/07/highest-and-best-use.html
Jeffrey J.
2 years ago
Brilliant!!
The following article is brilliant. Can I buy some shares in this idea? Finally, we can really solve BC's salmon problems. Kudos to Mr. Farrell...
"The Globe and Mail examines how the declining Fraser River salmon fishery impacts the traditions of people who for thousands of years relied on harvesting food fish. We present here an alternative that deals with present day and future realities by charting a new course for a major river system."
"We should face the inevitable and act now to maximize the Fraser River's economic potential. Since the salmon fishery is moribund, harness the river for hydro power, using the Columbia River as a model. Admittedly, the Fraser is shorter but the Columbia has 14 major dams on the main stem and about 400 in the overall system. North Americans generate huge amounts of clean electricity on one river. Additionally, a major dam can be a powerful tourist draw, particularly when close to a city, nicely lighted and effectively promoted."
"Under the current government strategy, private power producers entering the market are forced to commute to far away wilderness lands of the mid-coast and the north. That seems inconvenient and inefficient when there are potential power generating locations closer to urban markets. Unlike the wilderness sites, the Fraser is already well served by modern roads and rail lines. Electrical transmission lines are in place or in planning so the profit potential of Fraser River power is far superior."
"I haven't even discussed the gains from flood control and, without need to protect fish, we can eliminate expensive wastewater treatment and merely direct effluent into the river. It's mostly natural and organic anyway."
"Along the Fraser, First Nations people could be guaranteed a reasonable allotment of canned salmon from Alaska or perhaps a share from coastal salmon farms that will be expanded once the wild fish are gone."
"Sure the Fraser's landscape and ecosystem will change a bit but think of the wealth that would be generated for those well enough connected to acquire franchises to control the river. Premier Campbell would be celebrated in history for solving the power needs of British Columbia for years to come and for enriching a whole new generation of energy traders."
big money and that's not fair.
http://northerninsights.blogspot.com/2009/07/highest-and-best-use.html
Illahie
2 years ago
Alexandra's apparent lack of knowledge
is getting embarrassing. I can certainly see why DFO would not want to meet with her.
Norman Farrell
2 years ago
@ Illahie
DFO should be embarrassed by their performance on the east coast and the west coast. Failure is the consistent result. They tried abdicating responsibility for fish farms on BC's coast but the courts said no. Thank you Ms. Morton.
When salmon that migrate through Juan de Fuca - where there is no concentration of farms - survive but other routes are decimated, DFO management scratch their heads. Perhaps they need a grade school course in cause and effect and elementary logic.
DFO officials would rather enforce laws close to home. They spend more time monitoring drainage ditches in Richmond than they do on farming.
Skywalker
2 years ago
Way to go Alexandra.
I nominate her for Order of Canada.
Skywalker
2 years ago
Illahie
With comments like your assertion that " her lack of knowledge is embarrassing" we would expect you to stop hiding behind anonymity. That way we might judge how you become an expert on someone's lack of knowledge. Until then I'll stay with Morton. I think her dedication to this issue speaks for itself and she doesn't hide behind anonymity.
redneckstranger
2 years ago
Illahie
A conservative for wild Salmon. An oxymoron? Not on your life!
I believe that government is a necessary evil which is not necessarily evil, but is almost certain to be incompetent particulary when competence is absolutely necessary.
Come on fellow entrepeneurs and champions of free enterprise. We can not leave our quirky whacked out left-wing brothers and sisters to fight this fight alone. Write your MP and MLA and tell them the donations stop unless they do the right thing and close the Salmon farms.
The NDP in Ottawa can't even save themselves. It will take right wing BC'ers to end this lunacy so get off your butts and phone your MP.
Cheques not written are the most powerful instrument in our arsenal. If you donated to the Conservative party of Canada or the Liberal party of BC they will listen to you the way the NDP listens to labour unions.
This is about our Salmon not partisan politics. Send your local MP and Prime Minister Harper local MLA and Premier a message: No More Donations.
Roadie
2 years ago
'Dead Fish and Fat Cats'
I'm sure many of you have read this book, written in 2003 by retired BC fisherman Eric Wickham; which documents many of the reasons our fishing industry is failing.
Fishing methods which decimate the habitat. A bloated, ineffective DFO. Fish farms which destroy the fry as they emerge from their rivers and streams.
He knows his subject well and covers it with humour and intelligence.
http://www.viacorp.com/dead-fish-and-fat-cats.pdf