Blogs

The Hook: Political news, freshly caught

Document urges BC Liberal aides to avoid answers, spin the media

   

B.C. Liberal government ministerial aides are under strict orders when the B.C. Legislature is in session and rule No. 1 is to not provide answers to the opposition in Question Period and spin the media, a newly released confidential government document shows.

"It's Question Period, not Answer Period," reads an internal government document titled House Review: A Day In The Life dated January 2007.

"Answer the best you can each time, every time. But if you can't, ATTACK!! NDP record, evidence of internal conflict, etc ...." the document instructs ministerial assistants to B.C. cabinet ministers.

House Review also details how cabinet aides and other government staff are expected to influence reporters to keep them from writing about controversial issues raised in Question Period by the opposition.

A section titled: "10 A.M. - The News Blitz" says: "This is our chance to get to the media while they are still thinking about their lead - give them something else to write on so they aren't pressured to write on QP [Question Period]."

There are: "Several options for 10 a.m. blitz: 1) Legislation; 2) News Releases; 3) Comment on issues already on media radar."

House Review is part of 8,000 pages of confidential government documents ordered released by B.C. Supreme Court Justice Elizabeth Bennett Wednesday in response to an NDP court application.

The information was obtained through Freedom Of Information requests by defence counsel acting for David Basi, Bob Virk and Aneal Basi, three former government aides facing corruption charges related to the $1-billion sale of B.C. Rail.

Bennett also ordered that the documents be made available to media and the public for review but not photocopying at the court's Criminal Registry.

The document states in a "Question Period" section that: "Ministers are judged on the three Cs: Competence - we know the file better than the critics; Confidence - we are sure of our position; Control - we are clear in our communication."

The "Question Period" section also outlines how cabinet ministers are backed up by staff in several locations so they can answer opposition inquiries quickly.

"Speed Kills - one person in 223 [Room 223 in the Legislature, presumably], one in the office, so that info can get into the chamber," the unsigned document reads.

The media spin doctoring continues following Question Period, according to another section titled: "3 p.m. The Hallway" - regarding media questioning of ministers and opposition in the hallway outside the Legislature Chamber.

"The halls are Round 2 - if QP goes well, it's the NDP's 2nd Chance. If QP goes bad it's our chance for clean-up," House Review says. "The halls will NEVER be a good substitution for a good QP performance."

The newly released documents also include detailed briefing notes for Campbell prior to interviews with columnists Vaughn Palmer of the Vancouver Sun and Michael Smyth of the Province newspapers and for talk radio show interviews.

House Review outlines in detail what happens in the hallway after QP: “Jason, Dale, Caucus and PAB work the halls – follow their lead, stay in contact if you are the flavour of the day. Find out what the NDP is saying and distributing. Assess best mitigation techniques, including whether to keep your Minister in the House or bring them out on cue.”

“Dale” would appear to be Dale Steeves, Premier Gordon Campbell’s Communications Director. “Jason” may be Jason Keenan, Campbell’s former Legislative Support Officer. PAB is the Public Affairs Bureau, the government’s communications arm.

“We can use the halls to mitigate their attacks,” House Review continues. “1) Distribute paper that refutes their claims….2) Provide balancing data to supplement their stories – usually contrasting information; 3) Send the minister back out to take another round of interviews with media.”

House Review says the government’s day starts with an 8:15 a.m. House Meeting: “Smaller meeting with PO [Premier’s Office], Leader’s Office, Caucus and Whip’s Office – may introduce PAB into discussions. Final decisions on QP angles. Final decision on the 10 a.m. News Blitz.”

Bill Tieleman writes a column for 24 hours and appears regularly on The Hook.

Find more in:
   

7  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • sunshine coast girl

    4 years ago

    And the media..

    are still too stupid to know when they're being manipulated.

  • SharingIsGood

    4 years ago

    open accountable

    Time and again we witness these Liberal tactics, Bill; and now, thanks to you, we actually see proof in black and white that this is Gordon Campbell's policy. We see proof that our government servents have been instructed how to lie and how to use subterfuge. Gordon Campbell told us he would have the "most open and accountable government anywhere in the world". In light of these words, it is hard to imagine a more untrue statement. This government is corrupt from top to bottom, and it is time the Liberals were hoisted out on their own arrogant lying petards.

    Of course, as we have seen of late, this article will probably be innundated by a barrage of pro-Liberal possible Media Monitors who will, (possibly with our own tax dollars) try to use obfucation and subterfuge to change the topic from the Liberals. It is getting pathetic. Why do we not see Gordon Campbell being properly hounded by the press over this? This is an outrage, and it, like the BC Rail scandal and the Liberal MLAs,themselves, should not be let sleep until every last truth is exposed.

  • SharingIsGood

    4 years ago

    erratum

    servents = servants, excuse my typo please.

  • North of Hope

    4 years ago

    Political spin-doctors

    sunshine coast girl said, "And the media.. are still too stupid to know when they're being manipulated."

    I don't think so, I believe they are part of the manipulation.

    This reminds me of an interview with Harry G. Frankfurt, the author of “On Bullsh*t”

    "On Political spin-doctors, they don’t care about the truth, they care about a certain impression in the mind of people they are addressing. They are engaged in the enterprise of manipulating opinion; they are not engaged in the enterprise of reporting the facts."

    When I watch Question Period, I only once saw a Liberal answer a question with honesty. It was the former finance minister, Carol Taylor. She answered with no bluster and was very straight forward , consise and complete. There was no need for a follow-up question as her response was complete. No wonder she is not running again and has been removed from the cabinit.
    Contrast that with Kruger's response. Check Corky Evan's video.

    I posted this at Bill's site as well.

  • DJT

    4 years ago

    SIG Quote: "why do we not

    SIG Quote:

    "why do we not see Gordon Campbell being properly hounded by the press over this"?

    I read this article today in 24 Hours. Out of curiosity I went through both the Province and the Sun page by page. Not one word. Surprise, surprise!

  • Wilfred Laurier

    4 years ago

    Good thing eh?

    Good thing the NDP doesn't have spin doctors, isn't it?

  • G West

    4 years ago

    Wilfrid

    "Spin Doctors" for the NDP....you must be kidding.

    After the 2001 election, which is the period we're talking about here, the NDP had TWO, that's '2' MLAs, remember?

    And the CEO wouldn't even grant them any status as the official opposition, remember?

    The caucus had two, that's '2' researchers to support the two MLAs.

    Get serious my friend, your bias is showing.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.