Opinion

What It Would Take to Recall BC Liberals

Odds of recalling MLAs over HST will grow as tax hits and public feels ignored.

By Bill Tieleman, 29 Jun 2010, TheTyee.ca

campell-hansen-hst.jpg

Premier Gordon Campbell and Finance Minister Colin Hansen introducing HST to BC.

Related

"Where there is little or no public opinion, there is likely to be bad government, which sooner or later becomes autocratic government." -- Former prime minister William Lyon Mackenzie King

On June 30, the Fight HST citizens initiative petition signed by over 700,000 British Columbia voters demanding the Harmonized Sales Tax be killed will be delivered to Elections B.C. in Victoria.

And on July 1 -- Canada Day -- the B.C. Liberal government will ignore that unprecedented and historic exercise in direct democracy, imposing the new 12 per cent HST that will shift $2 billion in taxes onto consumers from big businesses.

Premier Gordon Campbell, Finance Minister Colin Hansen and B.C. Liberal MLAs will show contempt not only for the initiative process that obtained almost as many signed petitions as their party got votes in the 2009 provincial election --751,791 -- but for poll after poll showing overwhelming opposition to the HST.

Instead of listening to the will of the people, this bad government will push ahead with a tax that will dramatically and negatively hurt B.C. consumers, with a Statistics Canada study estimateing the average household will pay an extra $521 more in HST every year.

Rather than respecting public opinion, this autocratic government will push an extra seven per cent tax down British Columbians' throats on everything from restaurant food to domestic airline tickets to home repairs, cleaning and renovation to realtor and accounting fees to concert and sports tickets to gym memberships to dry cleaning to massage therapy to funeral services to investment counselling fees to new homes over $525,000 right down to postage stamps.

There is now only one answer to such an autocratic, undemocratic government -- to recall its elected members.

Ignoring the message

I proposed recall in this column Aug. 11, 2009, arguing that: "The appropriate response to abuse of power is to remove power."

The citizens initiative petition led by Fight HST leader and former B.C. premier Bill Vander Zalm that I support has given the B.C. Liberals a clear indication of just how angry British Columbians are with the HST -- a tax that party denied they would impose before the May 15, 2009 election.

And the citizens initiative provided Campbell and Finance Minister Colin Hansen an opportunity to reverse their serious mistake by cancelling the HST.

Despite this, the B.C. Liberal government has rejected every single indication from the people that the HST is despised. They even ignored one of their own cabinet ministers -- Blair Lekstrom -- who resigned from the B.C. Liberal caucus over imposing the HST.

The initiative process has succeeded beyond my wildest dreams from when I first proposed it here on Aug. 18, 2009. The NO BC HST Facebook protest group I started last July after the HST was announced has also had a fantastic response -- today it has over 136,000 members.

But the initiative -- as powerful an expression of public will as it is -- cannot stop or reverse the HST. Its main purpose has been to unmistakably demonstrate widespread voter anger and give the B.C. Liberals a chance to repent.

Whether the initiative results in a non-binding vote in September 2011 or the introduction of the initiative's HST Extinguishment Act in the B.C. Legislature, the government is under no obligation to kill the HST.

So now is the time for even more dramatic action against a government that simply will not listen to reason -- make them listen to the recall of their own MLAs who voted to impose the HST.

Recalls face a high bar

Recall is a very tough test -- to remove an MLA from office requires obtaining the signatures of 40 per cent of those voters registered in the riding at the time of the 2009 election within 60 days.

But just like the extremely challenging initiative rules -- obtaining 10 per cent of all registered voters in every one of B.C.'s 85 ridings in 90 days -- it definitely can be done.

There are now at least 11 ridings where the B.C. Liberal MLA got fewer votes than the number of voters who signed the citizens initiative petition.

And Fight HST has released a "hit" list of 24 B.C. Liberal MLAs who could be targets for recall campaigns when they are officially permitted, starting November 15.

Canada Day marks HST era

I predict a firestorm of anger will erupt starting on Canada Day as British Columbians who have not been following the HST controversy wake up to discover that hundreds of goods and services they buy are now seven per cent more expensive.

And then there's the one cent a litre carbon tax increase at the pumps, also effective July 1, literally throwing gas on the HST fire.

Life in B.C. is getting a lot more expensive -- and Gordon Campbell and his MLAs will pay a high price for imposing the HST.  [Tyee]

44  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Peter Dimitrov

    1 year ago

    Recall and Regurgitate or Seek the Deep Change we Need! - Part 1

    If an MLA is recalled, byelections will be triggered, the BC Liberal candidate would be at a disadvantage _ which will be augmented if the Conservatives get a "shiny new button" for a Leader. A split of the vote on the "right" implies logically that the NDP ought to win bigtime, but logic does not prevail. No doubt many fear-mongering perspectives about the "evil" anti-business incompetent NDP will be dusted off and trotted out of the political barn vs. the wealth creating responsible governning "free" enterprisers and business community....both of which dualisms are pure B.S. Then we are back to the same highly polarized 'whip-saw' divide that causes this Province to tilt from one side of the political spectrum to the other, to the detriment of the Province and governance in the public interest.

    I predict that for a majority of the electorate the choice will be 'none' of the existing parties. Bill, you are right, we have highly dysfunctional undemocratic government, but the root cause is an outdated institutional design that concentrates political and fiscal power excessively in the Premier's office, which disempowers citizens, cities, municipalities and the constitutional rights of First Nations to be significantly included, and which faciliates legislative capture, old privileges and exclusion. Metaphorically our 'operating system' is embedded with viruses and junk, and is completely outdated for these times, akin to using a Windows 3.1 or DOS operating system, rather than a modernized operating system.

  • Peter Dimitrov

    1 year ago

    Part Two of Seek the Deep Change we Need!

    Despite, IMO, the dictatorial and arrogant excesses/incompetencies of the BC Liberals, there is not a political party in existence that does not prefer the continuance of the Windows 3.1 institutional design - so that they and their supporters can also benefit if and when said party gets elected. That is the dysfunction, the HST is but one of so many symptoms of dysfunction of this low level colonial democracy imposed on this Province by the British in the 1800's.

    IMO, a new political party is needed, to campaign on one central question: "Do you the electorate support the election by proportional representation of a constitutional constituent assembly empowered to design and propose a modern, made in British Columbia constitution requiring ratification by the electorate before being proclaimed into law?" Otherwise, given the operating system, the dysfunctionality will continue ad nauseaum -under the BC Libeals or another party.

    Do we not deserve better, do we not as a people deserve to design new rules by which we wish to govern ourselves, do we not deserve to enshrine more equitable, collaborative, inclusive, power sharing & balancing arrangements into a modern governance design, surely, after so many years of dysfunctional polarized governance are we not up to the collective task to become authors of our own history rather than merely pawns. I want to know what you think, are you happy with the rules by which we govern ourselves or are you willing to go for a significant upgrade to the operating system, what are your thoughts on the question. Twitter me at JusticeNow_2288 Thank you, and while I expect that many will disagree with my comments my hope that we will rise to debate this article and the ideas that folloq in a respectful fashion without ad hominium attacks.

  • crankypants

    1 year ago

    Recall

    In order for recall to be effective I figure that we should target 15 BC Liberal MLAs all at once. Bill Vander Zalm's idea of one or two at a time will just be ignored by Campbell & Co. With 15 MLAs facing potential recall, the pressure on Campbell's resolve will be truly tested.

    And if Blair Leckstrom hasn't vacated his seat to run federally, I'd make him one of the 15. He is still a card carrying member of the BC Liberal Party which in my books makes him about as much an independent as Osama Bin Laden is a Roman Catholic.

  • Toobad

    1 year ago

    With this much anger.....

    Recall is a for sure thing.

    Donna Barnett and Don Mcrae are toast....Pat Pimm is toast..

    And what about George Abbot...Can you say "Tar and Feathered"!

    http://powellriverpersuader.blogspot.com/2010/06/george-abbot-gets-tarred-and-feathered.html

  • donntarris

    1 year ago

    People deserve to design new rules

    Good words Peter!
    It is time to discard the current system, and BC would be a good place to start. We can not only design our own method of governing in a fair and sustainable way, we can also shut private banks out of the money creation process by instituting a BC currency to facilitate in-province trade and simultaneously get people working at valuable jobs for good wages and clean up the province's public infrastructure, healthcare, education, public transportation...
    There is no reason for cutbacks on services and public funding, there is no reason for additional taxes. There is every reason to provide no-cost money to the people of BC to allow them to creatively design ways to be productive members of an equitable society.
    If the country won't do it, BC could be the first to introduce a guaranteed annual income and end poverty in this province. We could have the healthiest, best educated, most humane population on earth in no time at all - we need creative, caring representatives in a cooperative government to get there.

  • Frank

    1 year ago

    Vander Zalm's idea of

    Vander Zalm's idea of recalling 1 or 2 MLAs at a time is silly.

    It would mean most people wouldn't even be aware that there was a recall campaign going on in their riding since on the radio, tv and in the major newspapers local issues are not going to be covered.

    To get people's attention start campaigns in every riding where the Liberal MLA is vulnerable. That will get coverage from the provincial media and people will at least know its going on.

  • Jeffrey J.

    1 year ago

    Recall and One Day General Strike

    A one day general strike, tied to a recall of ten or so Gordon Campbell minions (MLA's) would provide the energy and time to launch the recall campaign. A great idea, one which would bring a much needed dose democracy back to BC.

    August 11, 2010 works for me Bill. Let us know when we can start working.

  • Camero409

    1 year ago

    Good Ideas Above

    What we need to do first of all is remove this government! We know what the so called "LIbERalS" and Cons stand for. They stand for a centralized government controlled by the Central Banks and Big Business. Once the government is removed we, the people of BC, can hold our own plebiscite and determine our own future. I have long held views that BC needs to separate from Canada and form our own country. Surely we can run our province/country much more equitably and efficiently than a centralized government based in Eastern Canada controlled by megalomaniacs and narcissistic egomaniacs.

  • blackie

    1 year ago

    fantasyland

    The joke in all this is that a successful recall campaign that yanks enough Liberal MLAs to defeat the government will do nothing to get rid of the HST. And the new government that replaces the Liberals after the successful recall initiative -- assume its the NDP --will also do nothing to rescind the HST. It is written in stone, because the cost of undoing it will be astronomically high -- far beyond just giving the feds back their $1.6 billion.

    The Zalm and his zealots know all this; which kinda raises the question -- why didn't they just skip the HST fight and go directly to recall?

    Which kinda

  • G West

    1 year ago

    History

    blackie, perhaps is ignorant of the fact that the HST was instituted in Saskatchewan in 1989 and subsequently dumped by a new government in that province.

    There is no reason NOT to dump the damn thing and you can be relatively certain that a new government formed after recall elections (remember we have fixed election dates in BC now) would be morally committed to dump the tax which, mutatis mutandis, will have been responsible for their accession to power.

  • sunshine coast girl

    1 year ago

    7 recall campaigns simultaneously..

    Is what we need to do. Focus the resources and volunteers. Get the job done within 30 days. That's two days more than election campaigns. And we have the means to pull it off.

    That's what I intend to work towards.

  • Bob Watts

    1 year ago

    Why????

    Why do BC Liberals ignore the will of the people?
    I don't get it!
    We send our troops to die in other lands, to share our Democracy. Sent the troops to Victoria!
    If you order a cheese burger, and they won't give you cheese, well as a business, that will be your last sale.
    NOW HOW LONG WILL IT BE BEFORE THE BC LIBERALS GO OUT OF BUSINESS???

  • logitack

    1 year ago

    recall

    Campbell and Hansen should be the FIRST to be recalled. Let the people do what the Liberal party wont do and remove Campbell for a leadership position.

  • crh

    1 year ago

    hang in there

    Campbell has convinced his puppets to hang in there and ride out this storm. And hang in there they will, right to the bitter end of their political career after enduring a recall campaign along the way.

    Independents will not serve their masters. Get rid of political parties now.

  • Ernest Black

    1 year ago

    Why do they ignore us?

    Because we let them. Pure and simple. We let them get away with it, and then we vote them in...over and over again. They have learned the lesson we taught them, that all they need listen to are their corporate masters. The true masters of government punish quickly and harshly. Don't do as we ask and we withdraw financial support.

    And even a dying government must make sure that owed favours are paid before they get turfed. This guarantees future funding for the party, and a cushy payoff job for the politicians themselves.

    What is interesting is why the media rarely call aspade a spade. All the pretty intellectual rationalisations about why and how things happen. When it simply comes down to greed, power and money, oh sorry that's greed again.

  • jim1966

    1 year ago

    Endgame For The BC Liberals Is Now In Sight

    Recall is the will of the people and it is our right. The BC Liberals simply just cannot be trusted. I agree with Ernest Black that they do all of this in the first place because they go unaccountable and we let them. For now I think those days are over. People are paying attention and Campbell knows it. Arrogance, Greed and Lying is not what British Columbia or Canada is all about and having these people in office is repulsive.

  • Luck

    1 year ago

    Liberals plus HST

    How about looking at:

    Breach of contract, conflict of interest, lieing, misrepresenting the taxpayer, fraud, recall, stupidity, arrogance, contempt, lack of experience, avoidance of truth, coverup, and on and on.

    What Vanderzalm and Delaney need to do with the NDP is too have the people of BC get off their ass and hit the streets and make noise.

    This is the only leagl way to get the attention of every BC'eer and every Canadian to make change for us for a change.

    Out of this aftermath have an election and every body get out and vote 100% vote. (only 37% of Canadian vote)

    This will avoid another mess.

  • Matt T.

    1 year ago

    Flashback

    During the late 1990's, the NDP government was behind in the polls by 57% to 17% - a whopping 40% margin.

    Along comes Kevin Falcon and his "Total Recall" campaign in order to dump the then perceived arrogant and out of touch government. That "Total Recall" campaign didn't get anywhere. No petitions were even handed into Elections BC.

    Recall campaigns require 40% of registered voters to sign within a 60-day period.

    The Initiative campaign required 10% of registered voters to sign within a longer 90-day period. People of all political stripes have signed the Initiative campaign.

    Yet only 4 ridings have exceeded the 40% threshold in the initiative campaign over the longer 90-day period- most just barely over 40%.

    Based upon the Delta South recall campaign, 25% of signatures were rejected. In other words, at least 50% plus signatures must be collected in each riding up for recall.

    Is it doable? Sure. Is it realistically doable? I dunno.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Matt T.

    The recall campaigns in the 90's were fueled more by media enhanced spin than anything real. The issues were fuzzy at best; sometimes it was a deck, sometimes it was a budget, sometimes it was just anger that the NDP had done done enough for this group or that. Most angry were the business community.

    This one could succeed because the hatred is so visceral that even a liberal media has not been able to counter the tide. This hatred crosses party lines unlike any other.

    The other factor is that the there was little door-to-door
    collecting of signatures for the Fight HST campaign and they still got the signatures. A recall campaign in seven selected has a better chance and with door to door work it will succeed. Then the whole issue (or should I say verdict on Campbell) can be decided on the campaign trail.

  • John F Carten

    1 year ago

    Gordon Campbell and Taxpayers Money

    Gordon Campbell is paid $180,000 per year.

    His Deuty Chief of Staff, Lara Dauphinee, is paid $150,000.

    We could call the HST - The Higher Salaries Tax.

    EDITED FOR LEGAL CONCERNS. -- TYEE MODERATOR

  • DPL

    1 year ago

    BY doing a recall on a

    BY doing a recall on a couple of those fairly useless Liberal MLAs it should convince a few others to jump ship before they get pushed

  • Soundguy

    1 year ago

    A social media network would help

    Something the Citizen's Initiative didn't have was a social media network. What is needed is a network of people dedicated to the success of any and all recall campaigns in BC using instant (but moderated) blog updates from their homes, work, and mobile phones, with corresponding Twitter and Facebook page updates so that people can find out where to sign the petition on any given day, at any time, and in any riding where a recall campaign has been launched by FightHST... oh look...

    Coming July 1st...

    www.recallinthefall.net

  • doggone

    1 year ago

    re Cull as many as possible

    I'm in the Nanaimo/Ladysmith area and really don't pay much attention to local politics (most of it disgusts me) I'm guessing that we may be represented by an NDP MLA because I have seen no Recall Petitions.
    I say recall the whole bunch and only run new candidates who drive trucks or build houses or teach children
    IN THE LOCAL AREA
    Get rid of the lawyers and real estate agents

  • rantnic

    1 year ago

    Campbell needs to be recalled

    As a recalled and publicly disgraced politician his career of feeding from the public trough would (except for his pension) end. No Senate seat, no Lt.Governorship, and no chance with the feds.Patti Bacchus could defeat Campbell in a recall election in his riding. Go Patti Go.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Somebody asked why do they ignore the people.

    The disaster that awaits them if they don't get all this extra cash will make the Campbell liberals a pariah for years to come. Thus opening the way for another right-of-center party. If they do keep ignoring us they think they still have a shot at it, maybe with a new leader, but still a shot. I think it is as simple as that. There is one problem with their theory; the longer they fan the anger the less likely any of thew two options will work for them..

    I have seen more liberal voters angry and I mean angry enough to vote for anyone but the liberals. It is deja vu.

  • ReeferMadness

    1 year ago

    Ulterior Motives, Bill?

    I'm no fan of the way this tax was implemented, much the same as the carbon tax was flawed in its implementation. But I can't help but be a little cynical when "Axe the Tax" Bill starts to advocate recall.

    Bill, as many of you will know, runs his own communication consulting business (in this case, think of the word "communication" as a euphemism). It's reasonable to surmise that if the NDP were to gain power, a guy like Bill with a lot of NDP connections could stand to get a lot of communications business.

    Which is why I really wonder why the Tyee gives Bill free advertising and a bully pulpit. And why I choke when people call Bill a journalist.

  • G West

    1 year ago

    @ReeferMadness

    Good tactics - can't find anything to criticize about the program and can't really disagree with the dump the HST idea... so I reckon you're left with only one alternative - TEAR DOWN THE PERSON WHO'D HAD THE COURAGE TO TAKE THE INITIATIVE AND FIGHT THIS FOR THE GOOD OF THE WHOLE PROVINCE.

    NICE.

    And one wonders why democracy in Canada is such a failed experiment.

  • RickW

    1 year ago

    blackie

    Quote:
    The joke in all this is that a successful recall campaign that yanks enough Liberal MLAs to defeat the government will do nothing to get rid of the HST

    No need to get rid of the HST. But it could be dropped from the 12%, to a single digit (say 7%).

  • samuidave (not verified)

    1 year ago

    And once recalled...

    ...I propose we have a number of them incarcerated for flagrant breach of public trust, and made to pay restitution for the damage they have done.

    (One can dream, no??)

  • brg61

    1 year ago

    Wide Support

    Real chance of losing power is Campbell's worst fear.
    BClibs have 48 seats; a loss of 6 means minority, 7 or more will kill the BClibs.
    Simultaneous recall efforts in 18 districts where eager volunteers are ready with lists of known supporters will get noticed by residents and media. Earlier recall drives failed because they were invisible.
    This time the odds are better, but not by much.
    Success in 6-9 of the 18 ridings is possible. The only way to meet the goal of 45% of registered voters is to attract voters from all parties. Volunteers from the left and right co-operating to reach a goal will appeal to wide base and if this results in mutual respect for each other, all of us win.

  • rantnic

    1 year ago

    RickW Re 7%

    The true issue is the Liberals have given the option of "reducing" the H.S.T. to the Feds, that are elected well before B.C.'s votes are even counted. So it ain't gonna happen.
    The transfer of power and control to a government, bought and payed for, by the "Bankers of Bay Street" is where the problems begin. Control of Our Provincial Resources are being sold as we pay homage to those politicians, federal, and provincial, who facilitate our "RAPE".

  • wisemonkey

    1 year ago

    Is Teileman and The NDP Using Vander Zalm?

    Teileman acts and talks like he is just a front for the NDP. He might have duped Vander Zalm (lets face it Zalm is not the sharpest tool in the shed) into getting the anti HST campaign to a level the NDP would only dream of if they were to sponsor it themselves.

    The plan probably was to support the anti HST effort as if it was sponsored by the NDP (using workers, lists and NDP organization) but using Vander Zalm as the poster boy. Brilliant!!

    The fact the government couldn't handle this thing any worse added to the success of the campaign.

    Now Teileman seems to be trying to get the Zalm salivating over recalling the government and VZ seems to be buying it hook, line and sinker. If he does the NDP will be working 24/7 in the background with Vander Zalm probably unknowingly leading the NDP charge. Haha.

    The only reason Vander Zalm is an eager participant in this is his ego in seeing the media call him and chase him around for interviews and opinions. This will end once the HST comes in unless he starts talking recall.

  • G West

    1 year ago

    @wisemonkey

    As I wrote above here:

    Good tactics - can't find anything to criticize about the program and can't really disagree with the dump the HST idea... so I reckon you're left with only one alternative - TEAR DOWN THE PERSON WHO'D HAD THE COURAGE TO TAKE THE INITIATIVE AND FIGHT THIS FOR THE GOOD OF THE WHOLE PROVINCE.

    NICE.

    And one wonders why democracy in Canada is such a failed experiment.

  • ReeferMadness

    1 year ago

    @G West

    I'm merely pointing out that Bill potentially stands to generate monetary gain from the position he is advocating. Most people would call that fair commentary. You call it an attack on democracy. You think that it's "brave" for Bill to advocate for something that might generate business for his company? Really???

    Maybe I lack the prerequisite NDP-orange colored glasses to see the issue properly.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Right on G West

    Frankly I would support the devil himself if he/she wanted to get rid of the instrument of the latest screwing over of the public by Campbell and his lackeys, or get rid of the whole bunch.

    As for not so wise monkey, Bill VDZ may have his faults but the pale to those of Campbell. Bill's don't cost me a dime. Campbell's cost more and more and more everyday.

  • crankypants

    1 year ago

    Who cares

    Who cares who took the bull by the horns and led the charge against the HST. It seems to me that those that are so pro-BC Liberal or anti-BC NDP are incapable of the discussing the HST without character assassination. I guess it's not surprising, as that is pretty much how Gordo & Co. have operated throughout their tenure.

    It's time for people to park their polarized political rhetoric and actually start paying attention to what has transpired over the last many years.

  • Conductor274

    1 year ago

    General strike

    We can't wait for recall campaigns to be held. The possibility that they won't succeed is high because of the numbers needed to accomplish the task. We can't afford anymore of Campbell's policies that are ruining us financially. Corporations and Campbell's rich friends are getting rich at our expense. We need a general strike in BC by all workers except for essential services. Not a union strike, not an NDP strike but a strike by all workers who care about BC's future. We need to stay on strike until Campbell is forced to resign and call an honest election.

    As for which party will form government afterwards, who cares! Any party and any other leader will be better than Campbell and his crooked cohorts.

  • ReeferMadness

    1 year ago

    @crankypants

    If some media outlet were crazy enough to publish commentary by Jimmy Pattison on the virtues of car ownership, would it be "character assassination" to criticize both Pattison and the outlet? Would it be "anti-car"?? I've suggested that Bill could realistically stand to gain financially if recall were successful. Nobody has challenged that suggestion; instead you and G West are accusing me of character assassination, causing democracy to fail and being "anti-NDP". Nice debate.

    Maybe you're the one that needs to drop the rhetoric and pay attention. The Liberals aren't the only ones that have unelected hangers on waiting to cash in on their success.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    ReeferMadness

    I will benefit monetarily if the liberals are gone. So will most of the folks because Gordon will not be able to put his hand in my wallet every time some business lobbyist wants a tax break of a good deal on a public resource. So does that make me ineligible to comment? That is just as silly as suggesting that Bill is motivated purely by monetary gain. Pity you don't hold the same standard when Campbell et all accept donations from the same people who get the benefit of the HST. Pity they don't have a conscience as Bill does.

  • ReeferMadness

    1 year ago

    Oh, Please!!

    How convenient for Bill that has conscience is on the same side of the issue as his business interests. Forgive me if I'm skeptical until I see him do the right thing when they aren't aligned (say, STV for instance).

    Seriously, Skywalker, can you not see the difference between your interests as a citizen who pays taxes and Bill's interests as a business owner who potentially could get extra business should an NDP government be elected?

    All you NDPers whine and snivel when Gordon Campbell's buddies cash in because of their political connections. Is it somehow better when the NDP does the same? Seems pretty hypocritical to me.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Since I'm not an NDPer.

    I guess your whine that because somebody worked against STV for no monetary benefit then whenever their position on, say HST, matches about 75 % of the population their opinion is then tainted and yours is not. You really must be joking about hypocrisy. You know the pot calling the kettle black.

    I imagine if Bill ever got any work from an NDP government in the future to satisfy you and prove your point wrong he would have to work for free even though anyone doing that work for a liberal government would get paid. Yeah that makes sense?

  • Camero409

    1 year ago

    Hey Reefer

    "All you NDPers whine and snivel when Gordon Campbell's buddies cash in because of their political connections. Is it somehow better when the NDP does the same? Seems pretty hypocritical to me."

    Looks like your LIbERal colours are showing. I know if I were the Preem the first thing I would do is surround myself with people and businesses I could trust. I would purge the LIbERal supporters and replace them with people who have the same political beliefs as I do. That would make sense wouldn't it? By the way, I am a Socialist NDPer. What are you?

  • zalm

    1 year ago

    Hmmmm

    Gordo's buddies cash in, and a river system gets destroyed, a fish run is wiped out, a lake disappears, a native people loses its livelihood, the treasury loses another billion dollars a year.

    NDP buddies cash in,.... and a bingo game sends its pot to Nanaimo...or 240 social housing units open on the DTES... or the wealthy pay another $740 a year in tax for the privilege of complaining bitterly and publicly about same....

    Yep, that's real moral equivalence, there....

  • ReeferMadness

    1 year ago

    Replies

    Skywalker
    With respect to STV, the No STV campaign did receive $500K of public money. The filings required by Elections are far too summarized to tell where that money went.

    In my view, mixing politics and business produces a toxic brew where ethics become murky at best. Anyone who mixes them should expect to be subject to scrutiny, regardless of their political stripes.

    Camero409
    I don't belong to or identify with any political party and I've never voted Liberal in my life. Politics should be a thinker's game, not a team sport where people mindless cheer for their side no matter what they do. Political branding is for people who can't or won't think for themselves.

    zalm
    You may be right that the NDP were (and perhaps are) less corrupt than the Liberals. Regardless, that doesn't leave them or their minions exempt from criticism.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.