- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
'No Effort to Secretly Give Money to NPA': Sullivan
Former Vancouver mayor Sam Sullivan offers 'clarification' of 2007 Tyee story.
Sam Sullivan: Nanitch helped fund anti-wards battle.
[Editor's note: Two years ago Tyee reporter Monte Paulsen published an article about a $5,136 donation to the Non-Partisan Association (NPA), the political party of Vancouver Mayor Sam Sullivan, by the Nanitch Policy Society, which Paulsen described as "a shadowy non-profit directed by. . . Sullivan." Paulsen, who sought comment at the time from Sullivan but was unsuccessful, wrote that Nanitch raised the issue of the need for more transparency in municipal election campaign fundraising. The stories led to rival politicians' calls for an investigation, but Community Services Minster Ida Chong ruled there was insufficient evidence of wrongdoing to launch a probe. Ex-mayor Sullivan now has asked The Tyee to publish his follow-up clarification, below.]
Since becoming a regular citizen I have learned there are several Tyee articles that require some clarification. As a long-time supporter of the Tyee and someone who made a small effort to support its start up I believe it is important for you to have the correct information. Either I or my staff obviously did not give enough attention to an interview request by your reporter at the time. Hey, I was the mayor and I was busy. With a little more time on my hands now, it is better late than never.
Several of your readers commented on the value of my charity work without full information. They may be interested to know that the Sam Sullivan Disability Foundation has raised $20 million for six charities that have provided services to 10,000 people with significant disabilities. I started these charities after becoming a quadriplegic when I was living in social housing and on welfare. I have a drawer full of awards for the work I did including the Order of Canada. For a more meaningful reference your commenters could ask a significantly disabled person they know if they have ever turned to an organization to go sailing, hiking, play music, garden, go gliding, get a custom-made assistive device or flexible part-time work while on welfare. If so, there is a good chance they have done so through these efforts.
The Tyee suggested that the Nanitch Policy Society improperly gave money to the NPA. The Nanitch Policy Society was never a registered charity. It was created under the same provisions as a local sports team, service club or professional association. Vision Vancouver, COPE and the NPA are also registered in this way. It was meant to influence government policy and thus was kept rigorously distinct and apart from the charitable organizations I formed.
I have spent my life doing volunteer work for numerous organizations. Nanitch was just one of them. As is common with volunteers, anyone wanting to contact me could do so where I work through my secretary Betty who I paid personally to handle such extra duties. I have always been careful to keep any advocacy and political activities completely separate from my charitable work. Shortly after Nanitch was formed some board members resigned. Some of the people you interviewed had been off the board for years when they were asked the questions for your article.
As an example of some of the activities of Nanitch, we became aware that there were no after hours wheelchair repair service in the city of Vancouver. When we checked into it we found that medical supply companies were obligated by their provincial government contracts to provide such services. Because of the pressure put on the government by Nanitch, today all people with disabilities do not have to worry that a wheelchair malfunction on Friday evening will mean a weekend in bed waiting for service on Monday morning.
In 2006 the Cope/Vision Council of the day announced they would unilaterally impose the ward system on Vancouver without a referendum. I needed to quickly find a vehicle to challenge this heavy-handed undemocratic action. I presented to the Nanitch board evidence that the six disabled municipal politicians in Canada had all been elected under non-ward systems. Not one disabled person had been able to get elected under a ward system. I also argued that the ward system facilitated parochialism and NIMBY-ism. In countless cities, the ward system had been used to prevent densification and social housing. The board agreed that this issue qualified under the mandate of Nanitch and that I should be empowered to stop the ward system from coming to Vancouver.
At the time almost no one believed the battle against wards was winnable. I would have to raise at least a couple hundred thousand dollars and recruit and motivate many volunteers from extremely diverse communities. And I would have to do so while fulfilling my obligations as city councilor and executive director of six charities. Fortunately things went well and we won. I began plans to have a volunteer recognition event. Some of the volunteers realized I would probably ask them to organize the event and suggested that instead we purchase tickets to the upcoming NPA annual dinner. This I did. We all sat together and had a great time. There was no effort to secretly give money to the NPA.
Having organized many fund-raising dinners for charity groups I know that less than half the money actually goes to the organization. Most of it is taken up in the cost of the dinner and the organization of it. Buying tickets to an annual dinner is actually not a good way to give money to an organization. As I had personally contributed more than $5,000 to the effort in retrospect I could have simply written the cheque myself and there would be no story.
I hope this clarification is helpful.
Sam Sullivan ![]()




8
Login or register to post comments
Jeffrey J.
2 years ago
Transparency Welcome
In a time of secrecy and hidden agendas, Mr. Sullivan's article is a breath of fresh air. Our democracy would be much further served if more public officials and elected people followed this example.
Whether this incident was mishandled or not (I believe it was), it underscores several larger issues. First, those of us on the left who daily experience the injustice of right wing business policies, are saddened when a courageous individual like Sam Sullivan announced he was running for a pro-business party, and against the progressive party. While I expect Mr. Sullivan believed it would help implement the progressive policies he has promoted all his life, the contrast between what he stood for, and the group he then joined, creates an overwhelming sensation of uncertainty, confusion and disappointment.
Sam Sullivan is not the first to be seduced by 'the ends justifies the means' (I can achieve good policy if I pretend to support pro-business, capitalists). He certainly won't be the last. We have seen many, many people who begin with strong principles, only to be bogged down in the quagmire of corporate double speak, reasons why nothing can change, and out right intransigence. Barak Obama, Hillary Clinton, Bill Clinton all have experienced the same 'process'. Even many NGO's and environmental groups have befallen the same fate.
But Sam Sullivan's voice is now free. I thank him for stepping forward and speaking. I hope we hear more from him, as I have no doubt he has much to tell us, the citizens of BC, about how we can make BC a better society. May he continue to speak out against injustice.
seth
2 years ago
Begin the roll
So glad you are helping us out with that one issue.
Now would you be so kind as to roll the rest. How about giving us the list of everybody who donated a dime in goods or services or favors to the NPA during your reign.
We'd all like to see the effects of campaign donations on decisions particularly taxi licensing and Citywide WIFI.
sunshine coast girl
2 years ago
I wanna know
how the Owelympic Village got so out of control?
Van Isle
2 years ago
Hey Sam, how come you have
Hey Sam, how come you have to hire on lobbyist's (who aren't registered) to go over to Victoria to talk to Provincal politians?
salty dog
2 years ago
We need to know
We need to know why you were nothing but a moron,inept,useless mayor of Vancouver?
Why do Vancouver mayors act like mental rejects once elected, who really controls you mouth pieces,Sam Sullivan, you were a useless politician,an orange pilon would have been more effective, on the plus side Sammy....
Gregor Robertson is making you look good,hard to believe anyone could be more useless than you were Sammy, is that the goal of all new Vancouver mayors? Keep moving the bar lower and lower in order to make us wish for the past?
Name one thing you or Gregor accomplished that people will remember you fondly about?
Name
2 years ago
Sorry Sam...
Olga's word that this was not a problem - under BC's wild west municipal financial laws where there are basically no rules and anything goes - is no reassurance. And your word is similarly meaningless - you're a politician, after all.
You've raised and played with a lot of people's money over the years. If you want us to believe everything was on the up and up, feel free to open up the books of all your various organizations to The Tyee.
Van Quad
2 years ago
Guilt by Accusation
It is good to see this article published by the Tyee. As a person with a disability who has benefited greatly by the societies created by Mr. Sullivan, it was hurtful & confusing to see my progressive and beloved Tyee drag his name through the mud.
Ask yourself this 'sunshine coast girl': how much more with the Olympic Village have cost us if we had put our scarce social housing dollars into Vancouver's most expensive neighborhood?
sunshine coast girl
2 years ago
I'm sorry Van Quad
I don't even know what you mean, and what does that have to do with my question?