News

A Tyee Series

Six Seats the BC Liberals Will Fight Hard to Keep

Boundary-Similkameen, Kootenay East, and ones in Surrey, Coquitlam and Vancouver.

By Monte Paulsen, 8 Apr 2009, TheTyee.ca

Gordon Campbell and Dave Hayer

Premier Campbell with Liberal incumbent Dave Hayer.

At first glance, this year's May 12 election looks a lot like the 2005 provincial contest. It features the same party leaders. They arrive bearing similar messages.

But the BC Liberals enter this contest with 33 safe seats, according to The Tyee's review of data that considers how the 2005 vote would have played out in the 2009 ridings. All Gordon Campbell has to do is to carry those seats plus 10 more and he wins another four years as premier.

Here's a quick look at six problematic ridings the BC Liberals will fight hard to keep:

Boundary-Similkameen

The BC Liberal Party has been running former area director Joe Cardoso as their candidate in this new riding (which bears the same name as an old riding). But Gordon Campbell's party stripped the nomination from Cardoso after learning that he criticized Premier Gordon Campbell in a 2005 letter to the editor of the local newspaper.

Cardoso has since signed on to run for the B.C. Conservative Party, and immediately became among that party's strongest candidates. He has claimed that more than 100 former BC Liberal Party members have left the party to support his new campaign.

The BC Liberals are now running former Osoyoos mayor John Slater, an 18-year veteran of local politics. Slater owns Desert Edge Nursery and is active in the Osoyoos Chamber of Commerce.

The NDP are running Lakhvinder Jhaj, who with her husband operates two convenience stores. Jhaj ran unsuccessfully for the party's candidacy to represent the Penticton-Okanagan Valley riding in 2005.

Robert Grieve is running for the Green Party.

Delta South

Independent Vicki Huntington won 33 per cent of this riding in 2005, losing narrowly to BC Liberal Val Roddick (who took 37 per cent). In so doing, the conservative former Delta councillor erased any notion that Delta South would remain a safe seat for the BC Liberals.

This year, Huntington faces off against Attorney General Wally Oppal, who lives in Delta, and is competing here rather than in the Vancouver-Fraserview riding he won in 2005. Oppal, who has spent the past two weeks dodging questions about the controversial BC Rail sale, may find it difficult to campaign as aggressively as he will need to in order to defeat Huntington.

Ladner resident and NDP candidate Dileep Athaide is destined to finish a distant third.

Kootenay East

Kootenay East is a polarized riding, with right-leaning voters concentrated in Cranbrook and left-leaning voters in Fernie. The addition of the St. Mary's Indian Reserve, which was added to the riding as part of the 2008 redistricting, could tip the balance of power if the First Nations vote turns out.

BC Liberal incumbent Bill Bennett is fighting off a two-front assault in the riding he has held since 2001.

NDP candidate Troy Sebastian, who lives on the St. Mary's reserve, is attacking from the left. Sebastian has worked as director of treaty, lands and resources for the Ktunaxa Nation Council, and was the NDP candidate in Okanagan-Vernon in the 2001 election.

B.C. Conservative Party Leader Wilf Hanni is attacking from the right. Hanni, who works as an oil drilling supervisor, lives in Cranbrook and was active in the Social Credit Party in the 1970s. He joined the BC Conservative Party in 2004 and became party leader in 2005.

Surrey-Tynehead

Redistricting has nudged some of Surrey-Whalley into this riding, transforming it from a very safe seat for the BC Liberals to one that leans BC Liberal by perhaps six points.

Incumbent Dave Hayer has held the seat since 2001, when the BC Liberals swept the province. Hayer, a former publisher of the Indo-Canadian Times, is a former director of the B.C. Chamber of Commerce and the Surrey Chamber of Commerce. He is one of two Canadians to have received the Pravasi Bharatia Samman Award from the government of India, and has been named among B.C.'s most influential Canadians of South Asian descent.

Hayer is being challenged by NDP candidate Pat Zanon, who was CEO of the South Fraser Health Region, and chairs the board of the Coast Foundation Society. She has been president of both Surrey Memorial and Langley Memorial hospitals.

Port Moody-Coquitlam

BC Liberal incumbent Iain Black will likely retake this rejiggered riding by a margin of about 6 per cent, if the 2005 vote repeats.

He faces NDP challenger Shannon Watkins, a Port Moody councillor from 2005-2008.

No Green Party candidate challenged this riding in 2005, and thus far none has been named this year.

Vancouver-Fraserview

BC Liberal Wally Oppal narrowly defeated the NDP's Ravinder Gill to win this heavily ethnic riding by just a few points in 2005. Oppal's decision to move to his home riding of Delta South leaves no incumbent to defend one of the most dynamic neighbourhoods in the province.

Former West Vancouver police chief Kash Heed is expected to run for the BC Liberals. Heed worked in the Vancouver police force for almost three decades prior to taking the West Van job. He should do well in a riding dominated by extended families who are opposed to liberal drug laws and shocked by recent shootings, many of which appear drug related.

Heed would face NDP candidate Gabriel Yiu in a riding where more than half of the residents are Chinese. Yiu is a Hong Kong-born florist and newspaper columnist who was named as among 25 future leaders by the Vancouver Sun. Yiu worked in the Chinese Head Tax Redress Campaign during the 2006 federal election, helping pave the way for the historical redress. And he coordinated the campaign to oppose a funding cut to the Mount St. Joseph Hospital's Emergency Room.

However, South Vancouver's Chinese voters have tended to vote BC Liberal, while the area's South Asian voters (who make up about a fifth of the population) have tended to back the NDP. Thus Heed's entry into this race would create an interesting new dynamic in which identity politics would appear to be at odds with ethnic voting trends.

The Green Party is running drug-rights activist Jodie Emery in Fraserview. Emery, who ran as a B.C. Marijuana Party candidate in the 2005 election and the 2008 byelection, has worked as an editor of Cannabis Culture Magazine, and is married to activist Marc Emery. Her presence will likely influence the outcome of what would otherwise be a very tight race.

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

10  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • southdeltawalker

    2 years ago

    Delta South-a bumpy ride.

    It's a three way race out here.

    The B.C. Liberals will probably loose.

    People are so fed up with a Liberal Government that doesn't listen and treats our community as a doormat.

    Independent candidate Vicki Huntington will probably win but it will be close.

    The NDP working hard as usual will be third.

    As for Liberal candidate-"StoneWally" Opal-he might actually have to answer some questions.
    Stay tuned.

  • Grumpy

    2 years ago

    Another Delta South voter who

    is voting for Vickie.

    Wally who? Like most Tsawwassen residents, Wally Awful, had such a low profile, no one realized he lived here.

    Wally is a Campbell toady and after Rodick's piss poor performance as a MLA (a fence-post with hair would have been better) that the name Liberal is laughed at in derision. Gateway, power-lines, buy outs, TFN, and non representation by MLA are all going to tell this time.

    I think Vickie will win as Liberal voters will play golf and avoid the ballot box.

  • munroe

    2 years ago

    Port Moody

    Be careful calling this one for Gordo. The new boundaries make the riding more working class and Black has been a weak, invisible MLA.

  • cboo44

    2 years ago

    Rural ridings vs Urban

    "Redistribution" has further consolidated the political power in the SW corner of the province. If the NDP are to unseat "Giveaway Gord's Liebrals" they have to campaign smart in Metro Vancouver and Greater Victoria, at the same time as pounding Gordo on the his giveaways of crown assets, lands and streams in the rural ridings. Generally speaking, urban voters are uninformed about the rampant privatization of crown holdings North and East of Hope. 90% of provincial resource revenues are derived from "Beyond Hope" and Gordo is giving it away.
    People in Vancouver and Victoria think the BC Rail "Scandal" is that a Liberal bagman was involved. HA!! The REAL scandal is that "Giveaway Gord" GAVE CN BILLIONS of dollars worth of crown held lands, FOR NOTHING !

  • Campbellwearsatutu

    2 years ago

    Dave Hayer

    I can`t understand why he got awards,but as a MLA........
    Well he has been a slug,he only speaks liberal talking points,the Surrey hospital expansion issue is huge,in a pre-election photo-op(2005 election)......
    Campbell/Abbot/Baldrey/and a camera crew Campbell announced with all the fanfare that a huge Surrey hospital expansion would take place........
    Construction was supposed to start years ago,completion was schedualed for 2008/2009 for the expansion and 2009 for a new ambulatory station.......
    Well construction still hasn`t started and the NEW TIME LINE for COMPLETION is.....

    2011-2012..........with code purples,code browns,code reds,the people of Surrey have tuned Hayer out.........
    The Indo Canadian voter are passionate,they won`t elect or re-elect a fibbing goverment........
    Put that riding down as a NDP lock.

  • Campbellwearsatutu

    2 years ago

    Munroe

    You are correct......
    I have freinds and reletives in that riding,some of who voted for Black in 2005........
    Besides being personaly annoying(IMO) Ian Black,according to a ex-Liberal voter freind of mine........
    He stated "Ian Black comes off as a elitist,comfortable in his role,role being appropiate for his bad acting and avoidance of any of the issues,he comes across that there is NO challenge to his talking points,Black has one script,robitic,never veers off message"

    With Black`s stance on minimum wage and Paramedic wage dispute(which he won`t comment)
    Black is minister of labour in name only,you might well a tape recorder as labour minister.......
    This one might be close,but I give to edge to the NDP,especialy since the evergreen line has been all but cancelled by Translink,and the people of that area know it.

  • kootenay

    2 years ago

    Kootenay East

    I think the NDP has a very good chance of winning the East Kootenay. With the recent shutdown of the saw mills in the Cranbrook area and the associated job losses the Liberals have sealed their fate.

    People have learned an important lesson, corporations don't give a damn about them, its all about money. If they have to destroy the entire forestry sector to de-unionize and privatize it, they will, and the hell with the people.

  • g.lane

    2 years ago

    Pat Zanon is not CEO of

    Pat Zanon is not CEO of Fraser Health. She was eight years ago, but the Liberals spent $700,000 to get rid of her.

    You fail to mention Wilf Hanni's disastrous stint as leader of the B.C. Reform Party. Hard to see how he will steal more than a dozen votes from the Liberals.

    I agree South Delta will be a close race.

  • Umslopogaas

    2 years ago

    He's one of us.

    Bill Bennett has had an advertising campaign running in S.E. Kootenay where he has been appearing in every guise from lumberjack, angler, hunter, seated on a snowmobile, seated on a quad, standing next to pile of split wood, seated in a canoe and so on and on.

    The Bill Bennett campaign slogan claims that "He's one of us."

    Here are a few pictures we won't see with BB in them:

    Pictures of BB standing on a pile of torn up contracts. Pictures of BB waiting hours in an emergency room (My wife had a bad fall and had to wait four hours in agony to get a dislocated shoulder set a few days ago.) Pictures of BB standing next to a coal bed methane well or BB telling us about the run of the river plans. No pictures of BB eating crappy farmed salmon. No pictures of BB on a picket line trying to protect Public Education or Elk Valley hospitals. No pictures of BB closing four schools in the Elk Valley. No pictures of BB scathingly telling the citizens of the Elk Valley that it was time that they started contributing to the economy of the province.(BTW, 20% of the mining revenue in B.C comes from the Elk Valley.)

    It really is too much.

    Most of us don't have a lot of time for all those leisure activities that BB features himself in in his advertising campaign and most of us can't afford all of those toys he likes to pose with.

    It is all very annoying but what upsets me most is that Bill Bennett was quite happy to try and gag us with Bill 42 and that alone is one more reason why he is not and never will be one of us.

    Many of our parents fought for the right of free speech and we have Canadian men and women fighting and dieing in Afghanistan in order to help people there have basic rights -like free speech. He just doesn't get it.

    Bill Bennett is not one of us.

  • brg61

    2 years ago

    NDP have steeper hill...

    The ndp will have to focus like a laser on
    15 to 20 ridings to just get close to the
    43 seats needed to win.

    But this doesn't mean they can't win.
    If they run a smart campaign, keep the
    popular vote from '05 and work to att-
    ract new/first time voters the ndp may
    surprise the experts; as they did in
    '05 with wins in Cariboo north and south.

    Campbell's liberal party is ahead, but
    there is a "soft" element to this. He
    lags his party in favourability and
    this election could see liberals lose
    votes to the conservatives.

    In 2005 Campbell's media puppets were
    predicting on election day that he
    would win 55 to 65 seats. They will
    repeat this next month. When will they
    wake up to the fact that this guy is
    not as popular as they think?

    I hope for a good turnout. And it would
    be a nice change to see the premier
    answer questions from voters; the ones
    the press should be asking.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.