Unplugged and Unglued
Confessions of an eco-mom in her darkest green hours.
Robyn Harding: Hand her a (recycled) tissue.
- Mom, Will this Chicken Give Me Man Boobs?
- Greystone Books (2009)
[Editor's note: When author Robyn Harding's family moved to Vancouver's Kitsilano neighbourhood, she felt the pressure to live an eco-virtuous life, and kept notes.Mom, Will this Chicken Give Me Man Boobs?is her funny account of trying to raise a green family without going crazy. Here's a (mostly organic) taste from her book.]
And then a new Costco opened up in nearby Yaletown. My neighbor told me about it. "A huge jar of organic peanut butter is only five bucks," she said.
That alone was worth the price of membership. We ate a lot of peanut butter. Valerie Green had told me that peanuts soak up pesticides and also create some kind of weird mold (her kids only ate almond butter). But we loved peanut butter. And organic peanut butter must be okay, right? But at the natural food store, even a small jar was five dollars. We had to become Costco members.
My green guilt was tingling a little as we drove down to the massive warehouse. An enormous wholesale store didn't feel very environmentally friendly. We were supposed to be consuming less, weren't we? But buying in bulk did cut down on packaging. It made sense to buy one enormous jar of peanut butter instead of five smaller ones. I just had to control my buying behavior.
But as soon as I walked through those gaping doors, something happened to me. I turned into a megaconsumer. I didn't care about buying green and buying less. Everything was so cheap! I ran down the aisles like a hyperactive kid in a candy store.
"I don't really need nine deodorant sticks, but it's such a good deal!"
"If I buy a case of mustard now, I won't need to buy more until 2011!"
"A box of 400 tampons should get me through to menopause!"
The shopping list I'd painstakingly made sat neglected in my pocket. I wasn't going to limit myself. I needed that gallon jar of artichoke hearts. And a three-pack of lounge pants! How had I lived so long without a pair of lounge pants? Obviously I needed three of them. When we got to the till, our bill came to over $300.
Negotiating toilet paper
The temporary high of accumulation soon gave way to megaconsumer's remorse. There I was, trying to green my home, and I'd just spent $300 on toothpaste and mustard and lounge pants that I didn't really need. I had to do something to make up for my overconsumption.
"Let's only use recycled paper products from now on," I said to my husband. I had been reading Laurie David's book Stop Global Warming: The Solution is You! It said that if every household in America replaced just one roll of regular toilet paper with recycled toilet paper, they would save 424,000 trees.
"Sure," he agreed.
The next time I went shopping, I bought an eight-pack of recycled toilet paper. Maybe I was only saving half a tree with this purchase, but over the course of our family's butt-wiping lifetime, it was sure to add up. I felt really good about it, until I got a rash.
Yes, I'm embarrassed to admit this, but I feel consumers should be warned. Recycled toilet paper gave me a rash. And what a bad place to get a rash! I had to stop using the stuff right then and there. Maybe I have an extra-sensitive bottom, but I was in agony. I wanted to save trees, I really did. But I wasn't going to walk around scratching my ass every five minutes.
"Okay, so from now on we'll use super-soft toilet paper, but recycled paper towel and tissues," I explained to John.
"Got it," he said. But he hadn't got it. He went grocery shopping and came home with two eight-packs of regular tissues.
"This isn't recycled," I said, looking at the eight boxes wrapped in plastic.
"It was on sale."
I looked closer. "This has lotion on it. That's even worse!"
"Why?" John asked.
"Uh..." I didn't know why but, in my annoyance, I felt compelled to make up a reason. "It's not real lotion. They use lotion chemicals. Those lotiony chemicals will soak into the soil when all this tissue ends up in a landfill."
"Okay," John said, "I'll remember to get recycled next time."
"Next time? We've got sixteen boxes of this stuff! Next time could be in a year!"
I knew John wanted to be green as much as I did. But for some reason, he didn't seem to suffer from the same sickening sense of guilt. Why was that? What was wrong with me?
My efficiently green friends
A few days later, I was chatting with my friend Trevor, who is very green. He and his partner were renovating their house using as many environmentally friendly measures as possible. They'd installed low-emissions, argon-filled, double-pane windows to keep UV rays out and heat in. An on-demand tankless water heater was much more energy-efficient than their old one. They'd ripped up and then re-laid their old floorboards after installing in-floor heating. And they'd torn out their inefficient fireplace and replaced it with an ultra-efficient woodstove. Unfortunately, renovating "green" was significantly more expensive than just plain renovating, and they'd soon exceeded their budget.
"It sucks that everything good for the environment is so damned expensive," I commiserated.
"I know," he agreed. "And apparently, if everyone in the world just unplugged all their appliances at night, we could basically stop global warming."
"What!?"
"Yeah," he explained, "Even when household appliances are off, they continue to draw energy. They're called energy vampires."
Bedtime, unplugged
My publisher had given me an advance copy of a British book called The Hot Topic (written by Gabrielle Walker and Sir David King). Imagine my surprise when the authors mentioned the very same subject. The book said that devices left in "standby mode" cost the world a full one per cent of our greenhouse gas emissions -- nearly as much as the entire aviation industry!
Then, about a week later, Oprah did a show on easy ways to be green. Her environmental expert suggested we plug all appliances into a power bar and turn it off every night. I didn't need to be told three times. We were going to do it!
"John!" I cried. "We have to start unplugging everything!"
So John went into the basement storage room and found an old power bar. He connected our TV, VCR, DVD player, and stereo to this power strip, and we switched it off every night. I was also good about unplugging the toaster, coffeemaker, and my cell-phone charger. (I started leaving the microwave plugged in when I got tired of resetting the clock every morning.)
Now I just had to get everyone else in the world to do this, and we could stop worrying about all this eco-crap. We could fly guilt-free again. Take long, hot showers. Drive big cars! In Australia, all power outlets have an on-and-off switch. Why the hell don't we have that here?
I decided to mention my brilliant plan to stop global warming to a group of moms on the school playground one day.
"Nothing can stop global warming now," one of them said. "Sure, we can slow it down, but no matter what we do as the human race..."
"Stop!" I wanted to scream at her. "I just put in trickling showerheads and dim lightbulbs. I got an ass-crack rash from recycled toilet paper and you're telling me there's no hope? Don't be so depressing!" But what would that do to my reputation in the neighborhood? Instead, I just pasted on a smile and nodded along.
Related Tyee stories:
- Green Stud
Excerpted: Almost Green: How I Built an Eco-Shed, Ditched My SUV, Alienated the In-Laws, and Changed My Life Forever by James Glave - My Family's Escape from Plastic
We chucked our handy snack-stashers. Are we eco-nuts? - On Salt Spring, Playing with Death
I just wanted to poke around nature with my toddler. Be careful what you wish for.



PatrickMcEvoyHalston
20-03-2009
On way to the neat and green
re: "'Stop!' I wanted to scream at her. 'I just put in trickling showerheads and dim lightbulbs. I got an ass-crack rash from recycled toilet paper and you're telling me there's no hope? Don't be so depressing!' But what would that do to my reputation in the neighborhood? Instead, I just pasted on a smile and nodded along."
This isn't sad, and you (should) know it--what you're doing here is identifying yourself as fully in fashion: Every green heroine these days lives the green life, admires its rightness but complains of its expense, and experiences the oh so very fashionable green guilt (which isn't so severe as to be crippling--in fact it kind of pleases, in that its light continual press always reminds of your over-all ethical rightness).
The "I just pasted on a smile and nodded along" should be pathetic--I mean, what would you do if you were living in a rascist small town (sorry small towns) and your thoughts were out of line? But of course, if this was the case, you never would have admitted to just walking by without at least some reply of brash resistance, you'd either have expressed at the time, or, if not, most certainly later--for if you had you wouldn't have gotten the pass/approval from your readers you seem to depend upon and so most assuredly will get here. You'll get a pass for your pasty cat-walk pass, because it's imitable, for four reasons: 1) deference here signals over-all approval of the Green Agenda; 2) to be the good, CBC listening, Globe reading, "upper-crust," "Upper-Cdn," Cdn, you have to appear constitutionaly DISINCLINED to engage in overly-emotive, loud public squabbles, and INCLINED toward (gentle and genteel) restraint, repression, and shy aversion; 3) it makes you sound like all the heroines we encounter in British/Cdn lit. who move into small towns and have to deal with their always disapproving and moralizing, "Cranford" matriarchy; 4) it pretends to (being about) compromise, but cat-walking past disturbance on way to the neat and green, is the sexiest walk to walk these days, baby! Morally in-step, failing but trying, and maybe you'll be allowed to stay on your present course: it's worked to keep many successfully ever upward and aloof for the last twenty-plus years, why not try and stretch it for another comfortable twenty?
alive
20-03-2009
a feeling good industry
I have a gripe about recycling.
You pay $15 to recycle your old computer, and it ends up in China, the recycler make money off you, and make money selling the junk again to a place where it will cause a lot of pollution .
You pay a fee when you buy tires, and the old tires end up in a heap somewhere waiting to catch fire (because they have no idea what to do with them).
You are supposed to recycle old cans and bottles, but you HAVE to remove all labels first.
As if the label would not burn when melted down?
All I can say make recycling practical and sensible, then perhaps I will bother!
sunshine coast girl
20-03-2009
"And they'd torn out their
"And they'd torn out their inefficient fireplace and replaced it with an ultra-efficient woodstove." I thought woodsmoke was a pollutant? And do windows really emit stuff? I didn't know that.
HawkEyes
20-03-2009
Sorry
...bout your ass but don't blame the recycled toilet paper...
I've insisted on using that stuff for years and have never had a problem. There are other causes for your problem.
I know royalty, like the princess from the pea story, doesn't like using this paper but who cares? I'm not impressed that people think a tree has to be cut down for their butts.
Congratulations on your your first step...and you've written a book already?
How about that for a waste of paper?
Last, realize this-'man boobs" are also nothing to joke about when they are a result of hormones and such in our food and water...
Round Two
20-03-2009
How can she still use paper towels?
Paper towels are bad for the environment and a waste of money.
We use washable cloths and rags to wipe up spills.
G West
20-03-2009
guys - lighten up
I liked the excerpt Robyn - think I'll pick up the book: But, just to keep on the 'green' side, I'll ask the Library to get a copy for me.
Thanks for the chuckles and good luck.
ReeferMadness
20-03-2009
Tragic
This story just emphasizes the idea that saving the planet will take systemic changes to the way we live. Low-impact changes like switching to recycled paper may make is feel better but if we maintain our wasteful lifestyles, it's not going to help.
PatrickMcEvoyHalston
20-03-2009
The personal IS politics
You're a generous person, G West, but your not infrequent telling of the guys to take it easy on the ladies--notably in their lifestyle threads, might not be the best way to register your respect for their work. It is a comic piece, but it's more than just for chuckles and the good laugh: it really covers what's on a lot of our minds these days, for our consideration and evaluation. You're a different guy when you react to politics and business, which I really want to say is cool, but don't really think so, but for some of us, politics/economics/the future is in everyman/woman's "negotiation" with their everyday "domestic" world. This excerpt talks of reddened buns (but you note, actually quite seriously), AND it tells us something important of who we need/want to be, from which so much else on the "grander stage" will follow. That is, to some of us this is not intermission fair but the Main Event itself, and we give its considerable weight its fair due--we take it seriously.
Stump
20-03-2009
Hi G West
"Now I just had to get everyone else in the world to do this, and we could stop worrying about all this eco-crap. We could fly guilt-free again. Take long, hot showers. Drive big cars"
This was the part that shows she has no idea WTF she's talking about. Her disparaging reference to 'eco-crap' in reference to the changes in lifestyle that are required if MY kid isn't going to be a bit player in a real-life version of the "Road Warrior" just shows she's another Petrol Princess looking for a trendy salve rather than solutions. Labouring under the misapprehension she can consume her way into a greener life-style with scratchy shit tickets and organic peanut butter creating enough of a trade-off for jet trips and SUVs quite frankly demonstrates she has no idea what's required or at stake. My patience for eco-ignorance wore out long ago.
PatrickMcEvoyHalston
20-03-2009
Validate your ass
Just to be clear--if there is one thing I wish she would take more seriously, it is her RESISTANCE to surrendering good things in pursuit of green living. Insist on excellence, regardless--and consumer push will generate better eco-products. For example, recycled paper is really improving in quality, owing to Europeans unwillingness to write on anything other than high quality paper. We should do the same with toilet paper--no joke! We really shouldn't have toilet paper which gives us rashes--what a bummer! (okay, that's a joke). Believe it; insist on it; and companies will deliver.
VivianLea Doubt
20-03-2009
The servant problem
"I knew John wanted to be green as much as I did. But for some reason, he didn't seem to suffer from the same sickening sense of guilt. Why was that? What was wrong with me?"
Tempting, almost too tempting, but I'll pass. Not for any reasons of politesse, just the sheer weight of the horror of it all. Yep, the personal is politics - and this perhaps one of the most disturbing commentaries of our current socio-political milieu, for it purports to be humorous. Perhaps we can look forward to a book on the trials of finding domestic help trained for the green household.
Words fail me, and I must resort to quoting Seth, in a long-ago-and-far away thread: "Disgorge the rich."
Fii
21-03-2009
My brilliant idea for the moms
I'd walk up to them on the schoolyard and ask why they didn't adopt a starving child rather than add to the staggering nightmare population of this Earth.
But then, what would that do to MY reputation in the neighbourhood?
DSB
21-03-2009
Ouch!
I hear your cries for revolution, but keep it cool.
The majority of people in North America don't think about making any sacrifices to see a better world. Harding self-consciously describes the transition to awareness, which is wrought with selfish feelings, feelings of loss, et cetera.
I don't think that she's trying to make herself out to be a heroine — in fact, this is a quite revealing and potentially embarrassing confession. What's more, is that it's accessible to many people — educated or not.
G West
21-03-2009
Stump and Patrick
I think you have to read the whole book - and remember, she's trying to be funny.
Nothing wrong with even the most serious minded folks having a bit of a laugh. And, she's obviously doing it mostly at her own expense.
Cheers
As for trying to impress the ladies, you haven't been around here long enough to be able to make that comment Patrick.
As for recycled toilet paper, I travelled extensively in Eastern Europe in the 90s and the one thing you could be guaranteed to find in every city were peddlers hawking rolls of Western toilet paper. They always sold out.
Stump
22-03-2009
read the book
"I think you have to read the whole book - and remember, she's trying to be funny."
I doubt that's (reading the whole book) going to happen. The heavy burden of the Soccer Mom rates about four hundred and nineteenth on my list of interests. :-)
JStog
22-03-2009
The Environmently Correct solution
Vancouver's such a clean city. But Is it
Green or Greenwash. Reduce Reuse Refuse to export the problem to someone elses back yard. Where does it go?
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2009/03/20/bc-chemicals-water-arsenic.html
Instead of Digging up the grass to plant pretty Gardens The New Mayor Robertson should take this toxic mess back and deal with it in the City Of Vancouver..The Chicken Mayor is in Charge Now.
Do Chickens need homes before the homeless. Get the priorities straight.