Opinion

Who Is Gordon Campbell 3.0?

Chatting with the polished puzzle who seeks a third term as BC's premier.

By Monte Paulsen, 20 Apr 2009, TheTyee.ca

Gordon Campbell, black and white

Campbell: Fitful dreams of 2050.

Gordon Campbell is in full election mode and it can be confusing to watch. The carbon-tax backing premier recently was photographed giving a grinning thumbs up while stumping B.C.'s gas fields with an oil firm boss.

He's asking British Columbians to give him a three-peat, a rare electoral accomplishment that would place him among the ranks of Thomas Pattullo and the Bennetts, W.A.C. and Bill. But what would Gordon Campbell 3.0 look like? That was one of the questions on my mind as I interviewed the premier for a profile appearing in the May issue of Vancouver magazine, from which this excerpt is drawn.

After all, there were some hard to reconcile differences between Campbell's first and second terms as premier.

The first was marked by severe fiscal austerity that included privatizing various government operations (including the controversial sale of BC Rail), a referendum on treaty rights, and the reduction of environmental protection.

His second term included the largest social housing expenditures in decades, an attempted new relationship with First Nations, and passage of a landmark carbon tax.

When asked what sort of premier would emerge during a third term, he said, "I understand the political analysis, but I think I'm the same person. You don't get to do the stuff we're doing now if we hadn't done the financial stuff early."

Few regrets

The "financial stuff" included closing schools and courthouses in small towns as well as tearing up contracts with unions. The Supreme Court eventually ruled tearing up those contracts illegal, but Campbell and his ministers have never apologized for the misstep that cost the province $84 million.

When asked what he would do differently if given the chance, he offered this assessment of his first-term budget cuts:

"Politically, if we could have done the financial changes we did in a way that felt less imposing to people, I'd do that over again, right?" He added: "I'm not sure I know how to do that, to be candid about it."

Conversely, when I asked what accomplishment he felt best about, Campbell replied:

"I am proudest that British Columbians feel good about themselves. You know, when I was growing up in British Columbia, there was a sort of cockiness and a jauntiness in your step and in the step of the people who lived here. I think that people were losing that in the 1990s. They were sort of looking down. Now they're looking up."

The personal lens

Premier Campbell offered several such upbeat anecdotes over the course of the Vancouver magazine interviews, and referred frequently to his excitement about the coming 2010 Winter Games. As I listened to his stories, and considered his own life story, it occurred to me that if one views Campbell's policies through the lens of his own life -- if you put Gordon Campbell on the couch, as it were -- the seemingly incongruous aspects of his record appear to converge.

His fiscal conservatism, for example, resembles neither the angry gnashing of Stephen Harper nor the patrician pruning of Paul Martin. Rather, Campbell's calculated conservatism may be nothing more than the threadbare thrift of the kid with taped-up glasses who grew up among wealthy peers in Vancouver's tony Point Grey neighbourhood.

When asked for his response to the economic crash and its effect on the province, the premier replied, "I think you have to prepare for the worst, and work for the best."

Likewise, his ardent support for the carbon tax looks different when viewed through the eyes of a man who not only longs to ski more often, but hopes his two young grandsons will as well. "For me, what we're doing now is for my grandkids, and your grandkids, and everyone else's grandkids. They're going to be here in 2050. I hope they'll want to live in British Columbia. We can pretend that what we do today won't have an impact, but I know it does."

Attuned to human frailty

In the same way, Campbell's provincial homelessness initiative, viewed through a strictly political lens, seems curious. After all, B.C.'s homeless population ballooned during his second term, in large part as the result of cuts to welfare and other social services made during his first term. But viewed through the personal lens, homelessness -- and its sibling spectres of mental illness and addiction -- are precisely the problems to which Campbell, given his family history, would be drawn.

"You know, my family lived through someone who obviously had significant addiction problems. My dad was an alcoholic, and he took his life. That's pretty clearly not someone who's happy with what's go on. He obviously had some serious challenges I wouldn't have known about when I was 11 or 12, but I lived with the consequences of those from when I was 13 on," he said.

"It's there. Let's not pretend it isn't there. Let's not pretend it doesn't have an impact on families' lives. We're not embarrassed when someone breaks their leg. Why are we embarrassed when someone has a mental illness?"

The interview was coming to an end. The premier's handler had given us the one-minute warning. "One of the challenges is that mental illness is mysterious," said Campbell. "Are you a normal human being? You could be having a problem today, I don't know.

"Or I could be."

A few final questions, handshake, eye contact, camera-ready smile -- and the premier was ushered to his next appointment.

The complete version of this profile appears in the May issue of Vancouver magazine, which hits the newsstands this week.

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

17  Comments:

  • AI

    19-04-2009

    Homelessness

    "But viewed through the personal lens, homelessness -- and its sibling spectres of mental illness and addiction -- are precisely the problems to which Campbell, given his family history, would be drawn."

    Is this why he worked so hard to increase it?

  • Grumpy

    20-04-2009

    Something that grumpy has learned..........

    ............the reason why Gordon Campbell wants to tear down the Port Mann Bridge (the newest of our major lower mainland Fraser River crossings)is that it will be named the Gordon Campbell Bridge - new bridge, new name!

  • PatrickMcEvoyHalston

    20-04-2009

    People like Campbell, like

    People like Campbell, like Newt Gingrich, who were/are determined to expand the number of homeless people, impoverished children out there, are people who grew up thinking that their own neediness--for attention, love--is what caused parents to neglect them. When they become successful, achieving riches/public recognition, they are at risk of "being overwhelmed with the memories of deprivation, despair and dependency [they] [. . .] had so long repressed. The same process was happening to [thousands] [. . .] of other newly wealthy [British Columbians] [. . .] who favored cutting welfare and child aid. Rather than [Cambell] [. . .] feeling his neediness, he dumped it into scapegoats, [thousands] [. . .] of needy [Cdn] [. . .] children, letting them feel his despair for him, saying they had to cut off their aid because it was making children 'too dependent.' What poor children had done wrong was to be dependent and helpless" (deMause, Psychogenic Theory of History).

    For more on why people from less nurturing backgrounds feel compelled to expand the number of poor children and homeless out there, especially when they begin to feel successful, check out this link (scroll down to you get to his discussion of Reagan's America). Link: http://www.psychohistory.com/htm/eln05_psychogenic.html

  • Skywalker

    20-04-2009

    Maybe I am getting cynical..

    ...but every time I hear Campbell talk about his difficult childhood I tend to ask, "So how is it that you have no empathy for others less fortunate?" I think there lies the problem. A lot of places and countries have people that once they have risen from poverty spend all their energies accumulating for themselves and oppressing the poor. I think Campbell's story is his crutch. It sure does not indicate that he is stronger for his experience or that his adversity has strengthened his character. BC has paid the cost of that lack. It is hard to feel sorry for his childhood or for his drunk driving charge when he really has not learned from either.

  • Van Isle

    20-04-2009

    When the Liberals won the

    When the Liberals won the election in '01 it seemed that their attitude was as if they had won a revolution and to hell with anybody who didn't see it that way. Too bad there weren't more Nettletons hanging around the Liberal caucus. When Campbell gave his speech when he won the '05 election the message I heard was "It's my way or the highway".

  • Jeffrey J.

    20-04-2009

    Not Who He Is, But What He Does

    Campbell, like Harper and Bush, represent the latest fad in figurehead governments. Campbell did not spend his adult life as a realtor studying philosophy and political science at night. He is delivering a program carefully developed by modern corporate interests. It doesn't matter WHO he is, sadly. If he goes off message, he'll hear about it right away and correct himself. If he dares to ignore the advise, he's expendable. This has become a very common method of controlling political and economic policy. Also very undemocratic and ultimately, highly dishonest. Great coverage as always.

  • RossK

    21-04-2009

    I dunno.....

    Now that the downturn is upon us, is it possible, when we remove the shiny new packaging on May 13th, that we might actually find ourselves staring at the new, improved Gordon Campbell v1.1?

    .

  • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.