- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Oh, the HypoChristy!
Auditor-general rips BC Liberals for honesty, but premier says municipal governments are what need auditing.
Premier Christy Clark to city halls: Do as I say, not as we do. Photo by Justin Langille.
"The true hypocrite is the one who ceases to perceive his deception, the one who lies with sincerity." -- Andre Gide, 1869-1951
At its best, political hypocrisy can be nothing short of astonishing.
Last week Premier Christy Clark set the gold standard for hypocrisy by calling for an auditor-general of municipal governments at the same the provincial auditor-general ripped her BC Liberal government for "unacceptable" accounting practices going back years!
Clark told delegates to the annual Union of B.C. Municipalities convention that her government would proceed with a new auditor-general for cities and towns, despite their opposition over a total lack of consultation.
But over in Victoria, provincial auditor-general John Doyle was telling the real story -- about Clark's government itself not reporting the books honestly to taxpayers.
Doyle pointed to a lack of transparency about over $80 billion worth of B.C. government contracts in private-public-partnerships or P3s, ranging from independent power producers to construction of the new Port Mann Bridge.
"In the auditing profession, a qualified audit report is a rare occurrence: it indicates to the users of the financial statements that some of the information is not auditable or is misleading," Doyle said.
"During the last 15 years, this office has issued qualified audit reports on the province's financial statements 12 times. For a government that strives for transparency and accountability, this is unacceptable."
Clark's answer to Doyle's body-slamming criticism: "Look over there! Municipal governments have no auditor-general! We're going to give them one!"
And even more amusingly, Finance Minister Kevin Falcon called the report a "somewhat esoteric debate on accounting principles."
Somewhat esoteric? B.C.'s auditor-general just called the government's performance "unacceptable"!
Oh, the coincidences!
But the hypocrisy gets better still, because two government allies made it even better.
First Phil Hochstein, president of the Independent Contractors and Businesses Association, major BC Liberal Party donors, issued a poll just before Clark spoke to the UBCM that said the public supports a municipal auditor-general.
What surprising timing!
Then the Canadian Taxpayers Federation's B.C. branch comes out with its own support for reining in those evil municipal politicians with an auditor-general.
And to strike even more fear into city councils, the CTF is demanding they sign a "taxpayers pledge" to cut their own salaries if they increase property taxes beyond inflation without a referendum.
Who is promoting the CTF's cheesy demands? Why, none other than Jordan Bateman, the CTF's B.C. communications director who happens to be the former BC Liberal constituency association president for BC Liberal Energy Minister Rich Coleman! What a coincidence.
And then the Canadian Federation of Independent Business launches its own remarkably similar "taxpayers pledge" last week.
But amazingly, the ICBA, the CFT and the CFIB -- who are all so concerned about taxpayers -- have said absolutely nothing about the provincial government's "unacceptable" financial reporting.
And they all strongly supported the Harmonized Sales Tax despite their claims of concern for ordinary taxpayers, who voted to extinguish it in the August provincial referendum.
Could it be that the ICBA -- some of whose members are building the Port Mann Bridge -- doesn't want to criticize its biggest patron, the B.C. government? Nah!
Oh the omitted truths!
None of this stopped Non-Partisan Association mayoralty candidate Suzanne Anton and her team from immediately endorsing the CFIB pledge or the call for a municipal auditor-general.
And even more coincidence, my fellow 24 hours columnist Daniel Fontaine -- chief of staff to former NPA mayor Sam Sullivan -- pumped the ICBA poll just days after it was issued!
But let's see how both levels of government actually compare on accountability:
Municipal governments and school boards are required by B.C. law to balance their budget every year -- and that legislation was never repealed.
The BC Liberal government broke and then repealed its own balanced budget legislation, going $2.8 billion in debt.
Municipal governments must obtain the approval of taxpayers for all major capital expenditures in a binding referendum before proceeding.
The B.C. government has increased capital expenditures by $45 billion over the past 10 years -- all without a single referendum vote.
Municipal governments hold open council meetings on a mostly weekly basis where the public and media can attend. The B.C. cabinet holds weekly closed meetings where neither public nor media are allowed.
Municipal governments hold elections every three years on a fixed election date.
B.C. governments hold elections every four years on a fixed election date that the premier openly speculated for months she would break to call a fall election to her political advantage.
Municipal delegates voted overwhelmingly to reject B.C.'s idea of imposing an auditor-general on them without consultation, noting that position would be under the political control of the government.
The B.C. government has consistently ignored its own auditor-general's demands to make its books more transparent and accountable to the point that it is "unacceptable" to an independent officer of the Legislature.
The provincial auditor-general is an independent officer of the B.C. Legislature and does not report to the government of the day. The municipal auditor-general would not be independent and would be under B.C. government supervision.
I would have to say the local governments win this debate hands down.
Read the report
For those who really care about accountability, provincial auditor-general John Doyle's report makes for grim reading.
His section on "disclosure of contractual obligation" is nothing short of stunning.
"As Exhibit 7 shows, these contractual obligations have exceeded $50 billion since 2007, and increased to $80 billion in 2011," Doyle writes.
"Most of the 2011 increase is due to BC Hydro entering into long-term energy purchase agreements with independent power producers. However, few details on these agreements are provided by government," he drily notes.
For the BC Liberals and their friends to lecture anyone on accountability is unacceptable hypocrisy. ![]()




28
Login or register to post comments
G West
33 weeks ago
What would one expect?
What would one expect from a premier who got her extreme self-confidence and lack of perspective fielding calls on CKNW?
Fish-counter
33 weeks ago
Without being sarcastic, I suggest that the First Nations
desperately need auditing as to how they spend money. 'Nuff said.
Dan the socialist
33 weeks ago
This has been the Liberals MO
This has been the Liberals MO since the start. If a thorough audit was done on this government I would not be surprised if some were wearing orange jumpsuits at the end of the day....
seth
33 weeks ago
Pirate Power and the BC Environmental movement
Note that the AG is now confirming the $65B in obligations for IPP's contracts that I've been giving out on these pages for almost two years now. There are still contracts waiting signature.
Note as well that pretty well the entire amount of power purchased could have been had with a single zero environmental footprint Candu 6E nuke worth $1.5B. $25B less than half of IPP expenditures spent on nuke power would have been sufficient to end all of BC's net GHG emissions.
Despite the 100% antinuclear Big Oil sponsored propaganda from the "green" industry, main stream, and progressive media most British Columbian's would have supported nuclear power. Almost all would if they actually were aware of the facts. For example, the Georgia Straight acting no doubt on instructions from Greenpeace insiders and contrary to stated policy actually blocked almost all of my comments correcting the junk science in their recently sponsored antinuclear series.
Junk science embracing antinuclear global warming denying environmentalists like Gwen Barlee seem to so easily ignore all the warnings about the imminence of an warming precipice from reputable science preferring their "renewable" fantasy to reality.
While acclaiming James Hansen as the world's foremost environmental scientist, founder of 350.org, arrestee at the White House tar sands protests and Greenie Superstar, they ignore his pleas to actually solve the problem with nuke power.
Gordon Campbell and his stockbroker cronies over at Private Power found all this to be most convenient in carrying out the biggest taxpayer ripoff in Canadian history.
Here's the world's foremost climatologist James Hansen speaking directly to the Georgia Straight, Gwen Barlee, Greenpeace, David Suzuki, Mark Jaccard, Pembina, and rest of the BC environmental movement.
On wind and solar:
"Wind and solar are like believing in the Easter Bunny and the Tooth fairy"
On Greenpeace's massive monetary support from Big Oil
'The insightful cynic will note: “Now I understand all the fossil fuel ads with windmills and solar panels – fossil fuel moguls know that renewables are no threat to the fossil fuel business.” The tragedy is that many environmentalists line up on the side of the fossil fuel industry, advocating renewables as if they, plus energy efficiency, would solve the global climate change matter.'
On the Green Koolarid Greenpeace dispenses:
http://bravenewclimate.com/2011/08/05/hansen-energy-kool-aid
Grumpy
33 weeks ago
I beleive.....
....that the office of the auditor General should become like that of Britain's National Audit Office, where governments at all levels and quasi government organizations Metro Vancouver, TransLink are audited on a regular basis.
Today, municipalities have become a financial sinkhole of incompetent bureaucrats, who only create more and more red tape, just to hire more bureaucrats. The current municipal organizations are unsustainable and value for money audits must become a regular routine.
pianosaurus rex
33 weeks ago
Accounting practices
The accounting here is completed by myself.
Beginning today, when I complete my HST form for the October end quarter report, I am going to use esoteric accounting principles just as the government does.
And I have government to thank for setting the example for me. As this government is setting the legal precedent to do so I welcome any writ dropped on my desk.
Fiat lux
33 weeks ago
"Conservative" governments
"Conservative" governments are propagandized as being "great fiscal managers", that's why people elect them.
When Campbell was first elected, the BC debt was $33.8 billion. His great fiscal management increased this to $53.4 billion and people applauded.
Then came the P3 racket, where the public pays the higher interests, plus the interests on the interests, plus the profits of the corporations, but these are not recorded as "debt".
We pay through the nose , but it isn't debt, but "contractual obligation", or "contingent liability" lapped up by the public as "sound fiscal management", raising the real debt of the province to over $100. billion, or over 3 times of the debt left by the NDP 10 years ago.
The same does on federally and the public has no clue, but keeps reelecting these fiscal masterminds.
Any society that goes for the P3 fraud is either stupid or is being misled by people of questionable integrity.
Ed Deak.
pianosaurus rex
33 weeks ago
off topic for a minute
Seth touched upon a topic regarding the Georgia Strait publication;
As far as the Georgia Strait publication is concerned ever since the million dollar assessment debacle with the time out series, the whole flavour of that newspaper has changed.
Not sure what McLeod is smoking any longer, but I found it to be quite a humorous irony that while the Georgia Strait has not one, not two, but six pages of adult sex proprietors propping up the revenue stream to keep the publication out of the red, the local store Womyn’s Ware advertising was denied because the dildo in the advertisement was deemed to be “too phallic.”
So seth, to be censored from the Georgia Strait would be a badge I would wear with pride. Even the Georgia Strait now has a desire to compromise the truth as per many of the other print publications.
The Georgia Strait has become the “best unknown” MSM publication.
Fish-counter
33 weeks ago
If Nanaimo is anything to go by, municipalities need oversight
The most recent egregious use of public money was the severance package given to the city manager. He received two years of full pay at over $200,000 per year, just to leave the scene and get out of the way of the new administration. That put everyone's hackles up, especially since there is a new convention centre sitting empty, with no hotel accomodation to support it.
I would have put the ex-manager on special assignment to get the hotel built or forfeit his severace pay. He knows quite a bit about municipal affairs and has contracted himself to other municipalities as a consultant, so he could have promoted the city very easily. Instead, he can be heard bragging about his settlement at the local gym.
In other news, Nanaimo City departments budget on an incremental basis and they have not had an external assessment done for many years. Councillor Jim Kipp wanted an external review of services, and a zero-budget approach, but his idea was rejected. The City administration was left to do their own internal assessment, which, by Jove, proved that all is well and they are on the right track. what a surprise!
Nanaimo needs a new vision for the future and it won't come from inside the present administration. That isn't a criticism, it is just a fact.
Overall we have excellent recreational facilities and we are developing a long term vision, but we also need new ideas. I suspect that describes most BC municipalities.
By the way, asking for an audit does not imply any wrongdoing but a good audit would propose improvements and efficiencies.
When you stop getting better, you stop being good.
Skywalker
33 weeks ago
Right on Bill!
I said it in another post but.here it is again. Municipalities are required now to have their finances audited. These reports are available to voters. A second audit mandated by a corrupt provincial government won't do anything. If municipalities elect incompetents then the municipal voter needs a brain audit.
All the BC Liberals are doing is deflecting attention away from themselves by going after municipalities (and teachers".
slowthinker
33 weeks ago
Zero base budgeting...that
Zero base budgeting...that would be nice. I wondered why the city budget was the way it was...incremental. Maybe we could get rid of some of the entitlements along the way.
Skywalker
33 weeks ago
Who really needs an audit?
Sean Hollman's site shows the figures on the overruns on projects done by the BC Liberals. On only three projects: BC Place, Port Mann and the Vancouver Convention Center the cost overruns totaled $2.4 billion dollars. By comparison the NDP had one which we all know and hear about constantly and it was a total cost (not just the overrun) of $463 million. So who really needs an Audit?
gdub
33 weeks ago
All style no stamina...
'Christy Clark Fan' seems conspicuously absent from this conversation...
zalm
33 weeks ago
Christy fan is
...likely back in jail again for stalking. He's missing from quite a few threads this week.
Fishie, not to discount your thoughts on natives, but they get a billion-five in funding every year, and about $800 million in contingent liabilities to cover this year - all federal money.
The province only has legal funding for land claims, and medicare provisions on the table, and that totalling $88 million, if I read the public accounts aright.
With $80 billion worth of junked cars in our own front yard, and no front steps on our house, shouldn't we be addressing our own issues first, as our General Oddity has done?
pwlg
33 weeks ago
independent audits
There is much to comment on...
I have read portions of the Auditor General's report (actually conducted by several people within the Auditor General's Office) and there is much to learn how our provincial government has been hiding debt and providing give-aways to industries who are flush with cash profits.
I don't think one can use the argument that municipalities don't need an auditor since the province is so deceitful in its own accounting.
I like what Grumpy had to say. One needs an auditor that examines all public accounts whether they be provincial or municipal.
Even if councils meet once a week it does not give the elector access to change accounting practices in their municipalities. In fact, the elector for the most part only partially scrutinizes municipal finances when they receive their property tax notice.
Also, not all municipalities are required to go to their residents if they wish to spend money on major capital projects. They are only required to go to the public in a referendum if they wish to borrow money for these projects.
If a local government raises property taxes to pay for a capital project and bypasses the banks or the Municipal Finance Authority then would it need to go to its residents for approval?
Just because we have dishonesty and a lack of transparency in our provincial government does not mean we shouldn't be demanding transparency and honesty of our local governments.
pwlg
33 weeks ago
local government accountability
When a few mayors who control most of the power in the region (Prince Gregor of Vancouver and Princess Diane of Surrey) can local metro residents have access to transparency and accountability?
Now throw in a Mayor's Council, a figment of the provincial government's imagination, where all one needs to do is have Vancouver, Surrey a few of those mini-states of Anmore, Bowen Island, White Rock and Belcarra vote for something like adding more taxes so that Translink can borrow money and you have a system that is not transparent and accountable and circumvents the Local Government Act which requires local governments to hold referendums if they intend to borrow money. Phew!
Well it's technically not local governments borrowing money, its Translink or RedInk (more apt don't you think). What a beautiful accounting instrument devised by the current Finance Minister, Kevin Falcon.
Is RedInk accountable to regional residents? No. So what is the purpose of the Mayor's Council? They have no control on what the province does with its gas taxes. Fuel taxes are the domain of provincial and federal governments so why are the Mayor's (specifically Prince Gregor and Princess Diane) permitting themselves to be used?
Well it's not only gas taxes that RedInk needs to finance expensive urban rail initiatives but property taxes (which are the domain of local governments).
But what say do we local residents of the region have on whether or not our local governments can provide indirectly the money for RedInk's loans? None!
Bring on the auditor and any other body that can get rid of accounting instruments that circumvent democracy, public accountability and transparency.
No other transit agency in North America is governed by a state or provincial body (none of them have a puppet with strings like our Mayor's Council). All other transit agencies are locally controlled and accountable to those who finance the agency (us). Any new taxes in the US require a referendum. After all, its not the Mayor's paying the bills of RedInk, its all of us.
Let us have a say!!!
John Corman
33 weeks ago
Reality Check
Bill Tieleman states:
"But over in Victoria, provincial auditor-general John Doyle was telling the real story -- about Clark's government itself not reporting the books honestly to taxpayers."
Take a year at random and look at the auditor's report on the province's financial statement. I chose 1998.
The Auditors report July 1998:
"In my opinion, except for the effects of not expensing the loans etc etc."
In other words a qualification of the provincial governments financial statements as we have this year.
This is not an earth shattering event, as a matter of fact, something quite common.
Skywalker
33 weeks ago
Look Folks...
...every municipal government must have their books audited. By law!
G West
33 weeks ago
Oh really - you really want to go there?
Doyle:
"In the auditing profession, a qualified audit report is a rare occurrence," ... "It indicates to the users of the financial statements that some of the information is not auditable or is misleading."
Thank heaven there are still SOME accountants and auditors who haven't drunk the Arthur Andersen / Accenture Kool-Ade.
Frank Lee
33 weeks ago
Dix is worse
Have you ever seen Adrian spitting with indignation at the Liberals for "playing games" and their accursed "spin machine"? Even his supposedly greatest achievement as an Opposition critic, when he took the Liberals to task for not coming clean about the circumstances surrounding a death in the Childrens' ministry, reeked with hypocrisy.
The reason Dix was so clairvoyant about the Liberals' evasive manoeuvres was that he was the point man for accountability evasion in teh Clark government. It was the clearest case of it taking a thief to catch a thief that I have ever seen--and the clearest case of a pot calling the kettle black. And I am a Phd in POlitical Science with five years experince working at both levels of government!
What ever you think of the hypocrisy of the Shallow Woman, that of the Hollow Man is even worse.
John Corman
33 weeks ago
Zalm - Please explain
You state:
"...but they (natives) get a billion-five in funding every year, and about $800 million in contingent liabilities......"
Question: How can someone give a "contigent liability" to another and, why would anyone want to accept this odd gift.
Reminds me of the joke about the irrate empoyee who wanted to get even with his employer so he absconded with the company's accounts payable
G West
33 weeks ago
Wow!
Five years exerience AND a Phd - am I ever impressed.
Corman - you're right - it's an exceedingly bad deal for the 'natives'...if you'd take the trouble to look it up, you'll find zalm is correct.
The funding formula for the costs of treaty negotiations alone is based upon an 80/20 loan to grant ratio. Many of the treaty tables have racked up bills and liabilities to senior governments which will totally wipe out the proceeeds of any settlement if and when it's negotiated.
That's the kind of deal you get when you have both hands tied behind your back and you're given the 'opportunity' to play in the only 'game' in town....
Frank Lee
33 weeks ago
Let's have improved Auditing both locally and provincially
I agree with the last two writers that just because the province doesn't have its own books in order is no reason to not have improved auditing for local government, which as we all know tends to be dominated by local real estate and other business interests.
As Dix's speech makes plain, he is just playing the tired old game of feeding off municipal discontent while one is in Opposition.
And if I am right about Adrian Dix, his government will mark the first time in history that a new government (especially an NDP one) will NOT take a major step forward in improving accountability.
G West
33 weeks ago
Frank Lee
So, let me get this right.
The government we have 'now' made the following set of promises when they gained power...
Here's the first half of their list - which appeared over Gordon Campbell's signature...
It’s time for a New Era of Accountability. Our plan will deliver real transparent, accountable government.
Our Vision: The most open, accountable and democratic government in Canada.
Establish workable initiative legislation, to make it feasible for British Columbians to call for a referendum on issues of province-wide concern that fall within the provincial government’s jurisdiction.
Establish workable recall legislation, to make it easier for citizens to hold MLAs accountable.
Give all MLAs and citizens a better voice in government through active legislative committees.
Hold open Cabinet meetings at least once a month that are televised and broadcast live on the Internet.
Give all government MLAs a meaningful new role in policy development and service planning through a new system of Cabinet decision-making.
Introduce free votes in the Legislature, to allow all MLAs to vote freely on behalf of their constituents on all matters not specifically identified as a vote of confidence.
Not sell or privatize BC Rail.
Vigorously defend the Crown's ownership of provincial land and resources.
Protect BC Hydro and all of core assets, including dams, reservoirs and power lines under public ownership.
Restore an independent BC Utilities Commission, to re-regulate BC Hydro’s electricity rates.
G West
33 weeks ago
and here's the second half
Pass a Living Rivers Act to protect and improve BC’s river systems with scientifically-based standards for watershed management, enhancements to fish habitat, and a 10-year program to correct past damage.
Push for provincial control over the management and revenues of BC’s offshore fisheries, to improve fisheries management and protect fishery jobs.
Adopt a scientifically-based, principled approach to environmental management that ensures sustainability, accountability and responsibility.
You shouldn’t have to pay higher than necessary electricity or auto insurance rates, because government wants to play politics with BC Hydro or ICBC.
Give school boards multi-year funding envelopes, to improve long-term education planning and budgeting.
Ensure that music, arts and physical education curriculums are fully funded in BC’s public schools.
Hold the line on court fees, to ensure that everyone has affordable access to our justice system.
Establish regional transportation authorities that are accountable to local taxpayers and give local communities more control over their transportation needs and planning.
Require taxpayer approval by regional referendums prior to authorization of any new type of TransLink tax or levy.
Outlaw “offloading” of provincial government costs onto the backs of local property taxpayers.
Restore open tendering on government contracts to allow fair competition for businesses and provide better value to taxpayers.
Implement a flexible, innovative program to increase the supply of affordable housing.
G West
33 weeks ago
Now, Frank Lee
Please tell me how any future government could acheive a worse record of following through on their promises than the difference between reality and what the Campbell Miss Christy government has achieved?
I'll be waiting.
Skywalker
33 weeks ago
Wow GWest...
...it is even worse than I thought. I had forgotten some of those promises. Thanks for reminding me. Now I am really depressed.
G West
33 weeks ago
My pleasure Skywalker
Take a cut and paste copy of those promises - because the Liberals have expunged THAT message from any online source that's still extant.
You can still get a cached copy from google or search it out on the wayback machine - but other than that, those 'promises' have been confined to the dustbin of history for obvious reasons.