Opinion

Dear Grads, Help Save Us!

Armed with an Arts degree, you can be a hero.

By Michael Byers, 27 May 2009, TheTyee.ca

Graduate

'Joan of Arc needed her crusade.'

[Editor's note: Political science professor Byers delivered this speech to graduating students at UBC's "Great Arts Send-Off".]

In medieval England, before the development of written land registries, local children were conscripted as witnesses to real estate transactions. At the exact moment that a piece of turf was symbolically handed from seller to buyer, the kids were whacked on the side of the head. By making the transfer of land memorable, the assault provided security of title for as long as the children lived.

Twenty-one years ago this month, I wrote my last exam as an undergraduate Arts student. I remember the occasion vividly because, with just 30 minutes left to go, the university was struck by a power outage.

There we were, rows upon rows of anxious students, sitting at temporary desks in a windowless gymnasium in pitch darkness. A quick-witted invigilator opened two outside doors, allowing a dull light into the hall -- along with a blast of cold air.

Four years of English literature classes had equipped me to recognize the symbolism. The lights had gone off -- not on -- at the conclusion of my Arts degree. As for the blast of cold air: what better metaphor for the harsh realities of life outside the university?

The true value of an Arts degree

In retrospect, I learned many useful things during my studies. I learned about passion and politics from William Shakespeare, evil from Joseph Conrad, cynicism from Niccolò Machiavelli and hope from Immanuel Kant. I learned that differences of culture, religion, ethnicity and sexuality make the human species more interesting. I learned that history matters; that asking questions is a mark of intellect, not ignorance; and that words, wielded well, have the power to change the world.

I even learned about the existence of the female orgasm -- though only because my French professor talked about it in her class.

In the past two decades, I've also developed a more positive view of adversity. Sometimes, it takes a challenge to bring out the best in people. Monumental challenges can inspire true greatness. Would Winston Churchill have achieved heroic status in the absence of the Nazi threat? Would Mahatma Ghandi and Nelson Mandela have been immortalized without the obstacles of colonialism and apartheid? Would Terry Fox have become a Canadian icon without losing his leg?

Every Edmund Hillary needs his Everest; every Joan of Arc her crusade.

This is not, I should stress, an argument for an "everyone-for-herself" approach to life. Many of our fellow human beings are too ill-equipped by fate or circumstance to overcome the adversities they face. Some people are heroes for just staying alive.

But you -- the UBC Arts graduates of 2009 -- are well-equipped for challenges. You've learned to think critically, communicate well, and cooperate with others to achieve common goals. You've acquired a respect for the insights and accomplishment of past generations, so that you stand on the shoulders of giants -- rather than starting at ground level again.

There are many future heroes present here this evening; more, indeed, than in most graduating years.

I say this with confidence because we can already see some of the monumental challenges you face.

Economic collapse

In the last nine months, the global economy has experienced a deep contraction. Trillions of dollars have been lost; hundreds of millions of livelihoods destroyed. Banks have stopped lending; trade flows have dried up. The ranks of the homeless and hungry grow deeper by the day.

Governments have responded by nationalizing scores of companies deemed too large or important to fail. Truly staggering sums of borrowed money are being spent in a desperate effort to resuscitate business and consumer confidence.

Most of you will have been touched by the economic crisis already. All of you will know students who could not afford to be here this evening. Many of you will not have a job lined up for after university. At the same time, the competition for places in graduate or professional schools has become truly fierce.

Climate breakdown

If the economic crisis were not enough, two months ago, 2500 of the world's leading climate change scientists issued the starkest possible warning to humanity. Climate change is accelerating more quickly than they had anticipated. Powerful feedback loops are beginning to operate, like the warming of the Arctic Ocean by solar energy that snow and ice would previously have reflected back into space. Yet greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise -- as politicians shy away from taking the decisive measures necessary to reduce them.

A two degree Celsius increase in the average global temperature is now almost inevitable. This September, Oxford University is hosting a conference to discuss the implications of an increase of four degrees or more.

Consider just one of the consequences of a temperature change of that magnitude: sea-level rise caused by the melting of glaciers in Greenland and Antarctica and the simple expansion of ocean water as it warms.

Most climate change scientists now believe that we'll see a rise of at least one metre this century. When that happens, much of the Fraser River delta will be inundated, including hundreds of thousands of homes and some of this province's best farmland.

Around the world, fully one-tenth of humanity will be displaced. That’s 600 million climate change refugees -- 20 times Canada's current population -- by the end of this century. How many of them will find refuge here, whether we want them or not?

George Monbiot, the Guardian newspaper columnist, argues that the term "climate change" no longer describes the situation we're in. It's time, he says, to speak of "climate breakdown."

Short-term thinking

The two monumental crises we face -- economic collapse and climate breakdown -- share at least one underlying cause.

In the late 20th century, Western societies and governments adopted shorter time horizons for decision making. By speeding up the flow of information, advancements in communications technology shortened the attention span and patience of media and citizenry. Politics became about the sound-bite and quick fix rather than the substantive speech and long-term solution.

In the corporate sector, there was a parallel shift from long-term dividends to short-term stock prices as the principal measurement of business success. Corporations began to focus on mergers, acquisitions, outsourcing and advertising rather than making better widgets and training better workers.

At the same time, it became widely accepted -- to the point of being considered beyond question -- that markets were always more efficient than governments in distributing resources, generating wealth and providing services.

But measurements of efficiency depend on the timeline used and the kinds of wealth you include.

Over the short term, subprime mortgages, derivatives and other financial innovations generated considerable wealth. Over the slightly longer term, they've prompted a global economic collapse.

Heavily subsidized roads, low taxes on fuel and lax energy-efficiency standards drove decades of economic growth in Canada and the United States. But those same decisions look stupidly short-sighted when you factor in the climate change impact, the health and social costs of people spending dozens of hours each week alone in their cars, and the absurd lack of fit between our sprawling cities and the reduced ecological footprints now required by both climate change and peak oil.

Doing things differently

Arts graduates have the tools to do things differently. We teach you about history, sociology, philosophy, psychology, literature and so much more because human experience—the collective memory of generations—provides a depth and wealth of knowledge and insight that guards against blinkered and short-term thinking.

Thanks to people like you, even the worst crises can be overcome.

So yes, we live in extraordinarily challenging times. And some of you will rise to the challenges in truly extraordinary ways.

Two decades ago, when the lights went out during my last Arts exam, the invigilators offered each of us a choice. We could finish the exam in the cold air and dull light, or return later in the week for a rescheduled last half-hour.

Most of us kept writing. And though I didn't see the symbolism of that decision then, I certainly do now.

Don't shy away from adversity. Carpe diem. Seize the day.

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

14  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • PatrickMcEvoyHalston

    3 years ago

    "But you -- the UBC Arts

    "But you -- the UBC Arts graduates of 2009 -- are well-equipped for challenges. You've learned to think critically, communicate well, and cooperate with others to achieve common goals. You've acquired a respect for the insights and accomplishment of past generations, so that you stand on the shoulders of giants -- rather than starting at ground level again."

    Last time I checked, this whole standing on the shoulders of giants thing, was under about 50 years of non-stop challenge by people in the Arts, who pretty loudly assessed these giants as amounting to, well, giants--that is, monsters. Faculty of Arts a bit on the conservative side at UBC? Or is it just tactically smart to feed students' parents what they want to hear (and can be expected to handle), that is, that will gloss their brood in genteel shine?

    The speech you delivered was no doubt truthful to your experience and sense of things, but seems dumb and inadequate. The link between Shakespeare, Keats, and Nietzsche, and over-all well preparedness to handle things like global warming and economic fracturing, requires some extrapolation, some fleshing out. Or at least it ought to require as much: There is some chance that, as Barbara Ehrenreich suggests, the Arts programs can keep on advertising the study of Shakespeare as miraculously ideal for attending to the student's soul AND his/her career needs (who'd a thunk, eh?) AND now our collective need to save society from itself (this is a bit of a new one--allowing you some room to de-emphasize the ideal career prep bit), and actually serve employers rather well--they want and need intelligent enough, tractable recruits, in loads of debt and desperately in need of reassurance, to reliably be counted on to think themselves the world's saviors, while dutifully towing the party line.

  • Moonbug

    3 years ago

    Nice speech. I wonder how

    Nice speech. I wonder how many students "got it" - especially since UBC is primarily a bastion of many of the most privileged kids in BC.

    I hope they got it. I really do.

  • Countrytype

    3 years ago

    a meeting of the minds?

    Let's hope that the arts grads don't think they can go it alone, and that the sciences and professions grads are not so segregated from the arts grads that they discount the arts grads entirely.

    I'm not sure how interdisciplinary UBC forces their undergrads to be. SFU has minimal Writing/Quantitative/Breadth requirements now in lower and upper level parts of the undergrad degree which while much hated are good, I think, for broadening student horizons to include arts AND science to some degree. Without some such requirement any field can become so focused that it's a wonder anyone can think that they have the answer to any social problem.

  • seth

    3 years ago

    Artsies

    Virtually all politicians, business executives, bankers, and stockbrockers are Artsies. The most vile of them,lawyers are all Artsies.

    So the corrupt class that has caused all the social, environmental and economic destruction, are almost all Artsies. Must be something wrong with your training. Perhaps Morality 101,201,301 and 401 should be added to course requirements.

    In fact most of Gordo's neocon MP's are you guessed it - Artsies. Gordon Hogg out in White Rock is actually a graduate of Antioch.

    Most of you couldn't change a tire to save your life - don't have a clue. But y'all can sure sell out fast.

    Go figure.

  • VivianLea Doubt

    3 years ago

    Thank god/ess

    for that French professor.

  • morechatter

    3 years ago

    You Gotta Save Yourself

    Before you can go save anyone or anything else and I don't care how many times you take that to the drawing board.

  • Fiat lux

    3 years ago

    They can't do a damn thing

    They can't do a damn thing as long as the criminal idiocy of neoclassical economics is being taught in other parts of the campus, damaging the minds of students.

    The fools who teach this crap would have been laughed out of the classrooms when I was student, albeit not in economics, but can still remember the heady, daring days we dreamed and lived in over 50 years ago.

    Now they're revered as "wealth creators".

    So, who is going to start asking questions and show the world the destruction they're causing ?

    How about you Michael Byers ? You obviously can see the terrible results of this crime wave, how about looking for the causes ?

    Ed Deak.

  • VivianLea Doubt

    3 years ago

    Patrick

    "...gloss their brood in genteel shine?"

    Nice, very nice.

  • PatrickMcEvoyHalston

    3 years ago

    "Sheen" lets the white teeth

    "Sheen" lets the white teeth shine, so "sheen," not shine, VivianLea

  • VivianLea Doubt

    3 years ago

    is an apology in order?

    :)
    Did miss something, Patrick?
    perfectly possible...

  • PatrickMcEvoyHalston

    3 years ago

    Yes--from me: I thought I

    Yes--from me: I thought I wrote "gloss their brood in genteel SHEEN," not "gloss their brook in genteel SHINE." I was correcting you, when I was the one in error. Sorry about that.

  • VivianLea Doubt

    3 years ago

    Either way

    I like it.
    (I have been corrected an uncountable number of times this last semester...)
    Perhaps I might venture on a limb here and say I thought this was a slightly different voice - anyway, nice turn of phrase that I rather envy.

  • Moonbug

    2 years ago

    keep speaking truth Ed Deak

    Thanks!

  • Bailey

    2 years ago

    Maybe only artists could change it, Mr. Deak

    Your outrage at the abuses of logic and honour that constitute modern economics really resonates with me, sir.

    I look at the thing and I think that such falsity could only come to such universal acceptance through the mass communication media, and then only by misusing them to spread cynical lies.

    I mean, your points on the ways resources are allocated, then accounted without reference to the holes they leave in the systems that sustain the world are quite self-evidently valid, yet the powers that be seem unable to wrest their eyes from the glamor of 'wealth' long enough to even consider them.

    It's an image, that glamor. It's a prose poem written in currencies. I think it must have been originally created by an artistic type itself. It has no reality other than that which our culture gives it, by believing.

    Now that the gloss is beginning to wear off it, and the real costs are showing up in so many ways undeniable to any but the blind, and the false assumptions and outright lies that support the whole house of cards are peeking through, who else but artists could have the skill at creating new meanings and new images to replace the old?

    Somebody is going to have to do it. Somebody has to rebuild a new economy that not only accounts the costs properly, but also chooses purposes in human ways, bypassing the old ideas of what 'interests' really are.

    This will be an important creation. It will have to inspire so many to such enormous sacrifices and give them such hope, to enable them to build a world on it.

    I doubt it could be done, if there is no art in the hearts of the ones who must undertake to do it.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.