News

Foreign Worker Review Was Already Underway, Permits Won't Be Pulled: Kenney

Immigration minister confident staff issued valid permits for Chinese temp miners in BC.

By Jeremy J. Nuttall, 10 Nov 2012, TheTyee.ca

Jason Kenney, minister of immigration

Immigration minister Jason Kenney: Labour minister Diane Finley's review announcement Thursday was about 'something that's already been underway.'

Related

Permits allowing foreign workers from China to work at a mining project near Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia will not be rescinded by immigration authorities as a review of the case goes on, said the federal Minister of Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism.

Minister Jason Kenney gave a different picture from news reports stating controversy over Chinese miners in B.C. "prompted" the review, saying the Conservative government had already been reviewing the Temporary Foreign Workers Program for months before the uproar in B.C.

The minister was addressing a Burnaby Board of Trade function Friday afternoon and afterwards told media the 201 miners will still be able to work at HD Mining's Murray River project.

The issuing of the permits has become a major concern among B.C. labour groups since the United Steelworkers Union found advertisements placed by HD Mining that said those who spoke Mandarin were preferred for jobs at the site.

In order to get a permit under the Temporary Foreign Worker Program, a Labour Market Opinion showing sufficient efforts to hire Canadian workers was carried out must be submitted.

Yesterday Canada's Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development Diane Finley said, in light of the revelations, a review of the case and the entire program would be launched.

But Kenney said as far as his ministry is concerned the workers will still be able to work at the mine site, despite demands they not be allowed to do so until after any investigations are completed.

"People who have been issued valid work permits have the permits, so they have status in Canada," said Kenney.

"If there's a review of the validity of the Labour Market Opinions we'll wait to hear from HRSDC about that -- but as my ministry does the work permits, as far as we're concerned they were validly issued."

'Permits must be pulled': Steelworkers union

Labour groups alleged the language requirements were put in place to exclude Canadians and are also concerned the miners are paying hefty fees for the jobs.

The provincial government has also launched an investigation.

Stephen Hunt from the United Steelworkers said he can't accept the permits remaining valid during the government investigations.

"I think the permits must be pulled and I think the whole LMO was predicated on fraud," said Hunt.

"Don't continue to allow somebody to commit a crime by enabling them."

Upon announcing the review Thursday Finley admitted it does appear there are some problems with the TFWP.

But Friday Kenney said a routine examination of the entire program was already underway and has been for some time.

"The Government of Canada has been doing an overall review of the Temporary Foreign Worker Program for the past several months and we'll be finalizing that in the next few months," he said.

"What she (Finley) commented on yesterday was something that's already been underway."

Foreign temp worker controversy grow

B.C. hosts about 70,000 temporary foreign workers and the program has been mired in controversy, especially during the last month.

News a group of workers awarded $2 million after winning a human rights complaint in 2008 has yet to be paid was brought to the spotlight by the media earlier this week.

The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal found the three dozen workers from Latin America were discriminated against because they were paid far less than their European counterparts when digging the Canada Line tunnel.

As well, Friday the B.C. Public Interest Advocacy Centre launched a human rights complaint on behalf of four Mexican workers working at a Tim Horton's in Dawson Creek, B.C.

The workers said they were the victims of mental abuse, racism and poor living conditions.

At Minister Kenney's appearance in Burnaby Friday there was a brief struggle as a woman protesting the alleged mistreatment of foreign workers was forcibly ejected from the lobby of the hotel where Kenney was speaking.

Immigration lawyer Tim Bailey said some foreign workers are vulnerable and can be hesitant to file complaints or stick up for themselves in the workplace.

"The Canadian government is not saying to everyone who gets a work permit, 'welcome to Canada,'" said Bailey.

"It's saying, 'you're here for a limited purpose and we will tolerate your presence here until your work permit expires.'"

He said consequently many foreign workers who are in Canada based on LMOs are usually afraid of being seen as doing something wrong and then being deported, which encourages silence when their rights are infringed.

"Ultimately that is what they're facing," said Bailey.

He added his curiosity was raised when he heard about the language requirement issues related to HD Mining's permits and that the company applied for so many permits at once, saying in his experience it was a large request.  [Tyee]

26  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Bailey

    27 weeks ago

    Curiosity

    Can we find out whether any of this 201 workers paid a recruitment fee for their jobs? I believe such fees are illegal, but workers who have paid would seem to have little chance of a refund from the snakeheads should they have their permits pulled. Many years wages, I believe. A fee that will have been paid by whole families or even villages.

    Does this consideration play any part in Minister Kenney's decision to carry on regardless?

  • Hakuin

    27 weeks ago

    Watch

    They will bring foreign labour to exploit and abuse while inflating the profits of the one percent and weakening further our middle class. Then when it is politically expedient, the foreign labour will be transmuted by a lapdog media into vagabond interlopers, to be ghettoized, scapegoated and expelled. Really, if you are already on top of our dung hill it's all win-win. Provided you are ALREADY on top. Such a pity so many of our home grown temporarily embarrassed millionaires believe that to be their case.

  • Skywalker

    27 weeks ago

    Another discredited harperite speaks.

    So this is an exercise in damage control. A controversy rises and you pretend that you were on top of it all along. Even making Finley look a fool is no problem. Jason Kenney has shown himself to be just another lying puppet of Harper's so what is new. They won't rescind the permit, it was what they wanted all along, the public be damned.

  • Rolly-polly

    27 weeks ago

    Oh

    So it was just a bunch of trickery, was it?

  • hg

    27 weeks ago

    Investigation

    Jason please BS, Balderdash, Twaddle, theses are the first printable words that come to mind

  • RockyRacoon

    27 weeks ago

    We need to organize a United Front Against Austerity and carry

    out a General Strike. All the oppressed from those downtown B.C to Nfld...Unions non union employed unemployed disabled a General Strike is the only way to stop the austerity bus and the devastation to our environment.
    RR

  • dunngy59

    27 weeks ago

    CYA At It's Finest

    A ten year old child could read both Ministers statements and conclude somebody is not telling the truth.It is really quite sad how this behavior is tolerated,or at least not paid attention to.Shame on us all,time to wake up and start screaming foul at the top of your lungs!Teach your children to pay attention to their world and to question those in power.

  • the real ODB

    27 weeks ago

    are you kidding me?

    Kenney confirms a couple of important points here. When he says "the conservative government has been reviewing this program for months" he's admitting not only is he useless, he's a moron. Or if you prefer, a useless moron!
    Time for the BC Fed and the Unions in this province to grow back the stones they seem to have lost in the last 25 years and start playing hardball with these neocon scumbags. Start by issuing a "hot" edict on this site (and any other like it) and cut them off.

  • Jeff59Langley

    27 weeks ago

    Chinese Mining Workers

    In Africa, we have countries where labour is imported from neighboring states where people are starving and will work for less. In Indonesia, gold miners at the richest mine in the world are paid less than $5 per hour. In Canada, people won't work for $18 an hour because you cannot live on it .... but you can always find starving people somewhere else who will.

    This is blatant, and it is terrible policy for Canada. It was done with the approval of the government -- period. Everything else we are being told is just damage control and it is only happening because the media got into the story and would not let it go.

    Thank God we have at least some media that are not controlled by the same people who would bring the miners in, treat them badly, and leave them behind as an expense for Canada to deal with.

    Look at the meat packing plant in southern Alberta as another example of exactly the same policy and practice.

    Come on Canada ... WAKE UP.

    Your country is being eroded and sold out from underneath you. Every day, a bit more.

  • Fiat lux

    27 weeks ago

    In Canada and in many Western

    In Canada and in many Western countries. the presently ruling neoclassical theory, combined with deregulated money creation by private banks, and "foreign investment", has inflated living costs by over 1,000%, housing by several thousand percent, impoverishing and destituting people, while their imaginary GDP figures are "growing".

    Now, the same "conservative" and capitalist governments who permitted and legalized this crime wave by inflation, against their citizens, claim that the workers "priced themselves out of jobs".

    This fraudulent claim gives them licence to sell the country from under citizens' feet and move industries abroad to slave labour economies.

    As far the "Harper government" is concerned, beginning with the chairman, they look, act and talk like escapees from some institution. So, what can anybody expect from them at their IQ level of 10?

    Ed Deak.

  • Okanagan Orchardist

    27 weeks ago

    What happens at the end of their work term?

    I can imagine a number of the workers would apply for refugee status just to avoid going back to overcrowded China. Then, of course, the taxpayers of BC would be responsible for them. Meanwhile, they might even be able to get relatives to come over and join them. Are the workers bilingual when they come to Canada? Are we creating a ghetto of Chinese workers in Tumbler Ridge? I heard we had enough trouble with the Newfie preponderance taking over local parks there. :)

  • Hakuin

    27 weeks ago

  • grapes

    27 weeks ago

    When you see line ups at the

    When you see line ups at the food bank in that region. When you see people stuggling to pay their bills. When you see homeless people with no work. Then you see that this company has brought in temp workers with the approval of the government you have a reason to revolt. Shame on you Harper and your trained seals. Harper listen to this, temp workers dont VOTE, we do..... moron.

  • Hakuin

    27 weeks ago

  • irth1st

    27 weeks ago

    Tip of the Iceberg

    No one is un-touched by the events of the two great wars. The sacrifices made by our families in previous generations are felt to this day. Most of us had family members who served overseas fighting the Nazis. Fighting for freedom and choice. As a person who did not receive an adequate education in public school about the great wars and the holocaust, it left me ignorant to the full atrocities. I try to improve my knowledge on an ongoing basis. Today, I believe we are again entering into a great war. I fear to make a comparison as I do not in any way want to diminish the immense costs and sacrifices, that to this day I still can't fathom. I still can't wrap my mind around the holocaust. However, I believe that we have entered a new fascism. I see the global economy as the driving force behind the new world order. A human construct that places massive power and limitless resources in the hands of so few. The power of the few has changed the lives of the many down to the most intimate of levels, family and community. Today, we are faced with forces largely out of our control such as money with no physical form, turning life supporting elements into trade commodities to generate profits and ROI, the homogenization of societal systems across the planet are just skimming the surface of a world gone wrong. The occupy movement that the MSM ridicules, demonizes and belittles is just the first skirmish in what will eventually become a full scale war.

  • crh

    27 weeks ago

    Why am I not shocked?

    Cons never stand up for Canadian workers. They hate us.

  • Hakuin

    27 weeks ago

  • bhglennie

    27 weeks ago

    Right-wing anti-union drive

    the right-wing governments in Ottawa and Victoria would prefer to bring in foreign workers than train our own country men and women. Foreign workers can be controlled easier by the companies that hire them, and there is less chance they will complain about poor working conditions, safety problems and join unions when the companies do nothing about their complaints.If you can't move the mines to China, like they do Factories, then move the Chinese workers and working conditions here.
    Price of goods and services keep going up, but the governments think that wages should not and then complain Canadians have too much personal debt...dah-h-h

  • Bob Watts

    26 weeks ago

    Why?

    Jim Sinclair says we have 70,000 foriegn workers in BC right now!

    We also have about 70,000 people collecting welfare right now!

    WHY?

    I totally agree if we need a worker with special skills then lets bring them to Canada. But the fact is 98% of foriegn worker serve coffee and pick fruit.

    Canada is in such a mess, this country has a type of cancer that no one sees or feels yet.

    Unskilled coffee servers that have only one way to stay in Canada (making Babies) will some day soon just turn Canada into a dumbass welfare state with an IQ of 71

    Please prove me wrong!!!

  • Rolly-polly

    26 weeks ago

    Actually bob....

    The most common last name for a Doctor in Montreal Nyguen....not something the racists predicted when the boat people came, is it?

  • Bob Watts

    26 weeks ago

    Rolly Polly

    Seems 40% of all Vietamese have the family name of Nyguen.
    The Vietamese did not come here to serve coffee, they are not foriegn workers.

  • Jeff59Langley

    26 weeks ago

    Foreign Workers

    When you have an industry that you cannnot ship off shore to where you can get cheap labor, what can you do?

    Why, import the cheap labor to the industry, that's what!

    So simple. So obvious. So much a sell out of Canada.

  • chuckstraight

    26 weeks ago

    Kenney

    According to documents obtained by the Canadian Press, Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) spent almost $750,000 — over the past three years — to monitor ethnic media.

    Disturbingly, the taxpayer funded research
    included "assessments of election campaign events and 'perceptions' of minister Jason Kenney."

    - Isn`t Jason spending our money wisely?

  • chuckstraight

    26 weeks ago

  • Deb Colburn

    25 weeks ago

    Then when it is politically

    Then when it is politically expedient, the foreign labour will be transmuted by a lapdog media into vagabond interlopers, to be ghettoized, scapegoated and expelled. Really, if you are already on top of our dung hill it's all win-win.

    http://www.tss-radio.com

  • Cyndi Lindley

    24 weeks ago

    This fraudulent claim gives

    This fraudulent claim gives them licence to sell the country from under citizens' feet and move industries abroad to slave labour economies.

    http://www.leonlogothetis.com/