News

A Tyee Series

Jean Swanson's Advocacy for Vancouver's Impoverished

Decades of activism in the Downtown Eastside earned her the People's Order of BC from Tyee readers. Last in a series.

By Ben Christopher, 10 Sep 2012, TheTyee.ca

Swanson.jpg

Swanson speaking out: 'I just knew that I had a rotten life and it would be nice to do something that made sense.' Photo by The Blackbird.

Related

Jean Swanson doesn't sound like a rabble-rouser. Her voice on the phone is quiet, cautious, self-deprecating. A mainstay among anti-poverty activists in Vancouver who has spent 38 years sparring with property developers, SRO-managers and politicians, Swanson tells me that she's reluctant to be interviewed.

"I'm getting older and the folks that are doing the great work are younger," she says. "It would be neat if you would profile them instead of me." She offers me a few phone numbers.

Since the mid-1970s, Swanson has organized and advocated in the defence of Canada's least defended -- all the while eschewing cultivation of her own celebrity.

"She's very quiet, very focused on results," says Emily Mayne, who first met Swanson at a Raise the Rates meeting in the early 2000s before going on to work with her for the next eight years. As much disposition as principle, she says, Swanson has always preferred to "step aside and let others take the limelight."

Last fall, Swanson was one of five reader-nominated British Columbians to receive the People's Order of B.C., voted by Tyee readers.

Mayne cast her vote for Swanson. She calls the choice a "no brainer."

"People need to know what a valuable resource she is," says Mayne. "You try to thank her and tell her how important she is, but she doesn't want to hear it. It's never been about her. She's always working. Jean is out there everyday."

'Good work'

As Swanson recounts it, she fell into the world of activism and community organization over the course of an evening in 1974. She was waitressing at the Patricia Hotel at the time, "slinging beer" to the regulars in the dingy ground floor pub of the East Hastings SRO. This wasn't work she was particularly proud of. Her boss was constantly pressuring her to "load up" the tables -- aggressively topping up the customers to keep them plastered in their seats and running up a tab until last call.

But pride in one's job wasn't something Swanson felt entitled to. The 31-year-old was just scraping by.

Born in New York state, Swanson spent most of her childhood bumping around America's West Coast. Her father, a mining prospector, was constantly shuffling his family around in search of work and Swanson recalls a lonely childhood. There were years, she says, when she was attending upwards of three schools per year.

By the time she'd moved to Canada and years later ended up working at the Patricia, Swanson was the mother of two daughters. One was born with a heart defect and Swanson knew she couldn't afford the necessary medical coverage back in the U.S. She had no plans grander than meeting next month's rent.

Then one evening during Swanson's shift, Bruce Eriksen and Libby Davies walked into the hotel bar. Swanson knew about Eriksen; she'd seen him on television, protesting safety conditions at hotels around the neighbourhood -- a neighbourhood that most everyone but he and his colleagues at the recently formed Downtown Eastside Residents' Association (DERA) still called Skid Row.

But Swanson had also received plenty of warning from her boss about DERA and its mercurial president. Loading up tables was a violation of provincial liquor law and Eriksen was known to report offenders.

Swanson approached the couple to check Davies' ID and the three got to talking.

"It seemed like he was doing good work," Swanson says now. "I didn't know that that kind of work existed. I just knew that I had a rotten life and that it would be nice to do something that made sense."

A few weeks later, Swanson spotted Eriksen eating lunch at the nearby Ovaltine Café. In an act of brashness that she now calls "one of the smartest things I ever did," she walked up to Eriksen's table and asked for a job. A few weeks later, Swanson, who'd been the editor of her high school newspaper over a decade earlier, started work at DERA's monthly paper, the Downtown East.

With, not for

Swanson downplays her role at DERA. Putting together the paper now seems so antiquated. "We were gluing down the columns with hot wax," she says, laughing.

By all other accounts, Swanson was doing much more than operating a glue gun during the organization's foundational years. As the best writer of the three, she assumed the role of DERA's secretary, with Davies managing the funds and Eriksen soldiering on as front man and street organizer.

On its face, the trio's project seemed an unlikely one. In a neighbourhood that the rest of the city had written off, the mission of the residents' association was to get the community politically engaged and advocating on its own behalf.

Working with, rather than on behalf of the members of a community is an approach to activism that Blair Redlin says he recognized when working with Swanson in the late 1980s.

"She isn't just talking about poverty and she isn't dealing with these issues as a matter of charity," says Redlin, who now works as a researcher for CUPE. "She has always worked with lower income people."

Speaking over the phone from Vernon, Emily Mayne agrees. Mayne, who often crossed paths with Swanson while working at the Kettle Friendship Society throughout the 2000s, says she was struck by the bond between Swanson and the residents of the neighbourhood.

"If you go out onto the street in the Downtown Eastside, you can ask: everyone will know her," says Mayne. "She works with the people in the community who are most affected. So who cares if people in Kits don't know about her?"

Living room of the Downtown Eastside

During Swanson's tenure at DERA, the ranks of the organization swelled to some three thousand residents across the Downtown Eastside in 1980. During that same period DERA campaigned for and won a community centre built in the Downtown Eastside.

Up until that point, says Swanson, "the beer parlors were the community centres" of the Downtown Eastside. By design, the single room hotels did not provide communal space to tenants. Especially in inclement weather, she says, there were few places where neighbour could meet neighbour without the temptation or obligation to drink or fix.

It was a seven-year fight to secure what many have since called the living room of the Downtown Eastside. Swanson helped stave off commercial developers, wrangle politicians and design a workable solution. Finally, on Jan. 20, 1980, the once defunct and disregarded public library at the corner of Main and Hastings was reopened. The building was renamed the Carnegie Community Centre.

Political action, not charity

Swanson split with DERA in 1981, after the association lost its funding to keep its Secretary on the payroll. While Eriksen went on to win a seat on City Council at the beginning of the decade, followed two years later by Davies (Davies is now Swanson's MP as well as one of her close friends), Swanson spent the first half of the 1980s working "a few odd jobs," with a longer stint at the Hospital Employees' Union.

When Swanson finally returned to anti-poverty activism in 1985, it was with a more ambitious goal in mind. Spurred on by then premier Bill Bennett's "Restraint" reforms, British Columbia's rendition of the economic liberalization policies being introduced in Ottawa, Washington and London at the time, Swanson co-founded End Legislated Poverty (ELP). As implied by the name, ELP was an effort to fight social injustice at what Swanson considered to be social injustice's point of origin –- the halls of provincial assemblies and national parliaments.

"Jean's perspective is that we need to get at the root causes of poverty, which are the public policy decisions that favour people of high income and that favour corporations at the expense of the rest of us," says Redlin.

In practice, "getting at the root causes of poverty" meant campaigning for higher welfare rates, higher minimum wages, and protesting the drawing down of trade barriers with the United States. Redlin says he first worked with Swanson when the two were helping to organize the Coalition Against Free-Trade.

"Jean helped me understand the connection between issues like that and poverty," he says. "That the solution to poverty isn't charity. The solution is political action and policy change."

Swanson's own political action campaigning continued to expand in scope throughout the decade. In 1988, Swanson ran for mayor of Vancouver on a coalition left-of-centre ticket. She lost to Gordon Campbell.

Off the campaign trail, she spent those years continuing to work with the ELP, joining the National Anti-Poverty Organization (now called Canada Without Poverty) and served as co-chair of Action Canada Network, another anti-free trade organization. Swanson would go on to join the NAPO board of directors and to serve as the organization's national president for two years.

A 25-year partnership

It was also in 1985, the same year she formed the ELP, that Swanson met Sandy Cameron, a warm-natured teacher and seasonal prospector from Toronto. Despite his upper-middle class upbringing, Cameron had a strong affinity for the underdog and a sense of social justice to rival Swanson's. Before moving to Vancouver, he had been a teacher, working in prisons and in remote Reserve schools and spending his summers bushwhacking, logging and prospecting in Northern Ontario and the B.C. interior. After settling in Vancouver with Swanson, Cameron made himself the de facto historian and poet of the Downtown Eastside.

On a website Swanson created in memory of Cameron after his death, she describes their relationship as a "25-year partnership in life and social justice work."

"He came to all the demonstrations, edited every word I wrote, always talked to me about different strategies," says Swanson. "But he also slowed me down, helped me to lead a more balanced life."

Cameron died of pneumonia in October of 2010.

Against poor-bashing

In 1996, Swanson started writing a book against widespread assumptions about poverty and the poor that makes it morally permissible to engage in "poor-bashing."

Poor-bashing, as Swanson defines it, is both cultural and institutional. To believe that poverty is a matter of personal deficiency or that welfare only coddles the lazy is a kind of poor-bashing. But so too are the policies -- the cuts to financial assistance and social services -- that are justified by that belief.

Too much media media coverage, says Swanson, presents the the poor only as helpless and inept, as "sufferers and victims."

"You never portray the poor as intelligent human beings who might have answers to the situations that they find themselves in," she says.

If society were given a less slanted view of who the poor are and what it means to be poor, she says, good policy would follow. "When stereotypes can be challenged -- for example, when people understand how low the (welfare) rates are and that you can't live on that -- then reasonable people will come to reasonable conclusions."

She adds, "I guess I would just plea for people to actually consider ending poverty. We have the resources. We could do it."

Swanson published Poor-Bashing: The Politics of Exclusion in 2001, the same year she retired from ELP.

'The soul of Vancouver'

After a five-year hiatus, Swanson once again returned to social justice campaigning in 2006 when she took on the role of Co-ordinator of the Carnegie Community Action Project. Today, CCAP is considered one of the city's most vocal (and by its detractors, fanatical) advocacy organizations on housing and income issues in the Downtown Eastside.

Ivan Drury is a researcher and organizer at CCAP. Prior to going to work with Swanson two years ago, Drury says he knew of the veteran activist as "the Godmother of the neighbourhood."

"Sandy Cameron wrote a poem that called the Downtown Eastside 'the soul of Vancouver,' " says Drury. "I think that Jean exemplifies that because she carries that soul through the wisdom of her experience, having known so many people who have been involved in the struggle here for decades."

Wendy Pedersen is, like Drury, a CCAP researcher and organizer. And like Drury, Pedersen, who has worked at CCAP for the last six years "day and night," says she's found a "mentor" and an "elder" in Swanson.

"She's always encouraging us to remember to spend time with our families, to not burn out," says Pedersen. "Everyone might not agree with her, but everyone that she comes in contact with does respect her and what she does and how she does it."

Certainly, there are many that do not agree with Swanson. Particularly in trying to hold back the tide of private development, Swanson and CCAP's position that gentrification should be sharply curtailed, or made contingent on the expansion of supportive housing, has engendered some bad blood between the group and the city's political and economic leaders.

But speaking to Philip Owen, one of Swanson's erstwhile political adversaries from city hall, Pedersen's claim is born out. As mayor between 1993 and 2002, Owen, a political moderate and a former businessman with a market-oriented view of the world ("we've got more social housing units in Vancouver than in the whole bloody country," he laments), he extends to the soft-spoken activist a degree of respect denied to most of her current and former colleagues.

"She wasn't an off-the-wall nutbar," he says. "She didn't yell and scream and shout. She didn't give it to you that way. She gave it to you in a way so that you'd sit and listen. She did a good job."

Bad as it ever was

Looking at the Downtown Eastside today, Swanson's outlook is grim. Since she joined DERA in 1974, overall conditions in the neighbourhood have only deteriorated, she says.

"The housing situation in the SROs was bad (back then), but at least there was a vacancy rate and you could get in," she says. "Now you have all these gentrification pressures which are pushing people out."

Pressures, she says, like a shrinking of the affordable rental stock with each renovation, higher rents and negligible vacancy rates in the hotels. As a result, unlike in the 1970s, homelessness must now be counted among the many problems afflicting the neighbourhood.

Meanwhile, while the cost of living continues to rise, provincial welfare rates have not kept apace, falling in real terms from an inflation-adjusted $970 per month in 1981 to $610 today.

"People are literally starving," she says. "It's bad to have to resort to middle income people to tell your story about poverty, but when Jagrup Brar was living on $610, he lost 26 pounds."

Last winter, Raise the Rates, a coalition of anti-poverty groups also directed by Swanson, organized the "MLA Welfare Challenge." Brar, the provincial legislator from Surrey, survived for one month solely on the B.C. welfare allowance to illustrate its insufficiency.

Yet Swanson is able to summon some hope for the future of her neighbourhood, and for that she credits her colleagues.

Colleagues like Wendy Pederson and Ivan Drury, but also Diane Wood, Robert Bonner and Fraser Stewart. These are the people she first proposed I interview in her place.

"Seeing that there are younger people coming up who can do the work now -- that's the best part for me," Swanson says.

Ivan Drury laughed as he predicted Swanson "will hate" to learn she'd been voted an accolade by Tyee readers, even one as grassroots driven as the People's Order of B.C.

Recognition distracts from what Swanson thinks is more important and runs counter to her personality, he says. "She hates to be recognized as important or significant."

But Drury offers his own perspective. "Jean is a hero in the Downtown Eastside," he explains. "Jean is a hero now and she will be a hero no matter what it says in any media outlet. So it's not so much that you can declare her a hero. But you can recognize what's already common knowledge on the streets here."  [Tyee]

26  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • morechatter

    36 weeks ago

    Jean is the voice of the Downtown Eastside

    Jean is my hero because she gives residents hope in a hopeless situation. And her pay, well Jean works for the impoverished so most of what she does is on her own time.

  • Bob Watts

    36 weeks ago

    All of BC.

    Poverty is all over BC, so whatever Jean does effects the whole province.
    I'm disabled an I help people all over BC. I also live in a very remote area, it no longer matters where you live to make a differance.
    I just could not imagine what poverty would look like if our leaders where not kept in check by people like Jean.
    The only so called large church to help the poor are on the government payroll, not good from my grassroot point of view!
    As Jean says the new poverty is about staving people (To Death is the outcome) it is a very slow death, you just get sicker and sicker.
    I help because I've seen other Disabled people stave, others who gave up the will to live is very very common.
    You know in Alberta the Disability Welfare rates are double that of BC. Why? Why Not!

  • LSC44

    36 weeks ago

    Jean Swanson is an amazing woman.

    Jean Swanson is one the most admirable people I know of, knowing I can never live up to her example of what a good human being should be, she still sets an example to strive for.
    Not only does she sincerely care for and respect others regardless of their income level,
    not only does she use everything she has to fight for respect for people who are materially poor and for their rights,
    not only is she incredibly bright and knowledgeable,
    . . .
    but she does all this with a level of humility that is truly awe-inspiring, of which most of us can only hope to attain a small part.
    She somehow manages to do all this fighting for others with grace and dignity, without losing hope and the ability to inspire, and still being just a regular person.
    We need far more Jean Swanson's in our world.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    Only poor people care about

    Only poor people care about poor people. As this article says, the situation in the DTES is much worse today than anytime in the past. Why? We recently spent $6 billions dollars for the elite to watch games played by athletes, many of whom struggle financially like the rest of us. This situation is obscenely immoral. And it is not just in the DTES, as Bob Watts say.

    I live in a small town and my living conditions are barely better than those of the slum housing in the DTES. At the beginning of this year, to save my life, I began a letter writing campaign to health officials starting with the Provincial Health Officer, politicians, bureaucrats, advocacy groups, etc, anyone who will listen to me, describing my medical history, how I have been abandoned by several doctors and have lost access to the medical system (it is not a health system), how I am being threatened by the legal system for self-treating because no doctor will help me, how I live in substandard housing that is negatively impacting my health, which is rapidly deteriorating, how I cannot afford market rental rates on disability benefits but the BC Housing waiting list is 14,000 long with 1,000 on the emergency list, and how I am great risk of complete homelessness which would lead directly to my death as I am at great risk because of several chronic conditions.

    I have been in constant crisis for the last six years, and though it has not yet reached the emergency stage (though many people in my situation would consider it an emergency), it could at anytime as I feel my life is threatened by the government's refusal to do the right thing for the poorest, sickest, most vulnerable citizens. And so far, none of the people who I have sent documents to detailing my entire medical history as well as all the issues I mentioned above have responded to me with compassion and willingness to help me. None. Not the doctors, the politicians, the lawyers or even poverty advocacy groups. I'm still contacting more people, but I have lost all hope that anyone is willing or able to help me. I really don't understand why.

    Anyone following my comments on this site this year will notice an increase in my desperation. Yesterday, I posted this comment on a Tyee article:

    "We already have citizens as desperate as that Tunisian fruit vendor, Mohamed Bouazizi, and I count myself among them. Unfortunately, I think suicide as a public protest would barely raise an eyebrow in this country, let alone start a national rebellion. I think its going to take a literal combat."

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    There is a huge scandal

    There is a huge scandal playing out right now that I just heard on CBC radio this morning. The CBC website has been wonky all morning so I can't find the report yet, but its part of CBC's Go Public series. There is a huge conflict of interest involving the recently married head of BC Housing and his wife who is head of a housing organization receiving millions of dollars in aid, while the slum hotels continue to be derelict. Apparently, because of that conflict or appearance of conflict, BC Housing has been under-funding his wife's organization, causing miserable suffering for some of the poorest, sickest, frail and vulnerable citizens.

    Cathy Tomlison described horrendous conditions in those hotels, with many seniors frightened to death to leave their rooms or tell anyone what's happening. We've known all this for years, and its getting worse, while the government continues to waste money without doing anything to reduce poverty and homelessness.

    The conditions described in that report are far worse than the ones I live in, so if I am as desperate as I am, having lost everything and nothing left to lose, imagine how desperate those elderly citizens are, forced to live slum hell paid for by the government.

    This is a great evil being perpetrated against the poorest citizens. Rich Coleman's response to this scandal on the radio this moring was immoral and disgusting.

  • Joseph Jones

    36 weeks ago

    Contrast

    I am struck by the 1988 political contest between Jean Swanson and Gordon Campbell. What a parable when you contrast the subsequent careers of the two. Who has served and who has profited, and how they have done so and who their constituencies are. Where the solid human legacy has been built is apparent.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    World Suicide Prevention Day

    I had no idea when I posted that comment above from yesterday that it was World Suicide Prevention Day today. Apparently the government doesn't either as their policies cause suicide, not prevent it.

    http://www.who.int/mediacentre/events/annual/world_suicide_prevention_day/en/index.html

    http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/michael-laxer/2012/09/remembrance-those-we-have-lost-suicide-prevention-day

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    letter from Minister of Social Development

    In July, the Minister of Social Development, Stephanie Cadieux, (she no longer holds that position) included an information sheet with the welfare cheque mail out, proudly announcing new policies and programs. There was not one single new benefit or program for the most desperate citizens, those on disability benefits but who cannot find or are unable to work.

    I wrote a one page letter to the Minister complaining of that. I also pointed out that the disability rate is not adequate enough for both decent, secure housing and nutritious food. You can't have both on disability. There is no such housing anywhere in the Province for the housing support of $375. People in my situation must either live in substandard housing so that they have enough money to buy nutritious food and over the counter medications, or live in decent, secure housing and rely on nutritiously poor free food handouts, if they can any.

    Today I received a reply from Minister Cadieux, and it is what I expected. It is pure propaganda bullshit from a government Minister who herself is disabled, but who has no empathy whatsoever for people in my situation. She has a completely deaf ear to our impossible, life threatening dilemmas.

    Her propaganda explains what great programs and policies they have for the disabled, completely ignoring everything I wrote her. She states the government will not even consider raising income and disability rates, and makes excuses for why BC can't follow Alberta's lead on disability rates. Her letter also makes clear that the government is well aware that housing support rates are below market rental rates. They know that people are greatly suffering because of that disparity, yet all the Minister can say is they are exploring the issue. More political bullshit. There is an emergency housing crisis. People are suffering and dying and all the government is willing to do is explore the issue?

    She recommends me to contact BC Housing, seemingly oblivious to the fact there are 14,000 households on the waiting list for subsidized housing, and 1000 emergency cases, which I am one of. She ends by brushing my desperate situation off and telling me to go to the Employment & Assistance Office, as if that will accomplish anything at all. It won't. That office actually tried to hinder my application for disability, on Gordon Campbell's watch.

    The letter is pure political propaganda by a disinterested Cabinet Minister. I doubt her successor will be much different.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    the CBC report on BC Housing scandal

    Here's the opening paragraphs of the CBC report I mentioned in my second comment above:

    "Public housing in Vancouver called 'crack shacks and brothels'"

    Several tenants and ex-employees of publicly owned housing in Vancouver say their buildings are marred by revolting conditions, rampant crime and shoddy management — by a company whose CEO is married to a top government housing official.

    "They're all crack shacks and brothels, and the old people in these hotels are too afraid to leave their rooms," said Don Brown, who worked for Atira Property Management as a front-desk clerk in two of the buildings.

    "I live on [Vancouver's Downtown] Eastside. But even I was horrified at some of the things that go on, and nothing is done about it."

    Go Public went into some of the buildings, where tenants showed doors with no locks; bathrooms with no toilet paper or lights; feces; urine; garbage and dirty needles in hallways; filthy, clogged and leaky plumbing; cockroaches; and black mould.

    "I didn't live there. I slept there. I didn't feel safe," said former tenant Shawna Taylor, who lived in the Marble Arch Hotel, an Atira-managed building, until recently. She said she slept with a knife under her pillow.

    "The things I've seen! Needles all over the floor. Blood on the walls.… Overflowing garbage, fecal matter. You come into the place and it just stinks."

    "The taxpayers are paying for it, and they're getting ripped off," said former front-desk clerk Keith Thornicroft. It's a dangerous environment."

    "BC Housing is a slum landlord," said Justin Hall, who lives in the Arco Hotel. "It's incredible." ...

    read the full article at:

    http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/story/2012/09/09/bc-go-public-vancouver-public-housing-atira.html

    Remember, the government actually pays slum landlords taxpayer money for the most vulnerable citizens to live in filthy conditions in inhumane, violent and toxic environments. And the Minister just wrote me and told me there is no help for those people, the system is working and everything is fine. How do those hypocrites sleep at night, knowing they are responsible for the immoral neglect of the citizens they are supposed to be helping? Would suicide as public protest even move them to compassionate action? I doubt it.

  • Skywalker

    36 weeks ago

    @ Joseph Jones

    Yours is a most excellent post. You have identified what is so terribly wrong in our society. Gordo can't hold a candle to Jean Swanson in any way.

  • Mr. PG

    36 weeks ago

    She sets a standard for us all

    I worked briefly with Jean Swanson probably 25 years ago. She was dauntless and indefatigable. She seemed to have boundless energy and her zeal and faith embarrased those of us less committed. It was a very memorable experience.

  • lynn

    36 weeks ago

    Perry

    Perry, your posts are eloquent and profoundly revealing of the desperate crisis in subsidized housing.

    "How do those hypocrites sleep at night, knowing they are responsible for the immoral neglect of the citizens they are supposed to be helping? " ~ Perry

    I don't understand how either, but somehow they do and collect big salaries and pensions in the process for the "immoral neglect" that they shrug off so easily.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    desperate people do desperate things

    Thanks lynn. I don't know about eloquent, but I am profoundly desperate. And there are many citizens all over this province and country like me.

    I said in a comment above that my situation is not yet at the emergency stage, though some people in similar situations would consider it an emergency. But this morning, I do feel like I am in an emergency situation. I don't know if I can survive another winter in an uninsulated travel trailer, huddled around a small electric heater, with my feet pressed against it as the only way to stay warm. I have no indoor plumbing and haul water in a plastic container. Many years ago I lived several years in poor, under-developed countries. Today, in one of the richest provinces in one of the richest countries in the world, I live like I did all those years ago in the 3rd world. All thanks to evil political leaders like Gordon Campbell, Stephen Harper and their ilk. And by evil, I don't mean in the religious sense (I'm an atheist, maybe that's why no one will help me?) but in the psychological sense as used by psychologist Philip Zimbardo: "Evil is intentionally behaving -- or causing others to act – in ways that demean, dehumanize, harm, destroy, or kill innocent people."

    My hesitancy to previously describe my situation as an emergency is because I dread being caught up in slum housing hell. If I move into some kind of emergency shelter or slum apartment, I will only end up on the street eventually. If I'm going to die an indignant death in indigency, I don't want it to be on the street.

    And I don't want to commit suicide because that's what the elite and their puppet politicians would like, for me to shut up, to lose the only power I have against them, my words.

    So what's next? I don't know, but desperate people do desperate things.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    Speaking of suicide, here's

    Speaking of suicide, here's how poor Japanese used to deal with their elderly. The modern equivalent in BC appears to be either housing them in slum hotels owned by the government if they live in the big city, and simply ignoring their plight if they live in rural areas. Out of sight, out of mind.

    "... the Aokigahara forest has became the popular place for suicides after the novel Nami no Tō (波の塔?) or “Tower of Waves” written by Seichō Matsumoto was published in 1960. In this novel, lovers commit suicide in the forest. But the Aokigahara forest was used for suicides long before the novel was published. Ubasute was practiced by poor Japanese. They used to leave their elderly relatives to the Aokigahara forest to die. During the drought and famine, ubasute was widely practiced. Remember The Ballad of Narayama! According to tradition, once a person reaches the age of 70, he or she must travel to a remote mountain to die of starvation. The Ballad of Narayama reminds me of Bengali Hindu widows! Family members send them to Varanasi, a holy place to die.

    Suicide in the Aokigahara forest reminds me of farmers’ suicide in India. Indian farmers started committing mass suicide in 1990′s. More than 17,500 farmers killed themselves every year from 2002 to 2006. 16,196 farmers committed suicide in 2008. Since 1997, much more than 200,000 farmers committed suicide. The reasons of farmers’ suicide: ‘debt, the difficulty of farming semi-arid regions, poor agricultural income, absence of alternative income opportunities, the downturn in the urban economy forcing non-farmers into farming, and the absence of suitable counseling services.’

    http://freethoughtblogs.com/taslima/2012/09/11/i-will-never-visit-the-aokigahara-forest/

  • carfreecity

    36 weeks ago

    DTES

    DRUGS!!!
    VERY BAD NOW
    Also more population and too many cars,trucks
    to degrade the atmosphere and dirty the streets making them filthy from soot and oil and chemicals

  • lynn

    36 weeks ago

    I think the set-up right now

    I think the set-up right now - the one that has removed all the spokes of the wheel from social infrastructure, from the social safety net, from citizen advocacy, and from legal aid has left people who want to help, not knowing what to do that will really change what needs to be changed.

    It has made people into helpless observers of a ghost town that is composed of structures that are only facades, fronts for so- called helping agencies. There is no real advocacy that is actually effective, except through the kindness and compassion of the Jean Swanson's of the world. It has all become mere pretense.

    Why should vulnerable and desperate people have to rely on the chance and whim of a good Samaritan entering their lives....or on the whim of charity that is there for the short sprint but not for the long distance run?

    We, as people have lost access to our own system, and with that the dignity of controlling our own lives.....and with that we have lost the ability to control the gears that would enable us to help those in need in a way that will genuinely address their very real concerns in an effective manner.

    Perry, you are indeed eloquent, in a powerfully informed and personal way that is rare. It is probably what those 'helpers' inside the system found so threatening. You're challenging the very system they are paid to prop up.

    That doesn't let the rest of us off the hook....I think we are lost...we don't know how to effectively react....and we don't know how to take effective action.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    lynn, that is an excellent

    lynn, that is an excellent summary of the situation. Thank you.

    I realized that I was putting certain people in a difficult spot when I sent them copies of documents about my situation, and that they may not have had any answers or suggestions, or the ability to do anything. I actually felt a bit bad about that, and so gave them an easy out in my cover letters. I never expected all of them to take that easy way out, though, and thought I'ld get at least an acknowledgement that the documents were received, and maybe a few words of empathy not to give up hope. But it was getting no response at all, even from people I once knew, that really hurt.

    And I know that there are people like you out there who understand these things and care, but are as frustrated as I am at how to get help not just for themselves, or an individual like me but for everyone in similar or worse situations. Knowing that, and your kind words, keep alive those last remaining strands of hope I cling to. Sometimes just those kind, understanding words are the most important things.

    Today is, or rather ought to be, a special day for me. But I cannot celebrate. I don't say that to elicit pity. I say that to illustrate how government laws and policies, and the politicians and bureaucrats who enact and enforce them, have beaten me down to a position of helpless suffering and misery. My human dignity has been shattered, and for me, that is an extremely position to celebrate.

    I doubt anyone is still reading these comments, but I'm still posting for the record.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    correction to last comment

    The last line in the second to last paragraph in my previous comment should read:

    My human dignity has been shattered, and for me, that is an extremely difficult position to celebrate.

  • Bob Watts

    36 weeks ago

    I am still reading...

    For the record.
    You are not alone Perry, there are thousands of us, fact is we don't have a voice.
    100 people may read what we say....but.
    I am PWD and I believe the government is killing us off. Dead Disabled people are much more cost effective!
    I am off to pick black berries and enjoy the sun.
    I left the big city long ago, crime is very low, rents are a lot cheaper, services are just as good, you can catch salmon right off the dock, lots of crabs the eatable type LOL.

  • Bob Watts

    36 weeks ago

    Just read lynn's comment.

    You are very right! Sad fact is groups start to help the poor in every way they can, until they start getting funding. Then a little rule enters the picture, which is don't bite the hand that feeds you.
    Advocates are gaged by the collection of their own paycheques.
    Even the Sally Ann, they collect money from MSD (welfare)from BC Housing, every Health Authrothy, the federal government (corrections branch, Vancouver City hall (poperty tax breaks) etc etc. The Sally Ann collects millions to provide services, but never to lobby the government to Raise the Rates or end poverty. Besides their number one goal is to save souls, nice to have a captive crowd every day!
    Did you know if you are mistreated by a Sally Ann staffer, that there is nothing you can do, and no-one I mean no-one will help you!!! Not advocates nor newspapers nor government that pays them will ever question the Sally Ann.
    Taking on welfare and government has nothing to do with how you feel, nor your pain and suffering, it is all about policy/legislation and what the book says. You are a number and you exist by a set of legal foot notes.
    I know you are real and you are being abused.
    Ever heard of covert murder? It is a little tiny gun with little tiny bullets and every month the leaders of BC and Canada pulls the triger and all the little shots kill you.
    PS: Child Poverty is a Crime.
    We could go to jail for staving our children but if the government does it......... Well.

  • lynn

    36 weeks ago

    Covert....

    is a good word for it, Bob Watts.

  • lynn

    36 weeks ago

    Perry

    Your dignity is etched into every word you have written here.

  • Perry

    36 weeks ago

    Child poverty is criminal negligence

    Thanks lynn, I really appreciate the encouragement.

    So right, Bob. Child poverty is a crime. As you point out, it is criminal negligence, as defined by the Criminal Code:

    "Every one is criminally negligent who in doing anything, or in omitting to do anything that it is his duty to do, shows wanton or reckless disregard for the lives or safety of other persons."

    The Canadian Judicial Council's standard set of jury instructions includes this extract on topic:

    "The Crown must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused's conduct showed a marked departure from the conduct of a reasonable person in the circumstances; and that a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have foreseen that this conduct posed a risk of bodily harm.

    "Bodily harm is any hurt or injury that interferes with a person's health or comfort and is more than brief or minor. In deciding what a reasonable person would have done or foreseen, you must not take into account (the accused's) individual characteristics or experiences."

    By those standards, many politicians ought to be charged with crimes, such as those who are responsible for the slum horror in the DTES, or like Gordon Campbell and Stephen Harper for their deliberate policies that negatively impact the poor, and for their refusal to implement poverty and homelessness eradication programs.

    Every reasonable person can understand that provincial and federal government policies, or lack thereof, have created the conditions in which citizens are harmed or die. Billions and billions of dollars have been spent in recent years on projects that are far less important than ending poverty and homelessness. This is a national crisis. Child poverty, in fact all poverty and homelessness, could have been eradicated long ago, if those in power actually cared, by simply putting all the resources of the state into immediately ending the injustice and inequality of Canadian children, or any Canadian citizen for that matter, suffering the indignity of poverty and homelessness.

    OK, I may not be celebrating today, but I still have fight left in me. Today, the Vancouver Sun had an article (hidden behind the paywall which I eventually skirted) about the current scandal in the DTES and interviewed a UBC psychiatrist who is studying these issues. I emailed him regarding my letter to the Provincial Health Officer that I refer to in my first comment above, offering to send him a copy. Each day, I am identifying one more person or organization to contact, and am keeping track of who responds and who doesn't. Eventually, I may find the right person. I'n not giving up.

  • Bob Watts

    36 weeks ago

    More Junk.

    Perry you sound like me Physically Disabled, not Mentally Disabled.
    I think it would be much easier to not know what is happening to us!
    My Disability is completely unstable, so there is no hope of holding a job.
    I could be a consultant to government, but they do not want to hear what I have to say.
    I have ideas that could save millions but that is a no go!
    Poverty is a growth Industry and the cost just keeps growing up.
    I wrote a paper a few years ago called “The Privatization of the Disadvantaged”, No One Cares!
    I now know for a fact that we have a Bounty on our heads as poor people, anyone in the poverty industry that talks with us gets $20 plus benefits and expenses.
    I talk a lot about the Sally Ann because it is the Government belief that this church will help us find God and we will shut up and wait for our reward in the next life; I love that we’ll get food and shelter, after we expire.
    When I first became disabled I felt so guilty about going on welfare, I was once a wealthy person, at that time I never thought twice about poor people. I was tortured by a welfare worker, a church going welfare District Supervisor, a sadist; I wonder what her body count is?
    Time for me to shut up, anyway she was fired, given an early pension as a reward for getting so many of us off the welfare roll.
    It amazes me how many evil people work in the poverty field, it reminds me of the priests that ran the orphanages.
    I must admit for the past 5 years I’ve had a welfare worker that helps me and others, she is the polar opposite of the last sadist.
    There are some good workers, but it is just blind luck in meeting them. Don’t give up, it does piss them off.

  • Perry

    35 weeks ago

    I read a very tragic story

    I read a very tragic story this morning.

    "Veteran shot dead by B.C. police treated for PTSD"

    http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/story/2012/09/13/bc-man-shot-by-police-ptsd.html

    Why I am posting this here now? Because it is related to all my previous comments above. The plight of veterans suffering from untreated PTSD is something I discuss in my letter to the Provincial Health Officer, as one of several groups of people in similar situations to mine. Also, because I've left several hints in these comments, so if the editors ever want to investigate what I've been talking about here they can do so easily, and these latest comments provide a bit more insight.

    I dread to think of it, but it is not hard for me to imagine ending up in a similar fate as the veteran in that report. When I read about some of the actions he was taking to get help before the police shot him, it kinda freaks me out.

    excerpt from the article:

    "Tracey Matters said her brother may have been suicidal at time but his doctor never considered him a threat to anyone.

    "In the hours before the fatal confrontation, Greg Matters sent a series of emails to the local newspaper, the Prince George Citizen, that mentioned his mental health struggles and his military service.

    "He wrote of a dispute with his brother at his mother's home on the weekend, and a belief that RCMP were out to hurt him.

    "This all goes back so much -- the police wishing to hurt me -- why do people want to hurt me -- I did nothing wrong but protect myself and more importantly my mother and property," Matters wrote to the Citizen in an email time-stamped 11:04 a.m. on Monday."

    ****

    There are veterans suffering from serious health problems, poverty, homelessness, across this country. If that is how Canada treats its veterans, who most people consider heroes, then what hope is there for someone like me, who belongs to some of the most despised classes of people who garner very little sympathy from the mainstream?

  • Perry

    35 weeks ago

    tick, tick, tick, tick...

    tick, tick, tick, tick...