News

Husband of Clark Aide Ghost Wrote Riot Report

Stewart Muir says he did not discuss contents with Athana Mentzelopoulos.

By Bob Mackin, 2 Sep 2011, TheTyee.ca

Stewart Muir

Former Sun editor Stewart Muir: hired to produce $313,000 report.

Related

The report on the 2011 Stanley Cup riot was ghost-written by a former Vancouver Sun deputy managing editor who is married to Premier Christy Clark's top aide.

But Stewart Muir said co-chairs John Furlong and Doug Keefe hired him to write, edit and produce the report and he said he did not discuss the contents with his wife, Athana Mentzelopoulos.

"The answer is a flat no, absolutely not," Muir told The Tyee. "You're talking about professional people."

"I was hired by the co-chairs and they had the dealings with external parties. My role was really to produce the document with them and take direction from them."

Co-chairs' 'inquiries' led to hiring Muir

Mentzelopoulos was director general of Consumer Product Safety with Health Canada until Clark hired her in August as deputy minister for corporate priorities.

A bridesmaid at Clark's wedding, Mentzelopoulus was deputy minister of intergovernmental affairs and head of the Public Affairs Bureau under premier Gordon Campbell.

"I did ask John or Doug how they found me, because I was curious to know," Muir said. "John told me that they made some inquiries... the words of John to me were all of those inquiries led to your door, as in my door."

Solicitor General Shirley Bond said the review cost $313,000, including $123,565 for former Nova Scotia deputy attorney general Keefe and $77,750 for VANOC chief executive Furlong. The budget included $70,813 for production of the report, but Muir did not reveal how much he was paid.

'Intense deadline'

"That must contain a lot of other things, it's certainly a vastly larger number than I'm getting," he said. "I've worked probably longer than I expected."

Muir was with the Vancouver Sun from 1995 to 2009 and was managing director of The Canadian Press subsidiary Pagemasters North America until last June. He said the riot review was "probably the most intense, sustained deadline period that I have ever worked on in 25 years of being a journalist."

Muir said the dramatic title, "The Night the City Became a Stadium," was not his idea.

"That was John."  [Tyee]

22  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • terminalcitygirl

    38 weeks ago

    Good God! $200K for Furlong

    Good God! $200K for Furlong & the Nova Scotia guy and they couldn't even write their own report?! And I can't stand the ridiculously obvious patronage hiring for this guy and his wife. Holy cow. Shameful.

  • Lorne

    38 weeks ago

    Nepotism

    After reading this article, I wondered if nepotistic was a word, so looked it up in the New Oxford American Dictionary. The meaning given is: the practice among those with power or influence of favoring relatives or friends, esp. by giving them jobs.

    What could better describe this situation. Ms. Clark's bridesmade marries up with Mr. Muir, and they both get fat paying jobs courtesy of Ms. Clark.
    Regardless of how qualified these people are, Ms. Clark to the contrary, the whole thing stinks of, yes, nepotlsm. I was under the impression that this practice was, if not illegal, at least immoral. But then, we're dealing with a person who has been documented by Alex Tsakumis as being up to her eyeballs in the BC Rail scandal.

  • RossK

    38 weeks ago

    But...But...But...

    Thanks to the HST voting preferences of the great unwashed, many of whom are not, apparently, 'professional people', we have no money for...

    Schools?

    .

  • dorothy

    38 weeks ago

    Hate to sound like a broken record, but

    None of this can be surprising fro those who heard - and remembered - Gordo's words on stepping up to the mike to victorize: "It's our turn now". Haven't they had their turn, and then some? When will we give them the boot? How much do they have to step us in the face and do it laughing, before we get it: These people are all about getting to the trough, applying their scoop, and making a really big hole in the stew.

  • Skywalker

    38 weeks ago

    That "oink" you hear...

    ...will become a deafening roar by the time an election is called.

  • Camero409

    38 weeks ago

    Wow

    Noriega and other Latin American despots must be regretting where they were born! BC is certainly the best place in the world to be corrupt and in power at the same time. No wonder Harper and the rest went to South America, we have talent here we can export to show them how it's really done and how good it can be for the crooks1

  • alive

    38 weeks ago

    Nothing new here

    In business circles this is called : "Networking"

    The idea being that you avoid regular channels and exchange favours between those who have influence and privileges.

    There is a whole society in this province that never pay regular prices for anything, because they are able to "trade" amongst each other.

    Obviously that practice also include arranging for plum positions, and we are fools to thing that there is no payback there.

  • ron wilton

    38 weeks ago

    shameless

    Is their no bottom to the depth of depravity these people will sink to for a few dollars more?

    How much more of, and for how much longer, is the citizenry of BC going to take and tolerate these vulgar elitists, before we storm the Bastille?

  • Ramona777

    38 weeks ago

    What Can The Plebes Do?

    What a disgusting old boys/bridesmaids network. We know it exists but to have it so blatantly rubbed in our faces .... How do we stop these crooks masquerading as public servants?
    Furlong, who offered his services, should have done the job gratis, particularly after the wealth he accumulated through the Olympic boondoggle and especially after he and his crony produced a document that any good researcher or journalist could have written for a tenth of the cost.

  • DonJuan

    38 weeks ago

    Buddies

    Christy gave a speech at Stewart Muir and Athana Mentzelopoulos' wedding at the Hotel Van. An important other detail.

  • RickW

    38 weeks ago

    $200G for two months "work"?

    Without splitting the proverbial hairs, $50G/month = 150X the average salary in Canada.

  • lynn

    38 weeks ago

    Life ? in The Firm:

    "A bridesmaid at Clark's wedding, Mentzelopoulus was deputy minister of intergovernmental affairs and head of the Public Affairs Bureau under premier Gordon Campbell."

    "and head of the Public Affairs Bureau under premier Gordon Campbell."...

    Well, golly gee whiz....what is that saying?.....coincidence is when we can't see the levers and the pulleys.

  • igbymac

    38 weeks ago

    The train of thought gets derailed

    QUOTE:

    But Stewart Muir said co-chairs John Furlong and Doug Keefe hired him to write, edit and produce the report and he said he did not discuss the contents with his wife, Athana Mentzelopoulos.

    "The answer is a flat no, absolutely not," Muir told The Tyee. "You're talking about professional people."

    __________

    SO MUIR and the others involved are so professional that any discussion that may have presented itself simply could not happen, yet not so professional as to see the obvious conflict of interest in taking/offering the contract to author the piece in the first place.

    Christ, I am sick of these liars. It is just an ongoing trail of deception, fibs, lies, half-truths and disinformation with these idiots.

    I pity the silly morons who vote for any of them; but more, I pity the nation as it falls into ruin.

  • dave49

    38 weeks ago

    "You're talking about

    "You're talking about professional people." Muir

    We're talking about a very small circle of people here. Not democracy at all.

    "I'll surround myself with honest people. Guys I know all my life" Comedian John Byner on the nepotism candidate (1970s routine)

  • RickW

    38 weeks ago

    igbymac

    Quote:
    I am sick of these liars. It is just an ongoing trail of deception, fibs, lies, half-truths and disinformation with these idiots

    Kleptocracy at work!

  • John Greg

    38 weeks ago

    Um ...

    So, Muir said:

    "... the riot review was 'probably the most intense, sustained deadline period that I have ever worked on in 25 years of being a journalist.'"

    I don't know. Is that something he's proud of?

    As I'm sure anyone here who has worked on deadline documentation knows, as soon as you get a really demanding deadline, the primary focus becomes What can we cut out; where can we shortcut; what few things can we not overlook; how much can we discard.

    It is no longer an issue of trying to provide comprehensive, accurate, meaningful material; it's just slash and burn.

  • G West

    38 weeks ago

    Well John, he shouldn't be very proud of this turkey

    Take a few minutes and read some of this deathless prose.

    It would be one thing to be overcharged for a good piece of work - the cost of this turkey is even more of a waste because it is such a terrible piece of writing.

    Clichéd, trite and mindlessly repetitive – it isn’t even a decent cut and paste job – it’s a hack job. They’d have done better to hire a Tyee intern to do their ghost writing.

  • RickW

    37 weeks ago

    G West

    Quote:
    Clichéd, trite and mindlessly repetitive – it isn’t even a decent cut and paste job – it’s a hack job

    Purely indicative of the contempt they have for the "great unwashed"........

  • trueman

    37 weeks ago

    riot report retort

    I confess to only breezing through the report. I agree that it appears poorly written. The connection to the Premiers office is unpardonable. Not only was she a vocal hockey booster, of the sort rallying citizens to come on down and enjoy the spectacle, (and I maintain, contributing to the pandering to the mood of expectation that has to underline the cause of the riot,) she clearly wanted the rioters to be charged and quickly. All well and good. Is it any wonder that the report spends way too much time blaming the obvious miscreants. Of course the rioters were to blame. But those who cavalierly set the stage and failed to prepare and plan sufficiently are culpable.

    On the matter of the title of the report,what the heck does "The night the city became a stadium" mean? Ridiculous title. The city,if it became a stadium, ceased being one when the riot erupted.

    The city became a cesspool of property carnage, extreme human bad behavior, lawlessness and fear.
    It should have been,perhaps, the Night the City became a Zoo...except Zoos are well run.
    Perhaps it should have been The Night The City Became Another Example of Drunken Stupidity and Rampant Disregard for Reasonable Behaviour by People who Clearly Don't give a fig for anybody but themselves...and even that barely.

  • newphorik

    37 weeks ago

    Bob!

    The last line of this story says it all, I thoroughly enjoyed this one.

  • Carolyn

    37 weeks ago

    So THAT'S what Deputy Ministers for Corporate Priorities Do....

    Okay, let me get this straight.

    First, in August Ms. Mentzelopoulos is hired by her close friend the Premier as deputy minister for corporate priorities.

    Then completely coincidentally and out of the blue, her hubby Mr. Muir gets hired to edit a report that he "did not discuss with his wife".

    And his hiring had absolutely nothing to do with his wife's job, unless of course the report can be defined as a 'corporate priority', whatever that means.

    Riiiiiight.......

  • Fish-counter

    37 weeks ago

    If Stuart Muir says he didn't talk to his wife....

    "The answer is a flat no, absolutely not," Muir told The Tyee. "You're talking about professional people."

    That wraps it up for me. We can rest assured that all the sinister connections are just a mirage.

    Time for a change of guvmint. We need fresh liars and lizards in Victoria. The old ones know the ropes too well and they are treating us with contempt. I want the left-wing lizards to be in charge again.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.