News

$6.7 Billion Lopped off Olympic Economic Benefits Projections

And government's new number, $4 billion, is based on a seven-year-old 'best case' scenario that hasn't panned out.

By Andrew MacLeod, 3 Nov 2009, TheTyee.ca

Gordon Campbell in Olympics gear

Premier Gordon Campbell at Olympic flame arrival ceremony in Victoria, Oct. 30. Photo: The Blackbird.

Related

Earlier this year, the provincial government quietly downgraded the expectation for economic activity to be generated by the 2010 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games in Vancouver and Whistler by $6.7 billion.

The government was using the number $10.7 billion as the estimated economic activity hosting the Olympics would produce. Now it prefers to say it will be $4 billion.

But even that amount is based on a best case scenario mapped seven years ago by a consulting company, and real tourism revenues in recent years fall well short of that projection.

Downgrade happened in February

The government's decision to drop its projection from $10.7 billion to $4 billion was explained in an email obtained by The Tyee as part of the response to a freedom of information request.

"We're updating the YourBC website and there are two numbers for 2010 economic activity," public affairs bureau employee Melissa Peters wrote in a Feb. 13, 2009 email to Greg Dickson, communications manager for the province's B.C. Olympic and Paralympic Games Secretariat.

"The 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games are expected to generate up to $10.7 billion in economic activity," said one version Peters quoted from the government website. "This translates to up to 244,000 person-years of employment."

The other version, however, shrunk that prediction by over 60 percent: "The 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games are expected to generate up to $4 billion in economic activity."

The amount of economic activity the Vancouver and Whistler Games will generate has been one of the central questions since it was first proposed, along with the question of what the Games will actually cost taxpayers in Vancouver, British Columbia and Canada.

Keep in mind that reporters looking at the full cost of hosting the Games have come up with a figure somewhere between $6 billion and $7 billion.

Asked Peters, "What is the bullet you are currently working with?"

'Use the $4-billion figure': official

Dickson responded to Peters in an email a few minutes later. "Please use the $4 billion figure," he wrote. "$10.7 billion included the convention centre and we're not going there right now."

It is unclear from the exchange why government officials chose to remove the Vancouver Convention and Exhibition Centre from the calculation, though it's worth noting the project hit $883 million by the April, 2009, opening, nearly double the original budget. And there's the question of whether it was fair to count the convention centre in the benefits from the Games even while politicians refused to include it while calculating the costs.

Despite the quiet reassessment of the impact of the Games, finance minister Colin Hansen continued to quote the much larger $10-billion figure in his public statements.

"The total economic impact, once the games are done, has been projected by independent sources to be as much as $10 billion," Hansen said on Feb. 17 as part of his budget speech as recorded in Hansard.

And he stuck to the $10-billion figure when reporters questioned him in March on how the recession would affect the projection.

Today, the YourBC website spells the economic activity details out more clearly, though it still uses the dated figures: "Overall, 2010 related spending represents $4 billion in economic benefits . . . When you include the convention centre expansion, the resulting economic activity climbs to $10.7 billion."

New reports promised

Both the $4-billion and $10-billion figures the government continues to quote come from a 2002 report by InterVISTAS Consulting Inc.

New Democratic Party finance critic Bruce Ralston dismisses the InterVISTAS report as wide in scope and dated. The province has more recent reports on the impacts of the Games that they've so far refused to release, he said, including a $2 million study by PriceWaterhouseCoopers.

"Why wouldn't they just release those reports?" Ralston asked. "Maybe those reports don't support what they're saying publicly."

VANOC is also withholding a study by University of British Columbia professors Bob Sparks and Rob VanWynsberghe that was to look at the economic, environmental and social impacts of the Games and was to be released in June.

The minister of state responsible for the Olympic secretariat, Mary McNeil, was travelling with the torch relay and unavailable.

During estimates debate on Oct. 21 she said PriceWaterhouseCoopers has prepared four reports looking at the impact of the Games between 2003 and 2008. One of them will look at the actual benefits compared to what was predicted in the InterVISTAS report, she said. Although she said they would be released the following week, they were not.

The provincial and federal governments are negotiating a release date, expected to be within the next two weeks, a spokesperson for the ministry said.

Prediction depended on tourism spike

There is reason to believe the InterVISTAS report, at least the parts the politicians quote, may be more positive for the government than the reports they are keeping under wraps.

The report set out four scenarios. The $4.2 billion boost to the province's Gross Domestic Product, arrived at after subtracting the convention centre from the mix, was only going to happen in the most optimistic "high visits scenario."

Under the "medium visits scenario" and the "low visits scenario", the impact was projected to be about half the size, as low as $2 billion.

If the "high visits" scenario were to be achieved, the report said, B.C. should see "higher volumes of visitors to British Columbia for at least two years prior and five years after the Games."

In the midst of the global recession, however, the most recent tourism figures for B.C. show steep declines in international visitors.

According to Tourism B.C.'s October, 2009, tables, based on Statistics Canada data, year-to-date visits were down significantly in August from a year earlier.

There were five per cent fewer overnight visitors from the United States to B.C., nine per cent fewer from Europe and 14.3 per cent fewer from the Asia/Pacific region. The declines followed earlier large declines.

'Report stood the test of time': Hansen

Finance minister Hansen said the Olympics are still going to be a bright spot in the B.C. economy in the coming years. Economists at financial institutions and bond rating agencies are positive about the impact the Olympics will have, he said.

Asked why it has taken seven years to produce an update to the InterVISTAS report, Hansen said, "I guess the InterVISTAS report stood the test of time."

It has been a tough time for updating economic predictions, he said. "We could have done an update of the economic forecast 16 months ago which two months later would have been out of date. The world has changed a lot in the last 14 months."

The InterVISTAS consultants, by the way, recognized that the estimates for the economic impact of the Games would shift as time passed and more was known. As part of their work they gave the government the model they would need to "easily" update their figures.

"InterVISTAS Consulting Inc. provided the British Columbia Trade and Investment Office with a new version of the economic impact model," the report noted. "The new model can easily be updated to estimate the economic impact of the 2010 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games as additional new information becomes available."

Minister unaware if model used

If the trade and investment office has ever used that model, the minister responsible, Iain Black, said he's unaware. "I don't have anything resembling an update beyond what we already know," said Black, the minister of small business, technology and economic development.

There will be about $4 billion in economic activity around the Games, representing some 24,000 jobs, he said.

Asked about the discrepancy with Hansen's $10-billion figure, he said, "This is one of the challenges you get into when you're analyzing this. Where do you put the goalposts around what is direct and what is indirectly involved with the Olympic Games?"

He added, "We've witnessed that kind of arithmetic gymnastics on the cost side of the Olympics as well . . . It really depends on who's writing the article or who's doing the analysis. There's a lot of philosophy that creeps into that long after the math's done."

The government is proud of the work on the Games, he said. "There's very little going on that we're not anxious to crow about," he said. "Every time we get a crack at this, the meetings that I'm involved in anyway, the excitement and the optimism around the results, it grows, it does not diminish, so it's nothing we're afraid of talking about and nothing that we're afraid of digging into."

The coming reports will be likely be more good news, he said. "My suspicion is it will only be to the good."  [Tyee]

69  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    Liar, liar

    Blah, blah, more lies!

  • gamedev

    2 years ago

    Its amazing to see

    How the BC Liberals and their shills can just stand in front of the cameras and lie or obfuscate the truth with nary a peep from the mainstream media. I guess its not much wonder, considering the BC Liberals and CanWest are both facist groups.

  • salty dog

    2 years ago

    H1 N1 factor

    Has anyone considered what effect H1 N1 will have on the olympics?

    I personally am not getting a shot but....

    In my entire lifetime I have never seen so much scary hype on a flu, well, there was the Asian flu scare but that fear was minor compared to this,maybe because we live in a 24 hour news cycle and with the explosion of the internet.

    What effect will the fear mongering have?

    From what I have heard and read, who knows if the vaccine will actually prevent the flu....And, now the peak of the pandemic has been forecast to occur in january/febuary....And,that peak time for people to be infected is about the same time in most countries.
    So not only will the H1 N1 flu be in full blown scare mongering,many people will be sick in their homeland,or have a wife or children sick with the flu,now throw in the recession,our poor american neighbors...And all still waiting for their shots,well, this could be a bust of olympic proportions.

    Cheers-Eyes Wide Open

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    Photo Caption

    Premier showing how to blow an elephant!

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    Or

    How much wool was needed to pull over BC voters' eyes!

  • Dr Alexander

    2 years ago

    freebear, Thanks for putting us on track

    Kaption Kontest!

  • Dr Alexander

    2 years ago

    Kaption Kontest

    "I am not a crook"

  • salty dog

    2 years ago

    Well, my caption title...

    "We used to have salmon this big in our rivers"

  • Dr Alexander

    2 years ago

    salty dog

    I salute you.

  • Tangler

    2 years ago

    Cool Mittens

    The coolest thing about the Campbell Mittens is that he can keep his fingers crossed while he talks ...

    Sigh. This whole fiasco is such a shame. I used to quite enjoy watching some of the winter Olympic events, like skiing, speed skating and the like - completely ignorant of what the host city and nation were going through.

    Now that I can see, first hand, the manipulation and lies that go into hosting the games, I don't think I can ever watch another event.

    I feel sorry for myself, in that respect, but most of all I feel sorry for the well-intentioned, hard-working, talented competitors. The crap surrounding the games is not of their making.

    It's time to disassemble the IOC and its parasites like the Canadian Olympic Committee and return the focus to excellence in athletic competition.

    Yeah, right. And one day, professional baseball (which I also used to love) will star players who haven't juiced themselves in order to earn multi-million dollar contracts. Dream on.

    I guess I have officially become a cranky old fa*t.

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    And

    My hot air produces this much carbon!

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    Or

    Mittens, get your mittens, made in China only $10.00. Buy now before the HST comes into effect!

  • freebear

    2 years ago

    And

    How big a rock I will need to hide under after my 'golden decade'!

  • Dungeness_Crab

    2 years ago

    The benefit estimate

    Missed it by THAT much.....

  • sunshine coast girl

    2 years ago

    Every time they open their mouths..

    all I hear is blah, blah, blah, blah, blah and then it all turns out to be lies.

  • DPL

    2 years ago

    Now hopefully, the other

    Now hopefully, the other cities in Canada will steer clear of the circuses. Listen to Question period as the Liberal MLa's talk of business opportunities, not how they support the people doing the different sport. From the looks of our economy I suggest that most of Gordos' crew wouldn't see a business opportunity if it smacked them on the side of the head.

  • Skywalker

    2 years ago

    Caption might be...

    "Real men wear mittens!"

    Sometimes I think the organizers are living in some dream world. First the mascots and now those silly mittens I wouldn't be seen dead with. Maybe they are symbolic of all the color we will be seeing for decades on the accounts pages after they are finished.

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    Kaption kontest

    I'm so much smarter than all of you my head should be this big!

  • Frank

    2 years ago

    Tangler

    Bang on. I used to enjoy the Olympics, especially the 1976 Summer games and didn't understand back then why Montrealers were so upset just because it cost them a few billion. Now I understand.

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    244,000 person years of employment

    at 10.7 billion dollars equals an annual wage of $43,852.46. I'm imagining a few folks making mucho dinero and lots making way less for that figure to be accurate. Assuming the $4 billion benefit still delivers the same amount of employment (perhaps this is not the case?) the annual wage delivered by the Games drops to an average of 16,393.44. A minimum wage earner working a forty hour work week for 50 weeks would make $16,000. Again, factoring in the high wage earners no doubt skews the median wage even lower.

  • MGS

    2 years ago

    RE: Now hopefully, the other

    Do you think the other cities might be unlucky as us and have an ignoramus running things without any public input whatsoever. We never got a referendum which might have stopped this circus in it's tracks. On another note: It's to bad that the federal government isn't duty bound by law to make sure that the governments of the provinces follow the law with regards to Medicare, etc. If that was the case Campbell would be in jail already.

  • SharingIsGood

    2 years ago

    kaption kontest

    "I an tell a lie... this big"

  • doggone

    2 years ago

    Salty Dog

    The thing in Ukraine is not going "softly":
    http://preventdisease.com/news/09/110209_ukraine_cover-up_h1n1_deaths.shtml
    I remember the Toronto "SARS"
    The harder they come the harder they fall

  • TheOrra

    2 years ago

    On Halloween we got less

    On Halloween we got less than 25% of the historical number of children at our door Trick or Treating. Was it H1N1, the economy, or just a change in attitude towards candy, who knows? But the Olympics (as a symbolic Halloween) are likely to experience the same low numbers for the same reasons: fear of the pandemic, not enough money to pay for the trip, or just a pervasive rancor over the spending on junk, rather than our economic meat and potatoes. I am just waiting to find out how much it will ultimately cost. I already know I won't see any benefit.

  • dave49

    2 years ago

    $10.7 to 4 billion is a VERY significant drop

    Spin, hot air and more spin....

    Frank, I grew up in Montreal and saw a bit of the summer Olympics. Lots of debt and lots of corruption. It was a choice for Drapeau: Summer Olympics or sewage treatment. Sewage treatment lost out and by the time Montreal went looking for Federal money, Ottawa stopped cost-sharing for sewage treatment. Bad timing.

  • BC Mary

    2 years ago

    Just a doggone minute ...

    ... The minister of state responsible for the Olympic Secretariat, Mary MacNeil, was travelling with the torch relay ..."

    How many people, how many vans, how big is the Expense Account for these people "travelling with the torch relay ..."

    The devastated communities through must surely be hurt and angry to see that parade of fat cats virtually flaunting their self satisfaction as they pass by.

  • alive

    2 years ago

    Fairy tale

    "The devastated communities through must surely be hurt and angry to see that parade of fat cats virtually flaunting their self satisfaction as they pass by."

    Reminds me of "the Emperors new clothes" flaunting, but in fact have nothing to flaunt!

  • samuidave (not verified)

    2 years ago

    If there is one thing we know for sure

    when the Campbell Liberals are talking money expenditures or future income, they have no intention of ever being honest, and will gladly promote any figure -- any figure whatsoever -- that is politically expedient in the short term. And why not, this BC electorate can't remember what happened 3 months ago.

  • Fish-counter

    2 years ago

    Jean Drapeau said it best....

    "It is more possible for a man to 'ave a baby than for the Olympics to lose money".

    Campbell must be expecting twins. Maybe he is the next Octopappy. These Olympics make my skin crawl. The absolute waste of money is the worst possible example of conspicuous consumption imaginable.

    First, the Olympic torch is flown from Greece to Victoria in an empty military jet. There was no thought given to the idea of including civilians on the junket; as long as a few privileged elite were made to feel important, that was OK.

    Then the torch is being run 24,000 km across Canada and back, through communities that have to boil their water, and have no hospital or clinic in town or nearby.

    This epic can be compared to the potlatch, when the objective was to give away as much as possible to show how wealthy one was. The difference is that this Olympic orgy will benefit no one except the RCMP who get to practice wearing SWAT uniforms and throwing their weight around.

    Something tells me that "Own the Podium" will be the most expensive three words in Canadian history. I am not against the Olympics at all, but this is not sport; it is a financial hemorrage.

    Reluctantly, I am with the protestors. Please get this paahty over with so we can count the cost.

  • crankypants

    2 years ago

    The Perfect Storm

    The recession and the H1N1 pandemic spell disaster for the 2010 Olympics. There ain't going to be any pot of gold at the end of this rainbow.

    On today's news alone we have been told that Whistler still has plenty of hotel space available and a good number of those that were going to rent their condos etc are still waiting for customers. They are now dropping their rates to hopefully get some bites.

    Also, tourism operators have said that they have experienced a 30% hike in British Columbians booking trips out of BC for the latter pert of February. Westjet has announced that they are adding flights out of Vancouver to accomodate the increased traffic out of Dodge.

    With a little over three months to go before the opening ceremonies, one can only get the feeling that these games will ensure that BC will be a have not province for many years to come.

  • offended

    2 years ago

    I was walking

    through the Bay today and I noticed one of the "official" (i.e. ripoff of Cowichan) sweaters and checked the tag to see where it's made. Any guesses?
    China. Yup. China will benefit from the Vancouver Olympics. Nothing that this government does surprises me.

  • ME2

    2 years ago

    Fish-counter

    Comparing the Olympic debt-orgy to a Potlatch does not work. The objective of the Potlach was to gain prestige by demonstrating how much SURPLUS wealth a tribe or clan had to give away, a sure proof of its strength.

    Looking at Campbell's asinine grin of "pride" for his part in this debacle, is akin to listening to his self-congratulation for his part in saddling coming generations with having to pay for his idiotic ROR give-aways.

    All he needs is a fiddle and he could be Nero.

  • biscotti

    2 years ago

    any comment from Bill Tieleman?

    ...like, any adjustments to your predictions of the benefits of hosting the games?

    "Even if only for the job creation, economic development and international profile, they are well worthwhile."
    Winter Olympics: Stay or Go?
    By Bill Tieleman, 27 Oct 2009, TheTyee.ca

  • Fish-counter

    2 years ago

    ME2 is right. Maybe Marie Antionette said it best

    She said, "Let them eat cake"

    Then she lost her head. Many folks are proving themselves to be a silent majority, by booking their vacations elsewhere, just as many Calgarians take their vacation during the Stampede. They don't want to embarrass anyone but they don't want any part of the traffic snarl-ups either.

    The Montreal Olympics had their detractors too, and so did the Calgary Olympics, particularly in the other host city. This is different; British Columbians are wholeheartedly sick of this orgy of spending, which is totally inappropriate in so many ways.

    For one thing, the $1 billion security price tag tells us that an authoritarian streak runs right through BC. Civil rights are being curtailed and businesses are being put out by this five-ring circus. Air traffic on Vancvouver Island is being re-routed from Saltsprng via Nanaimo to accomodate the security net. The Canada Line construction put businesses at risk with little or no compensation and the Olympics are doing exactly the same thing.

    The real risk at these games is not from terrorism, but from natural causes, including the possible lack of snow, a rock slide or a road traffic accident on the Sea-to-Sky highway. Playing cops-and-robbers is for kids. Note to the RCMP: DON"T TASER ANY OF THE ATHLETES.

    I hope the real estate market turns a corner and the Athlete's Village condos sell for a profit. Based on past experience, they will be sold en bloc for a song, to someone's drinking buddy so they can take all the profit.

  • Jeffrey J.

    2 years ago

    $2 billion, 17 day party: Squandering Our Welath

    Given the steady free fall our economy is in (keep watching the US; it's not over and we're next), this may be the last $2 billion we have. THINK of where it could have been spent: health care; education, complete rethink of homelessness; environmental protection, addressing First Nation's housing. The list goes on.

    But no, we're spending it on the IOC, police, enforcement and some goofy parties.

    The Olympics COULD occur every four years, in Greece, where athletes could attend, we could all watch, and it wouldn't be this corrupt scheme.

    Great coverage as always Tyee!

  • guystone

    2 years ago

    NDP

    I cannot believe the incompetent NPD pushed for these Olympics. What a waste of money

  • Dan the socialist

    2 years ago

    I wouldlike to hear more

    I wouldlike to hear more about the Olympic bail. Main stream media doesn't seem to want to touch it as per usual in this province. http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/News/local/2009/11/04/11629331-sun.html

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    Entourage-alicious

    "How many people, how many vans, how big is the Expense Account for these people "travelling with the torch relay ...""

    Because this is the greenest Olympics ever one doesn't ask questions such as this about the longest torch run in history. Didn't you get the memo? :-)

  • Chris Keam

    2 years ago

    Off-setting emissions from the Torch Relay

    Personally, I have mixed feelings about the benefit of off-setting, but in the interests of fairness the Sun is running a story on the topic today with this info included...

    "In another Olympic first, Vancouver 2010 Olympic Torch Relay presenting partners Coca-Cola and RBC joined VANOC in offsetting all their emissions arising from the 45,000-km journey across Canada, as well as from their entire operations related to the Games."

    http://www.vancouversun.com/technology/Vancouver+Olympics+push+carbon+neutral+status/2179044/story.html

  • sunshine coast girl

    2 years ago

    So, the Owelympics

    cost us $6 billion to generate $4 billion in economic acitivity? And everything we lost has been worth it? That sounds like BC Lieberal accounting practises to me. And Gordo's going around grinning like a freakin' Cheshire Cat. We live in Bizarro world.

  • The Blackbird

    2 years ago

    Caption Contest

    Not to make downplay the thoroughly researched and well-written article my photo illustrates, I wanted to let the spontaneous caption contest entrants know that I had submitted this to Frances Bula as a potential caption contest piece for her blog. She prefers to focus on the local scene there, and so declined.

    But his is awesome! I didn't even have to suggest it. ;-)

  • The Blackbird

    2 years ago

    Caption Contest

    Not to downplay the thoroughly researched and well-written article my photo illustrates, I wanted to let the spontaneous caption contest entrants know that I had submitted this to Frances Bula as a potential caption contest piece for her blog. She prefers to focus on the local scene there, and so declined.

    But this is awesome! I didn't even have to suggest it. ;-)

  • OhCanada

    2 years ago

    Billions here or tehre - it is going to be expensive

    I'm not worried... it will be a slap in the face for all of us and all we can do is either move out of BC or pay. If the Olympics will be profitable that will be a miracle. Keep your fingers crossed.

    On that note - I never thought how much is at stake until I lived in Montreal and heard people complaining about the costs of the Olympics. Should have stayed in Montreal - they at least paid off their debts.

    Read Chris Shaw's book - Five ring circus.

    I just feel like a poor dog who gets the scrap while the owner eats the fat tasty piece. All of us who volunteer (I don't) pay the debts of this fiasco and suffer the consequences while the rich play are really nothing but puppets moved on a string or some poor dog that is being kicked around.

    Oh yeah, there will be benefits... those of you thinking that please please give yourself a kick in the ass or a smack on the face before I do. WAKE UP!

  • Kam Lee

    2 years ago

    gordo - waste of skin

    It is time for all people with any common sense to stand up and be counted. This madman, surrounded with fire island kev, fat cop coleman, silly i black, pollack, bobblehead george, plus many more yes men and woman in the cabinet, back benchers, as well as pab.This is a mockery of justice, as well as overspending for the rich few. I am tired of the media. covering, lying, and on their knees in front of gordo, chanting his name. There are cowards, as well as losers. You hear me bill g, wayne m, etc. Off with all their heads. I'm sure they will be yakkin it up when the bills come in. What a sham.

  • The Blackbird

    2 years ago

    Kaption Kontest

    How about if we forget about the numbers and just say you've all been f***ed over by THIS much!

  • Crash II

    2 years ago

    ... and it's carbon neutral! Magic!

    And don't forget.. the games will be Carbon Neutral! That's right... millions of kms of flights, 1000s of kms of fleets of torch relay vans and a thousand carbon-spewing torches, millions of kgs of craptastic consumer garbage, the skies and ground covered with a war-of-terror force, and it's all Carbon Neutral! It's like MAGIC!

  • Takuan

    2 years ago

    turning point

    these games and Games will mark a turning point in BC history. The utter polarization of a tiny, corrupt, wealthy ruling class and all the rest will be remembered as stemming from this moment in history. Reap the whirlwind.

  • salty dog

    2 years ago

    Carbon neutral games

    Has anybody checked out the official 2010 offset company?

    They are called offsetters

    http://www.offsetters.ca.node/92

    They are a brand new company,the details on their cheap web site are very thin...I checked them out when they became a company last year and.....

    The only thing they have done at that time was....Gave the highly profitable company Lafarge cement a ton of money to convert a power source.And they haven`t done anything else since.

    So here is how offsetters work....People give offsetters money(over guilt) and offsetters gives the money to giant corporations to help them pollute less.

    There is a list of people involved at offsetters listed on their website,some UBC people,but perhaps my friends you might want to google up the key players from offsetters and find out who they actually are.

    [COMMENT REMOVED FOR POTENTIAL LIBEL. PLEASE PHRASE COMMENTS LIKE THIS WITH WORDS LIKE "ALLEGEDLY" OR PHRASE THEM AS QUESTION. THANKS, -M0DERATOR.]

    Lafarge was upgrading anyways,offsetters paid for the upgrade with SOME of the MONEY they collected...The important word is SOME

    Cheers Eyes Wide Open

  • salty dog

    2 years ago

    Ooops

    The link to offsetters....IMO...They are nothing but a scam,gold certified scam.

    http://www.offsetters.ca/

  • salty dog

    2 years ago

    We`re number one

    Well Tyee moderators.....I alledge that they(offsetters) are scammers,period.

    Lets talk about the biggest polluters in metro Vancouver.....

    #1 Lehigh cement plant in Delta 1.12 million tonnes of GHGs released in 2005/2006

    #2 Lafarge cement 863.000 tonnes of GHGs

    #3 Chevron refinery in Burnaby 430.000 tonnes of GHGs
    #4 Burrard thermal 70.000 tonnes of GHGs

    So offsetters is alledgly promoting the work they have done for Lafarge,alledgelly promoting the money they gave to the highly profitable Lafarge cement so Lafarge could take a dribble of their emissions out of our airshed.
    Gold Certified funding being sent to highly profitable cement business(IMO)

    IMO Lafarge and the other big polluters are more than willing to take your money to upgrade to plants...HA HA....

    Here is a link to those GHG numbers

    http://www.cityofportmoody.com/NR/rdonlres/05532DBF-2CCB-4F82-8E04-D500FD395CFE/73687/btlcminutes.pdf

  • Conductor274

    2 years ago

    Olympic debt

    Wait until the final bill comes in for this fiasco.It's going to so big that Campbell will be forced to step down as Premier but of course he'll say something like "I want to spend more time with my family" as the reason for leaving. His cronies in the media will portray him as some kind of hero while the taxpayers suffer for generations trying to pay for his mess. Even the Liberal/Conservative voters must like the NDP option by now.

  • salty dog

    2 years ago

    I messed up that link

    http://www.cityofportmoody.com/NR/rdonlyres/05532DBF-2CCB-4F82-8E04-D500FD395CFE/73687/btlcminutes.pdf

    And if that link is no good...I have the link inside this story..

    http://powellriverpersuader.blogspot.com/2009/09/burrard-thermalbig-polluternot-even.html

    I am not a rocket scientist but....IMO the more money we GIVE to Lafarge ---Miracuously they will pollute less...My question is this,why do we need a middle man like offsetters...Why don`t we just send the cheque directly to Lafarge.

    Cheers

  • ReeferMadness

    2 years ago

    Offsetting

    Offsetting is highly questionable in terms of its green credentials. What some of these companies do is plant trees, some of which would grow anyway and all of which will die sooner or later. This particular company invests in alternative fuel technology like biomass. Burning biomass may be preferable to burning coal but that doesn't make it green.

    IMV, the only way to offsetting should be considered valid is if they are able to permanently remove CO2 from the atmosphere and sequester the carbon. Otherwise, it's a shell game.

    Much like the shell game of calculating the costs and benefits of the games themselves. We've been had but almost nobody cares so nobody will be accountable.

  • vancityguy

    2 years ago

    bla bla bla

    you're all a bunch of naysayers complaining to one another. open another bottle of whisky and pass it around. you enjoying your boring whine and cheese?

  • mary jane

    2 years ago

    is this why

    Is it because the estimates won't happen as expected, the reason premier spite has cut back child care, funding to legal services, mental health funding and the crisis lines on vancouver island. These are only the latest cuts, do we need to mention health care, education, seniors care homes etc etc Leaving out kids to carry the burden of poor planning and waste.

    Who has flipped out?? Has the fact the world economics are not jumping to gordos tune caused these new problems. What a slap in the face to all BC'ers

  • dorothy

    2 years ago

    Caption Contest

    "I am a great shaman calling to the powers that be to descend and rescue me from the mess I got myself into". Clue: dressed in red and white. Shamen always do. this is to commemorate the bright colors of the sacred fly agaric, Amanaita muscaria, that will send you flying high or, in olde English 'hoo', thereof 'ho,ho,ho'. Check for yourself here...

    http://thelivingmoon.com/41pegasus/02files/Proof_that_Santa_Claus_is_Real.html

    and here:

    http://www.davidicke.com/forum/showthread.php?t=81884

    So, wherever on the spiritual spectrum our imbibing premier started out, he is now declaring allegiance to the 'ho,ho,ho' brigade. Take my word for it. Or recognize the body language here:

    http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2008/04/18/2008-04-18_millions_eagerly_await_popes_visit.html

  • doggone

    2 years ago

    "Humour in Uniform" Readers Digest

    This is not an exact quotation - it's about 50 years since I read it:
    Apparently the entrenched artilliary during the 1st world war took to inscribing stuff on the weapons they launched at each other. The incedent described here may be a myth but it ain't "Urban":
    The German gunners write:
    "Got Mit Uns!" meaning "God is with us" and launch the projectile. Maybe it did not explode and some Brits got to read the inscription - anyway - the next large bullet falls behind German lines with this written on it:
    "We got mittens too"
    Did I mention it was winter?

  • RickW

    2 years ago

    Kaption Kontest

    "I don't know about you, but my share of the loot is going to be THIS MUCH!"

  • RickW

    2 years ago

    Guystone

    Quote:
    I cannot believe the incompetent NPD pushed for these Olympics.

    Nice diversion! Too bad it didn't work. The NDP may have pushed for the Olympics, but they would have lost the bid, not be willing to spend like there's no tomorrow. And if there's one thig the IOC likes, it's a big spender.

  • Blue Cabazon

    2 years ago

    Boy, some folks...

    So the NDP floated the idea of going after the Winter Olympics, but that was over 9 years ago. Maybe those who are Liberal supporters could get it into their heads that at any time since they came to power, the Liberals could have called a stop to it. After all this time stop blaming the previous government and lay the full blame where it lies. The Campbell Liberals and only the Campbell Liberals!

  • Dr Alexander

    2 years ago

    Dorothy, if I am reading you correctly:

    By invoking his Shamanisitic Self and calling upon the spirit of the Amanaita muscaria, our illustrious premier is declaring himself to be the Great 'Ho.

  • Dr Alexander

    2 years ago

    Actually, dressed as he is in the photo

    It very much reminds me of some of the folks that I have seen in Berlin's Love Parade.

  • mary jane

    2 years ago

    way back when

    When the idea of the games was introduced by the ndp the thing was a simple afair not the horror show.

    We weren't supposed to have cut backs in health care, education, child care, mental health supports, food programs that help our very child poverty rate, Crisis lines on Vancouver island - the program that helps prevent and deal with family violence. Lets not forget cuts to the justice system or now cut backs to community advocates, Ignored Global Warming problems that must be addressed or we won't have a world. Oh that we wouldn't have premier spites' abusing the poor or creating ongoing homelessness. Hummmmm

    We weren't supposed to create a nightmare for our children to deal with. The IDIOT is still at it

  • Orcinus Cedarbough

    2 years ago

    strange?

    That sweater effect - it reminds me of another certain high profile politician. I think he had a cat with him... Maybe Campbell should have had a little pet quatchi he was petting in his arms.

  • North of Hope

    2 years ago

    Myths About Landing the Olympics

    Here is an article about the costs of the Olympics. Very informative.
    I also posted this in your article posted today.

    Myths About Landing the Olympics
    By Stefan Szymanski_Sunday, October 4, 2009

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/01/AR2009100103891.htm

  • RickW

    2 years ago

  • G West

    2 years ago

  • doggone

    2 years ago

    I worked in Liberia for MSF

    Now MSF is saying:
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8347503.stm
    Why would I drop this link here?
    Decline the Latin verb "damnifiknow"
    1) damnifiknow
    2) damnifiinats
    3) -?
    I know it is not a verb

  • North of Hope

    2 years ago

    RickW

    I'm not sure what happened. Maybe when I copied the address, I missed the final "l" in "html." The address you have posted works for me. And thanks G West for your connection.
    In any event, the article is quite informative. I hope you enjoyed it.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.