Opinion

No Sleaze, Please

Campbell set the bar so low, no wonder his team stoops.

By Rafe Mair, 4 May 2009, TheTyee.ca

campbelltears11

Premier's 2003 drunk driving press conference.

The "sleaze" factor is now near the top of the election agenda as it should have been from the outset.

For John van Dongen's most recent cabinet departure (he had to resign a few years back amidst a different scandal) simply is the rash indicating a serious disease.

This disease, a moral indifference to personal misbehaviour by government members, began during the last years of the NDP reign, when its ministers were getting into trouble. No one was more vociferous on the side of parliamentary probity and cabinet morality than Gordon Campbell. He was practically Churchillian in his declarations about the duties of ministers under a cloud to resign until their name had been cleared.

Campbell made the point that it wasn't a matter of presumption of innocence but the strict rule that if one of Her Majesty's ministers appeared to be compromised, he or she must stand down. At the time, Opposition Leader Campbell was dead on the money. Any member of his caucus of that day would have been able to point with pride to the code of honour adopted by their leader.

The trouble was, of course, that when now-Premier Campbell got hammered in Honolulu, he paid no political forfeit. He had disgraced his office, his office and himself, yet, after carefully judging his own conduct, decided that no political forfeit was called for.

One need not confine themselves to sins of the flesh, for it was Gordon Campbell who, after throwing up the trial balloon of selling B.C. Rail in the 1996 campaign, quickly got the electorate's message and promised, cross his heart and hope to die, that he would never ever do such a thing. That he did so is not the worst of it, for he played the part of a huckster lawyer as he said he hadn't sold B.C. Rail, merely leased it -- for 990 years. In order to see how long that was in real terms, I reckoned backwards to learn that 990 years ago, England was ruled by Ethelred the Unready!

Once that happened, people around him could be forgiven for assuming that standards of political morality were lower than a snake's belly. They might even infer that interests were no longer those of the public but of cronies and those who made campaign donations. The survival of fish was trumped by the greed of the fish farmers. The sanctity of our public power system came a distant second to handing billions of dollars worth of power to "mom and pop" operations like Ledcor and General Electric, and, while he was at it, letting them desecrate our environment.

And now we have John van Dongen's recent departure from the solicitor general's portfolio.

In 2003, van Dongen resigned as minister of Agriculture, Food and Fisheries after allegedly tipping off fish farmers as to when the inspectors would arrive. He also returned the fines they had paid for other misdemeanours over the years. Gordon Campbell put the man with this sense of moral behaviour into the solicitor general's chair, making him the province's police chief!

Why not? After all, if the premier can get away with being nailed for drunk driving, what's a little matter of helping a friend of the government who gets into a bit of a jam?

How big a jump is it from there to paying large sums to high-rolling lobbyists who are also getting paid by companies dealing with the government?

If there is no penalty for drunk driving or tipping off potential offenders, where is the line that must not be crossed?

We are, of course, all mortals with penchants for sinning and we all do sin. However, there are penalties. And sometimes the same sin will require different results depending upon the circumstances in which it was committed. The consequences for lying may run all the way from nil if it's merely a social fib to loss of a mate if it goes to the root of the relationship. The consequences to ministers are often high, higher than they might be to you and me in our walks of life.

It is for that reason that leaders, like Gordon Campbell, must set an example not just in their own behaviour but where they're judging colleagues.

Mr. Campbell's amorality came blazing through with the van Dongen resignation from the solicitor general's office. Van Dongen waited a week before telling Campbell, yet the premier's reaction was not to fire him, but to take away two departments while showering the disgraced solicitor general with words of praise and sympathy.

It wasn't a matter of concern to Premier Campbell that his solicitor general had repeatedly broken the law and then, by silence, misled him.

One would think that any premier who had a sense of right and wrong would have tossed van Dongen out and said to the public: "See? This is how this government and this premier deals with those who have failed to meet the standards of their office."

Gordon Campbell put his re-election chances ahead of his duty, but then, what else would you expect from a man who puts his own ambitions ahead of paying any forfeit for his own misdeeds?

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

22  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • frenchy mcswede

    3 years ago

    One can only remember with utmost

    distaste, and utter contempt for how the premier, in particuliar, grandstanded endlessly regarding the death of one child under the ndp, and then while premier referred to his abolishing of the advocate for children in bc, which led, or was strongly connected to, the deaths of at least three children as "dropping the ball." That wasn't a ball, mr premier, it was three innocent lives snuffed out due your arrogance, incompetence, and breath taking hypocrisy...

    When the 700 or more files regarding children, many of them sexually and physically abused for discovered in a sanich warehouse, the bc business community had it any real even vestiges of human decency should have condemned and abandoned the premier en masse, but we all know how that worked out don't we...? Even canwest newspapers were outraged and horrified for months, but I haven't seen them bring up the issue for at least 2 years, an issue which any decent british columbian should never forget or forgive...

  • nightbloom

    3 years ago

    Why does the referendum on

    Why does the referendum on electoral reform have almost no public profile in this campaign?

    This always seems to happen - Its like no one really wants it. Is electoral reform being quietly sabotaged or what?

  • Grumpy

    3 years ago

    When the Premier and his party.............

    ..............flaunt the law, so do the bottom feeders of society. When the rule of law is treated with disdain by the ruling elites of BC, the low-life's feel they too can treat the law with disdain.

    You can draw a straight line between the Bacon brothers and their ilk with the Gordon Campbell Liberals.

    What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander!

  • Hughes

    3 years ago

    Dunging out

    Nightbloom 1 hour ago:

    Electoral reform? Me thinks a major dunging out at the Rockpile is the first order of business the people of BC must contend with.

    The corruption & cover-ups, half-truths & outright lies, cronyism, amorality, unctuous, clandestine, arrogant and wanton performance emanating from this Premier’s office is unacceptable in a democracy.

    British Columbia has managed quite well for over 100 years using the “first past the post” system of electing government, and will likely continue to do so for another 100 years -- but another 4 years of this morally bereft regime???

  • Jeffrey J.

    3 years ago

    Go Rafe Go

    Gotta love Rafe's prose. Campbell's double standard has exceeded all previous governments. His contempt for citizens is palpable. And its only going to get more extreme. Four more years of Campbell will be a real blow to BC's long, proud history of a great province. We can only hope for a change in government.

  • danneau

    3 years ago

    The real sleaze

    As I said to a friend, we should let all those without blame cast the first stones: they can all heave at once. But these discussions of moral turpitude need to focus of the real lapses in morality, the lies about budgets, the selling off of the commons, the faux-green propaganda and the painful level of obfuscation and outright deceit. I know, as most of beyond puberty do, people who have driven faster than they should, driven while intoxicated and conducted extra-marital affairs and who have redeemed themselves and who have become constructive and thoughtful contributors to society. However, for the kind of transgressions committed by the Campbell crew, there should be no second chances in government. They can redeem themselves by righting the wrongs or by wearing a nice set of orange coveralls for a stretch as a guest of Her Majesty.

  • dorothy

    3 years ago

    Yeah, but

    "I know, as most of beyond puberty do, people who have driven faster than they should, driven while intoxicated and conducted extra-marital affairs and who have redeemed themselves and who have become constructive and thoughtful contributors to society."

    Yeah, but the important part is, for the people who manage to redeem themselves, it doesn't happen through a nominal paying of dues by crying for two seconds in front of a mike, and then continuing life in the same vein. Redemption entails an enduring change in the way one makes choices, just like weight loss that holds doesn't happen through a week's crash diet before the bikini-season, but through a true and lasting change of eating habits.

    The problem with our Premier is, that when you look at the good parts, and there are some (for instance that he stood up to teachers whining over the standardized testing, while I must comnfess to being wary of James' relationship to unions, particularly the BCTF), they appear to be unconncted dots, very lonely stars in a very dark sky. But when you look at the self-serving part and the dishonest approach, there is a red thread connecting all the points, from the first day on election 'Now its OUR turn', till yesterday's lack of straight answers, or even any answers, to straight questions. There has to be a reason why the minimum wage in this province is stuck at 'unliveable', behind everybody else, yet our Premier declined to give us that reason. Poor show.

    Let's put it this way: Maybe we ought to not elect Gordon Campbell. This could be what's needed for him to save his soul, redeem him as a human being, and who would be mean enough to deny him that?

  • Van Isle

    3 years ago

    Hello Hughes

    If you check your history, back in the early 50's we didn't have this system as we have now. Wacky Bennet changed it to what we have now. As Mr. Cleese's lecture points out; there's not too many counties who have FPTP system anymore.

  • Karen D.

    3 years ago

    Gross misuse of power

    It seems that Campbell and his Liberals have grossly taken advantage of their position of power. I'm having a hard time keeping track of all the scandals they refuse to comment on and the business opportunities they have created for their supporters and fellow politicians.

    A select few will benefit from the Liberal's pet projects such as fish farms, private liguor outlets, IPPs, crown land put into developers hands, and who knows what else will be uncovered next.

    In my opinion, the privatization of our crown corporations sets them up to be bought out by international investors and eternally removed from our control.

    Campbell has got to be stopped from selling our province out from under us one piece at a time.

  • southdeltawalker

    3 years ago

    Is Gordo the Donald Duck of this election?

    About 40 of us where out in front of a hotel here in South Delta first thing Sat. morn. as Gordo was due to make an announcement.

    It was switched at the last minute from a park to the hotel to avoid protesters-us.

    Did Gordo arrive by his bus? No. He snuck in and out a car with darkened windows.
    The police would not anyone into the hotel but BC Liberal supporters.

    His announcement? A soccer facility will be built...but the catch is-only if BC Lib candidate Wally Opal is elected.
    Isn't that vote buying?

    Anyways the "big plans" are to use ALR/farmland for this field. The fact that we need this farmland is of no concern to Gordo when it comes to getting votes anyway he can.

    BTW-in their usual unbiased way the major media reported there were 16 protesters instead of around 40 including 10 or more striking paramedics.

    Anyways Gordo "ducked" us, the paramedics and will probably continue to "duck" anyone and everyone who is questioning his leadership and the record of the BC Liberals this election.
    Quack quack.

  • southdeltawalker

    3 years ago

    Must see video-"BC For Sale"

    Please circulate this powerful video:

    http://www.callingfromthecoast.com/

    Made by independent filmakers with no political sponsorship.

  • Grumpy

    3 years ago

    Note to South Delta Walker - Notice.......

    Next time walking about South Delta, NOTICE THE 609 BUS.

    Notice no one on the 609 bus.

    Notice it runs every hour.

    Notice the destination on the 609 bus.

    Notice it goes to Tsatu Shores and Tsawwassen First Nations.

    Notice Wally Oppal lives at Tsatu Shores.

    Now notice again no one on the 609.

    Note well:

    The premier runs TransLink and bus service is provided on a political basis.

    Is this not vote buying as well?

    Is this bus nothing more than a heavily subsidized school bus for Wally's daughter who attends the local high-school?

  • Karen D.

    3 years ago

    Hello Van Isle

    You might want to go back to the history books. FPTP has been used in all of British Columbia's elections except for one. W.A.C. Bennett was elected during the one and only time B.C. used the alternate electoral system. He switched back to FPTP in order to maintain power.

    Also, according to Guy's 'People Politics and Government', FPTP has been used in 68 of 211 world states and elects legislative representatives for 50% of the world's population.

  • southdeltawalker

    3 years ago

    Hey Grumpy-

    Thanks...didn't know that. His daughter gets a bus and we folks, despite our protests-will lose our much used #601 bus.
    Makes "sense" only to Wally and Gordo.

  • DPL

    3 years ago

    Thanks for telling it as it

    Thanks for telling it as it is Rafe. The sleeze is oozing out in a number of places.

  • mcdull

    3 years ago

    Christy Clark

    Christy Clarks program on attack ads seem to be the latest NDP attack. Not much about the liberal friends attacks on Carol James. The slime just keeps oozing. But our Mayor running for the Lieberals after failing as a NDP candidte admires the man who took the Grit out of the word Integrity. May Gordo win so we can start a Vancouver Island First Party.

  • Hughes

    3 years ago

    How long has BC used the FPTP system?

    Van Isle:

    From what I can find there was some obscure “section 80” voting procedure in place in the 1949 general election, and in 1952 an “Alternative vote” was used (whatever that may have been? “Section 80 perhaps?). In 1953 the Alternative vote was used for the second and last time in a general election, and the first-past-the-post system was reinstated. That leads me to believe that the FPTP system has been used in BC since the first general election in 1871, so with the exception of those five years between 1949 and 1953, it would seem that FPTP has been in vogue for 133 years.

    But then I’m no rocket surgeon, nor a political historian.

  • kayakrick

    3 years ago

    politicians

    webester states; a politician is one engaged in political offices for selfish or other narrow short run interests.
    no mention of intergrity, honesty or loyalty, so why are we whining? we get what we deserve for all our ambivalance.

  • Connie

    3 years ago

    Banana Republic

    Over the last ten years we turned more and more into a banana republic, one of those states were corruption is rampant, civil rights are curtailed, human and environment health take a back seat over private industry interest and the land and resources get plundered for short term private interest profit.

    Rules and policies are changed behind closed doors, facts are hidden, public discourse distorted ...

    For whom is it the best place on earth to live?

  • morechatter

    3 years ago

    How Low Can You Go?

    As Campbell takes politics to a place untraveled called business as usual. But its not its government and Mr. Campbell had a duty to each and every citizen to ensure that it ran properly. Not run it into the ground as what did business do for British Columbians along with Mr. Campbell but leave BC in the dark like mushrooms while the province is run into a deficit during times of untold wealth and its not adding up. No matter how many ways its spin doctors try to spin their spin its dirty landry and the stains aren't coming out.

  • morechatter

    3 years ago

    Clark Is In the Dark

    Christie Clark lives in the dark or does she? Is she not aware that BC democracy under Campbell rule has been all but destroyed?
    That BC's environment is in serious harms way along with our safety as TILMA, GATEWAY, and GAS PLANTS etc... That being Does Clark not read? Is she not aware children are left in abusive situations while some die or go without treatment.
    Is she not aware women and children are left to the streets to pick up deadly diseases as they have no way to fend of disease as live on streets.
    Is she not aware there are 300,000 citizens who go to work each day that can barely stay alive. Mostly women and youth often mom's supporting their kids.
    Is she not aware of the high unemployment and that we are in a deficit despite untold wealth.
    Christie Clark lives in the dark or she wants British Colombians to live in the dark probably more like it as she lives in her own little dark world?
    Maybe someone should clue her in.

  • Dungeness_Crab

    3 years ago

    Ms. Clark does not live in a

    Ms. Clark does not live in a void. She understands full well the consequences of her actions and attitudes.

    Like any good neo-con she dances with them what brung her, the better to retire in luxury while the peons suffer around her.

    there are none so blind as those who will not see past their own self-enrichment. Alas, we are awash in these people the world over today.

    FSM help us all.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.