Packing so many attacks on nature into one bill, Harper bets, will confuse citizens. Here's what's at stake.
Ominous omnibus: 70 federal laws changes within one bill, so why is Harper limiting exposure and debate?

-
-
Pipes could carry 60 per cent more than now proposed. Result: hundreds more tankers off BC's coast.
-
What might he do with a majority? Well, he once called his country a "welfare state in the worst sense." Here's that speech.
Usually when the Harper Conservatives bring in a new law, there is a big roll-out. The prime minister or one of his heavy-hitters goes to a prime location, usually not Parliament Hill. A factory or a mall or a friendly backyard. Tens of thousands are routinely spent on a "branding" of the new act. There are banners and public relations firms to design the whole package.
Unlike the laws I used to study in law school, laws with names that sound like statutes, Stephen Harper's proposed legislation must go through focus group testing for the most "election-ready" phrasing. For example, the omnibus crime bill which brought in mandatory minimum sentences and a plethora of moves decried by every criminologist and bar society was christened the "Safe Streets and Communities Act." And Bill C-36, an act of all of four paragraphs amending one sub-section of the Criminal Code in relation to sentencing people convicted of assault (to allow taking into account age of the victim) was given a fabulously overblown title -- "Protecting Canada's Seniors Act."
The launch almost always involves a media and MP opportunity to digest the laws in a "lock-up" -- an advance briefing usually including colour brochures and charts and graphs and, if not brass bands, at least a serious amount of noise.
Not so for Bill C-38, known as the omnibus budget bill. Sure, it did get the fabulous title: the "Jobs, Growth and Long-term Prosperity Act." There all similarities to other pieces of legislation end.
There was no announcement. No press release for first reading. There was no lock-up. There were no schematic guides to understand the changes to the 70 laws undergoing a brutal overhaul. Like surgery without an anesthetic, the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act was repealed and a whole new act brought in. While the four-paragraph seniors bill, C-36, will get its own committee hearings and full debate in the House, the 420-page Bill C-38, the omnibus budget bill, will be fast-tracked through the Finance Committee.
To add injury to insult, Conservatives limited the number of days allowed for debate at second reading of C-38. Government House Leader Peter Van Loan puffed himself up to pronounce that this was a longer time for debate than other budget bills. Meanwhile the Opposition MPs are left to protest that no other budget bill in Canadian history had repealed, amended or overhauled 70 existing pieces of legislation.
Some laws are the stuff of future Conservative campaigning. They are over-sold and put in the front window. Then there is the orphaned and unloved bastard child of Harper's legislative agenda. It is hidden. It is not to be placed in the front window, nor proclaimed as it should be: "Vote for the Conservative Party, tough on nature!" The good news in this is that Stephen Harper knows that his base would hate a lot of what's in C-38. That's why he is hiding it -- in a way that hides it in plain sight for anyone who is willing to dig deep and read the fine print.
Here's what is in C-38 on the environment. (C-38 threatens more than environmental damage, but this should give you a sense of why I am determined to stop this bill.)
Canadian Environmental Assessment Act ditched. Repealed and replaced with a completely new act. "Environmental effects" under the new CEAA will be limited to effects on fish, aquatic species under the Species at Risk Act, migratory birds. A broader view of impacts is limited to federal lands, Aboriginal peoples, and changes to the environment "directly linked or necessarily incidental" to federal approval.
Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency seriously weakened. The agency will have 45 days after receiving an application to decide if an assessment is required. Environmental assessments are no longer required for projects involving federal money. The minister is given wide discretion to decide. New "substitution" rules allow Ottawa to download EAs to the provinces; "comprehensive" studies are eliminated. Cabinet will be able to over-rule decisions. A retroactive section sets the clock at July 2010 for existing projects.
Canadian Environmental Protection Act undercut. The present one-year limit to permits for disposing waste at sea can now be renewed four times. The three and five-year time limits protecting species at risk from industrial harm will now be open-ended.
Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act killed. This legislation, which required government accountability and results reporting on climate change policies, is being repealed.
Fisheries Act seriously weakened. Fish habitat provisions will be changed to protect only fish of "commercial, Aboriginal, and recreational" value and even those habitat protections are weakened. The new provisions create an incentive to drain a lake and kill all the fish, if not in a fishery, in order to fill a dry hole with mining tailings.
Navigable Waters Protection Act hampered. Pipelines and power lines will be exempt from the provisions of this act. Also, the National Energy Board absorbs the Navigable Waters Protection Act (NWPA) whenever a pipeline crosses navigable waters. The NWPA is amended to say a pipeline is not a "work" within that act.
Energy Board Act neutered. National Energy Board reviews will be limited to two years -- and then its decisions can be reversed by the cabinet, including the present Northern Gateway Pipeline review.
Species at Risk Act hamstrung. This is being amended to exempt the National Energy Board from having to impose conditions to protect critical habitat on projects it approves. Also, companies won't have to renew permits on projects threatening critical habitat.
Parks Canada Agency Act trimmed, staff cut. Reporting requirements are being reduced, including the annual report. Six hundred and thirty eight of the nearly 3,000 Parks Canada workers will be cut. Environmental monitoring and ecological restoration in the Gulf Islands National Park are being cut.
Canadian Oil and Gas Operations Act made more industry friendly. This will be changed to exempt pipelines from the Navigational Waters Act.
Coasting Trade Act made more offshore drilling friendly. This will be changed to promote seismic testing allowing increased off-shore drilling.
Nuclear Safety Control Act undermined. Environmental assessments will be moved to the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, which is a licensing body not an assessing body -- so there is a built-in conflict.
Canada Seeds Act inspections privatized. This is being revamped so the job of inspecting seed crops is transferred from Canadian Food Inspection Agency inspectors to "authorized service providers," the private sector.
Agriculture affected. Under the Prairie Farm Rehabilitation Act, publicly-owned grasslands have acted as community pastures under federal management, leasing grazing rights to farmers so they could devote their good land to crops, not livestock. This will end. Also, the Centre for Plant Health in Sidney, B.C., an important site for quarantine and virus-testing on plant stock strategically located across the Salish Sea to protect B.C.'s primary agricultural regions, will be moved to the heart of B.C.'s fruit and wine industries.
National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy killed. The NRTEE brought industry leaders, environmentalists, First Nations, labour, and policy makers together to provide non-partisan research and advice on federal policies. Its demise will leave a policy vacuum in relation to Canada's economic development.
More attacks on environmental groups funded. The charities sections now preclude gifts which may result in political activity. The $8 million new money to harass charities is unjustified.
Water programs cut. Environment Canada is cutting several water-related programs and others will be cut severely, including some aimed at promoting or monitoring water-use efficiency.
Wastewater survey cut. The Municipal Water and Wastewater Survey, the only national study of water consumption habits, is being cut after being in place since 1983.
Monitoring effluent cut. Environment Canada's Environmental Effects Monitoring Program, a systematic method for measuring the quality of effluent discharge, including from mines and pulp mills, will be cut by 20 per cent.
In spite of the fact that most Canadians have no idea how seriously Bill C-38 will affect their lives, the Senate is about to begin hearings so that Conservative senators can vote on it as soon as possible. This railroading version of democracy is tragic for Canada.
The Green Party of Canada is launching its C-38: Environment Devastation Act campaign to engage Canadians in having their C-38 concerns heard. Please visit our website for more information. ![[Tyee]](http://thetyee.cachefly.net/ui/img/ico_fishie.png)
Elizabeth May is Member of Parliament for Saanich-Gulf Islands and leader of the Green Party of Canada.
40
Login or register to post comments
Curt
1 year ago
It would appear the 1% are
It would appear the 1% are very concerned that citizens ARE paying attention and don't like what governments are doing here, and globally. This goes with the "austerity" BS in Europe. The 99% are fed up.
This is what the fanatics/dictators do - legislate/dictate.
Trouble ahead.
RickW
1 year ago
The Difference is:
Harper is secure in his dictatorship and can cut back on the smoke 'n' mirrors. Not that he will eschew them entirely. After all, he enjoys looking down his nose at we gullible peons.
ScrewgeGordo
1 year ago
REVOLuTION?
Can anyone see protests and revolutionary-type activities looming as the 1%'s pipelines start abuildin' soon?
Dan the socialist
1 year ago
The 99% are fed
The 99% are fed up.
========
I wish that were true as 99% of the 99% are still asleep and more concerned with driving their portly selves through the drive thru in their SUV and get home to watch the game on the big screen tv they could not afford..
Amazing how people know all the sport stats yet when it comes to our country they could care less. So many do not even know the OAS is now 67 but as long as they can fill their faces with cheap junk, drive their gas guzzler and watch the game all is well and the lamestream so called mainstream media is never going to tell them anything anyway...
Steve Hetherington
1 year ago
Still can't believe it
This is so damn scarey.Does anyone besides me have trouble believing they are reading this article in Canada?What the hell has happened?
Are there any lawyers out there reading this?
This man is insane,no question.There has to be something we can do.What about citizens arrest for him or his mp's that are supporting him with their silence.This article should be printed and placed in every mailbox and schoolroom in the country.
I feel The Tyee to be a great read and enjoy all tha natter we get to share-----it just is not enough to get the real news at our end of the country----howe do we inform all Canadians of truth?How do we inform our school children.Do they even have a clue of what sort of future Harper is carving out for them?
I am sadly believing along the lines of Screwgordo that we need to fight----how do we get past these pages and actually do something-----Please Please don't say we can fix this at the next election---toooooo late.
Skywalker
1 year ago
I think ...
...Harper is deluding himself that there will be no backlash to this. Either that or he is trying to feather his nest for when he gets turfed in three years. It will all come back on him.
Steve Hetherington
1 year ago
3years eh?
Can anyone even begin to imagine what will be left of "OUR" country if we wait 3 years?
Oh Chinada,our home and native land.
Realist
1 year ago
Harpers promise
This is what Harper promised us when he said give me a majority and you will not recognize Canada.Sadly,we voted for this. This is the cost of ignorance amungst the voters. Apathy caused this once again.
pwlg
1 year ago
Very distressing
This isn't good news.
Ms. May, it is also important to provide legal avenues and strategies in which citizens and provincial governments can fight back.
What do you plan on doing in the House? Is civil disobedience by a Member of Parliament in the House chambers in order? It took one person with one feather to stop the Charletown Accord. Perhaps even without a feather Ms. May you can do your best to prevent this terrible group of laws from passing or at least give the issues an international stage.
Playing by Harper's rules or by his subversion of parliamentary democracy will not prevent this omnibus bill from passing.
You have a much greater stage to play on then this one letter writer who gains nothing by sending letters to his Conservative MP.
Do the provinces have any say on what Harper and his Dominionists are doing? Perhaps in BC our best bet is to pressure the extremely vulnerable Socred-Liberal government.
Some solutions please.
pwlg
1 year ago
decades of work down the drain
I feel for the many who have worked hard protecting habitat in BC. In the early 70's I spent 7 years working on stream rehabilitation on the central coast.
I saw what a few dollars and lots of labour could do to restore habitat and renew the life cycle of a great many streams and their inhabitants.
This legacy must be protected.
Provincial governments must stand up to this bully Harper! He wants to download social costs to the provinces while continuing to dole out more corporate tax breaks and oil industry subsidies. Canada's corporate tax rate is now below Mexico's.
Harper is no leader. He is a destroyer, a dominionist and a defeatist.
Okanagan Orchardist
1 year ago
I have 6 friends...
You have 6 friends. Pass this article on to those friends. Write letters to the editors of your local news papers. Don't forget all of the free papers that most communities have. A number of papers may also have a site on which you can express opinions, similar to the TYEE. Our local papers here in the Okanagan have a number of writers on the opinion page who don't have much use for Harper, send this to them, perhaps they can also put this in front of the public. We also need to spread this across Canada, so if you have friends out of the province (particularly Alberta and Saskatchewan), let them know what is happening. We also have to get this into the hands of the people you know who voted Conservative last election. And it probably wouldn't hurt to send this to your Conservative MP just to let him know that you know what is happening.
Name goes here
1 year ago
Harper is without conscience
Stephen Harper has young children. He also believes in the word of God, and this planet is His creation. I do not have children nor do I believe in God, but I care more about what we are doing to this planet than Harper does.
He will bequeath to his children a hotter, more polluted and more barren planet - and a country raped of its resources.
Harper is without a moral conscience. He can't see what we are leaving to future generations, he can't see what we are doing to this planet.
Steve Hetherington
1 year ago
pwlg spot on
Thankyou for your very important question to Ms.May "is civil disobedienceby a member of pariament in the house in order?"
Ms. May you have written an informative and important letter.Now is your chance to shine.You are in a great position to be a catalyst for thisgreat cause.You start it my dear and I think you would be amazed at the following you would recieve.
I keep wondering why we hear so little from the opposition and then--there you are.Please follow up and follow through.We just need someone to start----then watch the shit storm we can rain on this treasonous bastard
Fiat lux
1 year ago
Harper is a very sick man,
Harper is a very sick man, with mental illness written all over him.
The communists have left incredible environmental destruction behind in every country they've set foot in and operated as governments.
Therefore it is no wonder that their idiot twins, the capitalists, are doing the same, with their tongues still dripping from the licking of communist asses in China.
As I've predicted, Harper is going to go crazy with his power this year, and he's right on track.
His bosses will pull him next year, after he's done their dirty work, and install somebody with human features to pacify the electorate for the next 2 years.
All this has been in planning for many years and right on track. After all we're now a "conservative country", with communist politbureaus and capitalist boards of directors giving us the orders.
But then, there always have been the "plans of men and mice....."
Ed Deak.
butcher99
1 year ago
Greens
The problem is that unless the greens the liberals and ndp do not quit fighting and splitting the vote we are stuck with Harper for ever. Time to roll up the welcome mat Elizabeth and join one left party.
freebear
1 year ago
The Bitumen Boys don't confuse me!
The liquidation of Canada continues at the expense of our common future!
seth
1 year ago
Fascist scales of justice
Dispute over $225K in tax 4.5 years in the slam
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/story/2012/05/10/bc-porisky-ttax-evation.html
Unprovoked road rage murder most foul 5 years
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/story/2012/05/09/bc-road-rage-sentence.html
seth
1 year ago
Green Party - The Fasicst farm team.
Lizzy May and her odious band of irresponsible malcontents knew full well the enormous damage they were causing when they sighed up to the Fascist farm team in 2010.
Anybody who had the wit to read a newspaper,knew that Canada's and Big Oil's Dear Supreme Fascist and Spiritual Leader for Life - Stephen the Pious would do exactly what he is doing. Yet Gaia's black tar enemy the Green Party decided to role the dice, and suck up as many low information progressive votes as they could.
Just like Ralph Nader whose US Green Party destroyed the election hopes of the Greenist president there ever would have been Al Gore, and electing in his place George Bush, Lizzie May and gang rolled the dice and we all lost big time. The world will never recover from George Bush and his election courtesy of the Green Party may eventually lead to the world's destruction in a global warming holocaust.
Last federal election, exit polls showed that people who thought the environment was most important issue voted overwhelmingly Green ensuring that Supreme's Fascists got to spend a few more years destroying Canada's environment.
Are Greens Canada's dumbest voters?
Fascists love the Greens's, thinking of them as "useful idiots" who elect them over and over.
The GP's existence rides on the brand name of the Euro Green movement who with their MMP electoral systems can actually get elected. Somehow some puerile Canadian's who don't play well with others, got a hold of the Green brand and now get a large contingent of brand conscious low information uninformed voters to vote their ticket These unfortunate voters give with their vote these irresponsible malcontents a huge pile of money magnifying their power enormously.
Had the Green movement not been so successful at stopping new nuclear power, global warming and peak oil would be unheard of. Hundreds of millions of air pollution deaths would have been prevented.
Now by driving us right over that as little as ten years civilization ending Climate/Peak oil crisis with their silly "renewable" religion, support of the Fascist political movement and support of Big Coal/Oil's fight against nuclear power killing millions more every year, the GP seems bound and determined to kill lots more folks in very big ways.
Lots of Green politicians ran for the NDP and Liberals and have made enormous progress in turning those parties towards sustainable policies. They could have signed up Green supporters by the thousands to these parties, taking over entire constituency associations, sending green delegates to policy conventions, nominating green candidates and making sure the parties went Green. Supreme even showed them how to do it with his Christian fundamentalist takeover of the Progressive Conservative party.
They have caused enormous damage to my county, my province and my planet.
Lizzie May and useful idiots in the Green Party are the dark side enemy of the environmental movement and Gaia herself.
Peter Dimitrov
1 year ago
hijacked
The Legislative agenda has been hijacked by the corporate agenda - Harper and his cabinet are their proxies. For many years I have said we have a seriously dysfunctional authoritarian democracy in canada that concentrates excessive, unchecked power in the PM/Premier's office and the Executive Branch of government. Our democratic institutions are as deficient as windows 3.1 operating systems for computers. As global climate change accelerates and the 'train of civilization' is careening off the rails along with multitudes of species - Harper and his corporate cronies want to dig up and export more carbon intensive tar sands oil. Blogging and being aware is not enough.
Fiat lux
1 year ago
Peter .....You're right...as
Peter .....You're right...as usual.
The Harper gang represents a criminal system , taught in our captive universities as a "science", but their crime wave can only be realized through dictatorial powers.
What we now have may be called democracy through elections by the public, but, regardless which party, the system gives them dictatorial powers for their term.
In other words, it is not democracy, but autocracy.
Ed Deak.
Fiat lux
1 year ago
"May threatens budget
"May threatens budget delay"
Let's hope the other parties will also go for it.
http://www.timescolonist.com/technology/Green+party+leader+threatens+b
udget+delay/6605103/story.html
Green party leader May threatens budget delay
MP wants wide-ranging bill split into separate, related items
By Cindy E. Harnett, Times Colonist May 11, 2012 5:56 AM
Saanich-Gulf Islands Green MP Elizabeth May is threatening to hold up
a vote on the Conservatives' sweeping budget bill for days if the
prime minister won't consider breaking it up into related items.
May said the federal government's sweeping budget bill - which
includes changes affecting everything from Old Age Pensions to
oversight of the Canadian Security Intelligence Agency - would change
Canada's environmental regulations, laws and policies for the worse.
Miss BC
1 year ago
I feel sick...
This is more than disgusting, it's terrifying. Thank you to Elizabeth May for giving us the details. Time to take to the streets yet?
OwlRol
1 year ago
Going forward
Dan is correct, too many of the 99% are still asleep and it's time to try and wake them up, as best we can.
Too bad that unemployment is decreasing country wide, not because I want people to have no jobs and live destitute, but because the Harperites will take credit for getting people back to work. Seems Adolph got quasi-legitimately elected on that exact issue in the mid 30s. Didn't happen overnight.
Most Canadians are not ready for violence and vandalism. Total blowback.
Peaceful demonstration has some value, but just like petitions, these guys ignore such for the most part, unless overwhelming.
The PMO, and to a lesser extent, the cabinet have too much power in their hands. Harper gagged his other MPs except for a few social dillberries who distract away from the real issues, and now they've been trained to obey.
The corporate-mainstream media-Harperite coalition will be a tough nut to crack. It will require united opposition MPs-union-student-progressive church groups-GLT (and others) as a coalition to go up against it. Fragmented groups cannot hope to succeed against this steamroller.
If Harper can ruthlessly replace or eliminate existing laws, then those replacements can also be repealed after being ousted. Of course the corporations that will benefit from the current changes will try to litigate the government for lost profits and opportunities (recall the NAFTA challenges).
Also curious to see how these new acts may affect the private sale and export of bulk water.
"And the people bowed and prayed, to the Neocons they made, and..."
Fiat lux
1 year ago
The employment figures mean
The employment figures mean very little, because they don`t say what kind of employment, what are the wages , etc.?
Meanwhile the foodbank lines also grow daily in the richest country on Earth. Stats Can reports a "job" at something like 20 hours/wk and nothing about wages.
The economy was also booming the day before the `29 crash.
Which brings up the question, why should the profitability of stock market games, playing with the lives of billions, while filling the pockets of a few, be a deciding factor in economics ?
What are the plans to save lives if and when a crash comes ?
Ed Deak.
rantnic
1 year ago
FACTORING IN
Canada as the richest country in the world is only there because of factoring in our environment as well as our "salable resources".
Let's hope that Ms. May has the intestinal fortitude to stand up in parliament and force all of Canada to recognize the real "Heir Harper" and his [OFFENSIVE COMMENT REMOVED. -MODERATOR.] lackey Neo-con members of parliament.
RockyRacoon
1 year ago
@ Ed Deak Try Fascist corporatocracy rather than communist polit
buro. It is more accurately related to capitalism and therefore closer to objective reality than your smear. In fact your anti communist smears and prejudice at every turn regardless of the topic and no matter how unrelated to this moment of world capitalist hegemony border on the psychotic. From James Petras 2004 Capitalism versus socialism: The great debate revisited
Under communism the economic decisions and property were national and publicly owned. Over the past 15 years of the transition to capitalism almost all basic industries, energy, mining, communications, infrastructure and wholesale trade industries have been taken over by European and US multi-national corporations and by mafia billionaires or they have been shut down. This has led to massive unemployment and temporary employment, relative stagnation, vast out-migration and the de-capitalization of the economy via illegal transfers, money laundering and pillage of resources.
In Poland, the former Gdansk Shipyard, point of origin of the Solidarity Trade Union, is closed and now a museum piece. Over 20% of the labor force is officially unemployed (Financial Times, Feb. 21/22, 2004) and has been for the better part of the decade. Another 30% is "employed" in marginal, low paid jobs (prostitution, contraband, drugs, flea markets, street venders and the underground economy). In Bulgaria, Rumania, Latvia, and East Germany similar or worse conditions prevail: The average real per capita growth over the past 15 years is far below the preceding 15 years under communism (especially if we include the benefits of health care, education, subsidized housing and pensions). Moreover economic inequalities have grown geometrically with 1% of the top income bracket controlling 80% of private assets and more than 50% of income while poverty levels exceed 50% or even higher. In the former USSR, especially south-central Asian republics like Armenia, Georgia, and Uzbekistan, living standards have fallen by 80%, almost one fourth of the population has out-migrated or become destitute and industries, public treasuries and energy sources have been pillaged. The scientific, health and educational systems have been all but destroyed. In Armenia, the number of scientific researchers declined from 20,000 in 1990 to 5,000 in 1995, and continues on a downward slide (National Geographic, March 2004). From being a center of Soviet high technology, Armenia today is a country run by criminal gangs in which most people live without central heat and electricity.
RockyRacoon
1 year ago
Capitalism versus socialism: The great debate revisited
In Russia the pillage was even worse and the economic decline was if anything more severe. By the mid 1990's, over 50% of the population (and even more outside of Moscow and St. Peterburg - formerly Leningrad) lived in poverty, homelessness increased and universal comprehensive health and education services collapsed. Never in peace-time modern history has a country fallen so quickly and profoundly as is the case of capitalist Russia. The economy was "privatized" - that is, it was taken over by Russian gangsters led by the eight billionaire oligarchs who shipped over $200 billion dollars out of the country, mainly to banks in New York, Tel Aviv, London and Switzerland. Murder and terror was the chosen weapon of "economic competitiveness" as every sector of the economy and science was decimated and most highly trained world class scientists were starved of resources, basic facilities and income. The principal beneficiaries were former Soviet bureaucrats, mafia bosses, US and Israeli banks, European land speculators, US empire-builders, militarists and multinational corporations. Presidents Bush (father) and Clinton provided the political and economic backing to the Gorbachov and Yeltsin regimes which oversaw the pillage of Russia, aided and abetted by the European Union and Israel. The result of massive pillage, unemployment and the subsequent poverty and desperation was a huge increase in suicide, psychological disorders, alcoholism, drug addiction and diseases rarely seen in Soviet times. Life expectancy among Russian males fell from 64 years in the last year of socialism to 58 years in 2003 ( Wall Street Journal, 2/4/2004), below the level of Bangladesh and 16 years below Cuba's 74 years (Cuban National Statistics 2002). The transition to capitalism in Russia alone led to over 15 million premature deaths (deaths which would not have occurred if life expectancy rates had remained at the levels under socialism). These socially induced deaths under emerging capitalism are comparable to the worst period of the purges of the 1930's. Demographic experts predict Russia's population will decline by 30% over the next decades (WSJ Feb 4, 2004).
RockyRacoon
1 year ago
The only thing the political parties can do is launch a court
case against all of these breaches and they cannot afford to do it. They should also appeal the the Speaker of the House who should rule that these omnibus budgets are unparliamentary ( under the unwritten aspects of our parlimentary system that depends on precedent and tradition-this is the second time Bush I was actually thinking Bush Freudian slip and preventing the opposition from doing it's work.
RR
Fiat lux
1 year ago
Rocky.... Try your praise of
Rocky.... Try your praise of communism on people who have been there, have seen its workings, the trains carrying their victims to gulags and millions to their deaths, including some of my family and friends.
The charges in many cases? They were accused of being social democrats.
I was sentenced to 10 years in the gulags, as an 18 or 19 year old, still don't know why, as I wasn't involved in any politics at that time. It was in absentia because they didn't catch me, so they arrested my mother and tortured her four times, trying to find out how I got to England and what I was doing there. Luckily, she didn't know.
The most unequal, corrupt society, where the ruling class had the power of life and death over the people, jailing and killing people at will, destroying their subjects and the ecology of their domains with all kinds of poisons, pollution etc.
My classmates started dying in their 50s from the conditions and now, in our mid 80s, there are only 2 of us left. How is it here, in comparison?
Capitalists are just as corrupt, but at least we don't have gulags and death camps. Yet.
I admire their butt liking sessions between them in China.
As far ownership of property is concerned, they've nationalized all houses in Hungary, then the resold them back to the owners, because nothing was done and everything was falling apart after a few years.
Good way to raise cash for the government.
By the way, we found our sister machinegun squad lying by the roadside with their throats cut. Must have had some fun with them. I was 17 at the time and we always carried a handgrenade in our belts to blow ourselves up with in case we're wounded, or about to be captured.
Some character smearing of the wonderful communist system, in the eyes of the faithful ?
Grow up !
Ed Deak.
Commonsens
1 year ago
AND IT WORKS LIKE A CHARM!
Harper knows how to misdirect people perfectly and show us again with C-38, how a master liar he is while showing us how stupid we are!
While we ALL jump on the environment portion of the C-38....all of the other parts goes unnoticed! No one even really challenge the fact that it is rammed as a "block" or rushed in before "vacations" without proper analysis (forget challenge as democracy and opposition is dead in Canada)
mikev
1 year ago
kudos to The Right Honourable Elizabeth May
You make me proud that I voted Green. A bright light shining down on all the repulsive fungal growths infesting those chambers.
Seth, people like you are wildly successful at totally alienating people like me. Take a nice hearty pat on the back from your adoring fan Stephen Harper. He really appreciates the work people like you are doing here.
If I say people like you instead of you personally, is that how you get a pass from the moderators? Nevermind, very tempting but I'll try not to push it.
I have been berated for not holding my nose and voting for someone other than who I feel best represents my interests. A blatant and brazen (and over the top rude) scolding attempt to subvert democratic principles.
I didn't get thousands of people together to take over a stale old dinosaur of a political party. Your coldly strategic electioneering calculations notwithstadning, without so much as a minor bit of statistical probability figuring, I went ahead and simply voted for the candidate and party that I would like to see in the driver's seat. I should feel guilty somehow? Look at her go! You should be eating crow.
I did support BC-STV. That's the best way to stop the split IMHO. If you don't support it, like just a little bit too many people did in our historic referendum, then we could hurl insults at each other until the cows come home for all the good that would do.
Strategic voting smells retchingly rank to me and if Elections Canada were ever to start coming down on pushers of that sort of thing I wouldn't be able to find much motivation to oppose it. The list on the ballot is longer than the list of people that have a chance to win. Hands up everyone who is overly impressed with the list of people who have a chance to win? I'm not going to vote for anyone but the best no matter how many charts and figures and predictions you've got, so give it a rest. If it's time for a change then let's bring it on already.
Have a day.
pwlg
1 year ago
Ed
I think you missed the point of the comments made by RockyRaccoon. His points are valid and concern themselves with the present state of former countries of the Soviet Union. Your comments appear to be shaped by your personal experiences of the past which are also valid and worth noting.
Both of the comments tell us that all socio-economic political systems require some critical thought before embracing them.
Hurling personal attacks like "Grow Up" are better left edited out. Thanks.
Fiat lux
1 year ago
Anybody who has anything good
Anybody who has anything good to say about the mass murdering Soviets, has problems.
The best example of the total corruption of the system is shown in the memoirs of Nikita Kruschev, authenticated by his son.
When Stalin was lying, dying in agony, his cronies were playing cards in the next room, without calling a doctor, waiting for him to croak, knowing that if he survives, all of them would be dead for having seen him in need of help.
Any system where some member of a party, or ruling sector, can just call the cops to get rid of somebody, as it happened to many people I knew, is an obscenity and anybody who can find anything praiseworthy in it is sick.
The Secret Police went to arrest the principal of my school, by the name of Frigyes Diossy and his older son Geza. Nobody knew why, or ever found out, but they were never seen again, as many I have known.
His job was taken by one of our teachers by the name of Ferenc Sipos, who must have been a closet communist before, because he sent a note to my mother that if they catch me I'll be on the first train to Siberia.
A teacher sentencing a kid virtually to death, without any reason, just because he didn't like me ?
And this is the system anybody can defend ?
I've been fighting all kinds of dictatorships
ever since, whatever they call themselves.
Ed Deak.
JefKeighley
1 year ago
Harper's Dictum
Harper's Dictum: 'When the cameras are rolling, smile, as you shove in the knife'.
cottamkj
1 year ago
The Green Party
The individual who is attacking the Green Party and Elizabeth May doesn't know what he is talking about. He is talking utter nonsense by claiming that should they have joined the other parties Harper would have been stopped. True, Harper is doing an irreparable harm to this country, but this is the fault of all those who were stupid enough to vote for him. Canadians are among the most unsophisticated voters in the West. Why did they vote for Harper? I am a former Progressive Conservative, but I would never, never have voted for an individual with this kind of harmful and extremist agenda and biography.
GordonK
1 year ago
Life at the end of Empire
Time to grow your own food.
jayphive
1 year ago
horrible article
this article is horribly written and detracts from the point of the article. we dont need another article about how harper is evil, we need information about the act and what its the changes are going to do to harm the environment. The useful information doesn't come until the last part of the article, when most people have stopped reading. Elizabeth, stop trying to get elected and try and actually help the environment.
Linker
21 weeks ago
jayphive above has just
jayphive above has just uttered everything I was about to say. Well said!
__________
Medical Assistant Job Description HQ
Linker
21 weeks ago
Forgot to say I love this
Forgot to say I love this blog.
__________
Medical Assistant Job Description HQ
josephsmeadows
7 weeks ago
Hi Thank you Elizabeth May
Hi
Thank you Elizabeth May for sharing such things about harper, i think he is sick man.
Thank you
medical assistant job description