Opinion

Would You Buy a Used Car from These Libs?

Eight old dents in believability Clark's polish hasn't fixed.

By Rafe Mair, 6 Feb 2012, TheTyee.ca

Christy Clark BC Libs cartoon

Cartoon by Ingrid Rice.

Related

So, Adrian Dix is higher in the polls than Christy Clark.

It comes as no surprise to me, who has said from the beginning that Christy Clark did not have what it takes to lead a party, much less a province. If she were not premier, I would call her an airhead.

It's interesting to note that only one person in her caucus supported her leadership bid, and he had to be shuffled into cabinet obscurity after screwing up his first minister's post. This is an important point because under the British system, when a prime minister goes, the caucus declares who the successor will be until the next party convention. A party-wide vote, democratic though it may be, is a popularity contest, while the caucus votes the most competent successor which they are best qualified to determine. At the very least, before a leadership convention, the caucus ought to be polled and the poll made public. As expected, Premier Clark refuses to face issues by changing the subject when she is asked tough questions to her amazing plan to make B.C. the most this or that, blah, blah, blah.

Before continuing, Premier Photo-Op has refused to cancel the HST as the people demanded. In my opinion, she is very hesitant to do so for a very good reason. Clark must obey Prime Minister Stephen Harper's every wish or Harper will queer any HST concessions. Premiers used to stand up for our province, while Ms. Clark genuflects before Prime Minister Harper as she holds out her begging bowl.

Most of all, today I want to look at some of the Campbell/Clark government's most egregious sins which should stand out there for all to see.

This is not intended to be an exhaustive exercise. Rather, I'll look at the Campbell/Clark government's parsimonious use of the truth. These incidents stretching credulity I will number for your easy reference.

1. BC Rail. Let's start with the 2001 election where Campbell promised not to privatize BC Rail. This promise was actually made in the previous election.  

2. Leasing? Really? Campbell said he was only "leasing" BCR -- right, for 990 years! My previous observation remains valid. "I can't tell you what things will look like in 990 years time, but look back 990 years and Ethelred the Unready was King of England!"

3. Botched bidding. Campbell said that privatizing BCR would be above board whereas, as we now know, it was not done without a monstrous abuse of power by two criminals.

Former attorney-general and finance minister Colin Hansen now enters the narrative in a big way.

4. Rivers of promises. When promoting the virtues of run-of-river projects, Hansen has strained credulity to the breaking point, as I have argued in some detail.

5. The harmonized sales tax. Let's move to Hansen and the HST. In the election campaign of 2009, he told us that the HST wasn't on the radar, yet we find out after the campaign that he had a large study of this tax done, and that report was in his office six weeks before the election. In fact, the HST was laid on the table just a few days after the election.

As one who has been a minister, I can say that federal/provincial deals of this sort take many months to negotiate and so I consider it likely that Hansen and of course the premier were negotiating the HST months before the election.

We're not finished with poor old Mr. Hansen yet.

6. Unreal budgeting. In February 2009, the government projected a rosy fiscal economic picture and that was the budget the Liberals touted throughout the election as proof they were great managers and the NDP proved wastrels. In fact, the projections in that budget were well over a billion dollars short.

The official line from Hansen and Campbell was that they were blindsided by the recession! This business-like government, the one best suited to handle our money, apparently had not heard of the stock market crash of 2007 nor the recession starting in 2008! More likely, the Liberals faked it in order to win the 2009 election.

7. Hosing Hydro. The Liberals have repeated that BC Hydro is the sacred jewel in B.C.'s possession and always would be so. Yet they forced Hydro into buying private power at a time when BC Hydro didn't need it -- and at a cost far more than were Hydro to generate its own power. For this and other reasons built into the Campbell/Clark government's deal with private power producers, Hydro is placed at such a disadvantage that if our crown jewel were in the private sector, it would be in bankruptcy.

First it was BC Ferries, then BC Rail. Next up, BC Hydro.

8. Waking the debt. The Campbell/Clark government alleges that it is the best suited to manage our fiscal affairs and that the NDP would bankrupt the province. The fact is that while the NDP were in, the "Asian Flu" had all but wiped out our forest industry, doubling the provincial debt. Now are you ready for this? The Campbell/Clark government, starting from a much larger base, has tripled our debt!

Move on, they say

Adrian Dix did a very wrong thing during the NDP years by producing a memo and then back-dating it in an effort to make it appear that then-premier Glen Clark had instructed him to keep him at arm's length from the process of awarding casino licences.

There is no doubt that this was egregiously wrong, but he admitted what he had done and was punished.

What the Campbell/Clark government has done is also egregiously wrong, but they have denied it and continue to deny it.

It does no good to state over and over that this was history. It's no longer enough to invoke the timely excuse of politicians in trouble and just say, "It's time to move on."

Then again, maybe it is time to move on. The best way to do so is to throw this untrustworthy and incompetent bunch out on their duffs.

[Tags: Politics.]  [Tyee]

31  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • DPL

    1 year ago

    Good summary and of course

    Good summary and of course there is much more events involving assorted BC Liberals. Ms Photo Ops is getting hard to watch as she spreads horse cookies around here in BC . She simply must go, either by her choice, the caucus, or the citizens of BC

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    This is all part of a long

    This is all part of a long term plan to take over and force BC and Canada under corporate dictatorship.

    The powers will allow the NDP/Dix to win the next elections. That will force the BCLibs to go the way of the Socreds and be taken over by the BC Conservatives, set up for this purpose by Harper.

    The international controllers of the world then will destroy the BC economy with the powers already given to them by various governments, under the guise of "competitiveness", blato put BC and Canada under a globalized, corporate dictatorship, given to them by our and the world's "conservatives" as the Will of God.

    At least, this is the plan, but the plans of men and mice don't always work out and the world is beginning to wake up to the fraud and enslavement.

    The important question now is whether the NDP has the capacity and understanding to make use of this inevitable, gradual, worldwide awakening, or sell out to the rulers the way Labour parties have sold out all over the world ?

    The communists have worked and are still working under 5 year plans, but their brother capitalists are working on much longer terms, as I've found out, talking to them in my Vancouver days 30-40 years ago.

    I wonder what and how much Harper will promise and sell to China in the next few days? How about another "free trade" racket for complete takeover by India, China and the EU ?

    For the purposes of "wealth creation" of course.

    Ed Deak.

  • jimmmmy

    1 year ago

    language

    when you call ms. clarke liberal it makes me queasy. a better term for her and her associates is rump socreds. you can't fix things until you properly define the problems.

  • off-the-radar

    1 year ago

    selling out BC and Canada to the corporations

    Yes, we're having our province and country sold out from under us to multinational corporations.

    In 20 years we won't have countries anymore, at least not in North America. Canada, the US and Mexico will have lost all sovereignty.

    Unfortunately global corporations, these soulless constructs, aren't sustainable for Mother Earth. They don't work for ordinary people either, we're mere fodder to meet the needs of billionaire hedge fund managers (US, UK) and criminal overclasses (Mexico, Russia, China).

  • Vox.Pop

    1 year ago

    Liars, liars, liars

    Well said, Rafe. This is the worst group of lying incompetents in BC's history. And Ed Deak, based on his many years of observation, explained why this gang are on the way out.

  • bob1964

    1 year ago

    Your almost frothing at the

    [OFFENSIVE COMMENT REMOVED. -MODERATOR.]

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Good one Rafe!

    Just imagine if we had a pit bull open-line show host like Rafe today. I guess that is why they had to get rid of him. You can't have this kind of honesty in the MSM these days as the liberal reign would have been over years ago.

    The deceit of this government needs to be kept front and center until they are gone. They have squandered more political capital than any group in B.C.s history. Lying has become an art form.

  • irth1st

    1 year ago

    You rock Fiat Lux

    Rafe and Ed, thank you for the clear concise perspective on a very difficult situation we are in. The big trade agreements we are bound to have removed our sovereignty. I believe the only method to re-patriate our resources and democracy has to start at the local and regional level; if at all possible.

  • gadrogeek

    1 year ago

    HST and A Balanced Budget

    So, we are going to have a "balanced" budget after all - by election time. So says Mr. Falcon. Great, I guess they really plan to collect enough of the HST by that time. Meanwhile, the construction industry and restaurants, and their customers, take it on the chin. Thank you, Rafe.

  • cyberhino

    1 year ago

    "the world is beginning to wake up"

    Let's hope so, Ed.

    And they used to call us "conspiracy buffs".

  • JohnTW

    1 year ago

    Many many more wrongs

    Good as usual, Rafe - thank goodness you are among the few people willing to try to "queer" the BCLiberals plans for re-election. But your analysis only scratches the surface.
    For example, Campbell should be called to testify at the Missing Women inquiry when "His Excellency" is in town on Feb. 10 to speak to the VBoT - because as young Gordie he was chair of the Vancouver Police Board when Willy Pickton began his serial murders.
    There also should be an investigation of Vanoc to see just what kinds of remuneration or kickbacks and other benefits were received by Campbell's and Clark's friends and insiders.
    Campbell was arguably the worst Premier in B.C. history and may have been the most corrupt too but we may never know because Christy refuses to answer calls for any inquiries into such matters.

  • shockedandappalled

    1 year ago

    The MSM jump on Dix

    No sooner has Adrian Dix pulled ahead of Christy Clark in the polls than the province headline reads: "Dix's priorities come with hefty price tag". And the Globe and Mail bleats:"Get ready for ‘Premier’ Adrian Dix?" - note the question mark and the quote marks around Premier, reminiscent of air quotes.

  • John Corman

    1 year ago

    Rafe's memory is getting a tiny bit short

    Here's just a couple of quotes of Rafe's regarding the "worst governments" he's ever seen in BC.

    Rafe in 2000
    "Bad enough that the NDP has provided the worst government in the history of this province – but to cap it off, as former Premier Dave Barrett … still, thanks to his party on the public tit … has amply demonstrated they’re a bunch of hypocrites to boot."

    Rafe Mair discussing inadmissable wiretap information regarding Adrian Dix's partner Glen Clark.
    "If this evidence – from what we’re told crucial evidence – is ruled inadmissible by reason of faulty procedure the public will have every right to be enraged. In fact, they have every right to be enraged that it is even an issue."

    Do your own searches to read Rafe Mair's actually feelings towards the NDP in matters such as:
    The Privatizing of part of BC Hydro for the benefit of NDP insiders using a tax haven in Grand Cayman.
    The NDP's payoffs to victims (clients) of Moe Sihota's.
    Giving an NDP insider, Jack Monroe a lucrative job running a ship building enterprise (fast ferries)

    The list goes on and on and, I'm rather surprised that Rafe could make such a turn around in core beliefs in a such a short period of time.

  • snert

    1 year ago

    Ed Deak

    Quote:
    "wealth creation"

    All that is is just the end product of being good at what you do. That can take many forms but the creation of wealth (actually the accumulation thereof) is inevitable simply because of the differences in human nature.

    The only way to stop it, Ed is for everyone to become followers Karl Marx. That didn't work in the past and probably won't work, ever, in the future. Seems that not all communes are created equal.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Corman

    All it shows is just how much worse the liberals are. You think you see something bad and then the masters of corruption and deceit set a whole new standard. I won't mention that all of the claims that you repeat have been revisited and found to be other than what was portrayed by the media. They are also now viewed in the context of the BC Liberals. By that new standard everything you repeat is a mere drop in the ocean in comparison. That is the way most people view it and that is why Christy Photo Op is desperate.

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    Snert...I have an over 45

    Snert...I have an over 45 year record fighting communism, and need no lessons on what it is about.

    Marx was a jerk, who let his kids starve to death, while his followers murdered millions.

    In any case, even his teachings had nothing to do with communism, any more than the teachings of Adam Smith have anything to do with modern day capitalism.

    Cooperation of free people needs no prophets, only a bit of common sense, something ignorant people who immediately associate any questioning of the crime wave of capitalism with Marxism.

    Ed Deak.

  • TYRONE

    1 year ago

    Throw the bums out . . .

    Fortunately for Us informed, we have a forum such as it is - alas the Tyee is much too small and sometimes unfair even to Us (this comment section is closed - no more comments) just when the discussion takes off!

    Yes, We the people (in the know) realize this world is going to hell in a hand basket, but We will keep fighting these 'windmills' even IF it does Us in!

    Forward and Upward ye mates!

  • igbymac

    1 year ago

    Fiat lux

    This is all part of a long term plan to take over and force BC and Canada under corporate dictatorship.

    Wow, that ship has long sailed, Ed.

    In the simplest of ways, what we see going on is the historic and repetitive power-play for control between a representative sovereignty and private capital.

    Representative democracy lost -- or was at least destined to lose if it did not change its course (which it has not) -- before the first sunset over the founding of this nation in 1867.

    Canada has never been free from the control of private capital except in words and on paper supported by the national rhetoric.

    As you well know, the elephant in the room is 1) the fraud of fractional reserve banking and 2) debt-based money controlled by private power.

    Canada has never been free to determine its destiny, always a lick-spittle to Empire and its financiers. We move as a nation where they dictate for at least three clear reasons:

    1) we the people do not even remotely understand the law or banking/money;

    2) we are propagandized from cradle to grave about our distinct nation, its history and our form of governance. What we learn is so distorted from the truth and so full of omissions that it is effectively a lie; and

    3) we are repeatedly extorted to accept any sort of 'expert sounding' plan when times get hard during one of the staged business cycle downswings.

    Throughout our history as a nation, I doubt 1 in 500 politicians has understood how they have been fundamentally failing at their job as representatives of the people. It's painfully obvious but not without reason: The imperialism of culture is more powerful than any army, perhaps even more powerful than the truth.

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    Igby....I've lived under

    Igby....I've lived under every ideology and they all were selling "freedom", while enslaving and killing millions.

    The nazis invaded the Soviets to "To bring them freedom, Christianity and Western civilization "

    And it goes on and on through history, to the present day. The religious and ideological scriptures used for these crime waves, my differ, or oppose each other, but the leaders are always the same predators.

    This is why I'm calling the leaders of both communism and capitalism brothers under the skin, as shown in the present asslicking session going on in China in the name of "trade".

    In the past the lie was to "spread the word of God", "bringing freedom", now it is "wealth creation" and "trade", all ending up in enslavement.

    It used to be done with arms, now with the perceived power of imaginary money used to alter facts, physical laws and dimensions to feed more power into the hands of the same rulers, from day one.

    Ed Deak.

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    Here's another good example

    Here's another good example of how the criminal sectors of history, now our international corporate mafia, is taking control of the world, assisted by our politicians, especially by the "conservative" kind.

    Ed Deak.

    http://www.commondreams.org/view/2012/02/06-0?print

  • John Corman

    1 year ago

    Skywalker

    You stated:
    "I won't mention that all of the claims that you repeat have been revisited and found to be other than what was portrayed by the media"

    Is there something I've stated above that is not true or exaggerated. Rafe's not going to didispute what I've written because he's made the same claims.
    You have to always keep in mind that the NDP's pool of experienced talent is very shallow. So, you end up with Attorney Generals swearing to false affidavits and Premier's staff forging documents (A Dix)

    The list goes on and on and you can confirm them all with Rafe.

    I'm a little disappointed with my favourite broadcaster that he referred to our Premier as an "airhead".
    There were numerous NDP idiots in control in the nineties and, not once did Rafe ever refer to a male clown in government as an "airhead". Something he reserves for attractive females, it appears.

  • Granville

    1 year ago

    The NDP should borrow from a British Labour Party slogan

    "Ditch the Bitch!"

    It was an anti-Thatcher line. Christy is OK with me, but her policies and her entire party suck.

  • igbymac

    1 year ago

    Ed Deak

    I don't think you and I are so far apart in our world views, Ed, the differences being mostly nuance. I do sometimes wonder about a few of your views which have not been made clear to me in your posts.

    A couple which come to my mind are how you rationalize capitalism being less brutal than communism, and how you see a better world ahead while retaining capitalism? I have my own opinions, but I'd like to hear yours.

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    Sorry Igby, but when did I

    Sorry Igby, but when did I say that capitalism was less brutal than communism ?

    As I wrote several times in the past, it took 2 world wars and the death camps of Stalin, Hitler and Mao some 70 years to kill about 120 million. Capitalism is accomplishing it in 4-5 years with starvation, bad waters and easily preventable illnesses.

    The only difference is that the criminals of capitalism are doing it in more refined fashion, away from the eyes of the "developed" world, also their long term plans are working over here very effectively.

    I hate all dictatorial systems and ruling classes, and have been fighting against them all my adult life, having had enough experience with them on the "other side".

    Ed Deak.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    Corman

    As I stated all that was revealed answered, and "paid". What you have not commented on is, how does it all compare to the sleeze that had permeated every operation under the Liberals? Rafe makes that very clear now that he has the Liberals actions to compare. It really makes no sense to worry about what he might have said more than ten years ago. You are simply trying to live in the NDP past while forgetting the BC Liberals now have a longer past. All of Rafe's comments are dead on.

  • igbymac

    1 year ago

    Ed Deak

    Thanks for that clarification.

    I am aware of your remark regarding the number of deaths over time under the respective regimes. But I also read recently where you said 'the capitalist propaganda was more refined and less brutal than the communist propaganda'. I conflated the two in my mind, perhaps erroneously.

    So how is one form of propaganda more or less brutal than another?

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    The purpose of propaganda is

    The purpose of propaganda is brainwash, one way or another. And people believe it, because they want to believe, as they have believed and sacrificed their lives for lies, for thousands of years.

    Whenever anybody starts selling "freedom", look out. One of the worst misused words in any language, because it usually means enslavement by some ruling sector.

    Like "free enterprise". I'm a dedicated private enterpriser, but know that all forms of enterprise are controlled by many factors, to prevent them becoming enslavement and crimes, as we have now.

    The communists used bayonets, the capitalists the perceived power of non existing, imaginary money.

    The communists pretended that everything is owned by the public, while the public was deprived from owning anything and the power of ownership/control, was concentrated in the hands of an ideologically empowered ruling class.

    Their slogan was "internationalization", "workers of the world unite", now we have "globalization". The same racket under another name. And all for enslavement.

    Now we also have "free enterprise", used by the same ruling class, under a different coloured flag, to take over ownership and control of the world.

    Like Henry Kissinger said it many years ago: "Control oil and you control nations; control food and you control people." The world's food supply is now controlled by a handful of corporations, in the name of "competitive free enterprise", "economic efficiency" , " specialization", "globalization".

    http://www.schillerinstitute.org/food_for_peace/kiss_nssm_jb_1995.html

    http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=389x2578928

    In the communist system of "democracy", everybody was forced to vote, by law, but only for one party.

    In the capitalist system we have all kinds of parties, but the elected government is a dictatorship, as we can see it every day. The Opposition is powerless shouters and arm wavers.

    At the same time, the real governments are the banks and the multinational corporate mafia, who pull the strings of the puppet governments and giving orders.

    As I wrote before, the rulers will most likely permit the NDP to win the next BC elections, that will give them the opportunity to take over the BCLibs and then wreck the economy for total control,to force people to beg for their dictatorship, kin the name of "economic efficiency" and " jobs, jobs, jobs".

    Ed Deak.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    You are right Ed.

    Governments come and go but corporations just accumulate wealth. With that wealth comes power that dwarfs governments.

  • Fiat lux

    1 year ago

    Wealth and power are the

    Wealth and power are the temporary control of energy, can not "created", but taken, usually with arms, or installed "faith" in the rights of the takers.

    When people will realize that they're stolen blind by always the same predators, under different flags, the world may just become a democracy.

    Today's boards of directors of the corporate mafia used to be the politbureaus under the communists, stealing people blind under both systems.

    The more things change, the more they remain the same, until people start asking questions and tell any would be rulers to go and screw themselves.

    What, I believe, democracy is supposed to be about.

    Ed Deak.

  • igbymac

    1 year ago

    Ed Deak

    This is getting semantic now, but I think it is important to clarify.

    If we can begin by agreeing that capitalist propaganda has replaced the communist bayonets as the principle means of persuasion over people, then either propaganda includes force (bayonets), or propaganda is some besides force.

    If all means of communication are forms of propaganda, and knowing that the capitalist regimes have caused far more suffering and deaths than the communist ones, it stands to reason that capitalist propaganda is more brutal. [I say this as I doubt there is any brutal act so severe under communism that it has not at least been matched by capitalism.]

    Alternatively, if it is the later, we return to my original question: "how is one form of propaganda more or less brutal than another?"

  • igbymac

    1 year ago

    Skywalker

    Corporations are a relatively new means of centralizing wealth compared to banking. As such corporations are a contemporary and useful tool of the banking industry.

    Yes, we live in a corporatocracy with the state-corporate merger, but behind that is the plutocracy. This is the root system of our governance. And if we are going to effect permanent change, we cannot carry on oblivious to reality thinking we only need to prune the tree. We must cut the root system clean out and grow again.

    Ultimately, this must be our goal, and we must keep our eye on it while we go about doing what we can to effect such an event. Like the adage -- act local, think global.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.