Hard Questions for Christy Clark
If she runs for Lib leader, she'll face tough queries about Railgate and the HST.
Clark: Other side of the microphone could be rough.
"Don't be fooled -- Christy Clark doesn't want to be mayor of Vancouver -- she wants to be premier of B.C." -- Bill Tieleman, 24 hours, Sept. 20, 2005
Christy Clark would be highly questionable as British Columbia's next premier.
And while as a talk radio host Clark may be adept at asking tough questions, answering them as a BC Liberal Party leadership candidate is much more difficult -- and perhaps politically fatal.
Clark claims she will "think very hard" about running for the nomination on her week off from radio station CKNW AM 980 duties as the afternoon talk show host.
But the only likely reason she wouldn't jump into the race is if contenders like George Abbott and Kevin Falcon have already sewn up too much of the BC Liberal caucus support and business community money needed to win.
If she does run, those asking the questions won't be as easy to cut off as a belligerent caller to her show.
And Clark's past political history will come back to haunt her along with four years of on-air commentary on a wide range of issues and her losing attempt to win the Non-Partisan Association's mayoralty nomination against Sam Sullivan in 2005.
Railgate and Bruce Clark
Start with questions about her role in the B.C. legislature raid case, involving the $1 billion privatization of BC Rail to CN Rail in 2003.
For example, Christy, what is your position on holding a full public inquiry into the strange circumstances that saw the political corruption trial of former BC Liberal ministerial aides David Basi and Bob Virk suddenly halted by a guilty plea bargain?
Were you going to be a witness in that trial? Do you agree with the government paying Basi and Virk's $6 million legal fees?
Oh wait, it doesn't matter, because as premier, Clark would have to excuse herself from any cabinet discussion about an inquiry.
Why? How long have you got?
At the same time police conducted the unprecedented raid of the B.C. legislature, they also executed a search warrant on the home of Bruce Clark, Christy's brother and a one-time fundraiser for her campaigns.
According to an agreed statement of facts from the Crown and defence at the surprise end of the trial, confidential government information obtained from Basi and Virk was found by police at Bruce Clark's home and office.
Clark was a lobbyist working for the Washington Marine Group, which was a bidder on a second part of the BC Rail privatization, the sale of its Roberts Bank Port Subdivision, a spur line worth up to $70 million.
The RCMP advised then transportation minister Falcon to cancel the sale because it was "tainted" by the leak of confidential documents. Bruce Clark was never charged with any offences.
The statement of facts reads: "With respect to Count 10 of the Indictment and in relation to the Port Subdivision bidding process, the RCMP seized a number of documents from Bruce Clark's office and residence, which Basi and Virk disclosed to Bruce Clark between Jan. 1, 2003 and Dec. 28, 2003."
"Two examples of the documents that Basi and Virk improperly disclosed to Clark are:
"a) The draft Request for Proposals for the Port Subdivision bidding process, which was received by Clark prior to the RFP being finalized by the Evaluation Committee; and
"b) A 'confidential presentation' made by TD Securities to the Evaluation Committee dated Oct. 14, 2003 containing a detailed economic analysis of what BC Rail considered to be the value of the Port Subdivision."
Would she have been a witness?
But that's just the tip of the Basi-Virk iceberg when it comes to Christy Clark's conundrum.
Clark was deputy premier to Premier Gordon Campbell throughout the BC Rail privatization and was a highly probable potential witness in the trial.
She and ex-husband Mark Marissen, a key federal organizer for ex-Liberal prime minister Paul Martin and former leader Stephane Dion, had a home visit from the police after the raid. The police were looking for information about Basi and Virk and Marissen has made clear he cooperated fully -- there was no search warrant.
Defence lawyers alleged in Basi-Virk pre-trial court hearings that Clark may have been a cabinet source of information for Pilothouse Public Affairs, the lobbying firm run by Erik Bornmann and Brian Kieran that was retained by BC Rail bidder OmniTRAX.
Both Bornmann and Kieran became Crown witnesses and were not charged with anything, despite admitting to police they provided money and other benefits to Basi and Virk in exchange for confidential government BC Rail privatization information.
"Pilothouse internal briefing notes appear to reveal sources in cabinet. Bornmann clearly had certain cabinet sources," Basi's lawyer Michael Bolton told Justice Elizabeth Bennett, the former Basi-Virk case judge, on June 4, 2009. "For example, Christy Clark may have been the source within cabinet -- certainly Mr. Bornmann was in contact with Ms. Clark," Bolton alleged.
Bolton's allegations are just that -- they were never proven nor tested in court, since the trial ended long before any witnesses could be cross-examined or evidence introduced.
But Bornmann's long connections as an executive of the federal Liberal Party of Canada's B.C. branch, including strong links to fellow executive member Bruce Clark, are well documented, as are his connections to the BC Liberal Party and role as a provincial lobbyist.
And then on July 20, 2009, justice Elizabeth Bennett, the former Basi-Virk case judge, ruled that emails between Pilothouse lobbyists and Christy Clark were "likely relevant" and must be disclosed to the defence.
"The Crown concedes that any email communication between the lobbyists and Christy Clark, Richard Neufeld, Gary Collins, Judith Reid and Paul Taylor are likely relevant," she noted in her decision.
"Ms. Clark was the deputy minister and may have expressed concern over the CN Rail dealing at a cabinet meeting. Further, there is some evidence that indicates that she may have had some dealings with Pilothouse. Emails of Ms. Clark relating to the divestiture of BC Rail and the sale of the Roberts Bank, as well as any contact with Pilothouse, are likely relevant," Bennett’s disclosure ruling continued.
All of this may have been an impetus for Clark to lawyer-up for the first time in the lengthy pre-trial hearings, retaining John Esson to represent her in court starting in Aug. 2009.
Media manipulations
Then there's the so-far unconfirmed rumour that Mike McDonald, the former BC Liberal caucus communications director, will be Clark's campaign manager. McDonald, now a consultant, appears regularly on Clark's show and is husband to Jessica McDonald, Campbell's former senior deputy minister.
But McDonald also has his own connections to the Basi-Virk case.
Again, according to unproven allegations made by defence lawyers in pre-trial hearings, McDonald was involved in supervising Basi's stacking of paid phony callers to radio talk shows, ironically including CKNW.
Virk's lawyer Kevin McCullough on April 23, 2007 read from what he told the court was a police transcript of a call between Basi and McDonald. "'Dave's asking Mike if he wants to make some calls to CKNW after the MLA is on,'" McCullough alleged. Justice Bennett interjected: "Is this a Liberal MLA? " McCullough: "Yes." Bennett responded, to laughter in the court: "I should have known that."
At another point McCullough alleges that McDonald and Basi discussed how Basi would organize calls to attack former B.C. premier Bill Vander Zalm during a radio appearance.
"Dave says they are going to give Vander Zalm a rough ride. [Mike] tells Dave to be careful, they don't want the phone numbers showing up from [government lines in] Victoria. Dave replies, 'Star 67, man,'" McCullough read from what he said was a police wiretap summary. (Star 67 refers to a caller identification blocking option.)
And there's much, much more to the tangled web of the Basi-Virk case that no doubt Clark would prefer was left undisturbed.
But with the trial concluded, there is no restriction on the media or others asking questions.
She's a fan of the HST
Plus, there are more unexploded bombs in Clark's recent past -- such as her steadfast defence of the despised Harmonized Sales Tax and her support for the overwhelmingly rejected Single Transferable Vote in 2009.
So if Clark finally admits she wants to be premier, expect her opponents both in and out of the BC Liberal Party to turn her candidacy into a walk in the hurt locker. ![]()




70
Login or register to post comments
realisticman
1 year ago
Someone's Scared...
You'd better not run Christy because Bill says so. He loves fighting old battles and he's starting these with you before you've even declared! I guess you saw that Globe poll. I'd say that poll just about sums it up.
pianosaurus rex
1 year ago
the past
Geez old battles; how many times have I had to listen to the fast ferry deal in the last 10 years, or Clarks sundeck…who is it that drags out the dirty laundry. Could it be both sides? This is the kind of playground politics that the general public find repellent in their lives.
Most of B C is just waiting for one of the current cabinet members or a previous cabinet member to tie themselves to the whipping post. I don’t think the name is going to matter too much.
Got my cat of nine tails ready for any one of them.
sunshine coast girl
1 year ago
What a hypocrite the woman is....
Nearly as many people signed the petition as voted for the Lieberals and she called us "Taliban". Now she wants us to vote for her in a general election? And she hates everyone and everything and doesn't mind telling anyone who will listen. Watch for the lists to start popping up if she does decide to run. Sheesh! The woman has nerve, I'll give her that.
Camero409
1 year ago
realisticman
realisticman, those points Bill brings up are not old battles except to you and the rest of the PAB's in the LIbERal government. This corrupt and illegal sale of BC Rail is being copied throughout this Government. Now we have the NRO being the latest example of expediting the sale of public assests.
It's important to shine the light EDITED FOR LEGAL CONCERNS -- TYEE MODERATOR so we can see the MO this corrpt government uses, for everyone to see. Keep up the GREAT work Mr. Tieleman. You and others like BC Mary, Leila Yuilie are the true "news" reporters in this province. I know Baldry, Vaughn and Smyth will never hold SCampbell's and his ilks feet to the fire.
Fiat lux
1 year ago
Christy would be, and is,
Christy would be, and is, another Stevie Harper in female form. They could be twins by looks alone. The same predator eyes.
Ed Deak.
jim1966
1 year ago
Not With My Vote
None of them deserve a single vote from any of us. They all endorse and or support the HST. The BC Liberals are finished (with these guys running), The lies, corruption and arrogance are still within this group of politicians. They still don't see the core issues that face British Columbians each and every single day, like, the minimum wage issue, schools closing, the unacceptable levels of both poverty and homelessness, high taxes and fees not to mention the complete and utter destruction of other key ministries in BC. The last 10 years should be remnamed Campbellgate and nothing more. And Christy Clark as leader?, Like duh......
alive
1 year ago
six of one ....
Too bad that the wikileaks does not include the activities of the BC government during the Gordo period!
Christy as a leader? she is as tainted as the other candidates, so what is the difference?
rick up north
1 year ago
Nice to have you back Bill.
Nice to have you back Bill. I don't know who you had writing your column for you while you were away, but I didn't like the guy.
Skywalker
1 year ago
Someone is scared. It's R/man
You can always trust a liberal to tell that you are "living in the past" whenever you question their record. R/man's first post is a classic. They simply run from their record but that is not a practice permitted for the NDP. Well Bill puts it plain and simply. Run Christy by all means and if the liberals choose you, there are a whole lot of questions you will have to answer without your finger on the mute button. Watching Christy bluster and obfuscate will be the entertainment of the day.
gomer
1 year ago
"But the only likely reason
"But the only likely reason she wouldn't jump into the race is if contenders like George Abbott and Kevin Falcon have already sewn up too much of the BC Liberal caucus support and business community money needed to win"
Howe Street/Fraser Institute will decide who is the most capable of hiding the truth and continuing the sell out.
deeby
1 year ago
Christy's always been a game-player....
....she loves the game itself, as much as governance, going right back to her Young Liberal days.
Game players make enemies, especially when they end careers. Better hope those boxes of Railgate emails, memos and briefing notes are being well cared for.
seth
1 year ago
F a Fascist campaign
One of these individuals is going to be premier and have their way with us for almost 4 more years. Which is the best of a bad lot? At this point it looks like Abbot, then Clark? Do we really want to see what damage fascists like Falcon and Coleman can do in four years?
BCHydro is on the ropes now with your rates set to double. Look at the destruction fascist leader Mike Harris did to Ontario Hydro. There is at least faint hope that centre wing of the party Abbot or Clark would at least slow the rate of destruction down?
Recall is doomed to fail because the stupidest people in province run the NDP and refuse to disgorge the worst, dumbest most egotistical leader in party history. Few will vote for recall when the Harridan is the alternative.
Nope, if you love your province and country, if you are a patriot, you must hold your nose and buy a BCLiberal party membership now.
If we all did this, we could stop the odious fascists like Falcon, Polak, and Coleman from retaining control of the province.
At least for the next three and half years, there would be a lot less suffering under an Abbot,Stilwell or Clark. The sale of BC to foreign corporate interests and the destruction of our environment might end or at least slow down. BCRail is gone but the current well under way campaign to sell off BCHydro to stockbroker pals of the corrupt Canwest/Gordo team might be halted in mid stream.
After the least odious leadership team is elected you can resign your membership and get back to straightening out the NDP or Green party or stay and supervise as is your preference.
The Fuck a Fascist campaign starts now.
puppyg
1 year ago
Please, no.
Please, no.
LeftRightLeft
1 year ago
I was with Bill right up until...
The article was great right up until the end, and then Bill had to go and drop the STV bomb. Let's run a straw poll here and see how many people think Bill's cheerleading against electoral reform and in favour of propping up our beleaguered two-party "electoral dictatorship" is more popular than Christy Clark's support for the more representative and democratic STV system. Leads me to think that that she's more capable of getting past the knee-jerk partisanship all too endemic on both sides of the aisle.
With all due respect, Mr. Tieleman, methinks you should leave that one alone on your Liberal head-hunting exercises. Supporting open and fair dialogue on electoral system is one of the few things the Liberals can be proud of in the past 10 years.
DPL
1 year ago
So the hot line gal is
So the hot line gal is possibly coming in to replace her old Boss Gordo. You know the one, who she agreed with for so long. The Liberal stew is a pretty bad lot. None are worth considering as a leader of anything. My God, this gang would make Dumbo the clown look like a real leader
My Opinion
1 year ago
Heaven forbids Christy Clark
Heaven forbids Christy Clark runs. She is way too close to the Basi/Virk affair, which in my opinion is the worst scandal of the B.C. Liberals (that we know of anyway). There's a reason why she quit politics suddenly. It wasn't to look after her son. Stay where you are Christy. At least you can insult your callers without fear of reprisal. And I'm not a rabid NDPer, I'm a disappointed Liberal.
G West
1 year ago
Think very hard!
What the hell does THAT mean?
If Ms Clark actually 'thinks' deeply about anything it will be the first time.
Stick with your CKNW 'family' Christy - that's the kind of echo chamber you love.
Stay out of politics for Hamish's sake.
What a phony.
As for your proscription about the past r/man - I've saved THAT little gem for future use - people who live in glass houses and all that.
warbler
1 year ago
Carole vs. Christy (dream for libs, nightmare for NDP)
As much it pains me to agree with realisticman, this article does come off as a defencive, NPD preemptive strike by Tieleman.
What you're going to read in this comments section is a lot of preaching to the converted, but outside of this forum the truth is that the NDP brass fear and loathe a Carole vs Christy match up because they know Clark would wipe the floor with James in addition to stealing the centrist liberal and female votes.
I wonder why the Young Liberals of BC were so quick to endorse Abbott before the full field of candidates were revealed. I would think that if Christy throws her hat in the ring, she'd have the youth vote locked up. I think she would be much more appealing to the youth, with all her pink shirt days under her pant-suit belt.
Otherwise, Tieleman's strategy is a good one: dissuade Clark from running. After that, start writing articles on how tolerable and respectable Kevin Falcon actually is, then pray like hell he wins so that the NDP's albatross, Carole James, has a fighting chance.
G West
1 year ago
Carole James will do just fine
Against Christy Clark - the only idiots who say otherwise are the people in the CKNW echo chamber - and they haven't done anything but drink their own BC Liberal bathwater for years.
In fact, CKNW doesn't even lead CBC Vancouver The 2009 Winter radio ratings showed that Canada's public broadcaster, the CBC, has emerged as the top-rated radio station in the market, besting long-time market leader CKNW by almost a full percentage point.
Just a few years ago CBC Radio One scored a paltry 5 percentage points, behind eight other stations. CBC Vancouver is number one and CKNW is basically an also-ran.
As for Tieleman firing preemptive shots for the NDP - I don't think that has much credence in the current political climate on the left either.
The NDP are, very wisely, going to keep on letting the Campbell liberals continue to shred themselves in public and there's no one better at being a shrill fishwife than Christy Clark - bring her on by all means.
Skywalker
1 year ago
Warbler and R/man dreaming.
I say let her run and I hope she wins. I for one will be happy to see Christy answer to all the old Liberal baggage she has so far dodged. Talk shows are a real phoney insulated forum. Once she's out there it will be like her race for the Vancouver mayoralty. She couldn't cut it there and she will put her foot in her mouth more often than Bill Vander Zalm ever did. Run Christy! We want you exposed.
Van Isle
1 year ago
Whenever I'm in a bit of a
Whenever I'm in a bit of a funk I'll tune into CKNW and listen to some of the spue from either Bill G. or Christy. Either one has a great knack at getting me all pissed-off on whatever topic they're on about. Before you know it my heart rate has shot up, steam starts venting out of my ears, I start yelling and cursing back at the radio, spittle is trickling down my chin, and my wife's yelling at me "to calm down". But what really pisses me off is that I know that these bone heads have loyal and true followers who think the sun rises and sets on them.
Cool Hand
1 year ago
Likely Scenario - How Things Will Play Out
1. Campbell steps down and opinion polls (Mustel) already show a rebound in Liberal support with Campbell taking his negatives with him;
2. We are on the eve of the leadership campaign, which will further change and enhance that dynamic when, with the MSM, it will be all Liberal leadership all the time;
3. Right now, an 800 sample size Gandolf opinion poll already shows that the leading contenders are tied with the NDP. With Christy Clark at the helm the current decided vote shows the Libs ahead of the NDP by a 12% margin as follows:
Lib: 43%
NDP: 31%
Green: 19%
Other/Ind.: 7%
4. Carole James's personal approval numbers are plummeting and will probably continue to do so;
5. The NDP caucus might even potentially implode/ break-up resulting in NDP freefall;
6. We'll probably see at least another 5 opinion polls before the Liberal leadership vote next spring;
7. Liberal voting delegates will likely vote for the candidate who will best be able to defeat the NDP based upon these opinion polls; Christy probably will remain ahead;
8. If Christy is crowned, the media will fawn all over her like a movie star akin to the crowning of Vander Zalm in '86 and Clark in '96;
9. The Liberal political momentum will be akin to a speeding freight train that could potentially leave the NDP in the dust;
10. More opinion polls thereafter will likely show the Liberals ahead of the NDP in the 50% - 35% range;
11. The legislature will be reconvened to move up the date of the election from May 12, 2013 to May 12, 2011 in order for the new Premier to seek a new mandate from the people; (again Vander Zalm and Clark)
12. The budget will also include a decrease in the HST rate from 12% to either 11% or 10% (mechanics of that to be worked out);
13. The Liberals win a landslide victory and Carole James will resign (if she hasn't already done so beforehand should the NDP caucus implode);
And life in BC will continue on as usual. :D
Skywalker
1 year ago
Cool Hand.
Your political analysis, which you always give when it suits your purpose which is determined by the PAB, is worth exactly what the Tyee paid for it. It's all pipe dreams.
G West
1 year ago
Lukie
Time to switch the dial - You're playing nothing but static.
dr evil
1 year ago
bottled up
I recently saw a fluff piece in one of the Vancouver tabloids asking certain B.C. celebrities their preferences in T.V. viewing.
Christy Clark mentioned how much she enjoyed "Spike T.V." and especially liked an episode where men would fart into bottles and then cork them..later opening the bottles to sense how much "oomph" remained with the contents.
She`d make a great premier for B.C. Really..Jackass press is gonna love her!
Perrrfect.
Golf courses...mining..tourism. real estate.... fishfarms and bottled farts..and absolutely NO bullying!
Oh B.C. ...B.C. what ever have you become.
pianosaurus rex
1 year ago
bedside reading table
Not to worry about Cool Hand; most likely he reads a few chapters of his favourite story before nodding off to sleep.
Oh right, the story??
That would be King Lear……
G West
1 year ago
Gandalf
You're now quoting US pay by the call phone polling companies.
Even those figures show Clark has little or no room for growth and that the NDP support is incredibly solid.
You might also take note that the 800 sample size is not consistent over all the responses - a sure sign that this bunch is into push polling and not real statistical analysis.
The total of 'certain Liberal voters' is actually less than one quarter of the sample polled by 'interactive' phone polling.
You know what most sane individuals do when they get a robocall from these Gandalf trolls, they hang up!
deeby
1 year ago
Give it up Luke....
EDITED FOR LEGAL CONCERNS -- MODERATOR
Sooner or later the temptation to take her down is going to overcome someone from her side of the fence. She's spent too much time pontificating and gloating from the sidelines while others do the heavy political lifting. Time to pay some dues....
shepsil
1 year ago
G West got it right. BCNDP support still high.
Fundraising for BCNDP with members and supporters over last year has gotten over 80% support for Carole James. Which is the same as the vote of support received at Prov. Council last weekend.
BC Liberals are desperately trying to stir the BCNDP pot.
editingfool
1 year ago
yoo hoo, realistic man...
you are not being very realistic mister realistic man.
it is not an, 'old battle,' until a victor has been declared.
the battle rages on. my money is on tieleman. this clark is lugging way too much baggage. besides, we don't need no stinkin' polls.
some liberals seem to think because they have gotten away with murder for so long, that their good luck will continue.
i know what you are thinking christie, did they fire six shots or only five? go ahead make our day.
happy
1 year ago
The libs?
I would venture it's the Gang of 13 who are stirring the pot, wouldn't you?
realisticman
1 year ago
Top Radio
We don't know where Westie obtains his radio station rankings but the standard is and always has been the BBM. The numbers are all here:
http://www.bbm.ca/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=88&Itemid=71
Latest, July 26, 2010 - October 24, 2010:
Monday - Sunday 2am-2am.
CBU (CBC Radio 1) Share 8.9%
CKNW Share 11.4
CKNW has the highest market-share number in the list of 19 stations.
If you don't like Gandalf perhaps you like the Globe and Mail. You like the CBC and Stephen Quinn, he also writes for the Globe. The Globe poll shows Christy Clark at 68% by far today's favourite, followed by George Abbott at 11%.
Not scientific but 3,600 interested people have voted.
As 'warbler' astutely points out above, Bill's attack does come across as a preemptive strike that comes across as a bit desperate. We shall see. It will be interesting.
Skywalker
1 year ago
The MSM and those who believe.
I always find these folks who quote various MSM organs as a bit naive. The media usually never investigate, they regurgitate. It is cheaper and they don't have to pay journalists. So a figure quoted by one organ just gets passed along as fact without anyone ever seriously checking the methodology used. It makes you wonder if it is by accident or whether they just like the result and want to manipulate the readers. I think it is the latter and it's why I never read any of the rags I mean really what would an eastern corporate rag know about B.C.
Also please don't tell me the CBC is much better. The CBC has not done any serious investigative reporting at the provincial levels for years. Most of their programing is useless fluff and when they have a story that might be relevant they ask silly questions a fool could answer. Most of the time it turns out to be a repeat of what is carried on the other networks.
archer2006
1 year ago
Basi Virk and Clark
Having seen some of the emails, I'd say bring her on.
Ricky
1 year ago
Good Times
I can't wait to see her as leader: I'll have a full tape of her quotes, in her voice, off her radio show, supporting the HST and deriding the initiative against, every single time I go out to campaign against her. I mean, written quotes are always suspect, but when you have her voice, and sometimes video, there's no denying it.
Thanks Christy, you twonk!
reallife
1 year ago
No wonder people are
No wonder people are reluctant to run for office in BC. Clark has not even declared and already the smear campaign has started - this article has lots of innuendoes but does not contain one proven allegation (shame).
BTW, the Liberals will get creamed in the next election if they pick Falcon as a leader and will lose (but not quite so badly) if they chose DeJong, Stillwell or Abbott. They may have a chance to win if they pick Clark simply because she appears so much more dynamic than the NDP leader.
steamdonkey
1 year ago
Shill
Many folk think this gal is smart but whenever I heard her speak all I heard was the party line, no personality, no analysis, no insight, nothing original. . Smart, OK, but a shill.
Fiat lux
1 year ago
What "smear campaign" ?
What "smear campaign" ? She's well known and has a well known record which should be disclosed if she wants to run for the top office.
Ed Deak.
alive
1 year ago
Christy Palin
Why should we not have a Sarah Palin here in BC?
Cool Hand
1 year ago
alive
We already do! Carole James usurped that moniker along time ago.
Let's see what the latest "Gang of 13" has to say today. NDP MLA Lana Popham on Carole James:
"Lana Popham says the current B.C. NDP leader is sending “a bad message” to the province about how her party would do business as a government."
"Popham cited the “same-old, same-old” politics that led to the October expulsion of MLA Bob Simpson, who had been critical of James."
http://www.bclocalnews.com/vancouver_island_south/saanichnews/news/111076904.html
With internal NDP caucus friends like these, who needs political enemies?
For a better world
1 year ago
Where there is smoke
Where there is smoke there is fire!
If Crusty Clark runs for the leadership of the BC Liberals, any criticism of her past actions or non-actions should be aggressively addressed by main steam media. Her past behaviour is not innuendo, but will MSM challenge her? Not likely, because she is now part of the incumbent brotherhood.
As "The Mouth that Roared", Clark still carries a lot of baggage from her roles during Campbell's first term.
Skywalker
1 year ago
Cool Hand
You really have to stop grasping at straws. Sarah Palin more closely resembles Christy. All the characteristics are there, a big mouth, opinionated but without much thought, shrill, a know-it-all without justification and she cooks up her own facts. Her only claim to fame is that she is one of the IN crowd and that is how she got the present job. They needed a mouth piece besides Bill Boring. Now if she gets the nomination it will be between a person involved in the Sale of BC Rail and all the crap that went with that and a nice lady by all accounts who does not shoot off her mouth just to hear herself think out loud. It may even be that there will be another leader for the NDP and it is a whole new scenario where honesty will triumph over Liberal sleaze.
Dream on my friend. First it was Taylor, then Watts, then Clark and on and on they are all Campbell liberals who sat with him and did squat but his bidding.
Skywalker
1 year ago
For the rest
Isn't it interesting that every Liberal who wants Campbell's job admits that the HST was "poorly introduced and poorly explained". Not a single one will admit that shifting costs from business to consumers was part of the strategy and that it is what folks are made about. There was no reduction in costs, it was not revenue neutral and it was a lie. Not one will go that far and that means they are all part of the same evil lot; all part of the lie. It is all about the end justifying the means for them.
Ida Chong in the Saanich news admits they had a massive hole in their budget after the election. That is the hole everyone said was there but the Campbell Liberals ridiculed the suggestion. This for her is justification for introducing the HST? It is pathetic from her and all the rest and the apologists who post here and make excuses for them
These clowns just don't get it and nothing short aof a real drubbing in recall or at the subsequent polls will restore any integrity to the political process in BC.
RickW
1 year ago
Cool Hand
Lana Popham is tired and won't be running come the next election.......
Camero409
1 year ago
Cool Hand and r/man
I believe Christy can see Russia from her bedroom!
CanadianLatitude
1 year ago
Does this matter? The next
Does this matter? The next election is already over and the only question is is if that Ms. James will step down or try a 4th time....
realisticman
1 year ago
Hard Questions for ...
Politics is such an appealing and rewarding profession.
G West says above that, "Carole James will do just fine - Against Christy Clark - the only idiots who say otherwise are the people in the CKNW echo chamber - "
Actually Westie there are one or maybe more others who would like to speak. You can call them idiots.
Here's a juicy quote:
"Hearing Carole James declare that the challenge to her leadership is over – because the NDP’s Provincial Council backed her – reminds me of George Bush on the US air craft (sic) carrier with the huge “Mission Accomplished” sign behind him after the initial attack in Iraq.
Talk about not getting it.
The NDP is now on suicide watch as James and Moe Sihota with James’ staff (eager to keep their jobs) egging her on, try to silence principled people in the party who know there has to be a change.
Those in the party who want a leadership review or a leadership convention point out that James’ leadership is severely lacking what it takes to win the next election. Who on earth could actually refute this sentiment? Of course she’s inadequate. "
Was this from someone inside the CKNW, so called echo chamber? No, but it did come that nasty Main Stream Media we suffer with.
By Murray Dobbin 26 Nov 2010
Vancouver Sun Community of Interest.
If Christy were to run don't expect this type of a ferocious attack on her from someone on her own side.
Seems as though the rallying cry is, "United We Can't"
G West
1 year ago
Hmmm?
Generally I like Murray - But I don't think he's main stream media - in fact far from it.
The NDP have their problems, no question, but having trouble beating Christy Clark isn't likely to be one of them.
The Vancouver Sun and the Province - on the other hand - are pretty much in the same echo chamber - like that stupid quote from Michael Smythe.
I spent some time yesterday with a member of the provincial council and it pretty much confirmed my interpretation of things.
By the way, you clearly haven't been paying attention either because I'm no fan of Moe Sihota's.
Cool Hand
1 year ago
Another Day - Another NDP MLA
Yesterday it was MLA Lana Popham.
The day before it was MLA Harry Lali.
Days before that it was MLA Mike Sather.
And before that MLA Bob Simpson and MLA Norm Macdonald.
What do they all have in common? They are all garnering front-page headlines in their local papers lambasting Carole James.
And today's lucky MLA is ... MLA Robin Austin.
"SKEENA NDP MLA Robin Austin wants a leadership convention, saying Carole James has failed translate her vision into policies for British Columbians."
"James’ leadership has been brought up before with comments coming from door knocking during elections, in the grocery stores, and emails from members."
"They would love to give Robin their vote but until Carole James was gone they would not vote for him because they don’t feel that British Columbians were connected to her"
http://www.bclocalnews.com/bc_north/terracestandard/news/111019804.html
Do these guys all have a death wish for the NDP? Perhaps a crash course in Politics 101 is in order.
Skywalker
1 year ago
Cool Hand
You are still blowing smoke. Carol will be gone soon. Then what will your slogan be? Campbell in 2013?
G West
1 year ago
Skywalker
The other thing my conversation yesterday confirmed is that most of the sparks being generated by the alleged problems in the NDP are the result of BC Liberal clones banging their heads together.
Luke and the r/man are just more examples of this...
They're the people with the death wish for the NDP.
Party supporters and honest hardworking people who've seen their situation worsen since 2001 - and that means most British Columbians - need to keep in mind that BC Liberals don't give a shit about anything but themselves and their own narrow propagandistic interests.
The NDP record is head and shoulders better than the BC Liberal record - in the long run that's what needs to be underlined.
Ignoring people like Lukie and the R/Man isn't all that difficult to do - just tune out their static - the reason they're here is not to do good.
freebear
1 year ago
The more Charlatans running the better...
The more likely they will divide the Fiberals!
Skywalker
1 year ago
GWest
party supporters, what is left of them these days, are not listening to the rest of the NDP universe. Just like the liberals were not listening and only started to listen when Campbell's popularity got to 6%. I think what is left of the NDP, that is the NNDP, had better start listening to what others are saying including those who are disenchanted.
I do not accept some of the polling around Campbell liberals candidates. These results are skewed for self serving reasons. None of these people listened for 9 years and they will only pretend to listen now. Not till the public gets their attention by booting their collective arses out will they ever change. That task is made much much more difficult by the insistence of the NNDP "Inner circle" to control all things in the party including free discussion.
I noticed the trend back in 2003 and it has not changed.
Cool Hand
1 year ago
NDP Caucus Collapse Today?
Gotta hand it to Carole and Moe!
This makes the Lib leadership race a dull and boring event in comparison.
"BC NDP Dissidents To Make Major Announcement In The Next Hour?
December 1st, 2010
I am hearing that a bunch are going to go independent en masse, but that has yet to be confirmed. Whatever the message is going to be, the people ready to deliver it seem elated.
Developing…"
http://civicscene.ca/bc-ndp-dissidents-to-make-major-announcement-in-the-next-hour
realisticman
1 year ago
G West
"I spent some time yesterday with a member of the provincial council and it pretty much confirmed my interpretation of things.
"The other thing my conversation yesterday confirmed is that most of the sparks being generated by the alleged problems in the NDP are the result of BC Liberal clones banging their heads together.
"Carole James will do just fine"
We are sure that you are, as usual, completely correct. Especially because you have this 'special' access and they told you everything.
Cool Hand
1 year ago
Breaking News
From Twitter/CKNW
"MLA Jenny Kwan has released a statement saying "there has been a steady erosion of our democratic principles under James leadership"
Developing...
Cool Hand
1 year ago
Jenny Kwan Statement - Incredible!
The NDP bloodbath has just begun.
Jenny Kwan, senior NDP caucus member who also nominated James at her leadership convention, just issued this statement:
MLA Jenny Kwan says NDP Leader Carole James has to go
http://www.straight.com/article-362145/vancouver/mla-jenny-kwan-says-ndp-leader-carole-james-has-go
Skywalker
1 year ago
Cool Hand.
You may as well gloat now while you can. It will be a short gloat.
puppyg
1 year ago
Crusty to leave showbiz? Say
Crusty to leave showbiz? Say it isn't so... greatest entertainer ever!
realisticman
1 year ago
G West
We have Jenny Kwan's email address if you need it to tell her that "Carole James will do just fine".
realisticman
1 year ago
With all due respect...
Might I humbly suggest a mud-wrestling match, perhaps a tournament, to both capture the public's attention and to clear the air.
happy
1 year ago
So if Carole steps down
does that mean ONLY female applicants may apply for the job, as was policy in the last election?
realisticman
1 year ago
G West
Are you having a nap, or are you pretty much trying to confirm your interpretation of things? By the way, have you seen Frank?
realisticman
1 year ago
Happy
That's interesting. I expect the policy to stand - otherwise the alienation probability would be seen as too much to possibly lose.
I expect Kathy to dump her yellow scarf.
Skywalker
1 year ago
Here's how to settle the race for the liberal leader.
Have each of them kiss a pigs arse. They have been doing this for 9 years. The one that smacks the loudest wins. You could even include non caucus members like Cool Hand and R/man. Maybe they could be the people's choice.
G West
1 year ago
ZZZZ @R/man - not at all - I sleep through all your posts.
This thread is about Christy Clark - I guess you didn't notice.
There are two other Tyee stories up at this moment where you can post anything you like about the NDP.
In my view, no matter how bad Carole James is, no matter how dysfunctional the NDP will be from time to time, Christy Clark is an even poorer excuse for a thoughtful humane being than Carole James is on her very worst day.
She deserves to stay at CKNW and stew in her own narcissistic bile, screaming invectives to the same dreary line up of cheese eating idolatrous callers as she spins her hate filled claptrap over the airwaves – little better than a distaff know-nothing Rush Limbaugh.
She is the one candidate for the BC Liberals who, had the people of BC the supremely bad judgment to elect her premier, would likely turn out to be even worse than the current premier of the place.
sals07
1 year ago
STV
Oh dear after all the haymakers you land at her feet you pile on with her dastardly support of the STV. The one change that would make a difference in the province that both the the Liberals and especially the NDP fear.
Skywalker
1 year ago
So true, so true.
She is the one candidate for the BC Liberals who, had the people of BC the supremely bad judgment to elect her premier, would likely turn out to be even worse than the current premier of the place."
RickW
1 year ago
CC is anti-education?
http://www.vancouverreview.ca/christy-clarks-legacy-of-education-cuts-lingers-in-bc/
bob1964
1 year ago
If Christy runs, the
If Christy runs, the liberals have my vote. Now if there was only a way to divert my union dues from the the NDP war chest I would be really happy