Opinion

'Liberalizing' BC Hydro

Top BC Liberal Party operatives help spin Olympics and Site C.

By Bill Tieleman, 20 Jul 2010, TheTyee.ca

Susan Yurkovich

Susan Yurkovich: from Liberal campaign to Hydro spin.

Related

"I can tell you that the sooner we eliminate patronage in the province, the better off all of our public institutions are going to be." -- Gordon Campbell, as opposition leader, March 26, 1997

Top BC Liberal Party political strategists and supporters have taken over key positions at BC Hydro, and the results at the province's largest Crown corporation have become clear in the last several months.

Sixteen senior managers, all making over $100,000 a year, were seconded to do low-level jobs like selling tickets for the Vancouver Olympics, as I reported exclusively last week in 24 hours. Who will pay for BC Hydro sending 67 employees at a cost of at least $2.48 million to work on the Olympics for up to five years? BC Hydro customers will, through higher electricity bills.

Why would BC Hydro give up so many staff to subsidize the Olympics? Could it be because people like Susan Yurkovich and Steve Vanagas are top BC Hydro executives who also happen to be key B.C. Liberal Party operatives?

Yurkovich was senior vice president, corporate affairs and was also responsible for BC Hydro's 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games operations until this month. She is now VP responsible for the Site C Dam project.

Key Liberal spin doctors

Yurkovich was also a member of the B.C. Liberal Party's secret central 2005 election campaign committee. And in the past year alone she has donated $1,450 to the B.C. Liberals.

Vanagas is BC Hydro's director of communications and public affairs and reported directly to Yurkovich. Vanagas came to BC Hydro straight out of Premier Gordon Campbell's office, where he was deputy chief of staff responsible for communications.

Both Yurkovich and Vanagas were parachuted into BC Hydro headquarters in 2006 after the provincial election.

Yurkovich has strong federal Conservative Party ties, having worked under the Brian Mulroney administration for B.C. cabinet minister Tom Siddon. She also sits as a provincial appointee on the University of B.C. board of governors and the Vancouver Coastal Health Authority.

Yurkovich was also a Canfor vice-president, serving under the term of Canfor president David Emerson, later a turncoat MP who switched from the federal Liberal to Conservative party in order to stay in a cabinet minister job.

Vanagas is a former staffer at the right-wing Fraser Institute and former reporter at the defunct BC Report conservative newsmagazine.

FOI requests now sent upstairs

But just in case the BC Liberals didn't have enough ability to spin BC Hydro affairs with two of their most loyal followers in charge of communications, they went even further.

A government "letter of expectation" issued in April orders BC Hydro to provide it with all freedom of information requests before releasing them -- no doubt including my FOI that revealed a $140,000-a-year manager was seconded by BC Hydro to be a "Ticket Representative" during the Olympics and that a $137,916 a year manager worked as a "supervisor, event services."

The letter of expectation has led the non-profit B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association to ask that B.C.'s information and privacy commissioner investigate possible political interference in FOI requests.

Friends on the board

The BC Hydro board of directors has also been stacked with top B.C. Liberal Party supporters.

From Jamie Brown, president of Canaccord Financial subsidiary Canaccord Genuity and son of long-time BC Liberal donor Peter Brown, to Larry Blain, the premier's top privatizer of public services as CEO of Partnerships BC, to BC Liberal donor and former BC Gas CEO Stephen Bellringer, the party is well-served at the directors' table.

From top to bottom, when it comes to BC Hydro the real power flows from the BC Liberal Party.  [Tyee]

20  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Camero409

    1 year ago

    Not Surprising

    that all these so called "free enterprisers" are hogs at the trough. After all "free enterprise" is just another name for Communism! [UNVERIFIED ALLEGATION REMOVED. -MODERATOR.] It is simply a method of keeping the taxpayers from finding out who really controls the province and to keep money flowing into the hogs pockets.

  • Hughes

    1 year ago

    Pathological Purjerer

    This is exactly why we need a FUNCTIONING AND FULLY INDEPENDENT B.C. UTILITIES COMMISSION, and why Campell hobbled the B.C. Utilities Commission by way of his not so Clean Energy Act.

    Yet another of Campbell's 180 degree policy changes.

    Campbell's M.O. -- Say one thing to get elected, then do the opposite again 'n' again 'n' again...

  • Jeffrey J.

    1 year ago

    Frightening End of Democracy

    This is really frightening.

    And don't forget BC's recent instructions to senior bureaucrats to manufacture crises in order to implement policy change, in Ms. Micheal Vonn's stunning article (following Sean Holman's explosive discovery):

    "The [BC] government considers it part of the job of senior bureaucrats to fabricate crises in order to advance policy. How’s that for laying it on the line? Here’s exactly what it says under the “Characteristics/Behaviours” section of the role profile: “Executives anticipate, and are prepared to institute change quickly. At times, to capitalize on the best opportunity, executives create a crisis to force change.”

    http://www.straight.com/article-334382/vancouver/micheal-vonn-bc-government-job-posting-exposes-crisis-democracy

    Strap on your seatbelt (yet again) as we sink deeper and deeper into political corruption and state run tyranny.

    Great coverage.

  • sunshine coast girl

    1 year ago

    All the more reason

    to get rid of these crooks immediately and instantly replace these hacks! Those Lieberals are really insidious (like skin cancer), we have to cut them out.

  • freebear

    1 year ago

    Solution?

    "All the more reason
    to get rid of these crooks immediately and instantly replace these hacks!"

    with different hacks?

  • Hermans Hermit

    1 year ago

    One Set of Hacks Replaced By Another

    And the board of directors of BC Hydro under the NDP was also represented by party hacks - to name a few:

    Jim Sinclair - BC Fed
    Jack Gerow - HEU
    Eduard Lavalle - BC NDP Provincial Secretary
    Bill Yee - NDP civic candidate
    Erda Walsh - NDP MLA

    Both the Liberals and the NDP should be crushed like a fly by another third political party who will represent the people - not party hacks out for themselves on the public trough!

    We are the people.

  • CHAOTICORDER

    1 year ago

    Electoral Reform

    I still feel the best alternative we have is to cinch the belt and take it for another term as we all know that regardless of what happens in the next election we still will not elect a government that has the peoples interests at heart.

    What is needed is true power at the voting station, an actual choice, as long as I have been on this earth a choice contains 2 parts, to say yes or no. Having that power on the ballot, to boot out all the options and force a complete governmental reform would hold these politicians accountable for the utter fallacies they commit time and again.

    This type of reform of course would require a non-partisan committee to establish exactly how we would go about rebooting our failing/failed system but I know it is possible. We, the people, have shouldered worse and come out far better in the end.

    Personally I think our politicians should be elected along the same lines as we perform jury duty. Taking out the glorification and corruption by having highly qualified people that run successful businesses in the private sector put in (while having their business interests taken care during their terms) and then transitioning them back into their employment when said term is over is a practical solution. Obviously it needs work and I expect criticism for suggesting it however I feel the brain tank that posts on the Tyee could come up with a viable alternative in case our much vaunted politicians didn't get the memo and refused to change their ways.

    Reform is needed, scratch that it is bloody required to ensure the people continue to uphold the democracy we have been fighting for nonstop for centuries.

  • BC Mary

    1 year ago

    Maggots do that.

    Sorry, it's awful. But I keep thinking about something similar in the swamps and grasslands and forests,

    where something dies (or is killed)

    and the maggots move in

    automatically

    and begin their ritual feasting.

    It is awful. But how is it different to what the Campbell Gang has done to BC Rail, BC Hydro, BC Ferries, the forests, the rivers, the salmon ...

  • toquer

    1 year ago

    Stack with hacks

    Of course, when Bill Tieleman's NDP were in power, they never would consider appointing partisans....

    Oh wait, they did it all the time.

  • shabbaranks

    1 year ago

    Emerson - Turncoat

    What does Emerson having crossed the floor have anything to do with Yurkovich? You used his negative image, and a tenuous relationship to Yurkovich to tarnish hers. He was her boss. Are we all complicit in anything our bosses do, in a different occupation, in the future?

    This article is filled with good points and analysis, but why use cheap, sensationalistic tactics that weaken the credibility? That's what the comments section is for!

  • Frank

    1 year ago

    Jeffrey J

    Interesting link, says it all about the Right's aims and methods.

  • blackie

    1 year ago

    Frightening End of Democracy???

    A three-term government is busy populating its crown corporations with supporters and sycophants, and this is a frightening end to democracy?

    Get a grip, guys. Liberal, NDP, Conservative, fedLiberal, Bloc Quebecois (well, maybe not them -- no power), Parti Quebecois -- they ALL do this, and when in opposition they ALL spout warm and fuzzy platitudes about ending patronage (having no intention whatsoever of doing it).

    Many years ago I asked a city mayor why he kept appointing all his friends to various advisory committees, boards, etc. He looked at me and said "you think I should appoint my enemies?"

    Didn't Gordo appoint Mike Harcourt and Dan Miller to a couple of things? Oh, sorry, they're traitors to the cause. How silly of me.

  • Frank

    1 year ago

    blackie

    Interesting that you think a government busily populating crown corporations and government posts with sycophants and financial contributors is okay.

    Thank god for public sector unions which make sure everyone working in government isn't a financial contributor to the government eh?

  • kootenay

    1 year ago

    End Of Democracy

    One of the reasons democracy doesn’t work is that the citizens have eliminated themselves from the political process. It is totally delusional to think that somewhere out there exists an honest politician who will serve up democracy to the masses on silver platter.
    Democracy isn't given to the citizens by the government of the day. Democracy is citizen's exercising their right to speak out against government initiatives and taking action against them. The most recent example of this is the anti HST protest with 700,000 signatures. Campbell has no intention of rescinding the HST, but as a result of the petition he has shown his contempt for the people in no uncertain terms.
    Our generation, the baby boomers, grew up in the most prosperous times for mankind, we’ve never had to fight for anything, we were handed the good life by our parents. In fact life has been so good, we have forgotten , or perhaps, never been taught, that democracy is a dynamic system requiring constant input.
    We’ve been asleep at the switch for so long, we’ve forgotten what it takes to maintain a democratic society. While it’s important to elect politicians who aren’t wholly tied to Corporations, it’s even more important to exercise your democratic rights, before we don’t have any at all. We can't continue to just sit at home and hope the next government initiative won't affect our livelyhood.

  • sunshine coast girl

    1 year ago

    At least NDP hacks

    don't sell everything we own, sign 999 "leases" and sacrifice British Columbians to the almighty big business.

  • kootenay

    1 year ago

    Agreed

    You're right Sunshine, the NDP would be an improvement over the Liberals, but so long as the citizens continue to exclude themselves from the political process, they too will smell like rotten fish in short order.

    Look at France for instance, when their government makes changes that affect them, they take to the streets by the hundreds of thousands to protest.

    In Canada, on the otherhand, we don't support eachother at all, in fact when one group has better benefits than another we call them greedy bastards and hope the government/corporation will bring them to their knees.

    While I agree, it's important to elect a government you think you can work with, it is even more important re-educate the electorate. Our Fathers didn't win the wages, benefits and social services we were handed without a fight.

  • Tieleman

    1 year ago

    Bill Tieleman responds

    Several posters here defend the BC Liberals by saying "everybody does it" in politics. The issue is that the BC Liberals absolutely went ballastic on the NDP previously and promised it would never happen on their watch - now they have gone far beyond anything any previous NDP or Social Credit government did.

    One simple point - the BC Liberals fired all public service, merit-appointed communications officers in their first term and replaced them with Order In Council appointees.

    That means every government communications officer reports to and serves "at the pleasure of" Premier Gordon Campbell. That includes forestry, highways and other communications staff where politics should have nothing to do with their jobs - but it does now.

    Secondly - I don't argue here or elsewhere that no one with BC Liberal connections can be a board member or do work for a Crown or government - that's obviously one way any government implements its policies based on a mandate from voters - like it or not.

    What has happened at BC Hydro is a wholesale takeover from top to bottom with rather obvious consequences, as I outlined with the Olympic Games as merely an example.

    What about the Clean Energy Act and its incredible bias towards subsididing Independent Power Producers? Why was CEO Bob Elton pushed out after objections to BC Hydro policies by IPPs?

    On the Board of Directors - I agree the NDP appointed supporters too - but they also appointed those who were not, including business representatives.

    The BC Liberals have not appointed anyone from labour or with an NDP background to any board or commission except Worksafe BC and - due to a union contract provision - BC Ferries - to the best of my knowledge. That's not only wrong, it's shortsighted to decline input from those with differing perspectives.

    Lastly, Susan Yurkovich is an obvious political player in both federal and provincial politics. She was a Conservative who followed David Emerson into the Liberal Party federally when he ran and followed him back to the Conservatives when he switched sides to keep a cabinet job.

    She was a key executive with Emerson at Canfor - that's not cheap tactics - it's clear facts.

  • zalm

    1 year ago

    Nicely done, Bill

    Campbell's been drinking the Kool-Aid so long it tastes like Scotch to him. It's always nice to have a messenger point out the real thing now and again.

    Quod mimimum specimen in illum ingenium? - Cicero

    (What microscopic evidence of wits can be found in him?)

  • toquer

    1 year ago

    But Bill..

    Bill:

    I don't think everyone who has mentioned the obvious stacking of boards and partisan appointments that occurred under the watch of the NDP is necessarily defending the Liberals: I for one despise this government. Rather, commentators are pointing out a glaring hole in your argument, which coming from a former NDP player who was/is 'in the know', seems like more than mere oversight. In a great many ways, I find your follow up in the comments section far more informative and even-handed than the orginal article.It highlight what's particularily egregious about this round of appointments, whereas before, it read as hypocritical sour grapes.

  • Skywalker

    1 year ago

    toquer

    I think Bill answered your point very well. Under the NDP the boards were still able to operate according to the mandates and these mandate were not changed to suit a political ideology. BC Hydro then was still the primary supplier for hydro power in BC.

    What the liberals have done is light years worse. BC Hydro is a trough for the corporate sector to feed on and a political money pit for the hacks who are now appointed. Such would never have happened under the NDP. Canwest would have gone ballistic and everyone would have been outraged.

    Bill Tielman is dead on. Way to go Bill!

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.