- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Gordon Campbell Slammed by Former Backer, Eco-Activist Tzeporah Berman
Former BC premier's lobbying against clean fuel laws 'shocks' enviro who gave him award.
Berman presenting Campbell with award for "climate action leadership" at climate summit in Copenhagen, Denmark in 2009. Photo source: BC government.
Former Liberal Party of B.C. premier Gordon Campbell could once count Tzeporah Berman among his closest environmental allies. But that was before he took a prestigious diplomatic posting in Europe and began lobbying against one of the world's most wide-ranging clean fuel laws.
Now Berman, who last year became a lead climate change campaigner for Greenpeace International, told The Tyee in a free-swinging phone interview that she is "shocked" by Campbell's role in an "absolutely reprehensible" oil sands industry offensive that makes her "embarrassed" to be a Canadian.
The only reason she helped him win B.C.'s 2009 provincial election and presented him months later with a high-profile award at the Copenhagen Climate Conference, Berman said, was for his "courageous" support of North America's first carbon tax.
With Campbell now playing down the environmental impact of Alberta's oil sands in a bid to keep European climate policy from spreading across the planet, Berman isn't even sure he deserves credit for that anymore.
"It really makes you wonder who in his government was behind the carbon tax," she said.
Splitting BC's enviros
Berman is arguably one of the most polarizing environmental figures to ever come out of B.C. She rose to fame in the early 1990s by leading fierce protests against old-growth logging in Vancouver Islands's Clayoquot Sound. She later helped negotiate a contentious detente between logging companies, green groups and First Nations on B.C.'s north and central coast, pushing the provincial government to protect a 2.1 million hectare tract of pristine wilderness deemed the "Great Bear Rainforest."
But some environmentalists felt betrayed by her actions before and after the 2009 provincial election. First came Berman's high-profile "resignation" from the New Democratic Party. Presented by Berman as a protest against leader Carole James' opposition to B.C.'s carbon tax, her decision helped split the local environmental movement and was seen as a factor in the re-election of Gordon Campbell.
Berman's decision to later join the BC Liberal government's green-energy task force after caused some activists to question her motivations.
Then, months after the election, at the Copenhagen Climate Conference, Berman and several of Canada's largest green groups presented Campbell with a major environmental award.
"The honour was for the potentially suicidal political decision to introduce North America's first economy-wide carbon tax," she recounts in her recent memoir, This Crazy Time.
'It's been absolutely reprehensible'
Yet other activists saw Campbell's so-called "climate leadership" as confusing or even disingenuous. For at the same time that he championed his government's carbon tax in Copenhagen and elsewhere, he also pushed hard to expand northern B.C.'s natural gas industry and boosted plans by Enbridge to build an oil sands pipeline from northern Alberta to coastal Kitimat, among other climate-damaging initiatives.
Then, only months after officially resigning as premier last spring, Campbell was named by Prime Minister Stephen Harper as high commissioner to the United Kingdom, one of Canada's most prestigious diplomatic postings.
It was clear from the start that Campbell had been enlisted to help defend Alberta's oil sands industry against the European Union's proposed Fuel Quality Directive. That legislation, which was recently approved by the European Commission and faces a final vote in coming weeks, is an "incredibly important" early victory in the fight against global warming, Berman said.
The legislation would help the climate by encouraging Europe's fuel suppliers to avoid selling any gasoline, diesel or jet fuel with a higher-than-average carbon footprint. Many see it as a tantamount ban on fuel imports from Canada, since the carbon footprint of viscous, corrosive, oil sands bitumen is 23 per cent bigger than regular, smooth-flowing oil, according to a European Union-commissioned study.
In response, an alliance of Canadian diplomats, Albertan politicians and European oil companies have been lobbying for years against any clauses targeting the oil sands.
"It's been absolutely reprehensible," Berman told The Tyee. "I have never been so embarrassed. You can't tell Canada's position on the international scene from Saudi Arabia's."
Campbell lobbies for oil sands
In Edinburgh, Scotland, late last month, Campbell joined the offensive, telling BBC News that "the oil sands have the same kind of impacts as many other sources of energy globally. To pick out one doesn't answer the problem."
Canada actually exports very little oil sands bitumen to Europe, but officials fear that European Union climate initiatives could be copied in Asia, or even worse, by the United States, the industry's biggest consumer. Campbell went on to explain to the BBC that Canada takes climate change very seriously, and has "an enhanced regulatory code" for the oil sands.
There was no mention that Ottawa cancelled plans this year to regulate the industry's emissions; or that Canada's environmental commissioner, Scott Vaughan, doubts the federal Conservative government can even meet its modest national emissions targets.
"You're kidding," Berman said after The Tyee informed her about Campbell's pro-oil sands lobbying in Scotland. "I find that really shocking."
Even still, the Greenpeace International campaigner wouldn't recant her high-profile award to Campbell in Copenhagen. But she's now begun to question whether he deserved it. "He put forward a courageous and seminal policy on the climate," she said. "His emerging as tar sands apologist internationally does make one wonder who it was in his government that held water on the carbon tax."
Several days after Berman spoke with The Tyee, two anti-oil sands activists crashed a meeting of Canadian and European energy leaders in London, groping, kissing and slathering each other with molasses on top of a boardroom table (click here to watch a video). Campbell, who was in attendance, watched with a wry smile, eight time zones removed from his home province and its landmark carbon tax. ![]()




91
Login or register to post comments
zalm
31 weeks ago
Berman's scratching hard, now
I give her full marks or earnestness, making her reputation as she did in the woods. I know it takes everyone a long time to grow up and realize leopards don't change their spots, but someone had to be propping her up from behind when she gave Campbell that award originally. She couldn't have done all that on her own.
I'm sure she's mad, now, too - that part is honest. But having dealt with forest companies for a decade, you'd thing she'd have known by now that when you lie down with dogs you wake up with fleas.
All this faux rage is a bit much for me. I can't hold it against her, though - she's accomplished a ton more in her much-younger life than I have.
Holding Campbell accountable just isn't one of them.
immigrant
31 weeks ago
Basic intelligence?
I'm relatively new to Canada so wasn't around to witness Berman's heroism around Clayoquot Sound. But really... shocked? Did she just crawl out from under a rock? I knew about Campbell's duplicity before I even lived here. If she's sincere about her new outrage, I have to wonder about her basic grasp on political reality.
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
A little late Tzeporah
The below article was written 18 months ago, everything in the Tyee story above was already reported in the below link, 18 months ago!
Come on Tzeporah, you knew what Gordo was all about, the damage is done, you Tzeporah Berman and David Suzuki made it possible for Gordon Campbell to become premier, now look, Enbridge, fish farms killing salmon, Fish lake....And now you want some comfort???
Gordon Campbell had a brutal environmental record, it was public knowledge...
Your shame Tzeporah, crocodile tears, just like the tears Gordon Campbell let rip after he drove drunk in Hawaii..
Too little, too late
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
Tyee won`t let the link through
Google up...
The silence from Tzeporah berman and David Suzuki is deafening...
Courtesy of the persuader.
Cheers
shepsil
31 weeks ago
She needs to redeem herself, before moving on forward
I read a Tweet asking her, how will she redeem herself after supporting Gordon C., with him now lobbying for the Tar Sands. Her response was angry and she tried to take the piss out of her challenger who was a New Democrat.
The other day she Tweeted she could not make the OWS event at the Art Gallery in Vancouver, as her kids insisted on playing soccer. Truth is, she would have been left rather victimized by the crowds if they had recognized her.
Last but not least, she was recently quoted in the media as saying she might run for the NDP in the near future. That would be a feat, but as a New Democrat myself, I think she might have to change the NDP culture first.
One thing she's got is chutzpah, but even that doesn't always get you what you want!
Frank
31 weeks ago
Berman run for the NDP?
Over my dead body. I hope she runs for the BC Liberals. She shares their beliefs.
oeanda
31 weeks ago
Berman is a Climber
It's not news to those who've known her.
Blinded by ambition to Campbell's ulterior purpose, even though it was obvious to the rest of us.
OccupyTyee
31 weeks ago
Tzeporah, thank you
Thanks.
You have to remember Gordon Campbell is not his own man but PMSH's. Which means BC values were left on the plane ride to diplomat school to be one of Captain Canada's sidekicks.
But thanks for teaching the BCNDP a lesson and rewarding the moxie of Premier Campbell to shift taxes onto carbon instead of small business. Thanks.
Frank
31 weeks ago
OccupyTyee cheering the bullying of the poor
Yes, thank you for helping produce a policy where schools spend tax dollars that could be spent on better things like helping the poor but instead have to buy carbon credits from polluting corporations.
Well done Tzeporah. The BC Liberals should give you an award.
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
Tzeporah Berman was after Green, as in MONEY, HONEY
[OFFENSIVE CHARACTERIZATIONS REMOVED. -MODERATOR.]
crankypants
31 weeks ago
Let's face it
Let's face it, she is doing nothing but trying to cover her butt now that she has come to the conclusion that she was played by Gordon Campbell and the BC Liberal Party. She was used like a worn out shoe and in the process lost whatever credibility she gained in her previous endeavors. She is nothing but yesterday's news and there is nothing she can say or do to change it. Once a person sells out their principles they have nothing, and she sold out big time.
herbiee
31 weeks ago
Phony Outrage
I guess she's been bit by the proverbial snake in the grass... Looks good on ya Tezporah...
tierra y libertad
31 weeks ago
Corporate Lockdown
I'll give Tzeporah the benefit of the doubt that her strategy with Campbell was to probably shame him into helping the environment..."See Gordy, if you do things to protect the environment, you get people like me to make you look good!" Unfortunately, the corporations call the shots, not our politicians. In the end, Tzeporah got burned over corporate greed vesus doing the right thing to save this planet. As for Campbell, just like a snake will always crawl on his belly, so too will he lie and cheat and whore himself to the highest bidder! More reason to keep the #OccupyWallStreet movement growing! Capitialism IS the crisis!
Grumpy
31 weeks ago
More and more like the MSM
This article is nothing more than "greenwash" for Berman. It is sad to see the Tyee becoming more and more like the main stream media.
As for Berman, no reporting is the best reporting.
Skywalker
31 weeks ago
She's trying to reinvent herself.
Oh and doesn't OccupyTyee sound so much like I_Am_Peo, JosefK and BC Order.
off-the-radar
31 weeks ago
Really Tyee?
c'mon, why is Tyee reporting this?
I actually laughed out loud. Tzeporah Berman's actions and reputation, just like Gordon Campbell's, speak for themselves.
OccupyTyee
31 weeks ago
@A Drop in the Bucket
That's not true and you know it, Sean Leslie is a friend of mine, and you just wanna lie & shimmy for your beloved BCNDP.
Norman Farrell
31 weeks ago
She still doesn't get it
Planning a return to Vancouver, Berman makes an effort at mending fences but she would be better off fully admitting to her own foolishness rather than suggesting that Gordon Campbell UNEXPECTEDLY took the wrong course. My gawd, what a miserable evasion of taking personal responsibility for personal choices made.
http://northerninsights.blogspot.com/search/label/Tzeporah%20Berman
freebear
31 weeks ago
Should have saved this for April Fool's day!
Berman is only an oportunist who craves media attention-remember the piece on her eco fashion!
How does she contain that ego?
Frank Lee
31 weeks ago
He's just doing his job--but he's quite comfortable doing it
Campbell represents Canada and B.C. governments in Europe.
As for his earlier support for the carbon tax, he was drawn to the idea to (1) shift a portion of revenue away from progressive income taxes, which disproportionately affect his core constituency of affluent voters, onto a tax the burden of which can be more easily avoided by affluent Vancouverites than by anyone else;
(2) he wanted to split the support for the NDP (now LIberals are more worried about getting back COnservatives who were alientated in the process);
(3) WHo knows maybe he actually basked in the praise that environmentalists and economist like Mark Jaccard were showering upon him.
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
Very Strange indeed
Now the Tyee is moderating the use of (Fictional names)?....I see no Joeseph K on this thread.
Unless you know something that we pee-ONs don`t..Pray tell!
[LINK TO EXTERNAL WEBSITE REMOVED FOR LEGAL CONCERNS. -MODERATOR.]
cboo44
31 weeks ago
HUH ???
So, Berman awards Gordo with a phony baloney "award" and it's all Gordo's fault ?? Just how gullible does she think we are? Gordon Campbell was a political animal, a liar and a corrupt premier who would do anything to get elected.
shepsil
31 weeks ago
Lets not forget Cortez connection!
Where Ms. Berman used to live, where Hollyhock Magnet, Joel Solomon lives, where Gregor Robertson has a place.
Joel Solomon is a big supporter of Mayor Robertson, which I believe is a good thing. But he has certain American political values and is connected to the same movers and shakers Berman is connected to.
The problem as I see it is Ms. Berman's Americanized ego and how she used it during the 2009 BC Election to criticize the BCNDP to her advantage.
American political ways are constantly knocking at our Cdn doors and resisting their negative aspects is always going to be a challenge. My naive hope, is that the politics of the NDP and Jack Layton's legacy will prevail and those American's like Solomon will join the NDP, rather than the NDP being compromised by those American ways.
Coastalhermit
31 weeks ago
To err is human.... but there is a price
Everyone makes mistakes. And she did. Methinks it was a mistake of ambition rather than ethics but I, too, have made mistakes so I will accept her claim of 'oops'. But, really, even if it was just a mistake, there is still a price that has to be paid. And, at the very least, the price should be the curtailment of her ambition for power. She can't run for anyone and still claim a shred of integrity. She should say, "I was blinded by ambition and I am now proven unworthy. Sorry. Can't run.".
Skywalker
31 weeks ago
Her epiphany.
It kind of reminds me of Campbell's show after he came back from Maui. It just doesn't work. She might have to undo the damage that her endorsement has done and that is nigh impossible.
sebastian toombs
31 weeks ago
shocked!
how shocking that a leopard would not change his spots...
or should that be a cheetah?
sz
31 weeks ago
beyond cocktail environmentalism
It's hard to believe that Ms. Berman didn't see through the charade of the carbon tax - just another way to tax BC workers to subsidize not transit, but the oil and gas industry among other big corps. She and others, perhaps believing they can maintain their class privileges and an unequal economy and still have a sustainable environment, were played like a fiddle by Campbell and his backroom boys. Campbell has never, ever been about that and never will be.
And here we are too, left with cynical Run of the River projects that destroy waterhsheds and put money into a new greenwash corporate class while raising rates for everyday people.
We can all learn from this. It's no longer enough for wealthy enviros to waltz around international conference curcuits, telling people who can barely put food on the table or a roof over the head to eat organic, drive less and install efficient heaters. There will be no environmental sustainablity without economic justice.
Fish-counter
31 weeks ago
Tzeporah Berman seems to attract a lot of criticism but...
DELETED FOR SEXIST COMMENTS -- MODERATOR
The thing is, if you don't test the water, you never know what temperature it is at. I think the carbon tax on gas was a good thing, and I don't care what the trolls under bridge at the Tyee think. Before we criticise someone like her, we should ask if we have done any better, or any more than she has to further the 'green' cause.
EDITED
munroe
31 weeks ago
Berman
She is not a person worthy of comment after her obvious intellectual deficit with respect to old oily Gordo. I trust this is the very last we will hear. No one rides forever on good works a generation past and since totally soiled. Look at Patrick Watson.
raingirl
31 weeks ago
Definitely Faux Rage
Count me as another who doesn't believe she didn't see thru Campbell's phony green tinge. She saw, but like Oleanda said, she's a "climber" and her little award stunt with Campbell & friends has paid off very well in terms of present & future job prospects, board positions, etc.
Oh, and FishCounter, ... I'll criticize/throw the first stone ... because I believe I have done better & I know many who have done no worse!
worried
31 weeks ago
Berman and Run of River
Her greatest environmental crime to me is her support for Campbell's give-away of 800 B.C. wilderness rivers to Private Power companies. Not only can they divert, dam and develop in pristine watersheds, they are given guaranteed contracts which force B.C.Hydro to buy power from them at crippling prices. Ms. Berman went on to become their poster child, exclaiming with starry eyed enthusiasm how this strategy was oh, so green. (she seemed to think it was okay to destroy black bear habitat to save polar bears) She knew full well most of these companies are backed by multi nationals or ex-B.C. Liberals cabinet ministers. General Electric now has the rights to develop 17 rivers flowing into Bute Inlet. I can't imagine her Cortez Island neighbours think much of her. She's an environmental nightmare with influence.
Norman Farrell
31 weeks ago
Some fool here said
"The thing is, if you don't test the water, you never know what temperature it is at. I think the carbon tax on gas was a good thing."
Please, spare us this simple minded claptrap. What does the carbon tax aim to achieve? It cannot be reduction of carbon put into the atmosphere because the same government encourages development of Alberta's tar sands so that unrefined dirty oil can be piped through BC's pristine wilderness and shipped to Asia to be burned with unknown regulation.
It is worth reconsidering Andrew Nikiforuk's work on the tar sands, here at The Tyee and in his book, which is discussed here:
http://northerninsights.blogspot.com/2011/09/taking-on-goliath.html
RickW
31 weeks ago
Tzeporah Berman et al
Tzeporah Berman
David Suzuki
Marc Jaccard
Andrew Weaver
et al have all done their job, which was help ensure a "socialist" government didn't succeed in the last election in BC. Having been successful in that endeavour, they are now free to say what they want.
Perhaps though, they are willing to put forward a united motion to have this government impeached and/or the last election nullified.....
Bruno96
31 weeks ago
She's a Politician NOW
Since this was an issue 18 months ago, I find her response of surprise a complete fabrication.
People are starting to apply memory to deeds past of the politicians; and it's about damn time.
All that time in the woods, and she never applied one of the most simple rules:
You lay with flea infested dogs......
greenmonkey
31 weeks ago
I'll cut Ms. Berman some slack
I think she jumped at the opportunity to back an initiative (the carbon tax) that seemed to be green forward. She was/is intelligent enough to understand that Campbell was using her for political purposes, in order to secure a few votes from the moderate enviros. But weighed that with the good it could do in the long run. In the same way that Bono met with Dubya.
It was a gamble and it couldn't have been easy for her. I think it would be easier on her now, if she just sat on her butt and said nothing about Campbells latest gig as a corporate whore.
She may have made a mistake, but she'd be a great addition to any NDP slate. Why do we spend energy to eat our own when there are so few talented from the left willing to stand up and go public?
cityprole
31 weeks ago
Gordon Campbell Slammed by Former Backer, Eco-Activist Tzeporah
When this award was given I was more shocked than Ms. Berman could possibly be Gordo's present actions.
Greenappease has gone terribly soft over the years, and hands out this 'stuff' at the drop of a hat...
Berman should join the Green Party, where as soon as she was elected, Ms. May showed her true Con colours hidden under her cloth coat...perhaps she'll learn a thing or two about politicians..run for the NDP? I sincerely hope it never happens.
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
The Cowardly lion...
Grow some balls!
Or should I say..
Grow some fins!
I guess it`s pretty sad when a lone voice outshines the "fin" by a mile time after time!
The bullshit of legal concerns for an external link!!!??????
Even your excuses are lame Fin
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
Part I
I have been patiently waiting for Tzeporah Berman or David Suzuki to speak up on the latest developments, I would settle for hearing from any of green sell outs, well Marc Jaccard, Andrew Weaver.......
Not one of you have gone public, why do I have to write what is in the heart of real Greenpeace believers, the carbon tax, it goes up another 1 cent per litre in July, it will also start to take in more money than they will pay back, Mr. Jaccard, could you explain why there are more than 200,000 vehicles on the roads in BC then there was before the carbon tax, perhaps you can explain why BC is the only Province in Canada that had an emission`s rise, Andrew Weaver, perhaps you can tell me how much you charged for the robo-calls during the last election, was it pro-bono, or was it off the books like the stunt Barinder Sall pulled?
I like to pick on Marc Jaccard, he is such an easy target, even Jaccard admits now that Gordon Campbell`s carbon tax is flawed and useless, Jaccard confesses until you completely penalize the driving public with $3 dollar per liter fuel Campbell`s carbon tax is nothing but phony greenwash, it hasn`t reduced a single emission, but the hypocrisy of the carbon tax, a massive spike in gas drilling and flaring in northern BC and yet we are insulted by an illegitimate Government inflicting a useless greenwash on us, Blair Leckstrom and Gordon Campbell are pushing the Enbridge pipeline while shoving a tiny carbon tax down our throats, sorry folks, time to remove the carbon tax, the exercise failed, it didn`t work, emissions rose, the gall to charge you and I a carbon tax while pushing to spend $5 billion dollars on a pipeline to move tar sand oil to Asia
RickW
31 weeks ago
greenmonkey
You have a point. But 99% of everyone I conversed with when the tax was implemented couldn't see how it would possibly work. So I refuse to believe that Berman could not also see that it wouldn't work. If it had been a dedicated tax, going to fund green R&D, that would have been fine. But it was dumped into general revenues by a government that had spent the province into near-penury, and needed money from every source it could conjure up.
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
PartII
Am I missing something, this Government can`t have it both ways, and where is Tzeporah Berman, I haven`t seen or heard from Tzeporah since Copenhagen, Tzeporah Berman praised her mentor, presented Campbell with a self-made award, I`m not sure what the award was for, I think it was an award for the largest rise in emissions in Canada, but since then, Site C has been announced, a massive oil spill is decimating the gulf states, millions of square miles of ocean have globs of oil floating beneath the surface, well Tzeporah, wern`t you a appointed to the green energy task board, where is your press conference Tzeporah, what about Enbridge, what about Site C.....What about the carbon tax,,,,,,,,,,,,,You see folks, I`m not a big global warming guy, but I am in favour of mandating industry to clean up or pay, a non-pass through tax for polluting, where I live there is no transit or taxi service, you either drive or walk most of the day, we have no choice, build clean, fuel efficient transport, you build it we will buy it.
What about you David Suzuki, what about Enbridge, we have to fight on this side of the ledger, once it starts we can`t stop it, there are thousand reasons not to build the Enbridge pipeline, number 1, the oil already finds a home without risking the West coast, Enbridge is a back-up plan to supply oil to Asia in the event the USA decides tar sand oil is too dirty, for Tzeporah Berman and David Suzuki to remain silent on this issue could almost be considered an act of National Treason, if those two icons of a Green future can`t join hands to fight loud and proud against offshore oil n Gas and tankers, if neither of you can`t or won`t call press conferences on stopping Enbridge then leave, retire......Step down, a ecological disaster unfolding before your eyes, a demented premier hell bent on scorched earth campaign, to hell with rivers, wild Salmon, to hell with protecting our B.C. coast, you can`t remain silent, Tzeporah Berman, you can`t sit on the fence, either denounce Gordon Campbell`s energy policy or embrace, get off the silent fence, as for you David Suzuki........
You are ruining a once great organization, what kind of a gutless coward are you David Suzuki, Gordon Campbell is threatening your back yard, my back yard, we don`t own the coast, it`s not ours to risk, where is your voice, why aren`t you on CKNW.......Why aren`t you calling daily press conferences, time for you David Suzuki to publicly denounce Gordon Campbell and all proponets of Enbridge.
You David Suzuki and Tzeporah Berman are directly responsible for the election of Gordon Campbell, all the pre-election press conferences from Tzeporah and Suzuki, you have a responsibility to the world to stop Gordon Campbell, the whole world is listening, the time to talk about these projects are precisely now, let people see what can happen, strike while the iron is hot,
A Drop in the Bucket
31 weeks ago
Part III
if Enbridge can`t be stopped with complete first Nation opposition, with a huge world push to cut emissions, with an oil disaster being played out before your eyes, there will never be a better time to stop Enbridge forever.
Join with me David Suzuki, get ready to turn on that charm Tzeporah Berman, the time is now for a joint press conference, time to use the power of the press, the time is now to publicly scold Gordon Campbell, if you aren`t up too the task, ship out, I have had enough
igbymac
31 weeks ago
she is "shocked" by
editingfool
31 weeks ago
i am with Frank
i am with Frank...Berman went over to the dark side years ago. and if this new democrat has anything to do with it, she will never be nominated as a ndp candidate.
Lawrence
31 weeks ago
Voting does work
People don't vote in BC because the Main Stream Media has for years pounded into the publics head that the NDP is just as corrupt as the Socreds/Liberals.
This isn't true but if a lie is repeated loud and long some of the people will believe it.
I would think the Tyee and other blogs were created to tell the truth and I would hope some of those voters will come back to the polls,once they realize the MSM lies, yep lies.
I don't think Suzuki or Berman swung the election in favor of the Liberals by criticizing the NDP's policy to get rid of the carbon tax. The NDP made a mistake on that one. I would just have said the NDP would improve the tax if elected, and left it at that.
Both Berman and Suzuki have done a great deal for the environment, knocking them is just stupid.
Yes Berman made a mistake; she's young, and swimming in a sea of sharks.
the real ODB
31 weeks ago
very sad
Very sad how otherwise intelligent people can be sucked in by scum like Campbell. I mean, the only time he lies is when he opens his mouth! But he's ALWAYS been that way. What the hell were these people and organizations thinking? Now everyone gets to pay...for a very long time, if not forever.
ReeferMadness
31 weeks ago
The usual NDP slagging
I see it's the usual NDP partisan crowd slagging someone who had the temerity to disagree with the party. Of course everyone knows that the NDP is always right and anyone who disagrees with them is misguided or just plain evil.
Go, Tzeporah. I hope you enter politics - in any party. We need someone who can think independently, not just parrot the party schtick!
Fish-counter
31 weeks ago
Norman Farrell seems to forget that we are all entitled to our
own opinions. Like so many in BC, he discounts anyone who disagrees with him as a fool. That gets old, fast Norman.
Most of us have made mistakes, often by following the lead of a well-spoken fanatic or a double-speaking politician. In the end, it is not what we think, nor how we feel, nor what we say that counts. The only thing that counts is what we DO.
Most folks in BC do nothing, but talk a lot[OFFENSIVE COMMENT REMOVED. -MODERATOR.]. We need a wind of change, not a change of wind. [AND HERE. -MODERATOR.]
Ricky
31 weeks ago
Ha ha ha, beautiful!
This is hilarious. After trading in her cred in BC for a cushy European posting, she's found that her old pal Gordy did the exact same thing! Damn it, she gave him the award, why won't he stop following her around! How embarrassing!
Stupid woman, you profited from facilitating his training in greenwashing and then thought that you could move on to - ugh, sorry folks - greener pastures? You should know, Tzeppie, all the greenwash action is in Europe now, and you let Gordo in on the game! Did you think he was going to stop using you when it became inconvenient for you? Guess what: he's dropping your name right now. OOOGABOOGA!
And you'll never be rid of him. He is the cat, and he has come back. Prepare for some drama. His presence will infiltrate your professional life and the intelligent people in the environmental movement out yonder will begin to wonder why this earthrape lobbyist bullshit artist knows you and proclaims you to be his friend. You know how capable he is of using people, and you will be used to maximum effect. There will be a cascade of inescapable, outrageous embarrassments. Try to have a sense of humour when it happens... again and again!
In fact, it would make a great sitcom! Remember Perfect Strangers? Gordo is your Balki! Oh, Balki, with his weird ways from the forgotten motherland... except instead of a thoroughly endearing accented rogue that, in the end, teaches us a bit about ourselves by being something of a goofy, oblivious clown, you have a soulless, empty shell of a man who's sole occupation is bullshit and who has been bought and sold so many times that if he issued receipts the roll of paper used would be so long that for the pulp, we would have had to, with great irony, log the Great Bear Rainforest. I went there. Or the Gordlinger can be Kramer to your Seinfeld! Except, instead of entering the scenes of your life with goofy panache and clumsy charm, just at the right time for a hearty laugh, he'll waddle in half-lit with that phony, doughy smile and that disgusting, practiced, shameless false modesty, just at the right time to discredit and use you, completely at your expense. I'll be laughing, though! In fact, I am laughing! Oh, Gord, you did it again (audience laughs, Tzeporah throws hands to sides, palms up in resignation). That's our Gordo! We can call the show Karma.
Ha ha ha! Cackle! I love it! Please keep an eye on this developing story, Tyee! These slippery characters are hard to pin down, but when you do it, things can get very interesting!
igbymac
31 weeks ago
Lawrence, you seem lost
...when it comes to voting and its usefulness (or is that uselessness) in our society.
You, that is the voter at large, start from the premise that our form of governance and all it entails is, for the most part, fine, and so you endorse it. You believe the rhetoric taught to you in school that we have a democracy and all the rest have been tried but found wanting.
In the end, you vote endorsing your desire to steer society in this direction or that; but you aren't so concerned that your desire be reached (food and shelter for everyone, but one obvious and shameful example), leaving that to the government of the day. And it never comes, not until people voting with their actions -- not marking a useless piece of state-printed paper which absolves them of real accountability -- force the government to react to an uprising.
Yes, I am putting words into your mouth because that is exactly what your actions say. Of course it is the weakest sort of deference of one's thinking imaginable considering what is at stake, but that is not the sort of matter registering on your radar.
Voting in our country is the systematic enslavement of oneself. But when the question about being truly free, about directing ones life as a man/woman and not a farm animal does not get engaged, its easy to plod on un-thinking and believing the lies of the state. And, thus, it becomes considered 'sound thinking' and a 'civic duty*' to back such folly as voting.
It's actually worse than folly. It's the force that true democracy has to relentlessly rise up against in our country to get anything of importance done. For the worthless vote has intoxicated the voter, put the voter to sleep for another 5 years, slumbering peacefully thinking he/she has already done his/her part. The vote does not put a wrench into the machination of abusive government, it actually oils the chain and cogs.
I am not going to quarrel about the matter. It is not the sort of thing one can convey to another without some serious discussion. But it does involve a deeper understanding about affairs of state and humanity than most are willing to look toward.
As Howard Zinn stated, and others through time in other ways, "Our problem is not with civil disobedience. Our problem is with civil obedience".
And what can be more obedient than peacefully voting for another second-rate thinker leading The Party with the objective of preserving the state over humanity at any cost?
.
* when one speaks of duty, they speak of one being dutifully served. They speak of slaves and masters, and intend on being the master. (a twist on Ayn Rand)
frank2
31 weeks ago
Berman's (and the others')
Berman's (and the others') praise of Campbell for the carbon tax was vastly overdone.
A carbon tax is necessary. But Cambell's tax was deficient from the start, as it didn't even tax carbon produced by some major polluters, a fact that Berman, Suzuki, Weaver and Berman conveniently ignored this at the time that they put their names behind the Liberals.
Not that they NDP has any defense for opposing the tax for the sake of opposing it. Let's hope the new leadership has more intellectual depth and will take a more constructive approach to issues.
igbymac
31 weeks ago
frank2, where does your intellectual depth stop?
"A carbon tax is necessary"?
Like water and food is necessary, or necessary within a capitalist economy that has evolved into fascism? Or something else?
Can you clarify exactly what you mean please?
the real ODB
31 weeks ago
frank2
You're exactly right!
igbymac
31 weeks ago
frank2 , I must make it clear, I am not questioning
your intellect, just posing a few questions about how far intellectually does the necessity of a carbon tax go. I hope you understand.
lauradupont
31 weeks ago
Tzeporah mad at Gordo
I have ALWAYS been boggled by the folks like Tzeporah and Suzuki, that congratulated Gordo's greedy "brilliance" in his Gateway mess, the appalling state of our wild salmon from the fish farm mess and worst of all for SELLING OUR RIVERS for supposedly "clean" energy to US multinational corps like GE! Seriously, I almost barf when he gets awards for being green - the only green that guy is is the evil green color of money. Sorry to say this but Tzeporah - you reap what you sew! Yes she has had guts in the past but no true BC environmentalist could think
anything good of Gordo or any of the BC Socreds ooops I mean Liberals!
Wake Up
31 weeks ago
about that carbon tax...
I've said from the beginning that the carbon tax is another way to punish the 99%. Which member of the 1% has to curb gas use, or even feels the pinch of having to get to work or ferry kids around the suburbs without adequate transit?
And even the CCPA has come to that thought:
check this link:
http://www.policyalternatives.ca/newsroom/news-releases/be-fair-bc%E2%80%99s-carbon-tax-needs-work
Is the carbon tax also 'necessary' on tax-funded schools and hospitals? Give me a break - I'm sure the bright and powerful out there could think of some other helpful way to have old creaky schools to become more emission-friendly. In the meantime, it's a claw-back and further cut to education.
Henry Dorsett Case
31 weeks ago
It takes a lot of guts to admit you are wrong and apologize.
Clearly Berman is not there yet. If this were an interview with a certain radio station that once employed a perky BC Liberal mouthpiece then perhaps she might tell herself that she really believed the Campbell government earnestly gave a damn about the environment in any sense other than selling out wholesale. And no one would question her.
But to do this interview with the Tyee? Maybe she really is completely naive. I would prefer to think that she is stunningly naive than that she thinks us all fools. She continues to demonstrate some pretty disturbing hypocrisy.
An apology is real and it starts to make things right. It starts with: I was wrong about... and I am sorry.
dave49
31 weeks ago
Berman isn't the only one...
So Gordon Campbell got religion on global warming. It was a great act convincing enviros he was sincere and it helped him win the election. He obviously did a great sales job, but now he's wearing different shoes and has lost his global warming religion.
We still have his nasty carbon neutrality policy, which sucks money out of public health and education to help fund industrial energy efficiency projects. Pretty lousy deal! Write Christie and your MLA and complain!!
dave49
31 weeks ago
Berman isn't the only one...
So Gordon Campbell got religion on global warming. It was a great act convincing enviros he was sincere and it helped him win the election. He obviously did a great sales job, but now he's wearing different shoes and has lost his global warming religion.
We still have his nasty carbon neutrality policy, which sucks money out of public health and education to help fund industrial energy efficiency projects. Pretty lousy deal! Write Christie and your MLA and complain!!
Jeffrey J.
31 weeks ago
Berman Polarized Environmental Movement: Understatement
Ms. Berman more than polarized BC's environmental movement. And along the way, she 'inspired' one of BC's most courageous activists Ingmar Lee to take action.
http://www.ingmarlee.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=133:why-i-climbed-the-flagpole-at-the-bc-legislature
pwlg
31 weeks ago
hmmmm
"Now Berman, who last year became a lead climate change campaigner for Greenpeace International, told The Tyee in a free-swinging phone interview that she is "shocked" by Campbell's role in an "absolutely reprehensible" oil sands industry offensive that makes her "embarrassed" to be a Canadian."
What! You mean just now she is feeling embarrassed? I'm surprised she wasn't feeling this when she presented the polarizing prize to Campbell in Copenhagen.
Always thought she was more into self-promotion. During one of her infamous "campaigns" she was videotaped talking with an aboriginal leader (kitasoo) and was told she was not helping matters and her presence in their territory was not welcome. That didn't deter her though. Watch this:
http://archives.cbc.ca/environment/environmental_protection/topics/679-3924/
The claim that Glen Clark in 1997 called Berman an "enemy of the people" is just not true. And the claim that he directed this at Greenpeace is not true. This is revisionism. Clark labelled environmentalists, not just faux and self-aggrandizing environmentalist Berman. Protests to protect the New Denver/Silverton drinking water source from logging triggered Clark's infamous "enemies of BC".
Over flowing Bucket
31 weeks ago
Well whadda ya know
The Courts have ruled.
Hyperlinks are not illegal, no matter what the content of the external link..
No slander, no defamation, no nothing
http://www.theprovince.com/Court+rules+hyperlinks+defamatory+text+publication/5573406/story.html
Yes indeed, Drop in the bucket was absolutely right, your reasons for Editing or moderating his comments were, as he said..
LAME!
igbymac
31 weeks ago
pwlg, I like it
... Protests to protect the New Denver/Silverton drinking water source from logging triggered Clark's infamous "enemies of BC".
How very Margaret Thatcher of Clark, relating to when she called the mine workers in Britain enemies of the state. This was the crisis that gave rise to Britain's implementation of Hayek's neoliberal fiscal policies (although Grenada obviously played a role in making Thatcher, the Iron Lady -- oh how our leaders like to be War Presidents and War PMs).
Regardless, when teachers or environmentalists or the labour movement can be called 'enemy of the state', we know we have a huge problem on our hands with state usurping power from the people.
Over flowing Bucket
31 weeks ago
And for good measure
The link Dropsy hyperlinked to.
That article was posted in Dropsy`s last part I..PartII..Part III comment.
And there WAS no legal concerns.
Case rested!
richardm123uk
31 weeks ago
This seems rather apt
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdV7GKzrqjU
morechatter
31 weeks ago
Corruption
And what are the people going to do about it?
Voters could vote in leaders who promise transparency and a accountable government.
Campbell was going to clean up BC government up as well as Harper who is into passing a major crime bill leaving politicians off the list. Yet a corrupt politician has the ability to do more harm than good to affect people in their daily lives and their future prospects and the environments where they live. How about the dirtest oil on the planet as I am listening to the CTV news, something to make you proud.
morechatter
31 weeks ago
Campbell is good for a laugh
Did you see the video as Campbell starts off the day on his new job in London with a sex demonstration of the oil sands? A young couple strips to their undies and starts rubbing themselves provocativly with the dirty oil.
The horror on Campbells face would have been better reserved for the oil sands horror but was good for a cuckle no less.
Frank
31 weeks ago
Fish-counter
You're upset about Norman calling you a fool after you called us "trolls"?
Grow some thicker skin. If you dish it out you have to take it.
deeby
31 weeks ago
No Surprise
Not even sure why I'm commenting, other than to concur with most of what's said here. Tzeporah bought everything that greasy bespectacled salesman was selling, hook, line an sinker.
When she looks down at the dead corpse of BC Hydro, and our wild salmon runs, and sees the final results of Campbell's disaster capitalism gambit, maybe she'll finally feel guilty, and help us oppose the privately funded dam north of Pavilion.
Luck
31 weeks ago
BERMANS GOT A BRAND NEW PAY CHEQUE
SHE IS ON SOMEONE ELSES PAYROLL.
BERMANS GOT A BRAND NEW PAY CHEQUE,
DRUM BEAT
Luck
31 weeks ago
GORDIES GOT A BRAND NEW PAY CHEQUE
HE IS ON SOMEONE ELSES PAYROLL.
GORDIE CAMBPELLS GOT A BRAND NEW PAY CHEQUE,
DRUM BEAT
Norman Farrell
31 weeks ago
BC Schools funding Encana
Encana and BC's Pacific Carbon Trust have a new deal by which the Trust is purchasing carbon offsets from Encana.
"...the deal represents a massive transfer of public money from British Columbian schools, hospitals and taxpayers to an already profitable private gas company.
"It essentially takes offset payments from schools and hospitals and gives them to industrial emitters," said New Democratic Party environment critic Rob Fleming. "To think we're going to drive private sector innovation by transferring money from schools, hospitals and public sector organizations is absurd."
http://northerninsights.blogspot.com/2011/09/schools-help-fund-encanas-foreign.html
freebear
31 weeks ago
The silence from David Suzuki is deafening
DropinBucket got it right; Suzuki no longer a natural world hero!
lynn
31 weeks ago
Berman never did get it.
She never did her research and it showed.
She never saw the correlation between the actual policies enacted by Gordon Campbell and the BC Liberals (especially the wide-scale privatization of our public assets and resources) and the resulting devastating consequences to the environment....that no intentionally distracting carbon tax ploy would ever remedy.
She never saw that the policies of Gordon Campbell and the BC Liberals would result in the stripping of our human rights and the loss of our autonomy and by doing so would have equally disastrous consequences on the environment. One example: that we would lose access and oversight to our rivers....as well as control over our once public energy resource because of the legislated privatization scam called ever so innocuously - "run-of-river".
This is the kind of trendy, lightweight 'thinking' that comes with over-confidence and ego.
These are the kind of triflers and dabblers that will sink our world.
Over flowing Bucket
31 weeks ago
Thanks Freebear
Berman deserves no sympathy, and..
And if she wanted to really attempt to atone her sins, she should have called a major presser WITH DAVID SUZUKI.
Not a vague lame telephone chat with the Fin, and the gall of moderators at this site to berate Dropsy while the likes of Puke Skywalker and stalkers of the female persuasion are allowed free range.
Yes indeed, I see both a yellow streak and jealousy rearing its head.
http://powellriverpersuader.blogspot.com/2010/05/silwnce-from-tzeporah-berman-and-david.html
Norman Farrell
31 weeks ago
Former environmentalists do "get it"
They get it in a form that can be deposited at a bank. Just follow the money when greenwashers are at work. It explains almost all motivations.
zalm
31 weeks ago
Well
We've certainly turned Berman into a pinata, and the loot is all over the ground.
Now who do we turn our attention to? Someone else who kinda looks like us, kinda thinks like us, but doesn't meet our standards of perfection?
I'm certainly all done on this thread - there's nowhere to go except back to the Occupy protest.
RickW
31 weeks ago
zalm
Public figures have to expect skewering. And I think the more appropriate word would be "consistency" rather than "perfection".....
Berman et al should never have backed Campbell's Carbon Tax, without a multitude of caveats.
Skywalker
31 weeks ago
Hey OverflowingBucket
I'm not related to Luke. I only made one small post here. I agree with you!
Wildwestwilly
31 weeks ago
@Skywalker
Bucket was referring to Mr. Cool..
You don`t troll, you tell the truth and stay out of the spin zone.
Bucketbrigade
31 weeks ago
Thanks Wildwestwilly
Wildwest is correct.
Cheers
Bucketbrigade
31 weeks ago
Testing
1 2 3
Bucketbrigade
31 weeks ago
Hyperlinks????
If one can`t link to other articles your site dies!
The internet is about linkage and connecting, connecting voices, stories, differing opinions, connecting people from around the world.
The Tyee doesn`t want to go down that road, I for one would leave for greener pastures, that may please some of you.
Slippery slope for sure.
zalm
31 weeks ago
Buckets
Check your browser - I can post links just fine. don't use IE - Firefox 5.0 works, and I hear Chrome does too.
zalm
31 weeks ago
RickW
"Public figures have to expect skewering."
Didn't I say so - first? Pretty much everything else has been the first few comments on rewind.
I wuz hoping for a bit of depth from commenters that might know Berman a bit better, but apart from Thomas-a-Bucket's comedy, there's been little.
Silly me for checking back here to see why my ass was tingling....
KevinC
31 weeks ago
Admitting you were wrong
Admitting you were wrong takes guts. I admire her for that. And I find it sad, but predictable, that those bitter about the NDP loss in the last election continue to inflate the significance and influence of Berman's position vis a vis the Carbon Tax on the election's outcome. Come on, the Berman/Suzuki/Carbon Tax factor was solely responsible for the NDP's ineptitude in ousting a deeply unpopular, corrupt regime? It is a logical fallacy to assume that a) those who voted Green did so only because of Berman/Suzuki and that b) the Green vote would otherwise have automatically gone to the NDP. For the record, my Green vote would indeed have gone to the NDP in the absence of a Green alternative -- but only as a vote *against* Gordon Campbell rather than a vote for the ineffectual, uninspiring, harmless Carole James.
Frank
31 weeks ago
zalm and KevinC
Sorry guys but this wasn't an "oops" type mistake.
She vociferously attacked the NDP. Said she was ripping up her membership. She literally fawned over Gordon Campbell. She supported a tax on the poor to make them decrease their energy consumption. She supported the privatization of our rivers and large increases to hydro rates. She did this in spite of the fact lots of environmentalists argued with her and explained to her why she was wrong. And she chose to do this in an election campaign.
Then 2.5 years go by and suddenly, when it just so happens the NDP are 7% ahead in the polls she turns on our now long departed ex-premier and muses about running for the NDP?
Oh please.
Even if she is sincere about being that dumb what is the pressing need we would have for someone like that and what assurance would we have that she isn't going to suddenly support a Liberal policy where the poor are sent to big work camps so they can be prevented from using energy and CLBC resources? If she was that dumb once it could easily happen again. I'd prefer her not being a mouthpiece for the NDP when I have no clue what bizarre policy she'll support next.
As for the attack on Carole James, she's a titan of intellect compared to Tzeporah.
Norman Farrell
31 weeks ago
Powerup powered down
but, for a while, greenwashing was good business.
As a founder and executive-director of PowerUp Canada, Berman claimed a vision:
"We aim to make Canada carbon neutral."
In pursuit of that goal, she promoted an IPP industry based on fraud so that today, power that BC Hydro MUST purchase for up to $124 per megawat is sold fo $4.34 on the surplus spot market.
Berman did her best for Gordon Campbell and his Liberal Party and, by obvious extension, their policies of unrestrained fracking in north-east BC gas fields and construction of Enbridge's Northern Gateway Tar Sands bitumen pipeline.
A grade 5 student could quickly figure out that carbon neutral and acceleration of Canadian tar sands production don't go together. Ms. Berman apparently was unable to make the connection during the time that PowerUp Canada was thriving.
The shortlived greenwasher PowerUp appears now to have abandoned its website. No doubt, a new strategy will emerge in good time.
x4estworker
31 weeks ago
Not on My Watch
Berman running for the NDP? As an NDP Party member, I would do whatever I could to prevent her nomination.
She is obviously a flavour of the week kind of person and changes her loyalties to suit her personal whims. Hopefully, the NDP would recognize what a liability she would be and refuse to accept any nomination.
Boreal
31 weeks ago
connecting a few dots ....
Plutonic Power, prominent funder of the BC Liberals (http://thetyee.ca/News/2010/04/12/PowerFirmsDonations/) recently merged with geothermal energy developer Magma Energy Corp. to form Alterra Power Corp.
The Executive Chairman of Alterra, and founder of Magma, Ross J. Beaty, is the largest shareholder (26.25%), with most of those shares (100 of 122 million) held "in trust for the Sitka Foundation, a registered Canadian charity founded to advance environmental initiatives", according to the Oct 18, 2011 "Management Information Circular".
The Foundation's web site (http://www.sitkafoundation.org/s/Home.asp) lists five current projects, one of which is "a new partnership with the David Suzuki Foundation". Although a specific dollar amount is not given, the DSF web site lists Sitka as one of six top donors (more than $1 million in 2009-10) (http://www.davidsuzuki.org/donate/major-supporters/).
x4estworker
31 weeks ago
Falling All Over Themselves to be Green
Boreal:
Connect a few more dots and you will find some more very corporate donations to the Suzuki Foundation. A trip to the Suzuki Foundation website shows that without the very generous financial assistance of big corporations, the Suzuki Foundation would have serious financial problems. According to the Suzuki Foundation 2009 Annual Report, its total funding for that year was $7.2 million. Of that, over $1 million came from the Power Corporation of Canada, one of Canada's largest companies. Another $1 million plus came from the Bronfman Foundation, a very prominent name in Canadian business. Over $250,000 came from the Jim Pattison Foundation.
Not a bad haul for someone who slams corporations at every opportunity.
zalm
31 weeks ago
Frank
All I said was that this thread was all worn out like an old (political) whore and that there wasn't anything new in the comments after the first few. It seems to suit everybody that Berman's in another country now, and not likely to come back for all the eggs and rotten tomatoes in BC.
...speaking of which, you might want to review the very first one....