News

A Tyee Series

'It's the Start of New Times for Us'

Solutions must recognize First Nations' distinct cultural values. Last in the series 'Native Youth Speak Out.'

By Jacqueline Windh, 2 Aug 2010, TheTyee.ca

Native youth Patrick Lucas

Pat Lucas of Port Alberni made a tough choice. Photo: J. Windh.

Related

[Editor's note: This article is last in a six-part series on native youth speaking out about their challenges and their dreams. The 14 young people interviewed for this series are introduced in part one.]

A decade ago, when Ken Watts was booted out of Grade 11, he stood a good chance of becoming one of the 62 per cent of aboriginal kids in Alberni School District who do not graduate from high school. Thanks to family encouragement, as well as an alternative school tailored to the specific needs of native students, he received his high school diploma -- and a BA as well.

This past March, Watts was one of the signatories on a Memorandum of Understanding between the Unified Aboriginal Youth Collective and the Provincial Government of B.C. The MOU acknowledges that "listening to the aboriginal youth voice is part of the process of building a relationship between the province and aboriginal people which is based on respect and reconciliation."

Watts calls the signing of the MOU "ground-breaking" for two reasons. First, he says, it is the first time that such a diversity of native interest groups, representing both urban and on-reserve First Nations as well as Métis youth, have come together to speak with one voice.

More importantly, he says, is that this agreement seems to be for real. "I was worried that it was yet another agreement on paper. Our people sometimes get sick of all these action plans, protocol agreements, MOU's."

But Watts says that early results are apparent. "We've already been contacted by several provincial ministries who say they want to work with us in several different areas. It's starting!"

Alternative schools make a difference

Alternative schooling programs are one example of successfully responding to the specific needs of aboriginal youth. Port Alberni's Vast Learning Opportunities Centre, for example, steered Watts from being a high school drop-out to a degree-holding community leader and current male youth representative of the B.C. Assembly of First Nations.

"Lots of First Nations kids don't feel comfortable asking questions in front of a group," explains Watts. "At Vast, there is lots of support in an intimate environment. You can do your work, and go up and ask the teacher in a one-on-one situation if you have a question."

Tom McEvay, Vast's principal of alternative adult and distributed learning programs, emphasizes that Vast is not what he would call a "full-service" high school. McEvay explains that traditional institutions emphasize the needs of the system, e.g., group intake once or twice a year, set course start and finish dates, a group graduation date.

"We focus on the needs of the clients," he explains. "Many of the students who come to us are somewhat marginalized in society. They don't have the capacity and support systems in their lives to get answers -- they may not have a family structure, they may not know how to find transport for an interview, they may not know who to call for information."

McEvay explains that the Vast program takes a holistic view of needs. "We know that higher-order needs, such as education, cannot be met unless their basic needs -- food and shelter, safety, connectedness, and self-esteem -- have been met." To that end, Vast liaises closely with social agencies that help its students, for example in finding housing, or day care, or employment.

In a previous article in this series, Pat Lucas of Port Alberni, who dropped out of school for a spell to care for an ailing father, framed his choice this way: "No matter how old you are, you can still go back and get an education. That chance is always there, but your parents might not be."

Learning on a flexible schedule

Rigid schedules, dictated by calendar or clock, are not a part of traditional First Nations culture. The flexibility that Vast's system offers gives many First Nations students an opportunity to continue their studies in a way that better suits them -- a far better alternative than simply dropping out. Vanessa George can still work several days of the week, and fit her schooling around the work schedule. Belinda Lucas appreciates both the flexibility and the independence. "At the alternative schools we can concentrate more -- you don't have the teachers right in your face, and they let you work at your own pace."

Last year, Vast celebrated the high school graduation of 75 young people who were not flourishing in the traditional school system -- 35 of whom were First Nations. In the Alberni School District as a whole, which historically has had one of the lowest graduation rates of aboriginal kids province-wide, 90 per cent of the First Nations kids who registered for Grade 12 in 2009 graduated that year.

In North Vancouver, about 10 per cent of the student population at Carson Graham Secondary School is aboriginal. Fourteen years ago, recognizing that a high percentage of aboriginal students were not finishing Grade 12, the school started a special stream to help increase "transition rates" -- the rate at which kids move up through the grades.

The First Nations Integrated Studies Program (FNISP) still teaches kids the same material, in terms of core courses such as math and English, as the mainstream program. But it does so with a Coast Salish cultural influence, and with native teachers who are culturally sensitive. Smaller class sizes of only 12 to 15 students allow for lots of one-on-one time between students and instructors.

North Vancouver Aboriginal District principal Brad Baker explains that, at first, FNISP was implemented only for Grade 8 students, to help "boost up their basic skills" upon entering high school so that they could successfully re-enter the main stream. Since then, the program has expanded to grades eight through 11.

"The aim is not to have kids in this stream the whole time," explains Baker, "but that they can come in to it for part of their schooling," giving them a chance to catch up if they have been slipping behind. And they still must complete their final Grade 12 year within the main stream.

It is clear from the Squamish youth I spoke to that the FNISP stream has helped them out. They appreciate the better teacher-student ratios and the one-on-one time, and LanLan and Sarah both said the extra support they received through the program helped them to catch up on weak reading skills.

Options for adult learners

Baker acknowledges that graduation rates -- when counted as kids finishing high school within five years of entering -- are still low for native youth at Carson Graham SS. But he points out that transition rates are now much higher. This means that more kids are graduating after taking an extra year or two.

Moreover, school-leavers have at least achieved a higher grade level before abandoning school, and so are far more likely to go back to finish their diploma later in an adult learning centre. And to that end, the Squamish Band has a half-time adult learning centre on-reserve called Eslha7an, currently attended by about 50 teens and adults.

Ken Watts feel that these are exciting times for aboriginal youth. And he emphasizes that today's youth are tomorrow's leaders. "The utilization of technology by our youth is very exciting," he says, referring to the conversance young people today have with the Internet, and to their better development of reading skills through use of the media such as Internet and texting.

"I don't mean any disrespect to the older generations, it was just a different time for them. But as today's young people move into positions of leadership, it's the start of new times for us."

Watts notes how many young people are already moving into leadership roles -- he knows several elected chiefs across the province who are under 30 years of age -- and he also draws attention to the youth of current AFN National Chief Shawn Atleo, who is 43.

The young people that I spoke to all clearly value formal education, and recognize that it opens doors and gives them choices about their futures. Helping them make their way through high school means supporting them: through alternative programs such as Vast and Carson Graham's FNISP stream; through providing them with healthy recreational opportunities, such as the sports teams that have helped Vanessa and Belinda to stay on track and avoid drugs and alcohol; and through creating healthy environments in homes and communities, so that teens may continue to live with their families and have the emotional support from them that completing high school requires.

"I do feel negative at times," says Watts, "looking at the social issues out our own back door, or the problems on Vancouver's Downtown Eastside. Those are our community members there, and there are dark parts, not only in our history, but in the current state too."

But he points to the importance of looking forward, trying to fix things rather than be critical. "My dad wrote an article about criticism. He said that if you just criticize, and don't come up with solutions, you are only hindering the process."

Watts feels that this MOU between aboriginal youth and the provincial government will lead towards solutions, giving native youth more of a voice about both what the problems are and how to solve them.

"No single agreement is going to create happiness in all aboriginal youths' lives. But this agreement works towards keeping aboriginal youth engaged, and also to informing non-aboriginal youth more about our culture. They are all pieces of a puzzle, baby steps along the way, leading to something bigger."  [Tyee]

12  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • toquer

    1 year ago

    Of course First Nations had calendars....

    "Rigid schedules, dictated by calendar or clock, are not a part of traditional First Nations culture". Contrast with "Vanessa George can still work several days of the week, and fit her schooling around the work schedule".

    Couple of things: the Nuu-chah-nulth, and other groups as well, have incredibly elaborate calendar systems, based on moon phases, seasonal resources, and migratory animals. The ritual calendar, built around these, strongly dictates the timing of important events. In many ways, traditional ways are entirely calendar based: there is little room for individual discretion, and certain things must happen at certain times, period. So I'd have to question the author's statement: it denies first nations credit for what is a profound cultural skill, the ability to organize and schedule critical events according to rigid timing. It seems a pernicious myth akin to the 'they didn't have a notion of private property' trope...In fact, the Nuu-chah-nulth had/have a conception of property that put early Euros to shame. In the same fashion, the traditional calendar(s) mentioned above contradict the article's claim.

    Second: It is clear that Ms. George's job constitutes a rigid schedule around which she must work her schooling, which she clearly manages in admirable fashion. Which is to say, whatever the claim regarding the past, the contemporary reality requires adherence to clock and calendar, and the traditions of native youth such as Ms. George clearly equip them to manage this. It would seem sufficient to say that the in the present situation, in which many school-age native youth are forced to make the terrible choice between work and school, programs such as the one discussed help resolve this otherwise insoluble dillemma. But it needn't be discussed in terms of the limits of tradition: significant numbers of immigrant youth face the same problem. It has more to do with the consequences of poverty, and the manner in which it restricts freedom of choice.

    Note this isn't a commentary on cultural programs within the schools: these are vitally important. Simply a reminder to be cautious whenever a writer states "First Nations traditional culture didn't have a conception of.....". These statements rarely stand up to scrutiny.

  • Jacqueline Windh

    1 year ago

    Comment from Toquer

    Thanks for your detailed comment, Toquer.

    I think that you have missed out on what I actually wrote, though. You seem to be responding to, or attempting to correct, statements that I never actually made.

    Of course the Nuu-chah-nulth, along with most (if not all) indigenous cultures did or do have calendar systems!

    But that's a far cry from my statement in this article, which is that First Nations cultures did not traditionally have "rigid schedules, dictated by a calendar or a clock."

    Rather, their activities (food gathering, hunting, travelling, hunkering down, etc.) were more fluid, and dictated by more natural cycles: seasons, moons, tides, weather, migrations - not by numbers on a piece of paper (e.g. calendar or datebook) or machine (e.g. clock).

    Your final warning ("Simply a reminder to be cautious whenever a writer states "First Nations traditional culture didn't have a conception of.....". These statements rarely stand up to scrutiny.") has absolutely no relevance to anything that I have written.

    I've never stated anything like this and I fear that, the way you have written it, you make it sound like you are quoting my own words here.

    I appreciate your comments and the thought that has gone into them. I hope that you'll go back and re-read what I actually wrote. You'll probably see that we don't disagree very much.

  • toquer

    1 year ago

    Fair enough, Jacqueline....

    Thanks for your reply, Jacqueline: mea culpa, to a degree...Though I would suggest that the Nuu-chah-nulth calendar is in fact quite rigid: after all, natural cycles obey a rather strict periodicity, and the timing of ritual events and the schedule by which they unfold is as rigorous as it gets. And I'd suggest that this traditional framework equips them rather well to manage the dictates of contemporary calendar and clock, which almost seem loose by comparison. On this point, I'd have to disagree with what you wrote, and what it implies. Apologies for anything I've misattributed/misconstrued beyond this, however: it is a good and timely series, all in all.

  • jnewcomb

    1 year ago

    ...and then what?

    "Rigid schedules, dictated by calendar or clock, are not a part of traditional First Nations culture". Ok - so after the special schooling that recognizes this distinction, what comes after? Is the First Nations university of BC going to be same special place? Then, after the university, what about workplaces? Special, sheltered workplaces that don't have rigid schedules, calendars or clocks? If treaties are negotiated that puts enough money in First Nations peoples pockets, only type of work need to be done will be checking on the financial advisors to make sure the cheques are coming into the bank accounts. But don't t hold your breath.

  • Birch

    1 year ago

    We might do worse...

    than to get rid of some of the tyranny of time with respect to the workplace and earning a living. Industrial culture may have made production efficient, but it has made making a living for billions of people a misery.

    If Euro-centered culture has been obsessive about time for several centuries and aboriginal societies have been less so (a concession to both the author and to toquer), as many aboriginal thinkers have argued, aboriginal culture has much to teach the newcomers.

    Despite all the lip service, industrial organization is not about encouraging thinking in the workplace. In most industrial jobs that I have had, most of my thought was devoted to figuring out how I was going to manage to keep from going crazy in such a mind-numbing occupation. Perhaps (unfortunately) that's how mass-gathered bell-regulated education is experienced by far too great a number of our youth.

    It doesn't HAVE to be this way. But in any system that systemically is organized for some people to be exploited to the ongoing profit of others, it will continue to be the most logical.

    I believe it was Bertrand Russell who remarked that the essence of wisdom is to recognize the supreme unimportance of time.

    Time should be enjoyed. Real work is a pleasure. A job is often a nightmare, or at best, a necessary evil.

  • snert

    1 year ago

    That's a crock

    "Rigid schedules, dictated by calendar or clock, are not a part of traditional First Nations culture."

    Pre-contact peoples followed natural rhythms which are really not much different than those of modern times only then if they were ignored the outcome was most likely death by starvation.

  • HawkEyes

    1 year ago

    Compelled to Critique

    I am disappointed with this series. It is well-crafted yet I am slightly reminded of fiction or a tourist in skidrow.
    If this series took a year to produce, and you are publishing a book next year, I am thinking this did not receive enough undivided attention? [As for the title of your new book, again I find liberties taken-First Nations people do not just 'talk' about Sasquatch, even among themselves.]

    You say we all know the stats, yet you miss many perspectives.
    Though VAST sounds excellent, what of alternatives such as Seabird Island School or the carving school at Ksan; where is an interview with the girl who goes to her gramma's daily for her education or an interview with youth from the only family that sings...
    Given the stats of people with diplomas and no jobs; given that the educated elitists have gotten the planet into a hellish mess, public education is not necessarily the primary salvation, if it ever was?
    Missing are important stats on aids, teen pregnancy.

    What do your kids know of canning foods? This knowledge is real wisdom. Blessed are the questions that enlighten. Poverty is not easily questioned nor is it always applicable. 'Kids', wisely, do not always recognize 'poverty', even if the stats apply... now I wonder if you are a parent!

    This critique began because of your insertion supplementing the kids' comments on racism. We all know racism is not dead yet. What was wrong with the kids' perspective? They don't know? So what is this point? A sequel?

    Still technically a 'youth', Ken Watts was not introduced as one of your 14, though he starts and ends this series.
    I wish him luck with the provincial government. It may be his day, but he should remember the world is in transition and the old ways are essential for the future of the planet and humanity.

    Despite everything endured, for First Nations, their community is still their strength.
    Your kids are rich. The beauty is that they know it.

  • Spiritlifter

    1 year ago

    Full Circle.

    I was adopted back in 1967, i was 7 days old. I was subjected to assimulation by ordeal in a non native environment. To me, this MOU represents the epoch of justice in this country. This MOU represents a policy change-an awakening to do the right thing. Instead of attacking the vulnerable self esteems of the young now this country will respect their self esteems instead. A full circle has occurred here. All my relations.

  • ASKBiblitz.com

    1 year ago

    Spread aboriginal education subsidies farther

    It's great to see aboriginal students at post-secondary institutions learning to compete in the regular stream of academia and business. But I am discouraged to learn just how much FN post-secondary students are subsidized - way beyond course fees and books. Many receive a substantial living allowance and even regular payments just for obtaining a university position. Then there are the undeclared benefits provided by the student's local band council, which quite often bestows a new computer as well as other perks, including in many cases cash payments.

    While I believe it's crucial for FNs to compete in Canada's mainstream, I'd prefer public post-sec subsidies were spread more liberally like manure to encourage more FN students.

    Surely one of the most important lessons in education is learning to appreciate its value, a lesson that's much harder to learn in the absence of a personal stake, i.e. a typically impoverishing student loan weighing heavily on one's conscience when it's time to study but friends are meeting at the pub.

    Bear in mind, too, that these generous education subsidies at taxpayer expense (see http://www.askbiblitz.com/aboriginal.php) are aimed at a population of fewer than 1.2 million Canadians, and Indian Affairs probably has the poorest record of any govt dept on program delivery.

    Could we please see some accounting to show taxpayers the money's going somewhere besides the pockets of a lawyer bureaucrat in eastern Canada?

  • snert

    1 year ago

    Hawkeyes

    Quote:
    Given the stats of people with diplomas and no jobs; given that the educated elitists have gotten the planet into a hellish mess, public education is not necessarily the primary salvation, if it ever was?

    Just remember your words about the educated elite as there are more and more natives starting to fit this category.

    Also there are a significant number of non indigenous people who do not perform well in a structured learning environments. Some never do well but others excel at life so time will tell if these differently structured learning environments, referred to, will pay off for more than '14' people.

  • dorothy

    1 year ago

    Of wealth and such

    "Poverty is not easily questioned nor is it always applicable. 'Kids', wisely, do not always recognize 'poverty', even if the stats apply."

    You are very right about this: My kids saw life as an adventure, where making it stretch was a sport and an accomplishment to be celebrated daily. Only when they hit school and got bitten by the 'new one in a box' bug, did they see themselves as poor. The rational knowledge that this seeming affluence was paid for by living in a damp basement and maxing out the credit card did not have much mileage with the respective peer groups.You cannot take homownership to school and show it off.

    Now, about the 'eurocentric' thing. It is not geographic nor even cultural. It only looks that way from this side of the Atlantic. What you see is that the same predatory breed of humans that maxed out in Europe on the willingness of the working class to multiply and be miserable, went elsewhere to get their numbers and thus the cheap work-force.

    The industrial culture never attempted to make mankind happy or better off. It was, from the outset, an attempt to maximize profits on capital. The number of workers and the degree of misery they suffer is of no concern to the coupon clippers, as long as they don't run out of said workers. This is the reason behind the moneyed people going if not all-out, then at least some way to try to fight AIDS in Africa. If there were no factories there, there would be no concern for the health of the people. Even there, they try to pickpocket you and me and make us feel guilty enough to pay for the preservation of their resource. Bono was 'not happy' with our effort on behalf of poor people elsewhere. Does he know whose tune he was singing? Maybe not. One must be up at the crack of dawn to not be used by these masters in using!

    So, please, not 'eurocentric'. As a European by birth, this really makes me cringe, because my people were never part of this, nor got any other part of it than the being used part. We should stand together there, as being divided is another way of dancing to the tune of the users.

    ...more

  • dorothy

    1 year ago

    the more

    As for the 'educated elites', you may ask what kind of education we are talking about. An important part of it has always been the learning how to step others in the face, i.e. the lesser people. Education as such is in the pubic domain. No one can prevent you from educating yourself. The part you won't get is the stamp on your derriere, which pronounces you fit for duty among the real people. That may also lead to being used. Maybe the education, this is my belief, among the elites you speak of was totally incidental to them being elites. It was maybe just a function of buying the best money could get you all around. You might as well have distinguished them as 'well-shod elites', or well-nourished elites'.

    What they all really have in common is short-sighted greed and arrogance. These are the parameters we may have help to overcome from the concept of 'political correctness'. It is up to people like you and me, regardless of color and origin, as heart and will is all that matters here, to hold the noses of these lawless people to the grindstone and make them make good on their pretty words wherever we can. They should never get away with empty posturing.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.