News

Car Free? You Stuck to the Idea!

Welcome to our Tyee experiment in post-it-note public discussion.

By Kaitlyn Braybrooke, 16 Jun 2009, TheTyee.ca

carfreeday2009.png

Take note! Car free celebrants send their messages.

On Sunday, Car-Free Day in Vancouver, a few Tyee staff members and noble volunteers set up booths at Commercial Drive and Main Street, which were blocked off so pedestrians could roam freely. Commercial looked pretty empty in the morning as I tried in vain to tie our banner to a tree. By noon, amidst a cacophony of dueling band horns, roars from a nearby roller derby race, and energetic crowd chatter, I scanned the scene and felt awe-struck. In mere hours, the street had transformed itself into a sun-drenched, exuberant bazaar.

Car Free Day was certainly a success for Vancouver this year -- and so was our transportation themed Tyee Post-It Project.

Public opinions on Neon Post-Its

For the festival, The Tyee wanted to get a sense of the 'word on the street' and provoke public participation from our two booths. We also wanted to take photographs of festival participants to showcase Tyee fans in our Flickr photo pool.

We decided to use a bright medium for festival-goers' feedback. We placed blank Post-Its and Sharpies on a sheet of butcher paper inscribed with the tantalizing question "If you had a sweet magic wand, how would you improve transportation in Vancouver?" And then we waited, digital cameras in hand.

By the end of the day, we had received 300 Post-It answers to our transportation question and 215 photographs of smiling participants holding up their ideas -- if we took a photo of you, check out our photo film below to see yourself in action or browse through our Tyee photo pool at this link on Flickr!

Commercial Drive: Street Suggestions and Reveling

Geoff, our content manager, and I started out the day by attempting to hold down our overly animated banner while kind, like-minded organizations aided us from all sides, giving us string and other useful banner-harnessing tools. By the time the crowd and our awesome volunteers (a big thanks to Jessica, Vivian and Amanda) started to arrive we were perfectly situated and spent the day debating, discussing and shooting photos of merry Post-It holding revelers.

An amazing variety of transportation visions were represented, from the serious to the humorous to the fully ridiculous. Pragmatic visions were plentiful, ranging from "We need free transit in downtown areas" (reproduced in several forms throughout the day) to "A Car Free Day every Sunday" to "More buses NOW" to "change the collective view that we 'need' cars." Some people had more whimsical ideas. One Post-It declared "Let's have human sized hamster wheels for everyone" while another suggested "free rollerskates for those over fifty." Yet another preferred "human-sized pneumatic tubes."

Main Street: Auctioneering and Extravagant Proposals

On Main Street we tried the same thing. Calling out auctioneer-style from the side of the street, Michelle, Amelia and Shelley drew an amazing response from the crowd. The Taoist Tai Chi club meditative exercise demonstrations across the street added to the general ambience of good vibes felt by all!

Overall, the Main Street crowd was mixed in preference, with half wanting to improve the bus system and the other half mentioning improved bike facilities and car infrastructure changes. Practical ideas such as "treat employee parking as a taxable benefit" and "better late night buses" flourished, as well as suggestions to "provide lower car insurance for bus pass holders -- AND an annual bus pass" and "build more well-designed neighborhoods containing walkable amenities." Some participants had more extravagant ideas; one proposes we "put bike thieves in public stocks -- immediately!" while another chooses "electric conveyer belts instead of roads" and yet another says "teleportation for everyone -- why can't we all have wings?" Another wing-themed suggestion involved everyone "riding a unicorn," an idea which was seconded by several parties.

Improved Transit as a Crowd Favorite

Overall, the most prevalent 'word on the street' at both locations was the desire to improve public transit. Most of you asked for buses to be more reliable, more plentiful, and cheap. As Rachel Marcuse, COPE's Executive Director, wrote on her Post-It note, "It's simple. I want more buses. Lots of buses."

Making public transit a free ride (paid for through taxes or some way other than fares) was the most popular concept of all. Several participants mentioned free-fare initiatives in Portland and Seattle and asking why Vancouver can't do something similar. It was certainly evident that transit in Vancouver is a hot topic of discussion and will continue to be in the near future.

We thank all of you who came by and shared your vision with us throughout the day. The variety and innovation we saw in your answers was truly awe-inspiring and showed us just how inventive Vancouver's residents can be.

For more thoughts and opinions regarding transit, check out our popular Tyee series "No Fares". These articles, written by Tyee Fellowship winner Dave Olsen and funded by our readers, make the case for free fares on public buses and show how that approach is working in other places.

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

12  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • OilbertaRedTory

    2 years ago

    Whimsical Tubes ...

    ... like human-sized pneumatic tubes ?

    That is sooo 1860's :

    http://www.capsu.org/history/pneumatic_despatch.html

  • carfreed

    2 years ago

    insanity

    having to share pathways with automobiles is insane,stressful and who thought out this one way back when? (obviously a motorist with city planning.)

  • Rod Smelser

    2 years ago

    Nearby Streets were jammed with ... cars.

    According to a letter in today's 24Hrs, nearby streets were jammed with parked cars and more cars circulating, prowling about hunting for parking spaces. I wonder how many of the people The Tyee spoke to had, just hours or minutes earlier, been an occupant of one of those cars?

    http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/PDF/2007/10/10/van061609.pdf

    Quote:
    I APOLOGIZE AHEAD for my cynicism but to me the “carfree” day thing seems like just another cash grab for local merchants. Although everyone was warm and fuzzy about saving the environment etc., you only had to move a block or two away from Main Street on Sunday to see the hundreds of cars racing around the neighbourhoods trying to find parking places so they could attend the event. I noticed the same thing last year on Commercial Drive as I was stuck in a major traffic jam on 1st Avenue. While sitting there, motionless, in a sea of cars spewing exhaust I had to wonder if this was going to have any impact whatsoever on our reliance on oil and cars. To me, it just seems like another lame excuse to hang out and spend money on crap.

    - Alan Layton, via e-mail

  • Stump

    2 years ago

    cars in the area

    No doubt some people drove to car-free day thereby completely missing the point, but I'll bet many of those 'hundreds' of cars may also have been through traffic looking to shortcut or find a way to avoid having to wait a few extra minutes at a light.

  • rac

    2 years ago

    Cheer Up

    Rod, there was no car parking along the car free streets. The traffic in the neighbourhoods could have mostly been people who would have driven to shop along the streets anyway.

    By the number of bicycles parked at the valet parking and on anything that didn't move, it was obvious that a lot of people cycled to the events.

  • Rod Smelser

    2 years ago

    The Festival Economy

    In a province that historically had more centennials than any other, and has hung it's hat during one recession on Expo86, and in this recession on the 2010 Olympics, I think there's a slight tendency to put too much faith in the Festival Economy, an approach called "bread and circuses" in an earlier time.

    CarFree Days! What a Blast! Carmen Mills and her friends will be overjoyed!

    But these days do nothing to actually give pedestrians any permanent claim to the street in question, and have all the earmarks of a dodge by local politicians. If there's a good argument to be made for closing a street to traffic, other than buses and taxis, why not just do it? Why toy around with CarFree Days?

    The answer is that the merchants along those streets figure they can maximize sales with a couple of days of partying, but a permanent exclusion would be ill-advised. And civic politicians and activists listen to those merchants very, very closely.

  • Stump

    2 years ago

    Just do it

    "But these days do nothing to actually give pedestrians any permanent claim to the street in question, and have all the earmarks of a dodge by local politicians. If there's a good argument to be made for closing a street to traffic, other than buses and taxis, why not just do it? Why toy around with CarFree Days?"

    It's an incremental process Rod. You start with a one event, once a year. You expand to more than one location more than once annually (where we are at now). Over time, people begin to understand that re-allocating a lane here and there isn't the end of the world and start to both support and participate in things like walking or bussing to work, or even cycling when suitable. I think it may be erroneous to consider the impetus behind Car-Free Days as having much to do with a 'festival economy' which, judging by your examples, have more to do with bringing visitors to the city rather than letting locals play in the streets once in a while.

  • Rod Smelser

    2 years ago

    Wake me when it's over

    Stump
    It's an incremental process Rod. You start with a one event, once a year. You expand to more than one location more than once annually (where we are at now). Over time, people begin to understand ...

    Will you promise to wake me when they get to the last increment and a street is actually converted to a pedestrian mall?

  • Stump

    2 years ago

    Be the change

    you wish to see. Always room for more people to help effect these changes AFAIK Rod.

  • Rod Smelser

    2 years ago

    Another Letter to 24Hrs on CarFreeDay

    In today's 24Hrs there's another letter on the subject of cars at CarFreeDay.

    Quote:
    WHAT PART of car free do you moron
    motorists NOT GET? You don’t drive your car to a car free event. Take transit to truly be eco-friendly. Hundreds of cars swarming around the neighbourhoods looking to park – what a debacle! Every car-free event is easily accessed with public transit and isn’t the goal of car free to be just that CAR FREE – even in the surrounding neighbourhoods! You should not drive to car-free events!

    - Roberta Gallagher, via e-mail

    So yesterday's writer wasn't the only person upset at the number of people driving to these events.

  • electric_bicyclist

    2 years ago

    This festival didn't have performers who walk their talk, like..

    BC Children's Festival Performers

    Vancouver BC Children's Festival Performers Canada

    Sustainable eco-friendly Kids Zone, main stage, roving, children's festival performers and artists who actually walk (ride) their talk.

    http://childrens-festivals-canada.blogspot.com/

  • Rod Smelser

    2 years ago

    Today, letters in support of CarFreeDay

    In today's 24Hrs there are two letters in support of CarFreeDay, one not so much.

    Quote:
    THANKS TO Roberta Gallagher (24 hours, June 18) for providing more evidence that the ‘Car-Free’ events are bogus. I’m sure some of those who go are truly eco-conscious and take transit, but the majority are there to enjoy the party and buy stuff. The car is here to stay and despite decades of “awareness” only economics have had any effect on their usage. Independent transport has been a major desire in humans since we descended from the trees and the convenience of the car is overpowering. And what do you think the inhabitants of the developing
    nations are going to buy as they become more affluent? Bicycles? Bus passes? No, it’ll be cars. It’s time to face facts and put our energy into developing cleaner fuel sources. A few street parties aren’t going to make the slightest bit of difference.

    - Alan Layton, via e-mail

    Quote:
    RE: CAR-FREE DAY: I disagree that this day was a cruel and silly joke! I live in the West End and truly appreciated not having to walk out of my building to crowded sidewalks, Denman Street congested with bumper to bumper cars. There was also a lot fewer people crowding up our beach. There needs to be more car-free days in the West End! For once the morons who run this city did something right!

    - Traysea Stelmack, via e-mail

    Quote:
    TRULY ENJOYED the Car-Free day on Main Street and the Drive. Had a great time, spent lots, ate lots and have only one complaint. The idea was to walk, bike or bus to the event. I bussed. Sadly, the service on Sunday really sucks. Overcrowded, dirty buses, if you can find one. Once again TransLink has missed the mark. Perhaps if we elected TransLinks’
    officials, things would improve.

    - T. Bear, via e-mail

    http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/PDF/2007/10/10/061909.pdf

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.