Mediacheck

Ho Hum, They're Rioting in Toronto

Much of the world media snoozed through the G20 clashes. Add your own links to good reporting below.

By Crawford Kilian, 29 Jun 2010, TheTyee.ca

Cops in riot gear at G8 summit

Conflict coverage vied with soccer contests. Flickr / picturenarrative.

While our own media covered the G20 weekend in detail, the rest of the world wasn't really all that interested. A quick survey of news media around the world suggests they looked for a local angle, or settled for coverage of the riots.

In Europe, the Spanish website Publico.es offered a slideshow of cops and demonstrators. A Vancouver freelancer was quick to publish an opinion piece in The Guardian, saying we have little to show for the G20 security bill.

The Moscow Times report focused on the G20 meeting, with a casual mention of the riots at the end of the story. In Germany, Spiegel Online ignored the riots completely but complained in detail that the conference had made no real progress.

Al Jazeera ran several stories on the G20, including one on mass arrests of demonstrators.

In Asian media, China's Xinhua news agency looked on the bright side, claiming that G20 boosts Toronto businesses.

Korea's Chosun Ilbo ran a big story about the riots, giving it more prominence than its story about the conference itself.

Vietnam's prime minister was the focus of reporting in Thanh Nien News, but it also ran a story on the conference featuring a photo of a burning Toronto police car.

NetIndian ignored the riots and emphasized the praise heaped on India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh by U.S. President Barack Obama.

Latin America was distracted today by Brazil's 3-0 victory over Chile in the World Cup, and by the assassination in Mexico of a candidate running for the governorship of Tamaulipas state.

But Brazil's Folha Online had a big headline about 850 demonstrators arrested. O Globo ran a video news clip featuring burning cop cars.

In Mexico, El Universal ran its story with a big photo of two huge Toronto cops dealing with a young woman lying face down on the pavement. And the story in Colombia's El Espectador emphasized the complaints of reporters about their treatment by Toronto police.

Digital Journal, meanwhile, praised the rise of citizen journalism at the G20 summit, with several photos of riot cops and camera-wielding citizen journos.

On Facebook, Resist G20 offered a forum for everyone.

And the summit itself published a declaration on its own website and said nothing about the riots.

The Tyee, meanwhile, is inviting people to submit their own eye-witness accounts to editor@thetyee.ca.

And you are invited, as well, to post in the comment thread below links to coverage of the G20 protests that you found useful.  [Tyee]

50  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Pete Allen

    1 year ago

    best roundup of citizen journalism regarding police action & law

    Best coverage of what the police actually did and what laws they actually disregarded:

    toronto.mediacoop.ca

  • Pete Allen

    1 year ago

  • The brain

    1 year ago

    Was there anything truly meaningful for the media to report?

    First, we had 20 political leaders coming together to make promises they couldn't keep. "We promise to reduce our woeful public spending by half within three years". The sad truth of it is that if these nations don't get their fiscal houses in order, it will go from bad to worse. I won't bore you with the details of how bond markets don't just look at public debt for risk but the combined totals of public/household/corporate debt against assets like regular accountants do with balance sheets, but if you like (and it wouldn't hurt for a good number of us who think they know whats going on but don't) try this link:

    http://www.americacanada.blogspot.com/

    Euro woes, Asian Real estate bubbles, whats next for us? Things are getting heddy. People are getting restless. Environments are declining, there are more and more of us and the best leadership can do is make promises they can't keep and who should be surprised at this? Its not like they've suddenly found their abilities to tell the truth. Responsablities, Accountabilities, Sustainabilities...

    The protesters who showed up maskless got to feel just how unwanted their presence was in police friendly Toronto. Did any one of their causes get airtime? Did any of them make a difference? Did but one groups name get whispered to the emperors of their empires? It looked like people acting it out to feel engaged, as though they were doing something right, like the world was watching perhaps but was teh world watching?

    And then the police, the ones in "black"... if they truly wanted to give themselves a good name, maybe they could have actually confronted their ego driven, disruptive alter egos instead of watching the "black bloc" dictate the flow. My God how reactionary and poorly pre-planned. Its not like the black bloc was something new to the world. Show up and react was the best the police could do? An easy way to lose a game of chess if I ever saw one.

    I can't help but think back to the protesters who actually made a major difference in this world. Gandi... Martin Luther King... Jesus Christ... some of us are thinking "increments" I know, I know (sounds eerily like Harper, "increments"... any takers on Dick Fadden hinting on Harper being "chummy" with nations abroad? (as well as ones close by) Steve was a lobbyist after all, nicely brainwashed by his southern brethern quite young... got distracted, where was I), but seriously. Gandi. Martin Luther King. Jesus. Does anyone really think the Godfathers of protest would have bothered to show for this one? 1.3 billion spent to burn out cops on box dinners and O.T., and preserve a few extra cars and glass.

    "Next time dear (and not so dear) leaders, do us all a favour and send us your broken promises by e-conference?" Just askin'. Never mind, we know you aren't listening (cept maybe Harper, he likes to waste public funds that way too).

  • Ramone

    1 year ago

    Another good opinion piece in the Guardian...

    ...is this one by John Hilary.

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jun/27/g20-toronto-policing-charade

    An excerpt:
    "To a foreigner, the Canadian police are a confusing bunch. With Toronto locked down for the G20 summit, several of them have been cycling around the deserted streets on mountain bikes presenting what we would see as the very picture of community policing. Yet side by side with this benign image is an intimidating, militarised presence that many Canadians feel has been deliberately cultivated in order to undermine their right to protest against the G20 and its damaging impacts."

  • miguel

    1 year ago

    International reportage

    Most of the reports in the Guardian were about the futility of the meeting itself. The Monday report on DemocracyNow was more in depth than some of ours.

  • off-the-radar

    1 year ago

    @ramone

    that Guardian piece is good and a good one to forward: short, interesting and well-written plus the credibility of the Guardian.

    The direct-reporting pieces are excellent but most of my acquaintance wouldn't believe the writers or even take the time to read.

  • Glen Murtz

    1 year ago

    I for one...

    am just happy that the BCTF's Pension Plan is still free to invest in any multinational tobacco company stock it wants to. I mean sure, I love civil liberties and all that gay-rights, organic food, enviro, blah-blah-blah junk; I'm a cultural liberal who drives a nice big SUV and sort of regrets it - but when it comes to my savings plan and RRSP's, well, crack open all the heads you want boys - cuz I'm a total conservative/neo-fascist about *my* money!
    I'm old enough and mature enough to realize state-granted rights and global capital don't actually go together too well. LOL. At least that's what my ROI has always shown! Seriously. I looked. It's hilarious.

    Far as I'm concerned, those cops were cracking heads so us Boomers can take our 6 week vacations in Oahu. Which I'll do again next year, thank you very much.
    Heck, I guess if I was pressed, I'd help hold my grandkids down while the cops sh** kicked them, if I could get another 3% return on my portfolio!
    LOL. Sucks to be you, Jeremy!
    Aloha Bloc-heads!

  • Grumpy

    1 year ago

    G-20 Like who cares

    All the G-20 was - was a media fest for a lot of inept politicians desperate to maintain their profligate lifestyles, Harper the Hated included.

    What we go was the typical Canadian police goon show with Gestapo style mass arrests and a trampling on our so called democratic lifestyle.

    As for Toronto, too bad they didn't burn the city down, it would have been a fitting end to central Canadian rule over Canada.

    In the end, the meetings and protests meant nothing as Canada and the rest of the world are sliding into economic oblivion and the riot police will be tested daily to cope with food riots and revolution.

    The end is coming faster than a BC Rail gate court case.

  • seth

    1 year ago

    black shirts

    were the police. thats why they did nothing

  • Jeffrey J.

    1 year ago

    Police Aide and Abet G20 Riot

    An incredible eye witness account of the G20 'riots' aided by the police.

    Everyone I assume recalls the hamfisted efforts by the police in Montebello, Quebec when they pretended to be anarchists in order to start a riot. Thankfully, it was captured on video, and alert union leaders stopped it from becoming a riot.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=St1-WTc1kow

    Clearly, their strategy has been refined since then. This time, they got their riot, but not without some extra care and planning.

    THIS is how a police state looks like, folks. And like all police states, they run on escalating trajectories. The early use of force in Germany and Italy was much, much less than the later use of force. Such is the history of concentration of power. There is no evidence Canada will be any different.

    The trajectory will continue.

    Excellent coverage Tyee!

    http://www.rabble.ca/news/2010/06/g20-police-let-rioters-run-amok-and-then-struck-back-hard-all-activists

    "It would appear that the security forces allowed this riot to happen in order to justify the $1 billion which appeared to have been wasted on security measures in Huntsville and Toronto."

    IN HIS OWN WORDS
    G20 police let rioters run amok and then struck back hard at all activists
    BY DAVID LANGILLE | JUNE 27, 2010

    Alongside my neighbours from the Danforth area, I joined the large march on Saturday afternoon on the first day of the G20 Summit in Toronto. We felt proud to be there alongside over 10,000 other Canadians -- women, unionists, students, teachers, people of all ethnicities and backgrounds -- demonstrating our commitment to peace and social justice. We passed by hundreds and hundreds of police without an incident...

  • realisticman

    1 year ago

    Conspicuous by Absence

    Yes, there were some incidents in Toronto last Saturday. Sunday was generally quiet after the arrests Saturday night and Sunday morning. There were many arrests and hundreds detained. We saw police cars, vans, buses, bicycles and helicopters. We saw fire engines. What we did not see were any ambulances. This massive operation with multiple actions occurring simultaneously in downtown Toronto was delicately carried out and apparently not one single ambulance was called. That is extraordinary and the police should be praised for that.

    Various reports confirmed this:

    http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/rabble-staff/2010/06/people-first-march-and-toronto-riot-600-tweets

    http://www.nypost.com/p/news/international/riots_rock_toronto_cuffed_xg8fjPHmFRP2H9XDCaWtNN

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100628/ap_on_re_ca/cn_world_summit_protests

    The Montréal Gazette is a bit more cynical but offers a valuable perspective:

    " ... A Toronto columnist quoted one arrested protester heard on CBC Radio complaining that she'd been given only inferior "bread with a piece of cheese, which proves to me I live in a fascist police state." Oh yes? What would she call Iran, then? Another complained that there was no vegan food in jail.

    This fuss in Toronto was no riot. In Thailand, 82 died in riots this spring. The Seattle WTO protest of 1999 had 40,000 demonstrators. Detroit's 1967 race riot left 43 dead and perhaps 2,000 buildings burned down. ..."

    Read more: http://www.montrealgazette.com/opinion/editorials/call+that+riot/3214402/story.html#ixzz0sFun5F1y

  • Frank

    1 year ago

    Hmm

    So the media thinks 30,000 more people should join the Black Bloc so that Canada can have "world class" riots.

    I hope the same media aren't whining about the property damage then.

  • realisticman

    1 year ago

    Cough up Frank

    We should all whine about the property damage Frank. We will all have to pay for that through our own insurance purchases. As you must know, insurance risks and costs are spread.

    If the vandals did achieve one thing it was to utterly ruin any prominence of legitimate protests.

  • Frank

    1 year ago

    r'man

    I'm always happy to pay my share r'man.

    As for the "vandals", they didn't ruin anything. Harper and the other leaders don't pay any attention to protesters. Something you and the National Post et al have yet to learn.

  • Tbarnston

    1 year ago

    Charade

    Has anyone ever considered the "Black Bloc", or at least an amorphous group imitating them, is quite likely a straw man supported by the authorities to justify their massive security budgets?

    A major benefit to having a group like the "Black Bloc" is that the media can focus on the riots, arrests, and police brutality instead of the issues (and solutions) that the legitimate progressive organizations put forward during these summits.

    The Black Bloc, or at least their tactics, has now been used to mute an important avenue of direct action because every significant grassroots protest is likely to be populated with these hooligans, which will allow authorities to respond with a massive police intervention, deflating momentum of the protest.

  • offended

    1 year ago

  • Marysue52

    1 year ago

    agents provacateurs

    T Barnston is likely right. Of course, it could be the police themselves decked out as agents provacateur (where's spellcheck?)as they were against CEP during a peaceful march a year or two ago. Fortunately they and their cop boots were caught on video and played on youtube for days! It could be corporate police (Walmart, Big Oil, Big Munitions, Big Mines, Big Pharma, even Big Computer, Big Clothing, Monsanto and Cargill and Big Media) hired to subvert. They did it in Chile in 1963, in the Congo, and lately in Australia, taking down an ELECTED leader and supplanting him with a fine corporate stooge. They even had the heads of unions backing them...which is a big problem here, too. They likely did it in BC, with false testimony against Premier Glenn Clark with help from Liberal-in-Disguise Doshanj. Of course, the media 'just happened; to be there to film everything. But they weren't there for Campbell's indiscretions! WHY? People don't like to believe in Conspiracies, and would rather believe in the Tooth Fairy, that Capitalism creates "wealth", instead of exploiting it, and that there's a profit to be made out of thin air, and that the poor are just not working hard enough and therefore are responsible for their state (even if they're 3 years old, apparently) and that global warming is merely only natural climate change and it will all right itself, etc. Arghh. Most people are so brainwashed and ignorant and stubbornly refuse to think or change.

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Strategy and Tactics...

    I have no doubt there is a "legitimate" Black Bloc that favours tactics of attacking banks and US owned businesses, as examples. Many different strategies and tactics are going to compete for effectiveness over the coming period. Some will advance, while others fall by the wayside... and I would not want to predict at this stage of things.

    That said, I, for myself, prefer tactics of preferably large scale "peaceful civil disobedience". And I do so largely for the simple reason that I think it will prove more useful for "mass" movement building, which at the end of the day, however the struggle later develops, is what is going to decide who rules and who is vanquished.

    But I've also got to be honest and complete in my analysis. I also think, at least right now, as is already being indicated by the early evidence, Black Bloc style tactics, if not Black Bloc activists per se, lend themselves to being "useful" to the State and their agents de provocateur, to justify propaganda-wise at least, attacks on "the whole" movement.

    Though it is yet really to be seen if tactics of "peaceful civil disobedience", with the emphasis on "disobedience" really fares any better from State/Police violence. I suspect not. But there is a greater chance that in the perceptions/optics of "the public", that they will be less inclined to sympathize with or support the police over time, if they are seen as needlessly "brutal". And again, at the end of the day, it is going to be about "winning" the public onside with the forces for social transformation.

    And this is NOT an attack on the "legitimate" Black Bloc, but merely a discussion with them, and a difference of view as to what "right now" is "effective vs ineffective" tactics. And which is not to deny that they have brought the light of media attention back to protest, as was/is failing with the Sunday Night Vigil crowd and emphasis. They, the Black Bloc, have established, I think, that there has to be more high drama brought to this "stage" of movement building. Again, "disobedience". A challenging of personal comfort zones AND The System.

    The post war prosperity period is dead, and the tactics that served the labour and progressive movements over the course of it.

  • emile

    1 year ago

    anarchy for saboteurs

    the news reporting tends to employ words as if they are understood the same way by all readers. this leads to debates where the energy is all coming from differences in mental imagery rather than from real differences.

    this sets us up for the battle of 'moot hill' where in spite of who wins or loses we all lose.

    some basic agreement on definitions and word usage in reporting are sorely needed as, for example, at

    http://goodshare.org/wp/anarchy-for-saboteurs/

  • jwstewart

    1 year ago

    The words seemed fairly straightfoward to me...

    One day, Rioting and wonton destruction by demonstrators.

    The next day, Random searches were performed, arrests were made without cause, by authorities who knowingly misinterpreted the bylaw and the charter of rights.

    Seems like neither side has respect for the law, it's just too bad they couldn't synchronize their schedules and have a geniune melee.

  • Erving Dogorilla

    1 year ago

    One journalist who witnessed the violence reports...

    http://dissidentvoice.org/2010/06/who-are-the-black-bloc/

  • BC Mary

    1 year ago

    We lost sight of ALL the genuine demonstrations ...

    .
    If these comments represent the best opinions of British Columbians toward the tragic events inflicted upon our largest Canadian city ...

    how can we expect any eastern understanding of BC issues?

    And wouldn't we all be better off with a little thoughtful understanding on both sides of the Rockies?

    There was media manipulation ongoing throughout the G20 event in downtown Toronto and it looks as if many people were caught up in that trap.

    Did nobody see or hear Toronto's chief of police?

  • Des

    1 year ago

    One Unexpected

    report I heard on the radio concerned the reporters gathered around Fake Lake at the media centre - you know, the place with the big plastic six-centimetre deep swimming pool and the giant tv screens broadcasting scenery from Huntsville while the reporters lounged around in their Muuskoka chairs.

    Guess what? The soccer games were on the little tv, so the reporters all turned their chairs around and watched that one.

    The games were more interesting than the riots outside. (Angela Merkel and Sarkozy both skipped G8 meetings to watch their respective teams compete earlier.)

    I wonder if Harper and his Cons arranged the Canadian meetings of the G8 and G20 at this time, knowing that the World Cup schedule has been set long ago? Was Toronto picked to be the fall guy and target deliberately? Tony Clement's riding in Huntsville was pork-barreled for both groups originally, but only the G8 met there, the G20 people shifted to Toronto at a later date. One Black Bloc rioter could have taken down Huntsville all by himself.

  • crankypants

    1 year ago

    If

    If I owned one of those businesses that was trashed by the Black Bloc, legitimate or police plants, I would be suing the City of Toronto for compensation. These business all pay taxes to the city, and as such should expect police protection from these types of antics. In the clips I saw on the newscasts, the police acted like spectators, not law enforcement officers. Maybe their reluctance to engage at that time does lead more credence to the theory that there were plants in the unruly mob.

    Either way, the businesses that were destroyed cannot get their insurance companies to pony up because of the riot, and I don't think it is fair to saddle the owners with the cost.

  • soleprobe

    1 year ago

    Good grief… picture of a G20 she-cop in black… hilarious

    To serve and protect.... :)

    http://files.abovetopsecret.com/images/member/d31d23200193.jpg

    Some hilarious variations

    http://i46.tinypic.com/2ywwz9w.jpg

    http://files.abovetopsecret.com/images/member/57da103bd16c.jpg

    Stills taken from the following video showing G20 Toronto Police Agent Provocateurs

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TbLU9tdDwxo&feature=player_embedded#!

  • soleprobe

    1 year ago

    On a more serious note... Canada is long gone

    Amy Miller, a young independent journalists with a press pass was detained for 13 hours in a cell with 25 other young women, threatened with rape and witnessed young female detainees stripped searched by male cops and one was evidently fingered.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-amzGk7qN8&feature=player_embedded

    If this doesn't make your blood boil what will? But of course our sicko bilderberg-run media won't cover this outrage and as a result some will get invited to the next meeting for their fine journalism.

  • j9

    1 year ago

    some g20 reports from non corporate-stream media

    http://rabble.ca/

    http://www.mediacoop.ca/

    http://bchannelnews.tv/

    http://pacificfreepress.com

    from paul manley (the guy who filmed the undercover cops at the spp protest in montebello):

    First my interview with a photo journalist who followed the black block for 1.5 hours and 24 blocks without any police interference until they reached the official designated protest site, got out of their black clothes, dispersed through the crowd and left the scene. Then the police brutally attacked peaceful protesters in the designated protest zone with batons and pepper spray.
    G20 Toronto Black Block get green light to rampage? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5G7aCgXtWg

    Full video of police charging on protesters as they finished singing the national anthem
    http://www.vimeo.com/12903946
    How respectful - they waited until the anthem was over and then charged!

    Amy Miller - Alternative Media Centre, Independent Journalist http://vimeo.com/12925239
    Describes her arrest and detainment at Toronto Film Studio makeshift prison including strip searches and threats or rape.

    The peaceful protest courtesy Alex Lisman. This is the story the media hasn't covered. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2mL46t8H4oU

    More of the peaceful protest where I followed Dave Coles from the Communications Energy and Paperworkers Union. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zQchFZ8zLw

    Amnesty International is calling for an inquiry and so are some folks on facebook
    Canadians Demanding a Public Inquiry into Toronto G20 on Facebook
    http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=135629036463012

    During the 12 days I was in Toronto I witnessed the police overreact and provoke innocent people. The first person I videotaped being arrested was charged and detained for 3 hours on Monday June 21 for possession of break and enter tools - the break and enter tool was the key to her workplace! The police didn't listen to her and only released her after finally calling her employer. She asked me not to post the video.

    I have lots of footage of police searching people on the street and as they try to enter parks in the vicinity of protests. I have footage of journalists and innocent bystanders being attacked and I have footage of the Council of Canadians and the canoe flotilla as they tried to paddle to Deerhurst resort. We had five police boats, two helicopters and RCMP zodiacs at ready to stop four canoes! Security indeed!

    I also have great footage of events and speakers at the Peoples Summit Launch and the Shout Out for Global Justice and interviews with people on the streets explaining why they and all of us should be opposed to the agenda of the G20. I will be posting lots of this content on the Canadians Nanaimo youtube site (http://www.youtube.com/user/CanadiansNanaimo) as well as packaging programming for the Smart Change Cable Access Coalition project (http://smartchange.ca/project/cable-access-coalition).

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    "My country broke my heart"

    My country broke my heart"
    Jeffrey J wrote:

    Quote:

    "THIS is how a police state looks like, folks. And like all police states, they run on escalating trajectories. The early use of force in Germany and Italy was much, much less than the later use of force. Such is the history of concentration of power. There is no evidence Canada will be any different."

    And if you think that is an exaggeration....and if you only have time to read one thing today....read this first-hand account that "emk" provided on another thread...and remember that these are early days...and that as Ed Deak often reminds us - things can swiftly change overnight:

    http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=397205503638&id=511491565&ref=mf

    The thing is, the values of a global market culture are constantly reinforced through repetitive advertising, where like trained seals its bewitched audience is taught to constantly value the insignificant and the artificial... over the significant and the real.

    Our human concerns are thus made insignificant - they are intentionally down-played, trivialized and smeared into insignificance.

    Their corporate ones are thus made highly significant....and to be urgently addressed.

    Inversely,

    Their corporate crimes become paltry stuff, immaterial, irrelevant, inconsequential....insignificant. The mere selling of rivers, the mere decimation of human rights, the mere killing of the Gulf of Mexico.

    The mere poisoning of the very things needed for survival on this planet.

    But standing up in protest and outrage against the above?

    That crime is apparently both significant...and unforgivable.

    Within a police state.

  • RickW

    1 year ago

    Mr. Harper is so proud of saving mothers and their newborns.....

    ...but what about the followup?
    http://www.starvedforattention.org/

  • Jerry Munro

    1 year ago

    Within A Police State...

    Outstanding, above me here, Lynn. I read it three times.

    When you nail it woman, you nail it!

    Love ya.

    Coyote

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    thanks, Coyote.....

    You wrote:

    "This should be viewed as a learning experience by the anti-capitalist and social revolutionary left. It was the most realistic demonstration to date, in this country, of raw ruling class State power. Though, kid yourselves not, they have even scarier arrows in their quiver, and such even more capacity for brutality as we have not yet seen."

    Yes, a watershed moment, I think, with more and more Canadians feeling like outsiders who no longer hold a stake in their own country. Certainly that young fellow on Facebook, and no doubt many more like him, have come to that disturbing realization.

    When I was his age, Canada was all things bright and beautiful...this is a different room now with a far different and darker view to inherit......

    But perhaps, as you've often expressed on these pages, these corporate thugs and their mercenary security forces are doing us a favour, defining the parameters of this struggle ever more clearly... and in your words - "awakening the working masses of this country again, and as will bring them in due course to challenge the assumed rights, legalities and privileges of Capital."

  • RickW

    1 year ago

    lynn

    Quote:
    When I was his age, Canada was all things bright and beautiful...this is a different room now with a far different and darker view to inherit......

    As I read more of our past, I wonder if it really was "bright and beautiful":
    http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Walter+Rudnicki+1925+2010/2682874/story.html
    Gordon Pinsent spoke eloquently of Walter Rudnicki on his CBC program "The Late Show" and in doing so revealed some sinister goings on in government that we were seldom privy to.

    Perhaps, what with a sense of general disillusionment that underlies our current society, we've come to expect our governments to be underhanded and secretive, instead of being surprised and disappointed that they would do these things.

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    Rick W

    "As I read more of our past, I wonder if it really was "bright and beautiful"

    You are, of course, absolutely right, Rick.....probably it is only the surface of things that gleams "bright and beautiful" ....a more tarnished story usually unfolds when we dig more deeply.

    I guess we colour the past with our memories and emotions as time moves on...and I remember Canada (ahhh....sweet and flawed memory) as a much more hopeful place then, where at least a Polish immigrant could arrive at the Vancouver Airport without leaving it in a body bag.

    An extremely interesting article you linked, too...I wasn't aware of so much of that background information.

    Not many that compare with Walter Rudnicki - what a rare and wonderful man!

    My husband comes from Scottish-Metis roots and really enjoyed reading the article as well.

    Thanks.

  • samuidave (not verified)

    1 year ago

    the problem with the facebook link...

    ...is that it IS a facebook link.

    Why don't you cut and paste, or perhaps "printwhatyoulike" and .pdf, the essay and see if you can't pass it along.

    I am sure you can appreciate that there is a whole world of people who have no interest in joining such sites. Thanks.

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    samuidave

    I will post a series of excerpts....it is a very long piece on Facebook.....so some context may be missing but it is still very revealing in itself...and for the journey that this highly disturbing experience took the young writer of this piece on. As he said at the end it has changed him forever:

    "We got to Bay and College when around 20 mini-vans full of riot cops honked their horns and went flying through the intersection - I had
    never seen anything like it, it was crazy. We arrived at University Ave to find it completely blocked off by riot cops in full gear. The
    "Free Speech Zone" was completely blocked in. The cops wouldn't answer any questions, wouldn't move, wouldn't look at you. Nothing. Then rows of riot police form on College behind us, start banging their shields and march in, followed by a rows of mounted horse units. Then out of nowhere two young guys are pepper sprayed nearby, everyone runs,
    nothing is said by police, no announcements. People help the guys and pick them up, they don't know what happened or why.....

    Shortly after some homeless people threw on arm bands and had extending night sticks and tackled people standing around and dragged
    them behind the dense line of riot cops and dragged them away. Secret under-cover homeless police -

    We head towards them to leave; they say 'Get Back', no problem. We turn to leave the other way, more riot cops "Get Back". Okay, We ask if we can please leave - no response. They haven't said anything.
    There are journalists in here, a couple comes out of The Keg and tries to leave, they are told, "It's too late." Too late for what they ask, and are told nothing. ......

    Then the riot squads form a half circle around us, shield to shield.

    People angry, afraid. We were nowhere close to the fence; there was no violence - what was this? People singing a John Lennon song all arrested?" ......

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "The unmoving riot officers had arm badges saying they were from Calgary. Then all at once, they took some pill and took a sip from the tubes attached to their riot gear. It became clear they were a little
    confused, a supervisor was yelling at them they were in a wrong formation, some of them tripped over each other. I noticed the street was blocked off at both ends, no media anywhere at either end...denied access to see what was happening down here. Soon the street was full of buses and paddy wagons and riot cops outnumbered people 5 to 1.
    Many of the cops behind the semi-circle took off gear and lay down, sweaty on the sidewalk, obviously overworked. One by one, officers
    would come through the shrinking semi-circle line and take people roughly away. People would turn and offer their hands peacefully, waiting to go.

    Next to us was a guy with a green mohawk, punky looking guy, two approaching arresting officers laughed and said "I want to get this
    guy right here", they pushed through the other people, grabbed and spun him around and pushed him away roughly. He didn't say anything or
    resist in anyway. Jesus. Another male officer says to the gay couple "I'll go find some lady officers to arrest you boys." His patch says Toronto. Really?.......

    I turned and offered my hands, I was handcuffed and made to walk backwards across the street to officers in front of the Novotel. I'm
    handed over, searched, asked my name - all very peaceful. My arresting officer asked me if I understood I was being arrested - I said I understood, but I didn't know why. He
    paused. "You're being charged with - " He stops, talks with someone else, moves me, and says "Mischief......"

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "The other guys tell me they never had their rights read either and were all told different reasons for the arrest "Disturbing the peace" "Obstructing Justice" and so on. No one clear reason we were all there. I can only make out their silhouettes when they lean forward, no lights. .....

    We arrived outside of the wet and dark Toronto Film Studio, with its large gates and armored guards and dozens of police cars and fenced off areas. It was creepy. The buildings were huge and grey with red signs with white numbers on them. It was something from a George Orwell novel. Large spotlight pointing down from posts, in the rain.
    Our bus was stopped in front of a large garage door to one of the hanger-sized buildings. The door rolls open a light pours out from it.

    We drive inside.....

    We all agreed that we were the hundreds of protesters left at the end of the day; long after the violence was done that afternoon. But hey,
    how do you justify to the people of Canada that we spent 1.2 Billion dollars? You arrest all the protesters. We thought we might held for
    24 hours so that the streets would be cleared from people demonstrating their right to free speech. I mean, they closed down the
    "Free Speech Zone" in a public space, so... why were we there? Finally an officer comes on the bus and states “come forward and give your
    number". So one by one we go. Outside we are handed off to a Court Service officer, all with "Special Constable" patches. Some have removed their nametags, others have them still on....."

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "Hanging about down to about 15 ft off the ground are rows of intense florescent lights. Dozens of rows as far as I can see in either
    direction. Over each cell is a small black pod container a camera. It appears to be a maze made of industrial shelving, construction office trailers, wooden decks and walkways and cages. The cages are roughly 12' by 20' and around 10' high. There is sheet metal on 3 sides; the front side has a sliding door section that locks. Inside each cage is a porto-potty with the door removed, no toilet paper. It reaches close to the ceiling is about 4'x4' around. Those potties -bright orange,
    with an elaborate art deco style molding. A 1.2 billion dollar porto-potty to be sure. I pass rows of the cages with people bleeding,
    crying slumped on the concrete floor. Huddled, asking to call family, asking for water, asking what the charge is, wanting to know their
    rights. All the officers were All the officers were ignoring them and laughing at people. I have never seen anything like this.....

    I was now around 2:00am. I've been held since 10:30pm, not read my rights, not explained anything, not yet charged, no phone call. And in
    an overcrowded cell with no access to water. Every guy had to pee; there was a line around the inside of the cell to piss. Trying to pee
    with your hand cuffed together was horrible...but we all managed...the outhouse was messy. No toilet paper. So, here we all were. Ages from
    16-78. Three German men asked why the guard made a joke about Auschwitz. They were here from Germany, left a bar, got arrested. They said they had no idea Canada was like this; they said the world
    thought we were free. The said "poor Canadians, this is shame". ....

  • John Greg

    1 year ago

    Woah

    Thanks for posting that Lynn. Mighty disturbing and sad to see what our once rather nice country (even if it is it is "only the surface of things that gleams 'bright and beautiful'") has become under the leadership of the corporate suite.

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    The stories from the men in the cell were all very similar. Some were protesters in the Novotel March, one man was having dinner at the Keg
    with his girlfriend (who was also arrested), there were two journalists, a homeless old man with a big grey bird and long hair with scruffy clothes- he was almost in tears and confused, he said
    they grabbed him walking on Carlton. He then asked us "What's a G20?"...

    The 16 year old kid hasn't been able to call his parents and nowhe's locked up with 39 men. The cage houses all kinds. There's a young gay couple curled up together. Some men have no shoes, some no laces
    and some still have both. Wet socks and feet and clothes in this freezing, unending hanger.....

    I was feeling the crowded cell growing tense and angry. One black, shorter male Toronto Officer came over as we began pleading for an explanation, for water and for some of use to be moved into another
    cell. He came over and said, "This is wrong. Guys, I'm sorry, this is fucked up. But there's nothing I can do. This place is just chaos. I'm
    sorry." he leaves......

    "Please, we need water. Please help us. Please help this 16-year-old kid. Please split us up, we can't even all sit in here". We look at
    the camera and beg for help. We can hear people in the other cells yelling and begging for water. We hear a girl 'Please! I need my medication! HELP ME!". I yell "Help that girl, what the hell is going
    on here!" Other cages begin to yell. I find out later this girl was in my girlfriends cell and was way passed her medication time. The male
    officers were laughing in at her and tapping their keys along the bars leering at the girls in wet clothes. Finally two female officers took
    the girl away. They also had a 17-year-old girl in her cage as well......."

  • John Greg

    1 year ago

    Temporary cages

    Pictures of those temporary cages remind of the illegal alien cages in Children of Men. They are a truly frightening reflection on the devastating and obscene moral corruption of our political and business so-called leaders.

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "Then, down the hall across from my cell I saw this: the bald Barrie officer was dragging in a kid with mild cerebral palsy (I saw him with
    a friend while they were arrest, he was so scared). He pushed and then they said something to him, his clothes were torn and his eyes read
    from crying. I guess they wanted his shoes, because he struggled to lift his leg (his pants were falling down) when the officer slammed
    his leg down 'Never mind. Stop being stupid" he laughed at the kid, as did the other officer. Away they went. Heard a door slam. ....

    We were told many
    times about being processed and we'd reach what they called "the Otherside". What was there? I don't know. They said that we'd have to
    wait again there anyways. What was this Otherside? Someone suggested we'd be turned into cheese slices. I said I would make terrible
    Soylent Green. A few guys laughed emptily.......

    We tell her about the 16 year old, she writes down his information and says she'll do something about it. I see her several times in the
    next few hours, ignoring us as we ask for an update. Poor kid. His
    poor parents. We see officer White a few more times, he always apologizes. They say they are looking for people they suspect of
    bigger crimes first - an officer comes by and yells "Islam! Is there an Islam in here?" Nope, no one by that name here......"

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "And my heart simply broke. That's the only way I can describe it. My beloved country, my city. I looked down at my t-shirt - bright blue
    with a big white maple leaf and in bold, caps letters below: FREEDOM. I kid you not. I was proud to wear that shirt earlier that day. Now it
    stung. I was so helpless and empty. For those of you who may not think this sounds like much, or is justified, you weren't there. People from
    all walks of life were breaking in that place, including police officers.....

    I'm lead down to Cell Block OL 2. Across from us are large sections of industrial shelves and we can see into deck area where 4 trailers meet, they each have a door. The door I can see says "Booking Room 10" with a red light above it. Cops lean on the railing, laughing, and dancing when people chant slogans from their cells. They think it's
    hilarious. Coming on 15 hours in custody. There are already around 15 men in this cell. They tell us some guys got removed a while ago.

    There are many similar stories in here and another journalist. There is one guy in an English soccer jersey that tells me he was at a bar,
    stepped out for a smoke and was arrested. He was a huge soccer fan and was about to miss the big Germany/England match. The 16 year old was
    now in this cell. Around 10am there was a shift change in officers and we began begging for water again, maybe these guards would help us. I
    notice the evidence shelves under label OL 6, there are 5 bags - but there were 40 guys in that cell...where's all our stuff?....."

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "I passed out. After begging for water. I passed out and fell over in jail. What was happening to me? No sleep, no water. They men went nuts
    "Is this what it takes, a guy passing out! Christ!! What's wrong with you monsters!" My head kills, they ask for medical attention for me, I
    second the motion and we're told "Not right now". Guys slump to the floor in defeat. The female officer who helped me aids in bringing
    some watery orange Tang to all the cells. We line up, quietly and broken for our drink. I find out that this same female officer broke down and cried with the women at their cell. She was
    sobbing and apologizing "This is wrong, you shouldn't be here. This is all so wrong". There own officers couldn't handle it, she was worn
    down by the injustices she was being ordered to do. This happened in Toronto. ...

    Across from our cell ..... We nicely talk with her
    through the cage. "Please tell us how you can do this? We are begging for water in here. This guy is only 16 and this guy passed out. Your
    co-workers laugh. They are joking to us about our rights and laughing at a disabled kid. You know this is wrong, what's happening" after too much of this, with tears in her eyes she breaks "I don't know
    anything, no one here knows anything! I'm not even a cop.." she then leaves in a hurry. Madness....."

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    contd.

    "The only evidence I can see that it's the day is a tiny hold 200 feet up with light on the outside. I wonder if anyone knows what happened down at the Novotel or what's happening in here? We've only seen officers - no lawyers, medics or media (other than the ones in cages). It's getting close to 24 hours in custody. I haven't slept in 40 hours
    and new prisoners are being brought in......

    ... just after the G20 was officially over, just before the legal 24 hours they could hold me, I was being rushed out. Convenient. They found a way to keep 500 legal protesters from their Constitutional
    rights. In this country. Canada. My shirt feels dirty. When I make it to the Otherside I see signs that let me know I was a Level 2 Detainee
    and I was heading in Levels 3 & 4.

    Inside this hanger, more cages and metal detectors. The L3 area housed
    small groups of men and women, looking battered, some bleeding. They all made peace sign and told me to tell everyone about them. Down
    another hall, rows of single person cells. These look like leaders, organizers, many bloody. I see the green mohawk guy. He says "Adios".
    I'm then put into another cage with some former cellmates. They tell me now to worry; they are taking us out one by one from here.

    Against the wall I'm told that was arrested for "breach of peace", I will not be charged, but if I am arrested for this or a similar crime
    again, I will be charged and appear in court. Do not join any more protests and assemblies during the G20.

    I have trouble speaking when she asks if
    I'm okay. I can barely keep it together. I tell her I'm fine. I'm not.
    She asks if they beat me - I don't know. I'm standing soaking wet in the rain on a collect call on a payphone with cars whizzing by. It
    took everything not to fall to my knees......

    I also notice how many people are raging about the protesters on facebook. Of course, the news is all about burning cop cars and broken windows. Things went exactly as I said when I saw those photos the
    previous afternoon. Jesus, it worked. Everyone got spoon fed a justification for the 1.2 Billion spent.......

    NOW:
    That's all true. Think about it. Is this Canada? Do you think this is
    right? You don't want to live in a country where this happens. It's changed my whole outlook and attitude on life. My responsibility to
    every human being in this world. Plato said, "The Price of Apathy towards public affairs is to be Ruled by Evil Men....

    The World needs you. Educate yourself.
    Your comfort is shame; your looking away kills people.
    You're not small. You're not helpless. You can do something.

    You have a voice, don't let them silence you before you even try to speak "

  • G West

    1 year ago

    Thanks Lynn

    If we've come this far under Harper in such a short time where will we be in another 3 years?

    There were a lot of young people celebrating Canada Day in my town...most of them were drunk.

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    Good to read you again, John Greg:

    "Pictures of those temporary cages remind of the illegal alien cages in Children of Men. They are a truly frightening reflection on the devastating and obscene moral corruption of our political and business so-called leaders"

    Yes, making us all illegal aliens in our own land.

  • lynn

    1 year ago

    G West wrote:

    "If we've come this far under Harper in such a short time where will we be in another 3 years?"

    On the dark side of the moon.

    That could be understating it. ;-)

  • John Greg

    1 year ago

    Lynn

    Thanks.

    Quote:
    Yes, making us all illegal aliens in our own land.

    Precisely. It's just so damn sad.

  • zalm

    1 year ago

    Thank you lynnn

    This is what war looks like. And I'm not sure we're up for it.

    Gawd, I wish we didn't have to fight it!

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.