Mediacheck

How to Attack a 'Fracking' Film

Documentary 'Gasland' shows flaming tap water caused by gas drillers 'fracking.' Industry speed dials its PR flaks.

By Kevin Grandia, 23 Jun 2010, TheTyee.ca

gasland2

Scene from 'Gasland'. Yes, that water is on fire.

Related

On Monday night the award-winning documentary Gasland got a big bump in profile when it was aired on HBO.

The film exposes the major human health and environmental impacts of an extraction method used by the natural gas industry called hydraulic fracturing (or "fracking").

And by the looks of the PR attack campaign launched today, it looks like Gasland is starting to get under the skin of the oil and gas industry.

I guess the dinosaurs in the dirty fuel lobby don't like videos of people who can light their tap water on fire after their wells are contaminated with methane gas, like this:

Of course the gas companies say this is all perfectly natural and has nothing to do with their operations, but Gasland documents the many stories of people whose drinking water is just fine until the gas companies come along and start pumping all sorts of toxic chemicals into the ground in an extraction process called hydraulic fracking.

In fact, I have heard this same story for years and as far north as Alberta, Canada where ranchers who have had natural gas drilling operations forced on to their properties can now light their water on fire. Not to mention the chemical burns their children get in the shower or the water irrigation shed that blew up in a ball of flames.

All perfectly natural indeed.

Shadowy spinners

Most of the PR push-back on Gasland appears to be coming from an oil and gas lobby group calling itself "Energy In Depth" whose anonymous website lists other oil and gas lobby groups, like American Exploration and Production Council, the Indiana Oil and Gas Association and the Texas Alliance of Energy Producers, as their members.

While the members of Energy in Depth might be listed, who is actually running the day-to-day operations and mounting the attack on Gasland is a bit of mystery.

No contact information, phone number, mailing address or anything else telling us who is organizing the group can be found on the website.

A little digging, finds that the website is registered to a Washington, D.C. public relations firm called FD Americas Public Affairs (formerly FD Dittus Communications).

FD's clients include other oil and gas lobby groups with one in particular that stands out, the American Energy Alliance, run by former Republican staffers Eric Creighton, Kevin Kennedy and Laura Henderson. The Energy Alliance ran an "Energy Town Hall" bus tour last summer attacking the Obama administration's Clean Energy and Security legislation.

As FD explains on its website:

"we have managed successful public affairs campaigns for clients on complex energy policy issues such as climate change, increased energy exploration and production, carbon capture and storage, electricity deregulation, natural gas prices, renewable energy development, and business and consumer energy efficiency."

An email that was forwarded to me gives a little further information on who's behind the PR push.

The email was sent by the Senior Public Affairs Representative for Anadarko Petroleum Corporation -- one of the world's largest independent oil and gas companies -- saying that the company is:

"actively engaged with groups like America's Natural Gas Alliance, Energy In Depth and the American Petroleum Institute to educate the public, government officials and other stakeholders about the errors in the film, and the truth about natural gas."

Looks like we're tipping!

In public relations, it is always a bit of a tricky decision about when to begin countering your opponents' message. If you hit back too early, you may give the story "oxygen" and inflame a controversy that may have gone away if ignored. But if you wait too long to counter your opponent you risk jumping in too late and losing the war of words. The trick is to watch for the tipping point.

Looks like the tipping point for Gasland's opponents was last night's HBO screening, so watch out because we're all about to subjected to more spin than the teacup ride at Disneyland.  [Tyee]

8  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • G West

    1 year ago

    Thanks for publishing this David

    I think an investigative series here at Tyee about how these same activities may be affecting Canadians and British Columbians would be valuable and timely.

    Especially looking at whether similar activities in Canada have been or would be exempted from liability and what body or bodies regulate such extraction methods here in Canada and in BC.

  • telus employee

    1 year ago

    How to attack public power

    In BC the private power industry and the BC Libs formed the astroturf group "BC Citizens for Green Energy" and have an army of letter writers (paid presumably) to support the policy. This 'grassroot' support for green energy really supports private power generation, disseminates misinformation and accuses their opponents of spreading misinformation.

  • vikanadian

    1 year ago

    trotter, le bon, creeley,

    trotter, le bon, creeley, bernays and of course our good friend dr paul joseph goebbels would be jizzing in their pants to see how far the PR dynamo has set our species back.

  • kl

    1 year ago

    Ahh, good old Kevin Grandia

    Kevin should know all about attacks. Him and his DeSmog blog came out swinging against the NDP the last Provincial election for not supporting a carbon tax. His DeSmog Blog was nothing more than an environmental front to win votes for his Liberal party. Turns out Grandia used to be a communication advisor for none other than Gordon Campbell and Raymond Chan. EDITED FOR PERSONAL INSULTS -- TYEE MODERATOR

  • G West

    1 year ago

    kl- you're absolutely correct

    And, that's why he spends all his time on the PR aspects of the story instead of the fundamentals - even so, the water quality issues are serious and need addressing - especially given the number of gas exploration leases Grandia's and Hoggan's Liberals have been selling in the past two years.

    I'd still like to know if there is legislative protection for potable water sources and aquifers in this province or, like mineral rights, have they already been sold off to the highest bidder.

  • shepsil

    1 year ago

    Good story, but look who the author is and why

    As mentioned above by G West & kl, he was a BC Liberal, last I checked as well. His boss, James Hoggan is a Public Relations pro who has placed himself as a go to guy on climate change.

    Hoggan, a big BC Liberal supporter, EDITED FOR LEGAL CONCERNS, AND FOR PERSONAL INSULTS DIRECTED AT THE WRITER. PLEASE REVIEW THESE COMMENTING GUIDELINES http://thetyee.ca/Comments/FAQ/#7 -- TYEE MODERATOR

    the corporate world, Gordon Campbell and the BC Liberals.

    Greenwashers are easy to brownwash, because the new definition of green can only be achieved by including social justice issues and people. One cannot separate the environment from people nor the other way round.

    This is also about transparency and the very nature of Corporate & Gov't PR is about obfuscating facts for political gain.

    Still a good article though!

  • doggone

    1 year ago

    Methane in your water?

    Some years ago the guy I was working for froze his water lines in his entryway. When he attempted to thaw the lines with a butane torch the buldge of ice burst in to flame.
    So I was not all that impressed when liquid water ignites
    Another site we built on drilled a water well that came up with lots of flamable gas. He thought he had hit the "Jackpot" turned out he had to cement the well
    Luckily for him it was not a mile under the ocean and spewing methane and oil at uncontrollable volume.

  • kl

    1 year ago

    Insults?

    Labelling somone as a political hack is an insult? Wow, grow some cajones Tyee. I'm pretty much done with this site. CBC has a much more open comments policy, it doesn't play big brother quite like the "progressive" Tyee does.

    Funny thing is is that probably some of my union dues are paying for the content on this site.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.