Mediacheck

Unlocked iPhones Could Herald True Mobility

Finally, in July, you can buy one and not be tied to a specific wireless carrier.

By Michael Geist, 22 Jun 2010, TheTyee.ca

iPhone

Four changes led to unlocking iPhone.

Apple begins selling the latest version of its iPhone this week in the United States, and while the device will not be sold in Canada until mid-July, Canadians will be among the few that will have the opportunity to purchase it "unlocked" so that it is not tied to any specific wireless carrier. The unlocked versions will come at a premium price, but in return consumers will be able to avoid the long-term contracts that have typified the Canadian wireless marketplace for many years.

The issue of locked cellphones has long been a source of consumer fear and frustration since some wondered whether unlocking phones that were rendered unusable when switching wireless providers was legal. In certain respects, this was an odd question to even have to ask. No one would ever question whether consumers have the right to tinker with their car or to use the same television if they switch providers from cable to satellite, yet the wireless industry somehow convinced the public that unlocking their phones -- consumers' own property -- was wrong.

That perception is rapidly changing with several developments paving the way for an unlocked iPhone.

Four developments freeing the iPhone

First, the new joint Bell-Telus network now means that Rogers is no longer the only provider capable of running the device. With each of the big three offering the device, an unlocked version makes consumer and business sense.

Second, Canadian wireless carriers have attempted to lock consumers into contracts for far longer than virtually any other developed country, with three-year contracts considered the norm. Several years ago, Canada instituted wireless number portability that allows consumers to keep their numbers when switching providers, yet long-term contracts have proven a major barrier to full portability. Given consumer frustration with long-term lock-in, offering a full-priced device without the contractual burden may resonate with consumers willing to pay more upfront for immediate contractual freedom.

Third, there has been a dramatic shift in power in recent years within the wireless marketplace. Until recently, wireless carriers occupied the power position, since handset makers depended on them for distribution of their devices. Carriers were able to extract favourable terms and demand carrier-specific restrictions on devices that ran on their networks. The popularity of smartphones from Apple, Research in Motion, and Google have reversed this dynamic, however, with the device makers now positioned to dictate terms to carriers anxious to offer hot devices that often run in short supply.

Fourth, the government sent signals earlier this month that it wants to avoid erecting new barriers that could render unlocking phones more difficult. Bill C-32, the recently tabled copyright bill, expressly excludes unlocking cellphones from its ambit. The last copyright bill would have made it a violation for Canadians to unlock their cellphones and banned the distribution of software programs that could be used to do so. This bill permits unlocking (subject to contractual restrictions), though obtaining the technical tools for those consumers with locked phones may prove difficult.

Given all of these developments -- marketplace demand for unlocked phones, changing power dynamics, and government policy designed to foster consumer mobility -- is there anything more to be done?

I'm finished, liberate my cell!

There is at least one stumbling block left that needs to be addressed. The availability of an unlocked iPhone may foreshadow a broader shift in the marketplace, yet millions of Canadians are still stuck with phones locked to a single carrier. Once the consumer contract expires, many believe the carrier should be obligated to unlock the phone upon request.

That obligation lies at the heart of the Cell Phone Freedom Act, a private member's bill introduced last week by NDP MP Bruce Hyer.

Whether by legislation or market pressure, it appears that true mobility may ultimately be coming to the Canadian mobile market.  [Tyee]

8  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • John Greg

    1 year ago

    Interesting, but ...

    I'm not sure it makes much difference, for a few reasons.

    First, the cost of these toys is simply beyond ludicrous. And that's not even considering that the manufacturers "new and improve" them about every six months rendering your, um, old one, er, obsolete.

    But more important, of what meaningful benefit is an unlocked cell phone when every single bloody service provider offers the same highly overpriced, and extremely limited choice service packages. We still get screwed in the end by these behemoths anyway.

    In my opinion the whole cell phone/smart phone ball and chain is still miles away from practical and fair.

    But thanks for the heads up.

  • seth

    1 year ago

    Unlock em

    You can buy locked GSm Nokia cell phones at the Goodwill for $1.4 most Mondays or other thrift stores.

    This link tells you how to unlock em. Easy peasey lemon squeezy.

    http://www.gsmliberty.net/shop/nokia_unlock.php

  • bcee

    1 year ago

    free my phone

    I have had an unlocked world GSM phone for three years now. The only way to talk! I bought it for 50$ and the vendor unlocked it for an additional 10$. I use a simple pay & talk plan. Sweet.

    When i go to Europe (i make an annual trip) I buy a new SIM card, pop it in and i am am now a local user! No roaming charges! Sweet.!! ( I get a new number with the new SIM card, but i simply email all my contacts that i wish to talk with that i have a new number for the next 3 weeks).

    So I have complete portability as far as my telephone number goes. I dropped Telus when we had the option to keep our number and went with Fido. But i am ready to drop even Fido if they don't smarten up and block some features that locked phones have.

    I have ZERO loyalty to cell carriers. And they have earned my scorn by their lack of transparency and other shenanigans.

    And don't even get me started with data plans!

    For now i have an iPod touch that i use for email and web browsing, tenet and other internet based services using free wi-fi hot spots.

    So bottom line for less than $30 every 6 weeks i have plenty of telecommunications at my disposal ;-)

    In the future I will consider an iPhone only if i can buy it unlocked AND without any data plan.

    (by the way what i save with my cell phone plan, comrade to what the average user spends ( $100-120 per month) I can fly to europe…SWEET! ;-)

  • snert

    1 year ago

    Lower Rates

    Not only unlocked phones but lower rates to reflect the fact that the carriers won't necessarily be subsidizing phones.

    I've had 2 phones since 1995, a battery eating Motorola brick and a Nokia mini brick (compared to what's available now) that just loves batteries.

    It took at least 6 years for the first battery to fail and the second one which I got for free and has held a charge just as long as the first is still going strong.

    Using an unlocked phone that has a SIM card in it just makes sense. The phone companies had to be forced to give up their monopoly on land line phones. I see no reason that they should keep it on mobile phones.

  • Paul9

    1 year ago

    Necessary?

    Half of my friends, family and colleagues own some sort of iPhone/MTC, and as often as I've played around with their shiny black toys, I just can't figure out the appeal. It's just as easy--and not as annoying to everyone around you--to sit at a regular desktop computer, check your email, surf the web (on a screen larger than 2" wide), and check the weather. 9 out of 10 users who show me their phone seem to be more interested in some stupid "app" (it's actually called software, people) than the actual utility of such a device. No, I'm not some anti-technology fuddy duddy, but seriously, put down your iPhone, check your computer, and then start having a life.

  • bcee

    1 year ago

    Ponder this: "But surely,

    Ponder this:
    "But surely, someday, there will be a non-phone-carrier wireless networking technology with far greater range than Wi-Fi. FaceTime, I think, is a first step in the direction of a mobile “phone” with no mobile carrier. If and when FaceTime is supported over 3G in addition to Wi-Fi, it’ll be data, not voice — megabytes, not minutes. And immediately, starting today, it’s a step away from tying your iPhone’s “calls” to your carrier’s network."

    ★source : http://daringfireball.net/2010/06/facetime_ipod_touch

    Leave it to Apple to push the envelope

  • Fii

    1 year ago

    I second Paula's statement!!!

    And have you noticed how more often iphone users update their facebook than those of us who can actually get through the day without doing so? It's gotten to the point where I've "hidden" some of my friends!! It's like a new disease or something... crazy.

  • John Greg

    1 year ago

    Third

    I third Paula9's comment. And as Fii said, yes indeed it is like some new disease: It's the continuing growth of the disease of rabid, fanatical, obsessive consumption and consumerism.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.