The Potato Underground
How the 'outlaw' Cariboo spud, once blacklisted by agribiz advocates, was saved. Latest in our Eat Your History series.
Why was this tuber illegal? Photo: Jenn Pentland
When Jerry LeBourdais learned that big agribusiness couldn't handle the Cariboo potato, he knew he'd found a variety that he wanted to support. The name didn't hurt either. If there was a potato out there named "Cariboo," it had a natural home on the back-to-the-land commune near Williams Lake that LeBourdais had founded.
All he needed was some seed. It sounded simple enough.
"Jerry wanted to get a hold of some, and asked me where," recalls John Ryser, a prize-winning seed potato farmer who lives south of Prince George. Ryser told him it wouldn't be easy, because the potato had been decertified for seed production in 1976. By the time LeBourdais came calling in 1983, the Cariboo spud had been banned for seven years and Ryser had given up growing the variety.
"I kept the Cariboo going for years," says Ryser. "The big cheeses de-listed it because it would hang on to the vines." Government officials may prohibit varieties for reasons ranging from disease susceptibility to a tendency to snarl farm equipment; industrial potato farmers want plants that harvest easily with machinery. "Once a variety is de-listed, if you grow it, they'll cancel your seed grower's licence."
But chance and luck launched a new chapter in the history of the Cariboo potato. During a spring meeting at the government experimental farm in Prince George in 1984, a visiting horticulturalist showed up with samples of all kinds of varieties, including Cariboo potatoes from the former Vancouver Research Station in Pemberton.
"Before it was all done, I got four or five of his six Cariboo potatoes and gave them to Jerry," says Ryser. "Then Jerry got in hot water because he was bragging about it, and they started calling it the 'Outlaw Potato.'"
The Cariboo potato rush
The Cariboo region is known today for beef and alfalfa, but a richer farming history stretches back to the gold rush of the early 1860s. Settlers began farming to feed the miners, who otherwise had to pay a premium for whatever fresh foods could survive being mule-hauled up the Cariboo wagon road.
The Cariboo gained a reputation for quality potatoes, explains Denis Kirkham, a retired seed potato specialist who worked in B.C. for the federal Ministry of Agriculture for four decades. In the "heyday" years after World War Two, he says, there were 35 seed potato growers in a belt spanning from McCleese Lake, just north of Williams Lake, to Hixon, just south of Price George.
Yet the Cariboo potato itself has roots about as far from gold-rush country as you can get without leaving Canada. The variety was first bred at the federal Potato Research Centre in Fredericton, New Brunswick, which each year sent seed potatoes out to be tested at a network of experimental farms nationwide. In 1963, one such variety did unusually well in central British Columbia's tough climate. Mike Van Adrichem, then a horticulturalist with the Prince George experimental farm, gave it the Cariboo name. It became popular just as small-scale farming in the region began to face its most challenging times.
"There are lots of reasons potato production in that area declined starting in the '70s," says Kirkham. The Cariboo had a labour shortage, he explains, made worse for farmers by the fact that there was more money to be made in logging and the mills. Freight was costly, too, and made it difficult for the region's family farms to compete with emerging industrial producers in places like Washington and Alberta, and later, global suppliers such as China.
Potato Leek Soup
Many potato leek soups taste thin and weak. The key to this rustic recipe is to use a strong homemade broth and organic heritage potatoes (such as Cariboo potatoes) which have more and better flavour than their supermarket counterparts.
3 c vegetable broth
3 potatoes, peeled
1 tbsp butter
3-4 leeks
1/2 c whole cream
4-5 leaves sage, minced
1 tbsp Dijon mustard
1/3 tsp black pepper
1 tsp salt (less if preferred)
1 dash liquid smoke
Dice one potato and add to broth. Bring to a boil, then simmer until potato can be mashed into broth. Meanwhile, melt butter in a fry pan at medium-low heat. Add sliced leeks, including leek greens, and a pinch of salt, then cover and fry until leeks are soft and golden (about 20 minutes). Add leeks to broth. Add the remaining potatoes, cut into cubes. Stir in remaining ingredients. Bring just to a boil at medium heat, then simmer until potatoes are tender to the fork. Serve immediately. Fried sauerkraut makes an excellent garnish.
"Small farmers couldn't compete -- but they certainly did in terms of quality for a bit. They had high disease freedom and quality and that gave them a premium for their extra work," says Kirkham.
John Ryser, who tracked down the Cariboo seed potatoes for Jerry LeBourdais, is one of the area's two remaining seed potato farmers. He remembers starting out in 1937 or '38, getting heck from his dad for not taking proper care of the potatoes on the family farm. At its largest, Ryser's seed potato operation spanned little more than a dozen acres -- tiny by industrial standards.
"Now I've got just a few acres, and have trouble selling what I've got," he says. "All south of Quesnel was growing at one time. Now it's all shipped in from Vancouver and Alberta. They're all buying them from Superstore and Overwaitea, which don't buy local."
An anti-capitalist potato?
It took a rebel to go up against the tide of history. Jerry LeBourdais, who died in 2004, came from a pioneer Cariboo family and was a lifelong social activist, leading a strike at the Burnaby refinery in his early years and later running several times for political office. Yet today, he might be most widely remembered as the Cariboo potato's greatest promoter.
"They grow really well for the northern region," says Jerry's daughter Lorraine LeBourdais. "They're a beautiful white potato, almost yellow, with pink eyes. They have smooth skin, and they grow tall -- you can pick them out in a patch because they're half a foot taller than other varieties. They pull out and then fall off the vine easily, which is exactly what you want for hand harvesting, but they're a nuisance for commercial harvesting -- they tangle in the harvester," says Lorraine. Cariboo potatoes are also known as excellent keepers, with a good size, shape and texture for baking.
Lorraine is a resident member of CEEDS (Community Enhancement and Economic Development Society), the commune that her father founded, in its original form, in 1971. Today, CEEDS operates three farms near Horse Lake, each on rented or leased land, as the commune does not support the notion of private property.
In 1982, while searching for Cariboo seed, Jerry LeBourdais wrote to the Ministry of Agriculture and was told, "the variety Cariboo can no longer be sold under any name and cannot be grown as seed." The letter continued: "I suggest that you select and grow varieties that can be legally grown in Canada."
CEEDS now grows about a half ton of Cariboo potatoes each year, walking a fine line along the official ban. In 1994, Harrowsmith magazine published an article on the Cariboo spud and CEEDS received letters from across the continent. Rather than sell the spud, they gave away free seed potatoes to everyone who wrote.
'Anything you can eat or smoke...'
The Cariboo isn't the only potato to have its own underground movement. Currently, momentum is building to save the Nooksak potato, another variety that has proved to be a regional standout in the Cariboo. To maintain a strong gene pool in their crops, seed potato growers must bring in new seed from another grower every seven years -- and John Ryser appears to be the last seed farmer growing the Nooksak. If so, this year's crop will be the last to be certified, and the Nooksak potato will live on only in the gardens of citizen seed-savers.
Backyard spud-saving is a Northwest tradition that goes back farther than almost anyone would expect. The Makah Nation of the Olympic Peninsula in Washington has been gardening the Ozette potato -- named for a Makah community -- since at least 1791, the date when it is believed the potato was brought from South America by Spanish explorers. The potato wasn't recognized outside the Makah community until the 1980s. Likewise, Haida Nation growers raise a fingerling variety, the Haida potato, which may have been acquired by trade or travel even before the Haida met their first Europeans. During the conflicted years that followed, gardeners alone saved the Haida potato from extinction. History is repeating itself with the Cariboo potato today.
"I'm not saying it's the greatest potato that ever lived, but it's got culture and associated history. It's very important and symbolic for what it represents more than anything -- biodiversity and independent local culture," says Bob Sarti, a retired reporter and longtime friend of Jerry LeBourdais. He notes that the legacy of the Cariboo potato is now inseparable from the commune that LeBourdais founded, and its philosophy.
"They're anti-capitalist. They never own land, and always had to move for this reason," says Sarti. "They've been doing continuous, uninterrupted agriculture, and are unique in the fact that very few can support themselves entirely this way.
"Jerry was a larger-than-life person," Sarti continues. "He had quite an impact in the Cariboo with the back-to-the-land movement. Jerry always said anything you can eat or smoke, you should be allowed to grow." ![]()





16
Login or register to post comments
make_up_another...
2 years ago
Save A Seed, Stick It To The Man
I've been doing reading on the food biz, the biotech firms, the plight of farmers, etc., and have been horrified by the concerted efforts by Agribiz giants, Monsanto, most notably, to control seed. To control seed is to control food.
Seed saving rebels that promote biodiversity are the only thing that can save us from what I call 'engineered food products'. There are no regulatory agencies in North America that aren't in lockstep with everything these mad scientists are peddling.
ME2
2 years ago
Small chance, but a chance nonetheless.
I agree, and I always get a small feeling of hope when I read of people who dare to thumb their noses at toxic organisms like Monsanto, Cargill, etc.
I don't know if we'll ever escape their clammy grasp, but as long as there is rogue seed out there, hope can survive.
jrb
2 years ago
meanwhile
on another coast, someone has been doing some very interesting work for a lot of years.
http://www.springwillowfarms.com/potatobreeding.htm
he has been rumored to have turned down offers from "the big guys" in the six- or even seven-figure range for the rights.
jwstewart
2 years ago
Illegal??
I fail to understand how growing or selling a potato can be illegal. What is the basis for making it illegal?
David Beers
2 years ago
Illegal potato? Here's how
from the article:
says Ryser. "The big cheeses de-listed it because it would hang on to the vines." Government officials may prohibit varieties for reasons ranging from disease susceptibility to a tendency to snarl farm equipment; industrial potato farmers want plants that harvest easily with machinery. "Once a variety is de-listed, if you grow it, they'll cancel your seed grower's licence."
Fiat lux
2 years ago
So, where can we get come of
So, where can we get come of these potatoes to try ?
The Cariboo won't be known for beef for very long, as all around us the ranchers are going broke and selling out, because, according to the corporate mafia that controls the feedlots, it is "cheaper" to import beef and food.
We sold our cows last month and kept only 2 plus two heifers for replacement, as we no longer could afford to subsidize them from our pensions.
Yet, our governments remain silent about this obvious case of price fixing and the economic destruction of real private enterprise in favour of collectivization.
Ed Deak, Big Lake.
teambates
2 years ago
advantages
I imagine that the reason why potatoes like the Cariboo are illegal to grow in Canada just because they snag harvesting equipment is because access to these varieties would provide an unfair advantage for hand-pickers to get varieties that commercial types would not have convenient access to.
Other advantages in the potato market, fair and otherwise, include the commercial harvester's advantage of scale, money, access to supermarket distribution, and the government lobby. The illegal one, however, is the access to inconvenient breeds of potato.
bluerev
2 years ago
Vivre La Resistance
I am always in awe of people who have the courage to live their lives differently. I personally believe that our futures depend on these groups of agro-terrorists (agro-freedom fighters).
Cnd Jim
2 years ago
Hmm...
I never realized there was so much to know about a potato. Coming from a farm with a seed growing history, I can appreciate how difficult it must have been to keep this variety going. Good thing there are still people out there willing to be a "rebel".
Anyway, good story.
Jim
soleprobe
2 years ago
illegal potatoes?
When potatoes become illegal and when a man needs a license to grow and sell food that’s when the government has way overstepped its boundaries.
Regarding the anti-capitalists and owning land…. I don’t get it. Owning land to raise your family on and grow your own food has nothing to do with capitalism. This way of living has been going on since the beginning long before capitalism.
Fiat lux
2 years ago
There's a tremendous
There's a tremendous difference between real private enterprise and capitalism.
I've been a business and property owner in BC since 1957, but would consider it an insult being called a capitalist.
Ed Deak.
RickW
2 years ago
I can understand de-certifying a product.....
....but I cannot understand making it illegal. If the "little guy" wants to grow it, then so be it. But it certainly isn't going to cut into agribiz profits, as 99% of their market are the cities, where people (IMO) are actually proud to be ignorant of the food products they consume.
It only goes to show just where the governments we elect really stand.
Castellan
2 years ago
Illegal food
Joanne:
Thank you for this very interesting article!
I suspect you've already got a long lineup of subjects you might dive into for future articles, but might I suggest adding "Illegal food" to your list?
I'm fascinated that there are such things - I wonder what organizations have the hubris to outlaw a potoato, and historically why they ever got this power.
Thanks!
Castellan
crust
2 years ago
That is a beautiful potato,
That is a beautiful potato, Thank you Joanne!
BrianWhite
2 years ago
Potato seed
Well done on saving the variety! We used a small dutch variety called scarlet pimpernel(because It had superb flavour) for years back in ireland. Long after it was decommissioned. I worked in a potato research center and they gave me a box of an early potato that never made it to commercial use. 3867bar7 was its name. BUT it was about 2 weeks earlier than anything else and produced the tubers just under the soil. Perfect for you to root around with your fingers and grab them! It meant your plant kept producing until the maincrop came in. And we had a horrible irish variety called cara. Cara was loved in England where it suited the drier climate and tasted like a king edward. And it was a massive success in ethopia where it outyielded everything else. We had one dry year in ireland where it tasted good and was TWICE as productive as anything else!
Just a note that saving tubers is cloneing. If you really want to breed potatoes for the cariboo, you need to plant potatoes of different varietys close together and harvest the potato berrys. (Like little tomatoes). Then sow the berry seeds. Whatever produces decent potatoes (probably in the second year you will get your first favourable results) might turn into a great new variety!
And why not? The canadian plant breeders are never going to produce spuds for the cariboo climate or for the needs of gardners now. It is all geared towards commercial growers and easy to harvest spuds.
My neighbour Harry Kehoe bread the cara potato. It helped stave off famine in ethopia on a few occasions. Your new breed may end up doing the same in years to come.
Brian
Mary Mac
2 years ago
more on Nooksak
I wrote an article about John Ryser (Prince George) and his hardy / resilient Nooksack potato which is on the verge of extinction in Northword Magazine www.northword.ca (August/ September 2009 issue).
The issue of "illegality" of seed potato growing stems (excuse the pun) from the federal Seeds Regulation (Seeds Act) which set out a rigorous (and I would say very outdated) regime for managing/ controlling seed potato growers in this country. . . the reason these laws are so outdated is because there are less and less seed potato growers all the time, and the regulations are very stringent & controlling in terms of the seed potato growers having to find other seed potato growers to continue to grow certain varieties. . . for such potatoes as Cariboo, Nooksack and other hardy/ resilient heritage potatoes, there are few remaining growers . . . John Ryser here in Prince George is one of them, an end of an era. . .