- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joel Berger is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Woodend's 2006 Flick Picks
These movies changed my life.
Escape and invigoration.
Sometimes it feels as if life is one enormous production of Waiting for Godot. ("Nothing happens, nobody comes, nobody goes, it's awful!") There is a sameness to modern existence that, fortunately, movies can disrupt for a time. Perhaps that why we love them so, and wish to live inside them.
Can a movie really change your life? Probably not. They can, however, nudge you in a different direction, offer a new perspective and sometimes even shock you into action.
The collective human experience, corralled inside a cavernous dark room, is much like Plato's cave; we watch the capering shadows, listen to the stories and are transported for a moment or two. This experience still has a tribal aspect. It reminds me oddly enough of sitting at the family dinner table as a child, listening to the grownups tell stories, and wishing they would never end. The sheer bliss of communion is increasingly hard to come by in a fractured and isolated world, but film can still unite folk, and maybe, even change the world.
With that ethos in mind, these are some of the things that have stayed with me from 2006.
Sex with tears was a common occurrence at the cinema this year; it was the opening shot across the bow in John Cameron Mitchell's Shortbus. The unsimulated aspect is guaranteed to attract a certain interest, but really, for a film that is all about sex, that is the least exciting part of the action. The mechanics are just that: nuts and bolts, positions and poses, and the people acting them out seem more sad than horny. The film follows a quartet of New Yorkers: a struggling gay couple (James and Jamie), a sex therapist who needs therapy (Sofia played by Sook-Yin Lee), and a reluctant dominatrix (Severin), who all meet at a club called Shortbus to work out their differences.
The echoes of Bob Fosse's Cabaret are explicit, which begs the question whether the current state of the U.S. and the Weimar Republic have something in common. But it is the need to escape the prison of the self that is ultimately the subtext to all that sex. Each of the characters seeks oblivion in one sense or another, if only to evade the constant scream of the ego. The ego is an insidious little critter, always hiding in the guise of righteousness, demanding to be supplicated, and liable to shatter like a Fabergé egg at the slightest blow.
Stupid ego! No wonder so much of religious or spiritual thought seems devoted to loosening its grasp from everything you do. The sense that we are all connected, and not just by our squishy bits, but by our pinkly delicate souls, as fragile as the horns of a snail, touching the air, seeking a way in the wider world, is what remains. If the film has one message to offer it's this: lose your preciousness, it means nothing, it effectively does nothing, so smash that vibrating egg (ego) to smithereens because we're all in this together, and really, whatever our differences, we're all the same.
'You're Gonna Miss Me'
Susan Sontag may have opined that art doesn't redeem Western civilization, regardless of how many Mozarts or Shakespeares we produce, but really, what else do we have? Art, music and film are still the only things that can convince me that there are noble forces still at work in the world. However, and whenever, they choose to manifest themselves, when they do, it is unmistakable: like the wind of the cosmos blowing down your spine, making all the hair on the back of your neck stand on end. If you get more than a couple of these per year, you're lucky.
One moment of true grace is exactly what You're Gonna Miss Me gives, but the rest of it is pretty interesting as well. The film meanders, following the life and times of Roky Erickson, lead singer of the 13th Floor Elevators, who was committed to an insane asylum in deepest, darkest Texas during the height of his fame. What should have been a tragedy, another lost rock and roll soul, turns into an ode to redemption, a journey into madness and partway back. This film made me care about someone I have never met and probably never will.
'An Inconvenient Truth'
Watching a great many films by myself is like dancing alone in the dark; it is very easy to slip and fall deeper inside my own head. Nowhere did this become more apparent than while watching John Cassavetes' final film, Love Streams at the Vancity Theatre, all by myself. One needs to see films with people simply to decompress afterwards, to work it out, to exorcise them. If you lack the option of doing this, a movie can ping-pong inside your brain for days on end, tugging away at you, as if your mind could worry it loose through sheer dint of effort. On the other hand, on the opening night of the DOXA Documentary Film Festival, I tricked my brother into coming with me, much to his bitter complaining, "I thought we were going to see a real movie!" he said. (But thanks to sitting next to Svend Robinson, who kept offering us popcorn, things got interesting.) Docs, in particular, are better with a friend.
By far the most interesting cinematic offerings this year happened in the realm of non-fiction, but Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth, although not a spectacular piece of film art, must be given special acknowledgment for bringing awareness to the average person about looming environmental catastrophe. A sea change is about, and some credit must be given to Gore's global-warming road show. In Vancouver this week, you couldn't walk more than a few blocks without seeing a 100-year old tree uprooted like a beached whale. But is the deep sense of uneasiness this engenders enough to make you change your own life? Will you give up your car, your trips to Wal-Mart? Yes, it might take more than a film to do this; even a tree falling on your head doesn't appear to be sufficient.
'The Epic of Black Gold' and 'Winter Soldier'
The connection between things becomes more apparent the more films that I see; for example, war, global warming and oil seem to all tie in together in an epic panorama of human folly. I keep returning to The Epic of Black Gold, a documentary series that screened at the VIFF this fall. The series offers up an enormous slice of 20th century history that sheds light on the fury that is the Middle East.
But despite all the war documentaries released this year, a decades-old film had the most impact. Winter Soldier, made in 1972, was largely unseen until recently. This long absence has done little to lessen its force. The voices and faces of the Vietnam vets interviewed in the film give blunt testament to the tragic sameness of all wars. As it was then, as it is now, men and women barely more than children themselves sometimes, are sent to a distant place and asked to perpetrate atrocities in the name of empty ideas voiced by hollow old men. How little has changed.
'Our Daily Bread'
My uncle recently slaughtered a pig. He fed it six beers before the act, hoping it would simply pass out, drunk and blissed out as it entered the great pig beyond. Needless to say, it didn't quite work out that way. He came in the house afterwards and sat in silence for 20 minutes. When my mother told me this story, I thought immediately of Nikolaus Geyrhalter's documentary, Our Daily Bread. This near-wordless film depicts industrialized agriculture in all its mundane horror. As E. coli keeps popping up on lettuce, spinach or green onions, the repercussions of how we grow food on an epic scale are self-evident. When it comes to matters of meat, things are even more disturbing. The film's scenes of vast abattoirs have eerie echoes of Nazi gas chambers in their effective mechanization of death. The sight of naked chicken corpses still leaking blood, or cows reduced from living creatures to tidy red packages in a matter of minutes, could convince anyone that being a vegetarian is the only sane and ethical choice.
Kids' flicks
Reading all the news of global crisis (collapse of fishing stocks, killer spinach, etc.) sinks tiny fangs in my subconscious mind, but it's seeing our own kids living this reality that brings it home. I have seen more children's films than I care to admit, that convinced me, the end is nigh. A great deal of kids' films this year, as any other year, use animals as their central focus. For the most part, the storylines are identical (The Wild, Over the Hedge, Madagascar, Open Season, Barnyard, etc.) It is the very sameness of these stories that made me think something odd is going on, a form of mini-propagandizing (like mini-props) that says, "Hey, kids, the only reality is one which you can purchase, everything is for sale!" I think there is an especially hot corner of hell reserved for those people who market to children.
I watch our kids watching this stuff, and some part of me dies a little inside for the idea that children everywhere are no longer free. I asked my mother the other day when it was that everyone everywhere (or at least in North America) accepted the idea that children could no longer be left alone, or could go anywhere themselves. She thought it might have begun in part with the disappearance of Michael Dunahee. Wherever it began, it seems at some silent point in recent history, within the last twenty years, it was decided almost universally, that you must never take your eyes off your children. Even though child abductions have not drastically increased, the idea, even the slightest possibility that this might happen was enough to change everyone's behaviour. The power of fear: it works so beautifully because it plays to our deepest and most fragile places. Anyone who has a kid knows that it's like living with a gun to your head; the level of risk is so scary. But sometimes it's the creeping insidious messages, housed in happy colours and singsong stories that truly ought to be feared.
All this sounds rather hopeless, but despair, no matter how warranted, isn't really useful. Hope is a better tool. The one important thing that film can do is to shift our sense of possibility, crack open the lid of perception. This being the holiday season, a time when people settle in with their favourite films, I think it is only fitting to close with John Cassavetes talking about Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life: "Idealism is not sentimental. It validates a hope for the future. Capra gave me hope, and in turn I wish to extend a sense of hope to my audiences."
Amen, brothers and sisters.
Related stories:



22
Login or register to post comments
_pk_
5 years ago
Comments on "Woodend's 2006 Flick Picks"
"...which begs the question..."
At the expense of sounding a little pompous, that doesn't actually mean what you think it means.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question
"Today, the phrase is also frequently seen in a different usage with the meaning "raise the question". In academic contexts this use is rare and widely regarded as incorrect, but it has nevertheless become very common in the news media."
mijnheer
5 years ago
You're not being pompous, _pk_. Professionals writers should try to get things right. A Globe and Mail story (not by Ms. Woodend) the other day had things "laying" about in attics and basements. But while we're on Ms. Woodend's case, let me get picky. Her Globe column last Saturday ("Women are funny -- but men are a joke") included the sentence "Women will even work for free when it comes to taking care of their families." The commonly used phrase "for free" really makes no sense, and should be replaced by "free of charge" or "for nothing". If I work for money, I receive money in exchange for work. If I work "for free", do I get "free" in exchange for work? The excellent Guide to Canadian English Usage (Oxford University Press) notes that some consider the expression "for free" childish. I don't mean to be rude; Ms. Woodend writes well. But I'm in the middle of marking exam papers filled with "arguements" (aarrghh) that beg the question. That's enough to make anyone grumpy.
mijnheer
5 years ago
And I just wrote "professionals writers". That'll learn me.
David Beers
5 years ago
Dorothy Woodend humbly offers an article full of ideas about works of art she says touched her deeply, even changed her. The first two commenters pounce on syntax, the second scolding that 'professional writers should try to get things right." Dorothy, as your editor I consider myself fortunate enough to publish your excellent essays week in and week out, knowing as I do how much thought and effort you do put into them. Happy holidays everyone.
marta
5 years ago
As her editor, perhaps you should have caught the improper use of "begs the question." It's not a problem with syntax. She is misusing a term which means something other than she thinks it does.
Sheesh. What's wrong with asking for correct use of idiomatic expressions?
David Beers
5 years ago
OK, Marta, I'll bite. Let's imagine this exchange happened not on the internet but in the classroom of mijnheer. A student or colleague stands in front of the class doing her best to makes sense of popular art, fold in larger ideas, reveal some personal feelings and interpretations. The talk is the result of many hours of preparation and the speaker is hoping that her classmates and colleagues will appreciate or at least engage her ideas. She certainly isn't giving her presentation for the money. Instead, the first and only comments, by mijnheer and another person in the room, is that the speaker misused an idiomatic expression. That's it, the only point worth making or taking away from the talk. Most people I think would consider that a poor way to reward good faith effort and encourage conversation. But on the internet, for some reason, that kind of exchange is far more common. And I'll be honest, as the editor who invites talented people like Dorothy to share her ideas in this forum, I often cringe at the rudeness and disregard Tyee readers must endure.
David Beers
5 years ago
Last line should read:
... I often cringe at the rudeness and disregard Tyee writers and readers must endure.
James Burns
5 years ago
aaaarrgghhh..... deal with the content people. If you're going to bother to comment deal with the fuking content. The piece is well written and the editing is fine, nitpicking over trivialities is idiotic. If there were numerous gross unintentional grammatical errors, then you may have a point, but there aren't.
Now I shall actually deal with content...yayy! A documentary that had a big impact on me, was one I just saw recently. Avi Mograbi's "Avenge But One of My Two Eyes". It takes a very interesting perspective on the jewish myths of Samson and Masada, and compares that to the current Israeli treatment of the Palestinians. It may sound flaky, but it works amazingly well, particularly because of how seriously many Israelis take those myths, and the sort of language they use when talking about them.
I can't say I was especially impressed with "An Inconvenient Truth", but then again I'm intimately familiar with a lot of the science around climate change, so it was all old news to me. The graphics were nice, but I found Gore's Pollyanna attitude was off-putting, because it blurred the serious need for action.
There aren't many actual movies that have left a big impression with me though. It's the miniseries like "The Wire" that have had a big impact. Dorothy if you haven't seen it you definitely should take Burgess' advice and start with the first season.
acadian driftwood
5 years ago
the asian chick on the cover of this article is hot. I'm sporting a chubby.
Frank
5 years ago
I thought it was a good article, lots of films I want to see but I doubt these will be showing up at my video store.
And I thought it was Clifford Olsen that was behind the fact we never let our kids out of our sight.
bpither1
5 years ago
Thanks for your contribution Dorothy. As always I find the Tyee far more stimulating than any of the two mainstream Vancouver newspapers. Now, as for my take on "begging the question" maybe the anal retentive above posters should read this:http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-beg1.htm and pay particular attention to the last paragraph. There are countless phrases we use which make absolutely no sense unless you sense the cultural context. Try this: No News is Good News Utterly meaningless but everyone knows what it means
mijnheer
5 years ago
I actually agree that we should focus primarily on the substance of Ms. Woodend's article, rather than on the occasional language hiccup -- which is why I wrote, "I don't mean to be rude; Ms. Woodend writes well."
bpither 1: Thanks for the link. As the author there concludes, the use of "beg the question" to mean "raise the question" is "better avoided altogether."
bloodnok
5 years ago
Right on, Acadian Driftwood! Way to bring some perspective into this forum! Enough carping about the misuse of idiomatoc expressions, let's talk about content. Particularly, apparently, the content of your shorts. But I heartily agree with you- Sook Yin Lee is totally hot. You can catch her on CBC radio each weekend , she's the host of Definitely Not The Opera. Of course you don't get to see her, but it's possible that she does the show topless. It's way more fun if you imagine it that way; I always do.
marta
5 years ago
Nope David, I don't buy your comment that we're not allowed to comment on mistakes.
One thing I teach my students in my university english clases is that their grammatical mistakes and problems with word choice can often obscure any valid points they were trying to make. This article is a perfect case in point. The first three respondents saw the mistake, and it prevented them from commenting on the content. That doesn't mean that those readers are petty or pedantic. It means that the writer, by making a common mistake in logic, has lost some credibility. Fix the mistake and that will allow people to embrace the content.
It's what a good editor does, anyway. Or that's what the journalism classes at my institution teach.
And of course we're allowed to comment on student mistakes! How else can people learn?
For a mistake made by someone who is NOT a student, even more reason to say something.
The correct answer was "Whoops! We let that incorrect use of the phrase get by us. We'll fix it next time!"
marta
5 years ago
And* sigh* sorry, it should have read "classes." I'll do better next time when I get my new reading glasses.
And as for the films, is no-one bothered by the real sex in "Shortbus?" Has the line between porn and legitimate acting finally been broken down?
Cunningham
5 years ago
Wow! Is this what online communication does to my beloved Tyee? Syntax? Hot Asian chicks? Where did the article go?
I'm thinking that a lot of forum contributors live in glass houses. Or hoses. Horses maybe.
A question for Dorothy... Any comment on "Little Miss Sunshine"?
Frank
5 years ago
Hey Cuinn (sp?), nice to see you again
Cunningham
5 years ago
Thanks, Frank. Yes, "Cuinn" is "O'Leary" now - not in order to disavow past posts on this site, but because I couldn't get my sign-in to work in my new location.
Jack's
5 years ago
Movies that score big with me, I usually end up watching more than once.
'Jacob's Ladder' was probably the exception.
'Boogy Nights' was not a great movie but it had its mostly comedic value and I found myself recently watching a re-run of that.
Most watched - 'Shane' - and a close second would be 'Pulp Fiction'.
Haven't seen 'Shortbus' and 'Winter Soldier' but after reading this article, will seek them out.
off-the-radar
5 years ago
Thank you Dorothy for another beautifully written piece that really made me think.
ianmack
5 years ago
Agreed, an excellent, thought provoking piece. Always enjoy your writing Dorothy.
Xenia Dragon
5 years ago
SHORTBUS... yes I agree with your take on it Dorothy. Curious simile use - "shatter
like a Faberge egg". Ever drop one?
The Sook-Yin Lee photo is arresting. I did
a search on it. Found THE RUNAGATES CLUB,
a Vancouver Blog hosted on blogspot.com/
which discusses Sook-Yin, Evelyn Lau and
our mean streets.
The movies are in capable hands. Thanks
for annoting our road map.
Xenia