Opinion

Spare Us from Gullible Gord

He's star struck by big biz beyond BC's borders.

By Rafe Mair, 23 Mar 2009, TheTyee.ca

Susan Heyes, Abby Palmer

Cambie Street merchants Susan Heyes (left) and Abby Palmer. Photo: Evalu8.org.

I've finally figured it out. The Campbell government consists of incompetent, blundering fools with frozen smiles and expensive suits.

It's worse, really, because that incompetence is combined with thoughtlessness, arrogance and hubris -- a fatal mix.

Let's start with the latest. The merchants of Cambie Street, led by Susan Heyes, are suing the government for loss of business during the time when Cambie Street was inaccessible because of construction of the Canada Line.

Campbell's transportation minister, Kevin Falcon, has hidden (no doubt on orders from above) behind legislative immunity, a medieval concept designed to keep the King from getting at MPs. In this case it's to protect the minister from giving evidence about the Canada Line's horrible impact on so many businesses. He would be sworn to tell the truth.

You can be sure that Premier Campbell made this decision out of fear: fear that Heyes might get justice, thus compensation, because of the government's heartless blunder. If it's a fact (as former MLA and finance minister Carole Taylor said in her testimony) that the government had no power over the RAV (Canada Line) construction, there's no reason for Falcon to be afraid of testifying. One is entitled to infer, then, that Falcon and Campbell might have something to hide.

Piling up blunders

Falcon is also the man who refused to build a tunnel at Horseshoe Bay instead of ruining a sensitive environmental area.

The Campbell government built transmission lines, after refusing to adequately bury them, over a neighborhood and a school in Tsawwassen then refused to listen to the residents who felt that electricity from the wires would put their children at risk. Having built the lines, Campbell looked at the polls in a safe riding and didn't like what he saw. He offered to buy out the houses involved, thus implying that these transmission lines are indeed potentially dangerous. Then the premier offers these potentially dangerous houses to other people.

The Campbell government blundered into public/private partnerships (P3s) failing to understand that rather than spreading the risk, it doubled it since the private company could go broke while the government couldn't. Thus the Campbell government, in one case, lent the private contractor enough money to pay back the money they owed the government on the P3 deal!

The government -- as usual without any public input -- pledges to spend a billion dollars upgrading the Deltaport facility just as the Panama Canal is doubling its capacity and the Northwest Passage is opening to cargo ships.

The Campbell government is building the South Fraser Perimeter Road, thus substantially increasing pollution while creating serious environmental damage, loss of farmland and interference with the abundant wildlife.

Gagging their opponents

The Campbell government has, since 2001, deliberately refused to understand the fish farms issue and the resultant devastation afflicted by sea lice on migrating Pacific salmon smolts. Even though it had all the independent scientific evidence of this massacre of hundreds of thousands of Pacific salmon in hand, the Campbell government ignored this evidence rather than lose the monetary support of fish farmers who almost exclusively come from out of province. Campbell even ignored the commission of his own choosing, chaired by former House of Commons speaker John Fraser, which confirmed this danger. Campbell's reaction was to expand this destructive industry!

Then Campbell passed the "Gag Law," which restricts the right to free speech during this election in order to stop people like me from taking a full part in the election campaign.

Beggaring BC Hydro

Scott Simpson, in an article on March 18 in the Vancouver Sun, tells us that under Gordon Campbell's energy policy, BC Hydro will be forced to buy energy from private producers, under sweetheart contracts, at $120 megawatts per hour for which they will receive $60 in the market! This is something Dr. John Calvert stated in his book Liquid Gold published 15 months ago and previewed in The Tyee even earlier. Logically this will bankrupt BC Hydro so that Campbell, if we re-elect him, urged on by the neo-cons like the Fraser Institute, can get rid of it as he did with BC Rail.

That's not all of course. And perhaps this is the most damaging and puzzling:

The private power companies can only produce energy during the spring run-off at a time BC Hydro has full to overflowing reservoirs and doesn't need power. When the reservoirs are lowest, the private powers can't deliver a single watt!

This means that the private power created will go primarily to the United States and bring NAFTA into play. The program also means that profits on power will no longer be paid to our government for schools and hospitals but to shareholders in large corporations!

Voiding local control

When the Squamish-Lillooet Regional District voted eight to one against the Ashlu River private power zoning request, the autocratic Campbell government passed Bill 30, thus retroactively voiding the district decision while at the same time taking away the rights of all regional districts, villages, towns and cities to zone for similar enterprises.

Moreover, B.C. doesn't need the power. The National Energy Board, which deals with energy export, tells us that we've been net exporters of energy for 8 of the last 11 years.)

This is all madness, you may well be thinking. No leader can be so stupid! Yes, one can be.

Taken in

Ah yes, I believe that now I have the correct image. There's our Gord, shaking hands with and in awe of the captains of large American industry (those not in jail or about to be), listening enraptured to the heroes of the far right, gazing, with the glazed eyes of Little Orphan Annie in the presence of Daddy Warbucks, overwhelmed when he meets Arnold Schwarzenegger, unable to believe his luck at having all these icons actually talking to and flattering little old him.

It would seem that his heroes of the right give our premier the vapors. I'll be damned if he isn't star struck.

Gentle readers, let me introduce to you (flourish of trumpets, please): British Columbia's own Gullible Gord!

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

51  Comments:

  • seth

    22-03-2009

    Ralph Sultan P.Eng Phd

    Here we have a professional engineer (Electrical) who used to work at BCHydro, former CEO of RBC Dominion Securities, and former Harvard Business School professor sitting in the back bench while uneducated or unqualified louts like Falcon/Neufeld/Hanson and Campbell make all the decisions.

    No doubt they don't like what Sultan is telling them.

  • Fiat lux

    22-03-2009

    First of all, with apologies

    First of all, with apologies for changing the subject, I would like to offer my sincere thanks to all those who were so kind to send me a large number of messages and cards during my recent illness. I was very touched and grateful for every one.
    ------------------------------------------
    Now on the subject of this pathetic bunch we call our government, which should also include the federal wing, pushing the same sick ideology of neoclassical market economy .

    Having lived in 4 countries and under every form of known ideology, and as a registered BC voter since 1956, my greatest fear is that this incompetent and morally corrupt bunch will be re-elected with the promise of "jobs, jobs, jobs, brought to BC by foreign investors". And people will lap it up, as usual.

    What is carefully kept from people is the sordid fact that we're not in a recession, but the collapse of a fraudulent economic theory that already pushed us into the hands of the biggest crime wave, destroying the lives and killing tens of millions every year, in the name of "prosperity through globalization", forced on us, and the whole world, by fools and crooks in the universities and governments of all countries on all continents.

    Just one item: It is a crime for trustees to sell properties doesn't belong to them. Yet, our governments have been selling the land and resources from under our feet in secret deals, without any permission and the owners are kept in the dark on what was sold and for what. This is what they now call a "resource based economy",which is nothing less than the sale of capital.

    The sale of resources, or capital, is not only the stupidest action for any business, but should never be accounted as "income", or even GDP, regardless what corrupt politicians and brainwashed economists are saying and teaching in our universities.

    This illegal act alone should be enough to kick them out of office, but now will come the huge propaganda campaign by the best mind benders big business and the captive media can provide to make certain the continuation of this fraud with the reelection of he same puppets dancing on their strings.

    The problem is that it won't work, because there's no hope in hell that the same policies that brought on this disaster can take us out.

    Unless our governments and economic systems are finally taken over by people capable of rational thought, we may be facing a period of extreme dangers and perennial violence by desperate people trying to survive another day, that will make the depression of the '30s look like a school picnic.

    Ed Deak, Big Lake.

  • Grumpy

    22-03-2009

    Campbell's Dane geld

    Fact: Over 100 households in Tsawwassen along the power-line corridor have accepted the governments bailout offer.

    Rumor: The bailout per house was 5% over 2008 property assessment, or over $600,000.00 per house - total cost, over $60 million.

    Cost to bury power cables $20 million over cost of overhead construction.

    Average resale values of said houses $450,000 or about $45 million.

    Just for a few million dollars more, Campbell may have just snatched victory from the jaws of defeat.

  • North of Hope

    22-03-2009

    At about the beginning of

    At about the beginning of February, Plutonic Power suggested that they should be allowed to export their electrical energy. On Feb. 7, 2009, BC Hydro ran an ad in the Vancouver Sun that was "A Notice of Application and Directions on Procedure; Application To Export Electricity To The United States." We buy it from Plutonic at a set price and we hope we can sell it a a higher price. A nice set up for Plutonic, thanks Gordo.

    Rafe, you say, "When the Squamish-Lillooet Regional District voted eight to one against the Ashlu River private power zoning request, the autocratic Campbell government passed Bill 30, thus retroactively voiding the district decision while at the same time taking away the rights of all regional districts, villages, towns and cities to zone for similar enterprises."
    Well thankfully the "BC Reconciliation Act" will help alleviate those problems. Gordo wasn't quite able to jam it through, but if he wins, you can kiss this province goo-bye.

  • doggone

    22-03-2009

    Spare us from the Gullible Voter

    In the '60s we had already bennitfited for many years in this wonderful province. There was a story going around then which I will attempt to bring up to date or even a few years into the future - let's say 2015: (by this time "global Warming" has produced some dastardly cold winters in B.C.)
    Hunter: "This time last year I shot a moose and it almost killed me."
    Wannabe hunter: "The Moose?"
    H: "No, the weather. It was up on the Chilcouten Plateau and while I gutted and cleaned the carcase a blizzard blew in and the temperature dropped like a stone. Couldn't see your hand in front of your face even if it was getting frostbight. Two miles to the pickup and the ATV wouldn't start."
    W: "So what did ya do?"
    H: "The moose was laying there and still warm so I opened up the rib cage and crawled inside. Actually fell asleep for a few hours. When I woke up the blizzard was over but the moose was frozen solid. there was no way I could force the ribcage enough to get out."
    W: "Then how did you get out?"
    H: "I did some thinkin' and when I got to the memory of voting for the Campbell Liberals in 2009 I felt so small I crawled out the hole under the tail."

  • JStog

    22-03-2009

    Gullible Rafe... money talks.. BS makes $$$

    Tutu

    Yes we Know all about the polls.... Pyew whats that smell LOL

    Rafe Mair... ah yes

    I heard Rafe shouting at the a Plutonic Q+A meeting. He was of turn and disrespectful to everyone who came to listen and ask Q's. Could be a Decent guy, but Rafe treated the locals like second class idiots. A typical socred.

    I'm a little unclear how the Glacier fed Creeks in Bute will stop running in the summer. It defies logic to pretend Glaciers will stop melting in summer. But if your Paid Big Bucks to say so....then it must be true....right Rafe?

    Rafe says BC doesn't need the extra Hydro.... We also don't need the extra lumber, the coal any mining or for that matter anything we export. Should we stop exporting everything Rafe?

    Gullible??? .... Not here Rafe.

  • HippyTreeMan

    23-03-2009

    Gullible Gordo

    Well put as usual Raif,I just wish the MSM would stop cheerleading long enough to do it's job and inform the population so we can have a functioning democracy again in this country.I know, I know,"you may call me a dreamer,but I'm not the only one."[John Lennon]

  • sunshine coast girl

    23-03-2009

    What took you so long, Rafe?

    We knew this government "consisted of incompetent, blundering fools with frozen smiles and expensive suits. And that "incompetence is combined with thoughtlessness, arrogance and hubris -- a fatal mix." And we knew these things after their first year in power. Glad to see you recognizing it now though.

  • alive

    23-03-2009

    the local TV news

    So, Arnold Swarzenegger endorses the P3 programs, and the local media is falling all over itself to announce that everybody is happy...EVERYBODY....
    To represent any opposition to P3 they bring in a government minister to tell us that perhaps some malcontents may be opposed!
    Talk about being biased.
    Surely we are heading towards an election and the story is obviously going to be how smart and effecient Gordo and his gang has been.
    I feel sure that old Rafe would have been willing to speak up on that news-item if asked?
    Perhaps even the NDP could have mustered a spokesperson to point out the failures?
    We are in for it people, totally biased reporting!

  • Van Isle

    23-03-2009

    If the NDP form the next

    If the NDP form the next Government, I wonder if Premier James will have our Auditor-General do an audit of the Liberal government's business dealings? If any improprierties are found can the former Premier/Ministers be charged?

  • Grumpy

    23-03-2009

    The truth and be damned!

    This why Gordo, did not want the Falcon to testify, for fear of telling the truth about RAV.

    Originally, RAV was estimated to cost a laughable $1.2 billion, which started TransLink down the road to RAV, with Gordo & Co. singing the praises of P-3's. They soon found that TransLink (and Ken Dobel and Jane Bird) fumbled the ball estimating the cost of RAV which was escalating faster than a skyrocket.

    To reduce costs RAVCo. pretended it was P-3 (the P-3 partner SERCo. took to the lifeboats), so the peons (taxpayer) could not vet the project. The costs for the subway then exceeded $2 billion, grand economies had to be made:

    1) The project switched to a generic metro instead of SkyTrain, which saved over $50 million.

    2) Cut-and-cover subway construction was substituted instead of much more expensive bored tunnel construction. C & C is only cheaper if compensation isn't paid.

    3) Single track operation in Richmond, which drastically reduces capacity and precludes any future extensions.

    4) Subway stations under Cambie St. were built to accommodate 3 car trains, which again dramatically reduces capacity. Capacity on the now (depending who you talk to) $2.4 to $2.8 billion subway, is much less (as much as 10,000 pphpd less) than if simple and much cheaper LRT were to have been built on any route, except a subway. Cost to increase station size, over $1 billion and then the C & C thing all over again.

    Imagine the embarrassment of Minister Falcon, TransLink and the MSM, if the truth about RAV came out?

    Even Bill Boring would blush!

  • Jeffrey J.

    23-03-2009

    Democracy in short supply

    BC Citizens still have a democratic alternative to neoliberal free market ideologues. In that, we're very lucky. However, should we wish to keep this alternative, we will need to remain fully engaged, speaking out, being involved in our community, and keeping the NDP fully informed of what the majority of British Columbians want and need.

    Alternate forms of media have really opened up exciting changes in democratic expression. Independent media like Tyee, Rabble, CCPA, and even Al Jazeera are reshaping the publics right to know. This too is likely to be challenged in the future and must be carefully protected.

    The sooner Gordon Campbell's thugs are given the boot, the better. They really have turned out to be pretty sad bunch.

    As always, great to see Rafe telling it like it is.

  • Fiat lux

    23-03-2009

    The problem with the

    The problem with the neoliberal market system is that it is not much different from the Soviet collectivized market system.

    When we scratch the surface we can see whole areas of the world's economy, like control of the world's food supply, in the hands of a small handful of corporations, who fix prices to ruin farmers so they can take over their lands, while raising prices in the stores.

    Look up on google "Control of the world's food supply"

    In short it is just another power grab, the destruction of democratic decision making powers and real private enterprise, but instead of bayonets, it is done with the perceived power of imaginary capital, enforced by pimp governments, like some we know.

    Ed Deak.

  • happy

    23-03-2009

    zerocarboncanada.ca

    "To say that all run-of-river projects destroy rivers and are not ‘green’ is absurd. I’ve been up to Toba/Montrose with the Klahoose. I’ve seen how Plutonic’s operations are reopening tributaries and cleaning up the mess of crushed culverts and downed bridges that logging left behind. The same would hold true for other heavily logged areas like Bute Inlet. I was fully prepared to see impacts on the river and was pleasantly surprised to find that, contrary to the horror stories circulating, the water diversion is high up near the glacial outflow, above waterfalls (fish barriers) where there are barely even nutrients in the water. The salmon habitat and water flows remain intact. Most people won’t know this because it turns out I am the only environmentalist that has bothered to take the Klahoose up on their invitation to go and see it for myself"
    Tzeporah Berman

    Thanks to Michael Smyth of the Vancouver Province for bringing this to our attention in an article March 22 titled "Enviromental hypocrisy is mind-boggling"

  • happy

    23-03-2009

    Margaret Atwood

    Is listed on the PowerUpCanada site as a supporter.
    I have a hard time believing she supports privatization of BC watersheds.

  • Janie Jones

    23-03-2009

    IPPs = Privatized Watersheds

    Perhaps she is not aware that is what she doing.

  • happy

    23-03-2009

    I have a hard time with that JJ

    The world class author and heroine of the Left, not aware of what she's doing?

    That doesn't reflect very well on her intelligence does it.

  • cfvua

    24-03-2009

    Star Struck

    Are they ever. The liberals are totally willing to sacrifice any jobs that might happen in the oil and gas service industry in order to help their friends from Calgary and Texas. $187 Million last week for a road to really no where. Oh but we got "procurement help desks in Fort Nelson and Dawson Creek" which won't much help people that are forced to sell their excavators and dozers because Imperial Oil brought in a dirt mover from Alberta to dig holes and build roads( which may qualify for a 50% injection of taxpayer funding). Lekstrom is more prone to listen than Neufeld ever was, but he can't fix what took two terms to break by May 12. Our only hope is that the candidates in the Peace get thrashed in order to get the message across. I doubt the NDP will get elected, but the independents sure could. Unemployed people are funny that way.

  • Rod Smelser

    24-03-2009

    I sure won't be blaming you, Wilfred!!!

    Wilfred Laurier
    What are you going to say when the Liberals form a third straight majority? Who are you going to blame?

    If you're getting ready to flatter yourself, don't bother!

    In the unhappy event that the Phil Hochstein party prevails once again, I won't be blaming boiler room bloggers. There are larger players out there who have conditioned the Canadian and especially the BC voter to believe that in a recession you must move to the right. It worked for Bill Bennett in 1983, and it worked again last Fall for Stephen Harper, again, with particular force in B.C.

    Curiously, that's the exact opposite of what the Americans just did.

  • Skywalker

    24-03-2009

    Strange is it not Rod.

    All the folks that get us into theses economic messes from time to time offer the solution that all we need is just a little more moving to the right. You would think that folks having been burned once or twice or three times would learn. No, there are enough out there like Wilf still clinging to their myths. When it collapses they come to the rest of us peasants to bail them out. Telling us that this economic system is so sacred, so critical for all of us it must be protected at all costs. We pay to do that either in our taxes or in a devalued dollar. Is it any wonder they like the gravy train they are on? The only thing critical in this economy is the protection of the elite wealthy with their notion of entitlement.

  • Janie Jones

    24-03-2009

    Enclosure

    The Americans had already been moved so far to the right that they are up against the wall. They elected a much more enlightened government in theory, in practice it looks like same old, same old.

    The notion of entitlement also fits in with the neo-pagan new age Buddhist beliefs of those born into the elite wealthy class. You see, it's their karma, their reward for the meritorious suffering of past lives to be born into wealth and power in this life. As for the majority of us who are not born into wealth and power, well that's our karma too.

    And I see from Jstogs links that thanks to Renewal Real Estate, the Hank's Beach controversy has been resolved! Silly me, that happened back in 2006 and I thought it was current. The Tyee story & thread on it was a good read and touched on (among other subjects) "the story of disappearing commons throughout British Columbia."

    Also known as enclosure, a notion now rearing it's ugly head in the name of "recognition", social justice and green energy.

  • dave49

    24-03-2009

    The Best Place on Earth(tm)

    But Rafe, we are living in "The Best Place on Earth(tm)". How could Gordon Campbell NOT have our best interests in mind?

    If the key benefit of the Olympics is, as Gordon Campbell recently said, that all these foreign journalists will visit, the real benefit is the advertising and marketing of BC as a tourist destination. Presumably, those journalists are supposed to return home and rave about TBPOE (tm) and we will be flooded with tourists and tourist dollars.

    The problem is that tourist jobs tend to be seasonal, low-paying service jobs (retail, accommodation, restaurants, transportation). Further, tourism depends on cheap travel, especially CHEAP air travel. Recall that the International Energy Agency, after assessing the world's 900 highest-producing oil wells, predicts peak oil by 2020.

    However, tourism is a development path we've promoted for third and fourth world countries. Why does this government promote a third world economic development model in a supposedly first world country? Is it because, as a friend commented, that this government prefers an environment closer to the Middle Ages, when there was no middle class?

    Basically, if you have the right credentials and have a good job that pays well you will have a nice life. If you have a MacJob you will be lucky to earn $10.00 per hour, will struggle to find affordable housing, save for retirement, etc.

    This picture does not sound like 'the best place on earth to me'. Someone votes Liberal, but not me.....

  • dave49

    24-03-2009

    Wind power

    By the way, wind power peaks in the winter, whereas all hydro peaks in the spring.

  • wiley

    24-03-2009

    Powering Up

    Bingo! Where else but in the spinning PR turbines of the Guardians of the Green Faith would Atwood get so much juicy material for a timely sequel to The Handmaid's Tale?

  • dave49

    24-03-2009

    RAV line a bargain?

    Grumpy,

    As a Cambie area resident, I have to admit that in comparison to the Olympic security bill, the RAV/Canada Line is starting to look like a bargain. We will spend $2-3 billion on rapid transit, but at least we will have a useful asset at the end. Olympic security will consume over $1 billion and not have anywhere near the same economic multiplier effects.

  • SharingIsGood

    25-03-2009

    one last fight

    I've got one good fight left in me, Rafe. This is my last stand. If Gordon Campbell runs this province for one more term, I'm inviting everyone to do like I do, pull up stakes and get out. This province, as pretty as it is, is not worth watching be destroyed. It is beyond my understanding how the public can elect and re-elect these crooks. If this is the government that the rest of British Columbians want, then it is time for me to leave. I cannot, in good conscience, pay taxes to a government that refuses to be kind to its own electorate. See you April 4, Rafe.

    SharingIsGood

  • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.