- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
The People's Order of BC: Your Nominations, Please
Given doubts about how Campbell, Dobell and Emerson gained the Order of BC, we're creating a new Order. Suggest a candidate!
Illustration by Alex Grunenfelder.
[Editor's note: Launched on Monday, we have already received nearly 70 entries. Keep them coming!]
Because of the controversy surrounding this year's Order of B.C., we've decided to start our own Order.
Well, that's not quite accurate.
We don't want this to be our award. We want this to be your award.
That's why we're calling it The People's Order of B.C.
Here's how we see it working:
1. Think of someone you think deserves the People's Order of B.C.
2. Fill out this simple online form
From there we'll select a shortlist everyone can vote on.
The winners will be awarded the just-invented honour of People's Order of B.C. (some here are calling it "The Order of the Fish") and will be profiled in The Tyee.
The nomination period ends on Sept. 30.
Who's eligible?
Eligibility is exactly the same as the regular Order of B.C., documented here. That means, essentially, you can nominate anyone who lives in British Columbia, or has lived in British Columbia for a significant period of time. That person must be alive and not holding political office at the time of nomination.
The online nomination form is straight forward. Unlike the Order of B.C., we're not requiring multiple letters of reference. We just want to know who you think should get such an award.
Why this? Why now?
Selections to the Order of B.C. include some of the brightest lights in the province. And this year is no exception.
But three selections triggered outrage from a number of quarters.
Gordon Campbell was selected to receive the honour mere days after he left office as one of the most unpopular premiers in Canada, ostensibly for having introduced the Harmonized Sales Tax without public consultation.
Ken Dobell was selected to be honoured despite being Campell's "master fixer," as described by the Vancouver Sun, who eventually pled guilty to violating lobbying laws.
David Emerson was selected to receive the honour after a long corporate career and a shorter stretch as (arguably) one of the most hated MPs in B.C. history after running as a Liberal vowing to oppose Stephen Harper's Conservatives and then, almost immediately upon winning his Vancouver riding, crossing the aisle to join Harper's team.
In response to those three Order of B.C. choices, some started petitions and online protests.
Others, like Bill Tieleman in these pages, criticized the apparent political nature of the honour.
"Regardless of Campbell's failings," wrote Tieleman, "he has made a long contribution to public service as a Vancouver councillor, mayor, MLA and premier.
"But it's the undue haste and obvious political nature of giving him this honour that stinks. Last year Campbell was giving out the Order of B.C.; this year he'll be receiving one."
That puts Tieleman and other critics at odds with Premier Christy Clark, who has said Campbell deserves the Order of B.C. right away.
Then again, when Tieleman analyzed the selection committee, he noted that it helps to belong to a club that includes Clark as well as Campbell:
"If you notice a common element in this selection committee it would be that most members have political or governmental connections to the former Campbell government."
What about the arts?
Canada's former poet laureate and an Order of B.C. and Canada winner, George Bowering, had different concerns.
In a recent letter to the Vancouver Sun, Bowering wrote about this year's selections:
"My main concern is that while politicians are being welcomed into the Order, people in the arts are not."
He went on to write: ". . . in the nine provinces that are not British Columbia, 18 per cent of recipients are in the arts. In British Columbia, the figure is zero per cent."
Think outside of the official box
So, here's your chance to nominate and select the people that make you proud to be from this place.
Maybe it's someone who's a guiding light in your field, your job, your community -- you nominate, you choose.
It doesn't have to be a pop singer who made it big in L.A. in the '80s. It doesn't have to be a politician. It doesn't have to be someone who seeks the public spotlight.
It could be the local fiddler who's been leading a local string group for the last 30 years, the former punk rocker who's Canada's alternative ambassador to the world, the 30-year volunteer at the local women's shelter, the local historian. It could be the mountain biker or skateboarder who pushed the sport and industry in a new direction. It could be your grandmother, your grandfather.
Think outside the frame of officialdom. This is the award that validates your values.
Who makes you proud to be a British Columbian, not based on the values of the establishment but on the swelling of your own heart? ![]()




39
Login or register to post comments
jimmy_laroux
35 weeks ago
David Emerson...
...was the most hated *MP* in BC history, not the mosted hated MLA. The most hated *MLA* in BC history is another Order of BC winner: Gordon Campbell.
David Beers
35 weeks ago
good catch Jimmy laroux
we'll fix that pronto
ron wilton
35 weeks ago
Salmon are Sacred
Alexandra Morton should be the first recipient of this award.
'nuff said.
notdarkyet
35 weeks ago
Politicians
I don`t want to knock the contributions of politicians but it seems to me that the Order of BC should be for contributions that go beyond a job.
Trevor Linden received the Order of BC. He was a pretty good hockey player but that is not the reason he got the award. He used his celebrity as a hockey player to do much good for his community and he is recognized for those contributions.
Politicians are doing a job. And at the federal and provincial level are compensated fairly well. Sure many work tirelessly for their constituents but so do many teachers or doctors or people in other occupations. That should not be the standard of the award. It should be more than just doing good work at your job.
The nature of a politicians job is to make a difference. And only time can tell how much of a difference a politician will have made.
Fish-counter
35 weeks ago
David Suzuki
He has a whiny voice, but he does good work.
Lawrence
35 weeks ago
The guys...
who put together The Tyee.
They did, and continue to do, an excellent job
Perry
35 weeks ago
sorry if I double posted
I've never had problems posting comments here. They have always been published automatically, until today. I twice tried submitting a comment just now but they never appeared. It contained a hyperlink so maybe that was the problem. I'll post this as a test without a hyperlink.
Perry
35 weeks ago
The Order of British Columbia is Out of Order
Here's a blog post I wrote last week about this. My blog Chain The Dogma is listed in BC Blogs on this site, but for some reason putting a hyperlink to it here in these comments causes the comment to be rejected.
The Order of British Columbia is Out of Order
If ordinary citizens of British Columbia, not corrupt political, legal, or corporate elitists, could choose appointees to the Order ...
Geoff
35 weeks ago
The form was broken!!!
It stopped accepting applications. But now it's working again. Sorry, folks.
monty
35 weeks ago
Harold Steves
Farmland forever!
Chris Cannon
35 weeks ago
ceremony?
Is there an official ceremony for the Order of BC? Any plans to organize a protest?
Fish-counter
35 weeks ago
P.S. Gordon Campbell's nomination was premature
Weasel-words aside, he was still in power when he was nominated. Maybe he was given the award after he quit, but his award should have been done next year, if at all. The way it was done sucks of patronage and incestuousness.
I would like to nominate two other people for their environmental work, but they are not public names and it would be inappropriate.
bookbinder
35 weeks ago
old order
Given who they have nominated I fully expect to see Thow nominated after he is out of gaol.
Van Isle
35 weeks ago
How about Terry and Betty
How about Terry and Betty Fox?
Norman Farrell
35 weeks ago
Replacing flawed OBC is a necessity
The fatally flawed Order of British Columbia must be scrapped. Rushing to aggrandize themselves and their own financial backers, BC Liberals destroyed the award's intended essence.
It was supposed to recognize:
"those persons who have served with the greatest distinction and excelled in any field of endeavour benefiting the people of the Province or elsewhere."
Over time, the statement has mutated to include a part two, which reads:
"those persons who have served the BC Liberal party with distinction and excelled at benefiting themselves and their associates without concern for the people of the Province or elsewhere."
I made my first nomination, a certainty for the short list: Alexandra Morton.
http://northerninsights.blogspot.com/2011/09/for-service-with-distinction-to-bc.html
Skywalker
35 weeks ago
How about?
Alexandra Morton, Rafe Maier, Michael J. Fox, Harold Steeves to name a few. Of course after the last high profile mistakes maybe none of them would be interested.
dorothy
35 weeks ago
I would very much like
the order to be awarded to those individuals in the Squamish Nation, who decided to 'adopt' the former Forest Service recreation sites in their jurisdiction and keep maintaining them and keep the accessible for the public. This is service to the Province as I understand it.
Driftwood
35 weeks ago
Powellriverpersuader
I'd recommend Grant for the humor he has provided over the last difficult years, the hard hitting articles he writes, and because he always has lots of facts to support them. Takes a lot of research to do what he does and to the best of my knowledge he doesn't get paid for it. Nobody offered Grant a duckshit in England with round the clock bodyguards to protect him from wrathful BCers.
WendyB
35 weeks ago
David Y.H. Lui
Sadly it's too late for David Y.H. Lui, though he did receive the OC in 2000.
igbymac
35 weeks ago
According to Tieleman
"Regardless of Campbell's failings," wrote Tieleman, "he has made a long contribution to public service as a Vancouver councillor, mayor, MLA and premier...."
When does having a job in government have to do with serving the public, prima facie? You talk like one leads naturally to the other. Talk about drinking the Kool Aid!
alvin54
35 weeks ago
truly deserving
Garth Warnock
Google that name.....
I_Am_PEO
35 weeks ago
ABSOLUTELY, POSITIVELY SEAN HOLMAN!
Sean Holman is the heroic journalist who speaks for me and every other citizen & friend of British Columbia who believes in fighting for the truth.
Not corporations.
Not ideology.
Not unions.
Just people. Real people.
In fact, as I recall, in the opening days of the "Order of BC" showdown, a Facebook group was created for Sean Holman - https://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Sean-Holman-for-Order-of-BC/120095378091716
Cool :-). Although I wonder why the page creator "likes" IRIS Flight Simulation Software. LOL!
Peter Dimitrov
35 weeks ago
My thoughts
Bob Williams
John Calvert
Alexandra Morton
Furthermore, there are some excellent lawyers, retired or near retirement that come to mind that have advanced the law in Canada considerably in such areas as labor law, first nations law, constitutional rights pertaining to disabled persons and environmental law. I will leave it to others to mention names.
Further, there are some incredible First Nations leaders who likewise deserve recognition for a lifetime of work advancing
the rights of first nations provincially, nationally and internationally. I leave it to others to mention names.
Finally, the late Professor Irving Fox deserves recognition for decades of work in the environmental area: (Sierra Club, Sierra Legal Defense, Westwater Research, Integrated Land Use Resouce Planning matters in BC.
The Director of the BC Food Banks for many years - name escapes me --but someone knows.
There are quite a number of musicians, writers, actors/actresses.
Aside from this, the entire Order of BC nomination and selection process needs to be much more open for public participation. Rather then letting a few decide, put the names on line and let those on the voters list vote electronically.
zalm
35 weeks ago
Off the top of my head
Nancy Hermiston - UBC Opera. Gave a much more public face to this art form that had languished so long in Canada, and now on par with Winnipeg and sending grads to Europe to perform.
Ben Heppner - tenor. Not one of Nancy's talents, but a stellar man nonetheless. Not only a European performer of great note, but a constant encourager of good works, helping other students, and lending his name and voice to raise funds for causes around BC and the world.
Abe Rogatnick - artist and architect; and every architect that came through UBC in the last thirty years had his influence to thank for whatever spark of creativity remains in their practice.
Mel Lehan - teach, author, tireless campaigner fopr every cause under the sun designed to make life better for ordinary people, from schools in his neighbourhood, to nuclear disarmament and Jews for a Just Peace. Comes from a line of similar people who also deserve the Order except they're dead.
Just a few quick names that I know personally. Sorry that none of them are businessmen or politicians - I'm sure someone will be able to remedy my oversight...
vera gottlieb
35 weeks ago
Trying to nominate someone to The People's Order of BC
Why is The Tyee making it so frigging difficult to nominate someone??? A name, an email address should be enough. My goodness, it isn't as if this is going to go world-wide. Some computer 'genius' at work again???
pianosaurus rex
35 weeks ago
Dr. Krist Miller and Alexandra Morton
I would put forward these two persons. Dr. Kristi Miller is the one who has taken the previous research into salmon ISAV and salmon anaemia and furthered the science on these serious problems that affect the most significant mental image that BC is known for; our iconic salmon runs; known worldwide by sports fishing enthusiasts, commercial fishermen, the restaurant industry Canada-wide, along with many other groups.
She has risen above the threats to from the federal government to silence her; further testifying at the Cohen Commission has cost her significant funding to her own laboratory; removed by the Treasury Board.
She along with Alexandra, are fighting to save what this province is well known for. That in my book deserves recognition. It is one of our visual symbols of this province; the twisting Chinook, leaping out of the raging stream, hooked on the line with the fisherman standing in wading boots……..
As far as comments on the Order of BC when we have the head of the court system Lance Finch spouting off in public like a cheerleader about Campbell’s eligibility, not only does this reveal a certain personal bias, it shames our entire court system and compromises our courts’ objectivity.
Geoff
35 weeks ago
@vera gottlieb
Thanks for the chance to clarify, vera gottlieb.
As mentioned in the story above, we hope to take this list and come up with a shortlist that everyone will have a chance of voting on. The more persuasive the write-up is(especially for those not in the spotlight), the more chance readers will vote for that person. And it allows us to vet the entry.
Apologies if this is too much of a barrier for you. It's much less than is required for actual Order of BC.
janetvickers
35 weeks ago
What a great idea
The Order of B.C. has clearly become an arm of corporate propaganda that rewards those who work for the anthro-hyaenas.
The People's Order of BC - I look forward to seeing who gets nominated.
michael maser
35 weeks ago
A few on my list ...
Alexandra Morton, Adrian Carr & Paul George, David Suzuki, Barry Sullivan (posthumous nomination; the Sullivan Commission of 1987 was a seminal blueprint for educational change that was bungled by ... well, just about every agency and vested interest group that felt threatened by it), Harry Rankin (posthumous nomination), many First Nations groups, sustainable architecture pioneer Peter Busby ... 'nuff for now.
alive
35 weeks ago
Go Dave!
Dave Barret introduced legislation that even the most aggressive neocons did not dare to destroy!
Thanks to Dave we have the agricultural Land Act, that has saved farmland from "development".
Yes, there have been politicians worth honouring!
Jeffrey J.
35 weeks ago
And the nominees are...
I would nominate:
Alexandra Morton
Rafe Mair
David Beers
Andrew Nikiforuk
UBC Prof. Chris Shaw
Sean Holman
Bill Tieleman
All have been exemplary leaders in the realm of inspiring us to respect truth and the search for justice.
Peter Dimitrov
35 weeks ago
Tyee please clarify how this will work
Hi Tyee,
Great idea but I think it time you clarify and make transparent "the rules" as to how this will work. For example:
1. who is eligible to be nominated, who not
2. who can vote, who can not
3. what safeguards will you take to ensure security of the voting system for one Tyee memeber = one vote.
4. are there limits to the number of people who can be nominated
5. could a little bio be written up about each nominee so voters can be informed
6. can a person nominated decline
etc.
Hope this gets the ball rolling further along, best now, Pete
Samp
35 weeks ago
People's Order of BC
for your consideration:
Bruce Eriksen - an artist, social activist and founder of Vancouver's Downtown Eastside Residents Association (DERA)
Bill Henderson - lead singer, main composer for the band "The Collectors" which then went on to became "Chilliwack"
lynn
35 weeks ago
With Thanks From The People of BC:
Donald Gutstein - For: "Not a Conspiracy Theory: How Business Hijacks Democracy".
Stanley Tromp - For his work on FOI.
Duncan McCue - For his reporting on aboriginal issues in BC.
Alexandra Morton - The definition of brave integrity.
Brian Brett - BC author/poet. Brilliant.
Sean Holman - Investigative reporting
The Tyee/David Beers - Last but not least. Investigative and Thought-provoking.
lynn
35 weeks ago
How could I forget.....?
The online "Salt Spring News"/ Editors: Jim Scott and Cameron Smith
A Drop in the Bucket
35 weeks ago
I nominate ....
BC Mary....A real Canadian hero, the voice of justice, the driving force in keeping the BC Rail theft story alive.
Illness and heartbreak couldn`t stop her.
Good Day
Mary deLisser
35 weeks ago
We nominate:
Dr Ernie Murakami retired MD of Hope BC who took on the role of Canada's go-to doctor for Lyme disease. Google his name.
Geoff
35 weeks ago
@Peter Dimitrov
You asked: "1. who is eligible to be nominated, who not"
As mentioned in the story above, same eligibility rules as the Order of BC, as documented here: http://www.orderofbc.gov.bc.ca/nominations/
You asked: "2. who can vote, who can not"
Ideally all British Columbian residents. But because of the technical details, we may have to go with one vote per household. Will get back to you on that.
You asked: "3. what safeguards will you take to ensure security of the voting system for one Tyee memeber = one vote."
Looking into it. Will get back to you.
You asked: "4. are there limits to the number of people who can be nominated"
Currently no limits. If we get a lot of spam, we may change that.
You asked: "5. could a little bio be written up about each nominee so voters can be informed"
Absolutely.
You asked: "6. can a person nominated decline"
Interesting question. We'll get back to you on that.
pwlg
35 weeks ago
all the unsung heroes who work tirelessly and without pay
There are three people who combined have for more than 20 years protected the environmentally sensitive area of Boundary Bay.
From the days when government wanted to fill in Boundary Bay to build an international shipping port to today where the bay is given an international designation as an important bird area and a wildlife management area my three nominees have been organizing their communities, going to endless meetings and hearings and preventing destructive plans from going ahead that would harm the fragile and important international aspect of Boundary Bay.
The big prize of all would be a RAMSAR designation as a World Biosphere Reserve.
In 1992, Boundary Bay and Roberts Bank were proposed as a World Biosphere Reserve by the Boundary Bay Conservation Committee: Ours to Preserve. The proposal was endorsed by 22 community groups and the Municipal Councils of Delta, Surrey, and White Rock.
Boundary Bay exceeds the recognized criteria for a wetland of international importance (a global designation under the Ramsar convention) and for a Hemispheric category WHSRN (Western Hemisphere Shorebird Reserve Network) site. In 1995, 11,000 hectares of Boundary Bay outside the dyke were designated as a Wildlife Management Area (WMA) by the province of BC.
In 1998, Sturgeon Bank was designated a WMA, and once Roberts Bank receives WMA designation the intention is to submit Boundary Bay, Sturgeon Banks and Roberts Bank WMA's for WHSRN designation.
The three hard working persons from Delta are:
Anne Murray
Susan Jones
Dr. Mary Tait
These are just three of the thousands of people of BC who work hard for a better future. Without fanfare and mainstream media piddling themselves over the rich and famours (the so-called movers and shakers) many BC residents collectively provide the most good (which politicians love to claim and own for themselves or their political parties) for all of us.