Opinion

'The Death of Evidence' in Canada: Scientists' Own Words

Data distorted for 'propaganda' and other complaints against the Harper government made at last week's Ottawa rally.

By Katie Gibbs, Adam Houben, Jeff Hutchings, Arne Mooers, Vance L. Trudeau and Diane Orihel, 16 Jul 2012, TheTyee.ca

Death of Evidence rally in Ottawa

'Death of Evidence' rally on Parliament Hill, July 10. Photo: Richard Webster.

Related

[Editor's note: On July 10, at least 2,000 people, many of them scientists and their graduate students, marched through Ottawa to Parliament Hill to protest the Harper government's cuts to scientific research and clamp-down on what government-funded scientific researchers can say in public -- a development organizers named "The Death of Evidence." Some of the speakers' remarks are reprinted here.]

An 'untimely death'
Katie Gibbs, PhD student in biology, University of Ottawa:

"Thank you all for coming out to mark this important occasion. It is inspiring to see so many scientists here today. I know most of you would much prefer to be in your labs doing what you do best rather than here, but we are at a critical point in Canadian history and if we don't stand up for science, no one will...

"We are here today to commemorate the untimely death of evidence in Canada. After a long battle with the current federal government, Evidence has suffered its final blow. Between the sweeping cuts to federal science programs, the changes to legislation in Bill C-38 and the muzzling of scientists, the injuries to Evidence were simply overwhelming.

"But today, we have chosen to celebrate Evidence. To do so, we have invited a number of prominent scientists, NGO leaders and politicians here today to deliver short eulogies that will, I hope, help us understand the importance of Evidence to Canadian society as well as some of the injuries that led to its demise..."

'We want to work together to solve Canada's problems'
Vance L. Trudeau, professor of biology, University of Ottawa:

"...As a proud citizen and a scientist I am completely perplexed at the decisions to fire world-class scientists, to muzzle government researchers, and to close world-class facilities. There is little budgetary justification for most of the anti-science actions the government has taken. Why not close the inefficient facilities?

"Either the government is very poorly advised, or they are part of an ideology that is anti-science and against making educated, well-informed decisions in the best interest of a dynamic, pluralistic society. I cannot make this judgment myself. I will leave it to the people of Canada to decide.

"However, the tendency to only use the data and evidence you 'like' is the misuse of information for alternative purposes. This is known as propaganda. If you think 'this can't happen in Canada,' then you are disregarding the very evidence the government is providing us by their own actions.

"Prime Minister Harper has said that we will not recognize Canada when he finishes with us. He is clearly missing some history lessons. Unfortunately, aspects of his government's social and environmental policies remind me of the Duplessis-era Québec and Canada in the 1950s.

"I have covered the criticism part of my talk. I would also like to point out something positive on the horizon. The current government is promoting some aspects of applied research and this is a very good thing. I support and respect this positive step, but it cannot be at the expense of fundamental scientific discoveries that actually drive applied research. I wonder whether the prime minister's office staff understands this important connection. The 2,000 people here (official numbers from the RCMP) at the Death of Evidence rally can help explain it to the PMO. We want to work together to solve Canada's issues and problems.

"Allow me to pose a series of questions to put into perspective the decisions our government has taken -- that is, to cut the sources of information needed for policy making, for long-term planning, and to treat all Canadians equally under the eyes of the law.

"Would you buy a house without checking market prices or without shopping for a mortgage? No.


"Would a physician tell you that you have cancer without a test? (Audience shouts 'No.')


"Would you even accept the diagnosis based on one test? (Audience shouts 'No.')


"Would you plan the economic, educational and social programs of a nation of 35 million people without the data provided by a detailed national census? (Audience shouts 'No.')


"I would not accept this approach from any party forming a government. Not from the current Conservatives, the NDP, the Liberals or the Green Party.

"My final question to you is...

"Do you demand that Parliament revisit their ill-intentioned and ill-advised decisions about science cuts? (Audience shouts 'Yes.')

"Yes, Evidence can be resurrected. Thank you."

'Evidence is how adults navigate reality'
Arne Mooers, professor of biodiversity, Simon Fraser University:

"A 'Death of Evidence' funeral is fairly funny, but all of us gathered today are deadly serious. In an age of accelerating global climate change, there is no option to us but to behave responsibly.

"We are facing very serious issues regarding our energy, our food, our water and our environment. There are things to discuss as adults: nuclear power may be worth the long-term headaches of its waste; all species may not be equally important to Canadian ecosystems; carbon taxes may be the fairest way to move our society away from fossil fuels. But all these are possibilities that can only be adjudicated for adults with evidence.

Death of Evidence rally signs

'Freedom of expression is no longer a right enjoyed by Canadian government scientists,' biologist Jeff Hutchings told the July 10 audience. Photo: Richard Webster.

"For evidence is how adults navigate reality. To deny evidence is to live in a fantasy world. Fantasy is a lovely place to find yourself if you are four years old. However, in an adult world where milk needs to make its way to shops day in and day out, one cannot live in a fantasy world.

"Indeed, and this has been mentioned already, when wielded by countries, fantasy translates to a very much darker term: propaganda. This sounds alarmist, even to me, and I am saying it, but we should call a spade a spade.

"Recent actions by our federal government, ranging from changes at Statistics Canada, to official positions on climate change and the gutting of the Fisheries Act, to the extreme control over how government scientists communicate to the people they work for, are retreats from reality...

"Canadians want to behave as adults. We must be seen by the world to be behaving as adults. Today, the risks of living in a fantasy world are real risks. A mock casket is funny, but the risks are not funny. Today is not a joke."

'An iron curtain is being drawn between science and society'
Jeff Hutchings, professor of biology, Dalhousie University, president of the Canadian Society For Ecology and Evolution:

"...The federal government has weakened national fisheries and environmental legislation, trivialized the relevance of scientific advice, and eliminated government scientific research of fundamental importance to the health of Canadian society.

"Why has the government taken these actions? The minister of Fisheries and Oceans provides a clue. In June he wrote that the existing Fisheries Act offered 'few tools to authorise pollution' but that the new legislation (Bill C-38) would 'establish new tools to authorise deposits of deleterious substances.' In other words, changes to the Fisheries Act will make it easier to authorise the pollution of Canada's waters.

"What can go wrong when a country prioritizes economic development at any cost and devalues science at the same time? Canada provides a stellar example.

Death at Death of Evidence rally

Funeral march to the Hill: 'This generation of students is at the forefront of the burgeoning science-and-policy debate,' said PhD student Adam Houben. Photo: Richard Webster.

"The collapse of Newfoundland's Atlantic cod fishery occurred 20 years ago this month. This was the greatest loss of a vertebrate species in Canadian history; it resulted in Canada's biggest single job loss. When will history repeat itself?

"Freedom of expression is no longer a right enjoyed by Canadian government scientists. These individuals paid by taxpayers to undertake research in support of society are not permitted to speak to Canadians unless they have ministerial permission to do so.

"When you inhibit the communication of science, you inhibit science. When you inhibit science, you inhibit the acquisition of knowledge. Government control over the ability of society to acquire knowledge has alarming precedents.

"An iron curtain is being drawn by government between science and society. Closed curtains, especially those made of iron, make for very dark rooms.

"A former Scandinavian politician with impeccable international credentials provides an informed and enlightened perspective on politics and science. These are the words of Gro Harlem Brundtland who served three terms as prime minister of Norway. She said:

"'Science must underpin our policies. If we compromise on scientific facts and evidence, repairing nature will be enormously costly -- if possible at all. Politics that disregard science and knowledge will not stand the test of time.'

"Thank you."

'Demanding open science within a transparent government'
Adam Houben, PhD Student in biology, University of Ottawa:

"The Death of Evidence event was largely organized by science students from across Canada, exemplifying the unified national scientific voice of the future. We contest that recent policies, cuts and deregulation will limit future research capacity and the long-term viability of our natural resources.

"This current generation of students is at the forefront of the burgeoning science-and-policy debate and will be even louder in demanding for open science within a transparent government.

"For all Canadian students, we ask that the government continue to support pure science, consult with the scientific community, and allow the basic freedom of scientific speech that all Canadians have a right to be informed about."

A 'blindfold of ignorance imposed'
Diane Orihel, aquatic biologist, University of Alberta, leader of the Coalition to Save Experimental Lakes Area:

"Dear friends, we are gathered here to mourn the demise of science -- a devastating loss that will reverberate in the daily lives of all Canadians for years to come.

"Today, with great sadness, I reflect upon the passing of Canada's Experimental Lakes Area -- a well-decorated soldier who lost the battle in the fight to protect Canada's freshwaters, its lakes and its fish.

"On May 17, the Experimental Lakes was found guilty of innovative, cost-effective scientific research; its punishment -- a death penalty by the Harper government. The Lakes sit nervously on death row, marked for execution at the age of 44.

"Born in the '60s during a decade of hope, the Experimental Lakes became an explorer, discovering important connections between the activities of people and the rest of nature's living web. It was spawned by a forward-thinking government who recognized the value of science-based evidence to find solutions to its problems.

"The Experimental Lakes propelled Canada to the very forefront of aquatic science. Its 58 small lakes, laced across northwestern Ontario, offered a living laboratory for study unlike any other in the world. The best scientists from around the globe flocked to these Canadian lakes to ask questions that could not be asked elsewhere.

"Its first mission in life was to save a dying Lake Erie. The Lakes led us to understand that the phosphorus making our laundry white was also clogging waterways with algae soup. This evidence led detergent-makers to change their formulas, and our lakes recovered.

"At age eight, the Experimental Lakes tackled a new problem. They uncovered that 'acid rain' from burning coal was killing the base of aquatic food webs, leaving fish to die of starvation. Again, evidence led to changes in air pollution regulations, and our lakes recovered.

"As a young adult, the Experimental Lakes got down to work with hydroelectric utilities to teach them how to design better reservoirs. In the years to follow, the Lakes discovered that hormones in sewage feminize male fish, and that mercury emitted from smokestacks accumulates in fish as a human neurotoxin.

"Now on the verge of its untimely death, the Experimental Lakes are grappling with unresolved problems, such as how climate change alters lakes, and how synthetic nanoparticles -- put on our clothes to kill bacteria -- may be a new threat.

"The Lakes may have answered these questions in time to prevent great human and environmental suffering, as well as economic hardship -- but, alas, the Lakes are marked for death.

"Today, we mourn the Experimental Lakes, but moreover, we mourn the blindfold of ignorance imposed upon our once great country."

To hear some of what was said at the July 10 rally, watch this video.  [Tyee]

41  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Forest_Lover

    48 weeks ago

    Forest Facts being hidden for a while now.

    The Commitee on Timber Supply just completed its tour of BC to hear from residents regarding where trees could be found to prop up jobs. This after BC government started muzzeling its Professional Foresters a decade ago. Plants and trees are indicators of climate change and by underfunding inventory and climate reaserach the Liberals forestalled the truth of what this commitee has been tasked with doing, facing the truth. People who walk the forests and saw this first hand were kept in the dark and from speaking. Why? Same reason. To allow natural resources to prop up the economy until the very last second.

  • Grumpy

    48 weeks ago

    We live in the age of Joeseph Goebbels

    If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”

    Joseph Goebbels

    This is the modus operandi of Harper and his Conservative government.

    Since WW2, the big lie is the main tactic of ruling governments and those in power will do anything to remain in power.

    Democracy and the freedom of speech, the forms that our politicians and their mainstream media henchmen preach almost daily just do not exist in this country.

  • rantnic

    48 weeks ago

    @# Grumpy

    Democracy in the USA? Democracy in Canada? Democracy anywhere? "The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie."

    P.T. Barnum said it, "You can fool all of the people some of the time..." But when you control the media and say over and over again, that same mantra? "Thou shalt not disagree with Harper".. "Thou shalt not disagree with Harper".. "Thou shalt not disagree with Harper"..

    The evidence that Harper is so ready to kill, comes from the same source as the evidence that proves his fundamentalist, "creationist" religious theories are completely wrong.

    Stephen Harper is about as far right as any Christian fundamentalist can go. That is a fact that is not said enough, over and over and over again by the Harper friendly media.

  • Fiat lux

    48 weeks ago

    What surprises me is that

    What surprises me is that anybody is surprised over Harper's actions. The man is a visible mental case and walking disaster area, born without conscience.

    I've been writing for many tears that I have seen those expressionless, brutal eyes under Totenkopf and Red Star caps.

    The cosy relationship between the leaders of our "conservative" capitalists and the communists in China, conspiring to supply them with resources to take over the world is the best example of their brotherhood and what the world can expect from them.

    Ed Deak.

  • Grumpy

    48 weeks ago

    Actually it was Abe Lincoln who said...........

    ............"You can fool all of the people some of the time..."

    P. T. Barnum said; "There is a sucker born every minute."

    It is my firm belief that anyone that people belonging to organized religion should be declared unfit for public office.

  • peasant43

    48 weeks ago

    a reminder : this is want Canadians want

    Canada 2011

    Conservative 166
    New Democratic 103
    Liberal 34
    Bloc Québécois 4
    Green 1

    BC 2011

    Conservative 21
    New Democratic 12
    Liberal 2
    Green 1

  • Hakuin

    48 weeks ago

    You don't need facts in heaven.

    Or hell.

  • Booker

    48 weeks ago

    This is not what Canadians voted for

    Peasant43: More than 60% of Canadians voted for something different than what we got in the last federal election. Virtually all of that 60% voted for something to the left of what we got. So, no, the Conservative government is not a representative government, thanks to our electoral system.

  • Fiat lux

    48 weeks ago

    Ideologies are also forms of

    Ideologies are also forms of religions, divorced from realities, as shown by some of our friends on this list.

    Monetary economics are bona fide religious theories based on "faith", with the so called "economists" acting as the Priesthood of the Money God who keeps promising "prosperity", but delivers poverty, disguised as "austerity", while increasing the powers of special interests that used to be called "aristocracies, chosen by God".

    There's nothing new in history, all this has happened, under various guises, for thousands of years and the suckers are still falling for the same faith based garbage.

    Ed Deak

  • igbymac

    48 weeks ago

    What surprises me, Fiat lux

    ... is that there is a nation full of folks who believe that perhaps some other Party leader would behave significantly different than Harper if put in to the prearranged seat of power.

    But, then again, 'belief is the death of intelligence'. ;)

  • Talon

    48 weeks ago

    Facts and Beliefs

    At home, believe what you want. In the restof the world however, your decisions should be based on evidence and facts. Prime Mistake Harper is a believer in the Pentecostal Missionary Alliance way of thinking about the world and it dismisses the evidence of science. As his buddy republican Senator Inhofe of Oklahoma repeats continuously, God makes all the climate change and global warming decisions for the earthlings, humans have nothing to do with it. Thanks Prime Mistake and Senator Inhofe for your beliefs but please keep them at home and let us make decisions about the real world with real evidence.

  • Hakuin

    48 weeks ago

    since all non-believers are destined for hell

    there can be no sin in rounding them up and exterminating them. God wills it.

  • Perry

    48 weeks ago

    seriously sick body politic

    Harper is not the first, just the latest and worst symptom of our seriously sick body politic. He is an evil man, and I don't mean in the theological sense, but in the psychological sense as used by Philip Zimbardo.

    The very system itself is corrupt. Politicians and bureaucrats like to consider themselves public servants, but they serve their corporate masters and themselves first, taking the very best portions of the public wealth and serving the crumbs to the poorest citizens to whom that wealth actually belongs.

    The poor can only be 'eaten' for so long before they turn the table and begin 'eating' the rich.

  • stevebailey

    48 weeks ago

    As ignorant as Harper

    Grumpy's commenta that "anyone in organized religion. "fundamentalist theories" and banning "religious people" from elected office are among the most ignorant comments imaginable. Such mindless irrational fanaticism is worse than anything the Harper Tories could hit us with. Grab a brain, Grumpy. Fight fire with fire, not stupidity.

  • Dan the socialist

    48 weeks ago

    stevebailey why should myth

    stevebailey why should myth and superstition be involved in running the country? people who believe in something that is not real are mentally ill.

  • woodworker

    48 weeks ago

    NOw I understand how Climate change/AGW became to be believed.

    If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”

    Only this time instead of the state it is the NGO's that found a great way to get funding and keep their jobs.

  • woodworker

    48 weeks ago

    Works both ways

    Works both ways folks, I see it all the time. The Tyee is actually worse than Harper by a long shot. they just don't happen to be our present dictator.

  • DavidN

    48 weeks ago

    Fiat Lux

    All interesting comments so far.
    Although FL, to agree with you I'd have to believe you. Since you are not logically debating a situation, you are promoting a belief. You are therefore now one of them.

    Its a stretch. A fun one for the acerbic among us. I agree that to have all play the same economic game demands a reliance on conformance to a principle, but that is still not religion. That is just a handy way to identify oneself as part of some class war.

    But I like the argument anyway, as it points out the fact to me that our ecosystem doesn't give a rat's petooty what economic theories we have all agreed upon. They are meaningless rules when we have exhausted the ability for this ecosystem to allow our survival to continue.

    Ideologies may not have value, and don't need to have value to be, but being unreal doesn't necessarily make them religions.

    But religion in a true sense can be a handy method of forming public opinion, and so rejecting the data upon which our long term survival depends for short term gain. It helps that the people in control of our resources actually believe in the religion...probably...maybe...you think? I don't think it is mandatory.

    Anyway, I guess I get your point.

  • Waltz

    48 weeks ago

    Fascism

    What we are witnessing is the successful suppression of democracy, the usurpation of citizen power by corporations, and the rise of fascism in Canada.

  • hg

    48 weeks ago

    MSM

    Here is an idea. Do not buy MSM newspapers or magazines, do not tune in to MSM channels. Completely ignore MSM. MSM means any company that owns more than one newspaper and/or station in more than one town.
    Go to the internet for your news and information.
    By reading or watching MSM you are paying for Harper's propaganda with your after tax income.

  • Fiat lux

    48 weeks ago

    David.....Ideologies are

    David.....Ideologies are pseudo religions and I have lived under every one, including the governments of Hitler, Stalin, Attlee and Churchill, just to name some big names. In other words, I have seen them all.

    I used to have a custom furniture shop on Powell nr.Victoria when Mao's Little Red Book was the craze. I was working high up on a ladder on the front of the shop, fixing something, when a young guy came slowly walking down the street, reading the Red Book.

    He walked under my ladder, without apparently noticing it and as he was past, he knelt down on the sidewalk and kept reading the book.

    When you see some of the political rallies, the mass behavour, the hysteria is the carbon copy of any fundamentalist religious rally.

    Faith conquers all, especially logical thought, which includes some university courses, like neoclassical economics.

    Ed Deak.

  • boondoggle

    48 weeks ago

    peasant 43

    "What luck for rulers that men do not think”
    - Adolf Hitler

  • Perry

    48 weeks ago

    The people are absolved from any further obedience

    "Native Americans’ resistance to the westward expansion of Europeans took two forms. One was violence. The other was accommodation. Neither worked. Their land was stolen, their communities were decimated, their women and children were gunned down and the environment was ravaged. There was no legal recourse. There was no justice. There never is for the oppressed. And as we face similar forces of predatory, unchecked corporate power intent on ruthless exploitation and stripping us of legal and physical protection, we must confront how we will respond.

    ...

    “Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power,” wrote the philosopher John Locke, “they put themselves into a state of war with the people who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience.”

    http://www.alternet.org/story/156204/time_to_get_crazy%3A_what_we_can_learn_from_native_american_resistance_to_colonists%27_greed

  • dsturdy

    48 weeks ago

    Triablism in Canadian politics

    Many of us are guilty of tribalism and until we can get beyond this, we will continue to have this dichotomy of left and right. I you haven't already, have a listen to this TED address.
    http://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind.html

  • nssx4driver

    48 weeks ago

    Follow the Money

    Every political and economic situation that over-rides environment, people, our ability to thrive, everything, can be evaluated in the long run, just follow the money to the very top, and I certainly don't mean the Canadian PM.

  • jimmmmy

    48 weeks ago

    Goon squad

    People say that a picture is worth 10,000 words to see what Harper and his goon squads think of democracy and evidence, pull up the video of a man on his knees being kicked in the face by a mountie wearing a steel toed boot with a pistol in his hand in downtown Kelowna recently. Tags are Mantler/Tavares.

  • Ernest

    48 weeks ago

    Logical influence

    With Harper ensuring corporate oil and gas investment will be met in Canada with financial and legislative support, along with all the new secretive legislation and spending, one can only wonder how much these flunkies are receiving in "extra" funds, also known as "graff, payola, bribes".

    In reality, Canada is not the only country with these woes - for example, recently, the LA Times online has repeatedly reported political payoff scandals that are destroying the state.

    To say it is not happening in Canada is foolish and naive. Our police should be monitoring the con and BC mobs all the time - I am convinced many would be arrested very quickly.

  • peasant43

    48 weeks ago

    boondoggle

    Hitler...don't buy it for a second. They're thinking clearly.

    Canadians may be passive aggressive compared with Yanks. They'll wave a green flag in public, but they want their FPP electoral system, minivans, McMansions, and RRSPs.

    The worse it gets environmentally/economically the more Harpers there are going to be...better get used to it.

  • Sask Resident

    48 weeks ago

    Science?

    Why were only biologists represented? I assume that they are all "wildlife" biologists rather than those working on DNA sequencing or working on transforming the environment for the production of animals and plants for human use (also called agriculture) or cell theory or genetics. How about researchers working in the fields of chemistry or physics? How about engineers who use the monitoring data to design and build infrastructure? So, the demonstration was mainly by wildlife biologists trying to protect their grants, except for maybe those trying to save the ELA.

  • Sask Resident

    48 weeks ago

    hg: MSM

    hg wants everyone to ignore the mainstream media and get their information off the internet. I assume he/she is kidding since the main stream media owns most of the news sites on the internet and The Tyee took this article from the main stream media.

  • OwlRol

    48 weeks ago

    Censoring evidence is suicidal insanity

    Hey, Ed, I never walked under your ladder, but there were some good ideas in Mao's little red book, amidst all the rubbish.

    Uninspected frames of reference often determine the blind zeal of the group.

    Like any orthodoxy, political, religious or economic, one must critically cherry pick the worthwhile stuff and heave the rest.

    Some notions need to be kept in a skeptical limbo until deeper analysis and verification can legitimately place them on the quality stack or the trash pile.

    Scientists, despite some of their foibles, including arrogance and inflexibility, as they practice sometimes quasi-religiously in their ivory towers, are still our best qualified individuals to rely on unbiased evidence to determine what's really happening amidst all the contradictory cacophony.

    Some evidence is open to interpretation, mostly because the research is incomplete, but other evidence is much more straightforward, unless the frame of reference is lacking.

    A killing bolt of lightning could be interpreted as the wrath of God, but if that were the case, only our worst would be struck. Evidence does not support this.

    Neo-classical economics has some value, but it is not based on solid, long-term evidence. Adam Smith would roll over in his grave to see how it evolved.

    Remove good quality evidence and any unsupported statement, such as the need for harsher Canadian laws are needed to reduce the increasing criminal activity now occuring. Without opposing evidence, even more sheep would believe it.

    The game is now to falsify good evidence, such is propaganda. Jewish skulls were inferior to German ones, although anyone growing up together knew it to be untrue. Let's dump pollutants in waterways because marine life there has little or no value. Climate change is a myth, nothing to do with humans.

    Both sides present evidence, some more reliable than other. If uncertain, place it in that limbo category, don't throw it all out without scrutiny.

    That's not what's happening now in Canada. It's the worst of Tea Party style evidential censorship, much worse than even under the W Bush regime, a true form of suicidal insanity.

  • Hakuin

    48 weeks ago

    Ernest:

    the people you want monitored OWN the police.

  • MHPNews

    48 weeks ago

    Evidence Base

    Wouldn't it be nice if everyone thought like us: the scientists, researchers, the ever-vigilant protectors of the facts? Here's a fact: as a profession we continually and collectively FAIL at getting our message across to main-stream media. Why is that? Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't dare over- generalize... there are some who are good at both. Our own 1%...

    If we are being honest & fighting to protect the factual domain, how many conferences have you attended where one of the topics Wasn't 'knowledge translation', or whatever terminology was in favor that year. We hold evidence in the highest esteem; love logical, well-reasoned arguments and think of ourselves as always open to having our assertions proven false. We congratulate each other on groundbreaking work- while the rest of Canada goes on with life. It's damn frustrating! However....

    ... the Ottawa rally. AMAZING!! Everyone who participated, from the speakers to the last person to show up - you were perfect! THIS is what can happen when we stop being so focused on our own obsession.. *ahem, I mean work for more than two minutes, look around us and say 'THIS IS WRONG', we have to be the protectors of evidence and we CAN'T stand by and watch.

    The comments about people bing shocked, how the 'scientist's revolt' was so out of character that it could not be ignored.. But we they shocked because of a lack of awareness of the issue or because of their image of a 'scientist'. Because we are one hell of a passionate group - our work happily occupies our thoughts day and night. Research is not just a job or a way of earning a living, it represents the very core of our values and beliefs! You don't work an entire career on a subject without feeling it in your bones.

    I think that the shock came a bit from both directions, but I worry more about the awareness. That is what made this rally so perfect: awareness raised! If politicians can have a 'supporter' base, why shouldn't we create our own 'evidence' base?

    I was and still am so proud of the scientific community, coming together to defend reason, logic and evidence.

    Next time it will be 4000...and I'll be there.

  • Fiat lux

    48 weeks ago

    Owl.....We can find merits in

    Owl.....We can find merits in the theories of the craziest. When Hitler took over starving, depression ridden Germany in 1933 the country was booming and the envy of Europe within months, but this doesn't excuse his later crimes.

    Albeit some of our politicians could find out what he did and how?

    One of the biggest frauds going now is the use of Adam Smith's "ìnvisible hand" theory to justify the biggest crime wave in history, just as the communists have been and are using Marx as the excuse for their crimes.

    All Adam Smith wrote was that investments in "domestick" industries will bring the investors unforeseen benefits.

    Now the "domestick" investments are going to China, but Smith's "invisible hand" is still praised for them.

    The list of similar frauds enslaving and mass murdering people is endless, yet most of them may have originated with some innocent and even good ideas used by crooks as weapons.

    Ed Deak.

  • Suspicious by nature

    48 weeks ago

    Agenda of Rapture

    "Stephen Caligula Harper will fall, our Emperor wears no clothes, there will be no reasoning, Harper and Harperism will not pause, no second thoughts, a straight path towards some distorted oil-soaked rapture, like a pit bull shaking and crushing the neck of a poodle, where even the owner of the pit bull can`t stop its own dog, where calls and demands to cease fall on deaf ears, only a bullet will stop the pit bull, Harper too will not stop, you can`t reason with one led by a god, even if that god is Satan. The only question is how much permanent damage will be done before sanity is returned to Ottawa"

    http://powellriverpersuader.blogspot.ca/2012/06/silence-of-lambs.html

  • headstrong

    48 weeks ago

    Bible Belt Stevie

    Canada is currently in the grip of a secretive evangelical cult that denies all science and research.
    We are also in big trouble, as we continue to fall behind the rest of the world in R&D, which creates a gap that can never be regained.

  • Fiat lux

    48 weeks ago

    Harper "knows" that the world

    Harper "knows" that the world was created in 7 days , 7,000 years ago and all the apparently old fossils and rocks were only put there to test our faith.

    As Reagan's first Secretary of the Interior, James Watt said it: " When the last tree is cut the Lord will return"

    ....and then we can see the true faithful, like Harper, shed their clothes and fly to heaven with Rapture.

    What a beautiful sight that will be.....

    Ed Deak.

  • Hakuin

    48 weeks ago

  • Hakuin

    48 weeks ago

  • Marysue52

    48 weeks ago

    a beautiful sight?

    The spectacle of a naked Harper and the rest of those partyanimals and their American corporate backers...ulp...

  • Hakuin

    48 weeks ago

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.