News

Mansion Market Slide Hits Kinsella, Powerbroker to Campbell, Clark

Want the house that lobbying built? Price is down a million dollars since July 2011.

By Bob Mackin, 15 Oct 2012, TheTyee.ca

Patrick Kinsella

Patrick Kinsella, rarely photographed, snapped recently at Hastings Racecourse by Tyee contributing editor and photojournalist Christopher Grabowski.

Related

British Columbia's man of political intrigue is reaping the rewards at the racetrack, but not so much in the luxury housing market.

Patrick Kinsella was the leading co-owner at Hastings Racecourse for the 2012 meet that ended Sunday. The political strategist and lobbyist behind Gordon Campbell and Christy Clark's rise to the premiership has slashed the price of his Shaughnessy mansion by $1.082 million.

The 100-year-old, four-storey, 6,441 square-foot house at 3839 Selkirk was listed in July 2011 by Rennie and Associates Realty for $7.28 million. There were no takers. Kinsella and his wife Brenda switched agents to Macdonald Realty BGW, which is now asking $6.198 million. The price has fallen 14.8 per cent since July 2011.

Kinsella is not alone. Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver figures show there were 32.5 per cent fewer sales in September 2012 than a year earlier. The Vancouver West benchmark price fell 6.5 per cent to $2.09 million. It was the worst September in a decade.

University of B.C. associate professor Tsur Somerville said west side, West Vancouver and Richmond properties are under pressure. Immigrants and investors who were snapping up properties in 2010 and 2011 have "moved from getting a unit at any price to -- if they are buying -- buying for the best price they can," he said.

"In any downturn, luxury homes tend to be more cyclical than starter homes. In the slowing market the luxury homes tend to get hit harder," Somerville said.

The Kinsella house was assessed at $4,129,667 and its property tax bill was $17,808.33, according to the City of Vancouver.

'To see is to fall in love'

"Deluxe master bedroom with beautiful living room and fireplace offering ultimate privacy and comfort," gushed the Rennie description. "Most bedrooms ensuited, including the nanny suite below. Extravagant chef's kitchen with solid wood cabinetry and timeless stone countertops. Set the ambience with built-in speaker system in and out. Securely gated professionally manicured grounds where you can enjoy lounging on your deck or take a dip in your private pool and hot tub. To see is to fall in love."

"A truly exceptional Shaughnessy 1 classic craftsman has been completely renovated by John Hollifield," explains the new Macdonald Realty description. A slide show tour of the house is here.

"The fine workmanship and exceptional attention to detail is evident throughout this stunning four level home. There are six bedrooms, seven bathrooms; four with ensuite bathrooms including the deluxe master bedroom with fireplace and walk in closet, a fabulous chef's kitchen, spacious principle rooms, a fully finished lower level with nanny's suite and media room and beautifully landscaped gardens. Private patios, pool and hot tub complete this extraordinary package."

A collection of interior photographs on Realtor.ca shows the Kinsellas enjoy ornate chandeliers and Persian rugs. There are even rugs in the kitchen.

Monique Badun, the lead agent on the listing for Macdonald, would not comment on the listing, beyond what is published by the Multiple Listing Service. She said she doubted Kinsella would welcome a tour by a reporter.

Phone and email messages to Kinsella at his company, Progressive Strategies, were not returned.

Winning at the track and elsewhere

Kinsella and horse racing partner Glen Todd operate the North American Thoroughbred Horse Co. stable that dominated Hastings Racecourse's 2012 season with 31 wins in 82 starts and more than $500,000 of purse winnings.

Their four-year-old, Commander, won the $100,000 B.C. Premier's Stakes on Thanksgiving Day, with Kentucky Derby-winner Mario Gutierrez aboard. Premier Christy Clark was a no-show. Same for Deputy Premier Rich Coleman, a friend of Kinsella's and the minister responsible for gambling. Commander is expected to challenge for the Breeders' Cup Marathon on Nov. 3 at California's Santa Anita track.

Kinsella, an invitee to Clark's March 14, 2011 swearing-in, joined Clark on Sept. 30, 2011 in B.C. Place Stadium's biggest luxury suite to watch the B.C. Lions beat the Edmonton Eskimos on the renovated stadium's reopening night.

The ex-insurance agent from Ontario turned 71 on May 26. He co-chaired Clark's B.C. Liberal leadership campaign and was behind Campbell's majority wins in 2001 and 2005. Elections BC records show Kinsella donated $113,654 to the BC Liberals since 2005.

Kinsella's Progressive Strategies lobbying clients include Corinex Communications, Great Canadian Gaming, MWH Business Solutions, Mark Anthony Group, Pacific Western Brewing Co., Sylvan Resources and the New Car Dealers of B.C. In May, Kinsella was appointed a director of Bralorne Gold.

Political connections, high profile clients

Kinsella terminated his lobbying registration for Exel Logistics on March 30, a month before the Liquor Distribution Branch privatization tendering opened. Four companies, including Exel, were shortlisted in July, but tendering was shut down more than two weeks prematurely when the B.C. Government and Service Employees' Union inked a tentative agreement on Sept. 27 that included a no-privatization clause.

Kinsella was paid $297,000 to advise BC Rail between 2002 and 2005. The railway's operations were sold to CN, headed by prominent BC Liberal donor David McLean, in late 2003. The controversial privatization spawned a police raid on the Legislature in December 2003. Ministerial aides Dave Basi and Bob Virk made a surprise guilty plea on Oct. 18, 2010 to bribery charges after maintaining their innocence. Their $6 million legal bill was paid by taxpayers and B.C. Auditor General John Doyle is battling in court to find out why.

Kinsella's client list, obtained from the State of Washington by Sean Holman in 2008, included Accenture Business Services and boasted of helping the company achieve a 10-year, $1.45 billion agreement to handle BC Hydro's back office services. Progressive Group was contracted by Washington to lobby the B.C. government and VANOC for Olympic business opportunities. Progressive's company description said it was "located in the heart of downtown Vancouver, while at the same time has a presence in the provincial capital of Victoria and a foot into the Vancouver 2010 Organizing Committee."  [Tyee]

17  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Frank

    31 weeks ago

    The Wire

    A great program which shows that often there is a fine line between "upstanding businessman" and crook.

    Just sayin.

    People that get very well paid by the powerful people they know simply for knowing powerful people.

    How convenient.

  • alive

    31 weeks ago

    Frank

    Yes, the fancy term is: "networking"!
    Which by the way also means, never pay retail-prices again!

  • Van Isle

    31 weeks ago

    I guess the scam artists who

    I guess the scam artists who have come from other countries to launder their dirty money by buying up BC property is drying up. Too bad Patrick's timing is off to sell his 'cosy cottage'.

  • Jeffrey J.

    31 weeks ago

    Corporatocracy and the Ruling Elite

    No-one epitomizes BC's descent into corrupt class rule like Gordon Campbell and his crony Mr. Kinsella.

    This Tyee coverage is truly gutsy. Even the NDP won't discuss this kind of revelation (sadly). But it is of significant public interest, given the loot these guys have obtained from their role in government.

    But it is only if citizens can see the true face (and opulent life) of wealthy, non-democratic rulers that we see the absurdity of their power.

    Kinsella, and Campbell,and all their taxpayer paid millionaire cronies (like Bob Elton (CEO of BC Hydro), David Hahn (CEO of BC Ferries) etc etc) don't do this for the public good.

    What a far cry from Plato's deeply thoughtful research in The Republic (where we watch as Timocracy devolves to Oligarchy, thence to Democracy and thence to Tyranny).

    Our current Masters of the Universe, flush with self-paid public funds, corporate profits and their meteoric rise in wealth, is in stark contrast to BC's citizens (the 99%).

    http://www.vopenhouse.ca/vid/11399_5aff61/

    http://thetyee.ca/News/2008/06/16/PatKinsella/

    Excellent coverage as always!

  • Grouse

    31 weeks ago

    Mr Kinsella should try getting a real job

    I hear walmart is hiring

  • miguel

    31 weeks ago

    Whoa!

    They have an awful taste in furniture and decor.

  • morechatter

    31 weeks ago

    It it speculators who drove

    It it speculators who drove the market housing market in the US and it speculators who have brought down the housing market it Canada. It all started with lobbyist thought who insisted regulations just get in the way of new job creation. Unemployment in the US remains high while the US household is over its head in debt. Canada has lobbyist who have convinced the government deregulation was the only way. Falcon was the little engine that never could perhaps because he wasn't that good.

  • morechatter

    31 weeks ago

    and with a flick of a finger

    It is speculators who drove up the housing market in the US.
    It is speculators who will have brought down the housing market in Canada.
    It all started with lobbyists who insisted regulations only get in the way of job creation. The US government changed its regulations on bubble financial instruments and it was if the average US household woke up broke the very next day. And they couldn't wait to give Canada a try next.
    Unemployment in the US remains high as well as the average household debt. Canadian households are burdened with debt and .
    unemployment is high especially for youths.

  • Don McBain

    31 weeks ago

    French revoulution

    It is people like this, that do not actually do anything for sociciety, that are ruining our country. Just like the French revolution it is time to get rid of them.

    I won't say "Off with their heads", but you know what I mean.

  • crh

    31 weeks ago

    old age

    You can wear any nice shirt you want Kinsella, but you're old dude. Time to pack it in.

  • Kreditanstalt

    31 weeks ago

    Nice house. Built 1912, the

    Nice house. Built 1912, the same year as mine, and in the same Craftsman style.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Craftsman

    One could get better decorating ideas if they had more photos...guess the agents expect anyone with that much money to want a tour...

  • Skywalker

    31 weeks ago

    Well Kreditan..

    ..now we know a little about your perspective on those who can't afford such a house.

  • Kreditanstalt

    31 weeks ago

    Not passsing judgement here...

    My house is worth a tiny FRACTION of that!

    I just like to save pictures of Craftsman-style houses so that I can see what the decor would have looked like in 1912. I'd agree with miguel though...the furnishngs in every room in Kinsella's house seems to clash.

    No sense of the period.

  • For a better world

    30 weeks ago

    Taxes and Assessments

    If the true assessed value of Kinsella's residence was $6.198 million, Kinsella should have paid much higher property taxes. Using the tax to assessment ratio for his actual 2012 property taxes, the appropriate levy should have been 50% higher (i.e. $26,727.59).

    For median or average home owners, their property assessments are much closer to market values.This is another example where the wealthy benefit to the disadvantage of the ordinary homeowners.

  • NoMoreLiars

    30 weeks ago

    Networking = influence peddling

    Once again, here is proof that so called "free enterprise" benefits the few in the club. If free enterprise were truly free, Kinsella and other "liberal" cronies would not be massively wealthy.

  • Advocate47

    20 weeks ago

    Tyee's Misplaced Attention

    It is interesting that the Tyee gives us a story about some worn out political hack's mansion while ignoring the many issues faced by strata or condo owners in BC. It seems that Tyee editors think one hack's house is more important than the homes of 700,000 strata owners. It appears that the Tyee's interest in being "progressive" does not extend to strata owner issues.

  • PeterMathews

    5 weeks ago

    Wow that's amazing man, hope

    Wow that's amazing man, hope we get to see some good collection of furniture's and all. custom rugs