Mediacheck

Canada's Digital Strategy Feels Like a Seinfeld Episode

Time to put some substance into the Harper government's 'Penske File.'

By Michael Geist, 4 Sep 2012, TheTyee.ca

George Costanza from 'Seinfeld'

Minister Paradis take note: George Costanza's famed project of endless busy work with no outcome was called the Penske File.

Related

Industry Minister Christian Paradis paid a visit to the Economic Club of Canada in Toronto last week to deliver a speech focused on the digital economy. As has been the case for months, the speech was short on specifics but filled with platitudes about a forthcoming digital economy strategy that "challenges our innovators" and "drives new technology."

Yet despite promises of a strategy by the end of the year, the issue remains the government's "Penske File," a source of regular speeches and much "work" but few tangible results (for non-Seinfeld watchers, the Penske file is a reference to a non-existent work project). In fact, with Paradis telling attendees that the government's role "is to give our best and brightest the opportunities they need to succeed and then get out of the way" the strategy may be about as ambitious as the character George Costanza was on the Seinfeld show.

Canadians have waited years for a digital economy strategy. Paradis should dispense with the well-worn clichés and opt for an ambitious plan that generates genuine excitement and broad public support.

Where to start

If Canada is to re-emerge as a digital economy leader, the starting point should be universal computer ownership combined with affordable broadband Internet access. The government has supported extending broadband access to rural communities in recent years, but there still remain thousands of Canadians who do not have access to affordable high-speed Internet services. Reliance on the private sector has failed to provide universal affordable access and the government should acknowledge the need for the public funds to address the issue.

Mere affordable access is not enough, however. As millions of Canadian students head back to school this week, it is worth remembering that many do not have computers in their homes. The solution lies in a digital economy strategy that brings together the technology and telecommunications sector to develop a plan that ensures universal access to computers and broadband Internet by 2015.

Ensuring Canadians have the necessary access is only the first step in the strategy. They must also have the skills and digital literacy to use the technology effectively. This will require a concerted effort at working with provincial and local groups to provide the necessary knowledge and tools. These programs should be integrated into schools and available more broadly within local communities.

Fight spam, boost e-commerce

Once Canadians are online, the government can't get out of the way until it establishes the legal framework that fosters public confidence in e-commerce and the online environment. Paradis should bring the languishing anti-spam legislation into effect by finalizing regulations that have been missing-in-action for the past year and introduce tough privacy reforms that mandate disclosure of security breaches backed by penalties for non-compliance.

Government also can't get out of the way until it has established a framework that fosters a fiercely competitive Canadian digital economy. Paradis told the Economic Club that "we need to take more risks, think more creatively and act more boldly to claim our place in the global economy."

Exhorting business to take risks isn't going to make Canada a digital economy leader, however. Creating a competitive market will, which necessitates removing foreign investment restrictions in the telecom and broadcast sectors, rejecting persistent calls to "regulate the Internet," enforcing net neutrality regulations, and using the forthcoming spectrum auction to encourage new entrants and greater competition.

There will be additional elements to the strategy -- government transitioning to electronic delivery of services, creating a digital economy leader around the cabinet table, and finding ways to pay for funded programs stand out -- but after years of delays, Canada needs fewer speeches on the digital economy and more substance.  [Tyee]

8  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • seth

    41 weeks ago

    Smart meter upgrade

    The fastest cheapest internet in the world is easily available in BC/Canada with a modification to the smart meter program. Only Fascist government corruption and philosophy stands in its way.

    BCHydro distribution system is comprised of over 2 million customers, on 57,000 kilometres of distribution lines, spread out over 900K power poles or about 60 meters a pole.

    The cost of covering that 57K km with the fibre optic cable necessary for smart meters is about $1200 a Km.or $70M. For
    an additional $20M ( a few more strands) that fibre cable could be expanded to bring 1000 Mb/s access at sufficent capacity to handle all the communication traffic telephone, cellular, television, and internet BC Hydro's 2 Million customers generate.

    Adding a maximum of one 300Mbs capacity outdoor boxed Dual band N router running the open-mesh system at $200 each every 2 poles would add $90M or so. Customers could access the wireless with their own equipment, buy new Open-Mesh units for $50, or demand wired access at 1000 Mb/s for $100.

    Mass produced white space WIF routers at 20 Mbs along the route could provide slower but still very fast by todays standard wireless service traveling for tens of miles and penetrating buildings for a miminal additional cost.

    So around $50 one time charge, every BCHydro customer in the entire province could have a best in the world 1000 Mbs communication channel internet with wired customer internet connections shared with wired smart meters, and out in the street wireless replacing cell phones.

    Ironically a Canadian regional cable operator Shaw has decided to use wifi for its mobile phone offering forgoing the massive investment it made a few years buying wireless spectrum.

    Having already covered the entire region with fiber, it will cost them well under a buck a subscriber one time cost to add wifi repeaters as needed. You are starting to see the service on WIFI as Shaw Open - free to date.

    Obviously, the BCHydro plan would pretty much put Telus out of business, interfering with campaign donations and post political board of director appointments for our corrupt politicians, so just like the Vancouver's city wifi dumped by the same corrupt politicians, it ain't a gonna happen.

  • Hakuin

    41 weeks ago

    Seth

    I agree with you.

  • frank2

    40 weeks ago

    IF Seth's article is

    IF Seth's article is quarter-way correct, someone needs to look at it in detail -- how about Hydro? A new revenue earning opportunity?

  • davidex

    40 weeks ago

    Old news for BC Hydro

    BC Hydro has been planning this for decades. I was foretold of this back in 1981 by an educator at SFU Communications Studies. He said back then that BC Hydro, Telus and cable, all had monopoly access to our homes, so it would only be a matter of time before they would become the 3rd conduit for information/telco. When they started installing Smart Meters, I saw his prediction coming to pass but no one else seems to have noticed this obvious development. Too busy worrying about the miniscule radio waves radiating from the meters, while the real story is that they're building a data highway into your house.
    They're waaaay ahead of you!

  • Hakuin

    40 weeks ago

  • Hakuin

    40 weeks ago

  • jedagroke

    19 weeks ago

    I enjoy reading this kind of

    I enjoy reading this kind of stuff. Thanks for sharing good knowledge.
    http://greenavis.com/

  • Cosy

    9 weeks ago

    This is excellent post. Its

    This is excellent post. Its having good description regarding this topic.It is informative and helpful.I have known many information from this. Thanks for sharing.
    http://sleepcosy.com/