- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Times-Colonist, Sun Shrink Protests, Ignore Crisis
Farmed salmon fighting rally, historic in size, rendered puny by BC's big Canwest papers.
Sea lice protest, May 8, at BC Legislature in Victoria.
We all know what a word or punctuation mark can do to a sentence. For example, to write "John, says Mary, is a lousy bed companion" is very different than "John says Mary is a lousy bed companion."
(In fact, perhaps both are, but that's not the point).
Today I'm going to deal with a single word in a sentence; the word is "nearly."
Some background.
On Saturday, May 8, well known and much loved Alexandra Morton ended her walk from her home in Sointula to Victoria in opposition to farmed salmon in the ocean, with a rally at the steps of the Legislature.
The Victoria Times-Colonist and Vancouver Sun, both owned by Canwest, gave appalling coverage, starting with the absurd statement than "nearly" 1,000 people were there. Please look at the picture accompanying this story and see how preposterous that statement was. It mattered a great deal because that statement trivialized the event and I say that was deliberate by the use of "nearly."
The use of "nearly" can only mean that they actually counted but couldn't quite make 1,000. There is no other construction one can put on that sentence. For if they hadn't counted, how could they say that there were fewer than 1,000 people at the rally? This cannot be a guess or speculation because on its plain construction it's clearly a statement of fact.
The truth is that they didn't count at all, so their statement is a plain falsehood making one wonder if they were even there. It's fascinating that when later challenged on their estimate, the Times-Colonist said that they evidently had asked the police who said it was 1,000-2,000, which doesn't quite explain the "nearly 1,000." Their nose, in fact, got longer.
'Thank goodness for people filming'
Let's look at some other estimates from people used to assessing the size of crowds.
Holly Adams, who was shooting for Global News, said, "I spoke with police outside the Legislature and they estimated just over 4,000 people, and that was just before 5:00 p.m." That was the estimate used by Global on their newscast.
Wendy Bales, who is a director of the Fraser Valley Regional District, said, "I was there and figured at least over 4,000, with some people coming and going for parts, so there were many more. Global TV reported over 4,000. I was also surprised (but then not) at the lack of coverage. As with so many things, the important stories have to be told by the people, and you can't believe the story on the surface. So what else is new? Thank goodness for the 'net'! I can't wait for the real story to be told. Thank goodness for all the people filming."
Vicky Husband, who has an Order of Canada, is probably the best known environmentalist in the province. She has seen many rallies and said, "Our estimate is between 4,000 to 5,000" -- the largest crowd she had ever seen on the Legislature lawn.
Erling Olsen, owner/skipper of the Pacific Viking, the fish boat which escorted the canoe that started in Hope and crossed the Georgia Strait, talked to a Victoria Police Officer who told him he had never before seen a crowd of demonstrators at the Legislature as large.
A conservative estimate
Environmental activist Ivan Doumenc did a bit of measuring and I thought it was the last word.
"I took a very conservative guess: I assumed -- which is very unrealistic, based on what the photo shows -- that each person used two square meters on an exclusive basis. That's a rectangle of one meter by two meters with no one else but its sole occupier on it. Measure that at home, and you will realize that it's a very, very conservative assumption indeed. I also assumed that not a single person was standing to the left or the right of the frame of the photo, and I further assumed that the columns of people still moving toward the lawn in the photo's far background were actually not going to the rally. "In spite of that, I still found that approximately 3,000 people were occupying my polygon. Once you add more realistic estimations that other people must have been standing outside of the picture, that some people in the far background are actually going to the rally, et cetera, you easily find yourself in that 4,000 plus range which was given to Global News on that day at by several on-site police officers."
Willfully ignored?
One little word -- "nearly" -- graphically shows us Canwest’s bias against environmentalists and its obeisance to the Campbell government.
Now with one little word we can understand why Canwest has assiduously avoided covering Alexandra Morton's eight-year struggle to get the word out about sea lice from fish farms killing migrating wild salmon smolts with the exception of the occasional article, usually buried in the business section.
This explains why Canwest has neglected to interview experts like Dr. John Volpe, Dr. Neil Frazer, Dr. Martin Krkosek, Irish lice specialist Dr. Patrick Gargan and Dr. Daniel Pauly of the University of British Columbia, said by the prestigious Science Magazine to be one of the top 50 scientists in the world.
That's why Canwest has never appointed a member of their staff to thoroughly investigate the entire issue.
This explains why Canwest has not gone to Norway to ask Marine Harvest, the biggest fish farmer on our coast, all the questions that have been raised. (Several environmentalists including Alex and my partner, Damien Gillis have been several times).
This explains why the fish farmers' spokesperson gets an op-ed piece, it would seem, when she wants.
It also explains that because the Vancouver Sun's editorial page, run as it is by a Fraser Institute alumnus, has never to my knowledge published an editorial critical of fish farming; this, no doubt, explains why columnists Vaughn Palmer or Mike Smyth have avoided like a plague dealing with the horrendous impact of fish farms on migrating wild salmon.
What you didn't read
What was it that Canwest did not cover on May 8th?
There were First Nations' speakers including Grand Chief Stewart Philip, Grand Chief of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, probably the most powerful native leader in the province. His speech was sometimes humorous but always carried the firm conviction that his people not only opposed fish farms in the ocean but were prepared to take the matter as far into the court system as needed.
The reason this was so important, and should have been reported, is that the two senior governments have clearly vowed to do nothing, leaving the courts the only way to go. Given the record of First Nations in court since the Calder case in 1973, this speech of Grand Chief Phillips and his colleagues had huge meaning, and I would have thought that even Canwest would understand its importance.
One might have thought that Canwest would have at least taken a clip of Alexandra Morton's speech.
These three papers did a great disservice to readers by not reporting what happened -- indeed they practiced censorship by remaining silent (except when they pretended to count the crowd).
It's trite to say that you can deceive by what you say and by what you don't say. Canwest, its dailies as well as its community papers, and the Black community papers have, by saying so little, kept their readers in the dark on hugely important environmental issues including not only fish farms, but the Campbell government's unbelievable destruction of our rivers and giveaway of energy to other jurisdictions.
Embrace new media
The use of the word "nearly" tells us where Canwest apparently is -- a staunch supporter of Gordon Campbell's destruction of the environment so dear to real British Columbians.
Canwest is bankrupt and has now been purchased. Because of the new ownership's association with Canwest past, this change doesn't give us any optimism about their coverage to come of environmental concerns.
There is this hope, however. President Obama taught us how to use the Internet and that where we must go if we want to save our precious heritage.
Readers can start their trek to truthfulness by going to www.thecanadian.org. (Sorry for the shameless plug … no, to hell with, it I'm not a bit sorry!)
Where Parisians past cried "aux barricades" we sing out "to the Internet." ![]()




34
Login or register to post comments
Skywalker
2 years ago
Lately the only reason to look at Canwest...
...is to see just how they are trying to manipulate the news. Sometimes I get a good laugh glancing at the front page to see what they think is important news of the day.
I guess that is what the media has come to these days.
Well done Rafe, keep them coming and well done Tyee.
Sockeye
2 years ago
Boycott
I wonder if a consumer boycott would have any effect on this?
Ed Seedhouse
2 years ago
5,000 is indeed an
5,000 is indeed an impressive turnout, but by historical standards it is still only one tenth of the crowd I stood in at the Legislature on October 15 1983 during the "solidarity" crisis.
http://thetyee.ca/Books/2006/06/27/BennettReconsidered/
Illahie
2 years ago
Canwest Shrinks Facts, Rafe Shrinks Facts
There was certainly a large turnout, and Canwest's numbers appear to vastly underestimate the turnout.
The big problem however, is that the Fish Farm controversy is based on a big hoax. If Rafe had bothered to look, he would find that BC Salmon farms do not have a fish health problem.
All of the Fish Farms in the province would fit easily into Stanley Park. That does not sound like an environmental disaster to me.
I am somewhat suprised that a character as inteligent and well spoken (and a contrarian) as Rafe Mair would fall for such a simple hoax.
Van Isle
2 years ago
Another word that the press
Another word that the press likes to use is 'yet'. As to Illahie's comments; It's obvious that he/she isn't paying attention to what the salmon fish farm industry is doing.
working slog
2 years ago
The BS & Spin will just get worse @ the Sun/Province & Canwest
Well written Rafe.
Along the same vain, we will have to get used to even greater right-leaning bias in our local papers soon as they start being run by the National Post gang.
The National Post has, and will always be, nothing more than a cheap rag to carry neo-con rants in Canada and with the recent buy-out of CanWest by this gang of editorial thugs, we can expect that this conservative version of yellow journalism will be parroted in all of these acquired CanWest assets.
We can only hope that the National Post group and their reputation of right-sided bias and total lack of demographic awareness, will turn all of these papers into the same big money losers that the National Post has been. Then perhaps, with a little luck and persuasion, someone with some journalistic integrity can come in and pick up the pieces.
Until then, I will not trust or believe a word they print.
G West
2 years ago
Well put Rafe
I was there too and the count was easily 4,000 and likely more...as for Illahie, you can ignore Bernard Von Shulmann - he has an axe to grind. As revealed earlier right here at Tyee. Have a close look at the comments to THIS Hook article
http://thetyee.ca/Blogs/TheHook/Environment/2010/02/16/SeaLice/index.html?commentsfilter=1
And then have a closer look at who Illahie actually is:
http://ca.linkedin.com/pub/bernard-von-schulmann/8/222/B22
And check out All his connections.
Illahie
2 years ago
How about a real MEDIACHECK
I think that the media have been lead down the garden path without doing their due diligence on this issue. A real MEDIACHECK would reveal that the journalistic community has been snookered.
Fortunately this hoax can be revealed by a little bit of research.
How about it Rafe?
You could easily check the fish health reports that are posted by the province (hint, the Broughton's are in area 3.3).
You could demand that the fish farms health records be revealed.
You could talk to a real fisheries biologist.
You could check the temperature salinity and current profiles for the Broughtons.
I bet that a distinguished journalist like yourself could debunk this hoax in less than a single day of research.
sylvangrove
2 years ago
a secret
I'm going to let you in on a secret.
If you want to know how many people are at a rally, don't ask the police. How would they know? Don't ask the organizers or sympathizers. They will always pump up the numbers.
Here's the secret, revealed to me years ago by a "reporter" (if you're an old gal or guy, you might remember these folks, they used to report the news):
You get up to high point and count them. At the legislature, there is a convenient climbing device called "stairs."
I climbed to the very top of these stairs at the salmon rally and counted 2,500 people, give or take a few undercover cops, lost tourists or news media types wandering around asking other people how many were at the rally.
Moat
2 years ago
Illahie... really?
Wow, you always spit out such wierd ramblings when it comes to the subject of fish farms.
You wrote -
"All of the Fish Farms in the province would fit easily into Stanley Park. That does not sound like an environmental disaster to me."
The hole in the ground from the Deeperwater Horizon in the Gulf is smaller than any fish farm. But the damage that it is causing is massive. Do it make a difference on how big the source of the damage is?
You see, Illahie, it does not take that much of a contaminant to pollute an awful lot of water.
But the disappearing salmon is all a hoax for you... an elaborate game of hide and seek put forward by a gang of busybodies.
As a shareholder and former subscriber of Canwest papers.... I know that their reporting on environmental issues has been shallow at best.
Norman Farrell
2 years ago
Where we go from here
Corus Radio's local flagship CKNW, on the 8am news a day following Morton's Victoria rally, reported that hundreds gathered on the lawns of the legislature for a protest. This is purposeful understatement comparable to GlobalTV's Chris Gailus reporting May 21 on "hundreds of thousands of gallons of oil that have poured into the Gulf of Mexico." He also said that oil was "soiling at least ten locations now."
However, if you think Canwest and Global are bad now, wait till the cost cutters do their work. That will be soon. Our dailies are soon to be controlled by New York bankers and the creditors owe a debt of gratitude to Harper Conservatives for allowing this Americanization of control to proceed.
Northern Insights' End of news as we know it talks about the challenge citizens must face. We must find ways to encouraging greater public interest journalism. There are models to explore in other nations and Canada needs change even more.
The question reader is what are you doing to contribute to balanced and ethical reporting.
Norman Farrell
2 years ago
Norman Farrell
It probably does not need repeating but Global's statement of hundreds of thousands of gallons spilled was ridiculous because even BP's faulty reckoning reports at least 6.5 million gallons while independent estimates range up to 100 million gallons while growing daily.
Skywalker
2 years ago
@Illahie
If we were expecting Canwest to do some research on whether fish farms were damaging the environment that would be one thing. We might expect some reluctance to spend the money to come up with the research. But good heavens, when all they have to do is look at a picture and they can see there are more than 1000 not nearly 1000 it is not like they have to do research. Just report the facts. Is that so difficult for a newspaper? Of course not so your trying to make this about the debate on fish farms avoids the real truth here. Canwest lied. Why? and for what reason?
The answer should disturb even you. You may be on the Canwest side on this, but what else are they not telling you the truth about? On Rafe's point of reporting accurately you have no ammunition. Nothing.
carfreecity
2 years ago
biggest
this was the biggest "environmental" rally I can recall and I've been to them all over the last 25 years.
carfreecity
2 years ago
best
not only was it the biggest
it was the BEST!!!
AnthonyB
2 years ago
Canwest papers distortions
The Canwest papers are notorious for bending the news to fit their views. For example, they never publish a story that is critical of Israel. Anyone who depended upon Canwest newspaper coverage of world affairs would likely believe that the Israelis are dominated and persecuted by Palestinians. Almost every day the Canwest papers violate the newspaper code of ethics.
RickW
2 years ago
AnthonyB
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/americas/
Norman Farrell
2 years ago
Thomas Jefferson
"The most effectual engines for [pacifying a nation] are the public papers... [A despotic] government always [keeps] a kind of standing army of newswriters who, without any regard to truth or to what should be like truth, [invent] and put into the papers whatever might serve the ministers. This suffices with the mass of the people who have no means of distinguishing the false from the true paragraphs of a newspaper." --Oct. 13, 1785
SharingIsGood
2 years ago
Disgusting, isn't it?
Even after the Asper family has left, the lying and half-truths and the non-reporting continues. We live the millenium edition of 20th century Chicago.
freebear
2 years ago
Do Canada's papers have a future
You mean Corporate Canada's papers!
Perhaps a future as propaganda tools!
Spikey
2 years ago
My pics of the rally show more like 4,000 too
http://www.flickr.com/photos/sprackett/sets/72157623902729607/
I could only conclude that the Times Colonist wasn't there when they said near 1,000.
x4estworker
2 years ago
More Bleating from the Greens
If there is one thing that environmentalists are good at, it is painting themselves as victims and underdogs. In this story, it is "oh poor us, look how those nasty big media outlets are treating us". Even if there were 4000 people at the Legislature, that is only 1/10 of 1% of the population of B.C. Given how the greenies will show up at anything to support the cause, that's really a pathetic turnout.
If there is one thing that Alexander Morton is good at, it is misrepresenting her campaign against fish farms. While she would like us to think that her views are somehow based in science, she is nothing less or more than an environmental activist.
I have posted on a number of forums asking that the Alexander Morton Fan Club provide one scientific study that doesn't have her name on it that supports her conclusion that fish farms are to blame for the decimation of wild salmon stocks through infestations of sea lice. To date, I haven't had any response.
Do you suppose such evidence just doesn't exist, at least without her name on it?
Moat
2 years ago
x4estworker... do some homework.
I suppose it is fitting that you go trolling around this debate.
Instead of surfing around looking for negative reactions... you could go to Google Scholar and look for yourself. Lots of articles.
If you don't trust Google, you can get yourself up to one of the Universities and read Pest Managment Science for yourself.
Better yet, if you can level such critism at Morton, why don't you start working on your own study and get it published in Reviews in Fisheries Science.
Maybe then you can stop posting to "a number of forums" looking for evidence.
You can do it!
RickW
2 years ago
x4estworker
You are an ex-forest worker because you support the kind of policies that put you out of work in the first place.
http://www.ubcic.bc.ca/News_Releases/UBCICNews02151002.htm
Illahie
2 years ago
Sounds to me that x4estworker has done his homework
Acorns do not fall very far from the tree. Morton is the only nut on the ground. No researchers or fisheries biologists support her claims. In fact, when DFO conducted extensive research they found that her claims were totally bogus.
ttp://www.pacificsalmonforum.ca/pdfs-all-docs/2007InterimFindingsFeb8-08.pdf
http://www.pacificsalmonforum.ca/pdfs-all-docs/2008ResearchProgram.pdf
Her sealice infection wild stocks has been completely debunked. As Morton herself wrote "our science has been completely debunked".
When she recently made her bizarre claim that sealice here in BC are becoming resistant to treatment, it was easy to test and her claims were quickly revealed as a total falsehood.
Many of the environmental crowd do not seem to care whether their positions are truthful, or whether they are living a lie. Perhaps there view is that even if they are spewing a packet of lies, there is a greater good in their protests. If so these people are not pro environment, they are anti enconomic protestors.
Frank
2 years ago
Morton
Somehow she's converted people across the globe then in spite of language barriers because resistance to fish farms is not just in BC.
One can easily google people in Norway, the British Isles etc who say the same things.
Frank
2 years ago
No worries
The United Nations says all fisheries around the world will be exhausted within 40 years anyway so we won't have to worry about wild anything as there won't be wild anything.
Good times.
Illahie
2 years ago
So Frank...
How does having tens of thousands of people suckered in by a hoax help the worlds wild fish stocks exactly?
G West
2 years ago
There are hoaxes and there are hoaxes
Personally Illahie (I mean [COMMENT REMOVED. NOTE TO COMMENTERS: ASSUMING YOU KNOW THE IDENTITY OF A FELLOW COMMENTER AND DECLARING THE IDENTITY OF THAT COMMENTER IS NOT ALLOWED IN THIS FORUM. -MODERATOR.]) I think you may be perpetrating a bigger deception yourself.
G West
2 years ago
And then there's this
http://thetyee.ca/Blogs/TheHook/Environment/2010/05/26/FishFarms/
Frank
2 years ago
Illahie
You claim fisheries scientists that agree with you know what they're doing. However, the UN says they don't as their policies will see the world's fisheries exhausted within 40 years.
Ergo, if you want to accuse anyone of a hoax you should look at those that tell you everything is fine.
Blue Cabazon
2 years ago
Not the numbers but where they are
Illahie, the number of Fish Farms might all fit into Stanley Park, but can you imagine what would happen if a wild salmon fry tried to swim through the park with all those farms there?
That's what IS happening. Most of the farms on this coast are clustered is areas that are very small in geographic size. Johnstone Straights is less that a mile across in some areas but 50% of all wild salmon swim through here either on the out migration to the sea or the return spawning migration. These fish swim 264 miles down the length of Vancouver Island and in the process swim through or past virtually every farm. That doesn't include the fish that swim down the outside of the island, yet here too, there are many farms that sit in their path.
An object doesn't have to be large to cause deadly problems, just look at viruses and bacteria. They don't take up much space either but boy, do they pack a wallop!
KWD
2 years ago
media gate keeping
Only the willfully blind would claim open net cage fish farms don’t pose a problem for wild stocks and the environment.
But the fish farm issue is secondary to the real message in this story: The impact of MSM gate keeping.
The sad fact is, despite the growing popularity of social networking, most folks, outside of the few using alternative news sources like the Tyee, aren’t interested in digging for the truth … it’s too painful.
What’s equally sad is the fact being successful in politics requires an uninformed public. And, as most are well aware, given the controversy generated by Sheila Fraser over MP spending, childcare issues highlighted by Mary Ellen Turpel-Lafond and Harper gagging political aides; politicians are doing their utmost to keep the majority uninformed.
We can probably expect BAU until the majority can no longer ignore the truth and the pain forces us to join the Bangkok “Red Shirts” and the Greeks.
Bernard
2 years ago
Since I have not missed the comment period
For those of you who think I am someone else, I am the Tyee as myself. I have no idea who Illahie is, but it is not me.