Mediacheck

Canadians Want Media Choice

At this critical moment, we must tell our politicians.

By Steve Anderson, 16 Jul 2007, TheTyee.ca

Media

Big media muscles out diversity.

Several major media mergers are threatening to make the Canadian media scene an even more concentrated affair. A few examples: CTVglobemedia has inhaled CHUM (with Rogers taking the spoils), Alliance Atlantis is on the brink of becoming a part of CanWest, and Quebecor Media is poised to take over Osprey Media.

A year ago (June 2006), the Standing Senate Committee on Transport and Communications Report on the Canadian News Media concluded that there are "areas where the concentration of ownership has reached levels that few other countries would consider acceptable." Canadians agree: well before the latest round of mergers, 56 per cent of Canadians said they had less trust in the media because of media consolidation, and fewer than one in five Canadians thought news organizations were independent.

Canadians understand very clearly the effects of media consolidation on media choice. For example, CanWest will now own the IFC (Independent Film Channel). Since CanWest is known for its conservative editorial stances, this change indicates that the Independent Film Channel is now anything but Independent.

Or again: as a result of CTVglobemedia's purchase of CHUM, the same company now owns MTV Canada and MuchMusic. One of these channels will likely face considerable divestment. It just wouldn't make good business sense to keep aggressively investing in both. Both of these two channels have become crucial spaces for the development of youth culture, and important sites of exposition for Canadian artists, as well as favourites among media consumers.

Fear in the newsrooms

The Canadian Energy, Communications and Paperworkers (CEP) union recently published a landmark study focusing on Canadian journalists, titled Voices From the Newsroom. The study suggests that journalists and news consumers are already feeling the brunt of big media domination.

Only 9.5 per cent of journalists indicated that they believe the corporate owners of their news outlet valued good journalism over profit. This perspective perhaps reflects the bookkeepers' view of employees as liabilities -- a management approach that is only exacerbated when big media get bigger.

CHUM laid off 281 people and cancelled news broadcasts across the country just hours before CTVglobemedia announced its intention to take over CHUM.

Quebecor -- another big media enterprise looking to get bigger -- has locked out the office and editorial staff of the Journal de Québec since April 22, 2007. Journalists tried to restart the negotiation process in mid-June, only to have Quebecor negotiators reject their efforts, sticking to their original demands from December 2006.

With this kind of treatment, it is not surprising that 44 per cent of journalists in the CEP study report a decreasing desire to stay in journalism.

With the recent and likely continuing big media centralization of media, we can only expect news and journalism to suffer more as economic imperatives drive operations. We can look forward to more unemployed or dissatisfied journalists, and more media consumers left wanting the penetrating journalism that used to be more prevalent in Canada.

Internet to the rescue?

Some people point to the Internet as the medium that will save us all from concentrated print and broadcast uniformity. Unfortunately, a high level of media consolidation also means that we are in danger of losing the open Internet in Canada and the ability to chose which websites we go to. For the most part, the media conglomerates that dominate conventional media also dominate web traffic. Independent media are pressed to compete with the vast holdings and promotional clout wielded by national big media conglomerates.

As big media increasingly merge with Internet service providers like Rogers, BCE and Telus, we risk unwittingly trading our open Internet for a closed system. In such a system, Internet (and cell phone) service providers can push traffic to their own content and that of their partners, while traffic to other more diverse media sites is slowed or blocked.

During the Telus strike in 2005, the corporation blocked access to a website run by striking Telus employees called "Voices for Change." There are many more examples of non-neutral Internet service-provider behaviour. A lone blogger or independent news website is hard-pressed to compete with the vast holdings and promotional clout wielded by national media conglomerates.

The Canadian Radio and Television Commission (CRTC) recently called for public input for their Diversity of Voices proceeding in order to review issues relating to the ownership of Canadian broadcasting companies. The main focus is on the impact that ownership trends have on the diversity of voices provided by Canadian broadcasters.

Until July 18, Canadians have an opportunity to submit comments about media ownership regulations, and the effect of concentrated ownership on free and vigorous debate about important public issues. The Diversity of Voices proceeding could result in drastic changes to the rules that govern Canadian media and communications.

How to take action

Canadians have historically supported media diversity. Many government reports have called for strict limits on media concentration. In 2002, an Ipsos-Reid poll reported that 86 per cent of Canadians believed the federal government should do something to alleviate Canadians' concerns about media concentration.

However, there is a new factor now. Canadians from across the country are speaking out loudly and clearly, asking for media choice over big media domination. They are urging the CRTC to maintain media diversity and public access to our national and regional communication platforms. The question is, will the CRTC take the lead from the Canadian public? With a clear indication that Canadians want a more diverse media system with more media choice, will the CRTC live up to its mandate to regulate media in the public interest?

The airwaves belong to the Canadian public, and rules to curb media concentration in Canada are long overdue. CRTC proceedings are usually dominated by big media, so comments from Canadians from across the country will go far to demonstrate the importance of media consolidation to all our lives.

Canadians can submit comments directly to the CRTC through a straightforward comment system on the Canadians for Democratic Media (CDM) website.

As former U.S. federal communications commissioner Nicholas Johnson said, "Whatever is your first priority, whether it's women's rights or civil rights or environmental concerns, your second priority simply has to be media reform. Because with that, the progressive community has a hope, and without it, you don't have a hope."

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

34  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • village

    4 years ago

    At the regional level..., such as a region as the one I live in

    Althought NEWSPAPERS are not mentioned in the article above.. I would like to point out that from the GROUND UP.., Newspapers are still the MEDIA that is impacting the most at the ground level of community itself.., and with that in mind ' I would like to make certain comments.., on how their particular mergers and behaviours impact on our sense of place.., sense of belonging and sense of identity..itself.
    ergo COMMUNITY..*

    There is already a concentration or rather I should say.., a dilution of so called COMMUNITY PAPERS in any given region..... for indeed they rather prefer the REGION WIDE approach to newspaper reporting.., offering up to it's readership.., what I refer to as a SMORGASBORD of COMMUNITIES which in effect dilutes any real meaning any individual CITY might have had as to being a COMMUNITY in it's own right.., ONLY TO BE REPLACED BY THIS IDEA THAT A REGION IS THE COMMUNITY*.. ( wink wink )..

    THEREBY JUSTIFYING OR RATHER as in ( RADLER ).., cutting the staff to it's bare bones necessity..., and when you can pass off a region as a COMMUNITY in the place of the individual communities that make up a region then..., WHY NOT .. RIGHT?

    WRONG.WRONG , WRONG , WRONG..!

    The reason being that the very idea of community is rendered meaningless.., when you can aggregate various CITIES and VILLAGES and pretend they are '' THE COMMUNITY '' by the stroke of a pen.. , well , you know something is wrong.., there..

    The bottom line driven ... community identity..( make that region as community folks..).., is what is wrong with our MEDIA these days..,

    At the Newspaper level.., this is clearly what is going on.., as to what was - once upon a time - SMALL TOWN NEWSPAPER..who actually championed the very idea of a town, village and City being A COMMUNITY- now gone astray.., by having substited that strategy with another.., and that is that the REGION now is THE COMMUNITY.., and it has to be so RIGHT ?..,because they say so , RIGHT ?..

    WRONG..,

    ESPECIALLY IN THE URBAN CITIES ... that find and lose themselves in this emerging regional model of identity.. ( totally fabricated by newspapers to serve their bottom line..,

    ( continued ).

  • village

    4 years ago

    HENCE , my concern.. ( when I think that at much larger scale an

    HENCE , my concern.. ( when I think that at much larger scale and scope.., radio and television do the same.. but at a much larger regional template..)*.., hence within provinces themselves.., and the country as a whole.., what is being lost in all of this is the very building blocks of our identity..,

    AND that is , how we think of COMMUNITY*..
    and neighbourhoods..- which I contend are the very building blocks of a CITY *..,of HUMAN SETTLEMENTS in their very own rights.., be they VILLAGES.., TOWNS , MUNICIPALITIES , OR CITIES.., they all have a history , a heritage passed down and a ', sense of place '' , '' sense of belonging'' and '' sense of identity '' along with an evolving sense of the FUTURE itself.., ( if it ever can have it's hopes , fears and dreams mirrored back to itself again .. ).., as was the role of MEDIA..,from time eternal..

    Thus the very idea of a Settlement and it's history and heritage quickly being lost.., through the MEDIA manipulation ,
    context , content and form itself.., which is attempting to circumvent the reality on the GROUND*..,

    The reality of NEIGHBOURHOODS.., THE REALITY of CITIES themselves.., as HUMAN SETTLEMENTS.. with not only a history and heritage but with an IDENTITY , with a HEART*.., that is quickly being fragmented/broken up.., into pieces..,

    (And then to go on lamenting the break up of Society ..- when they - THE MEDIA themselves are the worst perpetrators.. of the BREAK UP *.. )

    Be they cognisant of this is neither here or there.., but for the fact that they have now been laid bare .., in front of your eyes..,

    THE EMPEROR '' HAS NO CLOTHE'' when it comes to their claims of representing the COMMUNITY*..

    Which Community? Mine ? Yours? ..,

    Theirs obviously . (and fabricated at that )..,

    How are other regions in BC served by the print media ? It would be nice to hear from the emerging CITIZENS JOURNALIST that are living in various regions of this province.., or for that matter .., in other regions and provinces of CANADA..,

    Et vous au QUÉBEC.., quelle sont vos expériences.. par apart au journaux.. qui vous miroire une IDENTITÉ..*

    For those who do not comprehend the above paragraph I'm inviting our neighbours from yonder over the mountain also.., from all Provinces of our country..*.. ( and of course I would like to hear - and know - if any readers are from LA BELLE PROVINCE..)by asking what kind of newspaper coverage they are getting at the regional level.., and how well do they ( MEDIA ) mirror their COMMUNITY/IDENTITY*

    Take Care,
    Village .

  • gaulois

    4 years ago

    La belle province du BC and média concentration

    Good reminder from Village on the importance of the community print press even in our Net age.

    Don't forget too that the media concentration in the francophone press outside Quebec is huge, i.e. mainly State funded (directly or indirectly). I will let you guess the problem of identité that this leaves us with us dead ducks and reincarnated ones living hors-Québec...

    The "social engineering testbed" that we provide to the majority in the ROC and in Quebec should be IMO more of interest for those of you interested in what happens when freedom of press gradually gets eroded in the name of some dogma that everyone is expected to buy in, whatever that dogma is. Very similar situation with First Nations press BTW.

    Le Devoir remains a fairly good press in Quebec IMO although often "Quebec-centric" for a francophone living in the ROC. As far as they are concerned, we have pretty much disappeared and/or are of little interest to their readers. The GESCA/Quebecor media conglomerates impact on freedom of press and journalism is however very similar to the Canwest one, i.e. inquiétant.

  • Chris H

    4 years ago

    CRTC

    "The question is, will the CRTC take the lead from the Canadian public? With a clear indication that Canadians want a more diverse media system with more media choice, will the CRTC live up to its mandate to regulate media in the public interest?"

    My question is whether or not the CRTC has actually been helpful to the Canadian public, or have they been a protective layer for the media in Canada to protect their own turf? Is this in the interest of the Canadian public?

    New technologies come out that won't see the light of day for years because we have to "protect" the Canadian industry. It is the consumer who ultimately gets screwed. While AT&T gives their iphone customers UNLIMITED net access for $60 a month, Canadian customers are told by the telecommunication companies here that 5 MB per month is all they need! Imagine reading The Tyee on the bus on your way to work. How many years before Canadians can even buy an iphone?

    Media and telecommunications are changing rapidly. You'd think that Canadian companies would be encouraged to stay close to forefront of that change. Maybe we should refocus ourselves on making it easier for others to join the competititive media market instead of protecting those already in it. Perhaps we would see more diversity as a result. It wouldn't be any worse than it is now.

  • speedo

    4 years ago

    who cares

    I'm tired of complaints about the media. If you think newspapers are too conservative, don't read them. If TV news is too right wing, don't watch it. If you stumble onto an arch-fascist blog, stumble right off it. If someone you meet at a party is a Liberal or Socred bore, walk away.

    Why do people think their particular political hobbyhorses should be high on everyone else's agenda? Only a doofus would be surprised that a news organization, a corporation whose real reason for being is the creation of profit for owners, shareholders and employees, wouldn't betray those sorts of values in its editorials. The real problem with the newsmedia isn't its rightwing bias, it's with its down-and-dumb devotion to fluffy lifestyle clutter like How Paris Hilton is Holding Up in Jail. They can try all they want to Manufacture Consent but all you have to do to jack the system is ignore them and go throw a frisbee instead.

    Go to Google News and find the news you want if it matters that much to you. Or better yet, Be the Change You'd Like to See and make your own newsmedium.

  • Working Memory

    4 years ago

    Fractured Market

    The internet has fractured the market in a variety of disciplines. The music and movie industries are the most obvious and impacted examples, but the book publishing and public relations industries have also faced, and evolved, through radical changes in the last ten years.

    Any business with a communication engine at its core has been affected, especially the mainstream news industry, and because this industry is made up of a substantial number of academics and intellectuals, and because they have the most to lose, the transition has been slower due to resistance.

    "Owners" of mainstream news companies recognized the threat early and started way back in the mid 90's to lead their customers to believe that the internet would not change the news business. Newspapers were the most vocal and unethical in this manner. They impeded progress to protect their profits, and they did what they could to keep their model intact. A fractured market is not good for mainstream news profits.

    Here's why: Fracturing the news market separates the very large less-sophisticated gullible group, from the smaller group that values intellect over emotion. The internet makes it possible for smarter people to separate themselves from the common denominator masses.

    Owners of mainstream news companies rely on crowd emotion to sway political and commercial agenda. Basically, news media convince this large, less-sophisticated group to follow their path by spreading misinformation and half-truths. It's referred to in the industry as "necessary illusion" and "checkbook journalism."

    When this large, but less-educated lower income group buy into an ideology, they reluctantly drag the smaller group, which has a better understanding of issues, along for the ride. (On the outside chance someone from the larger group is reading this post, which is unlikely, here is a translation: Smart news publishers use stupid people as a megaphone to channel their message through to the masses. Polls are one of their tools.)

    continued ...

  • Working Memory

    4 years ago

    Fractured Market cont'd

    Thankfully, we live in an era where owners of mainstream news companies can no longer so-easily use the larger less-sophisticated crowd to overwhelm and inevitably influence the smaller smarter group.

    Mainstream news publishing companies are being forced to appeal directly to this smaller smarter group even though it is lowering their profits. Publishers can no longer ignore this smaller group because average citizens now also have access to the masses through the internet, plus they can push their message around the world.

    A good real-time example of this manipulation can be observed by watching how newspapers report news about the 2010 Olympics. In July of 2007, the Vancouver Sun finally announced that they had become an "official" Olympic booster, and that VANOC would hire them to promote the Games.

    Basically, the newspaper will use the emotion of the gullible masses to "overwhelm" the smaller intellectual group, and in doing so will force the will of the IOC on our region.

    Now that CanWest and CTV (bitter rivals) are "both" the "official voices" of the 2010 Olympics, citizens in our Olympic region have only independent internet news sources to rely on for accurate and non-partisan information.

    Nothing coming from mainstream news media regarding the 2010 Olympics can be trusted because VANOC and the IOC are now paying "all" the big mainstream news companies to tell the Olympics version of the Olympics story. This includes information about the homeless, taxes, real estate, budgets and costs, volunteering for the 2010 Games, etc.

    Maurice Cardinal
    Editor: OlyBLOG.com
    Author: LeverageOlympicMomentum.com

  • Working Memory

    4 years ago

    Who Cares - speedo

    You make great points speedo, but when you state "Who Cares," that is exactly what mainstream news companies want smart people like you to think. They want you to give up so they can have free rein to abuse the less-smart public.

    If you see someone abusing a child and you walk away saying "who cares" it sends a message that it is fine to abuse kids.

    The IOC used local news media to convince our 2010 Host region that the Games would be good for our community.

    Local newspapers and television spread "feel good" stores throughout our region, while they concurrently created a feeding frenzy for the real estate industry so they could make a killing artificially boosting house prices, which also boosted taxes so you could pay for the 2010 Games. Newspapers make a fortune selling advertising to the real estate industry. It happens like this in all Olympics regions, and Vancouver is no exception.

    Who cares? You should care, because you're paying for it and local newspapers got your neighbors to vote against you.

    Who is smarter now? More importantly, who will be the smartest in 2011 when your 2010 tax bill arrives?

  • BC Mary

    4 years ago

    Voices from the Newsroom ...

    Voices from the Newsroom found that:

    9.5 per cent of journalists indicated that they believe the corporate owners of their news outlet valued good journalism over profit. This perspective perhaps reflects the bookkeepers' view of employees as liabilities -- a management approach that is only exacerbated when big media get bigger.

    That's about how I figured it.

    What will people do, now and increasingly in the future, when they want to blame the journalists for not creating a better, wiser, truer kind of journalism? There won't be enough of them left to blame.

    I've seen what big media can do to small media, in a situation where a small weekly posed no real threat to the big Southam daily. Seems the big media just can't stand sharing.

    So Big Media isn't a net benefit to the public interest, in my view.

  • Working Memory

    4 years ago

    Fight back

    Options are available if you look.

    For example, take this story and its comments, or any other appropriate story on The Tyee that turns your crank, and email it to writers and editors at your local newspaper or television company and demand that they address news media issues. If they don't respond, report that they didn't respond. Silence speaks volumes.

    Maybe The Tyee can help out in this respect by keeping an "open" mainstream news media article with a perpetual "comments" section to address this issue. Casual sniping that happens all too often here accomplishes little if there is no follow up, and especially when mainstream media knows it's just hot air that will dissipate.

    Demand that local news media companies incorporate "Comments" sections on their properties.

    Or as "speedo" suggested, start your own blog.

    You can also post news on NowPublic.com - it's Vancouver-based and has global reach.

    Don't simply whine and complain - act!!

    The CRTC won't help you unless you help yourself. The CRTC is so far behind the times that they don't get it. In most cases it would be more beneficial if they simply got out of the way.

    BTW, if you're so concerned about this issue why haven't more people voiced an opinion about the "censoring" of amateur athletes in a recent Tyee article. I was the only person to make a comment on this critical media topic.

    It's important to connect the dots if you expect to understand how insidious local mainstream media really is.

  • gaulois

    4 years ago

    Let's not forget the Media Carta initiative

    The adbusters.org campaign called Media Carta seems most relevant to this story. I am always amazed at the ability of small groups to not better unite themselves when fighting the biggies.

    It would also been useful to point out under "How to take action" that the site redirected to an AFL-CIO web site. Nothing wrong with this, although not mentionning it seems reminiscent of big media questionable practices of restricting media choices...

  • village

    4 years ago

    to Gaulois , My research on what I call '' THE MIND OF CANADA ''

    has indeed come up with the challenges that communications vehicles of all origins CREATE for the individuals or groups that actual nourish themselves with ..., the nutrients ( food for thought )that is offered in any given ... CULTURE *..

    My interest in our MINDSCAPE , so to speak , stems from Experiences I've had within regions I've lived over a period of many decades..*

    Hence the role of NEWSPAPERS.., clearly , still the very daily.., or weekly source of news that is delivered..( still ) at your and my doorstep.., and becomes defacto the .. equivalent of ( PHONE BOOKS..)and what they were and still are to this day.., ie: if you were in the phone book , you were recognised as a person.., if not , you simply were considered passing through.., defining, along the way, as they do.., whether you exist or not.., in any given place.., in any given setting..

    Well I contend that MEDIA plays that very role in all of our lives.., be it at the individual or more importantly, at the COMMUNITY level of IDENTITY..,( and we all know how identity has now become defacto the .., very ingredient and engine of the FUTURE IDENTITY ECONOMY ..,) as one fascinating UNIVERSITY RESEARCHING PROFESSOR put it to us , at a most recent Public lecture.. on , of all things.., THE ECONOMY OF CULTURE itself..,

    ( it could have as easily been called the ECONOMY OF IDENTITY ).., he , this professor/ researcher explained that we are entering a time.., when economist are realising that the very NEXT ECONOMY will be built on our identity wants and needs.. for we have now gone beyond the model of the ECONOMY that was based on SCARCITY.., to a now reality of being an economy that has too much available for the consumer..,thus his interest in the ECONOMY OF THE MIND.. as I call it..,

    Let's be very clear about this.., the imagination side of what will become available to the consumer.., is now the largest emerging economy developing.. and as we discuss MEDIA ISSUES.., within CANADA..we need to be aware that we will be attracted to this emerging world thinking economy that , above all will attempt to lure us with the siren songs of GLOBAL IDENTITIES themselves.

    Thus , it would seem we are at a turning point of what we will experience in the EMERGING ECONOMIES OF TOMORROW.., and this will have great bearings on how the VOICES we are so accustomed to take our cue from.,will be heard, and will become ever more busy with communicating that very IDENTITY product that we all so yearn for..*

    Media , Ladies and Gentleman, positioned to take us on a flight of imagination like we've never seen or experienced before..,and at the speed of light..,

    No wonder , concerns about the technology is being expressed over and over again..,
    leading me to a thought that one of our best minds had..on the subject matter..,
    THAT TECNOLOGIES ARE BUT EXTENSIONS OF THE HOMO SAPIENS.. and are but tools..*

    (*limited tools ) at that..

  • speedo

    4 years ago

    OK, I get it. People are so

    OK, I get it. People are so stupid- well not Working Memory and everyone else posting here- that they aren't sophisticated enough to realize when they're being duped, so we, The Vanguard, have a duty to protect them from such hideously contemptible things as CanWest Global. Patronizing compassion for the masses from the left is just as unpalatable than rightist contempt.

    I'm on the side of Everyman and Everywoman because I think they're smarter than people like you are giving them credit for.

  • village

    4 years ago

    To MEMORY WORKS.. I like your comments about the role the TYEE

    could play...,in setting up a '' perpetual '' comments section.. ( And I think the Publisher should seriously consider it )

    I recall years ago that I posted on the TYEE certain observations I made in a letter to the Editor of my local newspaper . ( I also posted their response or lack thereof ..- can't remember which at this time .. however it was empowering to have a venue for PUBLISHING what another Media's behaviour is as per their role in society..) as purporting to be.., a VOICE FOR CITIZENS..

    ( fourth pillar talk and all of that )..

    What I like about your suggestion , MEMORY WORKS .., is that the TYEE.. could become an ARCHIVE and DEPOSITORY that would eventually become an INVENTORY or .. ( MIND MAP ) if you will, of how we are doing.., in our flight of imagination side of the equation.. WHEN IT COMES TO HEARING OUR OWN VOICES.., Not only within Canada itself.., but within each of the Provinces that are the building blocks of our NATIONAL IDENTITY*...

    AT THE GROUND LEVEL OF NEIGHBOURHOODS..,AND CITIES ,VILLAGES and MUNICIPALITIES of all sizes and shapes..,local Media - or lack thereof..- must be exposed for the role they are playing in diluting our very sense of place, becoming and IDENTITY itself..

    From the Ground Up..! indeed.., with a window to our very state of imagination.. as individuals, groups., or CITIZENS in their very own CITIES and VILLAGES.., we all have a stake in preserving a coherent sense of ourselves..,

    Reminds of the time I walked into a SEVEN ELEVEN Store.. and realised that the VOICES that were offered to us..,on the magazine racks.. were for the most part..,VOICES from beyond our borders..,

    continued ...

  • village

    4 years ago

    continued ... and this got me thinking of what we say about

    continued ...
    ( and this got me thinking of what we say about anyone that keeps hearing voices* from another source then their very own VOICES.., ..) and we all know where they end up.., lost and disoriented.., indeed.., fragmented and invariably stripped of any meaning and yes.., even stripped of their sense of being.., sense of place , sense of belonging and IDENTITY itself..

    So, in a MIND OF CANADA approach to MEDIA itself.., I would ask of all readers to question what role they are playing.. either to help us get into contact with our COLLECTIVE IMAGINATION... or is it , in the contrary .., breaking us up.., fragmenting our collective mind..into pieces that can never ever .., find itself, in the global frenzy of .., infinity of possibilities themselves..,

    Thusly creating , for the most part..,a break down of societies..,be it at the NEIGHBOURHOOD LEVEL, (* though it can be argued that because of this vast expansive dimension being foisted on people there is a tendency now to regroup at the local and neighbourhood level..and might explain away why there is this kind of resurgence.., of a GROUND REALITY approach to community.., to what I call,( and others have called ) COMMUNITY OF GEOGRAPHY..

    The surge of interest in GOOGLE EARTH as a case in point .. , and so many other examples that point to a return to the very ground that has nurtured us all.., in an agricultural and CULTURE sense of PLACE, sense of BELONGING , and eventual sense of COMMUNITY IDENTITY..,

    HUMAN SETTLEMENTS and the COMMUNICATIONS CHALLENGES OF THE 21st CENTURY .. becoming the topic , du jour..*..

    Just some thoughts , Take Care,
    Village.

  • snert

    4 years ago

    village

    Maybe we should just make sure that we have a courses on Critical Thinking in our schools.

    Learning how to judge ideas on their own merit, what an odd concept.

    That would pull the teeth of global media.

    FWIW You may want to define 'region' and 'community' as you use them in your arguments.

    Everybody has issues with something. Just how fine do you think we should split hairs?

  • Betty

    4 years ago

    Don't forget...

    ...that the 40-year-old, independent newsweekly The Georgia Straight still exists and should, I feel, be mentioned in any story challenging big media consolidation. It's holding firm and long may it continue.

  • village

    4 years ago

    testing ...

    hello , testing

  • village

    4 years ago

    to SNERT.., the closest that I can come to a definition of

    COMMUNITY*... is one that speaks to the HUMAN SETTLEMENTS '' road travelled '' of societies who from the very first steps taking in becoming agri-based .. quickly realised the advantages of pooling their skills and resources.., to a common gain ..

    Indeed the very idea of a COMMUNITY OF GEOGRAPHY comes from this unique perspective that even CULTURE as we've come to know it today stems from this particular AGRICULTURE approach to banding together and creating a win win for all that participated in it's venture*

    Thus to the question of splitting hairs.. I would think that clarity of meaning and having a frame of reference and thinking that makes our exchanges .. meaningful is the reason to get at the kind of questions you raise..,

    I thought that my mentioning repeatedly the building blocks of community as being NEIGHBOURHOODS.. in their own rights.., and mentioning the '' SENSE OF PLACE'', '' SENSE OF BELONGING '' and '' SENSE OF IDENTITY'' itself would do it..,but thanks for reminding me that we all have on very own and unique DICTIONARY / PICTIONARY... and further on have our very own MIND CONSTRUCT , as to how we experience the world around us..,

    MAKING THE QUESTION OF MEDIA INFLUENCE ON OUR INDIVIDUAL AND COLLECTIVE MINDS.. even more fascinating..,and Important .

    (*continued )..

  • village

    4 years ago

    For instance the pull of the internet in it's initial stages was

    For instance the pull of the internet in it's initial stages was one of belonging to a WORLD COMMUNITY via the magic and the speed of the internet itself.., which gradually gave way to the very notion and realisation that this was very VIRTUAL at best as to being a real community*... ( GROUNDED ).., for emphasis..,

    In my comments I try to bring back some kind of footings in our Dialog so that we all can arrive at a reality check in how we perceive the very ideas that our RESPECTIVE CULTURES / COMMUNITIES and even family units along with relations create for us in the LANGUAGING PATTERNS and TOOLS that we inherit from said environments....,( that indeed all would that could have the word community incorporated to give them meaning..,and understanding/innerstanding and outerstanding would provide for a breakthrough of communications .. wouldn't you think ? )

    But in effect.., the historical sense of COMMUNITY .. can be derived by it's ROOT elements.., as in COMMUNE.. or COMMON..,hence the importance that I give to the COMMUNITY OF GEOGRAPHY approach.. to which incorporated VILLAGES and CITIES have given a certain continuity to what was initially but a HUMAN SETTLEMENT at best.. ( an arrangement ) between people's of - usually like beliefs and language- but came to be.., more like , PEOPLE WHO WANTED TO BUILD SOMETHING TOGETHER FOR THE BETTERMENT OF THE GREATER NUMBERS WITHIN THAT GROUPING..,

    Tribes within the FIRST NATIONS come to mind as very strong units of identity , within the context of what it might mean to be part of a COMMUNITY.. usually a life time commitment to the survival of that particular entity...,

    There are other examples.., closer to our very own experience..when INCORPORATION of VILLAGES and CITIES..which eventually defined the PROVINCES.., in a meaningful way.. which in turn gave meaning to the IDENTITY of an even larger entity.. called a COUNTRY.. ( and on and on.. )

    As we now experience the SPACE SHIP EARTH reality of BUCKMINSTER FULLER's mind construct that so aptly described our future challenges..,way back then..,

    World Citizens.. and yes.. World Communities..,

    Part of our social fabric.., part of our individual and collective psyche also... stemming from..our imaginative flight possibilities..,

    of : what was discovered.., when realising that thought itself., became the fundamental building block.. of that creation of ours.., COMMUNITY indeed..,
    of PEOPLE and IDEAS.., Etc..

    Sorry for the long thought process , but I enjoyed your question snert.. and was , indeed..,free wheeling the imaginative side .., as I did INNOVATIVE THINKING by simply experiencing as well as observing the very sentences that flowed from your interaction with my previous post..,

    Thanks for that..
    Take Care,
    Village.

  • village

    4 years ago

    Betty . Georgia Straight has indeed a fascinating history ..

    And it's transformation from what it was way back then to what it is today.., is a great example of.., how COMMUNICATIONS can grown in any given environment..,

    And this ,the Georgia Straight did with
    great adaptive steps.., firstly as a VOICE that was being denied any kind of reality by the powers that be at that time,

    And further to this .., having to become very pro-active in it's guerrilla style survival.. by in effect reaching out to all readers who might , just might , want another point of view emerge in a landscape and MINDSCAPE that , much like today .. was owned and controlled by a very few power brokers .., who clearly could not take the Georgia Straight seriously.., even when it managed to not only survive and thrive..

    It was a generational leap of one VOICE.. adapting to.., and co-existing with many other VOICES.. who felt confident enough that they would prevail in their dominance of the READERS psyche.. as is now the confidence expressed by those who control the airwaves...

    As to the Internet.., having such a freedom built into it.., ( a free highway of expression ).., obviously becoming now a matter of focus and concern to those who wish to have not only a say in what people read or view..but want to control the GATES..,

    GATE KEEPERS.. by any other name.., that do not want their privileged position usurped by.. outsiders.., who just might upset the apple cart.., of COMMUNICATIONS»* as did the Georgia Straight in it's time.., ( but as you can see, they , all Media have not only adapted to this ..then New kid on the block but emulated some of it's approaches and non reverence to the institutions and powers that be of that time..

    AND now..? well I would venture to say that THE TYEE.. in having giving to readers such as all of us.. A UNIQUE FREEDOM of experiencing our very own VOICES..will one day challenge the powers that be..and be considered another of those recurring NEW KIDS ON THE COMMUNICATIONS BLOCK..*.who along many others is battling for the heart and minds of us , the CITIZENS of not only this province ..but of a country called CANADA..

    Along with COMMUNITIES OF GEOGRAPHIES..that make up our worlds on the ground.

    Village,

  • ov

    4 years ago

    Village

    Here is a conversation fragment on organization within society and whether it is economic, communications, complexity or community. The post that I made today has some links to extreme democracy which you may find interesting. That link is to quest mode and you would have to register to comment and participate but I thought you might see the potential for mind mapping and information archiving that you mentioned in a few previous posts. (note the enumerated post feature in that link)

  • village

    4 years ago

    Thanks OV.., I'm on my way out . ( Contractual obligations )..

    At first glance , I find interesting the exchanges you linked me to .

    I will have something to say when I return from my work. But I want to immediately say that I am pleased that you've offered to me an additional window of EXPLORATION and DISCOVERY.. (and in that light , welcome all others who would have other windows - angles of perceptions / points of view and what have you , to share with me..) I welcome all opportunities to broaden my horizons..., as to how we, HOMO SAPIENS, think.

    And especially how we manage to COMMUNICATE THAT THINKING.

    Thanks once again OV.
    Village.

  • BC Mary

    4 years ago

    Three news sites

    working memory:

    I followed your advice on both counts:

    ... start your own blog

    You can also post news on NowPublic.com - it's Vancouver-based and has global reach.

    and can report as follows:

    * It's a lot of work to sustain a good, newsworthy blog. Mine is The Legislature Raids and has produced 335 specific news items over its 14-month life. Somebody has to really, really care about the topic. To visit, the URL is: http://bctrialofbasi-virk.blogspot.com/

    * The site you recommended (NowPublic.com) is awful. Might as well look at CNN. I'd say Public Eye OnLine, or Salt Spring News, or Vive le Canada are more satisfying choices for Canadian readers.

  • SharingIsGood

    4 years ago

    One pagers bring some democracy

    Over the past 15 years, there have been several black on white bond one-page papers supported with advertising and sent to all the local retail restaurants and businesses for free distribution. These one pagers are good at getting much of the real local news out, but occassionally they touch on provincial matters. As most of the heaviest suporters are Liberals, the oe pagers are careful not to get to anti-Liberal, but there seems to be more freedom in what they say than can be found in the community bird cage liners and the Lower Mainland fish wraps.

    I would like to see these grow stronger province-wide. I would like to see these daily handbills being pumped out by people who are looking for truth - and not a truth from any political perspective. If the truth gets printed and passed around, the politicians doing evil and (equally evil) those doing nothing but sitting on their hands while tabled at the provincial trough will become evident.

  • iamcur

    4 years ago

    Media Choice?

    It is impossible, no matter how smart we think we are, to make good decisions when we do not have accurate information. If a few corporations control access to information and also choose what information is distributed to the public, they also control the political, social, economic and scientific policies that derive from this.

    It is already true that public relations firms spend multiples of money so that media can use their biased information to pass off to the rest of us as "news". News media that spend little on investigative journalists are then forced to use PR packages to fill dead air and print space. That is why current TV and Radio, as well as newspapers run the SAME stories- even if the media are owned by different companies.

    It is also true that newspaper, radio and tv owners are making agreements with Internet providers to narrow choice there too. And internet providers CAN block access to the Tyee and other sources of independent information- China does it politically and the US and Canada will do it economically [see Telus, Yahoo, etc].

    We are all in deep shit. Suppose the same guys control political, media, and energy decisions- we could be invading other nations, destroying our planet's environment and concentrating wealth and power in only a few hands- and the rest of us will applaud this enthusiastically

  • village

    4 years ago

    OV..., Woke up , got out of bed.., .......

    almost a song..., (* in my head )..., shades of Sergeant Peppers lonely Hearts Club band..

    Great stuff and I highly recommend any reader that's never heard it , to listen to it with not only great nostalgia , but if for the first time , to listen with great attention to the words , the music... the MEANINGS.. , but I digress here..,

    I did wake up this morning with a sentence going over and over in my MIND.. having read most of the comments on the conversation fragment*you offered up .. in the previous post..

    THE SENTENCE? : or rather the thought ?

    TERRITORIAL COMMUNICATIONS IMPERATIVE suggesting itself as one of the clearer explanation of our prowess as Homo Sapiens domination when it comes to our organisational or better yet ... our THINKING abilities .., bar none..,

    The very existence of LANGUAGING TECHNOLOGIES which we've improved from what was initially sound mimicing abilities of our immediate environment to the evolving codes and programming abilities of that particular LANGUAGING TECHNOLOGY itself..WHICH IS QUITE IN EVIDENCE TODAY, , has indeed brought us to the dominating role via not only our use of the very POWER*.., that has emerged from that very ability to communicate*.. but more clearly in evidence is what remains of that DISCUSSION , in my reflections of what I was hearing you and others postulate on..

    Indeed , one of the other imaginative leap that we were able to create, invent or simply stumble on and recognise for what it was worth.., was when we discovered that by learning to walk-WHILE STANDING UP - we were able to gain an advantage not only from a position of height itself , as to our mortal ennemies.., but we also discovered that the ability to stand UPRIGHT gave us an advantage..,

    And from these two initial creative EXPLORATIONS/ DISCOVERIES.. came this stunning ability to do what is now called R&D.., we have come to realise that our inate sense of COMMUNICATIONS .. in all of it's forms.., provide for our not only living conditions itself.., but suggest that it is within this IMAGINATIVE LEAP into the unknown itself.., that we forever find a way out of our perilous situations.

    In my BOOKS .. Power does not equate Control of ressources , but rather Power comes from INFORMATION and KNOWLEDGE of THOSE RESSOURCES.., which invariably gives the HOMO SAPIENS a certain control over them..,

    THUS THE IMAGINATION SIDE OF OUR SKILLS.. via LANGUAGING TOOLS EVOLVED FROM TIME ETERNAL ,in my opinion , is what transfers to us the very feeling, meaning and application of POWER*.. and we should approach it with all of it's limitations*.. ( known and unknown ),.

    THANKS , ONCE AGAIN..
    Village.

  • village

    4 years ago

    OV..., Woke up , got out of bed.., .......

    almost a song..., (* in my head )..., shades of Sergeant Peppers lonely Hearts Club band..

    Great stuff and I highly recommend any reader that's never heard it , to listen to it with not only great nostalgia , but if for the first time , to listen with great attention to the words , the music... the MEANINGS.. , but I digress here..,

    I did wake up this morning with a sentence going over and over in my MIND.. having read most of the comments on the conversation fragment*you offered up .. in the previous post..

    THE SENTENCE? : or rather the thought ?

    TERRITORIAL COMMUNICATIONS IMPERATIVE suggesting itself as one of the clearer explanation of our prowess as Homo Sapiens domination when it comes to our organisational or better yet ... our THINKING abilities .., bar none..,

    And from these two initial creative EXPLORATIONS/ DISCOVERIES.. came this stunning ability to do what is now called R&D.., we have come to realise that our inate sence of COMMUNICATIONS .. in all of it's forms.., provide for our not only living conditions itself.., but suggest that it is within this IMAGINATIVE LEAP into the unknown itself.., that we forever find a way out of our perilous situations.

    In my BOOKS .. Power does not equate Control of ressources , but rather Power comes from the earliest imaginative flight which inviably creates the INFORMATION and KNOWLEDGE of THOSE RESSOURCES.., which ultimately gives the HOMO SAPIENS a certain control over them..,

    THUS THE IMAGINATION SIDE OF OUR SKILLS.. via LANGUAGING TOOLS EVOLVED FROM TIME ETERNAL ,in my opinion , is what transfers to us the very feeling and meaning and ability of application of POWER*..( IE.. we could never have, nor harness power without the conscious realisation of it's existence ) and with that in mind ,we should approach it with all of it's limitations*.. ( known and unknown ),.

    THANKS , ONCE AGAIN..
    Village.

  • village

    4 years ago

    To BC Mary .. I am , once again , Reminded by revisiting your

    Blog.., how important that very act of yours WAS .

    You did all British Columbians a great service and I sincerely hope that you fully realise the gratitude that people such as I have , for that unselfish act.

    THAT PEOPLE YEARN FOR A FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION, FOR A FREEDOM OF BELIEFS ALSO, REMAINS ONE OF THE MOST POWERFUL INGREDIENT , along with this need we all have to aggregate , to in effect exchange , and learn from each other..:
    TO COMMUNICATE*..,

    This ever fading glow , from a candle that does have , indeed , the power to stand up against all of the DARKNESS that the UNIVERSE itself can bring up against it.

    These BLOGS become these candles..,kept burning , by the deepest desires of all who create them.., to simply be part of the HUMAN FAMILY..,to be part also of the decency , the respect, the tolerance , the joy also of belonging to an evolving thought process, that includes rather then EXCLUDES..*..

    Such is the pendulum change that we are going through.., when we reach out with our thoughts , with our feelings.., with our HEARTS..,

    Your reflections on the other side of the question - or Coin if you will - as to WHO ULTIMATELY GAINS BY ON GOING ATTACKS ON THE RCMP.. is a fine example of a thought process that is willing to look at all possibilities and scenario's and bears repeating for a larger audience ..

    I hope you don't mind my posting it here , for I do think it is a fine example of exploration and discovery THINKING .. that always opens up the possibilities and choices we all so need, to further our very own EXPLORATIONS and DISCOVERIES.., so that eventually some kind of consensus.. some kind of TRUTH eventually emerges and makes , for a better connected world..,

    A feeling , thinking world that rediscovers that it has individuals within it that have their very own thoughts , feelings and dreams. VISIONS if you will, which , when shared with all of us.. makes us all richer.., for having had the experience of EXPERIENCING these shared moments..,

    Now that is an economy I can not only identify with .. but willingly want to trade and barter in*..

    IMAGINATION MARKETS.. anyone ?

  • village

    4 years ago

    The post I mentioned above , IMAGINATION MARKETS.. and all.

    # posted by BC Mary @ 6:39 AM 1 comments links to this post
    Sunday, July 15, 2007

    Who wins, if we destroy the RCMP?
    .
    Tomorrow, we hope, the pre-trial Basi Virk Basi Hearings get under way again and I've been thinking about something for days. I'm sure others have too. Please bear with me, as I really need to say this and to hear your thoughts as well.

    Let's start in Victoria during that 1996 storm of the century when a freak weather incident dumped so much snow that people were stranded in their homes, hospitals couldn't change shifts, planes, buses, trucks, cars, ferries couldn't move. It was an emergency requiring the army to move in, which they did, smiling to the welcome they received. And rightly so.

    But here's where I started thinking -- did anybody shout: "Somalia! Remember Somalia? Somalia proves that the whole Canadian Army is so bad it needs external investigation and supervision!" Nope. Not then, not now. Rightly so.

    Fast forward a few years. Another kind of storm hits Victoria when serious corruption is suspected right inside the B.C. Legislature. This was also a storm way too big, too deeply hidden for citizens to cope with. This, too, was an emergency and the army -- in this case, the para-military -- showed up to do its duty.

    And I'm thinking: did anybody shout: "Thanks, guys! Thank goodness you saw that! Thank goodness you investigated! Thanks!" Nope, we didn't say that. There was a ghastly silence about the whole sickening issue until gradually the strange accusations began: rotten police, clumsy police, brutal police, unfair police ... until it became: never believe a word the police are saying. Oh? How come? Who decided on this media strategy? And who does that point of view serve in the longrun?

    So here's what I've been thinking ... we know better. We know that nobody stays true to their highest potential under a steady rain of abuse. I'm thinking we all know what a scapegoat is and that rats when threatened will use any strategy to escape or defend themselves.

    I've been thinking we know all sorts of things: that every human needs a decent bit of encouragement in their work. We know that the RCMP, just like the Canadian Army, has to face ugly, dangerous situations on our behalf; maybe for the RCMP it's even worse, as they face these dangers on a daily basis. Always on our behalf.

    continued..

  • village

    4 years ago

    continued from above.., RE: BC MARY's BLOG..

    ... until it became: never believe a word the police are saying. Oh? How come? Who decided on this media strategy? And who does that point of view serve in the longrun?

    So here's what I've been thinking ... we know better. We know that nobody stays true to their highest potential under a steady rain of abuse. I'm thinking we all know what a scapegoat is and that rats when threatened will use any strategy to escape or defend themselves.

    I've been thinking we know all sorts of things: that every human needs a decent bit of encouragement in their work. We know that the RCMP, just like the Canadian Army, has to face ugly, dangerous situations on our behalf; maybe for the RCMP it's even worse, as they face these dangers on a daily basis. Always on our behalf.

    This RCMP family photo (accessible on the Internet) exemplifies the RCMP.
    There's the Dad (retired), his two sons, his daughter, and his son-in-law.

    We know too that our para-military Royal Canadian Mounted Police is forbidden to speak out publicly in its own defence, so we rarely hear about the great things they do. Maybe that's a wise policy; but certainly it also makes them easy targets for the rats and the unscrupulous.

    And we know that even the family dog can tolerate only so much insult and whacking before he gives up and turns sour. We know all that.

    So we should be able to guess what's happening in a Mountie's heart and mind each time we insult the entire national police force for incompetence and corruption. We know that isn't smart. If we keep it up, we know that in the end, the RCMP will become a disheartened, uncaring, resentful national police force ... which leaves one awful question to be considered.

    I mean, Somalia did happen. Somalia involved real failures that went right up the chain of command to the Minister of National Defence (Kim Campbell). But Somalia was never allowed to define the entire Canadian Army. And I'm thinking: neither should Houston or Vanderhoof define the entire RCMP. [See: Report of Somalia Commission of Inquiry http://www.dnd.ca/somalia/vol0/v0s1e.htm]

    So, one last, awful question: who wins, if we continue to disparage the RCMP to the point where they fumble, fail, and can't serve the nation any longer? Who wins ... the Good Guys? Nope, I don't think so.

    I think it's the Bad Guys who will win -- and the good, decent citizens of this country who will lose bigtime -- unless we find a way to support and encourage all that's best in the national police force.

    It's not a rhetorical question. It's an urgent question of immediate importance: If this public opprobrium continues and the RCMP is brought to its knees, who do you think will come out of it with a benefit? - BC Mary.

  • village

    4 years ago

    Reflections , such as BC Mary shares with us in her blog does

    merit being read by many more readers.. and exemplifies the kind of FREE THINKING that will one day open up the
    Thinking Economy of the future , in the making..

    To trade and barter in IDEAS..,is clearly one of the flood gates to have arrived on the so called .., monetary based economy shores of a very distant past..*..( this is meant to be read circa 2020 ... )

    Well you get the drift of my thinking I'm sure..,

    We have an IMAGINATION ECONOMY .. right within each of our creative and receptive cells.., and with this emerging new energy.. - for we know that no economy can run without an ENERGY of some form or other.., - well Ladies and Gentleman.., I would submit that this very Ground Breaking new 21st Century Energy.., comes from within one of the first and now last frontiers ever to be Explored..,

    OUR VERY MINDS.. ( INDIVIDUAL AND COLLECTIVE MINDS..) able to generate the kind of '' electricity '' - read ideas.., imagination , creative urges of all kinds , types and forms..- and you will fully grasp not only the meaning of this powerful source of ENERGY..
    but you will also realise the applications that come with that new found realisation of a POWER*.. that much like electricity itself.. has the ability to LIGHT UP OUR LIVES.., OUR UNIVERSE..

    ( that can not only move people..,and yes even move CREATED mountains at times..-be they imagined obstacles or better yet heights to be conquered - ,for we all remember the very perceptive line that said.., '' THE PEN IS MIGHTIER THEN THE SWORD ''.. Well, somehow , we seem to have forgotten this..,)..and we need to reminded of our internal and collective POWER SOURCE and generator..

    OUR THINKING AND HEART abilities uniting for a powerful ''mind construct '' experience which will break down the walls of resistance and harness the very power and force of .. the very streams of consciousness that produces the kind of ELECTRICITY that eventually lights up the world..,

    the Creative act.., ( I think , therefore I am..) , of becoming alive!

    (continued ... )

  • village

    4 years ago

    continued.... in a stream of conscious way..

    the SOCIAL CAPITAL that is somehow alluded to in books these days..,really hints at this..KNOWLEDGE ECONOMY, an all, but in effect makes the mistake on focusing on the physical assets of any given community rather then looking at the greatest of the '' PSYCHIC INVENTORY'' that exist within each individual and collective groups that make up the COMMUNITIES of today..,and yes even more so..,

    the communities of tomorrow.. who in their turn are in danger of losing the footings , THE VERY GROUND , of the meaning of COMMUNITY itself.., indeed..,
    the

    COMMUNITY of PLACE.. ( OF GEOGRAPHY ). , sense of belonging , sense of identity itself somehow being lost from the perspective of HUMAN SETTLEMENT HISTORY..in this future push we are making in attempting to invent THE FUTURE COMMUNITIES of TOMORROW. that is there to remind us all, of our baby steps we are taking ,

    in need , CLEARLY ALSO , of being steeped in a better understanding, ( INNERSTANDING/OUTERSTANDING ) .. of whatever experience might have been the legacy of.., this earliest of settlement EXPERIENCE*..

    MEMORY indeed of Settlements of OLD.. now needing to be re-united with the effervescent feeling of the SETTLEMENT notions of NEW..

    The challenge for change projects and e experiences of the past.. will somehow help as we take the baby steps into - Albright - an unknown future..,yet very equipped are we.. with a new source of very old energy re- ENERGISED..

    IMAGINATION, CREATIVE .. tides.., much like the pendulum of time itself.., reminding us of our imagination ride..

    IDEAS , imagination.. and Creative strides into ..,

    this moment , of thought itself.

    Village.

  • village

    4 years ago

    test

    many articles written seem to be gone from this forum ..

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.