Artsculture

Borat Makes Me Cringe

And I like.

By Steve Burgess, 3 Nov 2006, TheTyee.ca

Borat Makes Me Cringe

Michael Moore meets Larry David.

Few recent movies have arrived with the advance buzz of Borat, the big screen debut for comedian Sacha Baron Cohen. Is it justified? Pretty much. But although frequently hilarious, Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan is just good enough to make you wish it was better.

Borat is a newfangled creation of modern cinematic science. TV viewers are familiar with Cohen’s routine -- posing as one of several characters, he interacts with ordinary folk and records the results. This time out it’s all Borat Sagdiyev. This movie might lay claim to being a whole new cinematic category: the docu-comedy. If Borat is reminiscent of anything, it might be the films of Michael Moore.

Directed by Larry Charles (of Seinfeld and Curb Your Enthusiasm fame), Borat stars Cohen as the uncouth Kazakhstani reporter, Ken Davitian as his producer Azamat Bagatov, and a lot of unwitting dupes who foolishly signed release forms. There’s a plot of sorts. Shortly after arriving in New York, Borat catches sight of Pam Anderson on a Baywatch rerun and determines to wed her, Kazakh style. Off he goes, producer in tow, on a cross-country quest to find Pammy and, incidentally, uncover some real live American zeitgeist along the way.

‘Drink the blood’

Some of the stunts he pulls off are astounding, such as gaining an invitation to be interviewed on a Jackson, Mississippi morning TV chat show, and another one to sing the national anthem at a Virginia rodeo. More astounding is the sheer courage required to stand in front of that redneck rodeo crowd and express the sincere hope that President Bush will “drink the blood of every man, woman, and child in Iraq.” To their credit, only some of the rodeo audience cheers.

Cohen is a fantastic and utterly fearless improvisational comedian. Your enjoyment of the movie will frequently depend on your tolerance for unbelievably awkward human interaction. At a formal dinner party attended by Borat, the hostess must finesse the delicate social art of when to smile gracefully and when to call the cops. (When your dinner guest returns from the bathroom with a bag of his own feces: gracious. When his rotund prostitute companion shows up at the door: cops.)

But the best parts of the Borat movie are when he gets to play straight man. At one point after plenty of crazy Borat behaviour, he staggers into a revival meeting and is suddenly transformed into the most normal guy in the room.

Spontaneous dislosures

Even better are the scenes where Cohen/ Borat simply listens while his interview subjects reveal the appalling contents of their minds and souls: from the rodeo organizer professing his dream of someday hanging all homosexuals to the RV full of drunk college students, America’s hope for tomorrow, demonstrating why the America of tomorrow is quite likely screwed.

It’s these scenes that raise the bar, making other parts of the film suffer by comparison. Many scenes basically amount to cruel pranks perpetrated on innocent victims. When Borat and Bagatov check into a B&B and discover the old couple running the place are -- horrors! -- Jews, their reaction is funny because we’ve already seen evidence of their superstitious anti-Semitism (in fact, not so much anti-Semitism as full-blown Jew phobia). But the old couple are so sweet you can’t help but feel sorry for them. That may be the very effect Cohen & co. was aiming for. Still, it seems more cruel than amusing.

Other scenes, particularly a disgusting naked wrestling match, aim straight for the sophomore crowd (a group both mocked and catered to at different points). After the high points hit earlier, that sort of stuff is a letdown.

But all is forgiven when Borat finally confronts Pam Anderson at a book signing. Poor, poor, Pam. Did she sign a release, or was she fair game on account of holding a public event? And considering the melee he triggers, how did Cohen stay out of jail? When Cohen actually gets off a climactic one-liner after being pummeled by security, it is clear that no performer this side of Jackass does more to earn your movie dollar. It "make benefit  glorious" career of Sacha Baron Cohen.
 [Tyee]

18  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • maestro

    5 years ago

    Comments on "Borat Makes Me Cringe"

    This dude is quite hilarious.

    His Ali-G show is great.
    He has found his own unique comedy niche', it's about time he had his own movie.

  • charlesdemers

    5 years ago

    In the strictest sense, it's not his first feature film -- he did a universally-panned Ali G movie called 'Ali G Indahouse' which was, by all accounts, a turd.

    Looking forward to Borat, but even more so to the Bruno movie -- Cohen's gay, Nazi-sympathetic fashion reporter; "Ricky Martin: Keep him in the ghetto or train to Auschwitz?" -- that has just been announced.

  • grw

    5 years ago

    I love Borat but I had to stop reading the review halfway through because Burgess gave away too many gags. I want to be surprised when I see a movie. Now the bag of feces gag will be old hat by the time I see it. Thanks.

  • skeptikool

    5 years ago

    Am looking forward to see it. Sounds a little more Pythonesque than Python.

    Don't have it at hand, but one review referred to imbibing "fermented horse urine". Does anyone know if such a practice exists? I should think there would be a great danger here in becoming doubly pissed.

    No, I am my own brewmaster, but I don't have horses.

  • Yammer

    5 years ago

    I am pretty trepeditious about this -- it sorta seems, I dunno, racist. Like "look, the foreigner has a funny accent" time. But the more I read about it, I guess it is more about how people react to Borat than about submarining the image of Kazakhstan.

  • spanky

    5 years ago

    Borat is my fukkin hero!

  • chrisyak

    5 years ago

    Sound awesome. But how about a nod to Rick Mercer's "Talking to Americans"?

  • teen

    5 years ago

    pretty funny. they had a segment on CTV national last night where they went to Kazakhstan to get the reaction of the people there. They hate him a lot.Maybe CTV made it seem like that, but there were on air death threats to him, one guy hoping he would be shot tomorrow! Apparently, as CTv pointed out, theres some whole Kazakhstan marketing campign about to begin due to the Borat movie's not so hot potrayal of Kazakhstan.

  • kjc

    5 years ago

    Aww . . . the bag of feces joke is old hat now.

    Is that supposed to be funny?

    Borat is the latest Jewish comic (i.e. Sarah "I would f**king kill Jesus again" Silverstein) who use "fake" ignorance & racism as a means of getting their victims to expose "real" ignorance & racism.

  • incredulous

    5 years ago

    Caught the movie this weekend - VERY, VERY funny. . . the wife and I are still tittering over some of the lines. Crude, yes. Offensive, YES.

    Oh, and I humbly disagree with Burgess about the sophomoric wrestling scene - was the highlight to the movie for me. . .it just got more and more ridiculous as it continued. . . I couldn't stop giggling for 20 minutes after the scene. It was the apotheosis of post-modern/colonialist performance art - they'll be auctioning-off that fist at Christie's next to some Mapplethorpe and Warhol in 20 years.

  • reuben

    5 years ago

    kjc - it's Sarah Silverman, not Silverstein.

  • kurt

    5 years ago

    Has anyone noticed that all the "Kazakh" words Borat uses are actually Yiddish? Pretty funny.

  • Pat

    5 years ago

    Perhaps IGA is a bad choice on the Coast,but here in the Interior, it is the one I like to support(in addition to the Farmer's Markets and our local organic delivery). Yes, the prices may be higher, but it is small, friendly and independent and is actually IN TOWN and not out on the edges of town like the big supermarkets.It means my dog and I can easily walk there and backpack the goods home. I frequently ask the manager to carry the organic goods that I would get at the much more expensive Capers- equivalent (also in Mall- land)and he is happy to comply. In so doing, I'm encouraging them to supply organics to more than myself.

  • Steve Burgess

    5 years ago

    Kurt--I read that some of Borat's chatter is Hebrew.

    What's with these rogue posts, i.e. IGA? It's happened before in other threads. A technical glitch?

  • atom

    5 years ago

    You not recognize Borat brother IGA?

  • Alcibiades

    5 years ago

    Apparently, some of the racist frat boys Cohen interviews are now claiming their release(s) were attained under false pretences.

  • Steve Burgess

    5 years ago

    They were interviewed while stupid. It's not fair.

  • Alcibiades

    5 years ago

    LOL - thanks Steve Burgess. Not so stupid to have found a lawyer to sue on a percentage retainer though.

    Personally, I'd be investigating a new identity.

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.