Books

'Murder City'

The violent horror of Ciudad Juarez. When Mexico's president visits Canada this week, will we be too polite to bring it up?

By Crawford Kilian, 27 May 2010, TheTyee.ca

Ciudad Juarez woman crying, Mexico

Grieving relative of one of thousands murdered. Photo: Amnesty International.

Related

  • Murder City: Ciudad Juarez and the Global Economy's New Killing Fields
  • Charles Bowden
  • Nation Books (2010)

Mexico's President Felipe Calderon is in Canada this week, seeking to improve relations with Ottawa. He'll have a lot to talk about, but one topic he'll mention briefly if at all: The worsening anarchy in Ciudad Juarez. It's so bad that it's literally unimaginable, but let's try to imagine it in Canadian terms.

So imagine Vancouver in a parallel world.

In this world, 30 to 40 per cent of us live, one way or another, off money from the trade in drugs to the U.S. Several tons of marijuana and cocaine cross the border into Blaine every day, waved through by bribed border officials on both sides.

In our own Vancouver, 117 of us were murdered in 2008. In this parallel world, more than 1,600 Vancouverites were murdered in 2008, many by Vancouver cops. Many other murder victims were themselves Vancouver cops.

In this parallel world, police officers are not fighting a war on drugs. They're fighting a war for drugs, and for the billions of dollars they generate. They're not fighting only the B.C. cartel; they're also fighting the Alberta and Saskatchewan cartels, not to mention the Mounties and the Canadian Forces. All are involved in a battle for control of the market.

Drugs and sweatshops

For young Vancouverites, a career in drugs is a reasonable career choice. It's even more reasonable if they start in law enforcement or the military: the training they receive will make them more attractive as assassins and torturers, whether for the cartels or for the cops or soldiers.

The alternative? Working for almost nothing in factories that make goods for Wal-Mart, at least until the owners move the business to China. Canadian farming has been ruined by cheap imports from the U.S., and huge parts of the country depend on money sent home from the States by illegal emigrants.

In this parallel world, Vancouver's mayor spends most of his time in his house in Seattle. It's safer there. St. Joseph's Hospital in Bellingham sees a lot of Canadian gunshot victims; if they'd been taken to VGH or Surrey Memorial, their attackers might have followed them into the ER and finished them off in front of the doctors.

In this world, you may be driving your kid to school when assassins fill your SUV with bullets. If they're professionals, only you will die; if not, your kid will die too. Your widow and your other kids may be shot to death at your funeral.

You'll be lucky if your death even makes the papers: Vancouver's reporters get killed too if they pay too much attention to such crimes.

Dystopia as a fact of life

That may seem like a far-fetched dystopian nightmare. But it's the basic condition of life for the two million people who live in Ciudad Juarez, just across the Rio Grande from El Paso, Texas.

Charles Bowden, who has written several books about the drug trade, started this one when 48 people in Juarez died violently in January 2008. That seemed to him an appalling number, but by the end of the year at least 1,607 had been killed. In his afterword, Bowden writes: "By the summer of 2009, Juarez looks back on 2008 as the quiet time." Later he notes that by early December 2009, 2,400 had died.

After years of visits to Juarez, Bowden knows the city and its horrors. He also knows that neither the American nor the Mexican media have come close to describing or explaining it.

So his book is not a meticulous analysis of the violence and its causes. He has no real narrative. Instead, he offers a mosaic of people, mostly dead, and events, mostly bloody. Taken together, they form a monstrous image of a collapsed society.

One of the people is Miss Sinaloa, a beauty queen who accepts an invitation to a party in Juarez; after days of being drugged and gang-raped, she's turned loose with bite marks on her breasts. Insane, she stumbles into an asylum for the drug-destroyed created by "the Pastor," a recent convert to evangelical Christianity. Bowden makes her a metaphor for Mexico.

The repentant assassin

Bowden talks to a reporter who has written too freely and has to flee to the U.S. -- where he and his teenage son are thrown in jail. Bowden meets with an ex-cop who became a sicario, a professional killer, for 20 years. The sicario didn't even know whom he was working for -- cartel, army, police, who cared? He finally became a Christian and escaped the job, but he knows his employers will never forget or forgive him.

Our immediate response is to look for a clear and simple explanation: cartels fighting one another for market share. Desperation caused by NAFTA's destruction of the Mexican farm economy. Millions of American and Canadian dopers who don't care who dies as long as they can get high.

Bowden is far past that. Those may be some of the causes of the nightmare, but now, he says, the violence is simply the new state of affairs:

"The violence has crossed class lines. The violence is everywhere. The violence is greater. And the violence has no apparent and simple source. It is like the dust in the air, part of life itself."

Our next response, like that of the Mexicans, is to lie low, keep quiet, and try to ignore the violence. We book holidays in Cancun or Puerto Vallarta. We watch Mexico's President Calderon visiting President Obama, who agrees that Arizona's new law against illegal immigrants is a scandal. They don't discuss why so many Mexicans flee their country. Meanwhile, the U.S. pays $1.4 billion to the Mexican army, supposedly to help it fight the cartels, when Washington must know that the army is itself a drug cartel.

Now Calderon wants us to drop our visa requirement for Mexican visitors, and to provide more training for Mexican police and judges.

Is Juarez our future?

But Bowden is past all those reflexive responses to the anarchy. It's not a matter of busting some crooked cops or "getting tough on crime." He returns to Juarez compulsively: "I think it is about tasting the future."

Juarez is not improving. On May 19, I visited the website of El Diario, a Juarez newspaper. One of its stories was headlined "Tragic day of nine deaths." It began with a description of a woman who was shot in both legs in front of her home while trying to protect her husband against armed attackers who'd shot him in the head. Crippled, she lay near his body while their two Rottweilers ate her dead husband's brains. The dogs then attacked the federal cops who arrived on the scene.

Yes, it's gross and horrible. But most such events don't even get reported, and chances are no one will be arrested, let alone convicted, for this murder. Or for the other eight.

It could happen here. Juarez, after all, is a taste of the future.  [Tyee]

7  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • jwstewart

    2 years ago

    Will we be too polite????

    It isn't too polite to send billions of our dollars to the drug lords to purchase their recreational products and create this mess, huh?

    The least we could do is legalize these recreational products and reduce the price to a level that doesn't invoke crazed greed.

  • cboo44

    2 years ago

    Too polite?

    Will the President of Mexico be too polite to "mention" that sanctimonious Canadians are providing a market for Mexican drug lords? And a safe haven for lower level smuggling gangs, an unending supply of BC Bud for the "market" and a complicit population that ignores the reality of the drug and gun trade?

  • Mustafarian

    2 years ago

    Murder Country

    It is important to note that it is not just Juarez that is suffering a drug war. I have contacts in Mexico that speak of many cities in the North of the country that are either ghost towns or de facto controlled by drug cartels. High levels of drug related violence also affect other areas of the country, specially the states of Sinaloa (home to the largest cartel), Michoacan (home state of the president), and Guerrero. Mexico City itself and Acapulco are also hotbeds of drug related murder.

    Canadian cocaine consumption is only a small cause of this. The overwhelming profits for the cartels are in cocaine sales in the US. But a critical factor in the equation is the collapse of the Mexican economy, especially the rural sector, for which NAFTA and similar policies are to blame. Add to this a dive in the once-thriving maquila economy as the race-to-the-bottom that is globalization sends jobs to the cheaper sweatshops of china, and you have legions of unemployable young men for whom the only options are the cartels or migration.

    But an appropriate amount of blame must also be laid at the foot to the incredibly corrupt, incompetent and violent Mexican political class, of which Calderon is but one of many key players. They have been miss-managing Mexico and enriching themselves, their friends and family at the expense of average Mexicans for decades. Not only that but they are also deeply tied to other criminal networks including the drug cartels, are complicit in countless atrocities and human rights violations, and are completely subservient to the whims of the United States and transnational capital.

    It's been said that Mexico's great curse is to be next to the United States. Let's just hope that one day Mexicans manage to shake the twin boots on their necks, that of Uncle Sam, and of their own uber corrupt elites - maybe then they can have peace in their country.

    Zapata vive!

  • Chris1

    2 years ago

    Murder City

    I feel like crying at this story.
    It is not about drug lords, or drugs or criminals.
    It is about this disconnected world.
    A world where people feel getting high is the only way to feel good.
    A world where you must all have granite counter tops, stainless steel apppliances and fit in.

  • YCSTS

    2 years ago

    The Drug War is a SCAM to pad pockets of Vested Interests

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fNrtdNwyZuA

    http://www.americandrugwar.com/

    Make no mistake about it, the Drug War is Big Money for Politicians & their benefactors. Anyone with even 1/4 of brain, knows it is unbelievable STUPIDITY. But, nowadays, the only thing that counts is HOW MUCH CASH DO MYSELF & MY BUDDIES MAKE ON THIS?

  • swami99

    2 years ago

    Decriminalize Now!

    Duh! So decriminalize drugs, and they won't be imported.

    Obama - the "enlightened one" - sees fit to continue Bush's usurpatious attacks on US State legislation on medical use of narcotics. He did nothing to assist Marc Emery.

    Note - few activists favour legalization of narcotics. Most want reactive data on labels. That is why they speak of de-criminalization. They want psycho-reactive drugs under the food, drug and pharmacological acts and regulations. Law enforcement wants status quo because: drug arrests are easy, and enable easy reach of the low quotas set by law enforcement entities. The work product of the average Canadian cop is: 1 convicted person per month, and one incarceration - beyond holds for remand - per year. Most drug cases take less than an hour to process. Do that once a month, and they spend the rest of the month parked behind buildings, pretending to work. Canadians need to know why our worthless police services, consistently get over 80% popular support. They should receive 99% opposition.

  • RickW

    2 years ago

    Mustafarian

    Quote:
    The overwhelming profits for the cartels are in cocaine sales in the US

    Kinda says it all. The "soft" image presented for the digestion by us middle class wienies is of some crazed homeless person breaking into our houses and stealing our jewels and rolexes so he can shoot up -- when all the time it is the owners of the jewels and rolexes who are the ones who can afford the stuff pouring into the US from Mexico, Columbia, Canada, Afghanistan.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.