Who Crowned Gordo?
Our premier acts like Louis the Sun King.
Campbell: Royal pain?
(Note: A few weeks ago I was clearly wrong to bring George III into this mess as the following will, I hope, amply demonstrate.)
Louis XIV, the Sun King, the last European king to exercise total power, is reincarnated, alive and well in Victoria. He and Russia's Vladimir Putin have one thing in common -- they think they're the only mortals on the planet who can handle public affairs. The public may sometimes be heard but never, for God's sake, listen to them!
Consider the power now in the Sun King's hands. All municipal power is ultimately wielded in Victoria. Any project His Majesty's friends want to undertake, no matter how much the people who will have to live with it object, will be approved without any interference from tiresome councils.
The power of Metro Vancouver (formerly the Greater Vancouver Regional District) to run Transit within its boundaries has been gutted and transferred to friends of the King. This unelected, unaccountable new transit authority will have wide ranging powers to raise money from taxpayers who have nothing to say about it. Where have we heard "no taxation without representation" before?
Louis XIV controls the environmental assessment process in that he gets to choose the guy who runs it. It comes as no surprise then that environmental assessment is started after the deal is done. The present process has no power to stop a project, only to make the best of it. Such projects as the Sea-to-Sky highway very much including the Eagleridge desecration, the South Fraser Perimeter Road and the Deltaport expansion gave no chance to the people who live in these areas to express an opinion before the deal was cooked.
All hail the untouchable one
The Agricultural Land Reserve poses only a token problem when His Majesty decides that his government would be fine with seeing the land developed, especially if it might help swing a deal with an Indian band.
There is of course the understanding that the King can do no wrong. He can be thrown into jail in lands across the sea without any loss of power at home. Members of his court, however, can be banished for writing a nasty letter.
Our beloved monarch can sell our property, like BC Rail, call it a lease, and account to no one.
The next move will be when our Sun King grants rights to WestPac out of Calgary to build an LNG plant on Texada Island so that they can sell gas into the American market with the huge safety and environmental risks being borne by local residents. Incidentally, the King must know that no American state on the Pacific coast will take this highly dangerous plant -- dangerous not only as a plant but supplied by dangerous tankers.
Let them eat farmed fish
With all the elected tyranny we've seen, none can compare to the arrogance shown by King Louis on the Atlantic salmon farms issue. From the outset the King has denied all problems in the face of overwhelming independent scientific evidence. Report after report have been issued outlining a host of environmental problems, all of them serious, including the devastating attacks by sea lice from the cages on migrating pink and chum salmon smolts. Eighteen world class scientists wrote to the premier, oops! I mean, His Majesty last fall begging him to understand the problem and make the farms move from the path of migrating salmon smolts and he hasn't deigned to reply.
Last month, the following article appeared in the Vancouver Sun, after first appearing in the Victoria Times-Colonist, usually committed royalist papers incidentally, which reflected reports in virtually every English speaking media story in the world -- making British Columbia look like a bunch of idiots in the bargain.
Here's the story based on the release of a paper by Martin Krkosek and Alexandra Morton published in the highly regarded Journal of Science. Headline: "Fish farms to blame for possible wild salmon extinction: study." Published on Dec. 13, 2007, reporter Scott Simpson wrote:
"A groundbreaking scientific study has today established for the first time a large-scale and deadly link between fish farms and sea lice infestations that threatens to wipe out entire populations of wild Pacific salmon."An article to be published in Friday's edition of Science, one of the world's foremost scientific journals, says wild pink salmon runs on the British Columbia central coast will be extinct in as little as four years because of a cluster of salmon farms that are creating lethal infestations of sea lice in that area. [emphasis added]
"The article's authors, including University of Alberta researcher Martin Krkosek and B.C.'s Alexandra Morton, looked at 37 years' worth of Fisheries and Oceans data for 71 central coast rivers and found that wild pink runs have comfortably withstood decades of commercial fishing -- but cannot survive fish farms. [emphasis added]
"'What we have seen is a very rapid four year decline in the pink salmon populations in the Broughton,' Krkosek said in an interview earlier this week.
"'Based on that measured rate of decline, which is real, we can expect that in another four years those fish will be all gone if the sea lice infestations continue. [emphasis added]
"'Sea lice hyper-concentrate around the farms and spread to wild salmon migrating in the vicinity of the farms. The lice may not be lethal to adult fish, but they're deadly for infant pink salmon making the transition to the ocean from their natal streams. . . .'
"The report says lice infestation rates are 70 times higher among juvenile pink salmon on central coast rivers compared to infestations in fish farm-free areas farther north.
"It also says mortality rates among juvenile pinks infested with sea lice 'is commonly over 80 per cent.'
"'If outbreaks continue, then local extinction is certain, and a 99 per cent collapse in pink salmon abundance is expected in four pink salmon generations,' the article says. [emphasis added]
"The study brings an element of finality to the debate about the threat salmon farms pose to wild fish. It also puts Canada's federal and provincial governments, and the salmon farming industry, at odds with the reigning body of opinion in the global scientific community." [emphasis added]
His Majesty's agriculture Minister, one Patrick Bell, reacted angrily because the Journal of Science didn't inform him first. The King himself hasn't deigned to reply.
Who is the State?
But the verdict is in. Sea Lice from fish farms are destroying our wild salmon while the King acts as if this issue was just some sort of parish pump political game. His supporters use every diversionary ploy possible. They point out that many other things kill the wild salmon smolts and of course that's so. Smolts must deal with predators in the river before they start migration and after; temperatures may kill them; there may be other factors they have to face. No one denies that. The points are these:
- The major problem the tiny migrating pinks and chum, on their way to the ocean, must face is the mass of sea lice surrounding fish farms.
- Of all the hazards in the smolt's journey, the sea lice from the fish cages is the only one we mere mortals can deal with and eliminate.
All the independent, peer-reviewed and published science makes it abundantly clear that it will be the sea lice from caged farm fish that will do the wild fish in. Louis XIV and his Council of Half-Wits simply don't care.
Louis XIV's government is hell bent on destroying our wild salmon and I can only ask this: How soon will King Louis of British Columbia utter the deathless words of his namesake, l'etat, c'est moi? (for the linguistically challenged, "I am the State")
Related Tyee stories:
- Translink Democracy Derailed
Political appointees to replace elected reps. - TransLink Hijacked
How Gordon Campbell stole your vote on region's fate.



95
Login or register to post comments
The brain
4 years ago
Campbell's got to go.
This one issue alone, the seriousness of it, and the way Campbell is doing nothing about it, is reason enough for Campbell's government to fall because it clearly should fall. This liberal government simply needs to be replaced on this one issue alone, never mind their other scandals and blunders.
Its not the economical opportunities Campbell has squandered before this province faces a true logging export recession caused by currency and dramatically slowed U.S. housing starts with Canada's numbers about to follow...
Its not Campbell's selloff of BC gas to Teresen and the sale of BC rail, BC ferries, Hydro, well, BC anything...
This is pacific pink salmon were talking about, here, a species that feeds more than just humans. I really can't think of anything more immoral besides outright aggressive war with other nations as trumping the seriousness of it. Campbell has to go. He's known about the problem since 93', virtually created the problem to begin with, has done nothing... enough is enough.
Campbell quite simply has to go, he's clearly too incompetent or self interested to run this province functionally to kill a wildlife industry in such a pchycopathic way for profit oriented reasons that benefit so few (his friends) at the expense of so many.
I'm ashamed of our premier and have been for some time, but this is different. I'm beginning to believe that Campbell has a phycological condition, that he might have some clear, mental issues that go beyond a lack of morality. His drinking, the divorce, giving into U.S. corporate interests so easily with privatization and scandal surrounding BC rail as well as other scandals, thats one thing, but to have no regard for salmon as its clearly such a large part of the foodchain that feeds so many, to risk it... its sick. We have elected a politician that, if left unchecked, will have created the extinction of wild pink pacific salmon. That's disturbing, folks, if BC voters and media alike, allow this to happen. Campbell, quite simply, has to go!
no1important
4 years ago
Yes Campbell must go but he
Yes Campbell must go but he won't be going anywhere anytime soon. There is no alternative and he is up in the polls even after 'everything' sea lice, ferries, privatizing health care cleaning staff, etc.
it seems people do not care. It is very puzzling to me. Nothing sticks to him.
It also does not help that the NDP has such a weak leader too.
I can't see him losing for a while. It was almost 17 years before the NDP got in again after Dave Barrett and only because of Vanderzalm did the Social Credit lose (aka BC Liberals). People here have to be real mad to elect the NDP but not so much to get rid of them.
Carole James is not a very good speaker and comes across more as a whiner , that bit about putting so many seats aside for women never went over to well, especially too that there are more women than men in the province. It is not the fact that she did this, but the way she did it that pisses people off.
Yes I am a card carrying provincial BC NDP Member. Trust me I am not the only one that wants her gone. I would not doubt if the provincial NDP were to implode and sooner than later.
Unless the Olympics have major over runs and major debt, I really can not see the BC Liberals losing power. Plus for some reason the Conservative Green Party takes votes from the NDP and not the right wing BC Liberals.
Gordo I hate t say will be with us as long as he wants the job and that is sad, really sad unless you are a corporation.
Grumpy
4 years ago
King Campbell......
.......will go down in history as the worst premier we ever had, kept in power by a corrupt media.
Jeffrey J.
4 years ago
Perfect Analogy
Well done Rafe. Let's open our history books and read about kingly centralized power, court intrigue and contempt for commoners. While Rafe has borrowed heavily from the French nobility, I prefer the English era of Charles Dickens. Either will do just fine. If one hasn't read up on the tone of life back then, I highly recommend it.
We have entered a very dangerous era of virtual omnipotence, contempt for democracy, and self aggrandizement. These eras have occurred repeatedly in the past, with awful consequences for everyone but the tiny group of elites who ruled England, France and Spain.
The history of the Western world is the long struggle to rid society of a tiny number of rulers. Much blood was spilt in the process, in the hopes that NEVER again would society be ruled by the few. And now, we are rushing headlong back into centralized, undemocratic abuse of power. Campbell, Harper, Bush. Private meetings with corporate CEO's. Contempt for unions and working people. Destruction of social programs. Eradication of nature. Extermination of wild salmon. All in the name of corporate monopoly.
Our forefathers and mothers would be appalled.
Thank you again Tyee and Rafe Mair.
Gary
4 years ago
As a former MLA...
Raif, I assume you know a little more about the constitution than the rest of us. Is there not something in there that would have a government removed before their term. I am talking about involving the Lieutenant Governor and/or the Governor General. I saw something there but didn't quite understand it with all the legaleze gobbledy-gook.
mobius113
4 years ago
Not enough articles of this kind
I enjoyed reading this article, but am dissapointed that I don't see more of them. I know our media is probably on par with the media from the reich in the late 1930's, but with the internet, I thought there would be more out there.
The sad part is, this King is actually elected and I don't see an end to his tyranny.
I think Rafe could have carried on a lot more with the things our povincial liberal party has decimated from our province. In fact you could probably write a book about the underhanded and seedy dealing he's done over the past decade.
The depressing part is he will get away with what he's done and will also prove that the politicians are always above the law. We will see this in the Basi, Basi Virk trial that no one will ever hear about it with the exeption of the internet or a short 20 second statement in one of our reich owned media..
freebear
4 years ago
Too bad he is not a Benevolent King!
No surprise here!
When the author says :
"Louis XIV controls the environmental assessment process in that he gets to choose the guy who runs it. It comes as no surprise then that environmental assessment is started after the deal is done. The present process has no power to stop a project, only to make the best of it. Such projects as the Sea-to-Sky highway very much including the Eagleridge desecration, the South Fraser Perimeter Road and the Deltaport expansion gave no chance to the people who live in these areas to express an opinion before the deal was cooked."
Sounds like how First Nations have been treated for the last 200 years!
murdock
4 years ago
Nothing new...
Rafe,
Your views are well expressed and while many may agree with them, where is / are the alternative(s)?
Are you not mentioning the total lack of a plan from the Non-Democratic Party?
Once again, we are collectively sleep-walking towards a 'toss the bastards out' election run. One that will not 'toss them out' in the coming run in 2009, certainly if the NDP continues to be the non-presence and not giving any alternative policies to what is going on in Gordo's game.
So far I would not want the NDP back in governance, only to watch what little building business activity that we have here in BC flee to Alberta.
What is really needed is an alternative to the NDP, one that actually will present that credible alternative to the BC Liberals.
Raise the bar, stop looking to just 'throw the bastards out', and look to actually elect a future.
IF the current choice is what I have to select from, then Gordo's gang looks like a 2 in a sea of 0.00003's.
Skywalker
4 years ago
Right on Rafe, but how did we get here.
I can still remember the hundreds of consultative processes that marked the 90's. It seemed that every time you turned around there was another government agency asking for your input. There were land use forums, treaty forums ad nauseum. Still with all that consultation everyone seemed "grumpy". So here we are. The NDP were not perfect but based on this piece one hell of a lot better than this bunch. You'd never have known it though listening to current crop who all seemed content to trample over the political corpses of the 90's to achieve the "larger opposition". Some achievement.
I suspect that it will take 19 years of Campbell because the strategy seems to be to get the public to forget what the Carole James leadership confirmed by their election strategy. I still see the same stategy at work.
None of the NDP Premiers were as arrogant as Campbell. None of them usurped local authority. None of them wasted as much in the value of BC resources as Campbell. Not even Glen Clark.
Part of me thinks that this is what BC deserves, the best democracy money can buy , but then I remember I am in this mess as well.
Van Isle
4 years ago
Thanks for the article Rafe.
Thanks for the article Rafe. Just more proof that our democracy is a myth which is propagated by our mass-media, spin doctors (professional liars) and politians.
murdock
4 years ago
Not the sun king, more Il Duce
I have just listened to the 'announcement' of funding for transit initiatives throughout BC.
This is something that would have, at best, been announced by the Transportation Minister; or even more likely been done by a simple letter or memorandum issued from the Transportation Ministers office.
The whole hoo-ha of the Premier announcing this with a crew of Mayors and MLAs golf clapping made me think of one thing:
"...at least he made the trains run on time."
Sorry to say but this is total overkill for such a thing as this public works plan and an opposite to the view of 'saving or paying down debt' during 'good times' and taking out loans to 'spur' economic activity in 'bad times'.
Carol Taylor is a lame duck Finance Minister and now the Premier and Transportation Ministries are spending like drunken sailors.
bilgladstone
4 years ago
Autocratic rule
Perhaps it has escaped your notice that this is happening all over the place; think GW Bush, Stephen Harper et al. - there is nothing unique, special, or different about the way our Premier is behaving.
In this era, when manners, honour, respect, gentlemanliness and genuine public interest are no longer predominant, our antique electoral systems are truly dysfunctional. The notion of meagre "checks and balances" limiting the incumbents' power to act unilaterally is now clearly seen as the myth it always was.
There is only one way to control this lunacy: electoral reform.
The first priority of the citizenry must be to repair the system that permits oligarchical, dynastic rule. The stagnation, favouring special interest, and unwillingness to consider public opinion will continue as long as we permit it.
Status Quo will not answer any of the challenges the world faces: environmental disaster, homelessness and poverty, war and hunger - any of it.
This is why the Party that gets my vote from now on will be whichever one most strongly supports electoral reform - some form of proportional representation.
Because without actual representation of all our opinions, the current cadre of self-interested "elites" will continue this, as you call it, monarchical rule.
from Kelowna, BC
Frank
4 years ago
murdock
You guys won't be getting a new right-wing party for the foreseeable future so by all means keep voting for Gordon while proclaiming you're "forced" to do it.
Its actually pretty funny.
Frank
4 years ago
"Forced"
By the way, I'm only voting NDP because of the lack of choice we have politically. If there was a party that ran the province democratically and with a conscience I'd switch to them in a heartbeat but since all we have are the semi-literate Liberals and the privatize-it-all Greens I'm forced to vote NDP.
jericho beach
4 years ago
El Gordo
I agree with the king metaphor Raif uses, however, I also see Sinclair Lewis' 'Elmer Gantry' alive in those 'crazed' eyes of Wee Gordie...
from the Literary Encyclopedia,
"Elmer Gantry is the story of a young roughneck who abandons his early ambition to become a lawyer and embarks on a career in the ministry. The opening sentence of the novel, “Elmer Gantry was drunk”, introduces one of Lewis's least likeable protagonists. While an undergraduate in an obscure denominational college, Elmer discovers that he loves to be the center of attention. While he is drunk one day in a small town near the college, he is lead to defend a classmate who is preaching on a street corner. Elmer beats up an irreverent heckler and then says a few words in support of religion. From that point on, the classmate and members of the faculty identify Elmer as a candidate for the ministry and try to convert him. In spite of the fact that he is tempted by the social position the ministry would offer, Elmer resists because he does not feel “the call” to preach, but at a crucial point he is converted, more by the power of raw whiskey than by his faith. After graduation, he moves on to a Baptist seminary.
Elmer is ordained a Baptist minister and licensed to preach after two years in the seminary, but he fails to graduate when he is dismissed after seducing a young woman and going on a drunken spree. He channels his power of persuasion into a secular field, selling farm implements, but he misses the attention that he received as a preacher. His chance to return to preaching comes when he meets Sharon Falconer, a successful itinerant evangelist. Elmer serves as her manager and becomes her lover but loses both her and his position when her new tabernacle is destroyed by a fire which kills Sharon."
Skywalker
4 years ago
Murdoch
There are some concerns on the horizon that the U.S economy is in serious trouble and the word "recession" is being used. It is only a matter of time before the BC bubble bursts. When it does, will you be as quick to blame Gordo as you were to give him credit when with higher world commodity prices, increased federal transfers, service fee increases and cuts to education he claimed that he single-handedly turned the economy around?
Frank is right. It actually is pretty funny>
morechatter
4 years ago
Its Corporate Campbell
And he's their King of Wheeling and Dealing with public funds and holdings as one deal after another aiding his Corporate pales at the expense of the his public. The announcement of BILLIONS being spent on rapid transit before the next election is no surprise as many can't even afford fares because they don't make enough money to survive speaks volumes on how Campbell feels about his peasants. Wasn't it governments job to protect citizens against greedy corporate interests?
LuckyGuy
4 years ago
Not exactly sustainable...
In the past year I have written, on two occasions, to my MLA Colin Hansen with copies to Barry Penner, Minister of the Environment, Kevin Kreuger, Chair of the Natural Resources and Economy Caucus committee, and Premier Gordon Campbell, politely asking them to reconsider or justify their Government's position on open-pen salmon farming, in light of the mounting evidence. I have not yet received even an acknowledgement, much less a reply. Its apparent that this government would rather pay lip service to the trendy issue of the day - sustainability & global warming - while ignoring the actual tragic damage to the ecosystem that they are accelerating by allowing the destruction of the wild salmon.
Eddy Haskel
4 years ago
We crowned King Gordo when
We crowned King Gordo when we allowed him to escape unscratched from his drinking/driving debacle. The PR that surrounds the man pales even the Exxon Valdese oil spill. And because we all lap it up like good little serfs it is only fitting that we get a government that doesn't give a shiii about us. Keep voting for them. The pennies you recieve for the loonies they steal are what keeps the average guy hypnotized into accepting a very shabby legislature performance from a crew whose only concern is themselves. BC's new motto should read Bring Cash.
Kam Lee
4 years ago
gordo - bad king
Raif,
Congrats again on a great article. This ahole and his band over followers are a huge problem. They do not think, they react to the C.D.A. and his wishes. Remeber this, if the Virk, Basi, Virk ever get to trial, his name will surface. Then lets see the double speak, the passing of the buck, and such. I wonder how kingly he will feel in jail? (Convicted D Abuser)
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Bigger Plans...
Right on Rafe...!!
It is unbelievable that one person has been responsible for selling out the fragile eco-systems on the West Coast. We all must have been sleeping to have allowed this to happen. He's brutal, but the people are a majority, so why are we not acting like a majority? Anyways, it is not because Campbell has a hard-on for wild salmon...No...they are just obstacles to weave around. It is because he has "bigger" plans.
Alex Morton, a lady, a warrior, and the one who volunteered to be the pointy end of the sword on this devastating issue wrote this:
Thank Alex. We are with you in this fight.
Peace,
Bear
rjm
4 years ago
who crowned gordo?
the welfare bums in ivory towers in new york city... that's who. (surprise;)
i can hardly wait to see what debauchery is involved in this latest multi-billion dollar round of (no doubt) p-3 plunder-governance.
btw, where is carole james... is she still a resident of british columbia?
has she left planet earth?
wtf indeed.
tks,
rjm
lynn
4 years ago
Louis XIV and His Council of Half-Wits
Louis XIV's government is hell bent on destroying our wild salmon...
What a tragedy. Thanks for all your work on this, Alexandra and Rafe.
Great comments.
What arrogance continually being displayed by this government.....what utter lack of any real kind of intelligence, foresight, compassion, or humanity has held sway over this province for so long now.
The brain, I agree, Gordo's got to go.... yesterday.
And you nailed it, Bear, no doubt, there are "bigger plans" in the works....once again man and nature are just "obstacles" in the way of the business plan of The Province of BC Real Estate Company.
I heard that bad King G. just turned sixty....and still not an ounce of wisdom in him.
Sometimes you feel like giving up when you read about the devious stuff the King and his Half-Wit Court have been up to. It helps to remember there are people like this still carrying on:
In Powell River there is a group of men affectionately known as the "Bloody Old Men's Brigade" or B.O.M.B Squad. They are a group of men, retirees that range in age from sixty years old to....well... into their eighties.
They are volunteers (who have come to be good friends) and who rain or shine and with the blessing of the Forest Service, have over the years quietly and with little fanfare cleared trails and built wonderful wooden bridges (works of art, really) deep in the forest here so that others could more easily wander and hike through our coastal woods.
Their touch to the forest floor has been exquisitely tender for "a bomb squad" - they pack everything in and out themselves. They labour for free, often with worn-out tools, and are a delightful anarchistically organized group made up of millworkers, engineers, surveyors, tradesmen, a medical doctor. Their work and their genuine respect for the natural world much appreciated by so many of us who enjoy the outdoors.
Moat
4 years ago
Ok, the salmon are in trouble.
Rafe wrote:
Yeah, but what do we do?
I have stopped buying the farmed stuff from the grocery store. Safeway and Superstore still sell it. My friends still serve it to me during visits (and of course I eat it) because they would not understand my refusal to eat farmed fish and it would not be worth the social cost. As well, things would eventually turn to my red meat eating habits.
How do we effectively get people to care about the salmon of the Broughton?
Do writing and sending "form" letters actually work?
doggone
4 years ago
Kings and fish
Rafe agrees with me (or I with him) so he has done his part. However, as MOAT says: "How do we effectively get people to care...?"
Apparently we won't. Most BCers are busy "eating cake" since they lack bread.
You gotta respect Gordon and his mini Harper/Bush settup - it works like a charm!
Votes are gotten
Plebes are (well if not happy) comfortable.
Very few think at all and those who do get confused
"The best lack all conviction..........
doggone
4 years ago
How long does it take you boneheads to post
Or have I been banned for some unknown violation.
Very occassionally Rafe piques my interest. Otherwise thetyee seems to be wandering off into "Starf===er" heaven
See ya later
G West
4 years ago
doggone
You've run afoul of the rating system.
Go back to the end of the story - any story - and select the ALL COMMENTS tab. Your post will reappear.
Every time you sign out the software defaults to the 'BEST COMMENTS' version and you only make that list if the powers that be decide your comment deserves it.
You haven't been around for a while - this new deal fools a lot of people until the realize if you want the whole enchilada you have to stick with the ALL COMMENTS version - nearly everyone does - the BEST COMMENTS track is often pretty lonely!
Glad to see you back.
rousseau
4 years ago
gordo's only the best
gordo's only the best premier since wac. while the ndp are, as usual, stuck in the mud or out counting potholes, the libs are moving forward and preparing for future growth and progress. it's easy to whine when you don't have any ideas yourself. what a sad bunch. and will their new saviour, mr. robertson, now abandon them for the mayor's seat?
rousseau
4 years ago
as for your question mr.
as for your question mr. mair; the electorate crowned gordo in two consecutive elections and will undoubtedly do so again for a third time.
Frank
4 years ago
Elliot et al
Lib supporters loved it when Campbell made cuts to health and children. Told us that's why they voted Lib, because they weren't big spenders.
Yet when they decide to embark on huge spending plans over decades they support that too, call him the greatest premier ever.
When transit fares go up the Rightees declare its a good thing because they love "user pay".
When people don't use transit because its too expensive they tell us transit is a waste and the money should be spent on wider roads and more bridges because people want to drive cars.
Now we will get the worst case possible, we'll break the bank building a huge transit system that many people its supposed to be for can't afford to ride. And the Rightees will cheer that too.
Frank
4 years ago
Carol James
James has not been completely invisible, she wrote this for the Province on the subject of a carbon tax.
http://www.canada.com/theprovince/news/editorial/story.html?id=464ba875-4ec8-4d13-acb8-3bb30c97737b
zalm
4 years ago
And today...
And now a multi-billion-dollar transit plan worthy of Eisenhower, on a budget worthy of Ken Lay.
Has he actually run this by anyone, or is someone going tohave to rescue his hide again?
morechatter
4 years ago
King Campbell proclaims billions
for the environment by buying billions of dollars worth of transit. How is that going to help the environment when most families will continue to shop and drag their kids in their cars because like how else do you get around take transit? Not happening. So how is that going to help the environment you say well hey taken a 3 hour bus ride lately? Not likely. I can hear it all now as the King speaks, "This government is especially committed to the environment". Its so committed that billions of dollars are to be spent on transit the very same transit where buses where cut back not to long after this government came into power something to do with supply and demand. Its pretty dishearting when you know these Billions will have little effect or no effect at all on the environment while jacking up the prices eluding those who really need to take transit while the environment is left to chance.
loblollyboy
4 years ago
Choking on Grapes, Swallowing Watermelons
For years, I have wondered at the harsh double standard in BC where we happily accept bad governance daily from the party of the corporate elite (currently the BC Liberals) that we wouldn't tolerate once a year from the NDP. What gives with that?
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Spheres of Influence...
Moat said:
Hi Moat,
Good question... I would say, as good as anything else. I can tell you however, what doesn't work, and that is to do nothing. We need to look at it like it was really OUR salmon that is being killed. OUR coasts that are being raped and pillaged. It has to get personal, real personal, before we can make good decisions on how best to approach this issue affecting all of us, and all our children to come. Is it personal to you?
The Nuxalk people went to Calgary a couple years ago all dressed in their regalia and stuck "Farmed and Dangerous" stickers on all the packaged farm salmon in Safeway and protested with signs outside. They did this because as "The Salmon People", it was personal. Did it work...? Safeway still sells farmed salmon, but if enough of the general public took the loss of the wild salmon as personal as the Nuxalk did, I think we could turn this thing around. We all are responsible to our "spheres of influence" and within those spheres we all can be impacting...
Cheers,
Bear
G West
4 years ago
Province oped
Thanks for that Frank - I thought the comments were interesting - nice to see that Jean-Jacques Elliot gets around. Not a big surprise he 'reads' the Province.
The Neanderthals around here and there still don't understand laws of general application OR the concept of equity and fairness.
Cycling Commuter
4 years ago
Blue Greens vs NDP
for some reason the Conservative Green Party takes votes from the NDP and not the right wing BC Liberals.
That's because a lot of directly self-employed people and people working for small, employee-owned companies are interested in Green issues such as the local economy, preventive healthcare, the environment etc. They never did like the way the NDP always has been and always will be in the pockets of union bosses. Light blue greens held their noses and voted for the NDP anyway. Now there's a Green alternative for small businesses.
The Chinese government recently admitted that birth defects have doubled in their country within the past 6 years due to increasing industrial pollution.
Meanwhile, the NDP plan is to give subsidized below market cost energy to unionized industries and charge ongoing capital taxes on energy-conservation equipment. It would make more sense to eliminate sales taxes and ongoing capital taxes (including municipal taxes) on residential, commercial and industrial energy conservation equipment, allow an instant Capital Cost Allowance write-off of such equipment, provide low-interest, long-amortization loans for said equipment, then charge full market price for energy plus a pollution tax on top of that.
Frank
4 years ago
Cycling Commuter
Actually, many in the NDP talk of doing similar things. You're comparing NDP policy from the 70's with Green policy now.
Conservative-Liberal policy has been to ignore the environment and develop the tar sands, refuse to put money into anything remotely green except photo-ops and so on. However, even they have people talking about doing things differently.
The difference is that they are beholden to business, and thus their hands are somewhat tied.
If and when the Greens ever form a provincial government it'll be interesting to see how many, if any, of their green policies actually come to fruition. And who will pay for it. My own guess is it won't be their friends in the business community. I expect their libertarian sympathies will take money from health and children and put it into helping business adapt.
Not something the NDP would do and which should give clear-eyed people the ability to decide who best represents them.
catlady
4 years ago
Gordo the Sun King
Yes, I agree with no1important. Those of us who are so apathetic must have blinders on. We need more people to join the NDP and vote in a new leader. Carole James does not have the clout necessary to take down the King.
Instead of the mobster 'Teflon Don', our leader could be called 'Lord Gordo the Grease'
Gary
4 years ago
On topic
I think a good read along with this column might be at http://www.kootenayactivist.ca
Scrool to "the Big Lie". Corky tells about a chance meeting with a political adversary. Whomever this person is he sure has a grasp on the Campbell administration.
rousseau
4 years ago
frank and gwest; not sure
frank and gwest; not sure why you continue to call me elliot, but i'm assuming you think it's b/c i used to post under that moniker. not true. i did, however, read that link to the teacher's diaries that you provided the other day mr. west, and learned that you used to post under another name and support your own arguments with your other handle. well done. very ethical. i wouldn't cast too many stones if i lived in your glass house sir.
realisticman
4 years ago
Can't win
Frank
Don't worry Frank, as you said a couple of months ago, "Lots of things pay for themselves if given enough time. The Fast Ferries would have too if they hadn't been sold off by Campbell for peanuts."
refedmel
4 years ago
Sun god
Canada and its subordinate governments in the provinces are all established oligarchies - any canadian citizen that expects 'democracy' is getting just that - the rule of the majority or 'mobocracy'. This mob is unwitting as it is manipulated into putting all governments into an omnipotent position between elections - The BC Refederation Party would end that with a Swiss model of direct democracy which gives the people the last say in all legislation - a process that requires a double majority that removes centres like Vancouver from dominating the province - like carbon taxes to pay for lowermainland assets.
G West
4 years ago
rousseau
Another similarity between you and elliot is the fact that you never do anything BUT make personal and ad hominem remarks , vilify the BCTF and unions generally (Ginny Simms was his favourite target and David Beers a strong second place)- without ever actually contributing something to the conversation of a substantive nature.
Elliot used at least five labels serially when he was here, a couple of them before I ever made a single post. You can refer to Frank for that information because he’s another one who was always getting dumped on by Elliot – using more or less the same bad spelling, poor grammar and syntax.
Elliot did much the same sort of thing all the time.
As I said, I'm inordinately proud of the contribution I made during the year in question - so bring it up as often as you want to.
It was especially useful when dealing with the kind of bullying behavior I used to run across here at Tyee almost on a daily basis. Most of those trolls have left – I’m not at all sorry to have seen the back of them.
Frank
4 years ago
Who me?
I didn't call you Elliot, you just assumed that. I did notice though that you even post at the same time of day as Elliot. Same hours, same grammar, same spelling, same nicknames for other posters, same strong opinions on the same subjects. All just a coincidence.
Frank
4 years ago
Realisticman
Assuming you sincerely believe what I write, do you believe that?
Frank
4 years ago
Awash in money
Since it has turned out that our old right-wing friends were wrong, and we actually appear to have 14 billion for spending I propose a different tack than the one put forward by our illustrious premier.
I called to see how much it would cost to convert my truck to propane. About $3,000. So that means for a measly 3 billion Gordon could have converted a million cars in the GVRD to propane. Anyone with a car too old to make that conversion worthwhile could receive the same amount of money towards getting a new hybrid or something.
It would reduce our CO2 output more than Gordon's plan and at only about 20% of the cost and without forcing people to change their lives.
What to do with that other 11 billion we'd still have left over?
The $2.75 billion Translink is putting into this would be better spent on reducing fares so that people will actually have an incentive to use transit when possible. I'd make it free but that's just me.
Money could be used to help people switch their homes and businesses to a variety of greeny ideas like on-demand hot water, heat pumps, geo-thermal etc.
We'd probably reduce our carbon footprint more than building skytrains people don't leave their cars to ride.
Or the savings could go into all the things the Rightees keep telling us there's no money for like child care, training more doctors, keeping operating rooms open for more hours per year, providing low-rent housing etc.
rousseau
4 years ago
frankwest; speaking of
frankwest; speaking of posting at the same time...
also, it sounds like you spend far too much time here. i wonder what you intend to accomplish by arguing with anonymous cyberspacers 24/7. you must have a public sector union job to have that kind of time to waste.
Frank
4 years ago
Elliot-boy
Elliot always posted just before 11pm too Jean-Jacques. Just pointing that out, don't get all bitchy about it.
As for me, I've said what I do about a kajillion times and have also said I haven't been connected to a union of any sort in decades.
You on the other hand, like many other Rightees, have always been shy about saying what you do which has led me to believe you guys do nothing at all.
Frank
4 years ago
Nemesis
I post here because you read what I write Jean-Jacques.
Thanks
rousseau
4 years ago
the problem with the extreme
the problem with the extreme left in this province is that they disagree with everything that the libs do on principle. ultimately that is what will sink the ndp b/c at least 90% of lower mainlanders will agree that our transit system MUST be improved. even the suzuki spokesman lauded yesterday's announcement b/c it makes sense at many levels.
Frank
4 years ago
Big spending right-wingers
And in the 1990's the extreme Right disagreed vehemently with everything the NDP did.
rousseau
4 years ago
so did everyone else.
so did everyone else.
happy
4 years ago
he's right Frank
77 - 2 wasn't just "extreme" right-ees
Frank
4 years ago
No, it was always the same
No, it was always the same Right-wing voices, over and over. The ones who never seem to have trouble finding a pulpit.
But go on believing 90% of the people in this province want Campbell's transit plan. I'm sure self-delusion works as well as prozac, and its cheaper to boot.
Frank
4 years ago
Unhappy
So Canada stopped believing in conservative values when the Tories were reduced to just 2 seats across all of Canada?
Interesting, yet only a little more than a decade later they formed the federal government.
The NDP popular vote was almost as high as the Socreds last election, does that mean more than half the province were unhappy with Socred policies?
Frank
4 years ago
Happy-redux
Or perhaps it means the "extreme" Left makes up almost half the province? Interesting.
happy
4 years ago
Franko
Frank says
"The NDP popular vote was almost as high as the Socreds last election, does that mean more than half the province were unhappy with Socred policies"
I don't know Frank. The Lib popular vote was higher than the NDP in the Clark election. Using your logic they should have won, no?
rousseau
4 years ago
sorry frankie-boy. saying
sorry frankie-boy. saying it's true doesn't make it so. the libs continue to dominate the polls. 50% to 32% and holding fairly steady. and that's between elections. considering that the ndp ALWAYS have their traditional 30% support b/c the union leaders tell their charges who to vote for, you have to admit that you don't have much of a chance for some time to come. then you have to ask yourself why. if you need the answer just let me know.
Frank
4 years ago
Happy=math genius
Hey Happy, you know there's more than two parties that contest elections in BC, right?
Frank
4 years ago
Elliot
Yes, but we were talking about actual elections. I didn't see you guys talking about polls so neither did I.
And in rousseau-world the people in unions do exactly what their leadership says. They never waver.
In Frank-world people who work for non-union companies all vote for the Socreds because that's what their bosses tell them to do. All those non-union workers don't have minds of their own after all.
I've actually told you why before Nemesis but since you insist on continuing this charade I'll make you happy and say its because the population is not as left-wing as the NDP. We live in a capitalist country next to a massive capitalist country and thus most people hear just the one message from the time they're born till the time they die.
Values such as greed are instilled in our society and that is not going to change in the near future.
The only reason NDP ideas like pensions, medicare, welfare and unemployment insurance are policies now is because people can see how they will benefit from it and the business community believes they're necessary to buy societal peace.
Frank
4 years ago
Happy again
Yes, and you believe it was right that they didn't?
Frank
4 years ago
Happy
By the way happy, you decided not to answer this question, why?
happy
4 years ago
Frank again
A lot of posters here say there is no difference between the Libs and Cons. Do you?
So Canadians didn't really stop believing in conservative values. Your argument would make more sense if you substituted NDP for Lib
And no, I don't believe it was right (the Clark election results) We agree on that
Frank
4 years ago
Happy
Yes, their differences are not ideological.
I assume that means you agree with me that Libs and Cons are the same thing? If not, you wouldn't try to make that point.
And on that point, would you prefer a new voting system which would reflect the popular vote more than FPTP does?
happy
4 years ago
Frank
"And on that point, would you prefer a new voting system which would reflect the popular vote more than FPTP does?"
I don't honestly care. The results will be more or less the same over the long run. The problem with changing the system, is the alternatives that have been proposed are more complicated than the present system, and for the average person, making something more complicated is not considered an improvement. Just my opinion.
Frank
4 years ago
Happy
You never answered my question as to whether you think the Libs and Cons are the same thing. As your point seems dependent on your answer.
So complexity should therefore be avoided as the results would tend to be the same anyway? Although I doubt any party would be reduced to 2 seats again.
happy
4 years ago
Frank
Libs and Cons the same? In many ways yes. I respect Paul Martin for the work he did as Finance Minister, too bad he reverted to Old School politics when he became PM - as in spend the surplus faster than its coming in. Look where it got him.
As for the complexity thing, I didn't say it should be avoided. I just said, in my opinion only, this could be a reason why the general public might be resistant to wholesale change.
Frank
4 years ago
Happy
So since you agree that they're the same I will say no, conservative values were not rejected when the Cons were reduced to two seats as people could vote for Chretien and get the same policies anyway.
In BC the Cons don't even exist as a real party, they aren't needed as the Libs are already here. Due to the strength of the NDP, it would just cause problems if the Right was divided.
On the issue of simplicity when it comes to politics, we have that now. BC is pretty much a one-party state. The existence of the NDP is all that allows this province to be called a democracy. If the NDP went away tomorrow very little would change.
The NDP have only been elected 3 times, once was a fluke due to the electoral system. The only other times was when the natural governing party had pissed so many people off they lost the votes of their own supporters. The existence of the NDP provided a way of forcing the natural governing party to take a time-out and get a new leader, that is all. It wasn't NDP policies that got them elected. They don't even need to have policies to win or lose elections as people don't care. (Which is why I always tell Working Man he doesn't understand the political system and Carol James does)
Most people on the Right have no real ideology, they will simply repeat the mantra of their leader, whoever he may be. If he's a big spender, then so are they, if he's a tax-cutter, so are they. Like those in Orwell's 1984 they will claim after changing their mind to match their leader that that is what they have always believed.
What passes for ideology is simply a rejection of anything the NDP supports.
happy
4 years ago
last post Frank
cause I think we're guilty of thread drift. This supposed to be about King Gordo. But before I go, I have to say I agree with practically everything you say in your previous post!
Cheers
lynn
4 years ago
Superficial environmentalism
I think if Al Gore is able to say how wonderful it is that a leader like Premier Gordon Campbell will be able to dazzle the world with his "green" environment during the 2010 Olympics, then I think it's time Mr. Gore did more effective research on who he pats on the back. Especially if real progress in addressing these environmentally desperate times is really going to happen. (Due to the policies of this government we have thousands of felled trees inside a watershed reserve near where I live, and absolutely no action by this government has been taken over the public's serious concerns over this excessive logging....and the threat to our water quality.)
Gore should know the kind of environmentalism he is championing by patting politicians like Campbell on the back. So yesterday we sent Rafe's Tyee article on "King Gordo" off to Al Gore, including the comments....noting that because of the arrogant and so-called environmental policies of the Campbell government 2010 may instead ring the death knell for one one of the most wonderful species on earth - the wild salmon. Let's hope Mr. Gore reads it.
Now if environmental groups would just stop shmoozing with guys like Campbell and his self-interested supporters, ( and with governments everywhere that are intent on merely acting the environmental part through the easier sell of an environmental image rather than the real thing)....if here in BC, environmental groups would just refuse to participate with a BCLiberal government that has clearly shown over the years that it has no regard for "the wild and the beautiful" in what used to be "wild and beautiful BC" - we and the natural world around us just may stand a chance of making it through this.
DPL
4 years ago
(50% to 32% and holding
(50% to 32% and holding fairly steady. and that's between elections. considering that the ndp ALWAYS have their traditional 30% support b/c the union leaders tell their charges who to vote for.) These sort of wild statements are simply not factual. I was in two unions as a elected director. The constitutions of both forbid any money going to a particular party, nobody told anyone who to vote for. Let's face it unless someone goes into the booth to force you vote one way or the other. And since no one goes into that botth, only the voter knows who he or she is supporting.
Dislike the NDP as much as you like as a voter but please make some sense of your statments.
Some folks try to ge a different voting system and other folks from all parties argue no change. In my view Gordon Campbell is a pawn of business and if the folks keep voting for him, the province will soon run out of things to sell
Frank
4 years ago
DPL
Oh, its just Elliot, he's always saying stuff like that. I remember on here at the time of the last election (before his "Elliot" days actually, he was "Nemesis" then, he said the very same thing over and over.
Don't worry, no one actually believes that stuff except Elliot himself and the Rightees that live in bizarro-world.
NRF
4 years ago
Surprise?
We cannot be surprised to experience a regal Premier - again. Our party system and constitutional form guarantees it.
In 1952, newly installed W.A.C. Bennett was obscure but untainted by the shady administration that preceded. When he left twenty years later, Victoria had long been ripe with cronyism and corruption.
Like his father, Bennett the Younger built a reputation for strict central control. When his eleven-year reign ended, it did so after prolonged civic unrest and amid suspicions of scandal. Then came the obloquies of Vander Zalm, Harcourt and Clark Johnson, Miller and Dosanjh served too little time to gain regal status.
The common thread here is an unrestrained premiership. Unrivalled power of one person eventually overwhelms collegiality. Authority turns arrogant and perceives its wisdom as infallible. Opponents are removed; critics ignored. Soon, only sycophants remain to reinforce the leader’s conceit.
Campbell’s eventual replacement will begin with appearance of change but human nature will prevail. As David Brin wrote, “It is said that power corrupts, but actually it's more true that power attracts the corruptible.”
We should limit the terms of party leaders and give counterbalancing strength and influence to individual legislative members. Presently, citizens only vote for the least important cogs of government. Unless the roles of MLAs change, Government will be or become corrupt.
As an afterthought, I suppose the secret roof ornament that Gordo plans atop Robson Square would be a CROWN?
zalm
4 years ago
Moat wrote: "Yeah, but
Moat wrote:
"Yeah, but what do we do?"
Perhaps eight years ago, I had a large group over for dinner, served three salmon - 2 wild (sockeye and pink) and one farmed. I'd never done a side-by-side before, and this wasn't intended to be one - I simply didn't have enough to feed 25 without the farmed one.
But the farmed one - flabby, flat, colourless wretch that it was - became the goat of the show for its lack of taste and mushy feel. Grabbing the bull by the horns, I encouraged everyone to taste-test the three, and let people draw their own conclusions. Some folks still mention that day to me, noting they've never eaten another farmed fish.
I do that again periodically - I've parents and in-laws who believe they're doing the right thing by getting something on sale and giving it to us kids, ignoring the fact that life's too short to eat bad food. So rather than throw them away, I invite a bunch more over and do the same thing. I'm gonna guess that over the past few years, another twenty people are definitely not eating "farmed" as a result of those dinners.
Some probably are, though. The "marketplace mentality" still rules for some people, even in their food choices. They'd eat rat poison if it was tasty and cheap enough.
Moat
4 years ago
Getting personal - Doggone, Right to Bear, Zalm
Good suggestions. However, I am not so convinced that the letter writing works. It is like signing those petitions.
However, the idea of serving farmed salmon beside the wild one is intriguing. I think I got to give that a shot.
We know that McDonald's food is not really a wise choice nutritionally, and we know that McDonald's is hard on the environment. However, we can accept it as a guilty pleasure. Some of us do have secret McDonald's cravings once in a while.
What is killer though, is that people are so willing to eat the farmed salmon under the guise that they are making a "healthy choice" and an environmentally wise decision.
Let's keep supporting the restaurants that serve wild salmon, and avoid the ones that are most likely using the "net penned" stuff from our coast.
At the moment, I am not willing to go to war with Safeway, Superstore, or Costco. We know that they are merely providing what the consumer wants.
However, I am willing to educate those at the dinner table through experience rather than words. The trick is to pull it off without looking like an organic food snob (which I am not).
The other food that kind of drives me batty is the beef jerky that is made in Brazil. But that is for another discussion.
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Tumor Choppers...
I am disappointed in Gore to say the least. Right on lynn. I hope Gore reads what you sent him. I have to say though, as much as he is the top whistle blower ever in the history of man, he sure has made some incredible mistakes. He supported the Makah whale slaughter a few years ago where a young grey whale took 24 hours to die from her wounds. People just floated around, waiting for her to die. Gore's support helped promote this pathetic event. Praising the Campbell government for greenness is so off base one can only hope the spin off from such a comment will induce the feedback necessary for Gore to see the truth of it...
Peace,
Bear
ps
Did you guys know that most fish farms hire "tumor choppers". This is an employee responsible for cutting off all the tumors on the farmed fish prior to processing...apparently it's kinda a secret position (no doubt). I think restaurants should have "Tumor-free" Salmon" written in their menu's if they want to sell farmed salmon... The public deserves more honesty. They are calling these fish "sustainably harvested" and other hidden words for farmed salmon... They should be forced to own up to their deplorable choices. B.
rjm
4 years ago
hmmn...
i wonder if campbell has 50% support in his own riding yet?
liberal support in british columbia is entirely dependent on the lack of effective opposition which carole james seems more than happy to provide.
a "real" leader of the ndp would have picked a fight with bctv and the fraser institute a long time ago.
identify them as propaganda whores in the same vein as fox news and neuter the effectiveness of their message.
people need a basis upon which to openly challenge these globalist shills such that their message is not delivered with carte blanche immunity to critical examination.
carole james should never give another interview/sound bite/single second of air time to bctv... period.
that would give her much more time to talk to cbc and bctv and would give bctv and cbc a reason to take her just a little bit more seriously.
the ndp, provincially and federally, should just walk away from canwest althogether.
tks,
rjm
rjm
4 years ago
oops...
should read
"that would give her much more time to talk to cbc and ctv and would give ctv and cbc a reason to take her just a little bit more seriously"
tks
rjm
rousseau
4 years ago
to the editor
'Don't worry, no one actually believes that stuff except Elliot himself and the Rightees that live in bizarro-world'
would a poster not be banned if he were to use the word 'lefty'? is there a double standard at the tyee?
Frank
4 years ago
Nemesis-Elliot-AdamWest-Robin
Double standard? Like maybe a guy that was banned for calling other posters names and constant trolling hides behind his 6th alias and yet is still posting?
Don't cry Elliot, just be glad you're still here.
Frank
4 years ago
Campbell's emissions
For those that believe Campbell just fixed the problem of carbon emissions in BC check out the column you'll find funny by Vaughn Palmer.
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.html?id=81d41ec8-f24a-4719-bb99-35bb6048fc52
lynn
4 years ago
the emperor is not wearing a shred of green
bang on , rjm.
But moat, if we boycotted them, perhaps it would provide some much needed attention to a dire struggle... and by informing consumers through the boycott thus change the wants of consumers.
The thing is we're talking just four years here and while I think it's a good suggestion I'm not sure the salmon can wait for all of us to taste test for farmed versus wild consensus at dinner parties.
BC Mary
4 years ago
Resist! Vote for the Do Nothing Party.
Frank said: By the way, I'm only voting NDP because of the lack of choice we have politically. If there was a party that ran the province democratically and with a conscience I'd switch to them in a heartbeat but since all we have are the semi-literate Liberals and the privatize-it-all Greens I'm forced to vote NDP.
Frank: Try my system: I'm going to vote for the Do-Nothing Party led by that nice Carole James, on the theory that it's better to do nothing than to sell or wreck every precious thing in B.C.
Loblollyboy: To explain why many British Columbians put up with King Campbell when they won't tolerate even modest errors by an NDP government ...
The answer is: we've been trained. Diligently, relentlessly we're trained to react, when we see anything New Democratic, we leap into the air and shriek: "NDP Ba-a-ad. NDP very, very ba-a-ad!"
But at least, we're offered three styles of training: Vancouver Sun, The Province, and Victoria Times Colonist.
Moat
4 years ago
But how else do we reach the masses?
lynn wrote:
I understand where you are coming from. But if I simply boycott Safeway, and refuse to eat farmed salmon whenever it is served to me, people are just going to question or giggle at my self-righteousness. Alarming people also does not work.
It is a real battle, as many people out there that feel that they really would not miss the salmon, the bears, and some of the other creatures that we exist on the earth with. Just by using our computers we are increasing the demand for electricity (hydroelectric dams). Are we willing to find other things to enjoy that have less impact on the environment?
But that is besides the point. The real issue is how do you reach the ones that say, "I really would not miss the salmon. They are just going to die off anyway"?
zalm
4 years ago
Choices
I'm lucky enough to live only a few miles from the fisherman's dock so I can walk down on a Saturday afternoon, buy something off the boat and walk back.
There's no easy answers on either side, folks. Eating wild isn't necessarily better, just because. It's harder on the environment, simply because we don't know how to work the black box called the ocean to controllably produce enough wild salmon for all palates. That's why farmed is making inroads. It's also more prone to storing up toxins such as PCBs in tissue becasue of the long life-cycle of the fish.
And farmed can become a healthier choice. Note: I said healthier, not healthy. I can do without the dye and growth hormones because I don't care what kind of makeup my slice of fish wears. Fully contained pens, closed-loop water treatment, and some kind of method of vigorous exercise may help produce better-quality fish. It won't be cheap, but you'll find me on all kinds of threads saying that food shouldn't be cheap.
Good cooking can do the rest. Wild can remain the gold standard for gourmet dining on Saturday night - it just doesn't have to be the only thing you eat if your Monday noon meal is just a maintenance meal.
And, Moat, if you want to taste-test, don't say anything. Just serve them both, and let people pick up on the difference themselves. They will. And they'll talk about it. You may never have to say a word.
HawkEyes
4 years ago
Who else?
He did.
But "Gordo" is much too modest.
We, the people, need a "royal" handle, worthy of the king. Contest!
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Our Health, and the Coastal Ecosystems...
There are 2 issues here: Our health, and the Health of the coastal ecosystems (intricately connected to our health too mind you...)
When the restaurants are honest and serve 98% Tumor-free Cedar Plank Farmed Salmon, then buyer beware, as they are deadly toxic. But when the open-net cages are replaced with close containment cages, and the fish farms are inland, then the wild stock will be protected and hopefully recover. This is the most urgent issue here. Go ahead if you will, and eat farmed diseased fish, but keep these fish away from the wild coasts as these animals primarily use salmon as their food to survive on, and we need to care about their survival.
Peace,
Bear
zalm
4 years ago
Ummmmm.....
I'm with you until you say that farmed stocks are the major contributor to wild salmon stocks' decimation. They aren't. Rafe didn't say they are. Nobody does. They are a serious problem in river mouths where they occur, but that is only a hundred or so of our spawning rivers.
The major issue for wild stocks is the maltreatment of spawning rivers due to logging and roadbuilding, and to warming spawning waters. Lice is a side issue - a potent one, but a side issue. The other issues affect every single one of the thousands of salmon runs in the province, and Alaska's too, which has essentially banned salmnon farms.
As well, you simply MUST address the problem of contamination of wild stocks with PCBs, etc. Neither is good for you - neither farmed stocks which use ground-up "waste" fish containing PCBs, or wild stocks which contain PCBs built up from their more limited exposure yet longer lifespan.
zalm
4 years ago
But
Thanks Rafe, but in the last couple of days you've just been proved wrong. Nothing can compare to the arrogance of King Grog and his transportation announcements and pollution targets.
Just like Louis the Sun King, he picks a pollultion target figure out of the air, calls it gospel, and says "Go for it!" He sees the sexiest mode of transportation on the market, says to himself "nothing is too good for my subjects", calls his ministers of state in and says "Go for it!"
He's desperate.
On the really important things in life, he's come up a zero. On the health care file, we're spending 35% more than when he was first elected, yet producing 3-18% worse results. He's come up a zero on the welfare file - more children in care are dying under his watch than ever before.
Gorgon is truly unable to solve the bigger problems of our time, but having castigated the NDP for the same results, now finds he must distract, avoid, flim-flam the public's queries.
Gorgon has no answers. Neither did the NDP. The difference is the NDP was honest about it. Gorgon isn't. For a so-called "policy wonk", he hasn't got much.
Loser.
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Zalm...
Victoria Columnist:
The article's authors, including University of Alberta researcher Martin Krkosek and B.C.'s Alexandra Morton, looked at 37 years' worth of Fisheries and Oceans data for 71 central coast rivers and found that wild pink runs have comfortably withstood decades of commercial fishing - but cannot survive fish farms...".
There are other factors contributing to the loss of the wild salmon, but "Lice" is the most impacting by far...
Cheers,
Bear
Right to Bear
4 years ago
Zalm...
Study Finds Sea Lice From Salmon Farms
Bear
lynn
4 years ago
Doing the right image instead of the right thing
I wouldn't even try convincing these guys, moat.....that could take forever and the salmon haven't got that kind of time - expose their ruthless policies instead. They'll never see the wild salmon as sacred beings in themselves unless they can be pricetagged as future profits, as more greenbacks for their wallets. It's all about what the wild salmon can do for them - and that's pretty much their narcissistic world view on everything.
Instead sock it to 'em where it most hurts. In the pocket book. Fast and hard. It's the only thing they understand.
We have a lot of harnessable power in our refusal to prop up the profit-motivated tyranny of the corporate world - through our refusal to participate in any act that serves to increase their stolen riches even more.
That's why I agree with boycotts (as a partial answer anyway... I know there is a lot more work to do then that). Since image is all important to the art of selling and ever-increasing profit margins.... if suddenly you are perceived as the bad guy and lose sales because of it, that's when businesses get nervous....and phone calls are made to government to fix it... or good-bye party donations.
We don't have to put pressure on Gorgon, his boycotted business friends will do it for us.
Just an idea.... since Gorgon is all cardboard image hiding lack of character - as zalm writes: "On the really important things in life, he's come up a zero" - he and his party spend a lot of time and mostly our money fabricating the right image rather than doing the right thing.
But 2010 is sacred ground for these guys. Front pew seats all round. Where else can they find such Olympian-sized opportunities to compete in the world-wide sport of making money?
But "greedy" isn't quite "the right image" to sport so they have selected a more eco-trendy one. And what they really, really, want to appear as in 2010 is green... sexy green , au courant green, and they hope, more-profitable-green.
It's "easy-green", designed to fool.
The last thing they want in 2010 is to be exposed to the world for bringing about the extinction of a world-renowned species like the wild salmon.
I mean, how's that going to look? ...'specially with all the environmental spin they've been so busy putting out there?
So why not somehow try to link this critical issue with the Olympics....something like getting our athletes and those from competing countries to get on board now in the race to save one of the great species of the world. It falls within the four year framework, focuses the attention of the world on the desperate plight of the wild salmon... and on the arrogant policies of the BCLiberals that are bringing about their extinction.
asher
4 years ago
this article contains an error
The Sun King wasn't invovled in the mess when this happened - it was just God's mistake that Rafe was born.
RickW
4 years ago
BC Mary
And the thing is, if the NDP actually do do something, it's a bonus!