Tyeenews

And the People's Order of BC Winners Are...

You nominated, you voted. Now it's time to give kudos to them all.

By Geoff D'Auria, 31 Oct 2011, TheTyee.ca

PeoplesOrderofBC

Illustration by Alex Grunenfelder.

Related

"There are billions of galaxies in the observable universe, and each of them contains hundreds of billions of stars. In one of these galaxies, orbiting one of these stars, lies a little blue planet. And this planet is run by a bunch of monkeys."

So begins Ernest Cline's poem, "Dance, Monkey, Dance," which holds a mirror to the petty squabbles and obsessions of all of us monkeys here on earth.

Cline claimed that because of our freakishly large monkey brains, we are a species cursed with self-consciousness and worries.

"The monkeys worry about everything, but mostly about what all the other monkeys think. Because the monkeys desperately want to fit in with the other monkeys."

To ease our fears, we do funny things like "make trophies" and then give them to each other "like it means something."

ACTUAL ORDER OF B.C. RECIPIENTS, 2011

Lt. Gov. Steven Point awarded the actual Order of B.C. medals to this year's recipients at an investiture ceremony on Oct. 4.

The actual Order of B.C. winners for 2011 are:

Luigi Aquilini
Peter Norman Baird
Ken Dobell
Crystal Dunahee
David L. Emerson
Yuri Fulmer
Tim Jones
Dr. Phil Muir
J.C. (Jim) O'Rourke
Karen O'Shannacery
Jim Robson
Baljit Sethi
Ellen White

Absent from the ceremony: Gordon Campbell

And that's what we monkeys did here at The Tyee a couple of weeks ago. We launched a new award called The People's Order of B.C., a cheeky response to the controversy surrounding this year's actual Order of B.C. selections where we asked you to nominate and then vote for your favourites.

And now we're going to give it to some deserving folks (see below) and, yes, we're going to act like it means something.

Because while Cline is right -- that the concerns of us monkeys down here on this forested corner of this little blue planet don't amount to much in an indifferent universe -- this is where we live.

And we live with each other. And meaning comes from the consensus of the crowd. It always has.

So, when an award purports to broadly represent us and our values, the selections can't really be controversial because, to us monkeys, these things actually kind of mean something.

Is The Tyee's People's Order of B.C. any better?

That's for you to decide.

We're proud to have received more than 100 nominations and more than 600 online votes. We're also aware that this is a miniscule fraction of the 4.5 million people who live here. But we're hopeful it broadens in a positive way the definition of who we are as a people.

Of course, every process has blind spots, this one included. For example, the only information most voters had to base their choices on was stories provided by the people nominating. Two or three paragraphs to represent a life's work is clearly inadequate, especially for those lesser known. And there was a risk that those savvy in the dark arts of Internet campaigning could control the outcome, though we didn't notice any obvious web hijinks.

All to say, we think everyone nominated deserves serious recognition, not just those who garnered the most votes.

And in the end, it was a worthwhile experiment, if only to give more credit where it's due, to channel frustrations directed at the Order of B.C., and to continue the conversation about what we want our awards to say about us.

So, to the top five and to all the nominees, a heartfelt congratulations -- not so much for being selected, but for life well lived. And we hope the recognition helps spur you to even more great work.

You make us proud.

And the top five are...

Alexandra Morton -- 425 votes

Originally from Connecticut, Alexandra Morton is a marine biologist best known these days for her studies focusing on the impact of salmon farming in the waters off British Columbia. Not only did Morton garner the most votes, but she also garnered the most nominations -- 20 in total. Many of them echoed these sentiments:

"Alexandra Morton has for many years sustained a selfless but articulate struggle against governments, industry and other financial beneficiaries of questionable ocean science. Her recent focus has been on fish farming techniques but she began living in isolation on the B.C. coast more than 30 years ago to study the marine environment of Orca whales. Her views have consistently called for preservation of natural ecology and application of the precautionary principle favouring preservation of natural order. She is a scientist, an author, an activist and, perhaps most importantly, a symbol of an individual's ability to peacefully confront larger and more powerful forces over issues of conscience."

Dave Barrett -- 365 votes

Known for his quick wit and sharp oratory, Dave Barrett, a former social worker, became the 26th premier of British Columbia in 1972, the first from the New Democratic Party.

Among many progressive reforms, his government created the Agricultural Land Reserve to protect the small percentage of arable land left in the province, a guaranteed income plan for senior citizens, a public automobile insurance program (ICBC) and the British Columbia Human Rights Board. It also introduced a question period and full Hansard transcripts into legislature proceedings.

Like Alexandra Morton, Barrett garnered multiple nominations from Tyee readers, with many sentiments like these:

"Dave presided over a government that made more progress in three years than B.C. had in the previous 20 under WAC Bennett... It was a very productive time, and although Barrett lost the 1975 election to the new coalition, the NDP vote actually went up by four per cent, not down. So despite what the right wing pundits always claim, the 'people' did not reject the Barrett government..."

The People of Hartley Bay -- 255 votes

Seven minutes after the Queen of the North ferry hit Gil Island just after midnight on Mar. 22, 2006, eight boats from nearby Hartley Bay were racing to the scene, while the people back in that small village were getting ready to take care of the survivors.

As Margo Pfeiff described in detail in, of all publications, Popular Mechanics:

"Six miles to the northeast, in the aboriginal settlement of Hartley Bay, Bruce Reece was awakened by the ferry's Mayday, relayed by the Canadian Coast Guard station in Prince Rupert on the marine distress channel, which northern communities monitor around the clock. Within seconds, phones were ringing throughout the village of 200. Men ran to the dock for their trawlers and skiffs, while women began preparing food and hot drinks, collecting blankets and warm clothes and heading to the community center to await survivors."

Along with a nearby Coast Guard ship, all the passengers and crew but two were brought back to Hartley Bay where they were kept warm and safe.

May Apsassin -- 238 votes

We don't know a lot about May Apsassin, save for what we learned in her eloquent nomination, which began:

"May Dominic, a Beaver Indian, was born May 7, 1940, in Doig River Reserve, BC. Her parents were Charlie Dominic and Jean Succona. Late Charlie Yahey, our late dreamer and the Great Chief Succona were her grandfathers."

Without making too many assumptions about people's motivations, it no doubt felt good to vote for someone who didn't seem to seek out the spotlight and was described as "a tremendously valuable resource for the Blueberry community as a traditional teacher, a spiritual counselor and [someone who has been] encouraging our younger generation to complete their education and to learn about our traditional [values], which will lead the young people to live the good life and not to become dependent on alcohol or drugs."

Jean Swanson -- 195 votes

Jean Swanson is coordinator of the Carnegie Community Action Project in Vancouver, an organization dedicated to the welfare of the Downtown Eastside, one of Canada's poorest neighbourhoods, and has been an anti-poverty activist for more than 30 years.

Swanson is a strong proponent of the idea that poverty is neither a choice nor a failure of the individual but more so a failure of a political and economic system. And she's found innovative ways to bring the issue to the forefront of the political agenda.

In the lead up to the Olympic Games, she appealed to the U.N. Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing, to intervene on behalf of the Downtown Eastside "with the Vancouver municipal government, the government of British Columbia, and the government of Canada, to urge them to end homelessness and improve housing conditions in our neighbourhood, the city, province and country."

To this nominator, though, it was as much the how as the what:

"Jean has also always made a point of working collaboratively with low-income people in order to ensure they are as involved as possible in issues that effect them... She endeavors always to ensure that poor people have a voice in the public policy issues that directly impact their lives... She is widely respected. Jean Swanson is principled, tremendously hard working and very inspiring."

Congratulations all!

The truth is, we had an embarrassment of good candidates. Should we have selected more? Could we have structured things differently? Let us know what you think because (who knows?) maybe we'll do it again next year.

Regardless, thanks for all the time and thought you all put into your nominations and selections. And congratulations again to everyone nominated.  [Tyee]

21  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Jeffrey J.

    29 weeks ago

    Congratulations Alexandra Morton

    Congratulations to Alex Morton. And to ALL the other people nominated for this great 'real people' award.

    And congratulations to the Tyee for creating this award, which has so much more relevance than the fake awards handed out to corrupt elites like Gordon Campbell and his cronies.

  • Talon

    29 weeks ago

    Recognition

    Thank you Tyee for The People's Order of BC. I think it is important to recognize those individuals who have taken those extra steps to make bring truth and equality and justice into the commons and into our dialogue . I heartily congratulate those who have been chosen this year, all of whom are outstanding individuals in many ways. I hope The Tyee does this again next year. Cheers and thunderous applause to all.

  • janetvickers

    29 weeks ago

    Well Done

    Although the person I nominated didn't get into the finals, I appreciated that this didn't become a dog and pony show, with a Facebook group of contenders asking their friends to vote for them. I appreciate that this is about real commitment to making the world a better place and that it was not coopted into a media game that trivializes that work.

  • Frank Lee

    29 weeks ago

    The Order of the BC Establishment

    David Emerson and Ken Dobell but STILL no David Barrett? A democratic legislature, a land reserve policy, a modern Labour Code and public auto insurance not enough?

    Gordon Campbell getting in right away, being driven to the Hall of Fasme immediately likely Gretzky or Lemieux having the normal waiting period waived because of their eminence?

    This, despite having to resign because of a furor over his policies--circumstances no better than Barrett's departure from office in the 1975 election?

    Seriously, folks--there is something seriously, seriously wrong with this picture.

    But congratulations to Dave Barrett for his achievement as the People's Choice.

  • pianosaurus rex

    29 weeks ago

    Agreed Frank

    If I was lucky enough to be a previous recipient of the Order of BC and I heard that Campbell was to get the same award I would formally return mine, as giving one to Campbell cheapens the importance and meaning of the award entirely.

    Similar to the furor created when the NHL wanted to give Alan Eagleson the Hall of Fame award. Bobby Hull and many other Hall of Famers threaten to return theirs.

    One has to wonder about the sanity of these people; Campbell, possibly the worst premier a province of Canada has ever had in its entire history; outright lies over policy decisions, gets caught red handed breaking the law, and they all make him their hero.

    Pretty much reveals the mindset of the Liberals. This mindset is not new to Campbell’s reign. The Liberal party has been like this for a long time.

  • RBULLER

    29 weeks ago

    PEOPLE's O BC

    Right on!
    Congrats on Dave Barrett's choice and for support for People of Hartley Bay. I didn't know much about the others but they sound so deserving. Not so "unsung" any more and that's the way it should be.

    Please open up nominations again another year!
    And keep up the good work,
    Robert Buller

  • Frank Lee

    29 weeks ago

    The Establishment Award

    And who will win next year---Christy Clark and Jessica MacDonald??!! Warren Kinsella??

  • RickW

    29 weeks ago

    Frank Lee

    Better to call it the "Anti-Occupy Award".....

  • Soren Bech

    29 weeks ago

    Next step?

    These are great winners. And all the nominees were worthy candidates, unlike the government's choices for the Order of B.C.

    Now we should order some nice plaques and organize a ceremony so we can give the winners a big round of applause.

  • Jeffrey J.

    29 weeks ago

    What Soren Bech Said.

    What Soren Bech said.

    We need plaques and a ceremony. Everyone nominated should be invited to attend and the top winners should be publicly recognized. A great idea.

  • skyhunk

    29 weeks ago

    What??!! After all that David

    What??!! After all that David Hahn has done so unselfishly for BC Ferries and the people of BC he didn't even rate a mention?

  • shedding_light

    29 weeks ago

    You made my day, Tyee!

    I couldn't figure out the technology to register and vote on this (the link to register led nowhere for me), but I was so pleased with those nominated, and enjoyed reading about them so much, it didn't make me feel bad at all, not having a voice in the choosing.

    In fact, those who 'won' are the ones I'm happiest to see given this honour, which I bet they will appreciate more than the B.C. Establishment one anyway!

    As to having meaning, personally the effect of seeing both the nominees and these five honoured in this way, having them 'brought to our attention' so to speak, does me a lot of good...it makes me feel that even though Canada and the whole world is upside down and topsy-turvy in so many ways, there are still many good people working hard to bring some goodness into it and who sincerely care for others. Showing our respect and gratitude to them in this way does US a lot of good I think. It's for us, not them, that we do this, really, and probably these folks will understand that we need to hear about them and honour them to strengthen our own hope for the future and determination to carry on, even as dark as it is sometimes.

    This kind of award, I think, brings out the best in all of us by reminding us of the best that humans are capable of, instead of only ever having the worst humans are capable of in the spotlight.

  • Frank Lee

    29 weeks ago

    The Establishment Award

    And who will win next year---Christy Clark and Jessica MacDonald??!! Warren Kinsella??

  • SCI

    29 weeks ago

    Love the People's Order of BC Choices

    Kudos to The Tyee for initiating the People's Order of BC. The winners are stellar.

  • Skywalker

    29 weeks ago

    Maybe next time we can also...

    ...introduce the Order of the BC Raspberry for folks like Skyhunk mentioned..

  • Geoff

    29 weeks ago

    Administrator

    Thanks for the kind words, everyone.

    A ceremony would be so much fun.

    More so, it would be great to get all you good folks in a room with the winners and the nominees for some mutual admiration.

    I'm afraid we're not able to do that right now, though. Not enough time and money! But thanks for letting us know you'd be interested. We'll give it some serious thought.

    We're also thinking of printing and sending to the winners some buttons. We were thinking of using the People's Order image that Alex Grunenfelder created (See top of this story).

    One reader suggested we use instead the blackberry flower, "it's often thorny and contentious but if treated with respect can yield flavourful fruit."

    What does everyone think?

  • ForTheHacks

    29 weeks ago

    Why didn't Sean Holman get nominated?

    Perhaps if he did, today's tragedy wouldn't have happened. People would donate to save the great Sean Holman.

    We just lost the greatest Journo of the rockpile and dare I say the Canadian Confederacy.

  • Skywalker

    29 weeks ago

    @ForThe Hacks

    Why is it so easy to tell from all your posts regardless of how many times you change your name that you are JosefK aka: BCOrder, I-Am- Peo etc. ?

  • boondoggle

    29 weeks ago

    Congratulations Alexandra Morton!

    For your incredible, selfless efforts to expose an utterly corrupted political system which has enabled our wild salmon, which are our heritage and a key component of the web of life in British Columbia, to be squandered in the name of transnational psychopathy.

  • lynn

    29 weeks ago

    Well done by all.

    I thought it was lovely list of nominees and a lovely idea - to take this award back for 'the people'.

    Well done by all. Thanks to Geoff and The Tyee.

    What wonderful dinner guests they would all be..... I would have so many questions to ask.

    What does Dave Barrett think of the state of things in BC and in the world at present? His feelings on the Occupy Movement? How doe he spend his days now?

    I'd love to hear what The People of Hartley Bay have to say themselves about that dark night on the coast that was lightened and lifted through their courageous spirit....and how are they all doing now? What do they think about the possibility of oil tankers plying the coast on a regular basis?

    And so much to learn from the lives of May Apsassin, Alexandra Morton and Jean Swanson....

    Anyway, to cut to the chase, hope The Tyee will do some in-depth interviews/articles on these deserving folks....hopefully even with some of the nominees. Love to hear more about these wonderful people.

  • MkumbaJoe

    29 weeks ago

    Great idea!!!

    Great idea! Keep up the innovative thinking!

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.