Opinion

Transit Geeks Rejoice!

Not only does Vancouver crush Portland and Seattle, but proving it involves nifty analysis and charts.

By Clark Williams-Derry, 19 Jul 2012, Sightline.org

Transit ridership graph

Chart courtesy of Sightline Institute.

Related

When it comes to commuting by transit in the larger cities on North America's northwest coast, neither Portland nor Seattle can hold a candle to greater Vancouver.

The simplest comparison among the three cities looks at the average number of bus and rail transit boardings per person, per year, in the entire metro area. And on that measure, Vancouver vastly outstrips its two southern neighbors (see chart at top of story).


Unfortunately, the story is somewhat more complicated than this chart suggests. Vancouver's transit system encourages transfers -- and since there's a single, unified transit agency for metro Vancouver, there's good data on how many riders actually transfer in the course of a single trip. Seattle, in contrast, has so many overlapping transit systems that it's very difficult to assess how many transfers there really are.

Still, even if you assume that each transit boarding in Portland and Seattle represents a single trip, but use Vancouver's data on "trips" rather than "vehicle boardings," Metro Vancouver still beats the two U.S cities handily:

Using the same "trip" definitions in the chart above, a mode-by-mode breakdown shows that Portland has far more rail riders than Seattle, while greater Seattle edges out greater Portland in bus ridership. But Vancouver still comes out on top in both categories.

Trips per capita, 2010*

By Bus: Vancouver 56, Portland 32, Seattle 43
By Light Rail: Vancouver 33, Portland 21, Seattle 3
By Commuter Rail: Vancouver 1, Portland 0, Seattle 1

Bus and rail trip graph

*Note: Vancouver data represent transit "trips," while data for both Portland and Seattle represent transit "boardings."

Of course, there's still more to the story. These charts exclude a number of transit modes, including dial-a-ride transit (which is typically door-to-door service offered to those who are physically unable to use standard transit service), as well as vanpools and ferries. I've decided to keep those out of the analysis for now, but I'll note that after including ferry trips in the total trip count count, Seattle's per capita transit ridership ties Portland's; and when you add in vanpools as well as ferries, Seattle narrowly edges Portland.

So perhaps Portland and Seattle are about tied... but tied in a race to see who comes in a distant second to Vancouver.

Notes and Caveats:

For this analysis, we considered all of the transit agencies in the greater Portland and Seattle metropolitan areas, as listed in the National Transit Database. For Seattle, those agencies included King County Metro, Sound Transit, Community Transit (in Snohomish County), Everett Transit, the City of Seattle, and a handful of ferry providers -- but not Kitsap Transit. For Portland, it included Trimet, C-Tran in Clark County, the South Metro Area Regional Transit agency in Wilsonville, and the Metro vanpool program.

All data for Metro Vancouver comes from Translink. In Seattle, Light Rail includes the monorail and South Lake Union Trolley. Population for the Seattle metro area includes the full population of King, Snohomish, and Pierce counties. Greater Portland's population includes Clark County, Washington, and Clackamas, Multnomah, and Washington counties in Oregon. Population for greater Vancouver includes all of Metro Vancouver. Note that Seattle and Portland population totals, as described above, may differ from the populations of the service areas as defined in the National Transit Database.  [Tyee]

What have we missed? What do you think? We want to know. Comment below. Keep in mind:

Do:

  • Verify facts, debunk rumours
  • Add context and background
  • Spot typos and logical fallacies
  • Highlight reporting blind spots
  • Treat all with respect and curiosity
  • Connect with each other

Do not:

  • Use sexist, classist, racist or homophobic language
  • Libel or defame
  • Bully or troll
comments powered by Disqus