News

Two DTES Groups Pull Out of Missing Women Commission

Calling inquiry a 'sham', women's organizations granted full standing quit, vow protest.

By Angela Sterritt, 3 Oct 2011, TheTyee.ca

Missing Women's March, 2010

Families and friends of the murdered and missing women burn sage and march through the Downtown Eastside, Vancouver B.C., 2010. Photo by nofutureface via Your BC: The Tyee's Photo Pool.

Two leading Vancouver Downtown Eastside women's groups have withdrawn from the B.C.'s Missing Women Commission, calling it a "sham inquiry."

The Women's Memorial March Committee (WMMC) and the Downtown Eastside Women's Centre (DEWC) -- granted full standing as a single participant -- released a media statement this morning saying they will not be endorsing nor participating in the Pickton Inquiry.

"We have been raising awareness on this issue for over 20 years and demanding an inquiry for decades, but this sham inquiry is flawed and unjust. We cannot endorse it," states Carol Martin, victim services worker at the Downtown Eastside Women's Centre.

The groups are denouncing the inquiry and will call for a "new fair, just, and inclusive inquiry that centers the voices and experiences and leadership of women in the DTES," the release says.

In the judicial inquiry, the commission will look at the police conduct surrounding the gruesome crimes committed by Robert "Willie" Pickton -- the murders of 33 women in five years, all coming from the DTES. It will also probe into why in 1998, the attorney general's office stayed attempted-murder charges against him.

According to the release, Diane Wood, a member of the Women's Memorial March Committee says: "We have essentially been shut out from this sham inquiry that is actually supposed to be about us and our experiences. It is vital to this inquiry that the voices of women and the community be front and centre when determining its recommendations. Without a commitment to the participation of women from the Downtown Eastside, the inquiry is not legitimate and has no credibility."

'We will not be intervening': Minister Bond

The news comes just days after 20 of the 21 groups provided standing at the commission released a letter to Premier Christy Clark, pleading for her intervention to "fix the broken process." They gave her an October 5 deadline to respond, but solicitor general Shirley Bond jumped to the task the same day.

"Let me be clear, we will not be intervening in the work of the commission. Given the budget challenges the ministry is facing, we have made our priority funding legal counsel for the families of the murdered and missing women," her statement read.

Bond said she expects the commission to complete its work by Dec. 31, 2011 and said the government will only carefully consider an extension on the request of the commissioner.

The WMMC and the DEWC coalition is the seventh to vacate the commission proceedings, with the most recent group -- Pivot Legal Society -- whose coalition members BCCLA and Amnesty International are still on the record as participating, departing last week.

Given the number of groups pulling out, some say it gleans evidence that the commission isn't working.

'Unfair and discriminatory': NWAC's Lavell

"So many people are feeling it's futile, and it's the integrity of the commission being questioned," says NWAC president Jeannette Corbiere Lavell. The Native Women's Association of Canada was the only Aboriginal organization granted full participation at the inquiry, but had to withdraw due to a lack of legal funding.

"It's unfair and discriminatory to the most vulnerable people in Canada -- Aboriginal women," said Lavell in a telephone interview. "Strong questions need to be asked and we don't feel that the counsel for the VPD, RCMP and the justice department are going to ask those questions due to the embarrassment it could cause them." On September 27, NWAC called on three United Nations Special Rapporteurs on Violence Against Women, the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and the Independence of Judges and Lawyers to make an urgent joint appeal to Canada for last minute funds.

A letter sent to B.C.'s attorney general last month expressed synonymous concerns over the province's refusal to fund all participants. It was signed by a group of prominent lawyers and academics who have been commission counsel or advisers at a number of public inquiries, including the inquiry into the bombing of Air India Flight 182, the Maher Arar inquiry, and the Ipperwash inquiry into the killing of Dudley George.

"We can identify no other case in Canada where a government, having appointed a commission of inquiry, then, in effect, overturned a commissioner's decision on standing by refusing funding for participation," it said.

In response, solicitor general Shirley Bond explained her government's commitment to the commission and cited the $1.9 million investment into it.

Just one week until the Vancouver hearings begin, and anger in the Downtown Eastside is rising. Residents are concerned that the original intent of the Commission is losing ground.

"We are sick of this. This inquiry was supposed to be about a measure of justice for us and the hope that things would change down here, but it is just more of the same injustices," says Beatrice Starr, who has resided in the Downtown Eastside for 30 years and whose sister and niece were both murdered.

The WMCC and DEWC press release lists several factors among the reasons for dropping out -- specifically citing a lack of transparency, an inaccessible process, and a disregard for vulnerable witnesses as top reasons. The groups also say that the study commission portion cannot be a replacement for a full and meaningful inquiry.

The coalition announced a rally at the beginning of the hearings on Oct. 11, 2011 at 10 a.m. at 701 West Georgia.

[See more Tyee rights and justice coverage.]  [Tyee]

10  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Fish-counter

    1 year ago

    In some ways, it is comforting to know that nothing has changed

    [OFFENSIVE COMMENTS REMOVED.]

  • Fish-counter

    1 year ago

    The DTES groups should hold their own inquiry

    They should televise it and pull no punches. These poor women deserve better than the cops gave back then, and nothing has changed. It is a disgrace to justice and to the province.

    It is tragic that young people have to hitch hike Highway 16. You would think that in this era of the internet, there coud be a carpooling system in place.

    I just drove from Nanaimo to Edmonton and could have used a passenger for company. I have to go back on Saturday if anyone needs a ride.

  • zalm

    1 year ago

    But...

    [OFFENSIVE COMMENTS REMOVED.]

  • igbymac

    1 year ago

    what can be said?

    Welcome to the bourgeois legal industry where the needs of the elite are entrenched for the continuation of their sub-species alone.

    Sorry, ladies, but the state does not give a shit about you.

    I applaud you for standing tall and leaving the sham behind, and in the process sending a clear message that resonates with all Canadians who are catching onto this national fraud.

  • Fish-counter

    1 year ago

    Actually Zalm, any police officer should apply to the new force

    as long they haven't killed a civilian or kicked them half to death for being East indian. The women of BC deserve protection, not pretense. They weren't getting it 20 years ago and they aren't getting it now because it is the same people in the same uniforms telling the same shabby lies.

    Most of the BC RCMP are decent honest coppers. The bad 5% get all the news. They should get the boot. It is them that need the famous starlight tour.

  • Fish-counter

    1 year ago

    Jesus Christ; doesn't anyone else want to chip in on this issue?

    It is hard to believe that Tyee readers are this harsh. The women of the DTES deserve respect and they ain't getting it. One human being is just as valuable as another.

    The downtown east side is a black mark on the image of Vancouver and it isn't going away just because everyone wants to pretend it is a beauty spot.

    Ditto the Stanley Cup riots. Both are engraved into history, no matter how the snotty people of BC's biggest city think otherwise. It IS your true nature, Vancouver, so embrace it you bastards.

  • zalm

    1 year ago

    Well..

    ...I meant "should apply for a ride" but we'll let that pass.

    Seriously, with this being week-old news, and with Stone-Wally being silenced, what's to say? We can't even get a decent protests against Howe St. going.

    Now you want us to care about an inquiry into the fates of people most of us don't even know?

  • Fish-counter

    1 year ago

    I am no champion of the oppressed women of the DTES but

    the lack of interest in this article suggests no one cares. Pickton probably killed 49 women before he was arrested. Dozens have disappeared on the Trail of Tears and dozens of BC cops are themselves on charges for breaking the law, and they have failed to lay a single charge after the Stanley Cup Riots.

    Am I the only person who sees a common thread to these undisputed facts? The RCMP and the other police in the Greater Vancouver area are on strike. They must have decided to stop enforcing the law about five years ago, and they are sticking with it.

    When the London cops killed one kid, there were riots for over a week in London and all acrioss England. The coppers had people in jail the next day and dozens have been charged and are now in jail doing time.

    The Vancouver cops are still poring over the videos, claiming that the optical quality isn't as good as the London cameras. Even those who have confessed have yet to be charged. Again I say, the cops are on strike. They just haven't told anyone.

    The impoverished women of the DTES are the chronic but hidden example of police impotence and failure to provide duty of care. The businesses in the West End that were trashed by the Stanley Cup riots are harder to ignore.

    Yes, we should care about people we don't know, and even those we don't like, because they are us, we are they, and we are all together.

    Something is rotten in the state of Denmark and in BC.

  • morechatter

    1 year ago

    Its all a Sham

    Scampbell, the previous mayor ensures things are in shambles before he leaves.
    Things have only gotten worst for people leaving on the DTES with the shelters temporary hiding the problem until the homeless are put back out on the streets.
    There are people in the shelters who can't look after themselves who are required to go and find a place as eviction at the shelter is up at the end of the month.

    In need of protection? Fear for your life?
    Are you a female? Good luck with that on the DTES as from the stats your numbers up.

  • morechatter

    1 year ago

    how are they living?

    They aren't living they are dying. As many leave the DTES for good.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.