- Ms Kaye is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Mary Carlisle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Prem Gill is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nancy Flight is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Justin Everett is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- John Westover is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Nora Etches is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Edward Henderson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Bharadwaj Chandramouli is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Dean Chatterson is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Marius Scurtescu is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Robert Parkes is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- James Murton is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Susan Doyle is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Vincent Strgar is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Helen Spiegelman is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Subir Guin is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Kimball Finigan is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- Joanne Manley is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
- David Leach is a Tyee Builder. You can be, too.
Protect Us from Assaults, Say Psych Nurses
BC mental health workers and their unions pressing for new safety measures.
'It's terrifying': warding off beatings part of job says nurse.
Few people go to work and get spit on, bitten or verbally threatened by the people they work for. You'd have to be a cop. A correctional officer. A fetishist.
But at Eric Martin Pavilion, a mental health facility on Vancouver Island, that kind of treatment is just another part of the job for the nurses and workers on the front line.
In August of last year, a patient beat a psychiatric nurse so severely she could not return to work. This March, the same patient attacked and repeatedly punched another nurse as they attempted to slide medication into the patient's room.
At Eric Martin, health care workers face the constant threat of patient violence. According to one nurse, it's gotten much worse over the past decade. She says it's a combination of provincial changes to the treatment of mental health and addictions patients, erratic security and deteriorating facilities that make working as a psychiatric nurse so dangerous.
The crisis at Eric Martin reflects a wider threat of violence against health care workers across the province, and according to some, an outdated industry tradition of tolerating violence and blaming employees for their injuries.
Unions are looking at regional health authorities to fix the problem, and the authorities say they are on the right track. Still, the assaults on health care workers continue.
'It's terrifying'
Eric Martin Pavilion is located in a six-floor building across the street from the Royal Jubilee Hospital in Victoria. In many ways, its cement-walled ambience fits the image of a Hollywood psychiatric ward.
Psychiatric nurse Shannon Breeze began work there 28 years ago. The physical structure of the place hasn't much changed, she says, but it's the increasing threat of patient violence that she worries about now.
"It's terrifying," said Breeze. "You can't have that level of aggression and not have turnover."
Breeze estimates that the locked ward has lost about 40 staff in the last six years. She has stories of nurses being choked and pummeled by patients, their heads bashed into concrete floors. She said she frequently sees biting, kicking, punching, spitting and verbal threats.
"Most of our people will say they see violence on a weekly basis," said Breeze.
The violence is reflected in injury compensation claims of health care workers in B.C. According to WorkSafeBC statistics obtained by The Tyee, more than 350 claims were made by workers in long term or acute care after experiencing an act of violence in 2009.
To compare, that same year law enforcement claimed 31 violent injuries. Bar and nightclub workers claimed 22 injuries.
Always, there's the memory of David Bland, a rehabilitation counselor at Richmond Mental Health who was murdered by a former patient in 2005. His death is a constant reminder of the risks faced everyday by mental health workers.
Volatile mix
According to Breeze, a number of factors increase the workplace danger factor.
For one, the province began integrating the treatment of mental health and addictions patients in 2002. Consequently, three different types of patients are sent to Eric Martin -- mentally ill, addictions, or some combination of both -- a meld she says nurses are unprepared to deal with.
"Suddenly, there's a mix of mental health clients, some with addiction, some not, but the mix is more volatile," said Breeze. "There was no extra funding, no adequate training, no safety mechanisms for the mix."
Former mental health care worker Lori Strom, now a staff representative for the B.C. Government Employees' Union, agrees that violence prevention training is inadequate. She started working for the union after one of her co-workers was beaten by a client until he was brain damaged.
"There is such a fear that if you're going to train the staff to defend themselves when they're being attacked, that they're going to go too far, but that's never been the case," Strom said.
"It's a very touchy, very difficult subject," she added. "Part of the problem is that health care sector employers are afraid to take a look at that, and the result is that workers are not safe."
Design increases danger
Breeze says that if patients get aggressive, the security measures that support nurses aren't always consistent.
"Some hospitals just have private security guards, guys making $10 an hour," she said. "They're not going to be the ones that are going to step between you and a thrown object."
The quality of facilities also affects violence, says Marty Lovick of the Health Sciences Association of B.C., a union that represents more than 16,000 health care workers in the province.
The risk is higher in aging buildings with nooks and crannies, and no mirrors to see what lies around the corner. Some facilities are laid out so that workers end up alone with aggressive residents, and some of the rooms lack emergency call buttons.
But it isn't just patient demographics, security, or crummy buildings that increase the threat of violence. Breeze calls it the "culture of blaming the worker" found throughout B.C.'s mental health and addiction services. Lovick calls it the "just pull up your socks and work" attitude.
Somehow, getting spit on or smacked in the face has become a regular part of the job. While there are inherent risks in mental health care, Breeze and Lovick say patient violence is something that should be taken more seriously by regional health authorities.
"People are putting up with [violence]," said Lovick, "and then when the worst case happens, it's because the tone has been to accept abuse and aggression and swearing and spitting, as opposed to having a policy that would have it dealt with at an earlier stage."
Lovick says the Vancouver Island Health Authority (VIHA) -- which governs workplace safety at Eric Martin -- "is involved, but isn't putting a firm action plan in place and isn't organizing audits."
"We're not confident that this health authority, or any health authority, is reporting things properly."
Safety survey cut
In 2009, the Occupational Health and Safety Agency for Healthcare in B.C.(OHSAH) surveyed over 2,500 health care workers in the province.
More than 80 per cent said they had experienced violence at work, but only 36 per cent said there were adequate violence prevention mechanisms at work. And less than half felt prepared to deal with violence. The survey also found that violent acts were often unreported.
"There's an unwritten rule not to report scratches, bites, threats," said Pam Piddocke, occupational health and safety officer of the BC Nurses Union. "The only time you report is if you end up leaving work because you've been beaten up so badly that you can't go back."
However, OHSAH won't be following up on the survey this year. The province cut the program's funding, and the agency is in the process of shutting down.
"It's unfortunate when you're seeing statistics like this, that they're cutting the only organization that was actually being proactive and working towards solving some of the problems in health care for worker safety," Piddocke said.
"They're making it more unsafe, at a time when it's becoming worse."
B.C. Ministry of Health spokesperson Ryan Jab stated that rather than having one central organization to deal with violence in health care, the province is transitioning to a violence prevention system "that is more reflective of the current requirements and accountabilities of the health authorities."
"It doesn't make sense to continue with a separate organization and infrastructure to do things we can do using current staff and infrastructure," wrote Jab via email.
If changes are in the works, that is news to Marty Lovick at HSA.
"If the ministry is taking a leading role in directing change, any specific initiatives have not been shared by them with the unions, to the best of our knowledge," Lovick said. "We would welcome a consistent approach being fostered by the ministry."
'An evolving culture'
While Lovick and Breeze say that health authorities could be doing much more to reduce violence and blame in the workplace, the Vancouver Island Health Authority (VIHA) disagrees.
Darren Buckler, VIHA's manager of prevention and health promotion, says that risk prevention and safety has become a "huge focus" of the health authority.
A WorkSafeBC officer is helping VIHA create violence in the workplace programming, he says. Creating a safety culture for health care workers is one of the authority's four "system-wide initiatives," and VIHA is training coaches -- some of them injured workers on compensation -- to teach employees about various safety issues.
Buckler adds that VIHA has "stepped up" its workplace inspections, and is "moving away from the notion of blaming workers."
"No, we haven't done everything," said Buckler. "This is an evolving culture, safety culture is evolving."
"I think we're on the right track," Buckler said, "and we keep trying to come up with strategies to do more."
Breeze plans to continue working as a psychiatric nurse for another 13 years, so long as the conditions at Eric Martin change for good. She said VIHA's initiatives are a great start, but front line workers have yet to see the impact.
"The biggest thing is actually making it work on the ground," said Breeze. "These are people who are facing violence literally on a daily basis."
"You just can't be scared going to work." ![]()




11
Login or register to post comments
driftwolf
1 year ago
not just psyche
It's not just psyche nurses, it's all nurses.
Mainly because psyche nurses (at least locally) don't (or can't) do a number of simple, common medical procedures. So these patients are sent to other floors - floors with even less safeguards.
But it's not just the psyche patients. Even patients who aren't diagnosed with mental illness will lash out at nurses. There isn't one shift at our local hospital when at least one nurse on shift gets hurt by a patient. Sometimes it's just a bruise, other times it's much more serious.
Management? They don't care. Report after report gets filed, and vanishes into a black void. Meanwhile, the violent, non-psyche patients get to keep coming back (they're often "frequent flyers") and nothing is done - no charges laid for assault, no consent to restrain, nothing.
Yes, something does need to be done, and VIHA isn't doing it.
warbler
1 year ago
Mentally ill only a threat to themselves... sure
I think this is part of a larger, misguided liberal, civil rights attitude (the same one that resulted in the policy of de-institutionalization) that continues to insist the mentally ill are, for the most part, not a threat to others, but only themselves. This is simply not true, and this article if proof of that. I qualify this by saying the potential for violence in this segment of our population is greatly diminished if they receive PROPER mental health care and treatment, which they do not under our health care system, and this is tragic. They do not get that care because it's allegedly a violation of their civil rights to force treatment on them. I'm not suggesting a return to the 1950's, but the paradigm in how we view this question needs to radically shift.
As for driftwolf's claim, I'd venture to guess those "non-psyche" violent patients at regular hospitals you speak of are actually suffering mental illness and are in need of that PROPER care and treatment, or jail time. I do agree with you that the buck stops with management and VIHA, as well as the health ministers at both provincial and federal levels. These bureaucrats, too, seem especially infected with this false belief that the mentally ill are merely lost souls generally incapable of hurting anyone other than themselves. Or is more that they don't want to open this Pandora's Box, because to do so would require huge spending to address the issue, not to mention the various legal implications at play.
driftwolf
1 year ago
@warbler
I agree with you that many of those violent patients SHOULD be psyche patients. Most seem to be either drug addicts (booze, meth, etc.) or geri-psyche (confused older folks whose family refuses to face the fact that their aging grandparents have, in fact, lost it).
I'd add that the treatment of mental illness is horribly under-reported and under-funded in this province (and others). Probably due to the stigma attached to mental illness that seems to blame the victim for that illness, and thus sees no point in funding treatment or even decent care, for some reason.
Samuel
1 year ago
violence and mental illnes
Having worked in this field in the past, I realize this (violence) issue is very real.
However, the fact remains that the institutions that "house" or contain people with mental illnesses, and the entire mental health care system itself, since people are often held against their wills, can be considered state violence.
I understand this kind of talk will make nurses roll their eyes, but we need to understand how oppressive this system is for people who are labelled and institutionalized.
For more info on the other side of things, I suggest reading psychiatrist Dr. Thomas Szasz:
http://www.szasz.com/
dorothy
1 year ago
Blame?
Maybe we're getting too mainstream moral here. I think it is not so much a question of blame as it is of acknowledging, that this is multi-faceted, and very little in there is black or white.
A few years ago, I would, as a health care worker, have stood with the pack that very ready to brand some patients as 'violent people'. Now I am less sure it is that simple. Meanwhile, a senior member of my family has suffered a series of debilitating attacks of major illnesses, necessitating long-term care and rehab, plus surgery and again long-term life-sustaining therapy.
I am sure that the environment and the repetitive, sometimes onerous nature of the jobs that surround such situations, as well as the sometimes unbearably drab environs, all of this drains the serotonin levels of both patients and health care workers. It certainly looks as if quite often, my relative got into situations with nurses and other caregivers, where mild and occasionally not-so-mild one-upmanship came his way, and usually he had no inkling of having provoked such behaviour, and he did not complain, seeing that he well understood the psychological parameters involved. I had opportunity a few times to observe and even together with my family member, be on the receving end of less than friendly behaviours on the part of health care workers. Not usually of the aggressive sort, more like varying degrees of cendescension. Likewise, of course, my relative was often 'tired of' other patients and saw them deal out less than friendly returns to the atempts of nurses and others of 'cheering them up'. What I am saying is, that environemts where chronically ill people reside for a while, they and their caregivers would have to be darn near angels, if things were never to deteriorate into mutual 'pecking'.
...more
dorothy
1 year ago
the more
I think that when you are dealing with not just ill, but mentally ill people, and addicts, which is a sub-category of the same thing (as in not being rational), things can go very bad very quickly, if caregivers are not downright superhuman. There is no question of 'blame' here, it's just the situation.
So what can we do to improve things? I think for sure that the self-defense training mentioned in the article is a necessity. The reason given for not providing it is completelty harebrained. This is not how it works,. Knowing that you can handle yourself will give added confidence, and this will come across to patients as greater security. Violence is generally a result of someone not feeling secure, and reacting badly to that feeling. I am not completely unfamiliar with dealing with mentally ill people, as I have worked in two facilities where there were such patients, and I got to do work for them. What was most glaringly obvious to me as a general observation was that they were first and foremost looking for reassurance. My guess is, that people now - with good reaon - are fearful of such patients, and this works againsnt them. Get that training to everybody ASAP, and things should get better. There are other things you could do, but this is the one I think is the biggie.
alive
1 year ago
keep cool!
I realize that situations happen where no amount of preparedness and goodwill can avoid incidents that could hurt a caregiver.
Having said that, let us remember that many jobs carry risks and whoever applies for such a job fully well knows that.
What we read here is not that different from what a fireman, soldier or police officer can encounter; they choose their careers and seem to be surprised when shit happens.
There is only so much prevention possible, it is up to the individual to step back and request assistance if in doubt.
That goes for police as well as nurses, keep a cool head and accept that you were choosen and trained to handle such situations.
I can only hope that such jobs are paid well!
max von smartt
1 year ago
more male nurses
a higher ratio of male nurses should be strived for and all workers should be trained in basic self defense and practice when the threat of patient violence is significant. and there are lots of nut cases in the general population to be wary of too.
b_guiled
1 year ago
self-defence basics
I've talked with a number of seniors' care workers, who say that that they regularly get swacked at and worse by their clients. No surprise, then, that mentally & emotionally challenged people of all ages can be abusive.
This interests me, because I've been teaching traditional, non-sport, non-competitive karate for 13 years now. This form of the art (not the tournament kind) has all sorts of unusual, quick, graceful moves for dealing with aggression. The aim to gain control, not to dominate, but for a peace-restoring, win-win outcome.
I think that a few self-defence basics should be taught to all caregivers working with potentially risky charges. Why is this not part of the curriculum?
zalm
1 year ago
Wonder when....
Psych nurses got changed to "psyche" nurses?
dorothy
1 year ago
Zalm
So did I ,but i could not imagine Marty hadn't proof-read the article, and he ought to know better...so I thought it was the newfangled name.