North Island Dreams of Better Days
Its aging, shrinking population earns below the BC average. How to turn things around?
Sointula on Malcolm Island.
Drive north from Campbell River up Highway 19, and you see no farms or ranches. It's just one enormous wood lot, rarely interrupted by small towns.
The towns are getting smaller.
A century ago, the North Island and the whole central coast were studded with working settlements -- logging camps, canneries, fishing villages. Steamers linked them to Victoria and Vancouver, but they were sturdy, self-sufficient communities.
In the glory days of the 1950s and '60s, people made a lot of money. On Malcolm Island, Sointula old-timers recall when their fishing village was one of the most prosperous communities, per capita, in the country. Port McNeill went from a logging camp to a thriving small town.
The pub owner in Holberg remembers the 1970s, when Winter Harbour at night glowed with the lights of 200 commercial fishing boats. Now it lives on a few sport-fishing operations, catering to rich Albertans and Americans.
An aging, shrinking population
The demographics of the North Island aren't encouraging. According to B.C. Stats, the population of the region in 2006 was 12,489 -- about the same as one square kilometre of downtown Vancouver. The region's total population has fallen about 2 per cent a year over the last decade.
That population is aging as well as shrinking. In 2006, about a quarter of North Islanders were young people under 18. By 2016, they'll be down to about one in five. Seniors were 7.7 per cent of the population in 2006, and by 2016 they'll be 13.6 per cent.
Economically, North Islanders have been doing poorly. In the 2000 census, average family income was $62,800 -- $2,000 below the provincial average. And that income was unevenly distributed, with the poorer half of the population living on 24 per cent of the total regional income.
Businesses aren't flourishing. According to the North Island Gazette, Western Forest Products operations are closing down for the rest of the summer in Port McNeill, Holberg and Englewood. Across the street from the Port McNeill ferry terminal, a building has been for rent for two years; it used to sell coffee and gifts to travellers. The Sointula Co-op, in business since 1909, lost $50,000 last year. The Wild Island Café, across the street, has reportedly gone into receivership.
Young and restless
Kirié McMurchy, a Sointula teenager, doesn't see much of a future in the North Island for her generation: "There were eight students from Sointula who graduated from high school this year. One is staying here to work for half a year and then go on to post secondary. One is staying for the time being and will most likely make his living doing odd manual labour jobs like his father. One is going to Malaspina [soon to be Vancouver Island University] in Nanaimo to become a ticketed carpenter and may or may not return here to work.
"The other five are going to UVic, SFU, Okanagan College, Mt. Saint Vincent in Halifax, and Queen's in Kingston (that would be me). Of the latter five, although all of us love it here dearly, we don't have plans to return in the foreseeable future."
Hard hit by forestry crisis
Claire Trevena, the North Island NDP MLA, sees the region's chief problem as the B.C. government: "There's little commitment to the North Island in health care, education and jobs."
She says the forest industry is in crisis. "We have a new forests minister, but no sign of leadership. We see untenable cut levels and jobs being shipped out."
Catherine Bell, North Island's federal MP and another New Democrat, agrees: "Most loggers on the North Island will be out of their jobs until possibly next year. Many of them only worked a few weeks this year.
"The softwood lumber agreement... sold out the government's ability to directly help forest-dependent communities, industry and workers. Any such help would be seen as a subsidy by the U.S., and Canada could be sued under NAFTA rules for violating the SLA."
Fishing is another problem area. Bell says, "The fear with a decline in the salmon stocks is that if we lose any more species or if they are declared endangered... it could shut down all fishing for commercial and sport for the entire coast of B.C. Sport fishing accounts for the bulk of revenue generated from all fishing in B.C."
One new industry has started up: a huge quarry north of Port McNeill, producing sand and gravel for U.S. and Vancouver construction companies. Apparently it's cheaper to ship gravel from the North Island to California than to truck it into San Francisco and Los Angeles from nearby quarries. Whether this venture will survive the current collapse of the U.S. housing market remains to be seen.
Tourism helps, a little
Is tourism the answer? "We're working hard to develop tourism," Trevena says, "but tourism alone won't sustain communities. It's an important add-on, but that's all."
Statistics bear her out. In 2000, the Mount Waddington Regional District reported that forestry jobs earned 44 per cent of the North Island's income. Jobs in the public sector generated 21 per cent of the income. Fishing and trapping earned six per cent, agriculture two per cent, mining one per cent, and tourism eight per cent.
"On the bright side," says Catherine Bell, "the opening of the North Coast Trail this year should attract wilderness hikers from around the world (but not likely in enough numbers to offset the other losses)."
Despite the stunning beauty of the region, most travellers see the North Island at a distance, from the decks of cruise ships. The 'Namgis town of Alert Bay on Cormorant Island is home to a brilliant community of Aboriginal artists, but it got attention only when Oprah, a guest on Jimmy Pattison's yacht, dropped in last year.
Fuel costs affect tourists and residents alike. Trevena says the impending rise in ferry fares will be "devastating." One welcome development is a new bus line running from Port Hardy to Port McNeill and then on to Woss. "It's needed for access to health care," Trevena says. "We have lots of poor people who need transportation."
The North Island may soon see more people in need of transportation right out of the region: on Nov. 30, the Elk Falls pulp mill will shut down, costing about 440 workers their jobs.
You can't go home again
This is especially disturbing because the region has always been one of working towns that proudly paid their own way. Now the money is coming from outsiders who buy waterfront houses, sight unseen, for $300,000 -- and then live in them for maybe a month or two every summer.
Becoming a getaway for rich Vancouverites and Americans isn't just a step down for the North Island. It means young people like Kirié McMurchy and her classmates will never be able to afford to come back.
Visitors and residents alike seem to have mixed feelings about the future. They'd like the North Island to stay the way it is, but they realize it can't.
"Why don't we have a Canadian IKEA?" asks Claire Trevena. The raw logs of the region go elsewhere for processing, when local industries could turn them into more than shakes and carvings.
Investing in infrastructure
More public-sector jobs would probably lead to more jobs in the private sector as well. North Island College has closed some of its local campuses. But an expanded college would give young people a reason to stay, while attracting more professionals to the region.
Government agencies could also expand their presence. A railway from Nanaimo to Port Hardy could carry forestry products and tourists as well.
Trevena says the provincial government is ignoring rural communities in general. "We need jobs, education, and health care to attract people. Why should people not have them?"
Early this summer, a grizzly bear was seen in the water off the east end of Malcolm Island. Evidently it had made the long swim from the mainland.
Perhaps it then walked across the 18-km island and swam west from the Pulteney Point lighthouse, because on July 11 a grizzly was seen near Cluxewe Resort on Vancouver Island, north of Port McNeill. Somewhere on northern Vancouver Island, that grizzly is exploring its opportunities. It may have better prospects than the people already living there.
Related Tyee stories:
- Tale of Two Strikes
Forestry strike spotlights 'suffering' side of BC. - Corky Evans on Making the Woods Work
Markets are good, logging can be honourable, and the left must lay claim to the language of the right to achieve its goals. - Carbon Tax Screws BC's North?
Finance Minister Taylor defends its fairness, rural or not.




18
Login or register to post comments
Jeffrey J.
3 years ago
Provincial Liberals Undermine Rural BC
A great snap shot detailing the fall-out from the neo-con policies of Gordon Campbell free market regime. Once the forest companies were given free reign to export raw logs and shut down wood supplies to local mills, the result was a foregone conclusion. Most of the wood has been highgraded and logging operations are being shut down.
Now they've pulled out of logging and focus instead on real estate development. Commercial fishing was ignored by the government while it too fell to corporate interests. At the same time, tourism has always been opposed by North Island local governments, because they didn't' fit with the logging or mining industry. Now, the North Island has virtually nothing left to fall back on.
A very, very difficult time for its residents. A great article covering the plight of rural BC.
dave49
3 years ago
Wind farms for the North Island
If you look at the BC Environmental Assessment Office website, this map shows certified projects http://www.eao.gov.bc.ca/maps/EAOProjectsCertifiedPostDec02_070525.pdf.
There are two proposed wind farms, Knob Hill and Holberg, that have completed the Environmental Assessment process. They will be applying to the BC Hydro Clean Power call of June 2008. If successful (BCH decides summer 2009), they could probably start construction in spring 2010.
Michael
3 years ago
Oil and gas?
So reading betwen the lines, is The Tyee arguing for oil and gas drilling off the North Coast resulting in an economic renaissance in the Interior, much like you see in Saskatchewan and Newfoundland?
Skywalker
3 years ago
Wind Farms?
That will really offset the loss of forestry resource jobs. I can hardly contain my excitement.
dogs
3 years ago
Misleading Forestry Information
Again, I see nothing positive from either NDP member - blaming the down turn in the forest industry on the current Government. Gee may be it might have to do with the drop in house starts from 2.1 million in 06 to the latest (Forest Web) figure of 637,000. Logs haven't been processed on the North Island for decades-very few are exported out of BC from this year as most of the Timber is Crown- they go to lower mainland mills. As cutting too much timber I believe this TSA is well under cut and the Crown cut on the coast in general is well under cut. The MLA should check her facts. Again the NDP offers no soultions. I would like to see new mills on the coast but who would invest in BC- besides the modern mills will offer a lot less employment than our current outdated mills- just look at the three new mills in Washington State.
Sam Salmon
3 years ago
There is no
There is no hope-none.
Labour intensive resource extraction jobs are gone never to return-tourism has it's Golden 100 Days and mcjobs and then disappears.
Wind farms haven't brought any prosperity to rural Europe and they won't here, a few jobs here and there and that's it.
Frank
3 years ago
Its the NDP's fault, yay!
Yes, we should never blame government for their policies, we should instead blame the opposition.
I for one believe China's human rights record is Glen Clark's fault, after all, I don't recall Clark ever making a speech about the issue.
It's also cool to learn that the North Island's problems just started when the credit crisis hit the US. Everything was hunky-dory before that apparently.
Now I think we need to all join hands and sing the Right's favourite song, "Don't blame Campbell, nothing is his fault..."
RickW
3 years ago
North Island Elects NDP Members,
So Campbell ignores the entire area until the folks there "do the right thing", namely:
1] vote liberal;
2] move to the "big city";
3] die.
ME2
3 years ago
Where's the hope?
It's easy to blame today's politicians for the plight of our rural communities, but it is undeniable that the story of bleeding the rural communities of their resources in order to feed urban populations is as old as civilisation.
To be sure, the Socreds and now Campbell have presided over the demise of our forest industry with their giveaways to the Corporations, but the old IWA and its handmaiden NDP were also bound to the system of maintaining the antiquated log butchering sawmills and pulpmills in order to keep an urban workforce employed.
And as that very system now gasps its dying breaths, it's kept on life-support by high-grading the last few old-growth Cedars and scattered Douglas Firs, with little concern expressed by the urbanites.
Even at this late date, there is likely enough OG left to allow the setting up of sustainable small scale saw milling in the local communities which could recover the full value out of these logs that the big mills are unable to do.
Just as the Forest industry kept itself afloat by not paying fair market value for its logs, such is now the case in the fishing industry which is now almost fully controlled by Corporate people like Pattison.
But even today you'll likely not find enough support in these communities for taking the logging and fishing back.
As Sam Salmon says in one of his too rare posts :
"There is no hope-none."
no1important
3 years ago
This is yet another reason
This is yet another reason why corporatism is a failure.
...and these rural people will still vote for the likes of El Gordo.
Skywalker
3 years ago
You got it right, Frank!
You now have dogs (the poster) blaming world economic issues. Funny how these guys never admit that it was commodity prices that saved Campbell's bacon. When they want an excuse for liberal inaction, indeed incompetence, then it is the global situation that is to blame. on the other side everything that happens in the world must be Clark's fault. "If it is good, it must be because of Campbell; if it is bad, it must be because of (Place any NDP member's name here).
After every resource is sold off to the corporations so they can make great profits and the citizenry wakes up to what has happened, guess who they will blame?
ME2
3 years ago
skywlker
You ask :
"......guess who they will blame?"
Why, us greedy consumers, of course. Whom else?
RickW
3 years ago
It's good tro know where the money comes from.....
....for this government's priorities:
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2008/08/08/bc-salry-hike.html
KWD
3 years ago
the free market myth
“A century ago, the North Island and the whole central coast were studded with working settlements -- logging camps, canneries, fishing villages. Steamers linked them to Victoria and Vancouver, but they were sturdy, self-sufficient communities.”
Understanding the falacy contained in this statement is key to understanding why there is little hope of finding a solution, not only for the North Island economic collapse but, on a global scale, for (so-called) free market economies everywhere.
North Van Isle communities may have been sturdy (whatever that means) but they were certaninly not self-sufficient.
Self-sufficiency implies an ability to survive alone, without external aid. The fact that once the easily-accessed fish and forests disappeared, so did the communities, should make it abundantly clear that they weren’t self-sufficient … they were entirely dependant upon external markets for their survival.
And it matters not a wit whether the political leaning is left or right, the outcome would be the same.
We are slowly becoming aware … unfortunately by circumstance, not choice … that we live in a finite world, and infinite growth is a neo-con myth. But I seriously doubt we can alter the outcome if the sociopolitco ideologies that limit our thinking persist.
G West
3 years ago
KWD
I'd suggest you need to do some research into the way certain Scandinavian communities and countries have managed their resources in order to understand why your statement above here is misleading and inaccurate.
Repeating the same mistakes is evidence of mental laziness, not evidence of unchanging reality.
There are, and will hopefully always be, alternatives to our current system of McCapitalism.
KWD
3 years ago
Thanks for the suggestion ...
Yes there are alternatives but let’s deal with reality. Last I looked global resource hegemony was in the hands of China (authoritarian centrally planned capitalism or Stalinist capitalism), the U$ (free-market capitalism) and to a limited extent, India and Russia … not certain Scandinavian communities and countries.
Despite the presence of the latter and the way they manage their resources, the evidence pointing to economic calamity as a result of the mindset of those in control is overwhelming.
ME2
3 years ago
KWD
You write :
"Self-sufficiency implies an ability to survive alone, without external aid. The fact that once the easily-accessed fish and forests disappeared, so did the communities, should make it abundantly clear that they weren’t self-sufficient … they were entirely dependant upon external markets for their survival."
But places like Vancouver, BC, and Canada, are also "entirely dependant upon external markets for their survival" - such is the inherent fallacy found in dependance upon exploitative resource capitalism. It's only that the crunch is always felt first in the boonies.
OTOH, Socialistic countries like Norway seek to retain some of the profits gained from the exploitation of resources like oil for use after the boom times have gone.
Our timber's gone, our fish are gone, and we don't seem to care. What will we do when our oil and gas is gone, our rivers all dammed, and the mines played out, when all we'll be left with is debt from the good times?
When we haven't retained any investment capital, and we haven't any resource inducements to attract any from out-of-country, who's going to be better off - us or Norway?
But why worry anyway? The next generations can figure that one out, eh?
Budd Campbell
3 years ago
THREE NEW MILLS IN WASH
dogs
... besides the modern mills will offer a lot less employment than our current outdated mills- just look at the three new mills in Washington State.
Where are these three new mills and who owns them? What is their market given the fall in US housing construction?