Life

The Jane Austen Guide to Manliness

Or how not to be suckered by today's heavily marketed 'masculinity crisis.'

By Shannon Rupp, 23 Feb 2013, TheTyee.ca

Mr_darcy.jpg

Colin Firth as Mr. Darcy in BBC adaptation of 'Pride and Prejudice.'

Related

This year's 200th anniversary of Pride and Prejudice arrives not a moment too soon to deal with the current crisis in manliness.

Have you missed the memo on this? Masculinity is in question everywhere as the marketing techniques that were once limited to undermining women's confidence seem to have invaded Boys' Town. A couple of decades ago, I thought it was just the New Age Wingnuts who claimed masculinity was in decline and sent men to bang a drum in the woods. As too many New Agers tend to be Ayn Randian style right-wingers who preach individual power -- which they will happily sell you -- I paid little attention. But by the time the noughties arrived, the internet-enabled Culture of Narcissism led to all sorts of oversharing by both sexes, and men began stewing over their inadequacies publicly as if they were characters in a Nick Hornby novel.

A few years later, what I now recognize as Son of DrumBeat arrived. I was vaguely amused by this second generation of male angst in the form of things like the Art of Manliness website, mostly because I thought it was satire. The design recalls 19th-century typography and the advice reads the way those 1930s high school education reels sounded. The section on "manly skills" offers tips on how to do such ordinary things as driving a stick shift or shuffling cards, while more exotic skills -- how to dress stylishly to conceal a handgun -- seem likely to appeal to NRA supporters. Need to know how to use a flashlight in a tactical situation? You will find the 411 here.

Taken as a package, it suggests the audience is made up of more than 150,000 particularly dim young men with neo-conservative fantasies -- there's advice on how to pick handcuffs! -- and it's very funny in that ironic way.

Then my guy pals began pointing out that given the sheer volume of websites, books, and workshops addressing the sorry state of manhood there must be least one or two serious endeavours to inspire the mockery. Suddenly I began noticing marketing campaigns for goods and services urging inferior male specimens to buy back their elusive masculinity.

It turns out the manliness craze is more than just the occasional eccentric professor, a retro barbershop or two, or even a WikiHow Be-Manly primer -- it's a marketing technique.

I'm sorry to see the boys have succumbed to what I long-ago dubbed Magazine Inferiority Complex. Much is written about the sense of failure women suffer from the sales psychology behind fashion mags particularly. The editorial is designed to make readers feel insecure about everything from the size of their butts to their sexual prowess while advertisers deliver a host of products designed to solve their imaginary problems. It's mercantile genius: the cosmetics business alone generates an estimated $50 billion annually in just the U.S., and that's before we consider the surgical solutions.

Apparently a generation of relentless harping on some imaginary male failings has led to marketers preying on men's now-enfeebled minds which have been primed to hand over the plastic for pretty much anything that promises them a return to true masculinity.

Stuff like the Wilderness Collective's camping tours for guys who want to "become truly great through wilderness adventure." And by wilderness, they mean trips to well-groomed parks with paved roads. This marketing video celebrates one of their man-building forays into roughing it on motorcycles, with a caravan of chefs in tow. They provide gourmet meals featuring artisanal cheeses and craft cocktails, because nothing says manly like a gin and tonic in a rugged tin cup.

"Candy-assed metrosexuals!" fumes a critic commenting on the video, which I encourage you to watch. This romantic, soft focus extravaganza is paired with one of the funniest scripts I've ever heard, delivered by a confident moron who does a passable imitation of radio superstar Ira Glass.

There's some dispute over whether this is a joke since the hilarious voice-over delivers gems like, "In an age of eroding masculinity where men are depicted as weak, and blundering, and misguided, and shallow, men need to be ever more intentional to carve out time for camaraderie, for adventure, and for introspection."

Sure. Or maybe they should just be seen in fewer videos like this one brandishing a crème brûlée torch to light the grill? Just a thought.

What would Jane have you do?

But as I watched I realized the whole sorry manliness movement should stop worrying about how to tie bow ties or wield shotguns or whatever supposedly masculine task will redeem them and just read Jane Austen to learn how to man-up.

Contrary to pop-culture interpretations, Austen wasn't a romance writer, she was a social satirist and she is an excellent guide to life -- not least because there are few things as horrifying as realizing you just acted like one of the twits in her novels. I've been advising men to read her since my undergrad days when guy friends would tell me tales of romantic woe only to punctuate the story with Freud's old chestnut, "What do women want?"

It's recently come to my attention that not a single one of them took my advice.

"It's just that her work always sparks a discussion on the swoony merits of either Mr. Darcy or Colin Firth," protested my otherwise well-read pal John, in his own defence.

For that I blame TV and movie producers who obviously skipped the book too. While Colin Firth is undeniably swoon-worthy in that clingy wet shirt (the single most viewed Austen clip on YouTube), Mr. Darcy of the novel is not. He's kind of a pill. When I first read the book at about 16, I was pulling for Wickham (the villain of the story) because he is so darn charming. And apparently he cuts a dash in his red officer's uniform.

But Darcy wins us over eventually, as he does Elizabeth, because of two prosaic qualities: he proves to be both kind and reliable.

"Not because he has 10,000 pounds a year and Pemberley?" my cynical pal Christopher always asks. (He's only seen the swoony adaptations.)

Build character

Well, who doesn't want some variation on Downton Abbey, as long as we don't have to clean it? But no. That's not the take-away point. This is: men should not underestimate the power of character.

Character is such an old-fashioned word, but I suspect that's what has really led to Mr. Darcy's enduring popularity over the last 200 years. And why Austen's insightful books hook men too (but only if they deign to read her). Superficially, Darcy is far from the ideal guy. He's something of an inept young fool at 27. But he is also the guy we can rely on when things fall apart -- and don't we all want him in our lives?

That's one of the chief differences between Austen and the romance writers she satirizes: her heroes are exceedingly good at doing the decent, upstanding thing. Unlike the Brontë sisters, who arrived three decades later and produced those kinky potboilers featuring sadomasochistic relationships. They serve as templates for today's formula romance novel industry and their heroes actually resemble Austen's villains -- narcissists, psychopaths, and stalkers.

Which brings me back to the manliness industry. As I laughed my way through the butch-it-up products and advice, I wondered who would be pathetic enough to pass off a mock wilderness camp as character building? Then I thought of the evil Wickham, Mr. Darcy's nemesis, who made a career of conning people through what we've now dubbed image-building. Today, he wouldn't just be one of the doofuses on that trip -- he'd be the marketing genius behind the company.  [Tyee]

Read more: Gender + Sexuality

13  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Doug Alder

    13 weeks ago

    To the point

    We now see commercials on TV with a somewhat rugged man applying testosterone to his armpits, because you know if you're male, in your 40s or older then you must be low on T and in need of it to compete with all those younger studs.

  • Hakuin

    13 weeks ago

  • Feverish

    13 weeks ago

    Shannon!

    Great piece to start the weekend with - thanks.

    The video is very funny... hard to believe it is not parody.

    Favourite comment: "And I think all men everywhere just wished they could join you"

    I did not share his sentiment cos my stubble is totally inadequate and I look better in earth tones rather than in red.

  • Jeffrey J.

    13 weeks ago

    Brilliant Prose!

    Another piece de resistance by BC's own Shannon Rupp. We Tyee readers are absolutely SPOILED with some of the best writing in the world. Such a gift.

    But I can't help but reflect that 30 years ago the mainstream media (MSM) published similar authors and journalists day in, day out. To think: Greenpeace co-founder Bob Hunter was a salaried columnist for the Vancouver Sun! Everyone in Vancouver was able to read his spirited works on a weekly basis. What a sad fate has befallen these once compelling newspapers...

    But great writing abhors a vacuum. Great writing (and great writers like Ms. Rupp et al) cry out to be read. And heard.

    Thanks to the Tyee (and other brilliant independent media outlets), these voices will not be silenced. And we get to hear them. Great coverage as always.

  • lucille

    13 weeks ago

    manliness

    I think the marketers would do well instead of going after men for the size of their butts; should turn them around and aim for their guts.
    Then coin would come pouring in.. . beer/wine/spirits AIN'T yer 'friend.' jus' sayin .. .

  • Judd's

    13 weeks ago

    Manliness weekend

    The cutest thing about these, outdoorsmen, is the lime wedge in their tin cups. Whatever happened to hotdogs, buns and ketchup, all weekend because you couldn't think of anything better. Who drinks gin and tonics anyway on a camping trip. Beer and whatever hard bar you could drink straight.

  • SharonJ

    13 weeks ago

    I could not watch the whole video. I tried. But failed

    The berries, the cheeses, the limes in the tin cups. And of course, the tales of manliness. I burst out laughing, when, out in the deep wilderness, they started their camp fire with a propane torch for gods sake. Reminded me of the first Earth Battalion guys in Men Who Stare at Goats.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=tOUDbGYyXhE#!

  • Sine Nomine

    13 weeks ago

    Existentialists don't fall prey to these trappings

    I think perhaps your focus is too narrow and you should look to the broader themes that marketers in general hew to these days -- like fear. Fear of aging and death, unattractiveness, loneliness, ineptitude, disease, lack of manliness, etc ad nauseum.

    Don't diss Ayn though. She has become an all too convenient whipping girl of the ignorant and overtly pedantic. Perhaps if you'd read and understood more existentialist philosophy, you wouldn't feel the need to read books like Pride & Prejudice more than once and get drawn into all the superficial trappings of contemporary society. My mind boggles at how one can become aware of the references you used in your article. I mean who just runs into this asinine tripe, and why, and why would you endure them enough and long enough to reference them?

    What is masculinity anyway? Can such a word even be defined? If you mean the testosterone fueled physical and psychological archetypes generally accepted by the masses, then there is a good reason for the decline in masculinity; testosterone levels are in marked decline in the male populations. If you mean ruggedness, well, just take a look at how we live and you'll see it's no longer necessary to live ruggedly. Humanity has become lazy and apathetic, I think as evidenced by anyone being entertained by an article as vacuous as this.

  • JordanRoszmann

    13 weeks ago

    I have been drinking G&Ts out

    I have been drinking G&Ts out of blue ceramic camp mugs since I was 17, but if your video contains the phrase: "present in relationship, intentional in listening," you are not making a video about men going into the wild together.

    Thanks for the hilarious video, Shannon. Thanks also for reminding me that the biggest masculine heart-throb in literature was awkward and mistaken for most of his novel.

    Now I might even read the version without zombies in it.

  • dave49

    12 weeks ago

    They should send these guys to hike into Cape Scott

    Last summer, my wife and I repeated the hike into Cape Scott Provincial Park. We had done it 20 plus years earlier. This time we had our teenaged son and a friend. Closest beach is 16 kilometers. Next closest beach is 19 km. Nothing to buy. Cell phones don't work. Water can be almost a two kilometer walk. There was a park ranger at the larger beach as a resource and to warn you about the wolf in the area. Cape Scott is REALLY getting away from it all. So 'guys', your mission is to CHALLENGE yourself and do that hike without support from some tourism company. That way you will really enjoy that nip of 'fine liquid'.

  • alive

    12 weeks ago

    "Candy-asses"

    That phrase reminds me of the theme repeated endlessly on the pro wrestling shows.

    One overdevelped "Athletes" after the other mouthing off about how tough and macho they are -- and an arena full of beer-bellied suckers applauding.

    Yup, they all buy into the idea that males no longer are what they "ought to be".

    Maybe this is the only chance they have to vent about being henpecked at home?

    Yeah I see females there too, butt-watching and perhaps wishing?

  • deeby

    12 weeks ago

    pseudo-crises

    I'm not sure which is the bigger misconception: the author's apparent belief that the bourgeois angst of a few thousand white North-American males represents a real crisis in the male psyche; or, the belief on the part of some men that their need to connect with other men, and experience something which transcends the day-to-day responsibilities of fatherhood or adulthood, generalizes to a fundamental need within all men.

    The proliferation of Web sites suggests little beyond the migration of Robert Bly's disciples to a new medium, coupled with a new audience of Gen X and Y men, thinking the same things that a few white boomers did, given the leisure to opine about the source of their discontent.

    As for any role that reading Jane Austen might play, character is indeed what's required to move past self-indulgent questioning of one's place in the family and society, but that's a lot easier to summon while living in P making
    £20,000 a year. Living hand-to-mouth, supporting your spouse, children or family while you do so, as most men in the world do, leaves little time for djembes, motorcycles or Jane Austen novels.

  • Popin

    12 weeks ago

    As a man the one thing is

    As a man the one thing is expected of you- don't be weak. Don't ask for help. Don't go for wimpy camping trips. Don't get seen with limes in your cup. Get in the box. Do your duty. Man-up.