A Tyee Ethical Gift Guide

Holidays without the mall days.

By Dee Hon, 15 Dec 2005, TheTyee.ca

orca-whale

"Look, Charlie, let's face it. We all know that Christmas is a big commercial racket. It's run by a big eastern syndicate, you know," said Lucy van Pelt.

It's been forty years since Lucy spoke that cynical line in 1965's A Charlie Brown Christmas. In 2005, her words seem to ring truer than ever. For many of us, Christmas comes with the realization that dad doesn't need another tie. And Bill Gates has already earned all the cash you'd ever care to give him. It's a sentiment that has probably been around since retailers started marketing the holiday as a "Christmas shopping season" in the 1920s. Church leaders then denounced the commercialization as un-Christian.

"I think there must be something wrong with me," Charlie Brown tells Linus in the classic TV special. "Christmas is coming, but I'm not happy. I don't feel the way I'm supposed to feel. I always end up feeling depressed."

Christmas is supposed to be a time for generosity. It makes us feel good inside when we give a gift that's appreciated. But playing Santa doesn't have to mean aiding and abetting the Christmas industrial complex. There's a growing industry of gifts that benefit charities, as well.

Last Christmas, I bought my brother a gorilla. The year before, a friend of my wife bought her a flock of birds.

The gorilla, of course, didn't arrive in a cage under the tree. My brother really got a stuffed toy ape and a certificate. Most of the money I spent went to protecting gorilla habitat. The flock of birds my wife received, in fact, went to feed a family in a developing country. My wife got a small card in appreciation. Essentially, you buy someone a donation to their favourite charity and they get a token of acknowledgement of their contribution.

There are two main ways to give charity gifts. You can buy items like books, t-shirts, mugs and other trinkets from a charity where proceeds going to the cause. Or, you can make the contribution a gift in itself, usually in the form of a symbolic animal adoption. Usually, in such cases, tax receipts can be issued.

The following is a short list of charity gift ideas, but of course, it's only a fraction of what's out there. At the bottom, we invite you to add your own suggestions to expand the list of possibilities.

Gifts that give twice

Amnesty International is a worldwide champion of internationally recognized human rights. You can purchase items from their online shop or order books, videos and reports at 1-800-AMNESTY.

The BC SPCA's online store offers shirts, dog collars and other products, all at affordable prices. Proceeds help the SPCA protect the province's critters from abuse.

Canadian Feed The Children helps provide food, clean water, medical care, sanitation and education to the world's impoverished children. You can help them and help a kid in your life learn to cook by buying CFTC's youth-oriented cookbook, Feed a Young Mind.

The Canadian Red Cross makes it easy to shop and donate at the same time. By clicking this link, 7 percent of any purchase you make from Amazon.ca goes to the Canadian Red Cross. Anything from Amazon's selection of books, CDs. DVDs and video games is available. You can even buy a DVD copy of A Charlie Brown Christmas for $13.46.

The coffee-lover on your gift list might appreciate a pound of Van Houtte's Honduras San Luis coffee, which helps support CARE Canada. CARE Canada is part of an international humanitarian network committed to improving the lives of impoverished people worldwide. The coffee helps small farmer cooperatives in Honduras earn a living from their work.

In 1971, a handful of environmental activists got together in Vancouver and gave birth to Greenpeace. You can help them save the planet by buying shirts, handbags, books and "nuclear playing cards" from their online store.

The Western Canada Wilderness Committee is a BC-based organization that works to protect wilderness and wildlife in Canada. Its online store offers a wide range of books, calendars, videos, posters and other items.

The World Wildlife Federation works to protect the planet's natural environment and protect habitats for endangered animals. Its online store offers cards, mugs, shirts, backpacks, and artwork ranging in price from about $9 to $380. Many of the products come with the WWF's famous panda logo.

Can't decide? GiveMeaning.com lets you purchase a (tax deductible) gift card, then the recipient gets to choose which of their listed charities receives them. Described as a "website for the $5 philanthropist," the site can also arrange monthly donations of time or money to a specific cause or help organize a giving group - one that gets together to raise money for a specific project.

Animal and habitat adoptions

Chimpanzees are our closest animal relatives, yet we regularly subject them to abuses that make CIA renditions look like summer holidays. You can adopt a chimp from In Defense of Animals' adoption center and help provide a comfortable home for an ape rescued from abuse. Your gift recipient will receive a picture of your chimpanzee, as well as a full biography and periodic updates of his or her life in the Sanaga-Yong Chimpanzee Rescue Center in Cameroon.

You can preserve African wildlife by adopting a gorilla, lion, zebra, elephant or giraffe from the African Wildlife Foundation's adoption centre. Your recipient will get a cuddly stuffed animal, as well as a certificate and animal factsheet. Adoptions include a membership with the AWF and a subscription to its quarterly newsletter.

Pandas, polar bears, sea turtles, elephants, boreal forests and coral reefs are up for adoption at The World Wildlife Federation's online adoption centre. The WWF provides the gift recipient with a kit including a stuffed toy version of the adopted animal, a personalized adoption certificate, educational materials and other fun goodies. Tax receipts are provided. Money raised goes to protect endangered habitats.

You can also adopt a local Orca whale through the British Columbia Killer Whale Adoption Program.

Symbolic adoptions of animals are possible, as are live ones. Heifer International provides real livestock to poor families to help them sustain themselves. You can give from a wide selection of animals including goats, sheep, cows, pigs, ducks, chicks, bees and rabbits. Give a symbolic flock of chicks to a friend, and know that a flock of real chicks is going to provide eggs and meat to a family in need.

World Vision Canada is another organization that lets you give livestock like ducks and water buffalo to needy families. But you can also sponsor vulnerable children -- the human kind -- through the organization. Check out World Vision Canada's catalogue here.

Maybe you're a Grinch who doesn't like animals or people. You can still adopt real estate. The Land Conservancy lets you adopt an acre of BC land to protect, as well as offering animal adoptions. Areas include the Horsefly River in the Cariboos, The Wycliffe Wildlife Corridor in the East Kootenays, and South Winchelsea Island in the Gulf Islands. Some people adopt the same chunk of favourite land, year after year.

Still can't decide? Want to give a real gift, but one that's local? Check out BALLE BC's Buy Local site which helps connect people to local, ethical businesses.

More ideas? List them below.

Dee Hon is a regular contributor to The Tyee. This year, he was nominated for a Jack Webster Award.  [Tyee]

18  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • castilleja

    6 years ago

    Comments on "A Tyee Ethical Gift Guide"

    Great article!

    To add to the list:

    (1) Council of Canadians - a citizen's advocate group that fights for social justice in Canada. Note that this group depends entirely on individual donations and does not receive corporate gifts/donations.

    http://www.canadians.org/browse_categories.htm?COC_token=23@@512c313516432e6bbeb87bea1d602219&step=2&catid=5&iscat=1

    (2) Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives - a non-profit think tank offering critical perspectives of provincial and federal policies and budgets.

    http://www.policyalternatives.ca/

  • guanolad

    6 years ago

    If you're buying coffee for someone, I'd recommend Fair Trade rather than coffee from a company that also donates to a charity on the side. Fair Trade coffee provides a decent wage to the producers, supports community development, etc. etc. - and without the paternalistic idea of "charity" attached.

    There are many options. Cafe Etico from CoDev Canada is great (especially the Cuban coffee):
    http://www.codev.org/codev/cafeetico.cfm

    Also many JJ Bean offerings, Ethical Bean, etc.

    Oxfam Canada has a "Gift of Peace" program which allows you to support one of its excellent international development programs.
    http://www.oxfam.ca/what_you_can_do/giftPeace.htm

  • Kevin Pollard

    6 years ago

    IDEAS FOR TYEE READERS

    Some excellent suggestions already. There are lots of ways you can give your loved one a special gift this year:

    (1) Individual shares with a framed stock certificate:

    Raytheon: http://www.giveashare.com/eshop/10expand.asp?productcode=rtn-101

    McDonald's: http://www.giveashare.com/eshop/10expand.asp?productcode=mcd-101

    Exxon Mobil: http://www.giveashare.com/eshop/10expand.asp?productcode=xom-101

    (2) Help make Canada a better place:

    Canadian Taxpayers Federation: https://secure.lexi.net/ctf/jointhectf.php

    The Fraser Institute: http://www.fraserinstitute.ca/supporter/index.asp?tnav=3

    (3) Or for those more practically minded, perhaps some new Birkenstocks, a tie dye kit, dreadlock wax, or a hand-crafted burlap poncho. There's something for everyone.

    Happy non-denominational celebration everyone!

  • alexwh

    6 years ago

    Happy non-denominational celebration everyone!

    Thank you, and merry Christmas and a happy new year to you! Once the PC folks get tougher we will be able to celebrate our birthdays twice. One of them 9 months before. And while we are at it let's get rid of our current calendar. It is too denominational.

  • Stump

    6 years ago

    I am accepting of all denominations... all year round to boot. Of course, I prefer the fifties, but even a a lowly fiver can find a home in my wallet!

  • Stuart

    6 years ago

    Kevin Pollard,

    I think you misunderstand this article, it's about giving to worthwhile causes and not catering to your hero's and tying to enrich oneself. I know the prospect must be insane for you , you know to give something and not expect a return.

    I know your just trying to be clever but I wish you right wing nut jobs would just give it a rest for one day , I know you don't mind stepping over a few homeless folks on the way to Church but just keep your little nasty thoughts to yourself. In short stop being so small.

  • mhoule

    6 years ago

    For about eight or so years, my partner and I have given gifts to charities in lieu of stuff for all the adults in our lives and have asked for the same in return. We also try to plan to spend time with people over the holidays, figuring that's what it's all about anyway. We don't want to ever return to the buying orgy of Christmas - too much stress and it's just not fun for us. How many of us receive stuff we don't want/need and give stuff that the other person just ends up taking back or regifting?

    Now I just have to figure out when to wean the nieces, nephews and goddaughters off of gifts. I figure at 16 they'll get a small gift and a gift to a charity so by the time they're 18 they'll get a gift to charity only.

  • Kevin Pollard

    6 years ago

    Thank you for your insightful contribution, Stuart.

    You are clearly the kind of person I and all Canadians should aspire to be.

    Stuart, how many vagrants will you be housing this winter? You shouldn’t assume all wing-nuts are the same; I for one understand that religion is a disease. I live by my own conscience, not that of an imaginary friend.

    I was merely following the think-tank donation suggestion made by castilleja, but I guess you're unfamiliar with the concept of free choice and opinion in an ideologically diverse democracy. If it's counter to your belief it's wrong. Call them a wing-nut and move on.

    If you have a moment to get off your pedestal, ponder the notion of ethical relativism - I made a constructive suggestion while you were compelled to scorn. As Rodney King said, can't we all just get along?

  • allan

    6 years ago

    Hey, I like that. A little stress and energy between the Xmasites as we await the third day after Solstice.

    Reminds me of the family get-togethers around the ol' tree in my long expired, impressionable youth.

    Sort of a mini- advance workup for when the parents kick the bucket. All eyes were on the calculator as the gifts were opened.

    Interesting to see that spirit live on in the latest celebrants of the consumer spectacular.

  • seanorr

    6 years ago

    "If you have a moment to get off your pedestal, ponder the notion of ethical relativism - I made a constructive suggestion while you were compelled to scorn. As Rodney King said, can't we all just get along?"

    I think you got on the pedestal fist sir. I don't think your suggestion was constructive, I think it was sarcastic. Perhaps my definition of 'ethical' is askew, but I was under the impression that, when applied to a business or an organisation, it meant doing little or no harm to people and the environment, or working to reduce harm and protect human rights. Raytheon, McDonalds, and Exxon are obviously incongruent with this definition and you are just being passive agressive. To top it off you resort to tired cliches of people who want to do good this Christmas by comparing them to hippies.

    Perhaps Mr. Pollard you are feeling insecure.

  • Stuart

    6 years ago

    ""If you have a moment to get off your pedestal, ponder the notion of ethical relativism - I made a constructive suggestion while you were compelled to scorn. As Rodney King said, can't we all just get along?"

    LOL, Hey Kevin Pollard.

    Maybe we all misunderstood you , maybe by suggesting we support the 3 most unethical corporations in the world and the 2 most right wing nut job organizations you were just misguided and not being a total jerk.

    So your either incredibly stupid or like I said a total jerk. There is a time and a place to be clever , do you also crack jokes at funerals.

  • Maureen

    6 years ago

    Or just go to Spartacus Books! No CEOs at that NGO.

  • GJW

    6 years ago

    While supporting animals and animal habitat is nice, there are millions of people who need our support, too:

    http://www.mcc.org/givingprojects/advent/index.html

    I know some will react negatively to me posting a link to a Christian charity, but the work they do helps young people in Sudan get scholarships, helps feed the hungry, helps fight the spread of HIV/AIDS, provides livestock for families and much more.
    I know there are some posters here who think religion is a disease. I agree. That's why true Christianity is so liberating – it allows us to get beyond the mechanics of soul-sucking religious systems and actually put into practice what Jesus Christ commanded us to do – love.
    Just as a person's body that does not have a spirit is dead, so faith that does nothing is dead!
    Merry Christmass, everyone.

  • cycle woman

    6 years ago

    In Nanaimo you can plonk down $25 to help buy Mt Benson or contribute to boardwalks in Linley Valley.......and your gift recipient receives a certificate with a beautiful photo of the area designated.

  • cycle woman

    6 years ago

    PS To add to the Nanaimo suggestions, the group to contact is Nanaimo Area Land Trust.

  • Stuart

    6 years ago

    Good posts, GJW

    I admire active churches, Jesus was a socialist and put us here to do something, I think your church is on the right path.

  • Mitzi

    6 years ago

    Another suggestion is the Nature Conservancy of Canada http://www.natureconservancy.ca/files/index.asp

    For $35.00 you can help protect an acre of habitat for a Canadian endangered or threatened. I've given this gift to nephews and nieces for the past two years (ages 5-14). They receive a certificate and a calendar. Good response from them so far!

  • Mitzi

    6 years ago

    endangered or threatened [/B]species[B] that is!

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.