News

Victoria Library Strike Escalates

Pay equity at centre of four-month dispute.

By Tom Sandborn, 19 Jan 2008, TheTyee.ca

Library Strike

CUPE 410 pickets

A long-simmering labour dispute escalated this week, shutting down all branches of the Greater Victoria Library system yesterday for the second time in three days.

On Wednesday and again Friday, unionized library workers walked out, closing every library in the region.

Previously, in carrying on a strike that began in September, CUPE 410 members had been conducting "work to rule" tactics, including regular noon-hour closures of library branches and shut downs of patron Internet access through branch computer stations.

The walk-outs this week were responses to management suspending a union worker on two occasions for carrying on a "food for fines" campaign. The campaign, initiated by the union but endorsed by library management last year, allows patrons to make a donation to the local food bank instead of paying fines on overdue books.

A CUPE 410 press release yesterday said three other workers who have received verbal warnings for waiving fines for food are also expected to face suspensions.

'Legitimate strike action': union

There is some dispute about the status of the food for fines program, with a notice on the GVPL's website indicating it was a management initiative that has now been cancelled, while a union representative says it is an ongoing strike activity legitimately pursued by union members.

"Food for fines is a legitimate strike action," said CUPE 410 president Ed Seedhouse. "Disciplining our members for such activity violates the collective agreement between the parties and the Labour Relations Code. By walking out today, we are simply doing what is necessary to protect our members."

In a letter to GVPL chief executive Barry Holmes, the union asked the body to stop disciplining members of CUPE 410 for participating in food for fines. The union cites a recent arbitrator's decision in a case involving Farwest Handydart Services that ruled a similar action -- drivers refusing to collect fares for rides -- was lawful strike activity.

$600,000 loss risked: management

Holmes told The Tyee that library management had its own, separate food for fines program that only allowed management personnel to handle the process. He said the union initiative, which has continued and escalated since the GVPL cancelled its own fine forgiveness program on Dec. 31, was illegal.

"They don't have the right to take fines off the books," he said. "That is a management prerogative. We have a legal opinion that disagrees with their argument about the Handydart arbitration. If this program were to continue all year, the library could face losses of up to $600,000."

In an interesting twist, the GVPL's website on Jan. 16 announced the day-long closure of its nine branches, and advised patrons that no late fees would be charged for books not returned that day.

Central branch circulation supervisor Helen Hughes is suspended for today and Monday, with the employer escalating disciplinary measures against CUPE 410 members.

Pay equity fight

The central issue prolonging the labour dispute, CUPE 410 president Ed Seedhouse told The Tyee, is a long overdue promise by the library to address pay equity issues for library workers.

"We've had an agreement on pay equity since 1992, but we still don't have what was promised us. Our jobs were supposed to be compared to jobs at Victoria City Hall and this was done, in theory, in a comparability study in 2000. But the wage differences remain."

Offering an example, Seedhouse explained: "At the end of December 2006, the last day our old collective agreement was in force, a page at the library made $9.87 an hour, while at city hall similar work earned $19.44 an hour. The library paid a circulation clerk $17.58 an hour, while similar work at city hall paid $21.47.

"What is at stake here," Seedhouse added, "is basic respect for librarians. The employer has refused to negotiate. We need some action on pay equity and on the library's excessive use of poorly paid auxiliary workers."

The Greater Victoria Public Library had 83 full-time staff and 248 part-time staff, including auxiliaries in 2006. In contrast, the Vancouver Public Library has 404 full-time and 404 part-time staff.

Negotiations stalled

GVPL CEO Holmes declined to answer any questions about union claims that there had been no substantial negotiations since the beginning of the strike in September, referring these queries to Ron Brunsdon of the Greater Victoria Labour Relations Association.

Several calls from The Tyee to the GVLRA offices requesting comment on this story from Mr. Brunsdon were not returned.

Seedhouse said the failure to negotiate was due, at least in part, to the "hall of mirrors" structure that governs library service in the Greater Victoria region.

"The library board has no real power," he told The Tyee. "They get money from 10 municipalities to operate the library system, but they don't negotiate with us. That's supposed to be done by the Greater Victoria Labour Relations Association."

Among the signs carried by picketers Wednesday were some calling on the library board to "grow a heart."

Related Tyee stories:

 [Tyee]

13  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Ed Seedhouse

    4 years ago

    More intimidation

    The Union received via email yesterday, January 19, a letter from the Chair of the Board, Chris Graham, a letter threatening lockout action if "Food for Fines" does not stop.

    The intimidation tactics continue.

  • RickW

    4 years ago

    Thank the Gods for The Tyee!

    There is NOTHING in the mainstream media, and I doubt one person in 100 knows that Victoria area libraries are on strike.....

  • bisquy

    4 years ago

    why is their union so, well, damp?

    And why is it that 1 in 100 in Victoria don't know the library is on strike? Because the union is not doing their job, that's why. Isn't this what the workers are paying dues for? Isn't this the raison d'etre of the union officials? Aren't they supposed to be out there making waves, getting publicity, meeting with other civic unions to go on strike in support of the librarians? Aren't they supposed to be making this an issue instead of lying low and waiting for the whole thing to blow over so they can go back to dusting their shelves every day while collecting really good pay for doing very very little? The problem with unions now is the management of them, not the workers. There are very real issues here folks, and the biggest ones are the way that union leaders shortsuit their workers without fail. I was in HEU when within one day of a province-wide general strike in support of all unions in this province, a strike that would have serious repercussions for the gov't initiatives that were disabling unions everywhere, when our leader caved in for mysterious reasons and accepted a 15% pay cut and other options that WE DID NOT WANT and there was no way he could have imagined we wanted. I think the librarians' union leaders are afraid to step it up. I think they just want to keep their nice cushy jobs and don't want to agitate for the rights of their workers. And overall, the unions need a shakeup because they are getting pushed around by a govt that cares only about enriching the rich. And for years and years they have only concerned themselves with their own particular members and their own comfy well paid jobs. It is not hard to see why many many working people are not supportive of unions. The unions are not working together, their vision is too small, their leaders not making good choices.

    The public libraries are just the latest in a long line of assaults made on unions all over this country. Health care, teachers, now librarians. We should all be sticking up for each other, the unions should be striking together instead of getting picked apart by the govt. Without the public libraries, and without enough teachers in schools, the level of public education is going to drop to next to nothing. We need the libraries to be strong! We need more teachers! We need more nurses and better preventive health care (starting with healthy hospital food, not fastfood outlets for crying out loud)! Paying taxes is not bad, it supports civil society. I want a good library, I will pay taxes for that, but I don't want to pay taxes for an arena or a convention centre or some crappy art nouveau about day is for sleeping and night is for resting. Get some politicians in there who have some values and some gumption for a change!

  • bisquy

    4 years ago

    intimidation tactics

    Well, if the union doesn't get some backup from other unions and the public, then of course the bullies are going to get tougher and use intimidation. They can see that the union leadership is weak and doing nothing to help their workers. If they do nothing, there could be a lockout, the librarians could all get fired and new people hired, and would the public know? This is the job of the union leaders, to mobilize support. Are they doing it? hmmmm.

  • RickW

    4 years ago

    Unions

    ...haven't been doing their jobs for any numer of years in this province.......

    I think union leaders consider themselves "executives".....

  • Frank

    4 years ago

    Better union leaders

    The path to having the union leaders you want is to vote for them. If some union official isn't standing up for those he represents then get rid of him.

  • zalm

    4 years ago

    Hunh....

    Leaders can't lead where people don't want to follow. People won't man the barricades any more. Bisguy speaks of the HEU coming within a day of shutting the province down. It wasn't ever going to happen - Jim Sinclair and compadres weren't going to let it happen. Private sector unions told the HEU to buzz off, and only CAW and BCGEU had any gumption at all to a)support the HEU and b) try to get it to see some sense in a mor productive pattern of job action than the atomic bomb of General Strike.

    Yet the writing was on the wall for more than a week before. Privately, the Gordocrats were making noises about legislating any work stoppage back to work for at least a week before, and it is likely that this is what the private sector unions were responding to.

    The other unions at the Facilities Bargaining Table tried to talk the HEU into a pattern of rotating actions of varying kinds - no go. We occupied only two seats at the table of 15. The hot-heads there wanted "General Strike", and the HEU leadership, whatever their motives, listened to them.

    So there we were - 6 IUOE guys - out on the lines for no strike pay, rotating shift-and-shift-about keeping them up all night long at my facility while the few HEU members that showed up for their PAID shifts during the day on the picket lines went home to their cushy beds.

    Sorry, bisguy, I'm not impressed with the vast majority of HEU members, not to mention two of their leaders - too much hot talk, and little gumption to back it up with.

    Strikes are a tough business. Any union or business that brings one on should have exhausted ALL their other options first. It's an atomic bomb, and nobody wins in a strike after two weeks - everyone loses big.

  • ferrytraveller

    4 years ago

    Union busting in B.C.

    As a library worker(although not in Victoria), I know firsthand that libraries across this province are mainly staffed by highly motivated, intelligent and hardworking/overworked staff who really care about their customers. Front line staff at libraries are among the lowest paid union workers in B.C.(yet we are usually the libraries' public face);we have weak unions that are overwhelmed by grievances created by an absurdly adversarial management more motivated by their annual salary reviews than pursuing the libraries' mandate to serve the public. Sadly, so much could be accomplished if management chose to work with their employees to create a true public service.

    Similar unfortunate situations exist in public education, public transportation and the health care system, which makes me question why I pay taxes? It seems my money goes towards supporting this dysfunctional system; an illusion of a public service that mainstream media is paid to portray as effective, by advertisers who fund the political parties currently in power.

    The only thing I can suggest is for members of the public, taxpayers and voters, to become actively involved; speak out, protest, write letters and use your local library. After all, you have paid for that privilege. As an employee, I have been effectively silenced by the threat of losing my livelihood should I be brave enough to speak out.

  • zalm

    4 years ago

    More action

    One of the best actions unions can do is encourage their members to support alternative media like the Tyee, as the IUOE and others have done.

    Honestly, any union member still sending money to the publishers of the fishwipe known as the Notional Pest should have his or her head examined. Not only is it utter, right-wing doggerel of the most vituperative order, but it's recycled from so many other sources that readers should be honest and go get it sooner (and better) there.

  • RickW

    4 years ago

    Zalm

    Quote:
    Private sector unions told the HEU to buzz off

    Private sector unions is just about an oxymoron, and private sector union "executives" are far worse than public sector "leaders", if only because they can do NOTHING when a mill closes here in BC, or when an auto plant shuts down back east. Hypocrisy of the worst sort.........

  • zalm

    4 years ago

    What do you expect?

    Well, they can't. If we were like Germany in that there exists some kind of cooperative management where the union gets a seat at the boardroom table by fiat, and all companies starting up business in that industry are automatically unionized, then there might be a case for demanding action.

    Otherwise, it's all hold your breath til you turn blue for all the good it'll do you. Times now are as bad as in the time of the great robber barons. There is no responsibility to society any more - just to the quarterly results, senior management's pay packets, and occasionally, the shareholders.

    Public sector unions are successful only when they remind government that there's no need for them to act like private sector companies, and that workers are almost as important as customers. Would that private sector unions could find a similar lever.

    Oddly, the government's memory continues to be short from time to time, roughly corresponding to the election cycle....

  • RickW

    4 years ago

    Touche, Zalm.......

    Touche, Zalm.......

  • Ed Seedhouse

    4 years ago

    While a lockout would, if

    While a lockout would, if done by the proper procedures, be legal, it would certainly not result in firing any workers. That is against the law in B.C. even under the "Liberals". And so is bringing in scabs, er, pardon me, "replacement workers".

    As for the "leadership", I suppose that I am that "leadership" and I've never claimed to do more than a mediocre job at best, but I keep getting elected by acclamation so they are stuck with me, at least until 2009 when I retire.

    The way to get elected as a union leader? Attend a meeting and at the right time stick up your hand and say "Oh alright, I'll do it."

    We are now pursuing a charge of unfair labour practices against the Employer, and the hearing starts tomorrow.

    We have a website at www.cupe410.ca by the way.

    Ed Seedhouse

    President, CUPE Local 410

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.