Life

'Taking the Cure'

Why foreigners find B.C. a perfect place to kick the smoking habit.

By Pavel Gonzalez, 4 Nov 2004, TheTyee.ca

smoker310sm

Liz Flores held a cigarette in her right hand as she screamed into her friend's ear, competing with 100 decibels of endorphin-releasing dance music. Under strobe lights in a typical Friday night at the Escena, one of the hippest nightclubs in her hometown of Monterrey, Mexico, Liz danced, laughed, drank and smoked. And smoked. And smoked. By the time she left the club, four hours had passed and she had puffed at least eight cigarettes.

Those days are gone. It has been more than a year since the last time she lit up. In fact, ever since Liz arrived in Vancouver, she has not even touched a cigarette. This is a new no-smoking record for her, one she is especially proud of, and for good reason considering that for the previous eight years she smoked no less than 20 cigarettes on a daily basis in Monterrey.

Mind you, she did try to quit several times before: by mere willpower, using nicotine patches, chewing gum, or any other remedy that came her way -even "hypnotic" audio and videocassettes. But nothing worked. She would stop her habit for a couple of weeks, only to find herself smoking even more heavily afterwards.

Victorians did it

Liz and a lot of other foreign visitors to British Columbia are pursuing the 21st century version of what Victorians used to call "taking the cure." Over a century ago, European and North American patients with lung problems were prescribed travel to hot, dry climates, where they'd breathe in the healthier climate and come back feeling noticeably better.

Today, "taking the cure" for smokers means immigrating to clean, environmentally correct cities to reduce your smoking habits dramatically.

Culture shock struck Liz just a few days after her arrival to Canada, when she was invited to an Irish pub in Vancouver. That, she says, was when she found out what "no smoking" was all about. "It was strange to be in a club, at night, and see nobody was smoking. I was drinking, having a good time with my friends, but I just wasn't allowed to light a cigarette. That felt unusual, but at the same time I knew it was better for everyone," she explains.

Pricey and prohibited

But it is the whole Vancouver "package," not just its nightclub culture, that makes the difference. Legislation, social norms, and even the cost of cigarettes combine to create the modern version of "the cure." As Liz found, "no one smokes around here, so no one has a cigarette to spare, you can't smoke anywhere, and cigarettes are so expensive!"

Liz, now 24, had a hard time enjoying smoking in the first place. For her, it was social pressure and the desire to belong to a group that led her to try a cigarette. "I had to work hard to like smoking. The first few times I felt I was choking, but we were a group of friends -the 'cool' gang at school- and we were all trying, so we kept on going for some time until we got it and, stupid as it may sound, we were proud," she remembers.

Not anymore. On Canadian soil, she is ashamed to put a cigarette between her lips. "To me, it seems like if you light a cigarette here people will look at you as if you were mass-killing deer. It is so not-cool to smoke I even feel embarrassed to say I ever did," she says.

So Liz has quit. Simple as that. Done. Well, for now, at least.

'Rain stronger than cigarette'

If Vancouver belongs to an expanding, global smoke-free zone, all of Asia remains one vast smoking section. Which is why Asians, like Mexicans, face massive culture shock when they arrive here.

Cheng Li, a UBC graduate student from Shanghai, China, has found it hard to adjust to British Columbia. Not only has he had difficulties learning the English language, but he is also grappling with quitting smoking, cold turkey. At first he was "dying" whenever he even caught the slightest whiff of tobacco fumes. But soggy weather and wet blanket attitudes here soon doused his craving. "Canadian culture was completely different and new, so smoking reduced the stress and relaxed me, but after a while the cold and the rain were stronger than the cigarette," Li laughs.

In the long run, of course, this has had a positive impact in Li's health, as he leads a healthier life than he ever did in his own country. "Smoking spaces are becoming more and more limited in China, especially in big cities, but they are still not as strict as Vancouver, so I really suffered during my first few weeks here. But health is important for everyone, so I am happy I could quit smoking," he admits.

Social pressure eases up

UBC sociology professor Gerry Veenstra, who specializes in the sociology of health, states there are two main forces that influence smokers -- namely, social pressure and nicotine addiction. "It is usually social pressure what leads smokers to try their first cigarette. Of course, there may be a physical or psychological dependence after a while, but it is not the triggering factor," he explains.

In societies where smoking is commonly tolerated, these factors push in one same direction, so addiction and socialization both encourage individuals to continue smoking. However, in societies in which social pressure is against smoking, struggle and balance of these forces take place, and eventually make it harder to smokers to keep their habit.

"On the one hand, addiction may be pushing the individual towards smoking, but on the other hand, in a particular cultural context smoking is a deviant behaviour, an undesirable element, so context is pushing them in the opposite direction. That, of course, makes it harder to continue smoking," the professor says.

According to Veenstra, Canadian culture affects immigrants in a variety of profound ways, including the perception of smoking itself. "Whereas in their home countries smoking could be seen as a way to help people deal with stress or cope with everyday life, here it may be different. This plays a huge influence in a person's decision to smoke or quit smoking," he adds.

This is particularly true in Vancouver, where healthy behaviour is encouraged by strict smoking legislation in public places. "British Columbia has succeeded in this matter, and Vancouver is certainly healthier in comparison to other Canadian cities. I was a smoker myself in Toronto, but quit when I came here," Veenstra says.

Lasting cure?

But what happens when an immigrant to Vancouver returns home, and finds temptation smouldering wherever two or more are gathered in public? For Alejandro Castro, at least, it looks like "the cure" continues to take. Castro, 32, spent six months in Vancouver three years ago, and cut way back on his smoking while here. Then he went back home, to breathe free in the world's largest and most polluted metropolitan area: Mexico City.

While in British Columbia, Castro went from smoking 20 cigarettes per day, to just two or three. And he's continued to keep his habit in check. His intense cravings never returned. "Vancouver was like shock therapy for me. All of a sudden, if you want to smoke, you have to go out in the rain and the cold weather. How pleasant is that? Now, I am smoking more than I did in Canada, but not nearly as much as I did before I went there," he explains.

"I don't think I will ever be able to smoke 20 cigarettes a day again, even if I wanted to," he adds, "I am back to a place much more tolerant to smokers, but it's not like I have to take full advantage of it and smoke a thousand cigarettes just because I can."

Born, raised and living in Mexico City, Pável González does not need to smoke to get his daily dose of deadly airborne toxins, to which he has by now become addicted. He has worked in Mexico's EsMas.com, television networks Televisa and TV Azteca, and freelanced for Cambio and TV y Novelas magazines.
 [Tyee]

8  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • Earnest Canuck (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Holy Christ, what Vancouver are these people visiting? I suppose it's nice that the health fascists are able to direct hapless foreigners to that squeaky-clean puritan city of the brochures. (I didn't think it really existed: but then I'd rather eat bugs than hit one of those "Irish-themed" fern bars.) Attention foreigners: the pencil-necks have not actually transformed this old port town into Stockholm just yet. Actual Vancouverites have many, many garrisons of old-fashioned adult fun and irresponsible vice we tend to keep to ourselves. But if you want to imbibe, inhale and party (as we say) *hearty,* just ask any native not affiliated with the Chamber of Commerce or the Tourism and Self-Righteous Nerdiness Commission -- and we'll be happy to show you our secret dens of iniquity. If you're holidaying for your *health,* though (mind-boggling as that seems to many of us), then by all means stick to Disneystrasse, I mean Robson Street.

  • Fi (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Yeah,...um, environmentally correct? I don't think so. We pretend to be but are FAR from it. I have to ASK for a mug, not a paper cup, everytime I go to a coffee shop in this city. But then the dude next in line gets two (one inside the other lest he burns his poor hands) and has it to stay. Why do I bother???? As far as cigarettes go, many of my Japanese students say the same as the Chinese man in the story- the cost of cigarettes here compels them to cut back or quit- BUT they are appalled at the way people toss their butts on the streets (which my friend, who just finished her MA in environmental sustainability, did the other day!!??) 'cause I guess that's just not so cool in Japan. So let's not get ahead of ourselves here, we are hardly a model of "environmental correctness".

  • Heavily Addicted (not verified)

    7 years ago

    I find it interesting that all articles that I read about smoking ignores or minimizes the 'addiction' portion of their message. This is 'Just Say No' in it's extreme. Does no one recognize the imortance of researching a way to control, if not cure, this addiction? As a smoker for over 50 years, I have tried every method of stopping, but failed because none of them takes the issue of addiction seriously. Even though most agree that smoking addiction is harder to break than heroin addiction, no real effort has been made to come up with a relevant method of fighting this addiction.

  • anne cameron (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Anybody else find it interesting that smoking cigarettes is more addictive than heroin or methadone, both of which are illegal, neither of which contribute to tax revenue, and for which there are detox centres and addiction centres... but there is NO such gov't sponsored programme for those of us who are addicted to a substance which POURS tax money into the government slush funds...if I was a junky supporting my habit by B&E, mugging, or hooking (hey, scratch hooking, I'd starve for lack of customers!!) stealing your SUV or banging you on the head as you leave the money-machine I could go to detox then spend up to 3 months in a clinic but because I'm just a black-lunged puffer I get to feed the tax trough as well as pay for "cessation aids" which don't work.

  • anonymous (not verified)

    7 years ago

  • kent (not verified)

    7 years ago

    Interesting that most of those who commented are smokers. I too smoked for many years. When in England during WWII the Red Cross gave us each a carton a month. But 30 or so years ago I decided I no longer wished to be a slave. It certainly wasn't easy, as my wife didn't quit, and is now in long term care because her habit caused several strokes, but I persevered. At today's prices I am far too cheap to smoke. When I started .15 cents bought a package of tobacco and papers. When I see someone paying $8.00 plus for a package of cigarettes I tell them "You must be very rich". Invariably they are offended.

  • anonymous (not verified)

    7 years ago

  • cathrynoustonward (not verified)

    7 years ago

    I am looking for a detox program for crack addiction in British Columbia please email me at

    • No best comments selected by an editor for this story yet. To see all comments, click the All Comments tab, above.
    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.