Artsculture

Boys, We're Going Straight to the Bottom!

The glorious failures of Big Star.

By Adrian Mack, 8 Oct 2009, TheTyee.ca

big-star.jpg

Big Star -- great hooks, great hair, epic fail

Related

Further to last week's slightly insane discussion of the Beatles boxsets, is this. It appears that around the same time that the Fab Four got their belated digital overhaul, the not-so-fabs out of Memphis, Big Star, also got theirs. The shiny new boxset Eye In the Sky is something that I've yet to hear -- if my wife is reading this, Christmas is only a couple months away, honey -- but any opportunity in the meantime to post a classic Big Star cut is an opportunity worth taking.

I suspect that as of 2009, with the iPod generation fast approaching a sort of all-knowing, field-leveling singularity in terms of music consumption, Big Star isn't quite the mysterious cult item it once was. But it's not like we get to hear "The Ballad of El Goodo" on the radio all the time, or "September Gurls" on the Starbuck's playlist (even if we should). And for those who aren't yet au fait with the troubled architects of power pop, I urge you to change that.

The brief history -- vocalist-guitarist Alex Chilton was the 16-year-old prodigy whose husky pipes made the Box Tops' "The Letter" such a memorable bubblegum factory item in 1967. Come the early '70s, Chilton and vocalist-guitarist-songwriter Chris Bell had the cockamamie notion of stitching the melodiousness of the Beatles to the heft of Zeppelin, from their not entirely sympathetic base in the hometown of American rock 'n roll. The tiny label Ardent Records made Big Star its flagship group, even though it wasn't much more than a studio project. Its 1972 debut, #1 Record, remains the blueprint for power pop.

Ardent sold about a dozen copies of #1 Record in total, but, in a stark reiteration of what you might call the Velvet Underground Effect, Big Star nonetheless became the ne plus ultra of influential, obscure rock bands. Its shimmering presence is felt in everything from the '70s underground, to the '80s college rock universe, to REM, to newbie Canadian upstarts Hollerado.

A second album in 1974, Radio City, was edgier, with harder angles, less sugar, and drumming from Jody Stephens that exceeded even the thrilling hyperactivity of #1 Record. The album only deepened the band's appeal, which had taken on a malevolent energy by this point. The hypersensitive Bell had already absconded prior to Radio City, dismayed by the lack of success, Chilton's outré and often-cruel personality, and a growing drug dependency.

Chilton's final, ugly, fractured recordings under the Big Star sign were so fraught with bad juju and despair that nobody would touch them until four years after their increasingly erratic and unhappy author vacated the studio. When it was eventually released in 1978, you couldn't even know for sure if Big Star Third was sequenced correctly. In an interview in 2000, producer Jim Dickinson shrugged to writer Barney Hoskyns, "There is no sequence."

Many consider the bleak, diseased, mangled anti-pop of Third to be Chilton's masterpiece. A depressed Bell, meanwhile, died in a car accident after years of hard drugs, capsized opportunities, and an inability to reconcile his Christianity with his homosexuality. Some have speculated that it was suicide. Chilton pursued a difficult solo career that seemed designed to renounce everything he'd done before. And there you have it.

Listen to this:

Regrettably, I've never gotten to see the Big Star that reunited in the '90s when Chilton and Jody Stephens hooked up with a couple of the fellas from Seattle's the Posies -- another band that belongs on the list of grateful acolytes -- for a not-great new album and the occasional show. A flat tire on the way to Bumbershoot in 2000 made sure of that, however I did get to see the mercurial and ever-perverse frontman solo at the Town Pump a long, long time ago. Mr. Chilton delivered a weedy set of standards like "Volare" that evening, with a band that might have passed muster on a Tuesday night at the Yale, but only just.

My clearest memory beyond that was catching the sneer he directed at a gorgeous blond in the front row, who was begging to hear him play Big Star's "Thirteen". He didn't, naturally. Which is probably Alex Chilton in a nutshell. Of course, Big Star without a weird, thorny, self-sabotaging legend at the helm wouldn't be nearly so interesting, would it?  [Tyee]

6  Comments:

Login or register to post comments

  • wayfarer

    2 years ago

    The greatest band no one's ever heard

    I used to refer to Big Star as the 'greatest band no one's ever heard' - that was before That 70's Show ripped off their classic track, "In the Street" via Cheap Trick. Even then, most people hummed the tune having no clue who wrote it. Some of my long-time music friends still insist Septembur Girls is a Bangles song.

    One of the trademarks of great rock & roll is timelessness. Big Star's #1 Album has that quality from beginning to end. The sound never gets stale, and those awkwardly brilliant reverse harmonies on Ballad of El Goodo - they truly don't make songs like that anymore. Few albums have this timeless quality for me. I throw Big Star into my CD player at least once every couple of months just to remind myself why I stopped buying records in the mid-90's, and to remind myself just how lousy the craft of rock is these days. Great stuff.

    There are some fine covers of Big Star out there. The more memorable include Jay Farrar's rendition of "Holocaust" or Elliott Smith's "Thirteen" - I saw Adam Duritz (Counting Crows) once attempt Ballad of El Goodo, but it paled in comparison to the original. I think he did say it was his favourite song of all time.

    I saw Jody Stephens playing with the Golden Smog down in Seattle about 15 years ago, but that's the closest I got to the real thing.

    I'm a bit disappointed you didn't mention Chris Bell's solo stuff. I still rank "I am the Cosmos" as one of my all time favourites. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kR594Kkxmzg

  • VivianLea Doubt

    2 years ago

    mmmmmmm

    Adrian, I wasn't au fait with Big Star, and wayfarer, enjoyed Chris Bell. Thanks!

  • jeffc

    2 years ago

    one of the best

    Familiarity with Big Star was the equivalent of a masonic handshake for music hipsters in the 80s.

    All three albums are great, and mention should be made of a Rykodisc release called Big Star Live which is a post Chris Bell set recorded for an FM station on Long Island. Features an astonishing four song acoustic interlude by Chilton.

  • Adrian Mack

    2 years ago

    Wayfarer, I really should

    Wayfarer, I really should have mentioned I Am the Cosmos, which has been covered by Pete Yorn and Scarlett Johansson on their new Break Up album (!!!). Haven't heard it though.

  • wayfarer

    2 years ago

    Chris Bell revisted

    Adrian,

    I think Bell is unfairly overlooked in the Big Star mythology, partly because he faded away so quietly, so fast - before Big Star even had a chance to earn that 'secret handshake status' - and because he was more passive than the domineering Chilton, who went on to reform and re-market Big Star years later.

    I just dusted off my copy of I am the Cosmos (the Rykodisc re-issue, 1992), and there really is some lovely stuff on there. The liner notes to this edition by brother David Bell are illuminating and heartbreaking, tales of Chris' solo musical journey, trips to London, Berlin in '75, Bell's unsuccessful attempts to reform Big Star for a UK tour, getting his life back on track....

    "... this is a brilliant record, and yet only a small slice of Chris' huge talent. I hope that in some small way this record will illustrate that Chris' contribution to sterling pop music, both in Big Star and as a solo artist is a significant and vastly underappreciated one." -- Jeff Rougvie

    Speed of Sound: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MzWJjdlXveM

    You and your sister: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JFzbtROpvtk&feature=related

    Adrian, thanks again for reviving the Big Star legend.

  • Steve Burgess

    2 years ago

    Zep?

    Kind of hard to fathom that they had Led Zeppelin as a role model, considering the results. If so, it would just show once again that many a band creates a unique sound through a failed attempt to imitate someone else.

    • The discussion for this story is closed. No more comments can be added.