Opinion

Ice Ice Baby, Whose Fault Is Port Mann Crash?

Experts raise questions about gov't decision to blame drivers, chill out on builders.

By Bill Tieleman 8 Jan 2013 | TheTyee.ca

Bill Tieleman is a regular Tyee contributor who writes a column on B.C. politics every Tuesday in 24 Hours newspaper. E-mail him at weststar@telus.net, follow on Twitter @BillTieleman or visit his blog.

image atom
Sunnier times: BC Transportation Minister Mary Polak opens new Port Mann Bridge on Sept. 13 of last year. Source: @MaryPolakMLA.

"@Surrey Police: #IceIceSurrey If ice is a problem, yo, you can solve it, check out this link while my DJ revolves it." -- Surrey, England police warning on Twitter.

Who knew that the $3.3 billion Port Mann Bridge was designed by slippery '90s rapper Vanilla Ice?

Not B.C. Transportation Minister Mary Polak, who will probably never listen to "Ice Ice Baby" again.

More importantly, why was Polak blaming the 40 unlucky drivers involved in ice-caused crashes on the bridge Thursday?

Why was she also blaming the totally predictable freezing wet, foggy weather --everything but the actual contractor responsible for making sure there's no ice on the bridge?

"There's nothing they've done that they were negligent in," Polak said of Mainroad Contracting. "There's nothing with respect to what they did that they could have predicted what did happen with any certainty."

Polak went on to put the blame on drivers. "People are able to reach speeds on the bridge at rush hour they never were before. As with any type of crash, there's a number of different causes and issues at play. This is unfortunately just the kind of circumstance people encounter on the road... chain reactions result in large numbers of claims," Polak continued.

There's only one problem with that last statement. The minister doesn't know her ice from her elbow.

'You can lose control on black ice at 10 mph'

The website Icy Road Safety explains all that Polak needs to understand about this winter hazard.

"Attributing the root cause of road ice crashes to people driving too fast is similar to saying that plane crashes are caused by pilots failing to keep their aircraft in the air," the website explains. "For black ice, no speeds are safe. You can lose control on black ice at 10 m.p.h., particularly if there is any banking or slope to the roadway."

And guess what? The new sloping Port Mann Bridge was covered in black ice, despite the contractor claiming they patrolled it just an hour before and found no problems.

But when you apply a salt brine solution 25 hours in advance and hope everything will stay safe, you're on thin ice.

As police reported, there was no visible salt or gravel and more ice than the Vancouver Canucks have seen this season.

Despite that, Polak argues neither the contractor nor the province is responsible for the crashes and not only will drivers' tolls not be refunded, they'll be responsible for ICBC insurance deductibles too.

Cold, hard reality check

If your car was damaged Thursday, you might think about calling a lawyer and then asking the experts from Icy Road Safety to testify, because here's what they say:

"An icy bridge's most dangerous threat is their element of surprise -- they catch drivers off guard, who are traveling at full speed because the rest of the roads are either clear or just a little wet," the website notes, adding that bridges freeze first because they are exposed top, bottom and sides by icy air compared to just the surface on a road.

And unlike B.C.'s transportation minister, the website, supported by several American state transportation agencies, cities, weather services and others, doesn't blame drivers.

"The result of a vehicle encountering black ice is no different than if it had been blown off the road by a tornado, in that both are 100 percent a result of external weather-related forces that are of no fault of the driver," it states.

Polak should do the right thing -- demand the contractor pay for damage done to cars last week and make them responsible for any similar black ice bang ups.  [Tyee]

Read more: Politics, Transportation

Share this article

The Tyee is supported by readers like you

Join us and grow independent media in Canada

Get The Tyee in your inbox

LATEST STORIES

The Barometer

Have any major issues been missed in the Alberta election campaign?

Take this week's poll